00:00:00Female-only scholarships. They've been around for decades, but perhaps not for much longer.
00:00:09That's my subject on today's Fiomingo File.
00:00:21I'm Janice Fiomingo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:24Most of us probably simply shook our heads in disgust when we read Susanna Walter's Washington
00:00:31Post rant last summer titled Why Can't We Hate Men, in which the professor of sociology and
00:00:38gender studies at Northeastern University outlined the reasons she believes it is acceptable to
00:00:44despise half of the human race. She's since clarified you may be relieved to know that it's0.95
00:00:50mainly white men that she hates. But one man, Professor Mark Perry of the University of Michigan,0.96
00:00:57did something more concrete and potentially consequential in response to the Walters
00:01:02tirade. He launched a Title IX investigation alleging that Professor Walters had contravened
00:01:10her own university's stated anti-discrimination policy. Title IX, for anyone who doesn't know,
00:01:16is an American statute that outlaws discrimination in education on the basis of sex. Perry asked in
00:01:24an email to Walters School, quote, how would it be possible for Walters to publicly state that she0.62
00:01:30hates all men and not discriminate against them any more than a KKK racist who gave herself the
00:01:38right to hate all blacks or gays would not likely discriminate against those groups, end quote.
00:01:44And he followed up by asking, how could a male faculty colleague applying for tenure and or
00:01:50promotion in her department expect fair treatment from Professor Walters? How indeed?
00:01:58Well, at the time when I first learned about Professor Perry's complaint, I honored him
00:02:04for his determination, but I was pessimistic about the possibility of any action being taken
00:02:09against the profusely misandrous Professor Walters. Of course, we know that any tirade
00:02:16against women by a male professor would result in immediate suspension of all academic activities
00:02:23pending a full psychiatric evaluation and extensive counseling for the professor's1.00
00:02:30delusional rage, and rightly so. But we live in a culture in which expressions of anti-male
00:02:36hatred or so normalized that Professor Walter's screed caused no discernible reaction from the
00:02:42leadership at her university, and she's not likely, in my opinion, to be disciplined for her bigotry.
00:02:48But I could be wrong, because what I didn't know at the time was that Professor Perry is something
00:02:54of a veteran in the fight against normalized anti-male discrimination, and he's had significant
00:03:01success. He's been challenging female-only scholarships and initiatives and programs
00:03:09at universities through the university's own Title IX offices for the past two years,
00:03:14and he's been winning some significant battles. Two women-only scholarships offered by the
00:03:20University of Minnesota, his alma mater, were open to men as a result of Professor Perry's
00:03:28challenge and the university of michigan flint where he now teaches opened its girls in engineering
00:03:34math and science camp to boys he's now filed more than 20 complaints against other schools
00:03:42for programs that discriminate against males and he's encouraging others to join his campaign
00:03:48noting that quote there are likely thousands of single gender female only scholarships awards
00:03:55fellowships initiatives programs summer camps clubs etc that are ripe for title nine investigation
00:04:03and other advocates are taking up the cause notably a young man named kursat pegots a
00:04:11university of southern california phd student who has launched some exciting title nine
00:04:16investigations with the department of education's office for civil rights mainly against a massive
00:04:22volume of female-only scholarships and awards, though he's also prepared various reports of
00:04:29bias against specific offices. The schools that are currently under federal investigation include
00:04:35the University of Southern California, Yale, Princeton, and others. Margaret Valois, a Title
00:04:43IX attorney who specializes in defending accused male students, has filed a similar Title IX
00:04:48complaint against Tulane University and obtained a win very recently. Further complaints are in
00:04:55process against Georgetown University, the University of Michigan, the University of
00:04:59Virginia, the University of Pennsylvania, and others. Now, despite some predictable anti-male
00:05:07backlash on social media, including gossip about Kerset's own brush with a false accuser under
00:05:13Title IX, he is undaunted in his quest to make universities live up to their stated
00:05:19commitments to equality. How can a university declare itself opposed to gender discrimination
00:05:28while offering dozens, in some cases hundreds, of scholarships and awards and initiatives
00:05:33that men can't access? If these discriminatory affirmative action measures were ever
00:05:40morally justifiable, which in my opinion, they never were. Justice required non-discrimination
00:05:48and nothing more. But if they were ever morally justifiable, they certainly aren't now. It's been
00:05:54over three decades since women were minorities in most academic faculties and schools. Women now
00:06:02outnumber men at a ratio of three to two, roughly, in all but a very small handful of specialized
00:06:09programs, particularly basically computing science and engineering. Overall, women are the clear
00:06:16majority at post-secondary institutions, accounting for 1,082,000 undergraduate degree recipients in
00:06:24the year 2014-2015, while male numbers are stagnating at 812,000. While feminists demand1.00
00:06:34ever more aggressive measures to shoehorn women into the STEM fields. Professor Mark Perry's
00:06:41own research shows that women now earn the majority of STEM degrees overall, depending on
00:06:47exactly what one counts as STEM. And women are twice as likely as men to be hired into academic0.75
00:06:53STEM positions, at least partly because of incredible feminist pressure. Men's numbers in0.97
00:07:00many specific university fields especially in education law medicine and the social sciences
00:07:08are really alarmingly low and all of these fields are turning against men promoting myths about male
00:07:15sexual violence and the harm of masculinity as seen recently in the american psychological
00:07:20association's guidelines for psychological practice with boys and men in addition as they
00:07:26always have men work in far more dangerous jobs than women and are far far more likely to suffer
00:07:34serious injury or death in their work lives the least that universities could do one would think
00:07:41is not add insult to injury by pretending that women are the disadvantaged ones unfortunately
00:07:49culturally cultural sympathy for women is so strong and at men's expense that it's very easy
00:07:57for gynocentrists to make the quest for gender equality look like an attack on women, as we see
00:08:05even from the title of a recent article published in December 2018 written for NBC News by Katie
00:08:13engelhardt called men's rights activists are attacking women's scholarships and programs
00:08:22the far less sensational truth is that these scholarships will still be available for women
00:08:29but men will have a shot at them too yes equality does look like disadvantage when you've been given
00:08:37unfair perks your whole life. For this article, Englehart interviewed a number of feminist1.00
00:08:45activists, all of whom attempt to justify the blatant discrimination. As one would expect,1.00
00:08:52they don't make moral or philosophical arguments, and they show themselves incapable of honest
00:08:58reflection on feminist overreach. Instead, they fudge the truth and rely heavily on tired claims
00:09:05about the special barriers that women have faced in history and supposedly continue to face. But
00:09:12it's worth looking at their arguments to assess the strength of the feminist case against justice.
00:09:19One such activist is Adaku Onyeka Crawford, who is the senior counsel for the National Women's Law
00:09:26Center. She defended affirmative action for women in that article simply by saying that if we take1.00
00:09:33it away, we may see women's gains falter. Well, yes, it is possible that if women are being0.99
00:09:42promoted simply because they're female, their numbers may decrease when female advantage is1.00
00:09:49removed. That's why it's called equality of opportunity. But one suspects that Ms. Onyeka1.00
00:09:55Crawford is not at all interested in this kind of equality. She revealed her near phobic aversion0.98
00:10:02to reality by calling women-only programs, quote, gender-inclusive. Other feminist activists
00:10:13interviewed for the article argued in hair-splitting fashion that Title IX is meant to redress1.00
00:10:21historical sex discrimination, not just under-representation, with the implication that
00:10:28women's underrepresentation in the past was a special kind of injustice for which overcorrection
00:10:35in the present is perfectly justifiable. Jocelyn Samuels, a former director of the Office of Civil0.84
00:10:42Rights at the Department of Health, is quoted in the article as saying that, yes, men may be
00:10:48underrepresented in some academic fields. And she singles out nursing as the one example that
00:10:55she'll admit to. But she claims this is, quote, not because of the same institutional discrimination
00:11:01that barred women from certain disciplines, end quote. Her statement implies that men's
00:11:07under-representation is the result of choice or some other neutral factor, while women's
00:11:14under-representation was and is the result of something far more malignant, something called
00:11:21institutional discrimination. But this is nonsense. There is no evidence that women have ever in the
00:11:30last century been kept out of academic fields through institutional exclusion. Women who wish
00:11:38to pursue a university education have been legally able to do so since the late 19th and0.94
00:11:45early 20th centuries no law or policy or institutional practice prevented it many chose
00:11:53not to because they didn't wish to go to college weren't expected to go to college weren't encouraged
00:11:58to do so and because marriage and childbearing prevented them from doing so if these are
00:12:05institutional barriers they're certainly no more tangible or deliberate than the barriers that are
00:12:11now preventing many men from choosing to attend or achieve success in post-secondary education,
00:12:18most particularly the overt anti-male bias that has become the orthodoxy in many fields.
00:12:26And it is disingenuous to say the least to pretend that only women can face significant barriers.
00:12:35Another feminist activist quoted in the article takes a different tack to say that it doesn't0.97
00:12:42matter if women outnumber men in the vast majority of academic disciplines. Her argument is that0.99
00:12:48until women achieve complete equality of outcome in the outside world, they will still deserve the1.00
00:12:56special academic perks they've had for the past half decade. Professor of Sociology Susanna0.99
00:13:03walters yes it's the same one is dexterous with a few convenient statistics she mentions that0.59
00:13:11female managers earn 77 percent of male managers salaries and she mentions that women make up just
00:13:1930 percent of university presidents and five percent of fortune 500 ceos so according to1.00
00:13:27walters until absolute equality of outcome is achieved in every metric that feminists care to1.00
00:13:35measure of course not the number of women in sewer repair or strip mining or frontline soldiering1.00
00:13:41and even in the absence of any evidence that women are being prevented from equaling men's
00:13:47achievement by anything but their own refusal to make the personal sacrifices necessary to do so
00:13:53until that feminist utopia is achieved, men should still be discriminated against, according to
00:13:59Walters, even in areas of academic study where women have an enormous, actually embarrassing
00:14:08advantage in numbers. It's obvious that Walters doesn't give a damn about men's academic1.00
00:14:16underachievement. On the contrary, one suspects that men's numbers could drop to zero and she'd0.87
00:14:22see no reason to discontinue female-only programs. In fact, then she'd have a different argument for
00:14:28why they could continue. Even if she weren't on record as an unrepentant man-hater, it would be
00:14:35hard to take her tripe seriously. And this is all that the feminists can marshal at the moment.1.00
00:14:45These Title IX challenges are unprecedented, and I suspect they have caught feminists by surprise.1.00
00:14:51We can expect to see them rally in 2019 to defend all of the special privileges that they've had in place for nearly 50 years.0.99
00:15:02But if men's advocates keep up the attack, launching more challenges and creating strong legal precedents, it may be too late for the feminists.0.84
00:15:10And either way, things in this particular area look bad for them.0.99
00:15:16even if they win. Their defense of such blatant discrimination reveals them for the bigoted
00:15:22female chauvinists we know they are. Normally I'm the last person to be confident, but in this case
00:15:29I'd say that both principle and strategy are on the side of long overdue justice for men.