The Fiamengo File - March 21, 2018


Who Is Rick Mehta - TFF Episode 74

My Human Rights Tribunal Story -TFF Episode 73 Are Universities About Truth Or The Protection of Approved Ideas? TFF-75

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

123.06

Word count

1,253

Sentence count

49

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
00:00:01 Who is Rick Mehta? And why is his university trying to shut him up?
00:00:05 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:17 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:21 Rick Mehta is a professor of psychology at Acadia University in Nova Scotia, Canada.
00:00:26 He's a free speech advocate who cares far more about reason-based analysis than political
00:00:32 correctness. All you have to do is read his Twitter feed to see his willingness to talk
00:00:38 about many of today's ever-increasing number of forbidden subjects. Among other topics,
00:00:45 Rick has posted about the controversial subject of residential schools to support the idea that
00:00:52 we should listen to the voices of all Indigenous people, including those who say their experience
00:00:58 at such schools was positive. He has posted critical comments about multiculturalism
00:01:04 and identity politics. He has questioned feminist views about the wage gap between men and women.
00:01:12 He has advocated that talk of rape culture and patriarchy are false and counterproductive,
00:01:18 and that the Me Too movement is a disaster for due process.
00:01:23 And he insists that freedom of expression is under attack at Canadian and American universities
00:01:30 and in Western society generally, and that we should all be concerned about that.
00:01:37 Radical ideas.
00:01:39 True to form, the students, professors, and activists who consider themselves social justice warriors
00:01:46 have been outraged by Professor Mehta's refusal to toe their line about what can and cannot be said
00:01:54 in a university classroom, and they're causing trouble for him by claiming that he is making
00:01:59 students unsafe. This is the predictable ruse of such people when their monopoly on ideas is
00:02:07 challenged. One of them, a woman calling herself a human rights activist, started an online petition
00:02:13 to have Mehta removed from the university altogether on the grounds that marginalized
00:02:18 communities in Nova Scotia can't feel comfortable with him teaching at Acadia. A counter petition
00:02:26 calling on Acadia to support Professor Mehta actually garnered double, more than double,
00:02:31 the number of the attack petition, suggesting that Professor Mehta has far more supporters
00:02:38 and detractors amongst both students and the wider community. But unfortunately, the university is
00:02:45 showing itself all too willing to kowtow to the SJWs. In response to a never disclosed number of
00:02:54 complaints, university administrators have moved to place restrictions on the courses that
00:02:59 Professor Mehta can teach and on how he is allowed to teach his courses. A letter from his designated
00:03:08 department head, Rob Rayside, dated February 26, couldn't cite a single racist or transphobic
00:03:17 utterance by Professor Mehta, but claimed that the tension level among students in his classes was so
00:03:24 high that some students couldn't bring themselves to attend class. And instead of politely informing
00:03:30 the grousing students that they should attend class and were free to engage in reason-based
00:03:35 discussion with their professor on all the matters he was raising, the head instead told
00:03:40 meta to conform to their sweeping demands. He actually told the teacher to avoid using
00:03:48 any material, quote, that might be seen by students as advancing a fringe point of view,
00:03:54 end quote, and to be, quote, very diligent about avoiding any comments that might be perceived as
00:04:01 racist or transphobic, end quote. Notice the Weasley phrasing. Professor Mehta is not barred
00:04:11 from making racist or transphobic comments, which there is zero evidence he did make. He is barred
00:04:17 from making comments, quote, that might be perceived as racist or transphobic, end quote.
00:04:23 Well, since nearly any unorthodox commentary will be perceived as advancing a, quote, fringe
00:04:31 perspective, and since any deviation from the leftist line on social issues is automatically
00:04:37 labeled racist and transphobic by the social justice left, the department head's directive
00:04:44 essentially concedes to totalitarian students the right to dictate what Professor Mehta is and is not
00:04:52 allowed to say in his own classroom. Talk about the tail wagging the dog. Even more critically,
00:05:01 Acadia University's vice president academic, Heather Hemming, has now launched a formal
00:05:07 investigation into the complaints against Mehta, hiring a man named Wayne McKay, retired professor
00:05:13 from nearby Dalhousie University in Halifax to look into the allegations of discrimination and
00:05:19 harassment. Professor McKay, as it happens, is a declared enemy of free speech who has publicly
00:05:27 endorsed university's supposed mandate to protect marginalized students from expressions they might
00:05:34 find offensive. In response to a scandal some years ago in 2014 involving dentistry students'
00:05:42 Facebook posts at Dal, he opined in a newspaper piece that, quote, all speech has its reasonable
00:05:49 limits, end quote, and that it is important to prohibit, quote, hate speech, targeting identifiable
00:05:57 groups and discriminatory speech more broadly, end quote. Well, that doesn't bode well. Notice how
00:06:05 hate speech, which is an already fuzzy and bloated term, isn't broad enough for Professor McKay,
00:06:12 who wants unacceptable speech to include anything, even not hateful, that can be alleged to be,
00:06:19 as he calls it, discriminatory, whatever that means, i.e. probably anything that a member of
00:06:25 a protected group can claim produced discomfort. As a side note, McKay is also a big-time feminist 0.64
00:06:33 activist who mentioned in this 2014 piece, quote, the alleged conduct of Xi'an Gomeshi as a tragedy
00:06:42 that revealed the deep-rooted misogyny of Canadian culture. In other words, he believed
00:06:48 women's allegations, believed those as themselves proof of what was alleged. So what are the chances
00:06:56 that Professor McKay will not find Rick Mehta's alleged speech to have crossed the line into
00:07:02 discriminatory discourse. So not surprisingly, the SJW sharks are now circling. A Canadian press
00:07:12 article about the university investigation quoted an associate professor of classics and ancient
00:07:17 history at the University of New Brunswick, one Matthew Sears, who is quick to offer a diagnosis
00:07:24 and a not very charitable one of Professor Mehta's motivations and objectives. Quote,
00:07:30 quote, he's just sort of parroting the much more popular Jordan Peterson, Sears said,
00:07:37 just a little dismissively. Quote, he's very clearly just trying to piggyback on that to gain
00:07:44 a certain notoriety, end quote. Of course, the classics prof didn't offer any evidence to support
00:07:50 his contention that Metta is insincere, and nor did he feel the need to justify his outrageous
00:07:57 contention quoted later in the same article that Mehta is, quote, an ignoramus about residential 0.70
00:08:04 schools and, wait for it, a racist. In a more civil era, it would have been extraordinary to see
00:08:14 one professor publicly calling another a racist merely because that professor questions received
00:08:21 ideas about residential schools. Unfortunately, the tried and true method of academic elites today
00:08:28 is simply to name call. It's little wonder that some university students now are so intolerant
00:08:37 that they resort to illegal disruption, intimidation, and even violence to prevent
00:08:42 points of view they don't like from being heard always with the claim that such points of view
00:08:47 make students unsafe. I wonder how safe students feel disagreeing with a professor like Matthew
00:08:55 Sears, whose trigger finger for firing off claims of racism is worrisomely itchy. 0.96
00:09:04 In my opinion, the extremely uncivil remarks of Professor Sears, as well as the ridiculous
00:09:11 directives in the letter from the department head, and the fact that Professor Mehta is now
00:09:16 under investigation by someone who has already declared himself a foe of free speech, all these
00:09:23 provide a pretty appalling picture of the hostile climate in which teachers are forced to operate
00:09:29 these days at universities. Acadia University, like way too many other post-secondary institutions,
00:09:38 has become indoctrinate you. And the radical profs who once marched for free speech
00:09:47 are now the ones shutting it down.
00:10:08 You