The John-Henry Westen Show - January 11, 2023


Cardinal Muller Exclusive： Will Progressive Leadership Destroy The Church？


Episode Stats

Length

47 minutes

Words per Minute

112.44491

Word Count

5,383

Sentence Count

76

Misogynist Sentences

6

Hate Speech Sentences

13


Summary

Cardinal Gerhard M. Muller, former head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith, joins us to talk about his memories of Pope Benedict XVI, and his thoughts on modernizing the Catholic Church. He also talks about why the Church should modernize in the 21st century.


Transcript

00:00:00.000 We are not looking to the Holy Father as the ideology is looking to the leader in China
00:00:06.840 or in North Korea or dictator, where human beings are absolutizing themselves as if they were gods.
00:00:16.420 The Pope, the bishops, the priests are not God.
00:00:19.700 We cannot, as Christians, only continue with our own prejudices.
00:00:28.000 Because our mission is to overcome the prejudices and to come together to give a good example.
00:00:36.880 Hello and welcome again to the John Henry Weston Show.
00:00:39.940 We are coming to you, obviously, from Rome, where we are in the presence of Cardinal Gerhard Müller,
00:00:46.060 the former head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith.
00:00:49.420 And one quick question for you.
00:00:52.060 This apartment, is it the same apartment that Cardinal Ratzinger had?
00:00:55.500 It's the same apartment, and he gave it personally to me when he became Pope.
00:01:02.080 For seven years, this apartment was empty, and he gave it exactly personally for me, for you.
00:01:11.240 He said, you are my friend, for you.
00:01:14.680 Amazing.
00:01:15.520 So we are coming to you literally from the former apartment of Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, Pope Benedict XVI.
00:01:23.080 This is the John Henry Weston Show, and I know you are going to want to stay tuned for this one.
00:01:34.560 Your Eminence, so good to be with you.
00:01:36.720 If you wouldn't mind, start us off with the sign of the cross.
00:01:39.360 In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.
00:01:42.140 Amen. Amen.
00:01:43.160 We are all here for the funeral of Benedict XVI.
00:01:47.680 This morning you were there in the cold, but for the funeral mass.
00:01:53.380 First of all, if you can tell us, what were your takeaways from the funeral mass?
00:01:57.260 And then, what is your message about your memory of and your love for Pope Benedict?
00:02:04.800 Yes, the funeral mass is like the funeral mass is for every Catholic, and it is a prayer in the power of the Holy Cross,
00:02:16.560 of the sacrifice of Jesus Christ on the cross, which is sacramentally present in the Holy Mass.
00:02:24.820 And we are believing to be united with the Christians, believers, not more believers,
00:02:32.980 but now they are seeing God from face to face with all the baptized in the heaven.
00:02:39.480 And now the baptized believers here in the pilgrim church, and also with the souls in the purgatory.
00:02:47.760 But we hope for him that it's not more of the purgatory, he had enough purgatory on earth.
00:02:56.480 With Cardinal Ratzinger, who you worked with, and then later with Pope Benedict,
00:03:01.940 he was a man, obviously, of great suffering, who suffered in the church, even from his own brothers in the church.
00:03:08.720 Tell us a little bit about that, if you will, especially from your knowledge of it, with working with him personally.
00:03:13.400 There is a wrong ideology that the church is behind of the development of the modern world,
00:03:21.740 and therefore we have to modernize the church, and this understanding, or the normal Catholic understanding,
00:03:30.480 church can never be behind of the time, because Jesus is the fullness of time,
00:03:36.980 and never we can overcome Jesus, the only mediator between God, the Father, and us.
00:03:43.400 The humankind, only the style, and so on, and the form of theology,
00:03:50.540 the answers to the challenges of the different times and epochs can change,
00:03:57.680 but not the revelation, the Word of God, His value forever.
00:04:05.180 Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today, and forever and all eternity,
00:04:10.100 and therefore the truth of Jesus Christ is outside of these competences between so-called conservatives or progressists and liberals and all.
00:04:22.360 This is only political categories, has nothing to do with our relation to God in His Word,
00:04:29.120 and in this healing of our souls, and in this healing of our souls and the salvation.
00:04:34.080 There is no conservative baptism or progressive baptism, or the grace is not liberal or not liberal,
00:04:43.760 or this is absolutely absurd, to define the question of the faith with political categories,
00:04:54.300 and what is the new time, the modernity, is only the modern technology or the modern medicine could help us,
00:05:03.140 or the modernity is also shaped by strange and bad ideologies,
00:05:09.480 understanding the definition of man, of all the existence of the world without God,
00:05:17.680 in the great ideologies, in the French Revolution, the Jacobinians,
00:05:23.380 and with all this terrorism and all these characteristics of these modern ideologies,
00:05:31.120 the communism, the national socialism, fascism, but now the posthumanism,
00:05:37.880 all this, the vogue culture, all anti-humanistic ideologies,
00:05:44.460 and we must resist against it, and we are more modern than in the Neos of Lyon,
00:05:52.260 the first and second century, this big work against the Gnostics of all times,
00:06:02.100 is that Jesus can never be overcome, not by politicians, nor by politics, nor by ideologies, nor by philosophy,
00:06:12.480 because Jesus is homo novissimus, most modern man of the world,
00:06:20.320 because he is the same, Alpha and Omega,
00:06:24.040 the beginning, the origin, and the aim, goal of everything,
00:06:30.320 and this was the position of Cardinal Ratzinger Professor Ratzinger,
00:06:36.900 Cardinal Ratzinger, and Pope Benedict,
00:06:39.620 he is belonging to the great culture, European culture,
00:06:49.200 Platon, Aristoteles, Aristotel, and all these great philosophers of the European culture,
00:06:59.160 the Roman right, and Athens, and Jerusalem,
00:07:03.000 for the three points of the orientation,
00:07:06.060 Christianity, Christian faith is not a mixture of all this,
00:07:09.520 but it's shaping all the human thinking,
00:07:15.480 all this longing for,
00:07:20.480 and it's a fulfillment of all human desires,
00:07:24.840 and I think some bishops or theologians was in contrary contradiction to him,
00:07:37.000 not only on the level of different theological styles or schools,
00:07:41.460 this is possible in the church,
00:07:44.440 we have St. Thomas Aquinas,
00:07:46.380 Tutskotus has the same Catholic faith,
00:07:48.840 but different St. Thomas Aquinas and the style of St. Augustine,
00:07:56.760 and Basileus the Great,
00:07:58.400 and so a different style and form to express himself,
00:08:02.840 it was confronted to other questions,
00:08:05.760 other challenges of their times,
00:08:08.460 that is not the question,
00:08:09.600 but here was the question,
00:08:12.320 what is the truth of the Catholic faith revealed forever,
00:08:15.520 and the mixture between these modern ideologies?
00:08:24.640 Joseph Ratzinger, when he was a young man,
00:08:27.240 or a boy first,
00:08:29.180 and a young man, adolescent,
00:08:32.180 when he was six years old,
00:08:35.760 or five years old,
00:08:37.220 and in Germany the Nazis came to the power,
00:08:41.080 and he grew up in this time,
00:08:43.580 but in the Catholic family it was absolutely clear,
00:08:47.420 that the Nazi ideology has nothing to do,
00:08:50.100 it's a contradiction to the Christian and Catholic faith,
00:08:54.480 but he was in this confrontation in the youth time,
00:08:58.460 it's very important,
00:08:59.700 and he did see what is happening,
00:09:05.160 if God is denied,
00:09:08.460 what is a human being without God,
00:09:14.500 and this is human beings are enemies to God,
00:09:19.040 and he later was as Pope in Auschwitz,
00:09:23.240 he said that is a result of the neo-paganism,
00:09:28.100 of the denying of God,
00:09:29.680 because the Jewish people have the same faith,
00:09:33.860 like we in the believing of the God of Abraham,
00:09:39.140 Isaac, Jacob,
00:09:40.360 and the God and Father of Jesus Christ,
00:09:43.640 is the God who spoke first in Moses,
00:09:47.980 in the first alliance,
00:09:49.420 and this was a contradiction,
00:09:52.060 also the communism,
00:09:53.100 Stalinism,
00:09:53.900 a direct contradiction,
00:09:56.100 not against the philosophical belief in God,
00:10:00.700 but against the biblical revelation of this God,
00:10:06.760 how we see revealed himself in the history of salvation,
00:10:13.100 and what is present in our great testimony in the Bible,
00:10:17.860 and that is a great legacy of Joseph Ratzinger,
00:10:25.880 Pope Benedict XVI,
00:10:27.380 to be firm in the belief in God,
00:10:31.020 and in his spiritual testament,
00:10:33.780 he wrote it and said it,
00:10:38.200 start to firm it in faith,
00:10:41.080 to be very sure and firm in the faith,
00:10:47.140 and there is no other salvation for us,
00:10:51.720 as in Jesus Christ,
00:10:55.500 the Savior of the world.
00:10:56.720 Absolutely.
00:10:58.140 His quote from the last testament that you're mentioning,
00:11:01.520 is he was to say,
00:11:02.640 to stand firm and to not be confused.
00:11:05.880 And one of the sufferings that Pope Benedict
00:11:09.700 sort of endured,
00:11:12.780 particularly in these last few years,
00:11:15.040 while he was Pope Emeritus,
00:11:17.680 was the suffering from the bishops of Germany.
00:11:21.000 And that's what suffering that you yourself experienced as well,
00:11:23.920 both as the head of the CDF and then after,
00:11:27.500 but also both of you as bishops from Germany,
00:11:31.480 watching your confrères,
00:11:33.740 your brother bishops in Germany,
00:11:35.660 seem to go against the faith in so many different ways.
00:11:39.560 Was that something that hurt Pope Benedict to see?
00:11:43.080 But also in this last number of days as he was closing his life,
00:11:49.300 he saw Pope Francis, it seemed,
00:11:54.640 would put as the head of the congregation for the doctrine of faith,
00:11:58.860 Bishop Wilma,
00:11:59.680 who is very much on that line that the German bishops are taking,
00:12:04.060 the line that I believe you have called one that goes against the faith.
00:12:08.260 Bishop Wilma,
00:12:09.280 I don't know him personally,
00:12:12.080 and I want to say anything against his person,
00:12:16.920 but his positions,
00:12:19.260 he's taking part of the so-called synodal path,
00:12:24.460 are heretical.
00:12:26.520 Because not only heretical,
00:12:30.780 this is an absolute contradiction to the revealed anthropology.
00:12:38.040 If we say God created human being in the Logos,
00:12:45.380 in the Son of God,
00:12:47.620 at the beginning,
00:12:49.180 male and female,
00:12:50.240 and according to his likeness,
00:12:54.520 in body and soul,
00:12:57.640 we cannot deny it.
00:12:59.020 It's a so-called new anthropology.
00:13:02.960 It's not a new anthropology.
00:13:05.220 It's an absolute distinction,
00:13:07.100 separation between the center of the person,
00:13:12.780 and the autonomy,
00:13:14.400 and on the other side,
00:13:16.260 the body.
00:13:17.040 We are a union between soul and body.
00:13:22.780 We cannot separate it.
00:13:24.760 If we are separated,
00:13:26.040 we will die.
00:13:28.560 But we will not fall back in the nothing.
00:13:33.840 But we will be,
00:13:35.160 after our death,
00:13:36.640 confronted to God
00:13:38.700 as our judge,
00:13:40.680 our final judge,
00:13:43.040 ultimate and definitive judgment
00:13:45.480 we receive
00:13:47.160 about all we are doing.
00:13:49.740 And all these documents,
00:13:51.220 they have
00:13:52.240 against the priesthood,
00:13:54.120 the sacramental priesthood,
00:13:57.160 and the matrimony,
00:13:58.980 matrimony as a sacrament,
00:14:01.940 and about the sexual ethics,
00:14:05.820 are absolutely against,
00:14:08.820 not in only some points,
00:14:10.480 but in all the hermeneutic
00:14:13.240 of these questions.
00:14:15.860 This is a contradiction
00:14:16.980 to the revealed Catholic faith.
00:14:21.300 They want a little bit to hide it,
00:14:24.220 presenting themselves as Catholics
00:14:27.420 in the other way.
00:14:29.980 But there is no Catholicism
00:14:31.900 in the other ways,
00:14:33.000 only the way.
00:14:34.820 Jesus Christ is the way.
00:14:36.880 And there is no other,
00:14:38.540 so-called other way
00:14:40.640 of those who are thinking
00:14:43.520 Jesus was only
00:14:45.680 the beginning point
00:14:47.380 of a great Christian culture.
00:14:51.020 And we have to
00:14:52.200 make it more perfect,
00:14:54.560 and we have to modernize
00:14:56.520 as if Jesus
00:14:58.280 was only
00:14:59.720 an ancient
00:15:02.620 thinker
00:15:04.100 or
00:15:04.800 religious
00:15:06.080 founder
00:15:07.100 or anything.
00:15:08.820 And we can develop
00:15:09.940 Buddha
00:15:10.480 and
00:15:11.000 Confucius
00:15:13.260 or we can
00:15:14.180 modernize
00:15:15.500 Plato
00:15:16.260 or the
00:15:16.860 Aristotle
00:15:17.440 or
00:15:18.000 if Jesus Christ
00:15:20.680 is the same
00:15:21.400 yesterday,
00:15:22.720 today,
00:15:23.060 and for all
00:15:24.880 the times,
00:15:25.700 for the
00:15:26.060 eternal times,
00:15:30.100 there is
00:15:30.720 it's not possible
00:15:33.120 to correct him
00:15:34.680 or to
00:15:36.420 fulfill
00:15:37.620 Jesus
00:15:39.160 is a fulfillment
00:15:40.140 of the
00:15:41.480 revelation.
00:15:42.500 He's a Logos,
00:15:43.380 he's a word of God.
00:15:45.200 And nobody
00:15:45.780 can
00:15:46.660 present himself
00:15:48.480 as more
00:15:49.800 intelligent
00:15:50.320 as
00:15:50.980 intellectus
00:15:52.180 divinos
00:15:52.840 intelligence.
00:15:53.840 Logos
00:15:54.740 is
00:15:55.020 intellectus,
00:15:56.100 intelligence.
00:15:58.820 The divine
00:16:00.160 intelligence
00:16:00.840 is revealed
00:16:02.560 in Jesus
00:16:03.060 Christ.
00:16:03.880 And therefore
00:16:04.780 about
00:16:05.320 what is
00:16:05.840 belonging to
00:16:06.660 our
00:16:07.100 relation
00:16:08.440 to God
00:16:09.120 and salvation
00:16:09.860 that is
00:16:12.060 absolutely
00:16:12.760 and fully
00:16:14.580 revealed
00:16:15.820 in Jesus
00:16:16.340 Christ.
00:16:16.960 one of
00:16:17.720 the things
00:16:18.200 that
00:16:18.680 for
00:16:19.540 Pope
00:16:19.880 Benedict
00:16:20.200 was
00:16:21.520 very
00:16:22.000 dear
00:16:22.280 to
00:16:22.500 his
00:16:22.680 heart
00:16:23.000 and
00:16:23.780 just
00:16:25.280 Archbishop
00:16:26.060 Genswein
00:16:26.640 gave an
00:16:27.080 interview
00:16:27.380 with
00:16:27.660 Tagospost
00:16:28.400 just now
00:16:29.200 about
00:16:30.140 what
00:16:31.040 broke
00:16:31.780 Pope
00:16:32.440 Benedict's
00:16:32.860 heart.
00:16:33.860 He
00:16:33.940 talked
00:16:34.260 about
00:16:34.680 you know
00:16:36.000 one of
00:16:36.840 Pope
00:16:37.460 Benedict's
00:16:37.820 probably
00:16:38.180 greatest
00:16:38.760 legacies
00:16:39.320 will be
00:16:40.040 Sumorum
00:16:40.380 Pontificum
00:16:41.080 and
00:16:42.560 Archbishop
00:16:43.640 Genswein
00:16:44.240 talked about
00:16:44.880 how
00:16:45.400 for the
00:16:45.760 very first
00:16:46.220 time
00:16:46.640 about
00:16:47.360 how
00:16:48.000 Traditionis
00:16:49.480 Custodis
00:16:50.280 broke
00:16:51.040 Pope Benedict's
00:16:52.440 heart.
00:16:53.000 If you can
00:16:53.780 explain that
00:16:54.740 for us
00:16:55.200 what's
00:16:55.860 behind that
00:16:56.440 and what
00:16:57.280 that means.
00:16:58.280 This question
00:16:58.980 is not
00:16:59.400 on the
00:16:59.980 strict
00:17:00.960 dogmatic
00:17:01.720 level
00:17:03.020 because
00:17:03.780 we have
00:17:04.720 in the
00:17:05.100 Church
00:17:05.480 the same
00:17:07.160 Holy Mass
00:17:08.200 the same
00:17:08.540 sacrament
00:17:09.000 of Eucharist
00:17:09.820 but in
00:17:10.760 different
00:17:11.220 rites
00:17:12.240 and also
00:17:12.920 the
00:17:13.240 so-called
00:17:14.560 Latin
00:17:15.140 Roman
00:17:15.780 rite
00:17:16.380 has
00:17:17.160 certain
00:17:17.740 developments
00:17:18.480 but not
00:17:19.200 belonging to
00:17:19.800 the substance
00:17:20.480 but the
00:17:21.540 external
00:17:21.980 forms.
00:17:24.000 The
00:17:24.100 Gloria
00:17:24.420 was not
00:17:25.040 all the
00:17:25.940 time at
00:17:26.400 the beginning
00:17:26.880 in the
00:17:27.240 Holy Mass
00:17:27.860 but at
00:17:29.220 the end
00:17:29.700 there was
00:17:31.320 developed
00:17:32.180 a certain
00:17:33.340 form
00:17:33.760 a certain
00:17:34.600 type
00:17:35.160 of the
00:17:35.980 Latin
00:17:36.280 rite
00:17:36.800 and the
00:17:37.580 Council
00:17:38.080 the
00:17:38.580 Second
00:17:38.840 Vatican
00:17:39.220 Council
00:17:39.740 didn't
00:17:40.700 want
00:17:40.980 to
00:17:41.180 change
00:17:41.960 to
00:17:43.160 substitute
00:17:43.680 the
00:17:44.340 Latin
00:17:44.660 rite
00:17:45.340 only
00:17:46.800 a little
00:17:48.300 bit
00:17:48.520 making
00:17:48.880 clearer
00:17:49.480 because
00:17:50.520 in
00:17:50.920 some
00:17:51.460 times
00:17:52.240 in
00:17:52.680 some
00:17:52.980 epochs
00:17:54.340 there was
00:17:55.620 in the
00:17:56.040 10th
00:17:56.940 century
00:17:57.360 we can
00:17:58.220 say a
00:17:58.600 little
00:17:58.780 bit
00:17:59.020 a
00:17:59.200 mixture
00:17:59.580 between
00:18:00.520 the
00:18:00.820 old
00:18:01.340 Roman
00:18:03.020 rite
00:18:03.740 and
00:18:04.160 these
00:18:05.420 churches
00:18:05.880 in
00:18:06.320 Gallia
00:18:06.940 are
00:18:07.160 today
00:18:07.500 France
00:18:08.140 and
00:18:08.460 Germany
00:18:09.260 and so
00:18:09.940 it was
00:18:10.780 a little
00:18:11.060 bit
00:18:11.360 mixture
00:18:11.760 and
00:18:12.180 some
00:18:13.100 elements
00:18:13.720 was not
00:18:16.000 so
00:18:16.360 absolutely
00:18:16.920 well
00:18:17.300 ordered
00:18:17.780 and this
00:18:19.360 was the
00:18:19.780 only
00:18:20.140 proposal
00:18:21.280 of the
00:18:23.160 Vatican
00:18:24.260 Council
00:18:24.880 and to
00:18:26.600 give
00:18:26.960 the
00:18:27.260 lectures
00:18:28.040 and the
00:18:28.660 gospel
00:18:29.040 in
00:18:29.600 the
00:18:30.980 language
00:18:31.380 of the
00:18:32.180 people
00:18:32.600 but they
00:18:33.140 didn't
00:18:33.480 want
00:18:33.840 to
00:18:34.520 eliminate
00:18:35.380 the
00:18:36.120 Latin
00:18:36.420 as a
00:18:36.800 basic
00:18:37.340 language
00:18:40.020 liturgical
00:18:41.140 language
00:18:42.020 in the
00:18:42.720 Latin
00:18:43.080 rite
00:18:44.440 but they
00:18:45.120 have
00:18:45.640 some
00:18:46.460 problems
00:18:48.860 in the
00:18:49.480 realization
00:18:50.800 of the
00:18:51.860 liturgical
00:18:52.760 renewal
00:18:54.540 and some
00:18:56.240 mistakes
00:18:58.880 or some
00:18:59.680 abuses
00:19:00.320 as if
00:19:02.340 the
00:19:02.740 liturgy
00:19:03.220 were
00:19:03.440 only
00:19:04.500 self
00:19:05.660 reverential
00:19:07.280 cult
00:19:11.000 and not
00:19:11.600 the
00:19:11.780 adoration
00:19:12.280 of God
00:19:12.980 the
00:19:13.540 theodentric
00:19:15.180 and the
00:19:15.720 christiological
00:19:16.620 mediation
00:19:17.360 and though
00:19:18.580 there was a
00:19:18.960 misunderstanding
00:19:19.540 of the
00:19:20.560 sacraments
00:19:21.200 as only
00:19:21.760 a religious
00:19:22.320 rite
00:19:22.880 according
00:19:23.800 to the
00:19:24.260 pleasure
00:19:24.600 of the
00:19:26.220 people
00:19:28.360 all these
00:19:30.520 symbols
00:19:31.080 the religious
00:19:31.700 symbols
00:19:32.220 expressing
00:19:33.220 my
00:19:34.120 feeling
00:19:34.760 according
00:19:35.760 to the
00:19:36.300 absolute
00:19:36.740 and so
00:19:37.480 and not
00:19:38.540 the
00:19:39.080 shape
00:19:41.540 and the
00:19:41.920 reality
00:19:42.620 of the
00:19:43.700 sacramental
00:19:44.420 presence
00:19:45.260 of the
00:19:47.240 grace of
00:19:47.860 Jesus Christ
00:19:48.700 in the
00:19:49.180 seven
00:19:49.520 sacraments
00:19:50.660 especially
00:19:51.140 in the
00:19:52.000 Eucharist
00:19:52.840 and this
00:19:54.700 was a
00:19:55.080 very wise
00:19:55.700 decision
00:19:56.180 of Pope
00:19:58.000 Benedict XVI
00:19:59.060 to
00:20:00.500 distinguish
00:20:01.500 between
00:20:02.080 the
00:20:02.400 ordinary
00:20:03.240 rite
00:20:03.920 in the
00:20:04.380 newer
00:20:05.660 form
00:20:06.380 and
00:20:07.000 the
00:20:07.520 extraordinary
00:20:08.180 rite
00:20:09.440 also by
00:20:11.020 underlining
00:20:12.360 that
00:20:13.540 the
00:20:14.600 Vatican
00:20:14.900 Council
00:20:15.580 didn't
00:20:17.160 want
00:20:18.800 to
00:20:19.880 make
00:20:20.340 a
00:20:20.840 rupture
00:20:21.300 in
00:20:22.920 the
00:20:23.820 continuity
00:20:24.520 of
00:20:26.120 the
00:20:26.520 life
00:20:27.000 of
00:20:27.860 the
00:20:28.260 Catholic
00:20:29.380 Church
00:20:30.140 and
00:20:30.520 in
00:20:30.760 the
00:20:31.140 Catholic
00:20:31.960 liturgy
00:20:33.280 but
00:20:34.540 now
00:20:34.860 I think
00:20:35.420 there
00:20:36.600 came
00:20:37.320 some
00:20:38.060 people
00:20:38.440 to
00:20:38.660 him
00:20:38.940 and
00:20:40.220 said
00:20:40.460 they
00:20:40.880 are
00:20:41.240 the
00:20:42.540 reactionaries
00:20:44.040 and
00:20:44.680 the
00:20:45.520 conservatives
00:20:46.240 and
00:20:47.140 the
00:20:47.700 rigid
00:20:48.140 people
00:20:48.880 they
00:20:49.940 are
00:20:50.400 preferring
00:20:51.320 the
00:20:51.560 old
00:20:51.840 rite
00:20:52.320 and
00:20:53.260 we
00:20:53.420 must
00:20:53.720 destroy
00:20:54.340 this
00:20:55.680 old
00:20:56.260 rite
00:20:56.660 and
00:20:56.880 then
00:20:57.200 we
00:20:58.000 are
00:20:58.280 going
00:20:58.860 together
00:20:59.840 but
00:21:00.220 I
00:21:00.400 think
00:21:00.660 that
00:21:01.600 was
00:21:01.820 not
00:21:02.200 pastorally
00:21:04.160 very
00:21:04.520 wise
00:21:05.060 to
00:21:06.840 act
00:21:07.380 so
00:21:08.020 brutally
00:21:09.840 in
00:21:11.720 questions
00:21:12.380 which
00:21:13.840 are
00:21:14.040 not
00:21:14.300 on
00:21:14.800 the
00:21:14.940 dogmatic
00:21:15.400 level
00:21:15.820 but
00:21:17.040 it's
00:21:17.240 I
00:21:17.420 think
00:21:17.680 it's
00:21:18.180 a
00:21:18.260 certain
00:21:18.540 contradiction
00:21:19.320 where
00:21:20.580 is
00:21:20.920 possible
00:21:21.800 plurality
00:21:24.160 legitimate
00:21:25.520 plurality
00:21:26.700 in the
00:21:27.120 liturgical
00:21:27.640 expression
00:21:28.460 so
00:21:29.640 they
00:21:29.720 are
00:21:29.960 suppressed
00:21:30.760 and
00:21:32.220 when
00:21:33.020 we
00:21:33.200 are
00:21:33.420 on
00:21:33.660 the
00:21:33.780 dogmatical
00:21:34.600 level
00:21:35.960 of the
00:21:37.280 doctrine
00:21:37.660 of the
00:21:38.140 church
00:21:38.480 of the
00:21:38.820 revealed
00:21:39.280 faith
00:21:39.740 they
00:21:40.520 are
00:21:40.820 very
00:21:42.620 liberal
00:21:43.100 they
00:21:44.100 accept
00:21:44.500 all
00:21:44.900 the
00:21:45.080 heresies
00:21:45.840 as if
00:21:46.920 the
00:21:47.100 heresies
00:21:47.620 a
00:21:47.800 contradiction
00:21:48.540 against
00:21:49.680 the
00:21:49.920 revelation
00:21:50.460 would
00:21:51.240 be
00:21:51.560 one
00:21:52.200 form
00:21:52.520 of
00:21:52.700 the
00:21:52.860 expression
00:21:53.420 they
00:21:54.480 are
00:21:54.600 very
00:21:54.860 totalitarian
00:21:55.820 in the
00:21:56.140 one
00:21:56.440 way
00:21:58.180 where
00:21:58.740 it's
00:21:59.640 possible
00:22:00.020 a
00:22:00.340 legitimate
00:22:00.880 plurality
00:22:02.140 and
00:22:03.320 where
00:22:03.500 we
00:22:03.660 have
00:22:03.860 the
00:22:04.100 unity
00:22:04.840 in
00:22:05.440 faith
00:22:06.120 the
00:22:06.600 pope
00:22:06.880 is
00:22:07.060 the
00:22:07.240 first
00:22:07.740 responsible
00:22:09.940 for
00:22:10.440 the
00:22:10.660 unity
00:22:11.080 of
00:22:12.100 all
00:22:13.060 the
00:22:13.280 bishops
00:22:13.720 and
00:22:14.740 the
00:22:15.040 faithful
00:22:15.580 in
00:22:16.760 the
00:22:17.080 one
00:22:17.400 revealed
00:22:18.180 faith
00:22:18.800 that is
00:22:19.420 the
00:22:20.540 expression
00:22:21.060 also
00:22:21.500 of
00:22:21.920 the
00:22:22.920 Irenaeus
00:22:23.520 of
00:22:23.720 Lyon
00:22:24.120 we
00:22:25.500 have
00:22:25.680 everywhere
00:22:26.540 the
00:22:26.840 same
00:22:27.120 faith
00:22:27.640 in
00:22:28.520 Libya
00:22:28.880 Egypt
00:22:30.080 Galia
00:22:31.860 France
00:22:32.760 Germany
00:22:34.360 the
00:22:34.660 old
00:22:34.900 Germanies
00:22:35.560 and
00:22:35.760 everywhere
00:22:36.160 in
00:22:36.440 Spain
00:22:36.820 and
00:22:37.640 Rome
00:22:38.040 we
00:22:38.240 have
00:22:38.420 everywhere
00:22:38.920 the
00:22:39.200 same
00:22:39.580 faith
00:22:40.740 in
00:22:41.220 spite
00:22:41.540 of
00:22:41.760 different
00:22:42.160 languages
00:22:42.680 cultures
00:22:43.300 and
00:22:43.640 so
00:22:43.920 unity
00:22:45.460 in
00:22:45.700 the
00:22:45.880 faith
00:22:46.300 and
00:22:47.180 also
00:22:47.460 the
00:22:47.740 second
00:22:48.240 Vatican
00:22:48.560 council
00:22:49.040 in
00:22:49.320 Lumen
00:22:49.560 Gentium
00:22:50.040 about
00:22:50.320 the
00:22:50.620 church
00:22:51.300 is
00:22:51.520 saying
00:22:51.820 what
00:22:52.120 is
00:22:52.680 the
00:22:53.120 service
00:22:53.500 what
00:22:54.440 is
00:22:54.560 the
00:22:54.700 mission
00:22:54.960 of
00:22:55.240 the
00:22:55.640 pope
00:22:56.020 not
00:22:56.880 only
00:22:57.200 to
00:22:57.540 be
00:22:57.780 here
00:22:58.100 some
00:22:59.120 rights
00:23:00.720 for
00:23:01.120 popularism
00:23:03.000 and
00:23:03.360 so
00:23:03.600 and
00:23:04.620 to
00:23:05.120 attract
00:23:05.580 the
00:23:05.820 people
00:23:06.140 for
00:23:06.440 the
00:23:06.620 television
00:23:07.100 and
00:23:07.460 so
00:23:07.740 but
00:23:08.520 the
00:23:08.920 pope
00:23:09.360 is
00:23:10.080 a successor
00:23:10.820 of
00:23:11.080 St.
00:23:11.400 Peter
00:23:11.720 is
00:23:12.660 instituted
00:23:13.560 to
00:23:13.900 be
00:23:14.240 to
00:23:15.280 guarantee
00:23:15.920 the
00:23:17.760 unity
00:23:19.300 of
00:23:20.720 all
00:23:21.380 believers
00:23:22.120 in
00:23:22.480 the
00:23:22.820 revealed
00:23:23.300 faith
00:23:24.040 not
00:23:24.380 the
00:23:25.060 unity
00:23:25.460 made
00:23:26.000 by
00:23:26.600 men
00:23:26.860 by
00:23:27.080 manipulating
00:23:27.880 by
00:23:28.260 political
00:23:28.820 means
00:23:30.000 and so
00:23:30.500 but
00:23:31.760 the
00:23:32.840 unity
00:23:33.700 in
00:23:34.200 Jesus
00:23:34.960 Christ
00:23:35.760 that is
00:23:36.640 the
00:23:37.220 faith
00:23:37.600 in
00:23:37.800 Jesus
00:23:38.180 Christ
00:23:39.040 I hope
00:23:39.980 for the
00:23:40.300 future
00:23:40.680 that
00:23:42.080 is
00:23:42.580 more
00:23:43.380 strict
00:23:45.880 theological
00:23:46.420 thinking
00:23:47.760 and
00:23:47.980 theological
00:23:48.460 orientation
00:23:49.500 not
00:23:50.540 in
00:23:50.700 theology
00:23:51.160 and
00:23:51.660 the
00:23:51.800 question
00:23:52.180 of
00:23:52.440 theological
00:23:53.360 schools
00:23:54.120 but
00:23:55.080 the
00:23:55.260 theological
00:23:55.900 perception
00:23:57.960 of
00:23:59.540 the
00:24:00.320 revealed
00:24:00.960 faith
00:24:01.980 which
00:24:02.580 is
00:24:02.820 the
00:24:02.980 basis
00:24:03.360 of
00:24:03.720 the
00:24:04.000 unity
00:24:04.940 of
00:24:06.000 the
00:24:07.120 Catholic
00:24:08.520 Church
00:24:09.660 Just a
00:24:12.740 quick note
00:24:13.120 before we
00:24:13.560 return
00:24:13.880 if you
00:24:14.680 would like
00:24:14.980 to stay
00:24:15.280 up to
00:24:15.540 date
00:24:15.720 on
00:24:16.000 LifeSite's
00:24:16.440 coverage
00:24:16.680 of the
00:24:17.060 latest
00:24:17.340 life
00:24:17.680 family
00:24:18.100 and
00:24:18.320 culture
00:24:18.580 news
00:24:18.820 subscribe
00:24:19.460 to
00:24:19.840 one
00:24:20.040 of
00:24:20.140 our
00:24:20.240 many
00:24:20.580 newsletters
00:24:21.080 by
00:24:21.300 going
00:24:21.580 to
00:24:21.800 life
00:24:22.000 site
00:24:22.200 news
00:24:22.520 dot
00:24:22.780 com
00:24:23.060 slash
00:24:23.460 subscribe
00:24:24.140 and
00:24:24.700 if
00:24:24.840 you'd
00:24:25.040 like
00:24:25.220 to
00:24:25.420 help
00:24:25.700 us
00:24:25.900 bring
00:24:26.200 our
00:24:26.440 truth
00:24:26.820 telling
00:24:27.100 coverage
00:24:27.440 to
00:24:27.660 millions
00:24:28.240 around
00:24:28.460 the
00:24:28.600 world
00:24:28.740 please
00:24:29.340 consider
00:24:29.760 making
00:24:30.140 a
00:24:30.300 one
00:24:30.480 time
00:24:30.720 or
00:24:30.980 monthly
00:24:31.260 donation
00:24:31.680 at
00:24:32.200 give
00:24:32.580 dot
00:24:32.980 life
00:24:33.220 site
00:24:33.400 news
00:24:33.680 dot
00:24:34.020 com
00:24:34.540 and
00:24:34.940 now
00:24:35.220 back
00:24:35.560 to
00:24:35.680 the
00:24:35.760 video
00:24:36.040 speaking
00:24:38.400 of
00:24:38.700 the
00:24:38.840 future
00:24:39.200 of
00:24:39.380 the
00:24:39.520 church
00:24:39.860 there
00:24:40.980 are
00:24:41.120 a
00:24:41.220 number
00:24:41.360 of
00:24:41.500 people
00:24:41.720 who
00:24:41.940 are
00:24:42.160 very
00:24:42.580 concerned
00:24:43.140 now
00:24:43.680 because
00:24:44.640 they
00:24:45.440 saw
00:24:46.000 Pope
00:24:47.220 Emeritus
00:24:47.760 Benedict
00:24:48.100 in his
00:24:48.600 retirement
00:24:49.180 as
00:24:50.420 a
00:24:50.740 sort
00:24:50.980 of
00:24:51.280 hand
00:24:52.680 of
00:24:52.940 stopping
00:24:53.900 perhaps
00:24:55.060 Pope
00:24:55.540 Francis
00:24:55.940 or the
00:24:56.700 liberal
00:24:57.560 wing of
00:24:58.040 the
00:24:58.160 church
00:24:58.360 or
00:24:58.460 whatever
00:24:58.660 you want
00:24:58.900 to call
00:24:59.080 it
00:24:59.240 from
00:24:59.760 going
00:25:00.180 even
00:25:00.420 further
00:25:00.780 so
00:25:01.280 that
00:25:01.460 Benedict
00:25:01.740 was
00:25:02.020 kind
00:25:02.280 of
00:25:02.400 holding
00:25:02.880 back
00:25:03.400 perhaps
00:25:04.500 even
00:25:04.820 a
00:25:04.960 more
00:25:05.260 severe
00:25:06.060 push
00:25:07.000 to
00:25:07.300 one
00:25:07.540 side
00:25:07.940 do
00:25:09.500 you
00:25:09.840 sense
00:25:10.560 that
00:25:10.760 that
00:25:10.940 might
00:25:11.200 be
00:25:11.340 the
00:25:11.460 case
00:25:11.740 and
00:25:11.920 what
00:25:12.300 do
00:25:12.440 you
00:25:12.540 think
00:25:12.820 is
00:25:13.060 the
00:25:13.320 future
00:25:13.720 the
00:25:14.160 near
00:25:14.500 future
00:25:14.900 of
00:25:15.040 the
00:25:15.120 church
00:25:15.340 now
00:25:15.580 that
00:25:15.760 Pope
00:25:15.940 Benedict
00:25:16.180 has
00:25:16.520 died
00:25:16.780 nobody
00:25:17.640 knows
00:25:18.160 the
00:25:19.120 past
00:25:19.540 the
00:25:19.780 church
00:25:20.040 has
00:25:20.260 been
00:25:20.520 sometimes
00:25:21.600 in
00:25:21.960 trouble
00:25:22.340 there
00:25:23.840 was
00:25:24.000 bishops
00:25:24.440 in
00:25:26.040 the
00:25:26.660 time
00:25:26.940 of
00:25:27.080 St.
00:25:27.300 Augustine
00:25:27.860 the
00:25:28.600 Pelagians
00:25:29.280 was
00:25:29.700 a
00:25:29.820 charity
00:25:30.360 against
00:25:31.680 the
00:25:32.000 Catholics
00:25:32.360 in
00:25:32.640 North
00:25:32.940 Africa
00:25:33.700 there
00:25:34.940 were
00:25:35.060 big
00:25:35.300 troubles
00:25:35.720 in
00:25:36.240 the
00:25:36.420 time
00:25:37.540 of
00:25:37.700 the
00:25:37.860 Aryans
00:25:38.340 John
00:25:39.880 Henry
00:25:40.300 Newman
00:25:40.620 wrote
00:25:41.000 a
00:25:41.260 big
00:25:42.340 book
00:25:42.600 about
00:25:42.940 the
00:25:43.200 Aryans
00:25:43.720 in
00:25:43.900 the
00:25:44.020 fourth
00:25:44.300 century
00:25:44.800 times
00:25:45.420 of
00:25:45.620 crisis
00:25:46.080 in
00:25:46.420 the
00:25:46.560 so-called
00:25:47.060 reformation
00:25:47.940 the
00:25:49.100 splitting
00:25:49.480 of
00:25:49.900 the
00:25:50.940 church
00:25:51.340 in
00:25:51.880 the
00:25:52.640 middle
00:25:52.820 of
00:25:53.000 Europe
00:25:53.840 Germany
00:25:55.720 Switzerland
00:25:56.700 Holland
00:25:57.620 Netherlands
00:25:58.860 so
00:25:59.760 the
00:25:59.940 question
00:26:00.300 of
00:26:00.620 the
00:26:00.820 understanding
00:26:01.380 of
00:26:02.500 the
00:26:02.700 primacy
00:26:03.300 of
00:26:03.500 the
00:26:03.680 holy
00:26:03.900 Roman
00:26:04.300 church
00:26:05.060 with
00:26:06.020 their
00:26:06.280 bishop
00:26:06.880 as
00:26:07.420 successor
00:26:08.280 of
00:26:08.540 St.
00:26:08.780 Peter
00:26:09.840 the
00:26:10.540 Pope
00:26:10.740 cannot
00:26:10.980 do
00:26:11.240 what
00:26:11.620 he
00:26:12.580 wants
00:26:12.980 Pope
00:26:14.620 Benedict
00:26:15.040 also
00:26:15.460 explained
00:26:16.040 it
00:26:16.340 on the
00:26:17.460 high
00:26:17.700 level
00:26:18.500 and also
00:26:20.300 explained
00:26:20.820 in my
00:26:21.180 book
00:26:21.420 about
00:26:21.800 the
00:26:22.180 mission
00:26:22.460 of
00:26:23.500 the
00:26:24.080 Pope
00:26:25.420 nobody
00:26:26.140 can
00:26:27.760 say
00:26:29.300 that
00:26:29.580 Cardinal
00:26:30.060 Müller
00:26:30.420 has
00:26:31.500 any
00:26:31.740 doubt
00:26:32.100 about
00:26:33.520 the
00:26:34.540 role
00:26:34.840 of
00:26:35.060 St.
00:26:35.360 Peter
00:26:35.580 in
00:26:36.680 the
00:26:37.020 church
00:26:37.440 but
00:26:37.880 will
00:26:38.060 not
00:26:38.260 say
00:26:38.540 that
00:26:39.580 we
00:26:39.740 have
00:26:39.940 to
00:26:40.080 accept
00:26:40.460 all
00:26:40.820 what
00:26:41.680 happened
00:26:42.000 in the
00:26:42.380 history
00:26:42.800 of
00:26:43.600 papacy
00:26:44.060 some
00:26:45.080 problematic
00:26:46.700 figures
00:26:47.240 and
00:26:47.960 the
00:26:48.880 of
00:26:49.600 St.
00:26:51.440 Peter
00:26:51.740 and
00:26:53.640 also
00:26:54.340 Newman
00:26:55.060 said
00:26:56.900 we
00:26:58.300 have
00:26:58.860 to
00:26:59.940 expect
00:27:00.400 all
00:27:00.800 what
00:27:01.060 is
00:27:01.300 said
00:27:01.840 and
00:27:02.440 made
00:27:02.880 and
00:27:03.200 etc.
00:27:05.220 The
00:27:05.420 infallibility
00:27:06.100 of the
00:27:07.780 Pope
00:27:08.060 is
00:27:08.700 referring
00:27:09.080 only
00:27:09.660 to
00:27:10.320 those
00:27:10.600 things
00:27:10.920 who
00:27:11.120 are
00:27:11.300 revealed
00:27:11.920 not
00:27:13.740 use
00:27:15.160 ecclesiasticum
00:27:16.120 only
00:27:16.420 the
00:27:17.680 varieties
00:27:19.860 of
00:27:20.740 some
00:27:21.780 regulations
00:27:23.140 practical
00:27:24.140 regulations
00:27:25.320 in the
00:27:25.840 church
00:27:26.240 or the
00:27:27.540 statements
00:27:27.940 of the
00:27:28.420 Pope
00:27:28.780 to
00:27:29.180 Russia
00:27:30.540 or
00:27:31.000 to
00:27:31.400 China
00:27:31.920 nothing
00:27:33.140 to do
00:27:33.520 with
00:27:33.680 the
00:27:33.800 infallibility
00:27:34.500 we
00:27:34.840 respect
00:27:35.440 surely
00:27:35.780 the
00:27:36.640 Holy
00:27:36.840 Father
00:27:37.400 but
00:27:37.840 as
00:27:38.040 the
00:27:38.140 Jansenist
00:27:38.720 there's
00:27:39.160 only
00:27:39.440 what
00:27:39.720 we
00:27:39.960 are
00:27:40.160 thinking
00:27:40.540 what
00:27:41.640 we
00:27:42.600 respect
00:27:43.480 as
00:27:43.760 Catholic
00:27:44.240 the
00:27:44.760 Holy
00:27:44.940 Father
00:27:45.320 as
00:27:46.360 a
00:27:46.500 person
00:27:46.840 single
00:27:47.220 person
00:27:47.860 and
00:27:48.980 in
00:27:49.140 his
00:27:49.480 task
00:27:50.280 and
00:27:50.460 his
00:27:50.640 mission
00:27:50.920 but
00:27:52.500 not
00:27:52.880 in
00:27:53.080 a
00:27:53.220 blind
00:27:53.500 way
00:27:53.900 we
00:27:55.580 are
00:27:55.780 not
00:27:56.060 looking
00:27:56.980 to
00:27:58.440 the
00:27:58.780 Holy
00:27:59.000 Father
00:27:59.480 as
00:28:00.720 the
00:28:00.880 ideology
00:28:01.400 is
00:28:01.660 looking
00:28:01.920 to
00:28:02.160 the
00:28:02.360 leader
00:28:02.640 in
00:28:02.880 China
00:28:03.220 or
00:28:03.740 North
00:28:04.820 Korea
00:28:05.340 or
00:28:05.920 dictator
00:28:06.620 where
00:28:07.540 human
00:28:08.320 beings
00:28:09.020 are
00:28:09.260 absolutizing
00:28:10.080 themselves
00:28:10.680 as
00:28:11.300 if
00:28:11.540 they
00:28:11.720 were
00:28:11.920 gods
00:28:12.320 the
00:28:13.920 Pope
00:28:14.280 the
00:28:14.520 bishops
00:28:14.920 the
00:28:15.160 priests
00:28:15.740 are
00:28:15.940 not
00:28:16.120 god
00:28:16.500 the
00:28:18.640 ministers
00:28:20.000 have to
00:28:21.560 serve
00:28:22.060 and
00:28:23.480 Jesus
00:28:24.420 after his
00:28:26.140 resurrection
00:28:26.760 before his
00:28:27.780 ascension
00:28:28.340 to the
00:28:29.400 heaven
00:28:29.720 is that
00:28:31.020 you have to
00:28:32.720 preach the
00:28:33.260 gospel
00:28:33.680 and to
00:28:35.480 baptize
00:28:36.280 the
00:28:37.360 people
00:28:38.120 make
00:28:39.120 them
00:28:39.440 my
00:28:39.800 disciples
00:28:40.500 in the
00:28:42.120 name
00:28:42.280 of the
00:28:42.580 Father
00:28:42.900 Son
00:28:43.220 of the
00:28:43.540 Holy
00:28:43.720 Spirit
00:28:44.060 but
00:28:44.380 including
00:28:44.840 all the
00:28:45.300 other
00:28:45.620 sacraments
00:28:46.920 and
00:28:47.320 at the
00:28:47.860 end
00:28:48.120 he said
00:28:48.580 you have
00:28:49.540 to
00:28:49.720 teach
00:28:50.320 the
00:28:51.940 people
00:28:52.340 in the
00:28:52.700 world
00:28:53.120 not
00:28:54.800 your
00:28:55.300 ideas
00:28:56.280 but
00:28:57.340 what
00:28:57.600 I
00:28:57.920 have
00:28:58.280 taught
00:28:58.740 to
00:28:59.000 you
00:28:59.720 Jesus
00:29:01.840 is
00:29:02.160 the
00:29:02.320 only
00:29:02.660 teacher
00:29:03.800 in
00:29:05.160 the
00:29:05.420 church
00:29:05.880 and
00:29:06.220 the
00:29:06.400 apostles
00:29:06.860 bishops
00:29:07.660 are
00:29:08.480 only
00:29:08.740 teachers
00:29:09.220 in
00:29:09.480 the
00:29:09.660 name
00:29:10.100 of
00:29:10.500 Jesus
00:29:11.760 you
00:29:12.580 have
00:29:13.720 not
00:29:13.940 other
00:29:14.320 thoughts
00:29:15.420 and
00:29:15.680 other
00:29:16.060 doctrines
00:29:18.000 and
00:29:18.600 we
00:29:18.780 must
00:29:19.020 be
00:29:19.300 firm
00:29:19.620 in
00:29:20.360 the
00:29:20.500 doctrine
00:29:20.900 of
00:29:21.140 the
00:29:21.280 apostles
00:29:21.760 and
00:29:23.500 when
00:29:23.720 Peter
00:29:24.520 and
00:29:24.780 Paul
00:29:25.240 came
00:29:25.600 to
00:29:25.860 Rome
00:29:26.240 they
00:29:27.180 brought
00:29:27.620 with
00:29:28.400 them
00:29:28.920 the
00:29:29.760 basic
00:29:30.440 doctrine
00:29:31.300 of
00:29:32.160 the
00:29:32.360 apostles
00:29:32.820 that's
00:29:34.240 why
00:29:34.480 they
00:29:34.680 are
00:29:34.820 the
00:29:35.020 founders
00:29:35.500 of
00:29:36.420 the
00:29:36.580 Roman
00:29:36.840 church
00:29:37.280 not
00:29:37.660 only
00:29:37.980 in
00:29:38.120 the
00:29:38.280 technical
00:29:38.700 in
00:29:39.000 the
00:29:39.200 founders
00:29:39.580 when
00:29:40.300 they
00:29:40.500 came
00:29:40.760 to
00:29:40.960 Rome
00:29:41.200 they
00:29:41.400 had
00:29:41.640 been
00:29:41.960 just
00:29:43.020 Christians
00:29:43.980 but
00:29:44.360 the
00:29:44.820 church
00:29:45.220 of
00:29:45.460 Rome
00:29:45.780 has
00:29:46.640 its
00:29:46.880 basis
00:29:47.320 in
00:29:47.580 the
00:29:47.760 doctrine
00:29:48.180 of
00:29:48.560 the
00:29:48.860 princes
00:29:49.380 of
00:29:49.800 the
00:29:50.080 apostles
00:29:50.980 the
00:29:51.240 first
00:29:51.600 two
00:29:52.060 important
00:29:53.380 apostles
00:29:53.940 Peter
00:29:54.360 and
00:29:54.620 Paul
00:29:55.020 that
00:29:55.680 is
00:29:56.500 why
00:29:56.900 then
00:29:57.660 Deneo
00:29:58.200 said
00:29:58.500 therefore
00:29:59.160 all
00:30:00.040 other
00:30:00.360 churches
00:30:01.080 local
00:30:01.760 churches
00:30:02.520 and
00:30:03.100 their
00:30:03.300 bishops
00:30:03.620 have
00:30:04.500 to
00:30:05.440 be
00:30:06.540 in
00:30:07.380 accordance
00:30:08.040 with
00:30:08.960 the
00:30:09.120 Holy
00:30:09.420 Roman
00:30:10.080 Church
00:30:10.520 because
00:30:10.880 it's
00:30:11.180 founded
00:30:11.580 in
00:30:12.340 St.
00:30:12.620 Peter
00:30:12.860 and
00:30:13.300 St.
00:30:13.820 Paul
00:30:14.300 their
00:30:14.920 doctrine
00:30:15.360 of
00:30:16.340 the
00:30:17.200 apostles
00:30:17.680 and
00:30:19.100 so
00:30:19.220 this
00:30:19.420 is
00:30:19.660 very
00:30:19.900 important
00:30:20.620 that
00:30:21.140 the
00:30:21.840 popes
00:30:22.360 have
00:30:22.740 very
00:30:23.660 strong
00:30:26.160 theological
00:30:26.960 advisors
00:30:27.600 and
00:30:28.960 don't
00:30:29.240 only
00:30:29.620 adulate
00:30:30.160 the
00:30:30.380 Holy
00:30:30.760 Father
00:30:31.160 was
00:30:31.360 you
00:30:31.500 are
00:30:31.660 saying
00:30:31.900 it's
00:30:32.080 every
00:30:32.380 time
00:30:33.340 the
00:30:33.820 best
00:30:34.240 and
00:30:34.480 you
00:30:34.680 have
00:30:35.240 illumination
00:30:36.940 directly
00:30:38.220 from
00:30:39.020 the
00:30:39.200 Holy
00:30:39.420 Spirit
00:30:39.800 that
00:30:41.980 is
00:30:42.160 not
00:30:42.360 the
00:30:42.560 case
00:30:42.980 popes
00:30:43.600 the
00:30:43.740 bishops
00:30:44.080 the
00:30:44.400 diocese
00:30:46.000 they
00:30:46.300 cannot
00:30:46.680 refer
00:30:48.480 themselves
00:30:48.880 only
00:30:49.600 to
00:30:50.480 their
00:30:51.040 formal
00:30:51.500 authority
00:30:52.140 I am
00:30:52.580 the
00:30:52.760 bishop
00:30:53.040 you
00:30:53.280 have
00:30:53.500 to
00:30:54.400 obey
00:30:55.000 me
00:30:55.380 it's
00:30:56.080 not
00:30:56.280 like
00:30:56.600 in
00:30:56.780 the
00:30:57.120 army
00:30:57.500 he
00:30:58.180 is
00:30:58.300 a
00:30:58.440 general
00:30:58.840 and
00:30:59.540 here
00:30:59.780 are
00:31:00.100 simple
00:31:01.480 soldiers
00:31:01.980 and
00:31:02.340 they
00:31:02.480 have
00:31:02.640 to
00:31:02.820 obey
00:31:03.220 everybody
00:31:05.360 has
00:31:05.900 received
00:31:06.440 the
00:31:06.700 Holy
00:31:06.980 Spirit
00:31:08.220 and
00:31:10.100 the
00:31:10.740 bishops
00:31:11.500 as
00:31:11.980 shepherds
00:31:12.480 they have
00:31:12.780 a special
00:31:13.380 task
00:31:14.240 within
00:31:14.820 the
00:31:15.720 complexity
00:31:16.380 of the
00:31:17.640 body
00:31:17.940 of
00:31:18.400 Christ
00:31:18.800 and
00:31:19.220 all
00:31:20.620 the
00:31:20.780 special
00:31:21.220 charismas
00:31:22.220 everybody
00:31:23.020 has
00:31:24.020 received
00:31:24.560 the
00:31:25.320 Holy
00:31:25.600 Spirit
00:31:26.220 and
00:31:26.620 we
00:31:26.820 obey
00:31:28.020 to
00:31:29.640 our
00:31:29.920 bishop
00:31:30.400 and
00:31:31.320 all
00:31:32.440 the
00:31:32.600 church
00:31:33.000 to
00:31:33.880 the
00:31:34.020 Holy
00:31:34.220 Father
00:31:34.560 because
00:31:35.320 he
00:31:35.940 is
00:31:36.260 saying
00:31:37.380 the
00:31:37.660 truth
00:31:38.040 and
00:31:39.720 not
00:31:39.980 on the
00:31:41.240 contrary
00:31:41.760 cannot
00:31:43.120 say
00:31:43.460 because
00:31:44.140 the
00:31:44.340 Holy
00:31:44.500 Father
00:31:44.800 is
00:31:45.000 saying
00:31:45.240 this
00:31:45.520 is
00:31:45.720 true
00:31:46.140 but
00:31:46.960 on the
00:31:47.200 contrary
00:31:47.540 because
00:31:48.180 the
00:31:49.240 thing
00:31:49.460 is
00:31:49.680 true
00:31:50.120 a
00:31:51.160 question
00:31:51.640 or
00:31:52.120 revelation
00:31:52.980 is
00:31:53.360 true
00:31:53.940 is
00:31:54.220 revealed
00:31:54.800 and
00:31:55.800 therefore
00:31:56.360 he
00:31:57.420 can
00:31:57.800 give
00:31:58.940 us
00:31:59.380 his
00:32:00.360 orders
00:32:00.860 to
00:32:01.340 obey
00:32:01.740 in
00:32:02.560 reality
00:32:03.040 we
00:32:04.120 don't
00:32:04.520 not
00:32:04.860 obey
00:32:05.520 to
00:32:06.900 him
00:32:07.220 to
00:32:07.820 human
00:32:08.180 person
00:32:08.720 but
00:32:09.620 we
00:32:09.780 are
00:32:09.920 obeying
00:32:10.420 to
00:32:11.460 God
00:32:11.840 because
00:32:12.540 Pope
00:32:13.320 bishops
00:32:13.880 councils
00:32:14.660 are
00:32:15.820 presenting
00:32:17.320 us
00:32:18.080 the
00:32:18.820 word
00:32:19.140 of
00:32:19.460 God
00:32:19.880 now
00:32:20.660 we
00:32:20.820 come
00:32:21.020 to
00:32:21.380 perhaps
00:32:21.780 a
00:32:21.940 very
00:32:22.060 difficult
00:32:22.420 question
00:32:22.940 at least
00:32:23.300 difficult
00:32:23.660 for
00:32:23.980 America
00:32:24.420 in
00:32:24.900 the
00:32:25.060 beginning
00:32:25.320 of
00:32:25.600 Pope
00:32:25.760 Francis
00:32:26.080 reign
00:32:26.620 Cardinal
00:32:27.960 Burke
00:32:28.220 was
00:32:28.440 removed
00:32:28.980 as
00:32:29.900 the
00:32:30.320 head
00:32:30.720 of
00:32:30.920 the
00:32:31.020 Apostolic
00:32:31.440 Signatura
00:32:31.980 given
00:32:32.820 the
00:32:33.000 position
00:32:33.480 with
00:32:34.520 the
00:32:35.240 Order
00:32:36.620 of
00:32:36.780 Malta
00:32:37.120 but
00:32:37.320 then
00:32:37.560 sort
00:32:38.020 of
00:32:38.120 removed
00:32:38.400 from
00:32:38.560 that
00:32:38.720 as
00:32:38.880 well
00:32:39.080 and
00:32:39.380 then
00:32:39.620 also
00:32:40.100 with
00:32:40.380 yourself
00:32:40.780 you
00:32:41.000 were
00:32:41.120 removed
00:32:41.560 rather
00:32:42.560 unceremoniously
00:32:43.320 from
00:32:43.740 the
00:32:44.040 Congregation
00:32:44.600 of
00:32:44.800 Doctrine
00:32:45.040 of Faith
00:32:45.360 but
00:32:46.680 you
00:32:46.800 were
00:32:46.940 both
00:32:47.240 Roman
00:32:48.080 cardinals
00:32:48.580 crurial
00:32:49.140 cardinals
00:32:49.600 and
00:32:49.920 the
00:32:50.940 effect
00:32:51.440 of
00:32:51.600 that
00:32:51.780 while
00:32:52.060 severe
00:32:52.520 wasn't
00:32:53.660 as severe
00:32:54.700 perhaps
00:32:55.120 as
00:32:55.280 what's
00:32:55.500 going
00:32:55.680 on
00:32:55.980 also
00:32:56.840 because
00:32:57.400 even
00:32:58.140 though
00:32:58.380 you
00:32:58.560 were
00:32:58.740 removed
00:32:59.080 from
00:32:59.320 your
00:32:59.480 positions
00:33:00.100 you
00:33:01.300 were
00:33:01.460 still
00:33:01.820 cardinal
00:33:02.540 in
00:33:03.620 in the
00:33:03.740 United
00:33:03.920 States
00:33:04.380 now
00:33:04.780 we
00:33:05.440 have
00:33:05.940 the
00:33:06.540 laicization
00:33:07.920 of
00:33:09.340 a
00:33:09.980 priest
00:33:10.460 known
00:33:11.480 throughout
00:33:11.960 America
00:33:12.640 throughout
00:33:12.980 North
00:33:13.280 America
00:33:13.500 in fact
00:33:13.820 throughout
00:33:14.240 most
00:33:14.620 of the
00:33:14.800 world
00:33:15.080 as
00:33:16.420 the
00:33:17.000 pro-life
00:33:17.760 priest
00:33:18.200 Father
00:33:19.040 Frank
00:33:19.380 Pavone
00:33:19.820 who
00:33:20.600 has
00:33:21.120 been
00:33:21.460 the
00:33:22.180 head
00:33:22.540 of
00:33:22.720 Priests
00:33:22.980 for
00:33:23.120 Life
00:33:23.400 and
00:33:23.600 also
00:33:23.860 runs
00:33:24.140 a
00:33:24.280 ministry
00:33:24.660 for
00:33:25.760 women
00:33:26.080 who
00:33:26.220 have
00:33:26.320 experienced
00:33:26.740 abortion
00:33:27.200 has
00:33:28.040 been
00:33:28.280 removed
00:33:28.840 from
00:33:29.540 the
00:33:29.800 priesthood
00:33:30.380 it's
00:33:31.140 stunning
00:33:31.680 for
00:33:32.260 America
00:33:32.760 because
00:33:33.460 we
00:33:34.820 see
00:33:35.460 from
00:33:36.280 America
00:33:36.760 who
00:33:37.900 gets
00:33:38.080 removed
00:33:38.360 from
00:33:38.520 the
00:33:38.660 priesthood
00:33:39.060 Cardinal
00:33:40.260 McCarrick
00:33:40.720 but only
00:33:41.300 after
00:33:41.800 like
00:33:42.460 years
00:33:43.460 even
00:33:43.880 decades
00:33:44.380 of
00:33:44.580 people
00:33:44.840 already
00:33:45.220 knowing
00:33:45.620 there
00:33:45.800 was a
00:33:46.040 huge
00:33:46.380 sexual
00:33:47.020 problem
00:33:47.520 but
00:33:49.040 with
00:33:49.220 Father
00:33:49.400 Pavone
00:33:49.780 we're
00:33:50.540 not
00:33:50.940 talking
00:33:51.340 about
00:33:51.680 any
00:33:52.100 sexual
00:33:52.520 problem
00:33:52.940 we're
00:33:53.820 talking
00:33:54.080 about
00:33:54.300 the
00:33:54.480 best
00:33:54.860 known
00:33:55.260 priest
00:33:55.820 fighting
00:33:56.400 for
00:33:57.000 John
00:33:57.680 Paul
00:33:57.920 II's
00:33:58.680 ministry
00:34:00.260 of
00:34:00.720 the
00:34:00.900 culture
00:34:01.320 of
00:34:01.600 life
00:34:01.960 that
00:34:02.560 fight
00:34:03.000 which
00:34:03.300 the
00:34:03.540 Pope
00:34:03.880 John
00:34:04.900 Paul
00:34:05.220 and
00:34:05.940 supported
00:34:06.360 by
00:34:06.640 Cardinal
00:34:06.920 Ratzinger
00:34:07.260 at the
00:34:07.480 time
00:34:07.680 and
00:34:07.780 then
00:34:07.900 later
00:34:08.140 pushed
00:34:08.460 also
00:34:08.900 by
00:34:09.140 Pope
00:34:09.320 Benedict
00:34:09.600 supported
00:34:11.400 Father
00:34:12.040 Frank
00:34:12.380 Pavone
00:34:12.820 in
00:34:13.440 this
00:34:13.640 great
00:34:13.860 work
00:34:14.060 in
00:34:14.220 fact
00:34:14.420 John
00:34:15.160 Paul
00:34:15.280 II
00:34:15.640 called
00:34:16.520 Father
00:34:17.140 Marx
00:34:17.520 when
00:34:17.680 he
00:34:17.760 was
00:34:17.860 doing
00:34:18.040 the
00:34:18.240 same
00:34:18.520 work
00:34:18.860 as
00:34:19.420 doing
00:34:19.580 the
00:34:19.700 most
00:34:19.840 important
00:34:20.140 work
00:34:20.360 on
00:34:20.500 earth
00:34:20.720 and
00:34:21.280 yet
00:34:21.560 Father
00:34:22.120 Frank
00:34:22.680 Pavone
00:34:23.100 is
00:34:23.260 laicized
00:34:23.640 we
00:34:23.880 have
00:34:24.380 brought
00:34:24.700 with
00:34:24.920 us
00:34:25.080 to
00:34:25.280 Rome
00:34:25.580 a
00:34:26.340 petition
00:34:26.860 of
00:34:27.100 over
00:34:27.320 45,000
00:34:29.000 Catholics
00:34:29.660 begging
00:34:30.840 the
00:34:31.300 Holy
00:34:31.480 Father
00:34:31.860 to
00:34:32.500 revoke
00:34:33.200 this
00:34:33.500 decision
00:34:33.980 that
00:34:34.220 was
00:34:34.380 made
00:34:34.640 by
00:34:34.780 the
00:34:34.900 Congregation
00:34:35.280 for
00:34:35.540 Clergy
00:34:35.880 on
00:34:36.000 November
00:34:36.260 the
00:34:36.460 9th
00:34:36.800 scandalously
00:34:38.120 Father
00:34:38.960 Pavone
00:34:39.340 didn't
00:34:39.560 even
00:34:39.760 know
00:34:40.100 the
00:34:40.360 position
00:34:40.740 the
00:34:41.180 banning
00:34:42.940 him
00:34:43.100 from
00:34:43.260 the
00:34:43.360 priesthood
00:34:43.660 or
00:34:43.880 laicization
00:34:44.380 until
00:34:45.360 the
00:34:45.680 media
00:34:45.980 got
00:34:46.300 to
00:34:46.480 him
00:34:46.700 just
00:34:47.360 in
00:34:47.520 December
00:34:47.920 if
00:34:49.720 you
00:34:49.880 can
00:34:50.140 comment
00:34:50.920 at
00:34:51.140 all
00:34:51.320 for
00:34:51.540 us
00:34:51.700 on
00:34:51.840 this
00:34:52.000 that
00:34:52.100 would
00:34:52.180 be
00:34:52.280 most
00:34:52.460 appreciated
00:34:52.900 I
00:34:53.420 read
00:34:53.720 also
00:34:54.000 this
00:34:54.400 letter
00:34:54.960 which
00:34:55.460 was
00:34:55.860 he
00:34:56.980 informed
00:34:58.100 or
00:34:58.360 the
00:34:58.980 publicity
00:34:59.860 was
00:35:00.280 informed
00:35:00.800 of
00:35:01.080 the
00:35:01.280 secularization
00:35:02.140 of a
00:35:03.300 priest
00:35:03.600 that
00:35:03.820 not
00:35:04.040 he
00:35:04.300 himself
00:35:04.960 I
00:35:06.100 think
00:35:06.640 this
00:35:06.900 is
00:35:07.040 unguilty
00:35:07.560 and
00:35:08.680 is
00:35:08.860 only
00:35:09.180 I
00:35:09.500 think
00:35:10.240 the
00:35:11.040 political
00:35:11.440 actions
00:35:12.100 the
00:35:13.200 secularization
00:35:14.040 of a
00:35:14.500 priest
00:35:14.840 is
00:35:15.120 instituted
00:35:16.560 by
00:35:16.820 Jesus
00:35:17.100 Christ
00:35:17.620 himself
00:35:18.900 and
00:35:19.140 not
00:35:19.300 by
00:35:19.480 the
00:35:19.660 Pope
00:35:19.960 and
00:35:20.160 not
00:35:20.520 by
00:35:20.780 the
00:35:20.960 bishop
00:35:21.340 can
00:35:21.780 be
00:35:22.040 secularization
00:35:22.900 only
00:35:23.480 a
00:35:23.880 penalty
00:35:24.320 in
00:35:24.860 the
00:35:25.080 ultimate
00:35:25.600 case
00:35:26.240 in
00:35:27.140 the
00:35:27.360 case
00:35:28.020 of
00:35:28.200 apostasy
00:35:29.040 or
00:35:29.860 strong
00:35:30.740 heresy
00:35:31.360 or
00:35:32.620 absolutely
00:35:34.220 contradictorial
00:35:37.020 behavior
00:35:37.780 against
00:35:39.300 the
00:35:40.340 priesthood
00:35:40.920 but
00:35:41.360 the
00:35:41.720 reasons
00:35:42.100 here
00:35:42.440 presented
00:35:42.980 are
00:35:44.140 not
00:35:44.380 justifying
00:35:45.100 not
00:35:45.320 justifying
00:35:46.160 secularization
00:35:48.200 I
00:35:48.660 I
00:35:48.680 think
00:35:48.940 is
00:35:50.200 the
00:35:50.240 only
00:35:52.580 political
00:35:53.160 action
00:35:53.660 I
00:35:54.080 think
00:35:54.300 there
00:35:54.540 was
00:35:54.860 surely
00:35:56.040 a lot
00:35:56.480 of
00:35:56.940 pressures
00:35:57.300 of the
00:35:57.880 democratic
00:35:59.160 party
00:36:00.160 and
00:36:01.680 those
00:36:02.020 activists
00:36:02.940 in
00:36:03.480 abortion
00:36:04.240 and
00:36:06.260 they
00:36:06.500 made
00:36:07.180 surely
00:36:07.420 pressure
00:36:07.860 here
00:36:08.080 I
00:36:08.200 don't
00:36:08.420 know
00:36:08.640 what
00:36:08.860 happened
00:36:09.220 here
00:36:09.500 in
00:36:10.420 Rome
00:36:11.060 but
00:36:12.860 I
00:36:13.220 see
00:36:13.420 only
00:36:13.760 the
00:36:14.120 phenomena
00:36:16.300 what
00:36:17.540 is
00:36:18.060 happening
00:36:18.520 and
00:36:20.180 nobody
00:36:21.260 with a
00:36:22.680 certain
00:36:23.040 theological
00:36:23.720 understanding
00:36:24.640 or
00:36:25.660 with a
00:36:26.100 feeling
00:36:26.800 human
00:36:27.320 feeling
00:36:27.940 of
00:36:28.820 justice
00:36:29.360 and
00:36:29.640 injustice
00:36:30.200 and
00:36:31.280 human
00:36:31.520 rights
00:36:31.960 can
00:36:33.220 understand
00:36:34.040 it
00:36:34.500 and
00:36:35.700 not
00:36:35.920 accept
00:36:36.380 it
00:36:36.660 there
00:36:37.260 are
00:36:37.460 other
00:36:37.740 prominent
00:36:38.260 persons
00:36:39.120 in
00:36:40.080 the
00:36:40.800 United
00:36:41.100 States
00:36:41.600 or
00:36:41.780 other
00:36:42.120 countries
00:36:42.740 who
00:36:43.640 are
00:36:43.720 denying
00:36:44.140 openly
00:36:45.220 the
00:36:46.440 basics
00:36:46.960 of the
00:36:47.580 Catholic
00:36:47.900 faith
00:36:48.320 and
00:36:48.520 morals
00:36:49.000 and
00:36:50.220 they
00:36:50.380 have
00:36:50.600 no
00:36:50.960 reactions
00:36:52.960 from
00:36:55.220 the
00:36:55.400 side
00:36:55.760 of
00:36:55.980 the
00:36:56.960 ecclesiastical
00:36:57.940 authority
00:36:58.660 and
00:37:00.120 those
00:37:00.460 people
00:37:01.060 who
00:37:01.280 are
00:37:01.560 fighting
00:37:03.300 for
00:37:03.880 the
00:37:04.060 life
00:37:04.520 against
00:37:05.980 this
00:37:06.440 brutal
00:37:07.000 crime
00:37:07.500 of
00:37:08.680 killing
00:37:09.060 of
00:37:09.980 a
00:37:10.160 person
00:37:10.560 in
00:37:10.920 the
00:37:11.060 mother
00:37:11.260 womb
00:37:11.760 second
00:37:12.360 Vatican
00:37:12.740 council
00:37:13.300 that
00:37:13.640 is
00:37:13.860 a
00:37:14.580 brutal
00:37:18.860 crime
00:37:19.480 against
00:37:20.580 humanity
00:37:21.360 and
00:37:23.400 also
00:37:24.180 since
00:37:25.820 ever
00:37:26.400 the
00:37:27.660 doctrine
00:37:28.160 of
00:37:28.520 the
00:37:28.660 conviction
00:37:29.120 of
00:37:30.060 the
00:37:30.260 church
00:37:30.600 if
00:37:30.840 God
00:37:31.420 is
00:37:31.640 the
00:37:31.800 creator
00:37:32.200 of
00:37:33.120 human
00:37:33.440 life
00:37:33.860 nobody
00:37:34.280 has
00:37:34.740 the
00:37:35.060 right
00:37:35.340 to
00:37:36.140 destroy
00:37:36.660 another
00:37:37.500 life
00:37:38.720 with
00:37:39.000 what
00:37:39.220 reasons
00:37:39.780 ever
00:37:40.340 and
00:37:41.820 all
00:37:42.080 this
00:37:42.440 position
00:37:44.780 there's
00:37:45.980 the
00:37:46.100 right
00:37:46.460 of
00:37:47.400 women
00:37:47.700 to
00:37:48.440 kill
00:37:48.700 their
00:37:48.920 own
00:37:49.160 babies
00:37:49.640 that
00:37:50.500 cannot
00:37:51.360 be
00:37:51.660 justified
00:37:52.160 in
00:37:53.380 any
00:37:53.740 way
00:37:54.420 there
00:37:54.720 was
00:37:55.060 great
00:37:56.020 ideologies
00:37:56.720 and
00:37:57.320 totalitarian
00:37:58.260 systems
00:37:58.940 atheistic
00:37:59.600 systems
00:38:00.180 who
00:38:01.400 are
00:38:01.700 saying
00:38:02.080 we
00:38:02.540 can
00:38:02.780 kill
00:38:03.160 the
00:38:04.660 babies
00:38:05.340 or the
00:38:05.980 ill
00:38:06.240 person
00:38:06.780 or the
00:38:07.260 old
00:38:07.580 people
00:38:08.120 we
00:38:08.940 have
00:38:09.340 to
00:38:09.500 kill
00:38:09.820 because
00:38:10.280 they
00:38:10.520 have
00:38:10.740 no
00:38:11.060 more
00:38:12.200 worth
00:38:12.900 economical
00:38:13.720 worth
00:38:14.540 this
00:38:15.320 is
00:38:15.500 only
00:38:16.300 a
00:38:16.600 reduction
00:38:17.120 of
00:38:18.860 the
00:38:19.060 human
00:38:19.420 dignity
00:38:21.240 to
00:38:22.920 their
00:38:23.680 economical
00:38:25.040 price
00:38:26.560 and
00:38:26.800 worth
00:38:27.180 there's
00:38:28.500 no
00:38:28.720 difference
00:38:29.760 to
00:38:31.800 the
00:38:32.200 misleading
00:38:34.260 and
00:38:35.120 maltratation
00:38:36.400 in
00:38:37.540 China
00:38:38.000 or
00:38:38.320 other
00:38:38.640 countries
00:38:39.620 China
00:38:41.880 is rich
00:38:42.440 has
00:38:42.720 success
00:38:43.240 economical
00:38:43.880 success
00:38:44.340 because
00:38:45.380 why
00:38:46.220 the
00:38:46.520 party
00:38:47.780 is
00:38:48.300 exploiting
00:38:49.000 the
00:38:49.220 people
00:38:49.620 where
00:38:50.520 is
00:38:50.700 the
00:38:50.840 human
00:38:51.160 dignity
00:38:51.700 of
00:38:52.660 every
00:38:53.100 Chinese
00:38:53.800 man
00:38:54.480 or
00:38:54.740 woman
00:38:55.040 and
00:38:55.520 we
00:38:55.760 as
00:38:56.120 church
00:38:56.700 we
00:38:57.560 must
00:38:57.900 not
00:38:58.640 interfere
00:38:59.260 in
00:39:00.060 the
00:39:00.280 politics
00:39:00.880 but
00:39:01.560 we
00:39:01.760 have
00:39:01.960 to
00:39:02.340 say
00:39:03.220 what
00:39:03.500 are
00:39:03.740 the
00:39:03.880 guidelines
00:39:04.460 for
00:39:04.820 the
00:39:04.980 politics
00:39:05.560 the
00:39:06.480 moral
00:39:06.940 essence
00:39:07.540 of
00:39:07.840 politics
00:39:08.460 the
00:39:09.280 politics
00:39:09.760 is
00:39:10.080 written
00:39:10.720 in the
00:39:11.140 sense
00:39:11.440 of
00:39:11.640 Machiavelli
00:39:12.320 to
00:39:13.440 remain
00:39:14.560 your
00:39:15.440 own
00:39:15.720 power
00:39:16.220 but
00:39:17.200 the
00:39:17.480 politicians
00:39:17.960 have
00:39:18.420 to
00:39:18.640 work
00:39:19.020 for
00:39:19.300 the
00:39:19.440 good
00:39:19.660 of
00:39:19.860 the
00:39:20.040 people
00:39:20.420 that
00:39:22.120 is
00:39:22.320 our
00:39:22.780 democratic
00:39:23.640 understanding
00:39:24.900 from
00:39:25.860 politics
00:39:26.580 defending
00:39:28.560 the
00:39:29.000 people
00:39:29.420 against
00:39:30.120 Ukraine
00:39:31.120 against
00:39:31.660 their
00:39:32.200 aggressions
00:39:32.920 but
00:39:34.200 in
00:39:34.700 the
00:39:34.940 politic
00:39:36.460 inside
00:39:37.060 of
00:39:37.380 a
00:39:37.540 country
00:39:37.980 their
00:39:39.060 own
00:39:39.600 line
00:39:41.160 they
00:39:41.840 have
00:39:42.060 to
00:39:42.260 follow
00:39:42.640 the
00:39:43.200 politicians
00:39:43.760 it's
00:39:44.060 not
00:39:44.240 their
00:39:44.400 own
00:39:44.580 power
00:39:44.960 their
00:39:45.260 own
00:39:46.060 interests
00:39:46.700 but
00:39:47.380 the
00:39:48.080 wealth
00:39:48.640 of
00:39:49.480 the
00:39:49.640 people
00:39:50.060 the
00:39:50.500 Bonum
00:39:50.780 Commune
00:39:51.340 in
00:39:51.900 America
00:39:52.460 I have to say
00:39:53.240 we feel
00:39:54.020 kind of
00:39:54.440 abandoned
00:39:54.840 by
00:39:55.480 the
00:39:56.380 Holy
00:39:56.520 Father
00:39:56.800 we feel
00:39:57.700 we had
00:39:58.620 support
00:39:59.120 from
00:39:59.400 John Paul II
00:40:00.040 as the
00:40:00.460 pro-life
00:40:00.720 movement
00:40:01.040 we had
00:40:01.460 the great
00:40:01.920 support
00:40:02.340 from
00:40:02.580 Benedict
00:40:02.940 as well
00:40:03.500 but
00:40:03.940 it seems
00:40:04.500 to have
00:40:05.200 gone
00:40:05.540 in the
00:40:06.400 last
00:40:06.600 decade
00:40:06.920 or so
00:40:07.400 but
00:40:08.200 you
00:40:08.460 yourself
00:40:08.940 have
00:40:09.660 been
00:40:10.000 for us
00:40:10.980 a
00:40:11.680 great
00:40:12.860 stalwart
00:40:13.440 especially
00:40:14.260 you just
00:40:14.660 came
00:40:15.000 to visit
00:40:15.980 with
00:40:16.160 Mark
00:40:16.480 Hauck
00:40:16.780 when he
00:40:17.240 and his
00:40:17.500 family
00:40:17.760 were persecuted
00:40:18.460 under the
00:40:18.900 Biden
00:40:19.120 administration
00:40:19.580 for being
00:40:20.160 pro-life
00:40:20.660 so I want
00:40:22.260 to thank
00:40:22.640 you for
00:40:22.900 that
00:40:23.160 how it
00:40:23.520 is
00:40:23.700 possible
00:40:24.140 that
00:40:25.420 30
00:40:26.500 heavy
00:40:27.920 armed
00:40:28.580 police
00:40:29.380 men
00:40:29.740 women
00:40:30.120 are
00:40:31.180 entering
00:40:31.860 a house
00:40:32.620 with
00:40:32.960 seven
00:40:33.860 children
00:40:34.540 from
00:40:35.860 2
00:40:36.300 to
00:40:36.640 70
00:40:37.940 years
00:40:38.460 and so
00:40:38.940 and
00:40:41.440 to
00:40:41.880 threatening
00:40:42.940 them
00:40:43.380 with
00:40:44.240 arms
00:40:45.000 what
00:40:45.820 is
00:40:46.300 happening
00:40:46.720 unfortunately
00:40:47.660 today
00:40:48.980 in the
00:40:49.320 Catholic
00:40:49.680 Church
00:40:50.240 first
00:40:50.980 we felt
00:40:52.160 ourselves
00:40:52.880 as Catholics
00:40:53.860 in all
00:40:54.940 the world
00:40:55.540 in all
00:40:56.500 the languages
00:40:57.140 as the
00:40:57.700 same
00:40:57.940 family
00:40:58.480 and now
00:40:59.700 there are
00:41:00.080 the prejudices
00:41:01.280 of the
00:41:01.720 Americans
00:41:02.860 and the
00:41:03.980 North
00:41:04.700 American
00:41:05.200 United
00:41:05.640 States
00:41:06.320 I had
00:41:08.520 a long
00:41:08.800 time
00:41:09.260 being
00:41:10.320 15
00:41:10.740 years
00:41:11.260 every
00:41:11.580 year
00:41:11.880 in
00:41:12.260 Latin
00:41:13.440 America
00:41:14.000 and I
00:41:14.660 see
00:41:15.040 there are
00:41:15.740 prejudices
00:41:17.380 but could
00:41:18.120 have been
00:41:18.820 also
00:41:19.800 the
00:41:20.120 reasons
00:41:21.380 in the
00:41:21.800 history
00:41:22.320 but
00:41:23.580 we
00:41:24.260 cannot
00:41:24.920 as
00:41:25.880 Christians
00:41:26.660 only
00:41:27.920 continue
00:41:29.880 with
00:41:30.740 our
00:41:31.060 old
00:41:31.380 prejudices
00:41:32.320 our
00:41:33.380 mission
00:41:33.760 is to
00:41:34.200 overcome
00:41:34.920 the
00:41:35.240 prejudices
00:41:36.080 and to
00:41:37.960 come
00:41:38.160 together
00:41:38.600 to give
00:41:39.020 a good
00:41:39.340 example
00:41:39.980 where they
00:41:41.460 are
00:41:41.800 often I
00:41:43.460 am in
00:41:43.800 Poland
00:41:44.160 and Germany
00:41:45.140 all the
00:41:46.280 Hitler time
00:41:47.040 and so
00:41:47.440 terrible
00:41:48.220 was terrible
00:41:48.960 what can
00:41:50.120 we do
00:41:50.660 as Catholics
00:41:52.620 not
00:41:53.280 continuing
00:41:53.920 you
00:41:55.860 have said
00:41:56.240 no
00:41:56.420 you have
00:41:56.700 said
00:41:56.920 no
00:41:57.220 we have
00:41:59.740 to give
00:42:00.200 a good
00:42:00.580 example
00:42:01.220 that is
00:42:01.800 possible
00:42:02.280 to live
00:42:03.440 together
00:42:03.900 especially
00:42:04.800 in the
00:42:05.980 Catholic
00:42:06.520 Church
00:42:07.080 and
00:42:07.440 the
00:42:08.320 Holy
00:42:08.500 Father
00:42:08.880 is the
00:42:09.220 father
00:42:09.580 of the
00:42:10.800 whole
00:42:11.120 Catholic
00:42:11.860 family
00:42:13.100 I cannot
00:42:14.140 say
00:42:14.520 this
00:42:15.500 of my
00:42:16.820 children
00:42:17.300 is better
00:42:18.480 than the
00:42:18.880 other
00:42:19.080 children
00:42:19.620 the other
00:42:20.740 child
00:42:21.200 we are
00:42:22.000 finite
00:42:22.920 human
00:42:24.660 beings
00:42:25.100 with our
00:42:25.700 limits
00:42:27.000 and so
00:42:27.540 and also
00:42:28.820 in the
00:42:29.240 natural
00:42:29.680 family
00:42:30.160 is possible
00:42:30.840 that the
00:42:32.800 mother or
00:42:33.220 the father
00:42:33.700 is loving
00:42:34.660 a little
00:42:35.000 bit more
00:42:35.580 this one
00:42:36.700 or the
00:42:37.080 other one
00:42:37.640 of the
00:42:38.400 children
00:42:38.860 on the
00:42:40.600 school
00:42:41.520 as a
00:42:42.940 teacher
00:42:43.320 surely
00:42:43.900 if you
00:42:44.660 have
00:42:44.860 40
00:42:45.380 pupils
00:42:46.620 it's
00:42:48.080 naturally
00:42:48.660 to have
00:42:50.040 more sympathy
00:42:51.020 for the
00:42:51.560 one
00:42:51.800 and less
00:42:53.560 for the
00:42:53.900 other
00:42:54.160 but in
00:42:55.220 this
00:42:55.480 position
00:42:56.020 that
00:42:57.180 father or
00:42:57.960 mother
00:42:58.360 or
00:42:59.060 teacher
00:42:59.480 or
00:43:00.280 pastor
00:43:01.520 shepherd
00:43:02.440 you must
00:43:03.740 overcome
00:43:04.480 your own
00:43:05.940 limits
00:43:06.840 you must
00:43:07.440 be
00:43:08.920 correct
00:43:09.960 and equal
00:43:10.980 to
00:43:11.540 every
00:43:12.160 body
00:43:13.320 in this
00:43:14.100 very
00:43:14.360 place
00:43:14.940 where
00:43:15.540 Pope
00:43:16.240 Benedict
00:43:16.960 while he
00:43:18.060 was
00:43:18.180 Cardinal
00:43:18.420 Ratzinger
00:43:18.860 lived
00:43:19.340 he did
00:43:20.900 something
00:43:21.400 that
00:43:22.420 American
00:43:23.340 pro-lifers
00:43:24.000 will always
00:43:24.680 remember
00:43:25.160 he was in
00:43:26.620 the position
00:43:27.220 which you
00:43:27.680 later held
00:43:28.440 as the
00:43:29.540 head of the
00:43:30.100 congregation
00:43:30.520 for the
00:43:30.820 doctrine of
00:43:31.220 faith
00:43:31.420 the year
00:43:31.820 was
00:43:32.040 2004
00:43:32.960 the
00:43:34.120 bishops
00:43:34.480 of the
00:43:34.980 United
00:43:35.200 States
00:43:35.680 were debating
00:43:36.360 the question
00:43:37.060 of communion
00:43:38.120 for pro-abortion
00:43:38.940 politicians
00:43:39.520 and under
00:43:40.680 the direction
00:43:41.120 of Pope
00:43:41.580 John Paul
00:43:42.000 II
00:43:42.400 Cardinal
00:43:43.460 Ratzinger
00:43:44.120 wrote to
00:43:45.420 the bishops
00:43:46.040 the letter
00:43:47.040 worthiness
00:43:47.500 to receive
00:43:47.900 communion
00:43:48.200 which
00:43:48.480 is sort
00:43:49.420 of
00:43:49.600 not talked
00:43:50.400 about
00:43:50.680 it was
00:43:51.020 oppressed
00:43:51.420 by the
00:43:51.980 Cardinal
00:43:53.060 McCarrick
00:43:54.820 typically
00:43:55.360 it was
00:43:56.740 it was
00:43:57.420 sent
00:43:58.440 officially
00:43:59.640 from Rome
00:44:00.440 in the
00:44:01.560 name of
00:44:02.180 Cardinal
00:44:02.540 Ratzinger
00:44:02.880 for John
00:44:03.400 Paul II
00:44:03.700 to intervene
00:44:04.700 in the
00:44:04.980 debate
00:44:05.380 over whether
00:44:06.340 pro-abortion
00:44:06.800 politicians
00:44:07.240 should be
00:44:07.660 denied
00:44:07.960 Holy Communion
00:44:08.380 and the
00:44:08.760 letter
00:44:09.080 said
00:44:09.960 they must
00:44:11.420 be denied
00:44:12.400 Holy Communion
00:44:13.240 by the
00:44:13.520 Ministry of
00:44:13.840 Communion
00:44:14.080 after of
00:44:14.580 course
00:44:14.700 they've
00:44:14.860 been warned
00:44:15.200 and so
00:44:15.460 on
00:44:15.600 but
00:44:16.120 they
00:44:16.260 must
00:44:16.740 be
00:44:17.000 and we
00:44:18.300 received
00:44:19.260 from
00:44:19.680 several
00:44:20.640 of the
00:44:21.160 other
00:44:21.500 bishops
00:44:21.900 who are
00:44:22.460 on that
00:44:22.940 committee
00:44:23.220 with
00:44:23.640 Cardinal
00:44:24.020 McCarrick
00:44:24.400 they were
00:44:25.240 very upset
00:44:25.900 that Cardinal
00:44:26.520 McCarrick
00:44:26.880 didn't show
00:44:27.820 them the
00:44:28.160 letter
00:44:28.380 so they
00:44:29.340 had a
00:44:29.820 response
00:44:30.160 but
00:44:30.400 that
00:44:31.060 letter
00:44:31.420 never
00:44:32.160 really
00:44:32.860 made it
00:44:33.520 public
00:44:34.280 and so
00:44:35.600 it
00:44:35.780 leaves on
00:44:36.500 in the
00:44:36.800 legacy
00:44:37.180 of
00:44:37.880 pro-lifers
00:44:38.780 did you
00:44:39.220 know
00:44:39.420 about it
00:44:39.740 at the
00:44:39.960 time
00:44:40.200 and what's
00:44:40.680 your take
00:44:41.040 on it
00:44:41.320 now
00:44:41.620 versus
00:44:42.360 McCarrick
00:44:43.000 wanted to
00:44:43.440 be the
00:44:43.920 big
00:44:45.120 friend
00:44:45.500 of the
00:44:46.040 politicians
00:44:47.500 of one
00:44:48.500 party
00:44:49.080 and so
00:44:49.680 indeed
00:44:50.960 didn't like
00:44:52.820 to make
00:44:54.000 this
00:44:54.240 confrontation
00:44:54.860 in favor
00:44:56.280 of
00:44:57.300 life
00:44:58.120 was more
00:44:58.720 interested
00:44:59.160 in his
00:44:59.600 own
00:44:59.840 position
00:45:00.380 to be
00:45:00.720 beloved
00:45:01.200 of
00:45:01.420 everybody
00:45:02.040 to be
00:45:02.460 the
00:45:02.620 darling
00:45:02.940 of
00:45:03.180 everybody
00:45:03.760 and not
00:45:05.120 to give
00:45:05.580 witness
00:45:06.220 what
00:45:07.040 an
00:45:07.760 epical
00:45:08.520 change
00:45:09.320 that
00:45:09.620 would
00:45:09.880 have
00:45:10.020 made
00:45:10.440 if
00:45:11.460 back
00:45:11.940 in
00:45:12.140 2004
00:45:13.040 the
00:45:13.900 bishops
00:45:14.300 of the
00:45:14.740 United
00:45:14.920 States
00:45:15.280 would have
00:45:15.640 heeded
00:45:16.100 the
00:45:16.440 will
00:45:16.820 of the
00:45:17.640 Holy
00:45:17.820 Father
00:45:18.240 John
00:45:18.660 Paul II
00:45:19.060 and of
00:45:19.920 Cardinal
00:45:20.160 Ratzinger
00:45:20.460 later became
00:45:21.260 Pope Benedict
00:45:22.120 the
00:45:22.640 contradiction
00:45:23.260 to be
00:45:24.020 a
00:45:25.360 Catholic
00:45:25.740 in
00:45:26.500 what
00:45:26.740 position
00:45:27.320 ever
00:45:27.760 and
00:45:29.040 to
00:45:29.440 be
00:45:30.660 in
00:45:30.860 favor
00:45:31.180 of
00:45:31.500 abortion
00:45:32.140 is
00:45:32.360 absolutely
00:45:32.920 a
00:45:33.980 contradiction
00:45:34.560 you cannot
00:45:35.060 say
00:45:36.520 yeah
00:45:36.780 we make
00:45:37.560 the laws
00:45:38.280 for
00:45:38.540 everybody
00:45:39.100 but
00:45:39.980 they have
00:45:40.340 the
00:45:40.500 responsibility
00:45:41.240 to
00:45:42.920 fight
00:45:43.340 for the
00:45:43.920 life
00:45:45.020 also
00:45:45.360 in the
00:45:45.960 parliament
00:45:46.440 in the
00:45:47.140 public
00:45:47.540 and not
00:45:47.980 only
00:45:48.420 because
00:45:49.080 they are
00:45:49.460 Catholics
00:45:49.940 but
00:45:50.440 every
00:45:50.840 man
00:45:51.980 of good
00:45:53.080 will
00:45:53.440 of
00:45:54.840 humanistic
00:45:56.960 orientation
00:45:58.120 knows
00:45:59.560 that
00:46:00.060 there is
00:46:00.700 no reason
00:46:01.440 and no
00:46:02.840 power
00:46:03.280 of us
00:46:03.940 to
00:46:04.480 declare
00:46:05.720 another
00:46:06.300 person
00:46:06.820 is less
00:46:07.380 worthy
00:46:08.020 than me
00:46:08.580 and I
00:46:10.320 have the
00:46:10.640 right to
00:46:11.100 live
00:46:11.360 and I
00:46:12.360 decide
00:46:12.920 if the
00:46:13.240 other
00:46:13.440 person
00:46:13.840 have to
00:46:14.280 die
00:46:15.220 absolutely
00:46:16.240 clear
00:46:17.200 for your
00:46:18.720 rational
00:46:19.740 understanding
00:46:20.620 but
00:46:21.620 the
00:46:22.220 more
00:46:22.620 if you
00:46:23.440 believe
00:46:23.980 in the
00:46:24.340 word
00:46:24.540 of God
00:46:24.960 and God
00:46:25.380 as a
00:46:25.680 creator
00:46:26.040 of every
00:46:27.440 life
00:46:28.860 and you
00:46:29.180 cannot
00:46:29.480 receive the
00:46:30.480 holy communion
00:46:31.140 Jesus Christ
00:46:32.100 the son
00:46:32.980 of God
00:46:33.440 who became
00:46:34.200 man
00:46:34.660 died
00:46:35.240 on the
00:46:35.620 cross
00:46:35.940 risen
00:46:36.500 in the
00:46:37.120 resurrection
00:46:37.620 and so
00:46:38.400 and then
00:46:39.160 our
00:46:39.900 savior
00:46:40.520 and in
00:46:41.620 the same
00:46:42.040 time
00:46:42.580 to give
00:46:43.820 the allowance
00:46:44.420 to kill
00:46:45.320 persons
00:46:46.440 who are
00:46:47.020 created
00:46:47.720 according
00:46:48.700 to the
00:46:49.080 likeness
00:46:49.620 the
00:46:50.280 image
00:46:50.600 of God
00:46:51.160 is
00:46:52.160 obvious
00:46:53.040 that
00:46:53.320 is
00:46:53.480 the
00:46:53.760 absolute
00:46:54.100 contradiction
00:46:54.960 Eminence
00:46:55.880 I want
00:46:56.400 to thank
00:46:56.720 you
00:46:56.920 on behalf
00:46:58.040 of
00:46:58.240 LifeSite
00:46:58.760 and all
00:47:00.060 the pro-lifers
00:47:00.560 in America
00:47:00.980 for your
00:47:01.640 great standing
00:47:02.920 for the truth
00:47:03.540 of the faith
00:47:03.980 on life
00:47:04.440 and for your
00:47:05.860 graciousness
00:47:06.400 in having us
00:47:06.960 here
00:47:07.180 Lord be with
00:47:08.220 you
00:47:08.540 and with
00:47:09.060 your spirit
00:47:09.580 may almighty
00:47:10.240 God bless
00:47:10.940 you
00:47:11.280 the father
00:47:12.020 and the
00:47:12.660 son
00:47:12.980 and the
00:47:13.580 holy spirit
00:47:14.340 Amen
00:47:44.340 Amen
00:47:46.340 Amen
00:47:47.340 Amen
00:47:48.340 Amen
00:47:49.340 Amen
00:47:50.340 Amen