The John-Henry Westen Show - Cardinal Muller Exclusive： Will Progressive Leadership Destroy The Church？

00:00:00.000 We are not looking to the Holy Father as the ideology is looking to the leader in China 0.91

00:00:06.840 or in North Korea or dictator, where human beings are absolutizing themselves as if they were gods.

00:00:16.420 The Pope, the bishops, the priests are not God.

00:00:19.700 We cannot, as Christians, only continue with our own prejudices.

00:00:28.000 Because our mission is to overcome the prejudices and to come together to give a good example.

00:00:36.880 Hello and welcome again to the John Henry Weston Show.

00:00:39.940 We are coming to you, obviously, from Rome, where we are in the presence of Cardinal Gerhard Müller,

00:00:46.060 the former head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith.

00:00:49.420 And one quick question for you.

00:00:52.060 This apartment, is it the same apartment that Cardinal Ratzinger had?

00:00:55.500 It's the same apartment, and he gave it personally to me when he became Pope.

00:01:02.080 For seven years, this apartment was empty, and he gave it exactly personally for me, for you.

00:01:11.240 He said, you are my friend, for you.

00:01:14.680 Amazing.

00:01:15.520 So we are coming to you literally from the former apartment of Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, Pope Benedict XVI.

00:01:23.080 This is the John Henry Weston Show, and I know you are going to want to stay tuned for this one.

00:01:34.560 Your Eminence, so good to be with you.

00:01:36.720 If you wouldn't mind, start us off with the sign of the cross.

00:01:39.360 In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.

00:01:42.140 Amen. Amen.

00:01:43.160 We are all here for the funeral of Benedict XVI.

00:01:47.680 This morning you were there in the cold, but for the funeral mass.

00:01:53.380 First of all, if you can tell us, what were your takeaways from the funeral mass?

00:01:57.260 And then, what is your message about your memory of and your love for Pope Benedict?

00:02:04.800 Yes, the funeral mass is like the funeral mass is for every Catholic, and it is a prayer in the power of the Holy Cross,

00:02:16.560 of the sacrifice of Jesus Christ on the cross, which is sacramentally present in the Holy Mass.

00:02:24.820 And we are believing to be united with the Christians, believers, not more believers, 0.97

00:02:32.980 but now they are seeing God from face to face with all the baptized in the heaven.

00:02:39.480 And now the baptized believers here in the pilgrim church, and also with the souls in the purgatory.

00:02:47.760 But we hope for him that it's not more of the purgatory, he had enough purgatory on earth.

00:02:56.480 With Cardinal Ratzinger, who you worked with, and then later with Pope Benedict,

00:03:01.940 he was a man, obviously, of great suffering, who suffered in the church, even from his own brothers in the church.

00:03:08.720 Tell us a little bit about that, if you will, especially from your knowledge of it, with working with him personally.

00:03:13.400 There is a wrong ideology that the church is behind of the development of the modern world, 0.67

00:03:21.740 and therefore we have to modernize the church, and this understanding, or the normal Catholic understanding,

00:03:30.480 church can never be behind of the time, because Jesus is the fullness of time,

00:03:36.980 and never we can overcome Jesus, the only mediator between God, the Father, and us.

00:03:43.400 The humankind, only the style, and so on, and the form of theology,

00:03:50.540 the answers to the challenges of the different times and epochs can change,

00:03:57.680 but not the revelation, the Word of God, His value forever.

00:04:05.180 Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today, and forever and all eternity,

00:04:10.100 and therefore the truth of Jesus Christ is outside of these competences between so-called conservatives or progressists and liberals and all.

00:04:22.360 This is only political categories, has nothing to do with our relation to God in His Word,

00:04:29.120 and in this healing of our souls, and in this healing of our souls and the salvation.

00:04:34.080 There is no conservative baptism or progressive baptism, or the grace is not liberal or not liberal,

00:04:43.760 or this is absolutely absurd, to define the question of the faith with political categories,

00:04:54.300 and what is the new time, the modernity, is only the modern technology or the modern medicine could help us,

00:05:03.140 or the modernity is also shaped by strange and bad ideologies,

00:05:09.480 understanding the definition of man, of all the existence of the world without God,

00:05:17.680 in the great ideologies, in the French Revolution, the Jacobinians,

00:05:23.380 and with all this terrorism and all these characteristics of these modern ideologies,

00:05:31.120 the communism, the national socialism, fascism, but now the posthumanism,

00:05:37.880 all this, the vogue culture, all anti-humanistic ideologies,

00:05:44.460 and we must resist against it, and we are more modern than in the Neos of Lyon,

00:05:52.260 the first and second century, this big work against the Gnostics of all times, 1.00

00:06:02.100 is that Jesus can never be overcome, not by politicians, nor by politics, nor by ideologies, nor by philosophy,

00:06:12.480 because Jesus is homo novissimus, most modern man of the world, 0.77

00:06:20.320 because he is the same, Alpha and Omega,

00:06:24.040 the beginning, the origin, and the aim, goal of everything,

00:06:30.320 and this was the position of Cardinal Ratzinger Professor Ratzinger,

00:06:36.900 Cardinal Ratzinger, and Pope Benedict,

00:06:39.620 he is belonging to the great culture, European culture,

00:06:49.200 Platon, Aristoteles, Aristotel, and all these great philosophers of the European culture,

00:06:59.160 the Roman right, and Athens, and Jerusalem,

00:07:03.000 for the three points of the orientation,

00:07:06.060 Christianity, Christian faith is not a mixture of all this,

00:07:09.520 but it's shaping all the human thinking,

00:07:15.480 all this longing for,

00:07:20.480 and it's a fulfillment of all human desires,

00:07:24.840 and I think some bishops or theologians was in contrary contradiction to him,

00:07:37.000 not only on the level of different theological styles or schools,

00:07:41.460 this is possible in the church,

00:07:44.440 we have St. Thomas Aquinas,

00:07:46.380 Tutskotus has the same Catholic faith,

00:07:48.840 but different St. Thomas Aquinas and the style of St. Augustine,

00:07:56.760 and Basileus the Great,

00:07:58.400 and so a different style and form to express himself,

00:08:02.840 it was confronted to other questions,

00:08:05.760 other challenges of their times,

00:08:08.460 that is not the question,

00:08:09.600 but here was the question,

00:08:12.320 what is the truth of the Catholic faith revealed forever,

00:08:15.520 and the mixture between these modern ideologies?

00:08:24.640 Joseph Ratzinger, when he was a young man,

00:08:27.240 or a boy first,

00:08:29.180 and a young man, adolescent,

00:08:32.180 when he was six years old,

00:08:35.760 or five years old,

00:08:37.220 and in Germany the Nazis came to the power,

00:08:41.080 and he grew up in this time,

00:08:43.580 but in the Catholic family it was absolutely clear,

00:08:47.420 that the Nazi ideology has nothing to do,

00:08:50.100 it's a contradiction to the Christian and Catholic faith,

00:08:54.480 but he was in this confrontation in the youth time,

00:08:58.460 it's very important,

00:08:59.700 and he did see what is happening,

00:09:05.160 if God is denied,

00:09:08.460 what is a human being without God,

00:09:14.500 and this is human beings are enemies to God,

00:09:19.040 and he later was as Pope in Auschwitz,

00:09:23.240 he said that is a result of the neo-paganism,

00:09:28.100 of the denying of God,

00:09:29.680 because the Jewish people have the same faith,

00:09:33.860 like we in the believing of the God of Abraham,

00:09:39.140 Isaac, Jacob,

00:09:40.360 and the God and Father of Jesus Christ,

00:09:43.640 is the God who spoke first in Moses,

00:09:47.980 in the first alliance,

00:09:49.420 and this was a contradiction,

00:09:52.060 also the communism,

00:09:53.100 Stalinism,

00:09:53.900 a direct contradiction,

00:09:56.100 not against the philosophical belief in God,

00:10:00.700 but against the biblical revelation of this God,

00:10:06.760 how we see revealed himself in the history of salvation,

00:10:13.100 and what is present in our great testimony in the Bible,

00:10:17.860 and that is a great legacy of Joseph Ratzinger,

00:10:25.880 Pope Benedict XVI,

00:10:27.380 to be firm in the belief in God,

00:10:31.020 and in his spiritual testament,

00:10:33.780 he wrote it and said it,

00:10:38.200 start to firm it in faith,

00:10:41.080 to be very sure and firm in the faith,

00:10:47.140 and there is no other salvation for us,

00:10:51.720 as in Jesus Christ,

00:10:55.500 the Savior of the world.

00:10:56.720 Absolutely.

00:10:58.140 His quote from the last testament that you're mentioning,

00:11:01.520 is he was to say,

00:11:02.640 to stand firm and to not be confused.

00:11:05.880 And one of the sufferings that Pope Benedict

00:11:09.700 sort of endured,

00:11:12.780 particularly in these last few years,

00:11:15.040 while he was Pope Emeritus,

00:11:17.680 was the suffering from the bishops of Germany.

00:11:21.000 And that's what suffering that you yourself experienced as well,

00:11:23.920 both as the head of the CDF and then after,

00:11:27.500 but also both of you as bishops from Germany,

00:11:31.480 watching your confrères,

00:11:33.740 your brother bishops in Germany,

00:11:35.660 seem to go against the faith in so many different ways.

00:11:39.560 Was that something that hurt Pope Benedict to see?

00:11:43.080 But also in this last number of days as he was closing his life,

00:11:49.300 he saw Pope Francis, it seemed,

00:11:54.640 would put as the head of the congregation for the doctrine of faith,

00:11:58.860 Bishop Wilma,

00:11:59.680 who is very much on that line that the German bishops are taking,

00:12:04.060 the line that I believe you have called one that goes against the faith.

00:12:08.260 Bishop Wilma,

00:12:09.280 I don't know him personally,

00:12:12.080 and I want to say anything against his person,

00:12:16.920 but his positions,

00:12:19.260 he's taking part of the so-called synodal path,

00:12:24.460 are heretical.

00:12:26.520 Because not only heretical,

00:12:30.780 this is an absolute contradiction to the revealed anthropology.

00:12:38.040 If we say God created human being in the Logos,

00:12:45.380 in the Son of God,

00:12:47.620 at the beginning,

00:12:49.180 male and female,

00:12:50.240 and according to his likeness,

00:12:54.520 in body and soul,

00:12:57.640 we cannot deny it.

00:12:59.020 It's a so-called new anthropology.

00:13:02.960 It's not a new anthropology.

00:13:05.220 It's an absolute distinction,

00:13:07.100 separation between the center of the person,

00:13:12.780 and the autonomy,

00:13:14.400 and on the other side,

00:13:16.260 the body.

00:13:17.040 We are a union between soul and body.

00:13:22.780 We cannot separate it.

00:13:24.760 If we are separated,

00:13:26.040 we will die.

00:13:28.560 But we will not fall back in the nothing.

00:13:33.840 But we will be,

00:13:35.160 after our death,

00:13:36.640 confronted to God

00:13:38.700 as our judge,

00:13:40.680 our final judge,

00:13:43.040 ultimate and definitive judgment

00:13:45.480 we receive

00:13:47.160 about all we are doing.

00:13:49.740 And all these documents,

00:13:51.220 they have

00:13:52.240 against the priesthood,

00:13:54.120 the sacramental priesthood,

00:13:57.160 and the matrimony, 0.99

00:13:58.980 matrimony as a sacrament,

00:14:01.940 and about the sexual ethics,

00:14:05.820 are absolutely against,

00:14:08.820 not in only some points,

00:14:10.480 but in all the hermeneutic

00:14:13.240 of these questions.

00:14:15.860 This is a contradiction

00:14:16.980 to the revealed Catholic faith.

00:14:21.300 They want a little bit to hide it,

00:14:24.220 presenting themselves as Catholics

00:14:27.420 in the other way.

00:14:29.980 But there is no Catholicism 0.99

00:14:31.900 in the other ways,

00:14:33.000 only the way.

00:14:34.820 Jesus Christ is the way.

00:14:36.880 And there is no other,

00:14:38.540 so-called other way

00:14:40.640 of those who are thinking

00:14:43.520 Jesus was only

00:14:45.680 the beginning point

00:14:47.380 of a great Christian culture.

00:14:51.020 And we have to

00:14:52.200 make it more perfect,

00:14:54.560 and we have to modernize

00:14:56.520 as if Jesus

00:14:58.280 was only

00:14:59.720 an ancient

00:15:02.620 thinker

00:15:04.100 or

00:15:04.800 religious

00:15:06.080 founder

00:15:07.100 or anything.

00:15:08.820 And we can develop

00:15:09.940 Buddha

00:15:10.480 and

00:15:11.000 Confucius

00:15:13.260 or we can

00:15:14.180 modernize

00:15:15.500 Plato

00:15:16.260 or the

00:15:16.860 Aristotle

00:15:17.440 or

00:15:18.000 if Jesus Christ

00:15:20.680 is the same

00:15:21.400 yesterday,

00:15:22.720 today,

00:15:23.060 and for all

00:15:24.880 the times,

00:15:25.700 for the

00:15:26.060 eternal times,

00:15:30.100 there is

00:15:30.720 it's not possible

00:15:33.120 to correct him

00:15:34.680 or to

00:15:36.420 fulfill

00:15:37.620 Jesus

00:15:39.160 is a fulfillment

00:15:40.140 of the

00:15:41.480 revelation.

00:15:42.500 He's a Logos,

00:15:43.380 he's a word of God.

00:15:45.200 And nobody

00:15:45.780 can

00:15:46.660 present himself

00:15:48.480 as more

00:15:49.800 intelligent

00:15:50.320 as

00:15:50.980 intellectus

00:15:52.180 divinos

00:15:52.840 intelligence.

00:15:53.840 Logos

00:15:54.740 is

00:15:55.020 intellectus,

00:15:56.100 intelligence.

00:15:58.820 The divine

00:16:00.160 intelligence

00:16:00.840 is revealed

00:16:02.560 in Jesus

00:16:03.060 Christ.

00:16:03.880 And therefore

00:16:04.780 about

00:16:05.320 what is

00:16:05.840 belonging to

00:16:06.660 our

00:16:07.100 relation

00:16:08.440 to God

00:16:09.120 and salvation

00:16:09.860 that is

00:16:12.060 absolutely

00:16:12.760 and fully

00:16:14.580 revealed

00:16:15.820 in Jesus

00:16:16.340 Christ.

00:16:16.960 one of

00:16:17.720 the things

00:16:18.200 that

00:16:18.680 for

00:16:19.540 Pope

00:16:19.880 Benedict

00:16:20.200 was

00:16:21.520 very

00:16:22.000 dear

00:16:22.280 to

00:16:22.500 his

00:16:22.680 heart

00:16:23.000 and

00:16:23.780 just

00:16:25.280 Archbishop

00:16:26.060 Genswein

00:16:26.640 gave an

00:16:27.080 interview

00:16:27.380 with

00:16:27.660 Tagospost

00:16:28.400 just now

00:16:29.200 about

00:16:30.140 what

00:16:31.040 broke

00:16:31.780 Pope

00:16:32.440 Benedict's

00:16:32.860 heart.

00:16:33.860 He

00:16:33.940 talked

00:16:34.260 about

00:16:34.680 you know

00:16:36.000 one of

00:16:36.840 Pope

00:16:37.460 Benedict's

00:16:37.820 probably

00:16:38.180 greatest

00:16:38.760 legacies

00:16:39.320 will be

00:16:40.040 Sumorum

00:16:40.380 Pontificum

00:16:41.080 and

00:16:42.560 Archbishop

00:16:43.640 Genswein

00:16:44.240 talked about

00:16:44.880 how

00:16:45.400 for the

00:16:45.760 very first

00:16:46.220 time

00:16:46.640 about

00:16:47.360 how

00:16:48.000 Traditionis

00:16:49.480 Custodis

00:16:50.280 broke

00:16:51.040 Pope Benedict's

00:16:52.440 heart.

00:16:53.000 If you can

00:16:53.780 explain that

00:16:54.740 for us

00:16:55.200 what's

00:16:55.860 behind that

00:16:56.440 and what

00:16:57.280 that means.

00:16:58.280 This question

00:16:58.980 is not

00:16:59.400 on the

00:16:59.980 strict

00:17:00.960 dogmatic

00:17:01.720 level

00:17:03.020 because

00:17:03.780 we have

00:17:04.720 in the

00:17:05.100 Church

00:17:05.480 the same

00:17:07.160 Holy Mass

00:17:08.200 the same

00:17:08.540 sacrament

00:17:09.000 of Eucharist

00:17:09.820 but in

00:17:10.760 different

00:17:11.220 rites

00:17:12.240 and also

00:17:12.920 the

00:17:13.240 so-called

00:17:14.560 Latin

00:17:15.140 Roman

00:17:15.780 rite

00:17:16.380 has

00:17:17.160 certain

00:17:17.740 developments

00:17:18.480 but not

00:17:19.200 belonging to

00:17:19.800 the substance

00:17:20.480 but the

00:17:21.540 external

00:17:21.980 forms.

00:17:24.000 The

00:17:24.100 Gloria

00:17:24.420 was not

00:17:25.040 all the

00:17:25.940 time at

00:17:26.400 the beginning

00:17:26.880 in the

00:17:27.240 Holy Mass

00:17:27.860 but at

00:17:29.220 the end

00:17:29.700 there was

00:17:31.320 developed

00:17:32.180 a certain

00:17:33.340 form

00:17:33.760 a certain

00:17:34.600 type

00:17:35.160 of the

00:17:35.980 Latin

00:17:36.280 rite

00:17:36.800 and the

00:17:37.580 Council

00:17:38.080 the

00:17:38.580 Second

00:17:38.840 Vatican

00:17:39.220 Council

00:17:39.740 didn't

00:17:40.700 want

00:17:40.980 to

00:17:41.180 change

00:17:41.960 to

00:17:43.160 substitute

00:17:43.680 the

00:17:44.340 Latin

00:17:44.660 rite

00:17:45.340 only

00:17:46.800 a little

00:17:48.300 bit

00:17:48.520 making

00:17:48.880 clearer

00:17:49.480 because

00:17:50.520 in

00:17:50.920 some

00:17:51.460 times

00:17:52.240 in

00:17:52.680 some

00:17:52.980 epochs

00:17:54.340 there was

00:17:55.620 in the

00:17:56.040 10th

00:17:56.940 century

00:17:57.360 we can

00:17:58.220 say a

00:17:58.600 little

00:17:58.780 bit

00:17:59.020 a

00:17:59.200 mixture

00:17:59.580 between

00:18:00.520 the

00:18:00.820 old

00:18:01.340 Roman

00:18:03.020 rite

00:18:03.740 and

00:18:04.160 these

00:18:05.420 churches

00:18:05.880 in

00:18:06.320 Gallia

00:18:06.940 are

00:18:07.160 today

00:18:07.500 France

00:18:08.140 and

00:18:08.460 Germany

00:18:09.260 and so

00:18:09.940 it was

00:18:10.780 a little

00:18:11.060 bit

00:18:11.360 mixture

00:18:11.760 and

00:18:12.180 some

00:18:13.100 elements

00:18:13.720 was not

00:18:16.000 so

00:18:16.360 absolutely

00:18:16.920 well

00:18:17.300 ordered

00:18:17.780 and this

00:18:19.360 was the

00:18:19.780 only

00:18:20.140 proposal

00:18:21.280 of the

00:18:23.160 Vatican

00:18:24.260 Council

00:18:24.880 and to

00:18:26.600 give

00:18:26.960 the

00:18:27.260 lectures

00:18:28.040 and the

00:18:28.660 gospel

00:18:29.040 in

00:18:29.600 the

00:18:30.980 language

00:18:31.380 of the

00:18:32.180 people

00:18:32.600 but they

00:18:33.140 didn't

00:18:33.480 want

00:18:33.840 to

00:18:34.520 eliminate

00:18:35.380 the

00:18:36.120 Latin

00:18:36.420 as a

00:18:36.800 basic

00:18:37.340 language

00:18:40.020 liturgical

00:18:41.140 language

00:18:42.020 in the

00:18:42.720 Latin

00:18:43.080 rite

00:18:44.440 but they

00:18:45.120 have

00:18:45.640 some

00:18:46.460 problems

00:18:48.860 in the

00:18:49.480 realization

00:18:50.800 of the

00:18:51.860 liturgical

00:18:52.760 renewal

00:18:54.540 and some

00:18:56.240 mistakes

00:18:58.880 or some

00:18:59.680 abuses

00:19:00.320 as if

00:19:02.340 the

00:19:02.740 liturgy

00:19:03.220 were

00:19:03.440 only

00:19:04.500 self

00:19:05.660 reverential

00:19:07.280 cult

00:19:11.000 and not

00:19:11.600 the

00:19:11.780 adoration

00:19:12.280 of God

00:19:12.980 the

00:19:13.540 theodentric

00:19:15.180 and the

00:19:15.720 christiological

00:19:16.620 mediation

00:19:17.360 and though

00:19:18.580 there was a

00:19:18.960 misunderstanding

00:19:19.540 of the

00:19:20.560 sacraments

00:19:21.200 as only

00:19:21.760 a religious

00:19:22.320 rite

00:19:22.880 according

00:19:23.800 to the

00:19:24.260 pleasure

00:19:24.600 of the

00:19:26.220 people

00:19:28.360 all these

00:19:30.520 symbols

00:19:31.080 the religious

00:19:31.700 symbols

00:19:32.220 expressing

00:19:33.220 my

00:19:34.120 feeling

00:19:34.760 according

00:19:35.760 to the

00:19:36.300 absolute

00:19:36.740 and so

00:19:37.480 and not

00:19:38.540 the

00:19:39.080 shape

00:19:41.540 and the

00:19:41.920 reality

00:19:42.620 of the

00:19:43.700 sacramental

00:19:44.420 presence

00:19:45.260 of the

00:19:47.240 grace of

00:19:47.860 Jesus Christ

00:19:48.700 in the

00:19:49.180 seven

00:19:49.520 sacraments

00:19:50.660 especially

00:19:51.140 in the

00:19:52.000 Eucharist

00:19:52.840 and this

00:19:54.700 was a

00:19:55.080 very wise

00:19:55.700 decision

00:19:56.180 of Pope

00:19:58.000 Benedict XVI

00:19:59.060 to

00:20:00.500 distinguish

00:20:01.500 between

00:20:02.080 the

00:20:02.400 ordinary

00:20:03.240 rite

00:20:03.920 in the

00:20:04.380 newer

00:20:05.660 form

00:20:06.380 and

00:20:07.000 the

00:20:07.520 extraordinary

00:20:08.180 rite

00:20:09.440 also by

00:20:11.020 underlining

00:20:12.360 that

00:20:13.540 the

00:20:14.600 Vatican

00:20:14.900 Council

00:20:15.580 didn't

00:20:17.160 want

00:20:18.800 to

00:20:19.880 make

00:20:20.340 a

00:20:20.840 rupture

00:20:21.300 in

00:20:22.920 the

00:20:23.820 continuity

00:20:24.520 of

00:20:26.120 the

00:20:26.520 life

00:20:27.000 of

00:20:27.860 the

00:20:28.260 Catholic

00:20:29.380 Church

00:20:30.140 and

00:20:30.520 in

00:20:30.760 the

00:20:31.140 Catholic

00:20:31.960 liturgy

00:20:33.280 but

00:20:34.540 now

00:20:34.860 I think

00:20:35.420 there

00:20:36.600 came

00:20:37.320 some

00:20:38.060 people

00:20:38.440 to

00:20:38.660 him

00:20:38.940 and

00:20:40.220 said

00:20:40.460 they

00:20:40.880 are

00:20:41.240 the

00:20:42.540 reactionaries

00:20:44.040 and

00:20:44.680 the

00:20:45.520 conservatives

00:20:46.240 and

00:20:47.140 the

00:20:47.700 rigid

00:20:48.140 people

00:20:48.880 they

00:20:49.940 are

00:20:50.400 preferring

00:20:51.320 the

00:20:51.560 old

00:20:51.840 rite

00:20:52.320 and

00:20:53.260 we

00:20:53.420 must

00:20:53.720 destroy

00:20:54.340 this

00:20:55.680 old

00:20:56.260 rite

00:20:56.660 and

00:20:56.880 then

00:20:57.200 we

00:20:58.000 are

00:20:58.280 going

00:20:58.860 together

00:20:59.840 but

00:21:00.220 I

00:21:00.400 think

00:21:00.660 that

00:21:01.600 was

00:21:01.820 not

00:21:02.200 pastorally

00:21:04.160 very

00:21:04.520 wise

00:21:05.060 to

00:21:06.840 act

00:21:07.380 so

00:21:08.020 brutally

00:21:09.840 in

00:21:11.720 questions

00:21:12.380 which

00:21:13.840 are

00:21:14.040 not

00:21:14.300 on

00:21:14.800 the

00:21:14.940 dogmatic

00:21:15.400 level

00:21:15.820 but

00:21:17.040 it's

00:21:17.240 I

00:21:17.420 think

00:21:17.680 it's

00:21:18.180 a

00:21:18.260 certain

00:21:18.540 contradiction

00:21:19.320 where

00:21:20.580 is

00:21:20.920 possible

00:21:21.800 plurality

00:21:24.160 legitimate

00:21:25.520 plurality

00:21:26.700 in the

00:21:27.120 liturgical

00:21:27.640 expression

00:21:28.460 so

00:21:29.640 they

00:21:29.720 are

00:21:29.960 suppressed

00:21:30.760 and

00:21:32.220 when

00:21:33.020 we

00:21:33.200 are

00:21:33.420 on

00:21:33.660 the

00:21:33.780 dogmatical

00:21:34.600 level

00:21:35.960 of the

00:21:37.280 doctrine

00:21:37.660 of the

00:21:38.140 church

00:21:38.480 of the

00:21:38.820 revealed

00:21:39.280 faith

00:21:39.740 they

00:21:40.520 are

00:21:40.820 very

00:21:42.620 liberal

00:21:43.100 they

00:21:44.100 accept

00:21:44.500 all

00:21:44.900 the

00:21:45.080 heresies

00:21:45.840 as if

00:21:46.920 the

00:21:47.100 heresies

00:21:47.620 a

00:21:47.800 contradiction

00:21:48.540 against

00:21:49.680 the

00:21:49.920 revelation

00:21:50.460 would

00:21:51.240 be

00:21:51.560 one

00:21:52.200 form

00:21:52.520 of

00:21:52.700 the

00:21:52.860 expression

00:21:53.420 they

00:21:54.480 are

00:21:54.600 very

00:21:54.860 totalitarian

00:21:55.820 in the

00:21:56.140 one

00:21:56.440 way

00:21:58.180 where

00:21:58.740 it's

00:21:59.640 possible

00:22:00.020 a

00:22:00.340 legitimate

00:22:00.880 plurality

00:22:02.140 and

00:22:03.320 where

00:22:03.500 we

00:22:03.660 have

00:22:03.860 the

00:22:04.100 unity

00:22:04.840 in

00:22:05.440 faith

00:22:06.120 the

00:22:06.600 pope

00:22:06.880 is

00:22:07.060 the

00:22:07.240 first

00:22:07.740 responsible

00:22:09.940 for

00:22:10.440 the

00:22:10.660 unity

00:22:11.080 of

00:22:12.100 all

00:22:13.060 the

00:22:13.280 bishops

00:22:13.720 and

00:22:14.740 the

00:22:15.040 faithful

00:22:15.580 in

00:22:16.760 the

00:22:17.080 one

00:22:17.400 revealed

00:22:18.180 faith

00:22:18.800 that is

00:22:19.420 the

00:22:20.540 expression

00:22:21.060 also

00:22:21.500 of

00:22:21.920 the

00:22:22.920 Irenaeus

00:22:23.520 of

00:22:23.720 Lyon

00:22:24.120 we

00:22:25.500 have

00:22:25.680 everywhere

00:22:26.540 the

00:22:26.840 same

00:22:27.120 faith

00:22:27.640 in

00:22:28.520 Libya

00:22:28.880 Egypt

00:22:30.080 Galia

00:22:31.860 France

00:22:32.760 Germany

00:22:34.360 the

00:22:34.660 old

00:22:34.900 Germanies

00:22:35.560 and

00:22:35.760 everywhere

00:22:36.160 in

00:22:36.440 Spain

00:22:36.820 and

00:22:37.640 Rome

00:22:38.040 we

00:22:38.240 have

00:22:38.420 everywhere

00:22:38.920 the

00:22:39.200 same

00:22:39.580 faith

00:22:40.740 in

00:22:41.220 spite

00:22:41.540 of

00:22:41.760 different

00:22:42.160 languages

00:22:42.680 cultures

00:22:43.300 and

00:22:43.640 so

00:22:43.920 unity

00:22:45.460 in

00:22:45.700 the

00:22:45.880 faith

00:22:46.300 and

00:22:47.180 also

00:22:47.460 the

00:22:47.740 second

00:22:48.240 Vatican

00:22:48.560 council

00:22:49.040 in

00:22:49.320 Lumen

00:22:49.560 Gentium

00:22:50.040 about

00:22:50.320 the

00:22:50.620 church

00:22:51.300 is

00:22:51.520 saying

00:22:51.820 what

00:22:52.120 is

00:22:52.680 the

00:22:53.120 service

00:22:53.500 what

00:22:54.440 is

00:22:54.560 the

00:22:54.700 mission

00:22:54.960 of

00:22:55.240 the

00:22:55.640 pope

00:22:56.020 not

00:22:56.880 only

00:22:57.200 to

00:22:57.540 be

00:22:57.780 here

00:22:58.100 some

00:22:59.120 rights

00:23:00.720 for

00:23:01.120 popularism

00:23:03.000 and

00:23:03.360 so

00:23:03.600 and

00:23:04.620 to

00:23:05.120 attract

00:23:05.580 the

00:23:05.820 people

00:23:06.140 for

00:23:06.440 the

00:23:06.620 television

00:23:07.100 and

00:23:07.460 so

00:23:07.740 but

00:23:08.520 the

00:23:08.920 pope

00:23:09.360 is

00:23:10.080 a successor

00:23:10.820 of

00:23:11.080 St.

00:23:11.400 Peter

00:23:11.720 is

00:23:12.660 instituted

00:23:13.560 to

00:23:13.900 be

00:23:14.240 to

00:23:15.280 guarantee

00:23:15.920 the

00:23:17.760 unity

00:23:19.300 of

00:23:20.720 all

00:23:21.380 believers

00:23:22.120 in

00:23:22.480 the

00:23:22.820 revealed

00:23:23.300 faith

00:23:24.040 not

00:23:24.380 the

00:23:25.060 unity

00:23:25.460 made

00:23:26.000 by

00:23:26.600 men

00:23:26.860 by

00:23:27.080 manipulating

00:23:27.880 by

00:23:28.260 political

00:23:28.820 means

00:23:30.000 and so

00:23:30.500 but

00:23:31.760 the

00:23:32.840 unity

00:23:33.700 in

00:23:34.200 Jesus

00:23:34.960 Christ

00:23:35.760 that is

00:23:36.640 the

00:23:37.220 faith

00:23:37.600 in

00:23:37.800 Jesus

00:23:38.180 Christ

00:23:39.040 I hope

00:23:39.980 for the

00:23:40.300 future

00:23:40.680 that

00:23:42.080 is

00:23:42.580 more

00:23:43.380 strict

00:23:45.880 theological

00:23:46.420 thinking

00:23:47.760 and

00:23:47.980 theological

00:23:48.460 orientation

00:23:49.500 not

00:23:50.540 in

00:23:50.700 theology

00:23:51.160 and

00:23:51.660 the

00:23:51.800 question

00:23:52.180 of

00:23:52.440 theological

00:23:53.360 schools

00:23:54.120 but

00:23:55.080 the

00:23:55.260 theological

00:23:55.900 perception

00:23:57.960 of

00:23:59.540 the

00:24:00.320 revealed

00:24:00.960 faith

00:24:01.980 which

00:24:02.580 is

00:24:02.820 the

00:24:02.980 basis

00:24:03.360 of

00:24:03.720 the

00:24:04.000 unity

00:24:04.940 of

00:24:06.000 the

00:24:07.120 Catholic

00:24:08.520 Church

00:24:09.660 Just a

00:24:12.740 quick note

00:24:13.120 before we

00:24:13.560 return

00:24:13.880 if you

00:24:14.680 would like

00:24:14.980 to stay

00:24:15.280 up to

00:24:15.540 date

00:24:15.720 on

00:24:16.000 LifeSite's

00:24:16.440 coverage

00:24:16.680 of the

00:24:17.060 latest

00:24:17.340 life

00:24:17.680 family

00:24:18.100 and

00:24:18.320 culture

00:24:18.580 news

00:24:18.820 subscribe

00:24:19.460 to

00:24:19.840 one

00:24:20.040 of

00:24:20.140 our

00:24:20.240 many

00:24:20.580 newsletters

00:24:21.080 by

00:24:21.300 going

00:24:21.580 to

00:24:21.800 life

00:24:22.000 site

00:24:22.200 news

00:24:22.520 dot

00:24:22.780 com

00:24:23.060 slash

00:24:23.460 subscribe

00:24:24.140 and

00:24:24.700 if

00:24:24.840 you'd

00:24:25.040 like

00:24:25.220 to

00:24:25.420 help

00:24:25.700 us

00:24:25.900 bring

00:24:26.200 our

00:24:26.440 truth

00:24:26.820 telling

00:24:27.100 coverage

00:24:27.440 to

00:24:27.660 millions

00:24:28.240 around

00:24:28.460 the

00:24:28.600 world

00:24:28.740 please

00:24:29.340 consider

00:24:29.760 making

00:24:30.140 a

00:24:30.300 one

00:24:30.480 time

00:24:30.720 or

00:24:30.980 monthly

00:24:31.260 donation

00:24:31.680 at

00:24:32.200 give

00:24:32.580 dot

00:24:32.980 life

00:24:33.220 site

00:24:33.400 news

00:24:33.680 dot

00:24:34.020 com

00:24:34.540 and

00:24:34.940 now

00:24:35.220 back

00:24:35.560 to

00:24:35.680 the

00:24:35.760 video

00:24:36.040 speaking

00:24:38.400 of

00:24:38.700 the

00:24:38.840 future

00:24:39.200 of

00:24:39.380 the

00:24:39.520 church

00:24:39.860 there

00:24:40.980 are

00:24:41.120 a

00:24:41.220 number

00:24:41.360 of

00:24:41.500 people

00:24:41.720 who

00:24:41.940 are

00:24:42.160 very

00:24:42.580 concerned

00:24:43.140 now

00:24:43.680 because

00:24:44.640 they

00:24:45.440 saw

00:24:46.000 Pope

00:24:47.220 Emeritus

00:24:47.760 Benedict

00:24:48.100 in his

00:24:48.600 retirement

00:24:49.180 as

00:24:50.420 a

00:24:50.740 sort

00:24:50.980 of

00:24:51.280 hand

00:24:52.680 of

00:24:52.940 stopping

00:24:53.900 perhaps

00:24:55.060 Pope

00:24:55.540 Francis

00:24:55.940 or the

00:24:56.700 liberal

00:24:57.560 wing of

00:24:58.040 the

00:24:58.160 church

00:24:58.360 or

00:24:58.460 whatever

00:24:58.660 you want

00:24:58.900 to call

00:24:59.080 it

00:24:59.240 from

00:24:59.760 going

00:25:00.180 even

00:25:00.420 further

00:25:00.780 so

00:25:01.280 that

00:25:01.460 Benedict

00:25:01.740 was

00:25:02.020 kind

00:25:02.280 of

00:25:02.400 holding

00:25:02.880 back

00:25:03.400 perhaps

00:25:04.500 even

00:25:04.820 a

00:25:04.960 more

00:25:05.260 severe

00:25:06.060 push 0.64

00:25:07.000 to

00:25:07.300 one

00:25:07.540 side

00:25:07.940 do

00:25:09.500 you

00:25:09.840 sense

00:25:10.560 that

00:25:10.760 that

00:25:10.940 might

00:25:11.200 be

00:25:11.340 the

00:25:11.460 case

00:25:11.740 and

00:25:11.920 what

00:25:12.300 do

00:25:12.440 you

00:25:12.540 think

00:25:12.820 is

00:25:13.060 the

00:25:13.320 future

00:25:13.720 the

00:25:14.160 near

00:25:14.500 future

00:25:14.900 of

00:25:15.040 the

00:25:15.120 church

00:25:15.340 now

00:25:15.580 that

00:25:15.760 Pope

00:25:15.940 Benedict

00:25:16.180 has

00:25:16.520 died

00:25:16.780 nobody

00:25:17.640 knows

00:25:18.160 the

00:25:19.120 past

00:25:19.540 the

00:25:19.780 church

00:25:20.040 has

00:25:20.260 been

00:25:20.520 sometimes

00:25:21.600 in

00:25:21.960 trouble

00:25:22.340 there

00:25:23.840 was

00:25:24.000 bishops

00:25:24.440 in

00:25:26.040 the

00:25:26.660 time

00:25:26.940 of

00:25:27.080 St.

00:25:27.300 Augustine

00:25:27.860 the

00:25:28.600 Pelagians 1.00

00:25:29.280 was

00:25:29.700 a

00:25:29.820 charity

00:25:30.360 against

00:25:31.680 the

00:25:32.000 Catholics

00:25:32.360 in

00:25:32.640 North

00:25:32.940 Africa

00:25:33.700 there

00:25:34.940 were

00:25:35.060 big

00:25:35.300 troubles

00:25:35.720 in

00:25:36.240 the

00:25:36.420 time

00:25:37.540 of

00:25:37.700 the

00:25:37.860 Aryans

00:25:38.340 John

00:25:39.880 Henry

00:25:40.300 Newman

00:25:40.620 wrote

00:25:41.000 a

00:25:41.260 big

00:25:42.340 book

00:25:42.600 about

00:25:42.940 the

00:25:43.200 Aryans

00:25:43.720 in

00:25:43.900 the

00:25:44.020 fourth

00:25:44.300 century

00:25:44.800 times

00:25:45.420 of

00:25:45.620 crisis

00:25:46.080 in

00:25:46.420 the

00:25:46.560 so-called

00:25:47.060 reformation

00:25:47.940 the

00:25:49.100 splitting

00:25:49.480 of

00:25:49.900 the

00:25:50.940 church

00:25:51.340 in

00:25:51.880 the

00:25:52.640 middle

00:25:52.820 of

00:25:53.000 Europe

00:25:53.840 Germany

00:25:55.720 Switzerland

00:25:56.700 Holland

00:25:57.620 Netherlands

00:25:58.860 so

00:25:59.760 the

00:25:59.940 question

00:26:00.300 of

00:26:00.620 the

00:26:00.820 understanding

00:26:01.380 of

00:26:02.500 the

00:26:02.700 primacy

00:26:03.300 of

00:26:03.500 the

00:26:03.680 holy

00:26:03.900 Roman

00:26:04.300 church

00:26:05.060 with

00:26:06.020 their

00:26:06.280 bishop

00:26:06.880 as

00:26:07.420 successor

00:26:08.280 of

00:26:08.540 St.

00:26:08.780 Peter

00:26:09.840 the

00:26:10.540 Pope

00:26:10.740 cannot

00:26:10.980 do

00:26:11.240 what

00:26:11.620 he

00:26:12.580 wants

00:26:12.980 Pope

00:26:14.620 Benedict

00:26:15.040 also

00:26:15.460 explained

00:26:16.040 it

00:26:16.340 on the

00:26:17.460 high

00:26:17.700 level

00:26:18.500 and also

00:26:20.300 explained

00:26:20.820 in my

00:26:21.180 book

00:26:21.420 about

00:26:21.800 the

00:26:22.180 mission

00:26:22.460 of

00:26:23.500 the

00:26:24.080 Pope

00:26:25.420 nobody

00:26:26.140 can

00:26:27.760 say

00:26:29.300 that

00:26:29.580 Cardinal

00:26:30.060 Müller

00:26:30.420 has

00:26:31.500 any

00:26:31.740 doubt

00:26:32.100 about

00:26:33.520 the

00:26:34.540 role

00:26:34.840 of

00:26:35.060 St.

00:26:35.360 Peter

00:26:35.580 in

00:26:36.680 the

00:26:37.020 church

00:26:37.440 but

00:26:37.880 will

00:26:38.060 not

00:26:38.260 say

00:26:38.540 that

00:26:39.580 we

00:26:39.740 have

00:26:39.940 to

00:26:40.080 accept

00:26:40.460 all

00:26:40.820 what

00:26:41.680 happened

00:26:42.000 in the

00:26:42.380 history

00:26:42.800 of

00:26:43.600 papacy

00:26:44.060 some

00:26:45.080 problematic

00:26:46.700 figures

00:26:47.240 and

00:26:47.960 the

00:26:48.880 of

00:26:49.600 St.

00:26:51.440 Peter

00:26:51.740 and

00:26:53.640 also

00:26:54.340 Newman

00:26:55.060 said

00:26:56.900 we

00:26:58.300 have

00:26:58.860 to

00:26:59.940 expect

00:27:00.400 all

00:27:00.800 what

00:27:01.060 is

00:27:01.300 said

00:27:01.840 and

00:27:02.440 made

00:27:02.880 and

00:27:03.200 etc.

00:27:05.220 The

00:27:05.420 infallibility

00:27:06.100 of the

00:27:07.780 Pope

00:27:08.060 is

00:27:08.700 referring

00:27:09.080 only

00:27:09.660 to

00:27:10.320 those

00:27:10.600 things

00:27:10.920 who

00:27:11.120 are

00:27:11.300 revealed

00:27:11.920 not

00:27:13.740 use

00:27:15.160 ecclesiasticum

00:27:16.120 only

00:27:16.420 the

00:27:17.680 varieties

00:27:19.860 of

00:27:20.740 some

00:27:21.780 regulations

00:27:23.140 practical

00:27:24.140 regulations

00:27:25.320 in the

00:27:25.840 church

00:27:26.240 or the

00:27:27.540 statements

00:27:27.940 of the

00:27:28.420 Pope

00:27:28.780 to

00:27:29.180 Russia

00:27:30.540 or

00:27:31.000 to

00:27:31.400 China

00:27:31.920 nothing

00:27:33.140 to do

00:27:33.520 with

00:27:33.680 the

00:27:33.800 infallibility

00:27:34.500 we

00:27:34.840 respect

00:27:35.440 surely

00:27:35.780 the

00:27:36.640 Holy

00:27:36.840 Father

00:27:37.400 but

00:27:37.840 as

00:27:38.040 the

00:27:38.140 Jansenist

00:27:38.720 there's

00:27:39.160 only

00:27:39.440 what

00:27:39.720 we

00:27:39.960 are

00:27:40.160 thinking

00:27:40.540 what

00:27:41.640 we

00:27:42.600 respect

00:27:43.480 as

00:27:43.760 Catholic

00:27:44.240 the

00:27:44.760 Holy

00:27:44.940 Father

00:27:45.320 as

00:27:46.360 a

00:27:46.500 person

00:27:46.840 single

00:27:47.220 person

00:27:47.860 and

00:27:48.980 in

00:27:49.140 his

00:27:49.480 task

00:27:50.280 and

00:27:50.460 his

00:27:50.640 mission

00:27:50.920 but

00:27:52.500 not

00:27:52.880 in

00:27:53.080 a

00:27:53.220 blind

00:27:53.500 way

00:27:53.900 we

00:27:55.580 are

00:27:55.780 not

00:27:56.060 looking

00:27:56.980 to

00:27:58.440 the

00:27:58.780 Holy

00:27:59.000 Father

00:27:59.480 as

00:28:00.720 the

00:28:00.880 ideology

00:28:01.400 is

00:28:01.660 looking

00:28:01.920 to

00:28:02.160 the

00:28:02.360 leader

00:28:02.640 in

00:28:02.880 China

00:28:03.220 or

00:28:03.740 North

00:28:04.820 Korea 0.61

00:28:05.340 or

00:28:05.920 dictator

00:28:06.620 where

00:28:07.540 human

00:28:08.320 beings

00:28:09.020 are

00:28:09.260 absolutizing

00:28:10.080 themselves

00:28:10.680 as

00:28:11.300 if

00:28:11.540 they

00:28:11.720 were

00:28:11.920 gods

00:28:12.320 the

00:28:13.920 Pope

00:28:14.280 the

00:28:14.520 bishops

00:28:14.920 the

00:28:15.160 priests

00:28:15.740 are

00:28:15.940 not

00:28:16.120 god

00:28:16.500 the

00:28:18.640 ministers

00:28:20.000 have to

00:28:21.560 serve

00:28:22.060 and

00:28:23.480 Jesus

00:28:24.420 after his

00:28:26.140 resurrection

00:28:26.760 before his

00:28:27.780 ascension

00:28:28.340 to the

00:28:29.400 heaven

00:28:29.720 is that

00:28:31.020 you have to

00:28:32.720 preach the

00:28:33.260 gospel

00:28:33.680 and to

00:28:35.480 baptize

00:28:36.280 the

00:28:37.360 people

00:28:38.120 make

00:28:39.120 them

00:28:39.440 my

00:28:39.800 disciples

00:28:40.500 in the

00:28:42.120 name

00:28:42.280 of the

00:28:42.580 Father

00:28:42.900 Son

00:28:43.220 of the

00:28:43.540 Holy

00:28:43.720 Spirit

00:28:44.060 but

00:28:44.380 including

00:28:44.840 all the

00:28:45.300 other

00:28:45.620 sacraments

00:28:46.920 and

00:28:47.320 at the

00:28:47.860 end

00:28:48.120 he said

00:28:48.580 you have

00:28:49.540 to

00:28:49.720 teach

00:28:50.320 the

00:28:51.940 people

00:28:52.340 in the

00:28:52.700 world

00:28:53.120 not

00:28:54.800 your

00:28:55.300 ideas

00:28:56.280 but

00:28:57.340 what

00:28:57.600 I

00:28:57.920 have

00:28:58.280 taught

00:28:58.740 to

00:28:59.000 you

00:28:59.720 Jesus

00:29:01.840 is

00:29:02.160 the

00:29:02.320 only

00:29:02.660 teacher

00:29:03.800 in

00:29:05.160 the

00:29:05.420 church

00:29:05.880 and

00:29:06.220 the

00:29:06.400 apostles

00:29:06.860 bishops 0.98

00:29:07.660 are

00:29:08.480 only

00:29:08.740 teachers

00:29:09.220 in

00:29:09.480 the

00:29:09.660 name

00:29:10.100 of

00:29:10.500 Jesus

00:29:11.760 you

00:29:12.580 have

00:29:13.720 not

00:29:13.940 other

00:29:14.320 thoughts

00:29:15.420 and

00:29:15.680 other

00:29:16.060 doctrines

00:29:18.000 and

00:29:18.600 we

00:29:18.780 must

00:29:19.020 be

00:29:19.300 firm

00:29:19.620 in

00:29:20.360 the

00:29:20.500 doctrine

00:29:20.900 of

00:29:21.140 the

00:29:21.280 apostles

00:29:21.760 and

00:29:23.500 when

00:29:23.720 Peter

00:29:24.520 and

00:29:24.780 Paul

00:29:25.240 came

00:29:25.600 to

00:29:25.860 Rome

00:29:26.240 they

00:29:27.180 brought

00:29:27.620 with

00:29:28.400 them

00:29:28.920 the

00:29:29.760 basic

00:29:30.440 doctrine

00:29:31.300 of

00:29:32.160 the

00:29:32.360 apostles

00:29:32.820 that's

00:29:34.240 why

00:29:34.480 they

00:29:34.680 are

00:29:34.820 the

00:29:35.020 founders

00:29:35.500 of

00:29:36.420 the

00:29:36.580 Roman

00:29:36.840 church

00:29:37.280 not

00:29:37.660 only

00:29:37.980 in

00:29:38.120 the

00:29:38.280 technical

00:29:38.700 in

00:29:39.000 the

00:29:39.200 founders

00:29:39.580 when

00:29:40.300 they

00:29:40.500 came

00:29:40.760 to

00:29:40.960 Rome

00:29:41.200 they

00:29:41.400 had

00:29:41.640 been

00:29:41.960 just

00:29:43.020 Christians

00:29:43.980 but

00:29:44.360 the

00:29:44.820 church

00:29:45.220 of

00:29:45.460 Rome

00:29:45.780 has

00:29:46.640 its

00:29:46.880 basis

00:29:47.320 in

00:29:47.580 the

00:29:47.760 doctrine

00:29:48.180 of

00:29:48.560 the

00:29:48.860 princes

00:29:49.380 of

00:29:49.800 the

00:29:50.080 apostles

00:29:50.980 the

00:29:51.240 first

00:29:51.600 two

00:29:52.060 important

00:29:53.380 apostles

00:29:53.940 Peter

00:29:54.360 and

00:29:54.620 Paul

00:29:55.020 that

00:29:55.680 is

00:29:56.500 why

00:29:56.900 then

00:29:57.660 Deneo

00:29:58.200 said

00:29:58.500 therefore

00:29:59.160 all

00:30:00.040 other

00:30:00.360 churches

00:30:01.080 local

00:30:01.760 churches

00:30:02.520 and

00:30:03.100 their

00:30:03.300 bishops

00:30:03.620 have

00:30:04.500 to

00:30:05.440 be

00:30:06.540 in

00:30:07.380 accordance

00:30:08.040 with

00:30:08.960 the

00:30:09.120 Holy

00:30:09.420 Roman

00:30:10.080 Church

00:30:10.520 because

00:30:10.880 it's

00:30:11.180 founded

00:30:11.580 in

00:30:12.340 St.

00:30:12.620 Peter

00:30:12.860 and

00:30:13.300 St.

00:30:13.820 Paul

00:30:14.300 their

00:30:14.920 doctrine

00:30:15.360 of

00:30:16.340 the

00:30:17.200 apostles

00:30:17.680 and

00:30:19.100 so

00:30:19.220 this

00:30:19.420 is

00:30:19.660 very

00:30:19.900 important

00:30:20.620 that

00:30:21.140 the

00:30:21.840 popes

00:30:22.360 have

00:30:22.740 very

00:30:23.660 strong

00:30:26.160 theological

00:30:26.960 advisors

00:30:27.600 and

00:30:28.960 don't

00:30:29.240 only

00:30:29.620 adulate

00:30:30.160 the

00:30:30.380 Holy

00:30:30.760 Father

00:30:31.160 was

00:30:31.360 you

00:30:31.500 are

00:30:31.660 saying

00:30:31.900 it's

00:30:32.080 every

00:30:32.380 time

00:30:33.340 the

00:30:33.820 best

00:30:34.240 and

00:30:34.480 you

00:30:34.680 have

00:30:35.240 illumination

00:30:36.940 directly

00:30:38.220 from

00:30:39.020 the

00:30:39.200 Holy

00:30:39.420 Spirit

00:30:39.800 that

00:30:41.980 is

00:30:42.160 not

00:30:42.360 the

00:30:42.560 case

00:30:42.980 popes

00:30:43.600 the

00:30:43.740 bishops

00:30:44.080 the

00:30:44.400 diocese

00:30:46.000 they

00:30:46.300 cannot

00:30:46.680 refer

00:30:48.480 themselves

00:30:48.880 only

00:30:49.600 to

00:30:50.480 their

00:30:51.040 formal

00:30:51.500 authority

00:30:52.140 I am

00:30:52.580 the

00:30:52.760 bishop

00:30:53.040 you

00:30:53.280 have

00:30:53.500 to

00:30:54.400 obey

00:30:55.000 me

00:30:55.380 it's

00:30:56.080 not

00:30:56.280 like

00:30:56.600 in

00:30:56.780 the

00:30:57.120 army

00:30:57.500 he

00:30:58.180 is

00:30:58.300 a

00:30:58.440 general

00:30:58.840 and

00:30:59.540 here

00:30:59.780 are

00:31:00.100 simple

00:31:01.480 soldiers

00:31:01.980 and

00:31:02.340 they

00:31:02.480 have

00:31:02.640 to

00:31:02.820 obey

00:31:03.220 everybody

00:31:05.360 has

00:31:05.900 received

00:31:06.440 the

00:31:06.700 Holy

00:31:06.980 Spirit

00:31:08.220 and

00:31:10.100 the

00:31:10.740 bishops

00:31:11.500 as

00:31:11.980 shepherds

00:31:12.480 they have

00:31:12.780 a special

00:31:13.380 task

00:31:14.240 within

00:31:14.820 the

00:31:15.720 complexity

00:31:16.380 of the

00:31:17.640 body

00:31:17.940 of

00:31:18.400 Christ

00:31:18.800 and

00:31:19.220 all

00:31:20.620 the

00:31:20.780 special

00:31:21.220 charismas

00:31:22.220 everybody

00:31:23.020 has

00:31:24.020 received

00:31:24.560 the

00:31:25.320 Holy

00:31:25.600 Spirit

00:31:26.220 and

00:31:26.620 we

00:31:26.820 obey

00:31:28.020 to

00:31:29.640 our

00:31:29.920 bishop

00:31:30.400 and

00:31:31.320 all

00:31:32.440 the

00:31:32.600 church

00:31:33.000 to

00:31:33.880 the

00:31:34.020 Holy

00:31:34.220 Father

00:31:34.560 because

00:31:35.320 he

00:31:35.940 is

00:31:36.260 saying

00:31:37.380 the

00:31:37.660 truth

00:31:38.040 and

00:31:39.720 not

00:31:39.980 on the

00:31:41.240 contrary

00:31:41.760 cannot

00:31:43.120 say

00:31:43.460 because

00:31:44.140 the

00:31:44.340 Holy

00:31:44.500 Father

00:31:44.800 is

00:31:45.000 saying

00:31:45.240 this

00:31:45.520 is

00:31:45.720 true

00:31:46.140 but

00:31:46.960 on the

00:31:47.200 contrary

00:31:47.540 because

00:31:48.180 the

00:31:49.240 thing

00:31:49.460 is

00:31:49.680 true

00:31:50.120 a

00:31:51.160 question

00:31:51.640 or

00:31:52.120 revelation

00:31:52.980 is

00:31:53.360 true

00:31:53.940 is

00:31:54.220 revealed

00:31:54.800 and

00:31:55.800 therefore

00:31:56.360 he

00:31:57.420 can

00:31:57.800 give

00:31:58.940 us

00:31:59.380 his

00:32:00.360 orders

00:32:00.860 to

00:32:01.340 obey

00:32:01.740 in

00:32:02.560 reality

00:32:03.040 we

00:32:04.120 don't

00:32:04.520 not

00:32:04.860 obey

00:32:05.520 to

00:32:06.900 him

00:32:07.220 to

00:32:07.820 human

00:32:08.180 person

00:32:08.720 but

00:32:09.620 we

00:32:09.780 are

00:32:09.920 obeying

00:32:10.420 to

00:32:11.460 God

00:32:11.840 because

00:32:12.540 Pope

00:32:13.320 bishops

00:32:13.880 councils

00:32:14.660 are

00:32:15.820 presenting

00:32:17.320 us

00:32:18.080 the

00:32:18.820 word

00:32:19.140 of

00:32:19.460 God

00:32:19.880 now

00:32:20.660 we

00:32:20.820 come

00:32:21.020 to

00:32:21.380 perhaps

00:32:21.780 a

00:32:21.940 very

00:32:22.060 difficult

00:32:22.420 question

00:32:22.940 at least

00:32:23.300 difficult

00:32:23.660 for

00:32:23.980 America

00:32:24.420 in

00:32:24.900 the

00:32:25.060 beginning

00:32:25.320 of

00:32:25.600 Pope

00:32:25.760 Francis

00:32:26.080 reign

00:32:26.620 Cardinal

00:32:27.960 Burke 1.00

00:32:28.220 was

00:32:28.440 removed

00:32:28.980 as

00:32:29.900 the

00:32:30.320 head

00:32:30.720 of

00:32:30.920 the

00:32:31.020 Apostolic

00:32:31.440 Signatura

00:32:31.980 given

00:32:32.820 the

00:32:33.000 position

00:32:33.480 with

00:32:34.520 the

00:32:35.240 Order

00:32:36.620 of

00:32:36.780 Malta

00:32:37.120 but

00:32:37.320 then

00:32:37.560 sort

00:32:38.020 of

00:32:38.120 removed

00:32:38.400 from

00:32:38.560 that

00:32:38.720 as

00:32:38.880 well

00:32:39.080 and

00:32:39.380 then

00:32:39.620 also

00:32:40.100 with

00:32:40.380 yourself

00:32:40.780 you

00:32:41.000 were

00:32:41.120 removed

00:32:41.560 rather

00:32:42.560 unceremoniously

00:32:43.320 from

00:32:43.740 the

00:32:44.040 Congregation 0.56

00:32:44.600 of

00:32:44.800 Doctrine

00:32:45.040 of Faith

00:32:45.360 but

00:32:46.680 you

00:32:46.800 were

00:32:46.940 both

00:32:47.240 Roman

00:32:48.080 cardinals

00:32:48.580 crurial

00:32:49.140 cardinals

00:32:49.600 and

00:32:49.920 the

00:32:50.940 effect

00:32:51.440 of

00:32:51.600 that

00:32:51.780 while

00:32:52.060 severe

00:32:52.520 wasn't

00:32:53.660 as severe

00:32:54.700 perhaps

00:32:55.120 as

00:32:55.280 what's

00:32:55.500 going

00:32:55.680 on

00:32:55.980 also

00:32:56.840 because

00:32:57.400 even

00:32:58.140 though

00:32:58.380 you

00:32:58.560 were

00:32:58.740 removed

00:32:59.080 from

00:32:59.320 your

00:32:59.480 positions

00:33:00.100 you

00:33:01.300 were

00:33:01.460 still

00:33:01.820 cardinal

00:33:02.540 in

00:33:03.620 in the

00:33:03.740 United

00:33:03.920 States

00:33:04.380 now

00:33:04.780 we

00:33:05.440 have

00:33:05.940 the

00:33:06.540 laicization

00:33:07.920 of

00:33:09.340 a

00:33:09.980 priest

00:33:10.460 known

00:33:11.480 throughout

00:33:11.960 America

00:33:12.640 throughout

00:33:12.980 North

00:33:13.280 America

00:33:13.500 in fact

00:33:13.820 throughout

00:33:14.240 most

00:33:14.620 of the

00:33:14.800 world

00:33:15.080 as

00:33:16.420 the

00:33:17.000 pro-life

00:33:17.760 priest

00:33:18.200 Father

00:33:19.040 Frank

00:33:19.380 Pavone

00:33:19.820 who

00:33:20.600 has

00:33:21.120 been

00:33:21.460 the

00:33:22.180 head

00:33:22.540 of

00:33:22.720 Priests

00:33:22.980 for

00:33:23.120 Life

00:33:23.400 and

00:33:23.600 also

00:33:23.860 runs

00:33:24.140 a

00:33:24.280 ministry

00:33:24.660 for

00:33:25.760 women 1.00

00:33:26.080 who

00:33:26.220 have

00:33:26.320 experienced

00:33:26.740 abortion

00:33:27.200 has

00:33:28.040 been

00:33:28.280 removed

00:33:28.840 from

00:33:29.540 the

00:33:29.800 priesthood

00:33:30.380 it's

00:33:31.140 stunning

00:33:31.680 for

00:33:32.260 America

00:33:32.760 because

00:33:33.460 we

00:33:34.820 see

00:33:35.460 from

00:33:36.280 America

00:33:36.760 who

00:33:37.900 gets

00:33:38.080 removed

00:33:38.360 from

00:33:38.520 the

00:33:38.660 priesthood

00:33:39.060 Cardinal

00:33:40.260 McCarrick

00:33:40.720 but only

00:33:41.300 after

00:33:41.800 like

00:33:42.460 years

00:33:43.460 even

00:33:43.880 decades

00:33:44.380 of

00:33:44.580 people

00:33:44.840 already

00:33:45.220 knowing

00:33:45.620 there

00:33:45.800 was a

00:33:46.040 huge

00:33:46.380 sexual

00:33:47.020 problem

00:33:47.520 but

00:33:49.040 with

00:33:49.220 Father

00:33:49.400 Pavone

00:33:49.780 we're

00:33:50.540 not

00:33:50.940 talking

00:33:51.340 about

00:33:51.680 any

00:33:52.100 sexual

00:33:52.520 problem

00:33:52.940 we're

00:33:53.820 talking

00:33:54.080 about

00:33:54.300 the

00:33:54.480 best

00:33:54.860 known

00:33:55.260 priest

00:33:55.820 fighting

00:33:56.400 for

00:33:57.000 John

00:33:57.680 Paul

00:33:57.920 II's

00:33:58.680 ministry

00:34:00.260 of

00:34:00.720 the

00:34:00.900 culture

00:34:01.320 of

00:34:01.600 life

00:34:01.960 that

00:34:02.560 fight

00:34:03.000 which

00:34:03.300 the

00:34:03.540 Pope

00:34:03.880 John

00:34:04.900 Paul

00:34:05.220 and

00:34:05.940 supported

00:34:06.360 by

00:34:06.640 Cardinal

00:34:06.920 Ratzinger

00:34:07.260 at the

00:34:07.480 time

00:34:07.680 and

00:34:07.780 then

00:34:07.900 later

00:34:08.140 pushed

00:34:08.460 also

00:34:08.900 by

00:34:09.140 Pope

00:34:09.320 Benedict

00:34:09.600 supported

00:34:11.400 Father

00:34:12.040 Frank

00:34:12.380 Pavone

00:34:12.820 in

00:34:13.440 this

00:34:13.640 great

00:34:13.860 work

00:34:14.060 in

00:34:14.220 fact

00:34:14.420 John

00:34:15.160 Paul

00:34:15.280 II

00:34:15.640 called

00:34:16.520 Father

00:34:17.140 Marx

00:34:17.520 when

00:34:17.680 he

00:34:17.760 was

00:34:17.860 doing

00:34:18.040 the

00:34:18.240 same

00:34:18.520 work

00:34:18.860 as

00:34:19.420 doing

00:34:19.580 the

00:34:19.700 most

00:34:19.840 important

00:34:20.140 work

00:34:20.360 on

00:34:20.500 earth

00:34:20.720 and

00:34:21.280 yet

00:34:21.560 Father

00:34:22.120 Frank

00:34:22.680 Pavone

00:34:23.100 is

00:34:23.260 laicized

00:34:23.640 we

00:34:23.880 have

00:34:24.380 brought

00:34:24.700 with

00:34:24.920 us

00:34:25.080 to

00:34:25.280 Rome

00:34:25.580 a

00:34:26.340 petition

00:34:26.860 of

00:34:27.100 over

00:34:27.320 45,000

00:34:29.000 Catholics

00:34:29.660 begging 0.78

00:34:30.840 the

00:34:31.300 Holy

00:34:31.480 Father

00:34:31.860 to

00:34:32.500 revoke

00:34:33.200 this

00:34:33.500 decision

00:34:33.980 that

00:34:34.220 was

00:34:34.380 made

00:34:34.640 by

00:34:34.780 the

00:34:34.900 Congregation 0.56

00:34:35.280 for

00:34:35.540 Clergy 0.98

00:34:35.880 on

00:34:36.000 November

00:34:36.260 the

00:34:36.460 9th

00:34:36.800 scandalously

00:34:38.120 Father

00:34:38.960 Pavone

00:34:39.340 didn't

00:34:39.560 even

00:34:39.760 know

00:34:40.100 the

00:34:40.360 position

00:34:40.740 the

00:34:41.180 banning

00:34:42.940 him

00:34:43.100 from

00:34:43.260 the

00:34:43.360 priesthood

00:34:43.660 or

00:34:43.880 laicization

00:34:44.380 until

00:34:45.360 the

00:34:45.680 media

00:34:45.980 got

00:34:46.300 to

00:34:46.480 him

00:34:46.700 just

00:34:47.360 in

00:34:47.520 December

00:34:47.920 if

00:34:49.720 you

00:34:49.880 can

00:34:50.140 comment

00:34:50.920 at

00:34:51.140 all

00:34:51.320 for

00:34:51.540 us

00:34:51.700 on

00:34:51.840 this

00:34:52.000 that

00:34:52.100 would

00:34:52.180 be

00:34:52.280 most

00:34:52.460 appreciated

00:34:52.900 I

00:34:53.420 read

00:34:53.720 also

00:34:54.000 this

00:34:54.400 letter

00:34:54.960 which

00:34:55.460 was

00:34:55.860 he

00:34:56.980 informed

00:34:58.100 or

00:34:58.360 the

00:34:58.980 publicity

00:34:59.860 was

00:35:00.280 informed

00:35:00.800 of

00:35:01.080 the

00:35:01.280 secularization

00:35:02.140 of a

00:35:03.300 priest

00:35:03.600 that

00:35:03.820 not

00:35:04.040 he

00:35:04.300 himself

00:35:04.960 I

00:35:06.100 think

00:35:06.640 this

00:35:06.900 is

00:35:07.040 unguilty

00:35:07.560 and

00:35:08.680 is

00:35:08.860 only

00:35:09.180 I

00:35:09.500 think

00:35:10.240 the

00:35:11.040 political

00:35:11.440 actions

00:35:12.100 the

00:35:13.200 secularization

00:35:14.040 of a

00:35:14.500 priest

00:35:14.840 is

00:35:15.120 instituted

00:35:16.560 by

00:35:16.820 Jesus

00:35:17.100 Christ

00:35:17.620 himself

00:35:18.900 and

00:35:19.140 not

00:35:19.300 by

00:35:19.480 the

00:35:19.660 Pope

00:35:19.960 and

00:35:20.160 not

00:35:20.520 by

00:35:20.780 the

00:35:20.960 bishop

00:35:21.340 can

00:35:21.780 be

00:35:22.040 secularization

00:35:22.900 only

00:35:23.480 a

00:35:23.880 penalty

00:35:24.320 in

00:35:24.860 the

00:35:25.080 ultimate

00:35:25.600 case

00:35:26.240 in

00:35:27.140 the

00:35:27.360 case

00:35:28.020 of

00:35:28.200 apostasy

00:35:29.040 or

00:35:29.860 strong

00:35:30.740 heresy

00:35:31.360 or

00:35:32.620 absolutely

00:35:34.220 contradictorial

00:35:37.020 behavior

00:35:37.780 against

00:35:39.300 the

00:35:40.340 priesthood

00:35:40.920 but

00:35:41.360 the

00:35:41.720 reasons

00:35:42.100 here

00:35:42.440 presented

00:35:42.980 are

00:35:44.140 not

00:35:44.380 justifying

00:35:45.100 not

00:35:45.320 justifying

00:35:46.160 secularization

00:35:48.200 I

00:35:48.660 I

00:35:48.680 think

00:35:48.940 is

00:35:50.200 the

00:35:50.240 only

00:35:52.580 political

00:35:53.160 action

00:35:53.660 I

00:35:54.080 think

00:35:54.300 there

00:35:54.540 was

00:35:54.860 surely

00:35:56.040 a lot

00:35:56.480 of

00:35:56.940 pressures

00:35:57.300 of the

00:35:57.880 democratic

00:35:59.160 party

00:36:00.160 and

00:36:01.680 those

00:36:02.020 activists

00:36:02.940 in

00:36:03.480 abortion

00:36:04.240 and

00:36:06.260 they

00:36:06.500 made

00:36:07.180 surely

00:36:07.420 pressure

00:36:07.860 here

00:36:08.080 I

00:36:08.200 don't

00:36:08.420 know

00:36:08.640 what

00:36:08.860 happened

00:36:09.220 here

00:36:09.500 in

00:36:10.420 Rome

00:36:11.060 but

00:36:12.860 I

00:36:13.220 see

00:36:13.420 only

00:36:13.760 the

00:36:14.120 phenomena

00:36:16.300 what

00:36:17.540 is

00:36:18.060 happening

00:36:18.520 and

00:36:20.180 nobody

00:36:21.260 with a

00:36:22.680 certain

00:36:23.040 theological

00:36:23.720 understanding

00:36:24.640 or

00:36:25.660 with a

00:36:26.100 feeling

00:36:26.800 human

00:36:27.320 feeling

00:36:27.940 of

00:36:28.820 justice

00:36:29.360 and

00:36:29.640 injustice

00:36:30.200 and

00:36:31.280 human

00:36:31.520 rights

00:36:31.960 can

00:36:33.220 understand

00:36:34.040 it

00:36:34.500 and

00:36:35.700 not

00:36:35.920 accept

00:36:36.380 it

00:36:36.660 there

00:36:37.260 are

00:36:37.460 other

00:36:37.740 prominent

00:36:38.260 persons

00:36:39.120 in

00:36:40.080 the

00:36:40.800 United

00:36:41.100 States

00:36:41.600 or

00:36:41.780 other

00:36:42.120 countries

00:36:42.740 who

00:36:43.640 are

00:36:43.720 denying

00:36:44.140 openly

00:36:45.220 the

00:36:46.440 basics

00:36:46.960 of the

00:36:47.580 Catholic

00:36:47.900 faith

00:36:48.320 and

00:36:48.520 morals

00:36:49.000 and

00:36:50.220 they

00:36:50.380 have

00:36:50.600 no

00:36:50.960 reactions

00:36:52.960 from

00:36:55.220 the

00:36:55.400 side

00:36:55.760 of

00:36:55.980 the

00:36:56.960 ecclesiastical

00:36:57.940 authority

00:36:58.660 and

00:37:00.120 those

00:37:00.460 people

00:37:01.060 who

00:37:01.280 are

00:37:01.560 fighting

00:37:03.300 for

00:37:03.880 the

00:37:04.060 life

00:37:04.520 against

00:37:05.980 this

00:37:06.440 brutal

00:37:07.000 crime

00:37:07.500 of

00:37:08.680 killing 0.97

00:37:09.060 of

00:37:09.980 a

00:37:10.160 person

00:37:10.560 in

00:37:10.920 the

00:37:11.060 mother

00:37:11.260 womb

00:37:11.760 second

00:37:12.360 Vatican

00:37:12.740 council

00:37:13.300 that

00:37:13.640 is

00:37:13.860 a

00:37:14.580 brutal

00:37:18.860 crime

00:37:19.480 against

00:37:20.580 humanity

00:37:21.360 and

00:37:23.400 also

00:37:24.180 since

00:37:25.820 ever

00:37:26.400 the

00:37:27.660 doctrine

00:37:28.160 of

00:37:28.520 the

00:37:28.660 conviction

00:37:29.120 of

00:37:30.060 the

00:37:30.260 church

00:37:30.600 if

00:37:30.840 God

00:37:31.420 is

00:37:31.640 the

00:37:31.800 creator

00:37:32.200 of

00:37:33.120 human

00:37:33.440 life

00:37:33.860 nobody

00:37:34.280 has

00:37:34.740 the

00:37:35.060 right

00:37:35.340 to

00:37:36.140 destroy

00:37:36.660 another

00:37:37.500 life

00:37:38.720 with

00:37:39.000 what

00:37:39.220 reasons

00:37:39.780 ever

00:37:40.340 and

00:37:41.820 all

00:37:42.080 this

00:37:42.440 position

00:37:44.780 there's

00:37:45.980 the

00:37:46.100 right

00:37:46.460 of

00:37:47.400 women 1.00

00:37:47.700 to 1.00

00:37:48.440 kill 1.00

00:37:48.700 their 1.00

00:37:48.920 own

00:37:49.160 babies

00:37:49.640 that

00:37:50.500 cannot

00:37:51.360 be

00:37:51.660 justified

00:37:52.160 in

00:37:53.380 any

00:37:53.740 way

00:37:54.420 there

00:37:54.720 was

00:37:55.060 great

00:37:56.020 ideologies

00:37:56.720 and

00:37:57.320 totalitarian

00:37:58.260 systems

00:37:58.940 atheistic

00:37:59.600 systems

00:38:00.180 who

00:38:01.400 are

00:38:01.700 saying

00:38:02.080 we

00:38:02.540 can 1.00

00:38:02.780 kill 1.00

00:38:03.160 the 1.00

00:38:04.660 babies

00:38:05.340 or the

00:38:05.980 ill

00:38:06.240 person

00:38:06.780 or the

00:38:07.260 old

00:38:07.580 people

00:38:08.120 we

00:38:08.940 have

00:38:09.340 to 1.00

00:38:09.500 kill 1.00

00:38:09.820 because 0.99

00:38:10.280 they

00:38:10.520 have

00:38:10.740 no

00:38:11.060 more

00:38:12.200 worth

00:38:12.900 economical

00:38:13.720 worth

00:38:14.540 this

00:38:15.320 is

00:38:15.500 only

00:38:16.300 a

00:38:16.600 reduction

00:38:17.120 of

00:38:18.860 the

00:38:19.060 human

00:38:19.420 dignity

00:38:21.240 to

00:38:22.920 their

00:38:23.680 economical

00:38:25.040 price

00:38:26.560 and

00:38:26.800 worth

00:38:27.180 there's

00:38:28.500 no

00:38:28.720 difference

00:38:29.760 to

00:38:31.800 the

00:38:32.200 misleading

00:38:34.260 and

00:38:35.120 maltratation

00:38:36.400 in

00:38:37.540 China

00:38:38.000 or

00:38:38.320 other

00:38:38.640 countries

00:38:39.620 China

00:38:41.880 is rich

00:38:42.440 has

00:38:42.720 success

00:38:43.240 economical

00:38:43.880 success

00:38:44.340 because

00:38:45.380 why

00:38:46.220 the

00:38:46.520 party

00:38:47.780 is

00:38:48.300 exploiting

00:38:49.000 the

00:38:49.220 people

00:38:49.620 where

00:38:50.520 is

00:38:50.700 the

00:38:50.840 human

00:38:51.160 dignity

00:38:51.700 of

00:38:52.660 every

00:38:53.100 Chinese

00:38:53.800 man

00:38:54.480 or

00:38:54.740 woman 0.99

00:38:55.040 and

00:38:55.520 we

00:38:55.760 as

00:38:56.120 church

00:38:56.700 we

00:38:57.560 must

00:38:57.900 not

00:38:58.640 interfere

00:38:59.260 in

00:39:00.060 the

00:39:00.280 politics

00:39:00.880 but

00:39:01.560 we

00:39:01.760 have

00:39:01.960 to

00:39:02.340 say

00:39:03.220 what

00:39:03.500 are

00:39:03.740 the

00:39:03.880 guidelines

00:39:04.460 for

00:39:04.820 the

00:39:04.980 politics

00:39:05.560 the

00:39:06.480 moral

00:39:06.940 essence

00:39:07.540 of

00:39:07.840 politics

00:39:08.460 the

00:39:09.280 politics

00:39:09.760 is

00:39:10.080 written

00:39:10.720 in the

00:39:11.140 sense

00:39:11.440 of

00:39:11.640 Machiavelli

00:39:12.320 to

00:39:13.440 remain

00:39:14.560 your

00:39:15.440 own

00:39:15.720 power

00:39:16.220 but

00:39:17.200 the

00:39:17.480 politicians

00:39:17.960 have

00:39:18.420 to

00:39:18.640 work

00:39:19.020 for

00:39:19.300 the

00:39:19.440 good

00:39:19.660 of

00:39:19.860 the

00:39:20.040 people

00:39:20.420 that

00:39:22.120 is

00:39:22.320 our

00:39:22.780 democratic

00:39:23.640 understanding

00:39:24.900 from

00:39:25.860 politics

00:39:26.580 defending

00:39:28.560 the

00:39:29.000 people

00:39:29.420 against

00:39:30.120 Ukraine

00:39:31.120 against

00:39:31.660 their

00:39:32.200 aggressions

00:39:32.920 but

00:39:34.200 in

00:39:34.700 the

00:39:34.940 politic

00:39:36.460 inside

00:39:37.060 of

00:39:37.380 a

00:39:37.540 country

00:39:37.980 their

00:39:39.060 own

00:39:39.600 line

00:39:41.160 they

00:39:41.840 have

00:39:42.060 to

00:39:42.260 follow

00:39:42.640 the

00:39:43.200 politicians

00:39:43.760 it's

00:39:44.060 not

00:39:44.240 their

00:39:44.400 own

00:39:44.580 power

00:39:44.960 their

00:39:45.260 own

00:39:46.060 interests

00:39:46.700 but

00:39:47.380 the

00:39:48.080 wealth

00:39:48.640 of

00:39:49.480 the

00:39:49.640 people

00:39:50.060 the

00:39:50.500 Bonum

00:39:50.780 Commune

00:39:51.340 in

00:39:51.900 America

00:39:52.460 I have to say

00:39:53.240 we feel

00:39:54.020 kind of

00:39:54.440 abandoned

00:39:54.840 by

00:39:55.480 the

00:39:56.380 Holy

00:39:56.520 Father

00:39:56.800 we feel

00:39:57.700 we had

00:39:58.620 support

00:39:59.120 from

00:39:59.400 John Paul II

00:40:00.040 as the

00:40:00.460 pro-life

00:40:00.720 movement

00:40:01.040 we had

00:40:01.460 the great

00:40:01.920 support

00:40:02.340 from

00:40:02.580 Benedict

00:40:02.940 as well

00:40:03.500 but

00:40:03.940 it seems

00:40:04.500 to have

00:40:05.200 gone

00:40:05.540 in the

00:40:06.400 last

00:40:06.600 decade

00:40:06.920 or so

00:40:07.400 but

00:40:08.200 you

00:40:08.460 yourself

00:40:08.940 have

00:40:09.660 been

00:40:10.000 for us

00:40:10.980 a

00:40:11.680 great

00:40:12.860 stalwart

00:40:13.440 especially

00:40:14.260 you just

00:40:14.660 came

00:40:15.000 to visit

00:40:15.980 with

00:40:16.160 Mark

00:40:16.480 Hauck

00:40:16.780 when he

00:40:17.240 and his

00:40:17.500 family

00:40:17.760 were persecuted

00:40:18.460 under the

00:40:18.900 Biden

00:40:19.120 administration

00:40:19.580 for being

00:40:20.160 pro-life

00:40:20.660 so I want

00:40:22.260 to thank

00:40:22.640 you for

00:40:22.900 that

00:40:23.160 how it

00:40:23.520 is

00:40:23.700 possible

00:40:24.140 that

00:40:25.420 30

00:40:26.500 heavy

00:40:27.920 armed

00:40:28.580 police

00:40:29.380 men

00:40:29.740 women 1.00

00:40:30.120 are

00:40:31.180 entering

00:40:31.860 a house

00:40:32.620 with

00:40:32.960 seven

00:40:33.860 children

00:40:34.540 from

00:40:35.860 2

00:40:36.300 to

00:40:36.640 70

00:40:37.940 years

00:40:38.460 and so

00:40:38.940 and

00:40:41.440 to

00:40:41.880 threatening

00:40:42.940 them

00:40:43.380 with

00:40:44.240 arms

00:40:45.000 what

00:40:45.820 is

00:40:46.300 happening

00:40:46.720 unfortunately

00:40:47.660 today

00:40:48.980 in the

00:40:49.320 Catholic

00:40:49.680 Church

00:40:50.240 first

00:40:50.980 we felt

00:40:52.160 ourselves

00:40:52.880 as Catholics

00:40:53.860 in all

00:40:54.940 the world

00:40:55.540 in all

00:40:56.500 the languages

00:40:57.140 as the

00:40:57.700 same

00:40:57.940 family

00:40:58.480 and now

00:40:59.700 there are

00:41:00.080 the prejudices

00:41:01.280 of the

00:41:01.720 Americans

00:41:02.860 and the

00:41:03.980 North

00:41:04.700 American

00:41:05.200 United

00:41:05.640 States

00:41:06.320 I had

00:41:08.520 a long

00:41:08.800 time

00:41:09.260 being

00:41:10.320 15

00:41:10.740 years

00:41:11.260 every

00:41:11.580 year

00:41:11.880 in

00:41:12.260 Latin

00:41:13.440 America

00:41:14.000 and I

00:41:14.660 see

00:41:15.040 there are

00:41:15.740 prejudices

00:41:17.380 but could

00:41:18.120 have been

00:41:18.820 also

00:41:19.800 the

00:41:20.120 reasons

00:41:21.380 in the

00:41:21.800 history

00:41:22.320 but

00:41:23.580 we

00:41:24.260 cannot

00:41:24.920 as

00:41:25.880 Christians

00:41:26.660 only

00:41:27.920 continue

00:41:29.880 with

00:41:30.740 our

00:41:31.060 old

00:41:31.380 prejudices

00:41:32.320 our

00:41:33.380 mission

00:41:33.760 is to

00:41:34.200 overcome

00:41:34.920 the

00:41:35.240 prejudices

00:41:36.080 and to

00:41:37.960 come

00:41:38.160 together

00:41:38.600 to give

00:41:39.020 a good

00:41:39.340 example

00:41:39.980 where they

00:41:41.460 are

00:41:41.800 often I

00:41:43.460 am in

00:41:43.800 Poland

00:41:44.160 and Germany

00:41:45.140 all the

00:41:46.280 Hitler time 0.94

00:41:47.040 and so

00:41:47.440 terrible

00:41:48.220 was terrible

00:41:48.960 what can

00:41:50.120 we do

00:41:50.660 as Catholics

00:41:52.620 not

00:41:53.280 continuing

00:41:53.920 you

00:41:55.860 have said

00:41:56.240 no

00:41:56.420 you have

00:41:56.700 said

00:41:56.920 no

00:41:57.220 we have

00:41:59.740 to give

00:42:00.200 a good

00:42:00.580 example

00:42:01.220 that is

00:42:01.800 possible

00:42:02.280 to live

00:42:03.440 together

00:42:03.900 especially

00:42:04.800 in the

00:42:05.980 Catholic

00:42:06.520 Church

00:42:07.080 and

00:42:07.440 the

00:42:08.320 Holy

00:42:08.500 Father

00:42:08.880 is the

00:42:09.220 father

00:42:09.580 of the

00:42:10.800 whole

00:42:11.120 Catholic

00:42:11.860 family

00:42:13.100 I cannot

00:42:14.140 say

00:42:14.520 this

00:42:15.500 of my

00:42:16.820 children

00:42:17.300 is better

00:42:18.480 than the

00:42:18.880 other

00:42:19.080 children

00:42:19.620 the other

00:42:20.740 child

00:42:21.200 we are

00:42:22.000 finite

00:42:22.920 human

00:42:24.660 beings

00:42:25.100 with our

00:42:25.700 limits

00:42:27.000 and so

00:42:27.540 and also

00:42:28.820 in the

00:42:29.240 natural

00:42:29.680 family

00:42:30.160 is possible

00:42:30.840 that the

00:42:32.800 mother or

00:42:33.220 the father

00:42:33.700 is loving

00:42:34.660 a little

00:42:35.000 bit more

00:42:35.580 this one

00:42:36.700 or the

00:42:37.080 other one

00:42:37.640 of the

00:42:38.400 children

00:42:38.860 on the

00:42:40.600 school

00:42:41.520 as a

00:42:42.940 teacher

00:42:43.320 surely

00:42:43.900 if you

00:42:44.660 have

00:42:44.860 40

00:42:45.380 pupils

00:42:46.620 it's

00:42:48.080 naturally

00:42:48.660 to have

00:42:50.040 more sympathy

00:42:51.020 for the

00:42:51.560 one

00:42:51.800 and less

00:42:53.560 for the

00:42:53.900 other

00:42:54.160 but in

00:42:55.220 this

00:42:55.480 position

00:42:56.020 that

00:42:57.180 father or

00:42:57.960 mother

00:42:58.360 or

00:42:59.060 teacher

00:42:59.480 or

00:43:00.280 pastor

00:43:01.520 shepherd

00:43:02.440 you must

00:43:03.740 overcome

00:43:04.480 your own

00:43:05.940 limits

00:43:06.840 you must

00:43:07.440 be

00:43:08.920 correct

00:43:09.960 and equal

00:43:10.980 to

00:43:11.540 every

00:43:12.160 body

00:43:13.320 in this

00:43:14.100 very

00:43:14.360 place

00:43:14.940 where

00:43:15.540 Pope

00:43:16.240 Benedict

00:43:16.960 while he

00:43:18.060 was

00:43:18.180 Cardinal

00:43:18.420 Ratzinger

00:43:18.860 lived

00:43:19.340 he did

00:43:20.900 something

00:43:21.400 that

00:43:22.420 American

00:43:23.340 pro-lifers

00:43:24.000 will always

00:43:24.680 remember

00:43:25.160 he was in

00:43:26.620 the position

00:43:27.220 which you

00:43:27.680 later held

00:43:28.440 as the

00:43:29.540 head of the

00:43:30.100 congregation

00:43:30.520 for the

00:43:30.820 doctrine of

00:43:31.220 faith

00:43:31.420 the year

00:43:31.820 was

00:43:32.040 2004

00:43:32.960 the

00:43:34.120 bishops

00:43:34.480 of the

00:43:34.980 United

00:43:35.200 States

00:43:35.680 were debating

00:43:36.360 the question

00:43:37.060 of communion

00:43:38.120 for pro-abortion

00:43:38.940 politicians

00:43:39.520 and under

00:43:40.680 the direction

00:43:41.120 of Pope

00:43:41.580 John Paul

00:43:42.000 II

00:43:42.400 Cardinal

00:43:43.460 Ratzinger

00:43:44.120 wrote to

00:43:45.420 the bishops

00:43:46.040 the letter

00:43:47.040 worthiness

00:43:47.500 to receive

00:43:47.900 communion

00:43:48.200 which

00:43:48.480 is sort

00:43:49.420 of

00:43:49.600 not talked

00:43:50.400 about

00:43:50.680 it was

00:43:51.020 oppressed

00:43:51.420 by the

00:43:51.980 Cardinal

00:43:53.060 McCarrick

00:43:54.820 typically

00:43:55.360 it was

00:43:56.740 it was

00:43:57.420 sent

00:43:58.440 officially

00:43:59.640 from Rome

00:44:00.440 in the

00:44:01.560 name of

00:44:02.180 Cardinal

00:44:02.540 Ratzinger

00:44:02.880 for John

00:44:03.400 Paul II

00:44:03.700 to intervene

00:44:04.700 in the

00:44:04.980 debate

00:44:05.380 over whether

00:44:06.340 pro-abortion

00:44:06.800 politicians

00:44:07.240 should be

00:44:07.660 denied

00:44:07.960 Holy Communion

00:44:08.380 and the

00:44:08.760 letter

00:44:09.080 said

00:44:09.960 they must

00:44:11.420 be denied

00:44:12.400 Holy Communion

00:44:13.240 by the

00:44:13.520 Ministry of

00:44:13.840 Communion

00:44:14.080 after of

00:44:14.580 course

00:44:14.700 they've

00:44:14.860 been warned

00:44:15.200 and so

00:44:15.460 on

00:44:15.600 but

00:44:16.120 they

00:44:16.260 must

00:44:16.740 be

00:44:17.000 and we

00:44:18.300 received

00:44:19.260 from

00:44:19.680 several

00:44:20.640 of the

00:44:21.160 other

00:44:21.500 bishops

00:44:21.900 who are

00:44:22.460 on that

00:44:22.940 committee

00:44:23.220 with

00:44:23.640 Cardinal

00:44:24.020 McCarrick

00:44:24.400 they were

00:44:25.240 very upset

00:44:25.900 that Cardinal

00:44:26.520 McCarrick

00:44:26.880 didn't show

00:44:27.820 them the

00:44:28.160 letter

00:44:28.380 so they

00:44:29.340 had a

00:44:29.820 response

00:44:30.160 but

00:44:30.400 that

00:44:31.060 letter

00:44:31.420 never

00:44:32.160 really

00:44:32.860 made it

00:44:33.520 public

00:44:34.280 and so

00:44:35.600 it

00:44:35.780 leaves on

00:44:36.500 in the

00:44:36.800 legacy

00:44:37.180 of

00:44:37.880 pro-lifers

00:44:38.780 did you

00:44:39.220 know

00:44:39.420 about it

00:44:39.740 at the

00:44:39.960 time

00:44:40.200 and what's

00:44:40.680 your take

00:44:41.040 on it

00:44:41.320 now

00:44:41.620 versus

00:44:42.360 McCarrick

00:44:43.000 wanted to

00:44:43.440 be the

00:44:43.920 big

00:44:45.120 friend

00:44:45.500 of the

00:44:46.040 politicians

00:44:47.500 of one

00:44:48.500 party

00:44:49.080 and so

00:44:49.680 indeed

00:44:50.960 didn't like

00:44:52.820 to make

00:44:54.000 this

00:44:54.240 confrontation

00:44:54.860 in favor

00:44:56.280 of

00:44:57.300 life

00:44:58.120 was more

00:44:58.720 interested

00:44:59.160 in his

00:44:59.600 own

00:44:59.840 position

00:45:00.380 to be

00:45:00.720 beloved

00:45:01.200 of

00:45:01.420 everybody

00:45:02.040 to be

00:45:02.460 the

00:45:02.620 darling

00:45:02.940 of

00:45:03.180 everybody

00:45:03.760 and not

00:45:05.120 to give

00:45:05.580 witness

00:45:06.220 what

00:45:07.040 an

00:45:07.760 epical

00:45:08.520 change

00:45:09.320 that

00:45:09.620 would

00:45:09.880 have

00:45:10.020 made

00:45:10.440 if

00:45:11.460 back

00:45:11.940 in

00:45:12.140 2004

00:45:13.040 the

00:45:13.900 bishops

00:45:14.300 of the

00:45:14.740 United

00:45:14.920 States

00:45:15.280 would have

00:45:15.640 heeded

00:45:16.100 the

00:45:16.440 will

00:45:16.820 of the

00:45:17.640 Holy

00:45:17.820 Father

00:45:18.240 John

00:45:18.660 Paul II

00:45:19.060 and of

00:45:19.920 Cardinal

00:45:20.160 Ratzinger

00:45:20.460 later became

00:45:21.260 Pope Benedict

00:45:22.120 the

00:45:22.640 contradiction

00:45:23.260 to be

00:45:24.020 a

00:45:25.360 Catholic

00:45:25.740 in

00:45:26.500 what

00:45:26.740 position

00:45:27.320 ever

00:45:27.760 and

00:45:29.040 to

00:45:29.440 be

00:45:30.660 in

00:45:30.860 favor

00:45:31.180 of

00:45:31.500 abortion

00:45:32.140 is

00:45:32.360 absolutely

00:45:32.920 a

00:45:33.980 contradiction

00:45:34.560 you cannot

00:45:35.060 say

00:45:36.520 yeah

00:45:36.780 we make

00:45:37.560 the laws

00:45:38.280 for

00:45:38.540 everybody

00:45:39.100 but

00:45:39.980 they have

00:45:40.340 the

00:45:40.500 responsibility

00:45:41.240 to

00:45:42.920 fight

00:45:43.340 for the

00:45:43.920 life

00:45:45.020 also

00:45:45.360 in the

00:45:45.960 parliament

00:45:46.440 in the

00:45:47.140 public

00:45:47.540 and not

00:45:47.980 only

00:45:48.420 because

00:45:49.080 they are

00:45:49.460 Catholics

00:45:49.940 but

00:45:50.440 every

00:45:50.840 man

00:45:51.980 of good

00:45:53.080 will

00:45:53.440 of

00:45:54.840 humanistic

00:45:56.960 orientation

00:45:58.120 knows

00:45:59.560 that

00:46:00.060 there is

00:46:00.700 no reason

00:46:01.440 and no

00:46:02.840 power

00:46:03.280 of us

00:46:03.940 to

00:46:04.480 declare

00:46:05.720 another

00:46:06.300 person

00:46:06.820 is less

00:46:07.380 worthy

00:46:08.020 than me

00:46:08.580 and I

00:46:10.320 have the

00:46:10.640 right to

00:46:11.100 live

00:46:11.360 and I

00:46:12.360 decide

00:46:12.920 if the

00:46:13.240 other

00:46:13.440 person

00:46:13.840 have to 0.99

00:46:14.280 die 0.99

00:46:15.220 absolutely

00:46:16.240 clear

00:46:17.200 for your

00:46:18.720 rational

00:46:19.740 understanding

00:46:20.620 but

00:46:21.620 the

00:46:22.220 more

00:46:22.620 if you

00:46:23.440 believe

00:46:23.980 in the

00:46:24.340 word

00:46:24.540 of God

00:46:24.960 and God

00:46:25.380 as a

00:46:25.680 creator

00:46:26.040 of every

00:46:27.440 life

00:46:28.860 and you

00:46:29.180 cannot

00:46:29.480 receive the

00:46:30.480 holy communion

00:46:31.140 Jesus Christ

00:46:32.100 the son

00:46:32.980 of God

00:46:33.440 who became

00:46:34.200 man

00:46:34.660 died

00:46:35.240 on the

00:46:35.620 cross

00:46:35.940 risen

00:46:36.500 in the

00:46:37.120 resurrection

00:46:37.620 and so

00:46:38.400 and then

00:46:39.160 our

00:46:39.900 savior

00:46:40.520 and in

00:46:41.620 the same

00:46:42.040 time

00:46:42.580 to give

00:46:43.820 the allowance 1.00

00:46:44.420 to kill 0.89

00:46:45.320 persons 1.00

00:46:46.440 who are

00:46:47.020 created

00:46:47.720 according

00:46:48.700 to the

00:46:49.080 likeness

00:46:49.620 the

00:46:50.280 image

00:46:50.600 of God

00:46:51.160 is

00:46:52.160 obvious

00:46:53.040 that

00:46:53.320 is

00:46:53.480 the

00:46:53.760 absolute

00:46:54.100 contradiction

00:46:54.960 Eminence

00:46:55.880 I want

00:46:56.400 to thank

00:46:56.720 you

00:46:56.920 on behalf

00:46:58.040 of

00:46:58.240 LifeSite

00:46:58.760 and all

00:47:00.060 the pro-lifers

00:47:00.560 in America

00:47:00.980 for your

00:47:01.640 great standing

00:47:02.920 for the truth

00:47:03.540 of the faith

00:47:03.980 on life

00:47:04.440 and for your

00:47:05.860 graciousness

00:47:06.400 in having us

00:47:06.960 here

00:47:07.180 Lord be with

00:47:08.220 you

00:47:08.540 and with

00:47:09.060 your spirit

00:47:09.580 may almighty

00:47:10.240 God bless

00:47:10.940 you

00:47:11.280 the father

00:47:12.020 and the

00:47:12.660 son

00:47:12.980 and the

00:47:13.580 holy spirit

00:47:14.340 Amen

00:47:44.340 Amen

00:47:46.340 Amen

00:47:47.340 Amen

00:47:48.340 Amen

00:47:49.340 Amen

00:47:50.340 Amen

The John-Henry Westen Show - January 11, 2023

Cardinal Muller Exclusive： Will Progressive Leadership Destroy The Church？

Episode Stats

Summary

Transcript