The John-Henry Westen Show - August 19, 2026


Why the Church Stopped Teaching Wives Must Obey: Tim Gordon’s Nuclear Take

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
This Air Force Colonel, PhD Chemist & Pro-Life Champion Is Here to Kick You Into High Gear Traditional Carmelite Nun: ‘Catholic Bishops vs Queer Minded Bishops’

Episode Stats


Length

52 minutes

Words per minute

167.73

Word count

8,819

Sentence count

504

Harmful content

Misogyny

35

sentences flagged

Toxicity

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

47

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 With this particular second type of killing, it's really, really important that people
00:00:04 understand this because it debunks the entire anti-death penalty narrative in principle from
00:00:10 97 to the present day. Well, my friends, I've got a very interesting guest for you today.
00:00:17 He is probably the most controversial Catholic podcaster out there. His name is Timothy J.
00:00:24 Gordon. And most controversially, he takes on feminism like no one else. In fact, he's wrote
00:00:31 the book called Patriarchy. And his film released now of a number of months ago, is released on the
00:00:37 Candace Owens network. It's called What a Woman Is, in response to Matt Walsh's What is a Woman.
00:00:42 It's fascinating that he has created such controversy, because what really it's based on
00:00:50 is a reading of the traditional catechism on the duties of husbands and wives.
00:00:58 Let's begin, as we always do, with the Son of the Cross.
00:01:01 In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. Amen.
00:01:05 I'm the author of five books.
00:01:08 Catholic Republic is my first, and The Case for Patriarchy,
00:01:11 which is what that movie is based upon that you're talking about,
00:01:15 what a woman is, are two of my five books.
00:01:17 I've been in the game for about eight years on YouTube. First year I was doing it was with
00:01:24 Taylor Marshall on his channel on that TNT show of 2018-2019 fame, the last seven years.
00:01:31 I'm very findable on YouTube on my own channel, Timothy Gordon. Rules for Retrogrades is the
00:01:37 title of the podcast. I'm currently making a second documentary on my first book, a second
00:01:43 documentary total on my first book, Catholic Republic. There will be some big headliner
00:01:48 names and a big headliner distributor for that one too. Question 27 of the Roman Catechism,
00:01:54 the duties of a wife. And I'll say this, the first half is not quite explosive like the back half of
00:02:03 it. On the other hand, the duties of a wife are thus enumerated by the Prince of the Apostles.
00:02:08 let wives be subject to their husbands that if any believe not the word they also may without
00:02:14 the word be won by the conversation of the wives while they behold your chaste conversation with 0.65
00:02:19 fear whose adorning let it not be that outward plating of the hair or wearing of gold or putting
00:02:25 on of apparel but the hidden man of the heart in that which is not corruptible of a quiet and
00:02:31 meek spirit which is in the sight of god of great price for after this manner in the old time
00:02:38 the holy women also who trusted in God adorned themselves being in subjection unto their own 0.83
00:02:43 husbands. Here's where it becomes more interesting. Even as Sarah obeyed Abraham, calling him Lord,
00:02:52 it should also be a principal study of theirs to train up their children in the practice of 0.57
00:02:56 religion and to take particular care of the domestic concerns. Unless compelled by necessity
00:03:02 to go out, they should willingly keep themselves at home and should never venture to leave home
00:03:07 without the permission of their husbands. Again, and in this, the conjugal union chiefly consists, 0.87
00:03:14 let them always remember that next to God, they're to love no one more than their husband,
00:03:19 to esteem no one more highly, yielding to him in all things, not inconsistent with Christian piety,
00:03:25 the most willing and cheerful obedience. Okay, then. Well, that's going to ruffle some feathers
00:03:32 to say the least um to unpack that last part a little bit even the concept of
00:03:40 beyond god to love your husband first sounds weird as odd as that may seem because i think
00:03:47 most would say well your children obviously when you were doing the film i think father
00:03:53 ripiger actually pointed to these teachings uh saying them very plainly i'm sure you got a lot
00:04:00 of pushback? What's what's sort of the main pushback for you, as you found as you were
00:04:06 going through this on these issues here? You might not believe it. But what we received
00:04:11 over the last several months is just email after email after email of conversion by by women just 0.99
00:04:19 saying, wow, this is so right. I've started living this way. And everything seemed to fit after 30
00:04:25 years, 20 years, 10 years, a couple years, the pushback, I have to go on like Reddit boards and
00:04:32 stuff, which I don't like doing anyway, you know, never read your negative clippings or really your
00:04:36 positive. Neither is good for the soul. But I not too many critics have reached out and offered even
00:04:44 the usual calm box or chat box critique. Everyone who's who's seen it, that's reached out has been
00:04:51 And it's been many, many dozens, even in the triple figures, have said this just works.
00:04:59 It's so obvious, but I didn't see it before.
00:05:02 It's like some sort of conversion chamber where it might sound strange before, like any sort of emperor's new clothes, obvious truth of not only scripture, but just natural law.
00:05:12 This is something that everyone kind of knows in their heart.
00:05:15 But until they allow themselves to say the word, they're not undone by the spell of feminism.
00:05:22 I mean, the idea that, you know, for a Christian especially, that the husband is the leader and that he should be loved next to God and that he is the householder and that a wife owes him obedience is sort of like saying two and two is four.
00:05:38 and yet Christians everywhere, because they've kind of come under the spell,
00:05:44 confront it at some decisive moment in their formation. And for a lot of people,
00:05:48 it's been 60 year olds saying, you know, wow, Tim, I've lived this way my whole life,
00:05:53 the feminist way. And, and, um, I, I guess this is just really obvious, isn't it? It works.
00:06:00 Do you think that Candace's endorsement has helped that way? Cause I mean, I'm,
00:06:05 I'm pretty stunned to hear the witness testimony that that's just,
00:06:09 that's pretty incredible.
00:06:10 I haven't read her,
00:06:11 her book on feminism.
00:06:14 I think it's a few notches back from mine,
00:06:18 from what,
00:06:18 what,
00:06:18 what's been indicated,
00:06:19 you know,
00:06:20 her book called make him a sandwich.
00:06:22 So I don't know if she agree.
00:06:24 I mean,
00:06:25 good for her that she's willing to platform views.
00:06:27 She disagrees with some,
00:06:29 and I know she,
00:06:30 she really does hate full form, 1.00
00:06:33 third wave feminism. 1.00
00:06:35 and aspects of second and first wave feminism.
00:06:37 So I really do appreciate her giving a platform to it.
00:06:40 But she hasn't, aside from, I think, two mentions on the show,
00:06:44 she hasn't pushed it all that hard.
00:06:45 She said, it's up on my site.
00:06:47 And she's been gracious in the way that you would be
00:06:50 if you agreed to platform something.
00:06:53 I have a personal and a business relationship with her husband,
00:06:56 and he really liked the way the film looked.
00:06:58 And he's a good friend, good man.
00:07:00 So I think they kind of agreed to do it while disagreeing,
00:07:03 disagreeing, at least Candace while disagreeing with portions of it. And she did put, she's like,
00:07:08 can I put a disclaimer at the beginning of this? And I was like, of course, but she hasn't pushed
00:07:13 really that hard. I think it got two mentions on her show. She let people know it was up. She did
00:07:17 play a clip, which I appreciate, but, and I, you know, if she disagrees that heartily, then I
00:07:23 wouldn't expect more. So I don't know exactly, um, what it would have done if, as I kind of,
00:07:30 you know, you get these stars in your eyes when a project is new and fresh and you have the highest
00:07:34 hopes for it. You know, if she was talking about it every day, even for two weeks, the way she
00:07:40 really she's a passionate person, she gets on a trail and she doesn't leave the scent. I thought
00:07:46 she might do that with that. And if in that case, all of the many, many already conservative house
00:07:51 wives who comprise most of her listeners, man, that would have been really interesting. But that 0.95
00:07:58 that didn't really eventuate. Lots and lots of people have watched this, bought it and watched
00:08:02 it. We made it only $1.99, but it never achieved the virality that it would have, you know, if,
00:08:08 if things were optimal, if conditions were optimal. So it's hard to fully answer that question.
00:08:12 Right. But you've got hundreds of testimonies. That's what's stunning to me of, of people who
00:08:16 have tried it the other way and it works. Now that's just a really neat, it's an experiential
00:08:24 thing we give it a shot and it actually works so that's really it is the teaching of the church
00:08:29 but they're not easy things the whole notion of obey is really weird because it's as as your
00:08:38 film points out it's it's beyond well of course when he makes sense we obey and then when we
00:08:45 disagree we have a discussion all of which is not forbidden but it's just after that discussion
00:08:52 Where do we go when it comes down to now whose way is it that's going to take precedence?
00:09:00 Whose way is it that we're going to follow right now?
00:09:02 And that's the challenge.
00:09:04 So this idea of obedience is beyond where he's right.
00:09:09 In other words, where he makes sense to her or where he is even right in terms of this direction we should take with our route for the trip, let's say, even if it's wrong, apart from the difference, the difference being where there's sin.
00:09:31 If anyone asks you to sin, whether he's an angel or whatever, anyone in authority, the pope or anything, you refuse.
00:09:40 But this direction from the husband is to be taken regardless of right or wrong in an earthly sense, not a moral sense.
00:09:47 Is that, am I reading that correctly?
00:09:49 Yeah, of course.
00:09:50 Of course.
00:09:51 I mean, when you consider, when I consider the alternative, I think it's preposterous. 0.91
00:09:56 Like if you'd read a woman with a job, 76 percent of Catholic women from the previous generations worked at a job, if her boss gave her an order and, you know, let's say she's the VP or something to the president of the company. 0.80
00:10:15 Well, if the president, who's still her boss, she still has this dignified role and her opinion counts, at least as a matter of first impression, or she can say, I don't know, and push back once. 0.74
00:10:27 If the president says, no, no, that's a good suggestion, I appreciate, but we're really going to do it this way.
00:10:33 Think of how odd, what a clown world or through the looking glass kind of vignette this presents to show everyone being staggered, shocked that she's got to do what her boss says ultimately.
00:10:50 No one pretends that this hypothetical woman who's vice president is infantilized or stripped of her dignity or anything like that. 0.91
00:11:00 And this is her freaking boss, you know, cue up G.K. Chesterton and all the paradoxes that he was saying in the early 20th century about women are willing to – working women are willing to listen to their bosses but not their husbands.
00:11:13 This is staggering for people. 0.95
00:11:14 I really don't – in all honesty, I don't agree that any of – that the Roman catechism contains any hard truths at all.
00:11:22 I mean it's a hard truth to, you know, the Trinity or maybe the bread of life discourse.
00:11:28 We have to consume our Savior, body, blood, soul, divinity. 0.63
00:11:33 But to say that a woman must, at the end of the day, follow her boss to whom she swore obedient on the marital altar is so in accord with nature and so in accord with the Bible. 0.67
00:11:47 And even all seven of the first 20th century popes say exactly what the Roman catechism said.
00:11:54 It's actually not such a hard teaching when you re-look at it. 0.99
00:11:58 Once you've had the conversion and you just say, wow, this is the witchcraft of not only
00:12:03 feminism, but just mimetic desire, you know, you've been outwinked, everyone out there.
00:12:08 So that's, that's what I would say.
00:12:10 It's just, it makes so much sense.
00:12:11 You have to follow your boss.
00:12:13 Such an interesting comparison to the working world.
00:12:16 Cause that, that just switches the focus.
00:12:21 Almost everyone can relate to that.
00:12:23 Of course you follow the directions of your boss.
00:12:27 you don't want to get fired you want to have your job that only makes sense and yet with regard to
00:12:33 the husband-wife relationship is the mindset as you said in the beginning for like 99 point whatever
00:12:40 percent is completely different now it is and i'm not saying that the the it is like a you know
00:12:48 paid relationship no no one's saying that but it's very true that in fact even over and above
00:12:56 a boss you would owe obedience to your husband as a wife so that's just that's that's pretty
00:13:05 stunning there are notions from both the enlightenment and the reformation that make this 0.56
00:13:09 in my view you know converted view two and two is four simple like that reductive seem less so
00:13:17 and i would say one of them is that's i think a great analog that helps people to see
00:13:22 is the very puritanical wasp notion of the parent who's talking to his teenager and says,
00:13:31 I'm your father, not your friend.
00:13:33 This is utterly, utterly anti-Aristotelian.
00:13:37 It's anti-Thomistic in the sense that St. Thomas and Aristotle say,
00:13:42 no, the best friendships in life are friendships not of peers, but of unequals.
00:13:48 Aristotle argues this, I think, in the seventh book of the Nicomachean Ethics, and he repeats it in the third book of the Politics, and St. Thomas gives it as full endorsement.
00:13:57 Best friendships are that between a king, meaning in like a polis, and his subject, you know, friendship of unequal.
00:14:05 Father and his son, best friendship of unequals, and a husband and his wife. 0.51
00:14:11 So you can form these close friendships that waspy people after the Enlightenment and the Reformation christen or sort of black christen with the notion of egalitarianism.
00:14:23 They sprinkle that poison water of egalitarianism all over and they say, well, peer friendships, those are the best ones. 0.97
00:14:29 Those are the ones informing modern psychology and DSM-5.
00:14:33 You know, you get into trouble with your friends.
00:14:35 A friend is just a lover of your soul for Aristotle and St. Thomas and the church.
00:14:40 And the best friends are the ones who love you so much.
00:14:44 Like a king with the subjects, it, of course, comes from the model of King Jesus.
00:14:48 And a father with his son, you would never, as a knowledgeable Catholic, say, I'm your father, not your friend.
00:14:53 I'm your best friend.
00:14:55 You know, your friends want to have a good time with you.
00:14:57 Some of them might survive the challenge and become type three Aristotelian friends where you actually develop virtue together.
00:15:03 But that's all I care about.
00:15:05 And, of course, St. Thomas will say of these three examples, he'll imply that there's only one of these that grows, these friendships of unequals, that grows into a single body, you know, one head members, and that is husband-wife.
00:15:23 So Jesus raises it to the dignity of sacrament at Cana,
00:15:27 and therefore it's even a holier, closer, more intimate best friendship between husband and wife.
00:15:34 Some of the red pill guys mock this notion as feminist.
00:15:38 It's not under the proper heading.
00:15:39 It's actually just patriarchal and Christian.
00:15:42 You are the best friends, but it's a friendship of unequals,
00:15:45 and you're closer than even a king and a subject or even a father and his son.
00:15:49 And then all the conditions for the possibility of understanding, I think, are actually set.
00:15:55 I get it.
00:15:56 Living that out in today's world, even once you ascribe to this truth, it's tough anyway.
00:16:06 The milieu that we live in, because everybody fights it, everything you see in media everywhere
00:16:13 is opposed to this.
00:16:15 In fact, it's the exact opposite, if you will.
00:16:17 How do you live this out?
00:16:18 I know you're a dad. You've eight children, if I'm correct. Yep. And you've been married now,
00:16:24 what, 20, what is it? You're at 30 years already or no? No, I'm coming up to 21. 30 would be cool,
00:16:30 but 21. I'm so sorry. I'm at 32. So you're in the midst of doing this. You're living this in a way.
00:16:38 Where do you move along the road to getting to that oneness? Well, I think the point of departure
00:16:44 also lies in this fact in intellectual history of the world that Christianity of course Roman
00:16:54 Catholicism was literally the first worldview I don't mean religion I mean worldview inclusive
00:16:59 of secular philosophies by which a woman selects her husband and this is not only determinative
00:17:07 not only it's not her dad doing it or her parents setting her up or some some um some
00:17:13 institutional mandate. But it's invalid if she herself did not choose the man. The man chooses
00:17:21 the wife, the wife chooses the man. And there's no one else in sacramental Christianity, in Roman 0.97
00:17:28 Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy also. If there was any more than those two rendering the decision
00:17:35 for themselves, I love you, you love me, let's go get married. Man picks woman, woman picks man, 1.00
00:17:42 then it's null and void, right? It's literally, that's the safest way to procure an annulment is 0.99
00:17:49 if you have some third party that's deciding, not the parents, not the father. This isn't some
00:17:55 bizarre, you know, side quest of patriarchy. It's literally the woman and the man choose each other. 0.71
00:18:02 And the reason I'm leaning into this so much, John Henry, is because when folks who have been
00:18:08 brainwashed by all the brainwash out there assume that patriarchy is inherently heavy-handed
00:18:14 they aren't understanding that this is a woman who yes has to obey her husband and everything
00:18:22 aside from categorical sin so even his his prop she thinks probably imprudent commands prudent
00:18:30 you know fronisist prudence won't be revealed until the end of time but you can say this is
00:18:35 probably dumb, but she's going to obey even his probabilistically imprudent commands until the 0.93
00:18:42 end of their marriage. But she gets to pick her boss. So if a woman finds it extremely off-putting 0.99
00:18:50 to be micromanaged, then don't marry a micromanager. Don't marry a heavy-handed guy.
00:18:58 And this is the condition for the possibility that is the, I'd say, the logical equivalent
00:19:04 of what we say to pro-abortion people, you know, they're like, wait a minute, what if
00:19:09 you get in this situation and you just, you know, you just can't have the baby, you have
00:19:15 to have your career, you have to have more money, you have to be able to abort.
00:19:19 You're like, you're skipping the important first step.
00:19:22 You chose to have intercourse with someone, right? 1.00
00:19:26 The woman gets to choose. 1.00
00:19:28 Christianity is the world philosophy where the woman gets to choose her boss. 0.98
00:19:35 So this is like what I have seven daughters. 0.98
00:19:38 This is what I tell all of them.
00:19:40 It's, you know, first thing, they've got to be a good, he's got to be a good man.
00:19:43 That's the most important thing, a good Catholic man.
00:19:45 But secondly, pick for your temperament.
00:19:48 Like if this guy annoys you, you got to go the distance.
00:19:52 You know, this might be 50 years.
00:19:54 You got to go 15 rounds.
00:19:57 And you have to pick someone you're wild about.
00:19:59 And you're not going to be wild about someone that if you like micromanagement, he's really laid back or vice versa.
00:20:05 If he's really a micromanager and you're laid back, you're going to be put off.
00:20:09 You also have to really be crazy about the way they look, the way they walk, the way they talk.
00:20:14 You want the most special one for you. 1.00
00:20:16 And again, kind of like the abortion argument, it's really a very silly pro-abortion argument for a woman to say, well, what can she do? 0.75
00:20:24 You skip that first step so that ab initio, if we block the first step, you chose to have sex though. 0.94
00:20:31 That's why this is still operative under the rules of self-determination.
00:20:36 It's like you drop a rock off a cliff, say, oh, this rock was always going to hit the bottom.
00:20:41 It's like, but you chose to drop it, right?
00:20:43 That first act matters. 0.99
00:20:45 A woman who chooses to marry a man, you are. 0.99
00:20:48 Now you go from a position of relative sovereignty, if you're 20 or 21 or 22, you got to pick anyone in the world you wanted. 0.93
00:20:56 You got to deny any suitors who ask you.
00:21:00 You're like, no, that's not the right temperament for me.
00:21:02 No, I'm just not attracted to that dude.
00:21:04 No, that's not the right temperament for me.
00:21:06 But when you find it, you're picking your boss.
00:21:08 So it's actually far, far, far, far better than a typical job where you don't get to pick your boss. 0.99
00:21:13 If you go start working, bagging groceries, your boss is, if he's mean, you're stuck with it, and you'll obey everything he does, you know, young women.
00:21:22 If he's nice, you lucked into it.
00:21:24 That's not what it is with marriage.
00:21:25 You pick someone that is going to be the best boss for you, knowing, once we start telling our daughters once again, that you're going to have to obey everything.
00:21:35 So take that decision really seriously, but you're still operating under self-determination.
00:21:40 my dear friends the mother of god is calling you to her shrine at fatima where she performed
00:21:48 the most outstanding public miracle in human history to warn us of the calamity the world
00:21:55 and the church are undergoing right now join world-renowned prophecy experts xavier eral
00:22:01 ted flynn father paul kramer and your favorite life site personalities father charles murr father
00:22:06 Altman, Frank Wright, and myself, along with special guest Cary Brajean Buller, for a powerful
00:22:14 conference dedicated to Our Lady Mediatrics of All Graces.
00:22:17 November 11th and 12th, stand where Jacinta, Francisco, and Lucia once played.
00:22:24 The very well where the angel of peace, the guardian angel of Portugal, appeared in 1916,
00:22:31 urging prayers and sacrifices for the conversion of sinners.
00:22:34 Walk the paths with us between the children's homes
00:22:38 and see how they lived in simple poverty.
00:22:41 Pray at the saints' tombs.
00:22:44 Join the breathtaking candlelight procession
00:22:47 right where Our Lady appeared,
00:22:49 giving us both the warning and the solution
00:22:52 to the crisis she predicted would come.
00:22:55 Stay at the beautiful Divine Hotel
00:22:57 just a gentle 15-minute walk from the shrine.
00:23:01 Savour the gorgeous land of Portugal
00:23:03 where our lady promised that faith would always be retained. Taste the famous pastries dedicated
00:23:09 to the sacred heart of Jesus. Stock up on rosaries and sacred gifts before Christmas.
00:23:14 And don't miss the unforgettable Fatto Music evening. Seats are limited. Book by August 30th
00:23:20 and lock in the best seats for every event. This is more than just a conference. It's your
00:23:26 invitation from heaven to make a pilgrimage of reparation for the attempt to strip our mother
00:23:31 of her titles. We will honor her as co-redemptrix and mediatrix of all graces in the very place she
00:23:38 came to warn us, to warn our generation. The time of fulfillment is upon us. Let's show her that
00:23:47 there are still some of her children who love and venerate her. Let's answer our lady's call
00:23:53 together. Seats are limited, so reserve now. In the fallout, I think, of a lot of this discussion,
00:24:03 you got into some controversial areas, even for most people, and it was, I think you called it
00:24:09 diaper gate at one time. Your thoughts on men should not be changing diapers, for the most part,
00:24:15 there's exceptions, but your thought was they shouldn't be. Explain that for us.
00:24:20 Well, a few grounding tidbits of context for one thing. 0.84
00:24:24 This came from mega Lily White, who's a good Catholic, really, really good Catholic woman. 0.99
00:24:30 Very likable young woman who tweeted like, look, I don't know, have the right quote in front of me.
00:24:36 But what she said is I find it really unattractive.
00:24:39 I think there's something really odd if a man is changing diapers for she meant for infants.
00:24:46 And I defended her, you know, and he was she was kind of in the process of.
00:24:50 of RCIA or whatever, OCIA at the time and coming in. So I was the better known Catholic entity and
00:24:55 I defended her and everyone thought it was my tweet. But I'm like, yeah, no, I'll defend that
00:24:59 then. I'll still defend it now. Her point was functional gender dysphoria. And this is why we
00:25:05 covered it. She's in what a woman is, really delightful person. Her point was she's not even
00:25:11 a provocateur. She's just a really, really pleasant young married woman with children. 1.00
00:25:16 You know, functional gender dysphoria. What's the expectation? Kind of like a man who's a layabout who expects his wife to do his job to, you know, to go in for him. Let's say he works from home and he just sleeps in and expects the wife to get up and, you know, log the first two hours for him from his home office or something. 0.97
00:25:41 that's what mega and we've talked about it a million times since then that's what she sees
00:25:46 everywhere uh around her in she she was living in another country i'm distinctly living in the west
00:25:52 that's what i see here that's what my friend will nolan was saying he's seeing in great britain
00:25:57 that's what my friend uh mike pentile was saying yeah this is everywhere in canada so we've checked
00:26:03 and everyone kind of knows you know you can believe us or your own lying eyes you know
00:26:08 So it's not one of those cases. We all know this is what's going on. Because of feminism, women are testing, you know, S-testing men, I'm not sure what we can say here, to see what they can get away with.
00:26:25 And widely speaking, it became the cultural norm that the, you know, to use the analogy, 0.79
00:26:33 the husband, you know, his alarm goes off, he yells at the wife, get up, clock, log my
00:26:38 first two hours from the home office.
00:26:39 If you don't do it, you're lazy. 1.00
00:26:42 Except in reverse, you know, women are everywhere having the men do the jobs of women. 0.83
00:26:47 And if a man doesn't want to do the job of infant care, which is distinct, I mean, talk 0.89
00:26:52 about Aristotle or Plato or any of the sane elders of bygone ages. And they're just like,
00:27:00 what was going on? That is more dysphoric than a man in, you know, women's dress. That's just 0.91
00:27:08 a crazy person, like we say in the film. But a woman who expects a man to do infant care, 1.00
00:27:14 like regularly, that's insane. Now, of course, Mega in her original tweet, me defending her, 0.95
00:27:21 weren't talking about in some exceptional circumstance, if the wife is really, really
00:27:27 sick and needs the husband to change the infant's diapers, men are just these big lumbering
00:27:34 oaths. They're really, really small. And what we showed in the movie was social media phenomenon
00:27:40 to substantiate what we're saying, that we're not talking about the exceptional instances.
00:27:45 I have changed a couple of my babies out of eight babies that we've had when my wife was very sick.
00:27:55 But we're talking about regular occurring man acting as the wet nurse to a baby. 0.80
00:28:03 And it's really absurd.
00:28:04 So that is in that segment of the movie you'll probably remember.
00:28:08 They're talking about changing the rules, which is what functional gender dysphoria is all about. 0.58
00:28:14 confusing the sexes, making them hate their own sex and their own role. Women's bodies are, 1.00
00:28:20 for heaven's sakes, literally make them into wet nurses. And this co-attends the primary 1.00
00:28:27 goal of feminism, which was to get women out of the home, particularly when they're infants, 1.00
00:28:32 but really, more broadly speaking, all the time, and just get them away from their small or 1.00
00:28:38 growing children. I have an infant in the house, as most traditional people do. If you always have
00:28:43 little kids around. I mean, I don't even know how women do the working, but I'm pretty much not 1.00
00:28:49 around the smaller kids alone until they're one, two, three, then, you know, three, you start 0.74
00:28:56 spending more one-on-one time with them to, you know, when the dad plays with them, I don't even 1.00
00:29:00 know how working women are pulling this off. You just have to feed them so much when they're small. 1.00
00:29:06 We have really small babies. We got to, you know, my wife is intent on fattening them up and,
00:29:10 you know feeding and changing go hand in hand so a lot of our audience would be non-working moms 0.83
00:29:18 who who are at home with their kids but they would particularly the ones who would have like we had
00:29:23 we had seven children in nine years then we lost three and then we had another one but
00:29:28 you know they're all older now but in those beginning years when I was working from home too
00:29:34 because I've been doing life site forever now there were a lot of times when I had to help out
00:29:39 with childcare because there was so many little ones and my wife was either breastfeeding and or
00:29:47 doing something that was totally occupying with one. And there was sort of an emergency with the
00:29:52 others. Um, you're not talking about not being able to do that or are you? Well, this is the
00:29:57 first thing that always happens. You know, people will, cause I have a call in segment at the end
00:30:01 of my, my show, you know, rules for retrogrades on YouTube and people will go, well, does this
00:30:06 apply to me. I mean, it's kind of just like saying, Hey, you know, the, the old meme, you say
00:30:11 water's wet. It's just a truth of the universe. Like the Roman catechism is saying here. And
00:30:16 people are like, well, what about in this case, if you go to the surface of Mars, you bring a
00:30:21 microwave, you, you try, you know, you dry out a cup of water and it theoretically isn't supposed
00:30:26 to, I'm just announcing water is wet. I'm not, I'm not, um, doing the dirty work of what you
00:30:32 learn in law school is applying, learn the black letter law, but applying the black letter law to
00:30:37 the facts is sort of all the work. It's sort of the whole story of our lives individually and
00:30:42 corporately. So I'm not really telling people, especially men who are the sovereigns of their
00:30:49 own household, exactly how to do it. But what I'm address, what I address and what, what mega
00:30:54 is addressing is let's, let's keep the categories correct. Infant care is for women. And, um, 0.99
00:31:00 And, you know, the men can decide in those instances, the men of their households could and should decide, well, here's my threshold for getting involved.
00:31:12 You know, same thing.
00:31:13 I remember when I was doing studying to begin the doctorate in Rome at a pontifical school, you know, I asked my wife, hey, would you please go to this one classroom?
00:31:22 I got a really bad cold.
00:31:23 It was a class at the Angelica.
00:31:25 It was a really cool class, Thomas and Islam.
00:31:28 Professor was a really cool, famous guy.
00:31:30 So I was like, you kind of enjoy this. I kind of want you to see it anyway, because we, you know, talk about everything. I've been trying to describe it to you. But I have a bad cold. Would you go take notes? And it turned into a funny situation. But I don't usually impose on Steph, my wife, to go do my job or to go take notes for me in class unless I deem it's really, really important.
00:31:50 And so the underscore here is getting society back on tracks.
00:31:56 We're a transgender society. 0.98
00:31:57 I don't care about crazy men in women's clothes. 1.00
00:32:00 That's not what I'm talking about. 1.00
00:32:02 I'm talking about we are an insane feminist isn't a strong enough word. 1.00
00:32:06 Functional transgender society where people treat you like you're crazy. 0.99
00:32:10 If you're like, well, I'm the man. 0.99
00:32:12 I need to earn the money.
00:32:13 You know, the man needs to go to a job.
00:32:15 If we don't have enough money, I need to get a second job. 1.00
00:32:17 My wife doesn't need to get a job. 1.00
00:32:18 We don't each need one. 1.00
00:32:19 I need two, three, four, as many as it takes, but she's equipped to be at home.
00:32:25 And I always took great pride when I did have a nine to five and I get up and, you know, 0.97
00:32:32 everyone's asleep because we've always homeschooled and women need beauty rest.
00:32:38 Kids need more rest. 0.94
00:32:39 I like being the first one up.
00:32:41 I'm up with the crack of dawn.
00:32:43 You guys get up at nine, have a comfortable breakfast.
00:32:46 I don't have to worry about them driving around in dangerous cars throughout the day.
00:32:51 You know, I just know my whole family is safe doing homeschool.
00:32:54 I'll call them after I teach my first class or two and maybe they'll be up.
00:32:57 I always liked that precisely because it sets the conditions for the possibility of safety and comfort that are concomitant to wifeliness, you know.
00:33:08 But at the end of the day, yeah, you can – it's a lovely life, the life of wives. 0.63
00:33:13 They can really, unless you're a micromanager, which I am not, they can really set their own 1.00
00:33:20 conditions, you know, wake up late, feed the baby in bed, maybe change the diaper. That's what my
00:33:26 wife has always done. Change and feed right there. Start homeschool at even 10 a.m., you know, have a 1.00
00:33:32 lovely life with plenty of beauty rest. Set your own schedule. Once school is done, we have eight
00:33:37 kids. But my wife has always had ample time for journaling. You know, she's written two books, 0.82
00:33:44 you know, gardening, watercolor. She plays the flute, hang out, take a nap. There's so much to
00:33:50 do around the house that is concomitant with that, you know, that style of life. So to change
00:33:57 a few diapers here is anything but asking too much. And that's what Megha was saying. And that's
00:34:02 that's what we say in the movie where we're going to stand by the categories on that one. Water's
00:34:06 wet yeah so it's just like having basically guardrails uh as to here's what the rules are
00:34:12 and people can then play within those guardrails and they can be all sorts of variation very much
00:34:17 like what the church teaches it's it sets the boundaries of where right and wrong is and within
00:34:23 those boundaries everybody's allowed to play which is a lot better than the arbitrary we don't know
00:34:28 where we're supposed to stand wanted to talk also about another area that you're really expert in
00:34:33 and that is with regard to the death penalty. We have something off the page strange in what's
00:34:39 going on in the church today, because we have a situation where the current official teaching
00:34:45 of the church, sort of, if you will, at least the teaching of Francis and Leo,
00:34:51 is the opposite of what it was in the whole of the church before that. Francis changes the
00:34:59 catechism to basically say the death penalty is inadmissible when it was the whole teaching of
00:35:04 the church before that it was admissible not only that that the states had the right to and that
00:35:09 they could use it as a deterrent and it was even a a necessary following from the fifth commandment
00:35:16 thou shalt not kill um so that they could um deal with those who do kill this is pope leo
00:35:24 reiterating Francis's teaching, new teaching on the death penalty, and saying, on top of all that,
00:35:32 that if you don't adhere to it, you're not really pro-life. Let's watch.
00:35:36 Someone who says I'm against abortion, but says I'm in favor of the death penalty is not really
00:35:41 pro-life. So someone who says that I'm against abortion, but I'm in agreement with the inhuman
00:35:49 treatment of immigrants who are in the united states i don't know if that's pro-life so they're 0.95
00:35:54 very complex issues i don't know if anyone has all the truth on them but i would ask first and
00:36:01 foremost that there be greater respect for one another and that we search together both as human
00:36:07 beings in that case as american citizens or citizens of the state of illinois as well as
00:36:13 as catholics to say we need to you know really look closely at all of these ethical issues
00:36:19 and to find the way forward as church. The church teaching on each one of those issues is very clear.
00:36:25 I'd like to get your reaction to that. I know you're an expert on the death penalty.
00:36:29 Love to hear your thoughts, first of all, on that, and then on where you think the church is today,
00:36:33 given all the ruckus that's going on in this sort of thing.
00:36:37 Well, I'll just start by saying that thank goodness for Ed Fazer and Joe Bissett.
00:36:42 You know, I've been friends with Ed for 25 years or something.
00:36:46 He happened to be a visiting professor at LMU when I was doing a master's there.
00:36:51 And Joba said I took a class on the Senate of his when I was briefly in the doctoral program at Claremont.
00:36:57 So when these two guys hooked up for their book on the death penalty, the goodness of the death penalty, allegedly it bore real fruits.
00:37:07 And allegedly, what I hear from my connections in the Curia in Rome is that they were actually going to, Francis, that is, in 2017, was going to say more.
00:37:20 He was going to use proper theological language preclusive of the death penalty.
00:37:26 And he changed it to inadmissible because he got a hold of this book.
00:37:30 And he just, someone, some advisors or something like that got a hold of him and said, you can't use the theological language because it would be wrong.
00:37:39 And that's the, if that story is true, I've heard it a couple of places now, then that's the beauty of our magisterium.
00:37:45 Even with a radical, a complete radical like Francis, they know they're bound.
00:37:50 The strangeness of the story of the death penalty, I do not track to Francis.
00:37:55 I lay this blame at the feet of John Paul II.
00:37:59 Second, he had for the first time, just as we talked about the we only have two universal catechisms in the church.
00:38:07 By the way, we were talking about this with feminism, only the Catechism of the Council of Trent, the Roman Catechism and the CCC, which was the first, you know, catechism in 400 some odd years.
00:38:21 We hadn't had a catechism since the Roman Catechism right after the Reformation.
00:38:24 jp2 one pope promulgates the ccc in 93 or 94 the same pope it's not even like a new pontificate
00:38:35 just three and a half years later in 1997 issues a correction a catechetical correction of himself
00:38:44 and this is where all the trouble begins really this is where i think 100 of the trouble accrues
00:38:50 And in this 97 catechism, he corrects himself, essentially, as the promulgator.
00:38:56 We know the two main authors of the CCC were not JP2.
00:38:59 They were his lieutenants.
00:39:00 But he corrects himself three and a half years later.
00:39:04 And it's very strange.
00:39:05 The 93-94 original version said what the church had always said, left intact the beliefs that the death penalty is a conditional good.
00:39:13 It actually leaves intact human dignity.
00:39:16 It's actually an exercise of human dignity, as Thomas Aquinas says.
00:39:18 But 97, he uses this language.
00:39:22 I don't have it in front of me, but I have done scholarly work on it even in a doctoral
00:39:27 program, and it works like this.
00:39:30 He changes it fundamentally, where you can basically only use the death penalty, you
00:39:35 have recourse to it anymore as a civil society, on a consequentialist basis.
00:39:41 He actually posits consequentialism, which is an evil that the church has condemned without
00:39:46 knowing it.
00:39:47 And here's how it works. For all 2,000 years of Christianity, there are only two times when it's
00:39:55 licit for one human being to kill another. The first is the prerogative that the state holds,
00:40:03 literally prerogative, the power of God to intend to kill a human being, whether it's a rule by one,
00:40:10 rule by few, rule by many, as long as it's a just regime and they're trying to do their best,
00:40:14 They hold the power of God. They can intend to kill this guilty accused. And it doesn't have to 0.96
00:40:21 just be for murder, by the way. It can be for rape. It can be for heresy, as in the Holy Roman
00:40:25 Empire. It's not like it has to be oriented to saving lives. And this is the principle of
00:40:31 retributivism laid out by Fazer and Bassett so well. And so there's no principle of double effect
00:40:38 in this first instance that's being alluded to or recurred to, I should say. It's literally you
00:40:46 have a guilty accused. He's safely housed in this prison. Maybe he wasn't even a murderer. He was
00:40:51 just a heretic. But you think because of the principle of retributivism, you're not saving
00:40:57 anyone's life. It's just that the state puts him to death. Retributivism just means preserving
00:41:04 proportional justice. So in theory, the idea of people, people will boil it down to an eye for an
00:41:11 eye, a tooth for a tooth, but the idea of justice, which is, uh, in, in book five of Aristotle's
00:41:19 ethics, this is the, the highest, most theoretical form of justice. Okay. So it has nothing to do
00:41:26 with saving lives or good consequences or anything like that. The death penalty is good in the case
00:41:32 of this adjust state, leveling it wisely, not to save lives, but to preserve the, the, the spirit
00:41:41 of general justice. The second, okay. So the second time that it's licit and it's always been
00:41:48 taught it's licit for one human being to kill another is not an intended killing. It's a
00:41:53 foreseeable killing that is unintended. Now this, this is really hard for people to get their minds
00:41:59 around, but this is where the principle of double effect kicks in. If someone breaks in and is going
00:42:04 to harm you or someone in your family or even your neighbor, even a stranger, you're not intending
00:42:09 to kill them even if you have a handgun and you aim at center mass. You are intending to stop them
00:42:15 and it's a permissible certain effect. You don't have to aim at an arm or a leg or anything like
00:42:20 that for this aspect of Thomism action theory to be true. You can aim at the heart or the head
00:42:26 And you're not intending to kill them. 0.99
00:42:28 You're intending to stop them.
00:42:32 And with this particular second type of killing, it's really, really important that people
00:42:37 understand this because it debunks the entire anti-death penalty narrative in principle from
00:42:44 97 to the present day.
00:42:46 It's not an intended killing.
00:42:48 And the second that let's say they're about to stab you and they have their arm raised 0.63
00:42:53 or they're about to stab your wife, if they think better of it before you've shot them
00:43:00 and they lower their arm and they start walking to the door, irrespective of what the legal
00:43:04 status would be state to state, it is no longer illicit killing because the principle of double
00:43:12 effect kicks out.
00:43:14 You're no longer preventing a death.
00:43:16 So you don't get to kill them just to be like, well, they're probably going to go do this
00:43:19 to someone else.
00:43:20 You don't hold the prerogative.
00:43:21 Even if that's probably true, you don't hold the prerogative that the state does.
00:43:27 So in JP2's 97 Catechism, bear those two, that's it.
00:43:32 Those are the only two times a human being can kill another.
00:43:35 JP2, I should have gotten the language up in the actual thing, but he literally starts
00:43:42 talking about the only continued niche instances of the ability for one human to kill another.
00:43:50 He's talking about the state now, which always had this plenary authority, the authority of God to punish as if they can kill based on the principle of double effect, at which point you have to be operating on a consequentialist basis, only if it will save another life.
00:44:07 And the funny thing is, this is where you can really prove that it's wrong.
00:44:11 It's rare in philosophy that you can make a proof.
00:44:14 But John Paul II uses language that says, OK, you're holding them in prison.
00:44:20 So they're not in the act of killing anybody, but maybe it's a third world country of low max prison, low, you know, non-supermax prisons, and they're probably going to get out. 0.96
00:44:29 Well, OK, in those cases, you can still kill them.
00:44:32 What he's done is he's tried to hybridize the two licit instances of killing principle of double effect with the principle of retributivism.
00:44:40 And it doesn't work.
00:44:42 It's actually a contradiction of his own premise.
00:44:45 Right. The state, if it's wrong for the state to kill in principle, a guilty accused, then it's wrong for the state to kill to achieve some good end, like saving a life, particularly a life when the guilty accused is just in a low max prison, not about to kill someone.
00:45:03 So you can actually prove the error in JP2.
00:45:08 He develops it further in the end of his life.
00:45:10 Benedict is a little bit less vociferous about it, but he seems to be sympathetic to JP2's view.
00:45:17 And then Francis just takes it a step further.
00:45:19 But it's all based on this actual provable logical error.
00:45:24 You can use symbolic logic and show where they're wrong.
00:45:26 Not only do we have the death penalty change, we have Amoris Laetitia, we have Fiducii Subticans,
00:45:32 We have the demotion of Our Lady. We have, let's go on and on. My favorite one, because I'm from
00:45:38 the pro-life movement, is the intentional equation of abortion and immigration when it comes to
00:45:44 political matters, which we find in Gaudete et Exultate. But these are all official teaching
00:45:51 documents on faith and morals. The Pope intending to teach on faith and morals. The Catholic
00:45:57 faithful are required to submit to these things in mind and will. And yes, there's exceptions for
00:46:03 exceptional cases, but even in those exceptions, you're not supposed to make public your
00:46:09 disagreements with the Holy Father. Where in the world are we? I was stunned when I heard
00:46:15 Cardinals Sarah and Burke, etc., calling upon the SSPX for obedience when they are withholding that
00:46:24 from the faith and morals teachings, which they swore to, uh, in their, uh, when they made the
00:46:30 professional faith as bishops. The most stunned I've been, well, actually I was, I was stunned,
00:46:34 but not, not, not really stunned was when Pope Leo the 14th said that he stands proudly in the
00:46:41 lineage of Chicago archbishops from, uh, Bernadine. Cause Bernadine's the one that made up this idea
00:46:48 that's whole life, you know, we're pro-life, but we're whole life. Um, I'm forgetting the little,
00:46:54 the nifty little name he came up with for it. But the idea that pro-life means not just abortion
00:47:00 and euthanasia, but it means, you know, poverty. It means all the leftist causes as well. That was
00:47:07 a shocking moment. Seamless Garment is pretty much openly heretical. It hasn't been decried
00:47:15 by a council, but that's shocking. And yeah, you're right. You're actually putting at the
00:47:22 front of my mind that Leo is, is fully, fully against the death penalty. I've been, I haven't
00:47:27 been on the cover Leo train on my own, my own podcast as much lately, but I was on for the
00:47:34 first few months and I was like, watch out, this is going to be bad. We're going to have seamless
00:47:37 garment more and more strengthened. I was, I mean, the mark of his pontificate in my view
00:47:44 would have been, I mean, the only way it would have been good is if he tended to the death
00:47:52 penalty issue and the other most important error of the Francis pontificate, which is Amoris
00:47:57 Laetitia, because remember, Amoris Laetitia is promulgated in April of 2016. And it's sort of
00:48:08 ambiguous, but rather clear which two sacraments he's talking about restoring to unrepentant
00:48:14 adulterers in adulterous second unions. But September, five and a half months later,
00:48:20 the Argentine bishop, this is, I think, the most important thing that took place
00:48:24 in a bad way. The Argentine bishop said, you're talking about giving communion to,
00:48:29 you know, unrepentant adulterers, and we want to do it. And he says, you have the only correct 1.00
00:48:34 interpretation. And the same day he replies with the respuesta, he sticks it in the act
00:48:40 Apostolic Assetis. And he calls it authentic magisterium. Yes, authentic magisterium. So
00:48:47 that's troubling. Now, as for the state of the world, I did do a big show on this with
00:48:56 Anthony Abate from Avoiding Babylon. The mystery of iniquity and the interpretation of the church
00:49:02 during this, I think, most dark seculum obscurum. There's a seculum obscurum in the 900s,
00:49:08 which lasted 68 years. That's roughly what we've got going on. This is darker though.
00:49:13 There's an interpretive dilemma around every corner. And what I would say is
00:49:19 what we're rescued by is Thomistic epistemology. So like if the Pope says that we have to believe
00:49:28 in a circular that's all orthogonal or a square that's all circular, we can't even form the
00:49:37 phantasms because of the something called the peripatetic principle we can't even form the
00:49:41 phantasms for such a planar figure in our heads or you know that the trinity has four persons in
00:49:48 it or something so you're not accountable to form a self-contradicting premise something that you
00:49:54 know like a logical syllogism whose premises contradict one another you can't even form those
00:50:00 syllogisms in your head. So there is no duty there. But aside from that, partly because of
00:50:07 my view on patriarchy, if there's a clearly imprudent judgment that these bad men are going
00:50:17 to give us, or these bad popes at the very least are going to issue, then yeah, imprudence is one
00:50:25 of, if you want to look at it, the benefits of the job. So you go along with imprudences.
00:50:31 You're not bound to go along with things like two and two is five or logical impossibilities.
00:50:38 And the church has in dark times, not quite as dark as now, operated like this before. But
00:50:45 generally speaking, I would just say, you know, something like the Benedict option,
00:50:51 be the head of your own household, get to mass on Sunday, go to confession often,
00:50:55 And the mystery of iniquity will be revealed at the end of time, won't it?
00:51:01 I'm very hopeful that this period will come to a close.
00:51:06 It is, I'm into some prophecies.
00:51:11 I have a great friend in Xavier Eral who wrote a book called Revelations, which goes through a lot of the Marian apparitions.
00:51:16 To me, it's really hopeful because the suggestion that there would be only two worm-ridden popes in our years and that after that it would be better fills me with hope anyway.
00:51:28 But Timothy Gordon, I want to thank you for joining us.
00:51:31 And I would urge folks to go check out his direct site, TimothyJGordon.com.
00:51:39 And God bless you, my friend.
00:51:40 Thank you so much.
00:51:41 Thanks a million for having me.
00:51:42 I really appreciate it.
00:51:43 And God bless all of you.
00:51:45 And we'll see you next time.
00:51:46 Many Catholics today are confused, discouraged, and heartbroken over what they see happening
00:51:57 to the Church. Some lose hope. Some lose their faith entirely. But this is not the time to
00:52:02 abandon the truth. I'm Father Charles Murr. When I researched Leo XIV's involvement with the
00:52:08 Patamama ritual, I knew the truth would be difficult for many to hear. But the truth must
00:52:13 be told. That is why LifeSite News matters. LifeSite News rewards faithfully, courageously,
00:52:20 and always with hope rooted in Jesus Christ. As our Lord said, the truth shall set you free.
00:52:27 If you value Catholic journalism in these difficult times, please support LifeSite News today.
00:52:33 Thank you.