The Fiamengo File - May 04, 2017


When "Survivors" Teach Rape Culture - TFF Episode 62

Philistia, aka McMaster University, vs. Jordan Peterson - TFF Episode 61 You Deny My Right To Exist - TFF Episode 63

Episode Stats


Length

12 minutes

Words per minute

140.27

Word count

1,793

Sentence count

26

Harmful content

Misogyny

19

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 What happens when a rape victim teaches the feminist theory of rape culture in a university 1.00
00:00:07 classroom? That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File. 1.00
00:00:19 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. Recently, a feminist sociology professor published
00:00:24 an anonymous article in the online magazine inside higher ed which is a mainstream seemingly 0.95
00:00:32 pro-feminist news and opinion site about post-secondary education the article called
00:00:38 surviving rape apologists in the classroom tells us probably more than most of us want to know
00:00:45 about how feminist convictions translate into extreme anti-male bias in the university classroom
00:00:53 i recommend that everyone read the full article which is really remarkable and i'll touch on a
00:00:58 few points here the article is essentially about how difficult it is to teach about rape to
00:01:04 unrepentant rapists correct that unrepentant male students but that's basically one in the same
00:01:12 in this author's mind it is disgusting and offensive to this professor that some male 0.95
00:01:18 students disagree with her contentions about sexual violence. Some male students, for example,
00:01:24 find it hard to accept that rape is really as widespread as feminist professors say it is or
00:01:30 that it should be as loosely defined as it is. Perhaps they're skeptical that a rape has occurred 0.92
00:01:36 if a woman consumes alcohol before sex and then is said to have been incapable of giving her consent. 0.98
00:01:43 I suspect that idea would get me in the professor's elegant words a fucking zero if I wrote it on an 0.96
00:01:50 assignment but I'm jumping ahead so let me back up. This article is immensely useful for what it
00:01:59 shows about the incredible echo chamber that the feminist classroom has become in which theories 0.74
00:02:07 are presented not to be analyzed or tested but to be accepted and in which a professor can actually
00:02:13 feel traumatized because a few students doubt the theories and want to argue about them in the
00:02:20 heady old days of interactive pedagogy instructors used to feel wild with joy when students felt
00:02:26 strongly enough about any subject to try to challenge the instructor but this instructor
00:02:32 doesn't want male students to question they are to listen and believe and at best they may come
00:02:38 to recognize themselves for the unknowing rapists they likely are yes you heard that right the
00:02:47 instructor actually informs us that not only do some students in her class come to realize that
00:02:53 they themselves have been raped isn't feminist consciousness raising a wonderful thing not only
00:02:59 that but sometimes quote students learn that they have actually perpetrated rape and struggle to
00:03:06 reconcile that with their images of themselves as good people and not one of those usually guys
00:03:15 imagine using classroom time for this convincing female students that the sex they regretted that
00:03:23 time they were on holiday last year was really a crime because they didn't give an explicit
00:03:29 affirmative at every stage of the proceedings and convincing male students that what they thought
00:03:35 was a mutually enjoyable consensual relationship was really sexual assault this is what sociologists
00:03:41 get phds for nowadays and what they're paid six-figure salaries to do at university 0.58
00:03:47 Unfortunately, from the instructor's perspective, too few men are willing to accept their culpability.
00:03:55 Some of them, surprisingly, resist her insistence that they're all rapists, or at least rape facilitators.
00:04:03 As the instructor tells us, quote, 0.98
00:04:05 many feminist instructors, especially those who are women, know all too well what it is like to 0.99
00:04:12 navigate the mansplaining of a few men students who would like to ardently deny that rape culture 0.98
00:04:19 exists, end quote. Ah, mansplaining, that mocking little word invented by the advocates of equality.
00:04:31 according to this professor mansplaining is what men do when they fail to accept that
00:04:37 masculinity is coercive and predatory i wonder if she calls them mansplainers to their faces
00:04:44 i wonder if she pretends to herself and others that she doesn't harbor a deep-rooted dislike
00:04:51 of men in the article she presents men's supposedly typical objections to her theory
00:04:59 of rape culture and i can't help but wonder if she has deliberately dumbed down those questions
00:05:07 for inclusion in the article you wouldn't want them to seem too acute but even in the way she
00:05:12 presents those questions they're the kinds of objections that ordinary people might find
00:05:17 reasonable questions about women's responsibility for their own safety for example or questions
00:05:23 about feminist definitions we can't tell from the article whether the professor deals with
00:05:30 these questions in a professional manner maybe she does but it's hard to imagine i suspect she
00:05:37 tells her students that asking questions in the first place makes them part of the rape culture
00:05:43 that she's trying to enlighten them about and she never seems to question what right she has in a
00:05:49 supposedly secular university to demand that students accept her version of truth
00:05:57 the climax of the paper comes when the instructor reveals that she has herself been raped and that
00:06:03 on a recent occasion when she had to grade an essay in which the student denied the feminist
00:06:08 theory of rape she had an emotional meltdown which she tells us about in the clear expectation that
00:06:15 we will all empathize and it's worth saying that a fair number of the commentators on the article
00:06:21 do empathize she tells us that quote as i went over his paper i realized that i was reading a
00:06:29 paper that sounded word for word like something the man who raped me would say and not only did
00:06:35 this sound like something my rapist would say this student fit the same demographic profile as him
00:06:42 white college male between the ages of 18 and 22." Now at first it isn't clear what she means,
00:06:50 whether she is telling us she was actually raped or whether she's just imagining what a rapist
00:06:56 would say. Then once we're fairly sure she is referring to an actual rape, it seems possible
00:07:03 at first that the instructor suspects that the student essay writer may be her actual
00:07:09 rapist but then we come to understand that she's experiencing a traumatic memory and this is how
00:07:14 she describes it she says quote i got up from my desk and went for a walk i could not concentrate
00:07:21 i had plans to read a book later that afternoon which were shattered by being thrown back
00:07:27 not the plans her i guess into a pit of traumatic fragmented memories by this student's paper
00:07:35 i was furious at the fact that as an instructor i was expected to take his paper seriously
00:07:41 and scared of what he might do if he did not like his grade although i knew it was unlikely that
00:07:47 this student would literally try to rape me his words felt so familiar that i began having trouble
00:07:52 distinguishing him from the man that did their words were so frighteningly similar that the
00:07:58 rational instructor side of my brain could not overpower the trauma survivor side end quote
00:08:06 i can only guess that this professor has read a lot of trauma theory and that we're supposed
00:08:11 to understand that her reaction is consistent with trauma and perhaps it is but she wrote this
00:08:18 essay after the traumatic episode had passed and what she presents here as a university teacher's
00:08:24 statement about the difficulty of teaching resistant men is, in my opinion, outrageous. 0.61
00:08:33 At the end of the essay, she expects to be congratulated that she
00:08:38 summoned the courage to grade the student's paper. Perhaps we can assume that she no longer
00:08:45 literally fears that the student is likely to rape her in revenge for a poor grade, but
00:08:51 obviously she still does believe, or she wouldn't have written this article, that a man who objects 0.90
00:08:58 to feminist theory can be logically linked to a man who rapes. Now forget the weirdness of her
00:09:05 description, whether she means that the man who raped her actually argued with her about feminist
00:09:12 theory during or after the alleged rape, or whether she was merely imagining what he might
00:09:16 have said in his own defense if she had confronted him it's not clear i think it does say something
00:09:23 about her inability to convey ideas in prose but never mind what is so remarkable is this idea
00:09:30 which i've never seen so baldly stated by an actual feminist in the classroom that a man who
00:09:36 gets angry at the feminist insistence that all men are potential rapists is a potential rapist
00:09:44 with his anger as the proof. This is the absurd and yet widely accepted circularity of feminist
00:09:52 logic. I'm going to force men to sit and listen to me tell them that there is something in men 1.00
00:09:59 in our present culture that makes rape not only a symbol, but also an all too likely outcome of all
00:10:06 male-female relations. And if a man objects to that, if it fills him with rage at being so
00:10:12 slandered that just proves my point and i've been raped so don't you dare object to anything i'm 0.88
00:10:21 saying zero the professor screams at her computer screen in an outburst of blind rage you get a 1.00
00:10:30 zero well this woman shouldn't be anywhere near university students and she herself admits as 1.00
00:10:39 much at least indirectly when she asserts that one of the most basic tasks of an instructor
00:10:45 to detach from the personal in order to be objective is impossible for her
00:10:52 quote how i wondered could i possibly evaluate the student's work in an unbiased fashion
00:10:59 such a request would involve me living an entirely different life than the one that i have had end
00:11:05 quote. Feminist activists told us for years that this was the lie that men used against women who 1.00
00:11:15 wanted professional careers, that women were too emotional to do the job properly, that they brought
00:11:21 all their personal issues into their work in an inappropriate way. Now a feminist is telling us 1.00
00:11:29 that this is the reality of women's lives and that we shouldn't expect professionalism from 1.00
00:11:35 women. Well, I don't like the position I'm put in as a reader of this article, either to accept the 0.99
00:11:43 author's contention that as a victim she can't be expected to do her job properly, or to admit that
00:11:49 I'm a monster devoid of human empathy. And that's my point. There are places and situations where
00:11:56 feeling is paramount, but the classroom definitely shouldn't be one. And when feminists insist that 1.00
00:12:03 lived experience be placed at the center of academic instruction, this is exactly what 1.00
00:12:09 results. Rape victims wanting to teach about rape in the classroom and unable to recognize what a 1.00
00:12:16 catastrophically bad idea that is, not only for this instructor, but especially for all the other
00:12:25 male students who will experience her irrational fury and hatred.