The Fiamengo File - March 12, 2018


My Human Rights Tribunal Story -TFF Episode 73

Are Men Responsible For Ending Sexual Violence? TFF 72 Who Is Rick Mehta - TFF Episode 74

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

144.7

Word count

1,572

Sentence count

73

Harmful content

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 To those of you who contributed to my legal defense and those who wrote me encouraging messages,
00:00:06 I owe you a big thank you. And today I'm finally going to let you know
00:00:10 what happened when I appeared before the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal.
00:00:14 I'm Janice Fiomingo. As many of you know I was named along with my university in a complaint
00:00:30 to the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal, the HRT for short. The complaint was brought by a former
00:00:37 student who alleged that I had discriminated against her because of her disability and a
00:00:42 couple of weeks ago, I attended the HRT in downtown Ottawa to answer the charges. We had already tried
00:00:49 mediation earlier unsuccessfully, and so a formal hearing was scheduled for February 22, 2018,
00:00:57 but it ended up not taking place. Instead, the student agreed to a mediated settlement with
00:01:05 the university. I'm not allowed to tell you any details of the settlement, though I can say that
00:01:11 I wasn't held responsible for any of her complaints, and I won't be disciplined in any way.
00:01:18 Now, on the one hand, this is a huge relief.
00:01:21 The student's claims weren't probably firing offenses, but they were certainly serious enough to cast doubt on my professionalism and moral character.
00:01:31 The student alleged that I had made, quote, poisonous remarks in the classroom about students with disabilities and had been deliberately unclear in descriptions of certain assignments so as to limit her chances of success with them.
00:01:46 She also claimed that I deliberately chose not to submit a copy of the final exam to the disability office because I had a prejudice against her.
00:01:57 She claimed that I harassed her in emails after I missed the exam deadline.
00:02:02 Now, if I had done any of those things, I think I'd be a pretty despicable person.
00:02:07 It's true that I missed the deadline for the exam, but I did so because I didn't have enough time to prepare it,
00:02:13 not because I had a prejudice against her, as she repeated throughout her very lengthy deposition.
00:02:20 The thought of being found guilty of any of her allegations was a nightmare.
00:02:27 It sickened me, and it has been on my mind ever since I first received the HRT letter.
00:02:33 So I'm glad I'm no longer walking around under that cloud.
00:02:38 But on the other hand, a mediated settlement at the HRT wasn't an ideal end to the story for me
00:02:44 because it meant that the students' claims were never rebutted.
00:02:49 Remarkably, there was no process of investigation of any kind.
00:02:54 The student didn't call any witnesses to corroborate her allegations about remarks I supposedly made in class,
00:03:01 and no member of the HRT ever interviewed anybody or looked into her complaints in any other way.
00:03:09 A number of the things I had supposedly said in emails were demonstrably false.
00:03:14 I had the emails and had submitted them to the HRT.
00:03:17 Her allegation that I, quote, harassed her in attempting to resolve the problem with the late
00:03:23 exam was demonstrably false. I had offered her on multiple occasions the opportunity to write the
00:03:29 exam at home, taking all the time she needed, as she had had on previous take-home assignments,
00:03:35 but she never acknowledged that offer in her complaint. Her contention that I could and
00:03:41 should have submitted the exam to the disability office months prior to the deadline was ridiculous 0.52
00:03:47 and showed a total lack of understanding of how a teacher actually makes up an exam.
00:03:53 And my lawyer was prepared to cross-examine her, but never got the chance. And the complaints were
00:03:59 simply left to hang. They were neither proved nor disproven. So you might ask, well, why would I
00:04:06 agree to have mediation then? The answer is because I didn't really understand the process,
00:04:12 and I had no idea how the adjudicator would rule if it went to a formal hearing. For all I knew,
00:04:19 the adjudicator might well find the student's account of events more credible than mine. After
00:04:25 all, why would the student lie? Why would she make up the fact that I had supposedly made
00:04:32 poisonous remarks if I hadn't actually done so. I couldn't prove I didn't say what she claimed and
00:04:39 I had every incentive to lie, I suppose. Maybe I did miss the exam because I had a prejudice
00:04:45 against her or simply because I was recklessly indifferent to her needs. The Human Rights
00:04:52 Tribunal of Ontario operates on the assumption that there is a lot of bigotry in Canadian society
00:04:57 on the part of the powerful against the powerless. The vast majority of HRT adjudicators are
00:05:04 themselves advocates for the rights of those powerless. So given the very damning nature of
00:05:11 the student's charges and her obvious belief in my guilt, I thought it likely that even in the
00:05:17 absence of material evidence, I might be found at least partially responsible for her distress.
00:05:24 Near the end of the mediation process, the adjudicator mentioned that actually the vast
00:05:29 majority of cases brought before the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal are either abandoned,
00:05:35 in other words, the complainant doesn't follow through, or they are resolved through mediation.
00:05:41 And many people might think, as I suspect this adjudicator did, that this is great.
00:05:46 All these conflicts in Canadian society, all these violations of people's rights are being
00:05:51 peaceably settled through negotiation. But actually, in my opinion, the tribunals create
00:05:59 two unpalatable choices for accused individuals. You can either spend years preparing for a trial
00:06:07 with thousands of dollars of lawyers' fees and grief and worry and time spent only to have it
00:06:14 fizzle out into a nothing or spend years and a lot of money and take one's chances with a formal
00:06:23 judgment for which there is no appeal and in which one is never really sure exactly what one
00:06:30 is being charged with or what one's penalty may be if found guilty. As far as I can tell,
00:06:36 Well, the Human Rights Tribunal is a rigged game and one with massive costs to the public.
00:06:45 My case alone must have cost tens of thousands of dollars of public money for the government
00:06:51 employees in the HRT office processing the student's claim and for the government employees
00:06:56 at the university who are involved in it.
00:06:59 What is most remarkable to me in the whole business is that there is absolutely no disincentive
00:07:06 to lodging frivolous charges. All complainants have to do is fill out a form and pretty nearly
00:07:14 any charge that fits the tribunal's mandate will be pursued. The complainant has nothing
00:07:21 to lose except time and potentially a lot to gain in an award for damages. Even if the
00:07:28 complainant's charges are found to be without substance, there's no penalty for the complainant.
00:07:35 can withdraw from the process at any time if it looks as if they're not going to win. And whether
00:07:41 they withdraw or not, they won't be forced, for example, as in the case of a civil suit, they won't
00:07:46 be forced to pay the defendant's legal costs. The defendant, on the other hand, has everything
00:07:53 to lose. Money, for sure, whatever the outcome. Lost time, for sure. Lost livelihood, possibly,
00:08:03 and lost reputation, and no real vindication even in a best-case scenario. I've never read an HRT 0.92
00:08:12 judgment that went out of its way to say that the defendant was a good person, undeserving of the
00:08:20 complaint. The best the accused can hope for is that after years of lost sleep and wasted time
00:08:27 and lawyer's fees, the complaint will at last go away. Most people I've spoken to seem to think
00:08:34 that because these tribunals can't actually sentence people to jail time, there's no reason
00:08:39 to get too upset about them. But if you're a small business owner or landlord or anyone who isn't
00:08:46 wealthy, thousands of dollars in legal fees plus a fine of $5,000 or more is utterly crippling.
00:08:54 And that's not to mention the humiliation and aggravation of the whole process, the anxiety
00:09:01 of being investigated by a state-funded body that exists precisely to sniff out cases of
00:09:09 discrimination. One big cost is undeniable, the comfort of ordinary Canadian citizens trying to
00:09:18 live their lives and build a career or business.
00:09:22 Because once you've gone through this process,
00:09:25 you definitely never want to go through it again.
00:09:29 And many of your decisions will now be shadowed
00:09:32 by a concern that another complaint might be on its way.
00:09:36 As a teacher, for example, I am more and more uncertain
00:09:40 what I can and cannot say in the classroom
00:09:44 without getting myself in trouble.
00:09:46 And feelings of alienation, bitterness, and resentment are almost inevitable. 1.00
00:09:55 Because what kind of a country does this to its citizens, encouraging malcontents to make claims
00:10:04 and forcing defendants to try to prove they're not racists or transphobes or bigots
00:10:12 and call that human rights?
00:10:16 The day you realize your government doesn't actually care about you, is the day you grow
00:10:22 up and get real.
00:10:25 But the day you realize your government will actively persecute you for non-existent crimes,
00:10:31 that's a very bad day for you and your country.
00:10:38 Thank you for watching.
00:10:39 If you enjoyed this video, please support us on Patreon.
00:10:42 If even half of our subscribers gave us $1 per month, we'd be well on our way to creating
00:10:47 more and better content.
00:10:49 And don't forget to subscribe to us on Studio Brulee.