The King's Hall - January 27, 2023


A Famine of Fatherhood: Symptoms of Fatherlessness

Topics
Mentioned
Season 2: Father Hunger How to Make a Bastard World

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 36 minutes

Words per minute

178.02

Word count

17,128

Sentence count

1,049

Harmful content

Misogyny

56

sentences flagged

Toxicity

59

sentences flagged

Hate speech

113

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, Brian here with a big announcement from New Christendom Press.
00:00:03 Possibly our most important book yet is now available for pre-order.
00:00:08 It's called The Longhouse, How Feminism Conquered the West and Made Us All Miserable.
00:00:13 And in it, Eric and I take you through the dark history of feminism,
00:00:17 what it's done to everything from politics to church life to the economy,
00:00:21 and what to do about it.
00:00:23 Pre-order it today at newchristendompress.com slash longhouse.
00:00:26 and as a thank you for pre-ordering you'll get 10 off automatically we'll also be signing the
00:00:32 first thousand copies so pick yours up today you love that woman right there you love her right
00:00:39 yes sir now you're not an adult till you're 18 do you want me to be your daddy for the next eight
00:00:45 years son huh yes you do
00:00:49 why you want me to be your daddy i have no daddy you have no daddy well let me tell you something
00:01:03 come here give me a hug you're listening to the king's hall podcast making self-ruled men
00:01:12 who rule well and win the world well gentlemen welcome to season two episode one of the king's
00:01:22 hall podcast i'm not really sure dan how you begin the show on a chipper note after that clip which
00:01:29 always gets me you had to give us a minute here eric yeah what is it about that clip yeah well
00:01:37 It's really interesting when you watch it because it's from Jenny Jones.
00:01:42 Very classy TV programming from the 90s.
00:01:44 Yeah, and so it was a whole shtick that she had where it was like drill sergeant shaming middle school-aged boys into behaving for their single moms.
00:01:57 And so it really is tough to watch.
00:02:02 It's interesting.
00:02:03 If you watch the video, we would encourage people to do that.
00:02:06 I just found it on YouTube.
00:02:07 But the drill sergeant's face when the kid said, yes, sir, I do like he was they started cheering.
00:02:13 The crowd did. Yeah. The audience. And he was like he looked like he was going to cry.
00:02:18 And then he's well, well, why? And the kid's about to cry, too. I have no daddy.
00:02:24 I think it's particularly moving to when you think about this, because in America, how many people are in that situation where they're saying essentially the same thing?
00:02:34 I have no daddy. It seems to be something that resonates with a lot of people. And when you look
00:02:40 at our culture, there's a desperation about this situation as well. So current data as of 2021
00:02:46 indicates that roughly 18.3 million children live without a father in the home, which is roughly
00:02:51 25% of all children in America. Guys, that's a high number. It's unbelievable. There's a lot
00:02:57 of fatherlessness. That number jumps up to 35% when looking only at adolescents. So as kids get
00:03:03 older it seems like parents are more likely to divorce and that affects teenagers as you know
00:03:08 teenagers that's going to be a huge demographic yeah uh that sets the tone for the next generation
00:03:14 so compare those numbers in 1950 in which just six percent of children lived in fatherless homes
00:03:20 clearly fatherness fatherlessness has drastically increased and been a problem something happened
00:03:26 as we'll see in this episode in the 50s and then in the 1960s but i think gentlemen that reality of
00:03:32 fatherlessness actually goes beyond just physical absenteeism. Many more fathers, though present,
00:03:40 abdicate their authority and responsibilities and may nonetheless neglect to have a meaningful role
00:03:45 in their children's lives. So you have certain things like workaholism, dads who are just
00:03:51 negligent or not there. But whatever the case, we have uninitiated men who are clueless about what
00:03:57 their responsibility is as men going into adulthood. And our friend Michael Foster has
00:04:03 called this sort of phenomenon, the clueless bastard, uh, bastardization, I guess, of our 0.99
00:04:09 culture. So you can also look at a few other numbers, which we'll do. And then I want to ask 0.97
00:04:13 you guys a question. One of the things that we look at is birth rates. They continue to plummet,
00:04:18 meaning there will be fewer and fewer fathers in the future. So since about 2007, the U S birth
00:04:23 rate has fallen by 20 percent 20 percent 20 and since 2007 seven i remember 2007 yeah it's not
00:04:31 like my truck is older than 2007 my car is from a different millennium
00:04:36 it's also pink it wasn't always though which is like faded cherry red but also yes so drastic
00:04:47 numbers two of the major events by the way uh why 2007 there's also a huge drop off in 2020
00:04:54 So 2008, the economic crash, that made people want to have children less and less.
00:04:59 And then 2020, we don't have all the data, but birth rates are absolutely tanking even more because people are saying, well, look at inflation, myocarditis, vaccine.
00:05:11 We just got canceled.
00:05:12 We just got canceled.
00:05:13 Come on, Eric. 1.00
00:05:14 Plus with plummeting fertility rates. 0.73
00:05:17 Yeah.
00:05:17 So that's the other thing that I want to talk about. 0.99
00:05:20 You've got millennials increasingly rejecting parenthood.
00:05:23 And because of the current hormonal health crisis that is afflicting, Brian, both men and women, we've talked about on BrightHearth and the Hard Men podcast.
00:05:30 Some studies have estimated that sperm count in men will be so low that by 2050, reproduction will become physically impossible.
00:05:38 Maybe that's why we see these like womb labs, like grow a baby in a lab stuff on social media.
00:05:45 Trying to figure that out.
00:05:46 They're trying to figure this out.
00:05:48 I've seen the Matrix
00:05:49 so I've seen that happen
00:05:52 it goes nowhere good
00:05:54 don't shoot the sun 0.65
00:05:55 you know the orcs 0.84
00:05:56 what is wrong with me
00:06:00 don't shoot the sun
00:06:00 wow
00:06:01 into this desert cauldron of greed
00:06:05 distrust and violence
00:06:07 some men rode alone
00:06:10 men of action
00:06:11 men who tried to shoot the sun down
00:06:14 some of us need some more father time
00:06:19 so for those biological fathers left in the mix whoever's left in this matrix and this
00:06:26 problematic world traditional masculine roles for them continue to be attacked by the culture at
00:06:31 large this includes mainline churches fatherhood has fallen on hard times and as a result there
00:06:36 is a greater hunger for authentic masculine fatherhood that's kind of what we're driving
00:06:42 at in season two this quote i want to read uh which we also read in the cold open of the
00:06:48 introduction but i think it's so good it's worth reading again this comes from fatherlessness in
00:06:52 america published in 1995 by david blankenhorn and he writes this so this is 95 we i think we've
00:06:58 actually gotten worse yeah the united states is becoming an increasingly fatherless society
00:07:04 a generation ago an american child could reasonably expect to grow up with his or her father
00:07:09 Today, an American child can reasonably expect not to.
00:07:14 Fatherlessness is now approaching a rough parody with fatherhood as a defining feature of American childhood.
00:07:21 So, gentlemen, I want to just ask you guys right off the bat the question about fatherhood.
00:07:28 Why is it so important?
00:07:30 Again, we talked a little bit about this in the introduction.
00:07:32 But as we tee this up, why is it so important that we address this issue for our country, for our churches, for our families?
00:07:39 Why is fatherhood so important?
00:07:42 Well, I mean, in the introduction, I had said something about how the father is the most important authority in humanity.
00:07:53 And so, and I think that's true.
00:07:55 I think that the family itself is a foundational covenant structure of humanity.
00:08:01 You know, we talked about that a lot in season one.
00:08:03 It is the support structure holding up all of human civilization, economics, politics, education, even giving your life purpose, you know, like waking up and getting out of bed has a lot to do with family.
00:08:20 And so the purpose or the motivation to continue in work, to building grand structures, to making churches, all areas of life have families at its foundation.
00:08:33 and the single biggest factor, the single greatest authority is the father.
00:08:40 And the father, I think, is such a determining factor in the well-being of these family structures
00:08:47 that I do believe it's the single most important authority in all of men.
00:08:52 We've actually seen that in studies, too.
00:08:54 I think it's something like in the mid-80 percentile.
00:08:58 Like, whatever the father does religiously, that's what the kids end up doing.
00:09:01 Yeah. I mean, if you were to just chart like a graph of influence versus number of people, you know, like a father has tremendous influence over a few number of, you know, a few people, whereas like a politician, it's inverse, right? You have little influence over a lot of people.
00:09:18 And so a father has maximal influence over people, image bearers. And so if you're just, I mean, just to think about this as simply as possible, imagine the archetypal man that had a good father versus the archetypal man that had a bad father or the archetypal woman who had a good father versus the archetypal woman who did not have a good father.
00:09:45 And so I think that that authority is the most important human authority in shaping and directing entire cultures and times of people.
00:09:55 Yeah. And you see the effect of fatherlessness in many, in sometimes ways that you might not understand immediately that it is an issue of fatherlessness that you're seeing. But think about something like our obsession with these top-down, famous, big figures to be our daddies in different spheres.
00:10:17 I even mean the obsession with the president of the United States. When you have a fatherless culture, a culture where you have none of that organic, low-level leavening everywhere of good fathers raising up good sons and daughters, you start to reach out to figures that you hope will fix the problem, will parent everybody.
00:10:38 And so you become obsessed with Donald Trump or you become obsessed with Joe Biden.
00:10:43 You just become obsessed with this father figure at the top who's going to fix everything or influencers.
00:10:50 And a lot of times we pedestalize people who are celebrities because you don't know any of their faults.
00:10:56 I think it happens in the reform world too, Brian.
00:10:58 Yeah.
00:10:58 Just with – it could be great men.
00:11:00 You could be a Doug Wilson guy or a James White guy.
00:11:04 But I think it probably just reveals this father hunger.
00:11:08 Well, yeah, you can see especially modern father hunger because Jordan Peterson would have been a nobody in 1950.
00:11:14 Yeah.
00:11:15 Because the message, go clean your room, would have been like vanilla in 1950.
00:11:22 Ward Cleaver was saying that too.
00:11:23 Yeah.
00:11:24 Yeah.
00:11:24 He didn't have a huge following.
00:11:26 So, gentlemen, I want to run this by you.
00:11:27 I think this is going to serve as something like a thesis for the show and where we're going with this one.
00:11:33 This is really what I'm driving at.
00:11:35 There is an intense father hunger in the land and is the heart of why families, churches, and societies are failing.
00:11:41 The degradation of fathers is largely why we no longer have a robust Christendom.
00:11:46 So to put it yet another way, there will be no Christendom without the recovery of fatherhood.
00:11:51 So Brian, I want to ask you that question related to, specifically, we've been about the new Christendom.
00:11:57 So tie those together, new Christendom and fatherhood, how do they connect in your mind?
00:12:01 Yeah, so Christendom is going to be the result of a leavening of the gospel's work through society, if it's to be a Christendom worth having, right? 0.73
00:12:12 What we don't want is just a top-down sort of apparatus where you have a few key leaders here and there in institutions and political spaces who are imposing a bunch of stuff, Christian stuff on people.
00:12:25 What we want, and the way the gospel is designed to work, is to have the gospel leavening society itself, leavening families.
00:12:34 And what do you need at the family level if you're to have a healthy society?
00:12:38 You need fatherhood.
00:12:39 You need good Christian fathers being good Christian men, building homes that then go out and establish good churches,
00:12:48 that can do the work of the church, and that go and establish good businesses and pass the legacy on down,
00:12:53 and establish states that can praise the good and punish the wrongdoer and prevent essentially on
00:13:01 that level city fathers. When we talk about Christendom, we actually are talking about
00:13:06 something that cannot happen. It just cannot happen in a godly way without fathers being
00:13:14 Christian fathers. And so when you look at the state of the world, the church, society, 0.99
00:13:18 you're going to find that shot through all of the problems somewhere if you tug on the thread
00:13:24 it will connect to a failure of fatherhood whether you're talking about some of the things we took up
00:13:29 in season one with big fast and famous model again why do we want big fast celebrity pastors
00:13:36 because we don't have fathers so we're trying to fill some hole why do we want a president who can
00:13:43 just decree and be an authoritarian and be a king well because we're like the israelites who wanted
00:13:47 a king like the Lance. We don't have fathers, and so we try to reach for ersatz versions,
00:13:53 fake versions of fathers. And what it all comes down to at the bottom is that at the very
00:14:00 foundation level of reality is a father. There's a father there. And so you can expect
00:14:07 for nothing to work if fatherhood goes wrong. All of creation is supposed to reflect the father
00:14:15 rule of God. And so I think when we talk about Christendom and we talk about fatherhood,
00:14:20 we're talking about a hand-in-glove sort of thing, if that makes sense.
00:14:25 It seems to be a thing of first order.
00:14:26 Yeah, it's a first order issue.
00:14:29 Yeah, I think that's really important. The other thing I want to say by way of just talking about
00:14:33 this episode, we're going to be talking a lot today about the diagnostic nature of, you know,
00:14:39 what's wrong with fatherlessness in America. So we'll be doing a lot of the diagnosis.
00:14:43 The second part, we're going to look at some of the root causes of fatherlessness.
00:14:47 So this will actually be the second part of this episode.
00:14:49 You'll see it as a separate episode altogether.
00:14:52 And then third and finally, we'll plant a seed for the vision, I think, that we want
00:14:55 to unpack in the rest of the season for the recovery of biblical fatherhood in the 21st
00:15:00 century.
00:15:00 I think it's also important to connect this, Dan, to our post-mill leanings here, because
00:15:05 there's a hopefulness about this.
00:15:07 I think that many people, when they look at, you know, reproduction in men, for example,
00:15:12 They just assume, well, it's always going to keep getting worse.
00:15:15 That's actually not our expectation.
00:15:17 We believe that through preaching the gospel, hearts can be transformed,
00:15:20 people can be and will be regenerated,
00:15:23 and that the gospel will grow up like leaven so that we can disciple the nations.
00:15:27 So just for a second, would you talk about that connection?
00:15:30 No, absolutely. That's right.
00:15:31 I think, you know, we talked in the first season,
00:15:35 these grandiose visions of, like, societal world change and domination,
00:15:39 And you're kind of like, well, yeah, I mean, there's practical advice, but a lot of it's
00:15:43 like, that seems like a pipe dream.
00:15:45 Clean your room, guys.
00:15:47 They're like Jordan Peterson, us.
00:15:49 Yeah, yeah, that's right.
00:15:50 And so what this really does is it focuses on the foundations.
00:15:55 I think it really gives us a scope and a hope because the project is not too big.
00:16:01 Yes.
00:16:01 The responsibilities that are in front of you are not world dominion.
00:16:07 They're not hope in some abstract politician, you know, some ideal of Christian nationalism that we need to legislate towards or, you know, you are one man.
00:16:18 You only have one vote. 0.54
00:16:19 You cannot change the entire world no matter what they told you in school unless God determines that you're going to be that guy.
00:16:27 Really, the job that's in front of you is not beyond you.
00:16:30 With the power of the Holy Spirit, you can love your kids.
00:16:34 Maybe in a way that you weren't loved.
00:16:35 You can be a father.
00:16:36 You can be a father in a way that maybe you weren't fathered.
00:16:39 And what you can find is that by simply doing that, you can become a father that has impact on literally tens of thousands of souls.
00:16:49 And that's—I can think of almost—like you said, Dan, fatherhood is the central authority in all of human existence.
00:16:57 And I think that, again, reflects the fatherhood of God.
00:16:59 It's a design feature here.
00:17:01 And what that means is that when you get that central authority right, the potency of it is incredible.
00:17:10 It's incredible.
00:17:11 You're reaching downstream in the generations, and you're changing history for a people.
00:17:20 You can do that, not because you're God, but because you can simply obey the duties God has given you right here, these small little duties as a father.
00:17:28 And I think that is just such a captivating, hopeful note that we want to strike.
00:17:32 Because, man, when I hear that clip in the intro, I almost can't hold it together.
00:17:37 Still, I've heard it dozens of times probably now at this point.
00:17:41 And it can be absolutely depressing and bleak when you start to consider some of the realities.
00:17:49 And the effect can, I think, make you go either into the ditch of despair, just black pill.
00:17:55 or one of the other things it can do
00:17:58 is make you want to change the whole world tomorrow.
00:18:01 Oh, let's go fix everything.
00:18:02 And what God has put in front of us really is just,
00:18:05 let's figure out how to be fathers today.
00:18:07 Let's figure out how to be fathers here.
00:18:09 Well, I think that's kind of the bent,
00:18:11 our education system, our culture, whatever it is.
00:18:14 It's sort of the Greta Thunberg reality.
00:18:16 Like you're this little kid,
00:18:17 like telling the world how to fix itself.
00:18:19 As Dan said, like everybody's saying think big.
00:18:22 And really what we're encouraging guys to do
00:18:24 is sort of the Mother Teresa.
00:18:26 If you want to change the world, go home and love your family.
00:18:29 And really, as fathers, like this is God's biblical pattern.
00:18:32 If you would be qualified to be an elder in your church
00:18:34 or a politician or a city father,
00:18:37 you must first qualify yourself in the home anyway.
00:18:40 So that's going to be the testing ground.
00:18:42 What I want to do now is we're going to jump into the symptoms of fatherlessness.
00:18:47 And Dan, I'm going to start with you.
00:18:49 The first thing that we were talking about,
00:18:51 so what's one of the symptoms we see in culture
00:18:53 that men are fatherlessness, we came upon this Papa YouTube idea, and it's titled Dad, How Do I?
00:19:00 It's got 4.37 million subscribers. So, Dan, I guess just first off, I think this is a symptom.
00:19:07 Tell me about Dad, How Do I? Do you think it's a symptom of fatherlessness? And what is it?
00:19:11 Yeah, it's really interesting. I was talking to my younger brother the other day about this,
00:19:16 and he said something about he was looking for a car repair or something, and he stumbled across.
00:19:21 I don't think it's the dad who, how do I channel, but it was a different one where the guy's like, Hey, uh, I didn't have a dad to show me how to change oil in my car.
00:19:31 And, um, you know, I figure a lot of you probably don't have dads either.
00:19:35 So I'm just going to show you how to change oil in a car, you know?
00:19:39 And it stuck out so much to my brother because we both had a father, you know, that showed us things like that.
00:19:45 He was like, wow, that to me was really insightful as to what's going on.
00:19:53 And so, yeah, Eric and I started looking at this poppy YouTube thing because if you want to know how to do almost anything, you go to YouTube and you look at it.
00:20:01 And this one YouTube channel, Dad, How Do I, I think his number one video, millions of views, is How Do I Tie a Tie?
00:20:12 His next one is How Do I Shave?
00:20:15 And then his third and fourth videos, as far as view count, are like thanking people and saying, I'm proud of you.
00:20:31 In 2023, Indigo Sundries became one of our sponsors.
00:20:34 At the time, their business was little more than a side hobby generating a couple hundred dollars a month.
00:20:39 But because of their partnership with us and because all of you chose to support them, they've grown enough to make it their full-time livelihood. 0.92
00:20:44 This is what happens when Christians support Christians.
00:20:47 Our communities are strengthened and faithful businesses thrive.
00:20:49 So if you're a Christian business owner who wants to reach thousands of like-minded people and grow your company, we'd love to partner with you.
00:20:56 Email us at advertising at newchristendompress.com.
00:21:04 Yeah, so he's got a video called I'm Proud of You, which was, he's basically acting like a father.
00:21:10 He reads from Teddy Roosevelt's Man in the Arena.
00:21:13 Yeah, that's right. He was talking about critics. Like, hey, don't listen to the critics. You know, I'm for you. I'm in your corner. I'm proud of you. I love you. God bless you. And the comments, people are just falling apart.
00:21:24 Yeah, that's what really, I guess, hit me was when you read the comments section, you see the father hunger.
00:21:31 You see people longing for just a father figure in their life to say, I'm really proud of you.
00:21:36 I look at your life and I think, you know, you are an encouragement to other people.
00:21:42 You know, there's just positivity.
00:21:43 The other thing that he does that I think is really interesting, when he opens the shows, he's usually got a dad joke, but he always says, hey, kids.
00:21:50 and I'm sitting there thinking like okay maybe it's dorky maybe it's cheesy a people are eating
00:21:57 it up it'd be there's something about it that resonates because I think there's just such a
00:22:01 vacuum in our world for yeah it really is a tragedy that that along with the 4.4 million
00:22:08 other people it's so impersonal it's synthetic you know because he's not a real dad he doesn't
00:22:14 know you he doesn't know if out of you yeah he's not but people are so hungry for it almost like
00:22:20 a starving person that
00:22:22 finds a bowl of plastic fruit
00:22:24 and is like, it's close
00:22:26 enough. Close enough. This reminds
00:22:28 me of a
00:22:30 phenomenon that is cropping up that is going to be
00:22:32 absolutely massive, and it's the
00:22:34 artificial intelligence friends.
00:22:37 Most of them right now, you see the
00:22:38 advertising for, is for gross 0.98
00:22:40 sex, porny stuff. They're 0.99
00:22:42 like, oh, I'll be your friend, I'll date you,
00:22:44 and then it's all about, like, I'll send you pictures
00:22:46 and role play. It's gross. 0.51
00:22:49 Artificial intelligence chatbots that will be your girlfriend. 1.00
00:22:52 Seriously.
00:22:53 I'm not even kidding.
00:22:54 This is the thing.
00:22:55 They're advertising on Twitter, and every time I see one, I block it.
00:22:59 I'm like, you are blocking.
00:23:00 This has been happening in Japan for a long time, where we had a military member who was going to be touring in Japan with some government officials.
00:23:08 And they said, just so you know, there's a chance that one of them will bring their robotic girlfriend or wife, and you must treat them like a human being.
00:23:19 Are you serious?
00:23:20 Yes, this is for real.
00:23:22 Doug Wilson wrote the novel for a reason.
00:23:24 Yeah, because it already does exist.
00:23:26 So my prediction is that you will probably have father versions of that.
00:23:32 Really?
00:23:32 You think so?
00:23:33 I mean, I almost guarantee it.
00:23:34 Within the next five years, I'm going to call it.
00:23:36 Someone can fact check me in five years.
00:23:38 from the year of our Lord, 2023,
00:23:40 that there will be artificial intelligence apps
00:23:43 that you can have a dad
00:23:44 and you can ask it questions like,
00:23:46 dad, how do I change the oil?
00:23:48 How do I tie a tie?
00:23:49 Dad, you know, that will text with you and say,
00:23:51 hey, I'm proud of you.
00:23:52 How's work going?
00:23:53 How's, you know, do you need any advice?
00:23:55 I guarantee you that will happen.
00:23:58 But I think I agree with you.
00:24:00 And I think you've already seen this,
00:24:01 like movies like Big Hero 6,
00:24:03 where it's like the kid's best friend is like a robot.
00:24:05 It's a robot.
00:24:06 But, you know, the whole point is, like, the robots develop, like, personalities, like humans, and we're really moved by it.
00:24:12 I think it's this—it's tied to a bigger thing, but I think that is, like, this fourth industrial revolution.
00:24:17 They're trying to warm you up to it.
00:24:19 Yeah.
00:24:20 Dan, any other thoughts on Poppy YouTube?
00:24:22 I guess, what do you think the application takeaway from that is for a lot of guys?
00:24:27 Because, I mean, as a father, I see that, and I think about the young men that maybe come into my pastor's office and we do counseling,
00:24:33 And I think, hey, don't forget, above all things, these these men need a father.
00:24:38 They need encouragement.
00:24:40 You you typically see we'll get into this next, but you typically see in the OK Boomer thing. 1.00
00:24:45 It's like, hey, stupid, you know, let me tell you something. 1.00
00:24:48 You need to respect me. 1.00
00:24:49 It's it's not what you find with.
00:24:51 Well, dad, how do I?
00:24:53 Yeah, I think that this probably seems like a shallow example using YouTube is like, well, yeah, I mean, I I have to look up how to change the alternator on my car.
00:25:02 so does that mean I have father hunger
00:25:04 or you know that's a really
00:25:06 shallow example to see somebody
00:25:08 like tear up because there's some a guy
00:25:10 who looks like a dad saying I'm proud of you
00:25:12 but I think really what it shows is
00:25:14 just even the basic
00:25:16 foundations to the point where
00:25:18 there are millions of
00:25:20 people that don't have somebody that
00:25:22 they can say hey dad
00:25:24 how do I use a stud finder
00:25:26 how do I
00:25:28 find a stud behind a wall
00:25:29 You put it on your chest, and you always start there.
00:25:32 You have to.
00:25:32 Well, you know, you've got to watch the video because he does it.
00:25:34 Does he do that?
00:25:35 Well, he says if you clicked on this video because you're a girl
00:25:37 and you want to find a boyfriend, then this is the wrong video.
00:25:40 So it was pretty funny.
00:25:42 It wasn't what you expected.
00:25:43 No, no, no.
00:25:44 But, I mean, it just shows, like,
00:25:46 even at the most foundational level of human functioning,
00:25:50 there wasn't a man there, a dad, to say,
00:25:54 hey, son, let me show you how to split wood.
00:25:56 Let me show you how to tie a tie.
00:25:57 Let me show you how to patch a hole in drywall.
00:26:00 Let me show you how to change your brakes, much less the deeper things in life. 0.99
00:26:05 Like, hey, son, let me show you how to win a woman.
00:26:08 Hey, daughter, let me show you affectionate and love so you don't seek it from any worthless man that passes along.
00:26:14 I mean, so I think the YouTube thing is a perfect example of how deep this problem goes.
00:26:23 And it's even human functioning, not just human flourishing, but just the very elemental things in life.
00:26:30 Well, I think, Brian, it's tied to stuff you guys have talked about on BrightHearth.
00:26:34 But I was thinking the other day after church, I was talking to Lexi about this, where midwifery and OBGYNs and stuff like that.
00:26:42 We have people who give birth, but it's really because we lost a whole body of knowledge that wives and mothers used to pass along to each other.
00:26:50 Yeah. So for both of the sexes, it seems like there's just been a the household got destroyed.
00:26:56 And with it, we lost like many, many generations of competencies. 1.00
00:27:02 Yeah. Yeah. When you talk about, I think, a lot of what this shows isn't necessarily like that you have one particular skill that maybe you failed to get from your dad, whatever.
00:27:13 That's going to happen. You're going to have skills that you're going to look up.
00:27:16 but honestly, most of the answer to this, like most of this is actually a dad showing you,
00:27:23 just living with a dad, having, this is just the tip of the iceberg out here that's a diagnostic
00:27:28 showing you kind of like, whoa, there's an issue here. Because for most of us, our dads didn't do
00:27:34 less. If you had a dad, they didn't do lessons with you. You were like, now, son, we're going to
00:27:38 blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. What happened was if you had a father who was a good, especially a
00:27:42 good christian present man you just did stuff with them hold the flashlight that's what you did you
00:27:47 held the flashlight and even those kind of things are are endearing where you you know we a lot of
00:27:53 us can commiserate about you're like well you know i did stuff with my dad but like he really
00:27:57 didn't trust me to do anything other than hold the flashlight but you still saw the process
00:28:02 you're familiar with it and it's funny because now i have my kids and i'm like okay you want to
00:28:07 mow the lawn, but can you though? Everything that involves mowing is sharp. It's sharp and it spins.
00:28:15 It's a death spinny thing. And, and you start to, you realize that the answer isn't like dad
00:28:21 university. It's the love of a father, the presence of a father who will just simply live
00:28:28 with you and be there and just involve you and that you want to be involved with. Cause you know,
00:28:35 Dad's awesome. I love being with Dad. I love just hanging on his belt loops when he's doing stuff in the shop, and it's probably annoying to him at some level, but the answers to these Papa YouTube thing is it's not just about skills. It's really at the bottom about love.
00:28:55 Yeah, I think so much like in John's gospel that you get is Jesus talking about being on the same mission as his father.
00:29:03 I and the father are one.
00:29:05 We're working together.
00:29:06 We're working on the same projects.
00:29:07 So even beyond, Dan, the basic competencies, you're wanting to share your mission so that your boys understand what was dad for.
00:29:16 And, yeah, maybe it gets lived out if you're working on the bus in the driveway or you're doing gardening.
00:29:21 But really it's about the presence.
00:29:23 They sense that you want to be with them.
00:29:26 Yeah, there's an identity tied to that, right?
00:29:27 Yeah.
00:29:28 I mean, a father should tell you what you're for, what you exist to do.
00:29:32 I mean, you can see this like all the way back when you look at the Middle Ages to where there's like, hey, you have a family crest or you can do like a family crest designer or whatever.
00:29:42 Imagine if you had a family motto that was you inherited.
00:29:46 Like, no, this is your identity is that we exist for honor, you know, or we exist for this.
00:29:52 this is your crest tying you to your ancestors, or even last names. A lot of people have the name
00:29:58 Baker or Smith, or you can think of a lot of names like that. That ties you to something,
00:30:04 to an identity, and it's supposed to be from your father. And so you can see that like,
00:30:09 hey, son, we go to church every Sunday because we exist to glorify God and worship him.
00:30:17 So, I mean, a lot of it is identity. A lot of it is purpose. And so you have a purposeless people
00:30:22 and they're set adrift.
00:30:24 You see some cultures even have their patronymics
00:30:28 where, like Russian, if you wanted to say,
00:30:32 well, my dad, they would call me Brian Duanovich.
00:30:36 It means Brian's son of Duane,
00:30:38 like, or Brian Ivanovich.
00:30:40 That's what it means.
00:30:41 When you hear that in Russian,
00:30:42 it means they literally would call you your name
00:30:45 and son of this guy.
00:30:47 Well, it's like a Simon Barjona.
00:30:49 Yeah.
00:30:49 Same deal.
00:30:50 Lots of equivalents in all kinds of languages that just show you, again, in the fabric, in the very heart of what it means to be a human being as God created in this world is to be the son of someone.
00:31:03 And what happens when you take that away?
00:31:06 That's why I think it's so devastating and depressing, and it's so emotionally – it hits you hard when you see the young kids who so clearly don't have a father.
00:31:18 is because you start to, when you understand the depth,
00:31:21 you're understanding that we've, our society,
00:31:24 our sin is stealing, it's robbing children
00:31:27 of one of the most essential features
00:31:30 of what it is to be a person.
00:31:32 And you're just stealing that from them.
00:31:34 Wow.
00:31:35 Yeah, I think that's absolutely true.
00:31:38 Moving on now to number two,
00:31:39 number two symptom, if you will,
00:31:41 of fatherlessness in our culture 0.92
00:31:43 is what I'm calling the okay boomer phenomena,
00:31:46 or you could also call it a clash of generations i think it's interesting because i looked this
00:31:52 one up as i said before i was doing some research on this and it was kind of shocking it goes back
00:31:57 to 2017 i thought it was much older and probably on reddit or somewhere somebody was yeah using
00:32:03 the phrase earlier but this was the first one that this this author could find 2017 it hit
00:32:08 mainstream on tiktok which is where all major societal trends of course chinese tiktok came
00:32:15 from uh okay boomer is one of them so it's interesting too according to an article from
00:32:19 vox okay boomer is really about the following so i'm going to quote this it says okay boomer is an
00:32:25 instantly relatable cry of frustration for many people don't get it twisted it's important to
00:32:31 understand that what really lies behind the meme is increasing economic environmental and social
00:32:36 anxiety and the feeling that baby boomers are leaving younger generations to clean up
00:32:41 their mess kind of an interesting theory behind okay boomer dan do you see some of what the vox
00:32:49 is talking about one of our favorite outlets by the way it is my the only thing i read actually
00:32:55 no so the number of examples that i could pull from just in counseling younger men is is actually
00:33:03 there's a lot of them but the economic one is is really the easiest one to see because i'll have a
00:33:08 guy that's, um, you know, has a, a tech degree in some blue collar trade like welding or CNC or
00:33:16 whatever. And during the boomer generation, like you could, you could pay cash for a house. You
00:33:22 could send your kids to college. You could have your wife stay home. You could have two vehicles 0.99
00:33:26 and you'd be fine. And the men now, uh, that have a tech degree and are doing the same trades
00:33:33 can't afford a rent payment they just can't they can't make it yeah and then when you get the hey
00:33:41 i'm having a hard time the answers are not satisfactory because the older generation is
00:33:48 just like well kids these days snowflakes work harder you know stop complaining stick it out
00:33:53 you know just make it happen and that's not a satisfactory answer because the times are
00:33:59 different. And, I mean, if you look upstream, the economic and societal toxic waste has been
00:34:10 coming from the previous generation and a lot of the decisions that are being made had been made.
00:34:16 And so, I mean, I can see, especially for people that are younger right now, where that is
00:34:22 amplified. And I think this is only going to increase. Yeah, I think it's going to get worse.
00:34:27 So I was reading a book titled The Theft of a Decade.
00:34:30 This is by Joseph Sternberg, writes for The Wall Street Journal.
00:34:33 Subtitle, How the Baby Boomers Stole the Millennials' Economic Future.
00:34:37 So he begins that book by talking about how there was a popular article.
00:34:41 I think it's like 2010, somewhere around there.
00:34:44 And a guy was saying, hey, you know, I'm so sick and tired of millennials.
00:34:47 They talk about how they can't build wealth.
00:34:49 Well, if you'd stop having avocado toast for breakfast every day.
00:34:51 And going to Starbucks.
00:34:52 And going to Starbucks, then you'd be able.
00:34:54 So then you had follow-up articles where they were like, OK, let's add up a lifetime of avocado toast for the millennial.
00:35:00 He still couldn't – if he saved all that money, he still couldn't afford a down payment.
00:35:05 So I think that was part of the like – on the one hand, the older people saying like – the accusation is you just don't work hard enough.
00:35:12 But the failure to see the reality that, well, 2008 is a huge part of this, why it's getting worse.
00:35:18 You had all this like government bailout, economic collapse.
00:35:22 Massive inflationary spending.
00:35:24 And what Sternberg says in his book is he said fundamentally what the boomers who were in charge at the time did financially is they just took out more and more debt to cover these losses, and the debts will be called in fully and finally in 2050.
00:35:37 He said conveniently that's pretty much the end of the boomer generation.
00:35:41 Yeah, 1946 to 64 is the boomer generation. 0.60
00:35:44 Right. 0.99
00:35:44 So by 2050, they'll be dead.
00:35:47 That's reality.
00:35:47 Yeah. So but once they're dead and they've had their Social Security and everything else covered, then the millennials are going to inherit even more of this economic problem. 0.94
00:35:56 We've already seen it, as Dan pointed out, with inflation and some other things. 0.59
00:36:00 So that's the economic side. Are there any other levels for the boomer, this boomer divide between the other generations that you guys see that are not economic but are divisive?
00:36:12 Well, I think especially since I think we're going to talk about this phenomena in depth later.
00:36:16 Yes. So when I think about just this purely as a diagnostic, a symptom of fatherlessness, I think that what it shows, regardless of whether it's true or not, this is a key point. Regardless of whether all of the different reasons millennials and Zoomers might be frustrated with the baby boomers, regardless of whether they're justified in being frustrated, they are. They really are.
00:36:39 There's a real frustration.
00:36:40 They don't feel like they were fathered or loved or taken care of or given inheritance or set up.
00:36:46 They feel like this is just in the zeitgeist is the general consensus in popular culture that these later generations were robbed, that our dads did not think about us.
00:37:01 they thought about themselves, and not only did they not think about us, they actually stole from
00:37:06 us with a lot of their political, monetary, cultural decisions. We see things like the
00:37:11 sexual revolution coming to its height during this time, the 60s and 70s, and onwards. We see
00:37:19 things like out of this generation, this is a generation coming out of World War II, where we
00:37:23 really get to the height of the global American empire in its global warmongering, global police
00:37:29 officer, spending our money on foreign wars, inflationary spending. The young men have to go 0.52
00:37:35 fight these wars. Military industrial complex. So whether there are answers to exonerate
00:37:41 the boomer generation from a lot of these things or not, I think it's just important to see that 0.87
00:37:46 either way it shows the reality of fatherlessness, that there are whole generations following this 0.58
00:37:54 that at least are convinced that they are fatherless
00:37:59 or that their fathers have failed them.
00:38:01 It's interesting because one of the biggest retorts
00:38:03 in the articles and books that I've read about the boomers
00:38:06 is that when their kids complain,
00:38:10 so, you know, Gen X, millennials,
00:38:12 when they complain about the boomers,
00:38:14 one of the most common retorts from the boomers is,
00:38:18 well, yeah, I didn't have a father either.
00:38:20 So actually, this is a problem that predates boomers. 0.85
00:38:24 Right. It's really about a period of time that they were, that their parents were very fruitful after the war. There's an explosion in population. I think it's something like 25 million more boomers than millennials right now, even though they're, you know, dying off. Yeah. But there was a lot of them. That's part of it. Yeah. But they also had father problems there. 0.57
00:38:44 People call the boomer generation the pig in a python generation because it was this baby boom. 0.87
00:38:49 That's what's the boomers, the baby boom following the war. 0.77
00:38:52 So we lost a bunch of young men, come home, have a huge generation with lots of children, and it's like a python that swallowed a pig where you have this big lump going through. 0.54
00:39:05 And so one of the demographic features is that there is something actually unique.
00:39:10 It's not just the same.
00:39:11 There's something actually unique about the baby boomer generation, even demographically.
00:39:15 So I don't think it's wrong to isolate and ask questions about and say, what happened there?
00:39:21 What is going to result?
00:39:23 Because it really is.
00:39:24 It's weird.
00:39:26 Yeah.
00:39:26 And one guy said that really is you go from the baby boom generation onward.
00:39:32 You basically, every decade, even into the 80s, the key thing about the decade is what were the boomers doing during that decade?
00:39:40 so 70s 60s what were the boomers doing the 50s they were kids they were watching tv that shapes
00:39:46 a whole generation yeah that sort of thing dan closing thoughts on boomerism particularly as
00:39:53 you think about okay the pastoral issue maybe one of the things to bring up is malachi 4 6
00:39:58 it says this and he shall turn the heart of the fathers to the children and the heart of the
00:40:03 children to their fathers lest i come and smite the earth with a curse so i guess if you would
00:40:09 just connect for me, okay, we see the generational, there's a warning light on the dash, as Brian
00:40:13 said, but I guess so that we don't get blackpilled, how do you connect it with scripture and hope
00:40:22 and a path forward? Yeah, so I think some of the principles that are definitely difficult to thread
00:40:27 when you're looking at generational divides, especially when you, you know, it's one thing
00:40:31 to just speak generally about a generation. You know, you're just like, hey, this generation
00:40:37 stinks because of this you know my dad didn't didn't uh pass the bill you know for inflationary
00:40:44 spending like he didn't do that yeah you know so the real challenge becomes in honoring your father
00:40:50 and mother not um and not just absolutely blasting an entire generation like they yeah uh it might be
00:41:00 an unusual generation because of some you know socio-economic global political environment and
00:41:06 they they existed and there was a there's a lot of problems that that came from that but it doesn't
00:41:12 absolve you of your responsibilities um going forward or in looking back so looking back would
00:41:19 be in honoring your father and mother and not not uh rebuking older men like you would a younger man
00:41:25 and just being like hey i'm you know what you screwed up and i'm gonna let you know about it
00:41:31 all the time that's gonna be my new identity going forward is like yeah but these people 0.55
00:41:36 really stink you know and so looking forward you have responsibilities and that's really going to
00:41:43 be the main thrust of the season isn't just going to be like hey for the next 12 episodes we're going
00:41:48 to tell you about how bad you have it because we're gonna fuss yeah we're gonna fuss we're just
00:41:53 gonna fuss yeah yeah for 12 episodes because the thing is what's what's really going to this is
00:42:00 going to make things probably more difficult for people in a lot of ways and i'm sure we'll get
00:42:04 into it into the season, but as we repent of the sins of our fathers, which needs to happen in every
00:42:10 generation, right? That's what happens. Simply put, you know, when you have a bad father who
00:42:17 has a son, who then the son becomes a Christian and repents from generational sins, you have that
00:42:25 happening. Well, even the same thing if you had Christian fathers, as you look at their shortcomings 0.96
00:42:30 of, you know, their unique time, their product of time and culture. And as you begin to repent 1.00
00:42:34 of their sins, Lord willing, and you correct a lot of their errors, there will continue to be
00:42:41 inflammation between the generations, that generational divide. But the key is to not
00:42:47 be fussers, like Brian said. Don't be a fusser. Don't be a fusser. Honor your father and mother.
00:42:54 And one of the best ways you can do that is by repenting of their sins, but not telling them
00:42:59 that that's what you're doing and some of it is like some of some of us will have to be some of
00:43:04 you will have to be jonathans with a with a with saul as your father yeah and not walk in the sins
00:43:10 of your parents and some of them it will be that obvious you know my dad was a drunk my dad was uh
00:43:16 was also maybe my dad was a miserly greedy man who piled up a big pile of wealth and then told
00:43:21 all of his kids i'm giving this to the local dog clinic not you because i don't want to spoil you
00:43:27 or give you a bad lesson.
00:43:28 Because the dogs are better than you.
00:43:29 No, I won't help you.
00:43:30 And some of you have to repent of that.
00:43:33 But a lot of us will just have to, you know,
00:43:35 we'll have some mixture of really great gifts from your parents.
00:43:42 And then also things you look at them and you say,
00:43:45 man, they were sinning there or they weren't well-trained there.
00:43:48 And you have to do what your children are going to have to do.
00:43:52 My children are going to count.
00:43:53 Stand on your shoulders.
00:43:54 Man, Dad, Dad, I hope they say Dad was a faithful man.
00:43:57 He was a good father. He loved us. He cared for us. He left us inheritance. But Dad also had these
00:44:03 issues, and I hope not to walk in those. It's really difficult to do those. It takes wisdom,
00:44:10 self-control, godliness, humility, and it's the fruits of the Spirit we're talking about.
00:44:16 And that means that they're not just a few little hallmark card quips or proverbs that you can get
00:44:25 down and fix everything right away. What we're talking about are everyday long haul fruits of
00:44:31 the spirit sort of things. And so they're very difficult. They're going to take a long time.
00:44:36 Yeah. In some ways you can even say a lot of these things are in your blood.
00:44:39 Yeah.
00:44:40 That they're in your blood, like that you came from an angry house.
00:44:44 Yeah.
00:44:45 And that your generations have been angry people.
00:44:47 Yeah.
00:44:48 The work is going to be hard.
00:44:49 Yep.
00:44:50 But it should be a good work.
00:44:51 Yes.
00:44:52 Yeah, I think in many ways it's like inheriting a field and you realize, okay, they're stones.
00:44:57 So we clear that field, not only for ourselves, but for future generations.
00:45:01 And they're going to have to continue the work.
00:45:03 Yeah, and maybe the next generation will deal with erosion more, you know?
00:45:08 And then that'll be the next thing.
00:45:09 They took all the stones out.
00:45:10 Yes.
00:45:11 Well, also freeze-thaw cycles do cause stones to rise to the topsoil layer in a field.
00:45:14 So, I mean, new stones might pop up.
00:45:17 Wow, that's really depressing.
00:45:18 We just took that metaphor pretty far.
00:45:19 I picked all of the stones, and now there's more stones.
00:45:22 There's more stones.
00:45:23 Speaking, Dan, of more stones, we have another symptom of fatherlessness here.
00:45:28 This one I've labeled men hate going to church.
00:45:31 Of course, you can read the book by David Murrow, Why Men Hate Going to Church.
00:45:34 But I think suffice it to say there's a lot of problems why men aren't going to church.
00:45:38 We know that the number of them participating in the church has been on a decline cycle for a long time.
00:45:44 And so what you get is a spiritual, quote-unquote, space that is not being led by fathers and by men.
00:45:51 A number of examples have shown up.
00:45:54 I think Murrow mentions it in his book, but what are Father's Day sermons like versus what are Mother's Day sermons like?
00:46:00 Overall, just an environment where you typically don't see a lot of male engagement.
00:46:05 I know that's not necessarily true in our church.
00:46:07 We've been very fortunate, I think, because we've had masculine leadership that there are men here.
00:46:13 One of the things that Murrow claims, though, I find interesting,
00:46:15 he said that when you have young adult men, it brings vitality to the church
00:46:21 because they bring with them young women who they're married to,
00:46:24 young children, families.
00:46:26 It causes the church to thrive.
00:46:29 So I guess my question on this one for you guys,
00:46:32 I would think, as I've seen in pastoral counseling,
00:46:35 as we talk to these young men, because we do have them in our church, thank God,
00:46:40 And what I tend to see at just a very practical level is, wow, you lack a lot of just basic life skills, like what we talked about, these father skills.
00:46:52 So I guess talk about the church sphere.
00:46:53 Do you see it as a symptom of fatherlessness, what's going on in the church?
00:46:58 Yes, certainly.
00:46:59 And I think we actually see that as a self-diagnosis from lots of the young men in the church, that they would say maybe sitting down in some marriage counseling or just general,
00:47:09 hey I need advice on this issue and you start talking to them they'll say well here's the thing
00:47:13 this is how I learned it from my dad or even more common I just I never saw this like disciplining
00:47:22 kids is a good example that comes to mind where sometimes pastors think they can just say things
00:47:27 like hey make sure you discipline your kids regularly and consistently people are like I
00:47:31 don't actually know what that means but they're like how this is why so many young men when they
00:47:35 hear pastors talking on masculinity and femininity. They're saying, stop, okay, get out of the
00:47:42 principles and give me application, because I don't know how to do what you're—I don't have
00:47:46 enough information already to connect my life to that principle. One of the laws of teaching
00:47:52 is that you have to connect the new information to some pre-existing handhold in the information
00:47:59 the person already knows. So if you just say, for example, man up or love your wife or cherish your
00:48:06 wife, well, a lot of these guys grew up and their dad either never showed them that, or they
00:48:12 literally didn't have one, or their dad showed them the worst possible way of dealing with that
00:48:17 issue. So you end up with guys on this huge body of life from basic things like, oh, I'm supposed
00:48:26 to like, when I think about money, I shouldn't just think about, can I make the monthly payment?
00:48:30 That's not a healthy way of thinking about budget. All the way to, I thought I was being,
00:48:36 I didn't know I was being a terrible, toxic, angry husband and ruining the environment of my
00:48:40 wife's life. This is just how I thought you did it. Yeah. In a lot of ways, we've probably all
00:48:45 had jobs like this where you start some entry-level position and your training is like,
00:48:50 this is where you punch in and then here's your uniform. Good luck. Yeah. Here's your job. Go do
00:48:55 it and except yeah and you so you don't know anything about anything right you're stumbling 0.98
00:49:01 around looking like a fool except this is how a lot of men have to operate in their lives day to 0.88
00:49:08 day is that they're untrained yeah in life and so yeah you do see that in in the church and i think 0.95
00:49:15 men not going to church is is a definitely a symptom of that in a few ways the first way is
00:49:23 kind of like what you said, Brian, is you get these pithy like punch at men sort of comments,
00:49:29 but it's not a very well aimed punch. Like it's, it's not a, like a, a really good punch for men
00:49:35 is like a punch in the shoulder. Like, Hey, bozo, like, come on. Yeah. You know, like a fatherly
00:49:40 sort of punch. Like I give to my sons all the time when I'm wrestling. I'm like, not a shot
00:49:45 to the groin. No, not a shot to the groin. You know, when, when you, um, when you discipline
00:49:49 your son out of anger for something that he was ignorant on, that is, that is like abuse.
00:49:56 You know, your son doesn't know any better because you didn't teach him and then you
00:50:00 discipline for him, you know, for that, uh, that can be, I mean, man, that's horrible.
00:50:05 It'll crush the souls of, of your boys. And so, so many of, of men that are Christians 1.00
00:50:12 that are going to church, they either get that to where they're, they're getting hit 0.98
00:50:16 for being ignorant, or the other one is that it is so effeminate that it is degrading to be a man 0.93
00:50:26 and go to church because of the songs you have to sing, the messages that you hear, and then you're 0.98
00:50:31 being nagged at either by women or by men who could be classified as women. You have a whole
00:50:38 selection process for elders, and church cultures are mainly dominated by women because there are
00:50:44 more women go to church than not. 0.97
00:50:45 So the selection process for elders in the church
00:50:48 is influenced heavily by women in many churches. 0.97
00:50:51 Who can please those women? 0.97
00:50:52 Yeah, so who will please the ladies in the church
00:50:54 is not actually the same answer as who will be a godly pastor.
00:50:58 So men also come to church,
00:51:01 and they basically are told that almost every aspect
00:51:06 of how they naturally, like the natural creational way of being a man,
00:51:10 the things you care about naturally,
00:51:11 that most of them are not just not important.
00:51:15 They're actually sinful.
00:51:17 Like an example would be the dominion-taking feature of masculinity
00:51:23 where a guy wants to go turn a profit, start a business,
00:51:25 employ some people, make some changes.
00:51:28 He wants to do stuff.
00:51:29 And they're like, that's ambitious, and you need to repent. 1.00
00:51:32 Yeah, you need to kill that. 0.95
00:51:33 And you just need to think about missions more. 0.98
00:51:36 Well, you think about the most popular books.
00:51:38 And theology more.
00:51:39 I think like Dane Ortlund's book, like Meek and Lowly.
00:51:41 Yeah.
00:51:42 Well, surely there's some meekness and lowliness to Christ.
00:51:45 I'm not going to argue with that, but is that the full picture of Jesus?
00:51:48 You know, one of the things that's been completely neutered from the church is danger.
00:51:52 It's the idea that you are a danger.
00:51:54 You're made for danger.
00:51:55 Yeah, you're made for danger.
00:51:56 And I can say that's true because you can read the Chronicles of Narnia where the question
00:52:01 is asked about Aslan, like, is he dangerous?
00:52:04 Is he safe?
00:52:04 Is he safe?
00:52:05 They're like, no, he's not.
00:52:07 Heck no.
00:52:07 But he's good.
00:52:08 Brian will know this, but from Lord of the Rings.
00:52:10 I think it's Gimli says to Gandalf
00:52:13 You are fraught with dangers yourself, Gimli
00:52:15 Isn't Fangorn dangerous?
00:52:17 Yeah, isn't he?
00:52:18 Were you going there too?
00:52:19 Yeah, I had been thinking about that
00:52:21 That's why I was so quiet
00:52:22 Is because I was going to go there
00:52:24 And then you stole it from me
00:52:25 We are like three peas in a pod
00:52:27 We are, we really are
00:52:29 And so the message of saying
00:52:32 Men, especially young men
00:52:35 You are strong, you have zeal
00:52:37 You are dangerous
00:52:38 you know and that can be a good thing or it can be a bad thing but that whole message has been
00:52:43 completely neutered from the church and so it's far better what i mean is is that the church has
00:52:49 failed men as church fathers not just in the house but that's definitely part of it is because 0.57
00:52:56 they've essentially said men you cannot be dangerous you have to be more like women instead 0.55
00:53:03 of saying, I mean, I would rather join a church that said, hey, we're going to take the gates
00:53:09 of hell. Grab your weapon. Let's go. Like this. The apostle John, who is known as the apostle 0.73
00:53:18 of love, writes continually about love. Love one another, brothers. 1 John 2.14, he says,
00:53:24 I write to you fathers because you know him who is from the beginning. This is the father. He's
00:53:29 saying, basically, I write to you, Father, because you know the Father. I write to you,
00:53:33 young men, because you are strong, and the Word of God abides in you, and you have overcome the
00:53:39 evil one. You're fighters. How many sermons have you heard in your life where the pastor got up,
00:53:44 and he says, young men, you are the glory of God. You are strong. You have overcome the evil one.
00:53:50 Most people would be like, is Osteen up in here? You're like, no, no, actually, the Apostle John,
00:53:55 the beloved apostle of Jesus.
00:53:57 Why do we do it behind the mic?
00:53:58 Let's go get our weapons.
00:53:59 Let's do it.
00:54:00 Let's go.
00:54:01 And the men in the church,
00:54:02 this is the thing.
00:54:03 Who can we fight?
00:54:05 Effeminate leadership
00:54:06 thinks that they change the men
00:54:08 by making them feel ashamed of themselves,
00:54:11 of where they're bad.
00:54:13 Young men don't hear that. 0.97
00:54:13 Why can't you just be more like your wife? 0.97
00:54:15 Yeah. 0.98
00:54:15 Young men don't hear 1 John 2.14, though, 1.00
00:54:18 and go, I am perfect. 0.99
00:54:20 No. 1.00
00:54:21 Any Christian man that hears that 0.97
00:54:22 is immediately thinking like,
00:54:25 I know how sinful I am.
00:54:28 I know my problems.
00:54:29 It's the warrior's conundrum, right?
00:54:32 Where the biggest fear of a warrior is, will I be courageous?
00:54:37 Yes, will I prove that?
00:54:38 When the time of testing comes, will I run?
00:54:40 I hope I'm not a coward.
00:54:43 You read this a lot in World War II narratives to where when the fighting gets hot, that's what's going on in these men's mind.
00:54:50 It's like, am I going to be able to die with honor?
00:54:53 Am I going to be able to fight with honor, or am I going to run away like a coward?
00:54:57 Oh, hey, whoa.
00:54:59 We need to save some of this fire for the agon.
00:55:01 In a minute.
00:55:02 In a minute.
00:55:03 Yes.
00:55:03 Because I want to put a pin in that, because this is agon stuff.
00:55:06 This is beautiful.
00:55:07 We've got to get there in a minute.
00:55:08 So I think dovetailing then with the next one, which is number four on our list,
00:55:13 the church, I think, failing this gospel-centered preaching that gives no practical aids,
00:55:18 it really leads to the next thing, which is the red pill movement and intellectual dark web.
00:55:22 Absolutely. 0.96
00:55:22 I think these are like Absalom categories, right? 0.98
00:55:25 This is where men are being stolen away to.
00:55:28 So, Brian, just talk about—do you agree with that, first of all?
00:55:32 Yeah, absolutely. 0.78
00:55:33 I mean, the red pill movement is basically a result of the church abandoning proper teaching and instruction on the formation of men, where nobody knew how to be a man anymore. 0.73
00:55:47 We started to put forward a model for the ideal man as the pastor, because the pastor is supposed to be a man you can imitate in a church, that was selected by women for traits that were feminine to the detriment, and then slowly even shifting to now masculine traits that are actually good and godly and glorious when they're pointed at the right thing, are almost talked about as de facto just sin. 0.86
00:56:12 So what you get is Absalom. When David steps back and lets sin run rampant in his family and is passive, nature abhors a vacuum. That's not just going to be a father slot that remains open. It's going to be a job opening. 0.63
00:56:29 And so you'll have Absalom step in that say, oh, the church, this Christian Western culture
00:56:34 that was supposed to teach you how to be a Christian man or woman in every part of what
00:56:39 it means to be human.
00:56:40 Oh, they're not teaching you about sex.
00:56:42 They're not teaching you about physical health.
00:56:43 They're not teaching you about dominion taking and vocation.
00:56:46 Okay, we'll come in. 0.95
00:56:47 We'll teach you how to pick up women, sleep with 100 women. 1.00
00:56:49 We'll teach you how to make a ton of money and build your own Tower of Babel.
00:56:54 We'll come in and we'll teach you how to get people to respect you, how to carry yourself
00:56:58 with gravity so that people are scared of you. We'll teach you how to become a dangerous fit man
00:57:03 and no guns and no martial arts. And whether it's in a Southern gun culture way or a pseudo
00:57:10 intellectual philosophical way or an Andrew Tate way or an Andrew Tate way, that's just fully
00:57:15 wicked, completely debased. You're going to get the red, whatever you call it in whatever
00:57:21 generation, you're going to get an Absalom movement that steps in and wins the hearts of the 0.95
00:57:28 men to the wrong end. And what was fascinating to me, so last year I spoke at this red pill 0.90
00:57:38 conference, basically like did a lot of degenerate stuff. And they invited me because I'm a Christian.
00:57:44 They wanted some Christians. Michael Foster had been there before, cultivated some relationships.
00:57:49 And so, and I told them like, you know, I'm going to be just obnoxiously Christian and tell people 0.72
00:57:53 to repent to their sexual sin and trust Christ. Right. And they're like, yeah, that's fine. 0.82
00:57:56 And I was on a panel and there was this guy who is basically like into philosophy and he was a speaker and he started talking.
00:58:05 The founder just sent me the clip yesterday.
00:58:08 He started talking about what it meant for him to succeed in getting everything that he had been told by this red pill that he was supposed to want.
00:58:17 He's like you get into – he starts talking in this Ecclesiastes way. 1.00
00:58:21 He's not a Christian. 0.98
00:58:22 He's like, look, if you get every craziest sexual fantasy you've ever had fulfilled by every woman you could ever want, he says, it's pleasurable in the moment, but where it takes you is hell. 0.99
00:58:33 He said, I'm in hell. 0.98
00:58:35 Really?
00:58:36 Hellish.
00:58:37 That's how he described it.
00:58:38 And he said, more and more, I'm thinking that maybe there's something to this.
00:58:43 Maybe the answer is to live the Christian dogma.
00:58:46 That's what he said.
00:58:47 Wow.
00:58:47 So what you get is you get this huge swing that actually ends up, in the name of empowering men, it will destroy men.
00:58:56 And that's what we're seeing.
00:58:58 That is, it's abdication of fatherhood in the church.
00:59:01 So what do you get?
00:59:02 You get Absalom's.
00:59:03 It's interesting, too, because, like, with the men going their own way, I've seen a lot of these guys. 0.98
00:59:07 I usually have to block them on my post.
00:59:09 Yeah.
00:59:10 Because they're like, hey, marriage is a bad deal. 1.00
00:59:12 Don't do it.
00:59:13 So you just turn away completely from any source of biblical wisdom principle.
00:59:19 Right, because that was the original red pill, I believe, of this movement, if I'm not mistaken, where it's like you're going to work hard, get married, buy a house, have a kid.
00:59:31 She's going to commit adultery. 0.95
00:59:34 She's going to leave you and take your house and your kids and half your income, and then you're going to get screwed. 0.98
00:59:39 I mean, your whole life, you're behind. 1.00
00:59:41 They're going to assume that you're evil, she's great, because we worship women as gods,
00:59:46 we think men are evil, so then you get Rollo and Jocko and Joe Rogan and Jordan Peterson.
00:59:51 And so their answer is, just don't get married and sleep with as many women as you can.
00:59:56 Yeah, take advantage of women, that sort of thing. 0.59
00:59:59 I think it does tie closely to the next point as well, which is, I've said that men lack initiatory rights,
01:00:05 so as a result, society is full of immature, uninitiated men.
01:00:10 So I think it's kind of the response to Absalom is wise fathers, Proverbs.
01:00:16 A wise father, older men, who would come alongside younger men and lead them into masculinity.
01:00:22 Dan, we've talked about this quite a bit, but it comes from the fairy tale Iron John, also a book by Robert Bly.
01:00:29 And there's this moment in the fairy tale when the boy is carried off on this wild man's shoulders.
01:00:34 It is symbolic of an historically rooted practice in virtually every culture.
01:00:39 Men separating from the world of mothers and children and then being initiated by older and other men than their fathers.
01:00:46 And what they're being initiated into is a world of men, war, craftsmanship.
01:00:51 So Robert Bly writes this.
01:00:53 In our culture, there is no such moment of initiation. 0.99
01:00:57 The boys in our culture have a continuing need for initiation into male spirit, but old men in general do not offer it. 0.77
01:01:03 The fault is that the old men outside the nuclear family no longer offer an effective way for the son to break with his parents without doing himself harm. 0.51
01:01:11 The ancient societies believe that a boy becomes a man only through ritual and effort, only through the active intervention of the older men, end quote. 0.58
01:01:20 So I just want to ask you about that first, Dan.
01:01:23 Do you agree with this?
01:01:24 Do you feel like there's a problem with initiatory rights? 0.99
01:01:28 Maybe Bly's right. 1.00
01:01:29 I think he says elsewhere, he says, yes, the, the old men who should be initiating the younger
01:01:33 men and their grandsons are in Arizona RVing, I think was his line. Wow. So the retirement culture
01:01:40 of the boomers was like, Hey, forget those young people. Yeah. But it's to say to the older guys, 0.89
01:01:46 like, like Kings hall, it's not just for young guys, but if you're an older guy,
01:01:50 you have a responsibility and a role to play in what happens in the coming generations to
01:01:56 Agree, disagree, Dan? 0.90
01:01:58 Yeah, I agree.
01:01:58 I agree.
01:01:59 And I'll use a different illustration.
01:02:01 So my wife, my first child, before we went all crazy and did like home births and stuff like that, we had a hospital birth for our firstborn.
01:02:11 And my wife, she gets a, you know, she's leaving the hospital.
01:02:15 She gets like this gift basket, right?
01:02:17 Yeah.
01:02:17 Full of a whole bunch of stuff to help her.
01:02:19 And on the front, it says, welcome to motherhood or welcome to the society of motherhood.
01:02:25 Something along those lines, like you have arrived, you are one of us, you are a mother.
01:02:32 And the thing that Bly taps into, and even, you know, it's interesting with the retirement
01:02:37 culture, John Piper actually, when he talks about seashells, like don't waste your life,
01:02:42 you know, you're like, he was blasting them.
01:02:45 His target was off though, because it was essentially like, you should go do third world
01:02:52 missions is what really what you should do. And that's, that's not the answer for most cases.
01:02:57 It's not the answer, but he did tap into the issue and that's, there is no initiatory rights
01:03:03 for men to say like, Hey son, you're one of us. You are now a man. And not just to have fathers,
01:03:13 but other fathers, like other men to say like, come here, son, you are now one of us.
01:03:19 So many men long for that and hunger for that.
01:03:23 And Eric and I have talked about this a lot on other podcasts, but, you know, in hunting, this is so often what happens is you get a boy with his first kill.
01:03:32 Oh, big time.
01:03:33 And the rituals around that are like, you know, put blood on your face, eat liver or heart, you know, or something like, something just like an initiatory rite, even if it's rudimentary, you know, from a bunch of guys.
01:03:45 Or actively pagan.
01:03:46 Beer guts or, yeah, whatever it is.
01:03:48 But it's all universally true, is that what they're saying is that because you went through the same thing we did, you are now one of us.
01:03:58 And all of those men, or most of those men in our case, have abandoned their responsibilities.
01:04:06 And a lot of it is because they weren't initiated either.
01:04:09 No.
01:04:10 They weren't initiated either.
01:04:11 And so this is a generational thing.
01:04:13 And what it takes, man, I remember this moment.
01:04:16 I have a good dad who was present and faithful to my mom, not in sexual sin or not an angry man,
01:04:25 not, you know, a good dad, good Christian dad, led us to church every Sunday and didn't start
01:04:31 his adult life as a Christian. So just an amazing testimony to God's grace and disrupting from
01:04:38 family in many cases of alcoholism and radical dysfunction to the left and right and behind us
01:04:45 on my mom and my dad's side to where I don't even know my mom's. I don't know my maternal
01:04:49 grandfather's name, nor does my mom, because he was just, you know, abandoned them. But my dad,
01:04:56 I remember this moment that even though we didn't have, we still don't, we still need to do a good
01:05:03 job of recovering these. They don't all have to be like this big elaborate ceremony. For me,
01:05:08 it was this moment where I did Boy Scouts when Boy Scouts were still boys with a bunch of military 0.67
01:05:13 old, old guys. And so it was really masculine, very masculine environment for like seven years,
01:05:18 a lot of outdoors stuff, a lot of suffering in the wilderness kind of stuff. And I remember this
01:05:24 moment where my dad and I had decided to start a troop, a new Boy Scout troop at a church rather
01:05:30 than the one on the military base. And so we, we had planned and we were leading this troop out to
01:05:35 the city of rocks in Idaho for this camp. And my dad had essentially said, okay, you, you teach
01:05:43 them how to do rock climbing and stuff and you teach them this so you give me responsibility
01:05:47 and we we had planned this whole thing we got there early to set up and i just like
01:05:51 seared in my memory is this moment my dad probably doesn't even remember this i've never talked to
01:05:56 him about it but he was like i was 18 and we sat down and he opens a cooler if you're fed stop
01:06:04 listening and he gives me a beer like 18 year old and it was like there we were we had we had planned
01:06:12 this thing we were now gonna help these 11 12 13 14 year old guys and he was like you're a man
01:06:18 here have a beer let's do this thing there was nobody there it wasn't this elaborate thing but
01:06:25 like that was huge for this young 18 year old still a kid like you know not at my own house
01:06:34 my own wife my own anything but it was like my dad saying you are a man and and 99 of young men
01:06:45 today would never hear that will never have that well they just will never have anything approaching
01:06:50 that it's kind of the joke right that um again i think i mentioned it before but it's a meme
01:06:55 which says like that nobody talks about the true miracle of jesus life that he had 12 friends in
01:07:00 his 30s yeah um men lack it gets to our next point men lack a platoon male only spaces boy scouts vfw
01:07:09 these things are largely going away i think one of the issues is that fatherhood like masculinity
01:07:14 is largely something bestowed by other men right you need to be confirmed among other men i was
01:07:20 thinking ordination the other week was so powerful because it's the men that you respect most saying
01:07:28 to you you're in yeah we approve yeah that's such a pivotal thing uh that is missing in our world
01:07:36 so anthony eselin writes about this i think it's really helpful how men need these platoons these
01:07:42 hierarchical groupings and he says this until people made a pointed effort at making girls
01:07:46 more like boys there is no instance that i can recall of girls or women spontaneously coming
01:07:51 together in teams for competitive sports so true the team is an anthropological constant for the
01:07:57 males of our species the activities of the team reflect or they make evident the structures of
01:08:03 masculine organization in arts and letters the masculine team may be a necessary feature for
01:08:07 the education of boys without it many a lads simply will not learn so compare that to 2019
01:08:15 dan the boy scouts changed its name to scouts bsa or the gay bsa is what it should have been
01:08:21 yeah a change that reflected the inclusion of girls into the once male only space yeah again
01:08:27 And we've seen similar things.
01:08:28 I remember growing up in Colorado when Katie Nida, her dad was a news anchor for one of the stations.
01:08:34 She insisted, they insisted that she participate on the CU Buffs football team.
01:08:40 Later, there were rape allegations, blah, blah, blah, huge problem.
01:08:43 Well, I think any father probably could have seen this was a problem.
01:08:46 Yeah.
01:08:47 And why is it a problem?
01:08:47 Because, again, we need mail-only spaces, but because of equality, we're not allowed to have them.
01:08:53 Do you agree?
01:08:54 Do you see this as a sign of a bigger issue?
01:08:57 Man, Dan, your point about birth is such a good point. 1.00
01:09:02 I mean, and you have these women-only spaces,
01:09:04 these women initiatory rights in some ways where it's like, 0.97
01:09:06 welcome, you know, but they don't let men. 1.00
01:09:09 You're not allowed to have male-only spaces anymore. 0.75
01:09:12 No, if you were to have a men's-only club, 0.99
01:09:14 I mean, immediately there would be lawsuits. 0.97
01:09:17 I feel like that's probably the case.
01:09:20 But, I mean, the reason—
01:09:21 Well, Augusta—I'm sorry to interrupt, but Augusta National Golf,
01:09:25 every year it's a huge thing because they were like, 0.95
01:09:27 we're petitioning for the lady golfers to be included and they're like no this is a men's
01:09:32 golf club but it's a huge point it still is yeah wow amazing good for them good for based man we
01:09:39 need we need to start golf is awesome yeah i mean they didn't even like it these men's only spaces
01:09:44 are are necessary uh and and it's proved just if you've ever seen teenage boys and how they
01:09:51 interact with one another, and then you introduce a girl into the room, things change radically.
01:09:59 Things change radically. The body, the posturing, the activities, the sorts of things that they do,
01:10:06 it's completely different. Women ruin male-only spaces. 1.00
01:10:11 Absolutely. Even one of the things with Boy Scouts, I happen to have almost all male leaders, 1.00
01:10:18 but you could have female leaders, and it's a lot of the Christian alternatives to scouting that
01:10:23 have cropped up. The problem with them is they're actually still too politically correct. They still 1.00
01:10:28 have mother leaders involved in the Boy Scout thing, and women won't understand this. It 1.00
01:10:34 actually hurts their feelings a lot of time to hear this kind of thing, but women, you actually
01:10:39 need to go away sometimes, and you need to make sure that your boys and your husband and men
01:10:44 have male-only spaces and don't ruin them by showing up or trying to be included.
01:10:49 It's amazing how bonding is different.
01:10:51 My wife even says this because I've said in years past, I said, hey, do you want to go hunting with me and the boys?
01:10:56 She's like, absolutely not.
01:10:58 Yeah.
01:10:58 You guys need space where you can – the dynamics is just so much different.
01:11:03 By the way, correction, a sad correction.
01:11:06 I looked this up while we were talking.
01:11:08 Oh, no.
01:11:08 Is it –
01:11:09 Augusta is –
01:11:09 Augusta, they caved.
01:11:12 See, another one falls.
01:11:13 They've been admitting – this one is from 2017.
01:11:16 They've been admitting, like, Condoleezza Rice, other power women.
01:11:19 Condoleezza Rice? 0.98
01:11:21 Power women? 1.00
01:11:22 Oh, my God. 1.00
01:11:22 Power. 0.98
01:11:23 The pantsuit-wearing demographic. 1.00
01:11:25 Get out of here. 1.00
01:11:27 You okay?
01:11:29 I couldn't have said it better myself.
01:11:31 Nigerian camera guy.
01:11:33 I can't remember what his name is. 0.98
01:11:35 So we agree that men need male-only spaces.
01:11:38 One of the other ones tied, again, very closely to this.
01:11:40 I said men lack a meaningful agon.
01:11:44 So, again, this is why I think you have things like Fight Club.
01:11:47 Why was it so popular?
01:11:49 Basically because you have immature boys finding destructive, narcissistic ways to try to pursue masculinity in a world where there is no space for that.
01:11:58 I do think that there was a lot to learn from something like Fight Club.
01:12:01 What's the attraction?
01:12:03 Again, it tends to be a very Absalon-type space.
01:12:07 But as Anthony Esselin has pointed out, men learn best in the context of an adventure or a fight or an agon.
01:12:15 But we're not, Dan.
01:12:15 We're not allowed to have those.
01:12:17 No.
01:12:17 Our words are violence.
01:12:18 Violence is toxically masculine. 0.99
01:12:21 We need to put those things to death. 0.97
01:12:22 James Cameron said that testosterone— 1.00
01:12:24 Are you gay? 0.99
01:12:25 What? 0.88
01:12:26 Are you gay? 1.00
01:12:27 You are gay. 1.00
01:12:27 James Cameron said that testosterone itself needs to be banished. 1.00
01:12:32 Well, it's being banished.
01:12:34 I think they're pretty successful.
01:12:36 But, Dan, just briefly, why do men need a combat zone for ideas and their bodies? 0.91
01:12:42 Yeah, I think there's a certain safetyism that comes with mothering.
01:12:46 I mean, it's kind of built into mothering.
01:12:50 It's a verb.
01:12:51 There's action there, meaning like, hey, nice, nice.
01:12:55 Be safe.
01:12:56 Be careful.
01:12:57 Don't do that.
01:12:58 Don't climb there.
01:12:59 Don't do this.
01:12:59 You know, the other day I was looking for a taekwondo or jujitsu gym for my boys.
01:13:05 I've got four boys.
01:13:06 they fight constantly i mean it's just like you know that's what boys do and i was like well i
01:13:12 mean at least i should train them how to you know take a punch and to deliver a punch but all of
01:13:16 these gyms are like co-ed yeah they're co-ed so they're gonna have to fight girls that was a
01:13:21 problem we ran into as well yeah like no no you do not fight girls anyway anyway yeah the point
01:13:27 is that men need this because they need male-only spaces and boys need male-only spaces because like
01:13:32 we talked about earlier they're dangerous it's a design feature like it's actually a good thing
01:13:37 to have a dangerous man pointed at the right enemy it's a really good thing but if you have 0.95
01:13:43 the feminine instinct which is the the feminine is a very important part of family society life 0.67
01:13:50 but if you have that feminine instinct of safetyism and protection and nurturing it kills the thing 1.00
01:13:58 It kills the thing. How can you learn how to be a dangerous man that is potent in winning the girl, in taking dominion, in being strong if you have someone over your shoulder constantly saying, no, too dangerous. No, too risky. Don't do that. Don't climb that. Don't lift that.
01:14:21 You could get hurt. You could do this. You could do that. Like always at the forefront of your mind, there's risk there. Red alert. Don't go any further. There's risk. Whereas the masculine should say, heck yeah, there's risk. Let's do it. What if we lose? Then we lose with honor.
01:14:39 Yeah. And the problem is there is no such thing as a safe man. A soft man is the most dangerous man of all. He can destroy a whole world. So it's not as if you're going to declaw men. If you declaw men, you make them more dangerous.
01:14:55 because then they give way, they stop fighting, they stop building,
01:15:00 they stop cultivating, they stop doing the things that men obsessively were made to do.
01:15:06 Even things like inventing.
01:15:08 The greatest artists and inventors are men historically, and it's not an accident.
01:15:15 It's because they were meant to aggressively throw themselves into things in a way that builds worlds.
01:15:21 And when you neuter, when you cut their testicles off and you do it by removing all of their places of struggle and removing all the male influence and removing all of the fathers and you just give them mothers of both sexes, then what you end up doing is you actually make the most dangerous man of all. 0.99
01:15:36 The fat, soft, low-T loser. 0.99
01:15:39 And I also think – like we've talked about the physical, but it also ties into intellectual. 0.99
01:15:44 Brian, you've talked a lot about how it's such an awkward thing like when there's ladies on Twitter like arguing.
01:15:50 Oh, yeah. 1.00
01:15:50 And Beth Moore is the master of actually detonating a whole conversation with a very manipulative feminist approach, right? 0.97
01:15:58 Because when a woman enters and says, oh, no, these mean boys are being mean to me, well, it changes where you're no longer able to have this intellectual fight. 0.99
01:16:07 Can't do combat. 0.89
01:16:08 No.
01:16:09 It's an interesting quote.
01:16:11 Ethelon says this.
01:16:13 The whole of rational life, as John Milton conceives it, is an agon, an adventure, and a fight.
01:16:18 We must fight because it is for us men of the essence of virtue itself, whether physical or intellectual.
01:16:25 So for us to progress as men, we need these spaces to fight.
01:16:28 If courage is the testing point of every virtue, and it is, and you remove all situations or you attempt to build a world where courage will no longer be needed, you're actually eliminating virtue itself.
01:16:40 Virtues no longer have the possibility of being tempered by heat.
01:16:43 It's like all you can get is low-grade steel for the rest of forever because you're never going to get men who actually know how to take a punch intellectually and verbally and relationally.
01:16:52 And men will have to in the world that exists right now.
01:16:56 I mean, men will have to.
01:16:57 If you take it away, it's not that they're not going to do anything.
01:17:00 It's that they're going to build a hellscape.
01:17:03 They're going to build a bureaucratic mothering hellscape. 0.69
01:17:05 Like they're just going to ruin everything in churches and society and families. 1.00
01:17:09 They're going to give way to the feminine everywhere. 1.00
01:17:13 And the feminine will become a monster. 1.00
01:17:14 So, like, when you lose the masculine, the feminine also becomes this she-beast hydra that destroys everything. 1.00
01:17:22 She-beast. 1.00
01:17:22 She-beast, you know?
01:17:24 So it's very difficult to overstate how important it is that men and boys get this, get this time and these spaces and that we create them and recover them.
01:17:39 Yeah. The importance of fighting and the masculine is, is, is hugely important. I remember when I was in grade school, um, I had a, uh, I, I caught an interception at recess and returning for a touchdown. And I was doing some sort of celebration dance. Right. One of the kids made fun of me, punched him right in the face, right in the nose. And I, I, the thing is he was, he was stronger than me. And after I did that, I was like, Oh no, what is he going to do? You know what happened? We became best friends.
01:18:08 He was like, yeah, I deserve that.
01:18:10 Yeah, yeah. 0.91
01:18:11 But I guarantee you, two girls fight, guess what? 1.00
01:18:15 The feud is on for life. 1.00
01:18:17 Even to this day, my wife talks about fights she had with this other lady that, anyway, 1.00
01:18:23 has the same name. 1.00
01:18:24 This is how names, baby names, get taken off the table.
01:18:26 Yes, yes it is.
01:18:27 No, we can't name her Cindy.
01:18:28 I knew a Cindy in third grade. 1.00
01:18:30 She was a real piece of work. 1.00
01:18:32 Piece of work is what I was, she was bad. 1.00
01:18:35 Yes, that's what you were looking for. 1.00
01:18:36 She was mean. 1.00
01:18:37 She was mean to me. 1.00
01:18:37 She was a witchy lady. 1.00
01:18:38 She was witchy. 1.00
01:18:40 There you go.
01:18:41 That's how, and every husband who's tried to name a daughter knows this.
01:18:44 You absolutely know it.
01:18:45 You've proposed a name and found out that there was a feud somewhere that has taken a name.
01:18:50 And it's still continuing to this day.
01:18:52 You're like, I'm sure she grew out of whatever happened in third grade.
01:18:54 She's fine.
01:18:55 She's probably fine.
01:18:56 Actually, she's probably not.
01:18:56 Are you on Cindy's side now?
01:18:58 The odds are.
01:18:59 No, no, no, no, no.
01:19:01 Cindy, we're sorry.
01:19:02 Cindy, I'm so sorry.
01:19:03 Gentlemen, I want to close.
01:19:05 We've got two points.
01:19:06 We're going to devote other episodes to these, so we don't have to go too in-depth here.
01:19:10 But I think worth mentioning signs of fatherlessness.
01:19:14 And the first one would be the sexual chaos, largely stemming from the sexual revolution, post-1960s, all that good stuff.
01:19:21 But when you think about things like immodesty, right?
01:19:25 I was watching a—I think it was a football game.
01:19:28 It was a Michigan football game, and they were getting absolutely destroyed by TCU.
01:19:32 and they were showing like the quarterback sister and she's in the crowd and she's got like a tube
01:19:37 top and daisy dukes and her dad is standing right there and i'm just cringing and going to change
01:19:43 the channel as they keep zooming in on them and one of my sons said why does that father do nothing
01:19:50 and it really struck me because i was thinking wow that's actually the i think the key point
01:19:58 here why is dad standing there watching her dress like that and not saying anything so brian agree
01:20:04 disagree it seems like a lot of the sexual chaos that we're facing is fathers who didn't do what
01:20:08 god did in the garden which is no no no no more clothes yep protect nurture love pour into not
01:20:17 leave this gaping void of affection that needs to be sought by every man not teaching daughters that
01:20:26 they have this temptation before them always to try and manipulate and seek their validation
01:20:33 wanting attention by sexual attention to be lusted after by a thousand men instead of
01:20:37 faithful to one man and this is all father hunger even even i think if you push back and said what
01:20:44 about mothers and there's we're not doing a season on motherhood so it's like but but even
01:20:48 the motherhood is designed to sort of nest under the covering of fatherhood so a lot of the issues
01:20:57 you see with daughters you also see with men who would not correct their wives and so now the wives 0.99
01:21:04 are discipling the daughters to be hoes you literally see this where they're taking them out 0.99
01:21:09 they're teaching them to be obsessed in vain with their appearance to where oh she it's fine she 1.00
01:21:15 looks great. This is the fashion
01:21:17 now, honey. You just don't understand.
01:21:19 I mean, sexual chaos
01:21:21 is the result of unself-controlled
01:21:23 men who
01:21:25 give way.
01:21:27 Yeah, you have fathers that
01:21:29 are supposed to show their daughters that they're
01:21:31 actually a treasure. They're something
01:21:33 to be sought after.
01:21:35 They're valuable.
01:21:37 Glory of man. And therefore,
01:21:39 a treasure must be protected.
01:21:40 It must be protected. You're valuable enough
01:21:43 that you must be protected instead of just displayed
01:21:45 like on a football screen in front of millions of people.
01:21:49 I've had to have this conversation already 0.94
01:21:51 with one of my little ladies 1.00
01:21:52 because she's very feminine. 1.00
01:21:54 She is an absolute queenlet, as I call her. 0.99
01:21:58 And I've had to tell her 1.00
01:21:59 because she was frustrated with Mama one day
01:22:01 about why Mama wouldn't let her wear some clothing 1.00
01:22:05 without a dress. 1.00
01:22:06 Like, you can't wear these pants, these legging things
01:22:09 without the dress to come down your knees.
01:22:11 and I had to take her aside 0.99
01:22:13 because she was a little, little lady 1.00
01:22:15 real frustrated with mama
01:22:17 and I'm like, mama's loving you right now
01:22:19 she's protecting you
01:22:20 and not because you're shameful
01:22:23 but because you're glorious
01:22:24 you are a treasure, you're a crown
01:22:26 and I just think of how many
01:22:29 little girls grow up
01:22:30 where they don't have any of that 0.96
01:22:33 nobody's telling them
01:22:34 just like nobody's telling a young man
01:22:36 you're strong 0.97
01:22:38 your strength matters, you're supposed to be dangerous
01:22:41 You're supposed to have ambition.
01:22:42 You're supposed to love the Lord and your people and go do hard things.
01:22:45 Don't punch your sister.
01:22:46 Don't punch your sister. 0.92
01:22:48 No, actually now they're telling him go to the jujitsu gym and punch another person's sister.
01:22:52 But no one's telling the young ladies that they are a glory and that they are – that glory is supposed to be a gift and a crown.
01:23:04 Yeah, their value is – it's funny because no little girl that's grown up in the last 30 years has doubted their value.
01:23:11 Yeah. It's like, well, you know, you rock girl, you know, whatever you can do anything, whatever. But it, it's a misplaced value because it's not just for any passing, passing guy. Like you are too valuable to be displayed this way. And, and so there's that lack of affection from fathers to daughters that have shown like, this is what right affection looks like towards a daughter.
01:23:33 But the same thing could be said about a son and directing him as far as promiscuity goes, instead of just saying like, hey, do whatever feels good sort of thing, get whatever you want.
01:23:44 Instead, it should be like, hey, you're potent, you are dangerous, and you can raise a line of children, of sons and daughters to your own glory and the glory of God, and that's a dangerous thing.
01:24:00 Make sure that you choose wisely the woman that you're going to select.
01:24:05 Don't settle.
01:24:06 Don't just go out and sow your wild oats and all that.
01:24:09 Yeah.
01:24:10 Yep.
01:24:10 Be a glory.
01:24:11 Yeah. 0.99
01:24:11 The last thing to say about that is homosexuality. 1.00
01:24:14 I wonder if one of you would talk just a little bit about that, but it really makes fatherhood obsolete. 1.00
01:24:20 For the obvious reason, you can't multiply.
01:24:23 I mean, yeah, you can even see this in some relationships where there will be like a much older guy who's groomed a younger man.
01:24:30 Which is, I mean, this whole subject is absolutely revolting and disgusting, but this is a common thing that you see is like an older guy and a younger guy and you have like father issues on display for like, I mean, it's the, almost the most obvious, just a, should I call you mister?
01:24:49 I said you. 0.92
01:24:50 Yeah, I mean, it's such a twisted—the reason it's so disgusting is because it's so twisted and inverse of the good and beautiful things that God has given to us as gifts in marriage and in sex and in affections, and it's so unbelievably twisted and revolting. 0.99
01:25:11 Yeah, homosexuality is essentially it's the enlarging of male lust to, like a supernova, just eat the whole universe, eat the whole solar system of masculinity. 0.99
01:25:27 Homosexual relationships are often extremely promiscuous and extremely sexual. 0.99
01:25:34 I mean, like the number of partners, 1.00
01:25:35 because what you get is you're taking two male libidos
01:25:40 and just pointing them at each other 0.57
01:25:41 in a really disgusting and perverse way.
01:25:45 And so you end up with, 1.00
01:25:47 instead of this beautiful creational design 1.00
01:25:52 where you have a glory that cannot be
01:25:56 without the coming together of the man and the woman,
01:25:59 which is world-building and life-giving, 0.87
01:26:01 you have this death cult
01:26:03 it's a death cult
01:26:05 it's another way of seeing that those who hate wisdom
01:26:08 love death because it's impotent
01:26:09 it cannot produce
01:26:11 it's fruitless 0.99
01:26:12 it can only rob and steal and kill and destroy and pervert 0.99
01:26:15 and it gets poop all over everything 0.98
01:26:17 the best stories are
01:26:19 I want to just fly by that as quick as I can
01:26:22 I'm not even kidding
01:26:23 I know
01:26:24 thank you Thabiti
01:26:27 for recovering your gag reflex
01:26:30 I mean that both as a literal fact and a metaphorical fact.
01:26:35 It puts poop on everything.
01:26:36 Yeah, it's a good question. 0.73
01:26:37 So, I mean, like the archetypal story is the knight who fights the dragon to win the girl.
01:26:44 Like the whole driver of society and virtue and everything is like, I will do this glorious thing.
01:26:50 Again, I can go back to the group of teenage boys that are standing around.
01:26:54 All of a sudden they're like pushing each other, you know, when the pretty girl walks by.
01:26:57 You're lifting weights, and you're like, I'm going to lift way too much weight, but I'm going to try, and I'm going to show off.
01:27:05 It's the driver of human society.
01:27:07 I'm going to carry so many chairs.
01:27:08 It becomes your supernova thing, although really dorky, is a really good picture because it just implodes in itself, and it just swallows. 0.96
01:27:16 And it will take an entire people with it because that's what homosexuality does is it defiles a people, not just a person. 0.97
01:27:24 It's late-stage sexual perversion on a societal level. 0.81
01:27:27 It just shows like you're in the late stage of empire, the late stage of decadence and complete lack of restraint where that which is – even the women are giving up the natural use and burning with lust for one another. 0.83
01:27:43 I mean it's just like it is the evidence that you have rejected wisdom wholly. 0.99
01:27:49 Yeah, it's essentially like the death throes of a culture I think.
01:27:52 Dan, I want to close with something that you put on our list which I thought was phenomenal.
01:27:57 which is that fatherlessness produces risk-averse drones,
01:28:00 corporatism, statism, that sort of thing.
01:28:03 We can close with this one, but what did you have in mind?
01:28:05 I thought it was a fantastic point.
01:28:07 Yeah, because men don't have that family crest
01:28:09 and that family motto, like I talked about.
01:28:12 They'll inherit anything that a father corporation
01:28:16 or statist government will give to them,
01:28:19 and they almost interact with organizations
01:28:21 like they would a family line and family legacy.
01:28:25 I've seen this before.
01:28:26 Or there was a, there's a man who has, he's a boomer.
01:28:30 He worked for a company his whole life and he wants to be buried at the
01:28:35 company grounds.
01:28:37 What?
01:28:38 Like the family plot.
01:28:40 I'm not joking.
01:28:41 Weird.
01:28:41 He wants to be planted, you know, put in the ground at this,
01:28:46 this factory because that's how he relates to this organization is almost
01:28:51 like, this is my, my father.
01:28:53 My whole mission in life has been to make this company successful.
01:28:59 And that's, I mean, that's an extreme example, but what it really reveals is that so many men don't have a, like a family motto or a crest.
01:29:09 I don't either, you know, but I'm, I have, I'm discovering after this conversation, I'm going to make one.
01:29:14 I think my family motto is just going to be full send.
01:29:16 Full send.
01:29:18 That'll probably age well.
01:29:19 Yeah.
01:29:19 And so you can see how people now relate to government and to work and to career and to a lot of other things, very strangely, like a father.
01:29:34 And so the expectations from those things, especially the government, almost becomes like a father being benevolent to its children.
01:29:43 Like, oh, you can't pay for college? A good father would help you with your education.
01:29:49 I, daddy government, will be a good father and I will pay for some of your student loans.
01:29:54 You know, we could use tons of examples about that.
01:29:58 Like, hey, you're getting up in age and, you know, a good father passes on an inheritance.
01:30:03 So here is a social welfare or social security program.
01:30:07 I will take care of you.
01:30:08 Enter into my loving embrace.
01:30:10 And it sounds kind of like over the top, but that is exactly what has happened,
01:30:16 is that you have a political ideology, a government or a corporation
01:30:20 or some dream that you have that you end up relating to as a father.
01:30:25 And it just shows that there's an aimless people that has no purpose.
01:30:30 And so it's been co-opted by status government and by corporate America.
01:30:38 Really interesting teaser for the next episode that we'll do. 0.74
01:30:42 But it's interesting to note that the black fatherlessness rate, which is so high now, pre-1960s welfare, there was actually less fatherlessness in the black community than in the white. 0.51
01:30:54 Wow. 0.66
01:30:55 So it hasn't always been the case, but it's that transfer, Dan, of you went from fathers to papa government.
01:31:02 Yeah, that's right.
01:31:03 And that was an intentional move.
01:31:04 Yeah, even government workers, you can see that a lot of the times.
01:31:08 I mean, we have a lot of government people here that are definitely, like, awake to this sort of thing.
01:31:14 But you can see the standard trope of a government worker, like a road crew, like there's six guys leaning on shovels.
01:31:22 You know, daddy will take care of me.
01:31:24 Yeah, when you don't actually have to do – you don't have to go into the agon and work.
01:31:27 You don't have to compete because you have complete – the government has a monopoly on the use of force.
01:31:33 And so it can force people to pay taxes.
01:31:35 It can print money whenever it wants.
01:31:36 And so your job is safe. As long as it can keep stealing from people, 40% tax rate, whatever, you're good. So you don't have to go in the agon. You don't have to fight and win. The top 5% do to go up the ladder and get to these high, high positions. And there are good leaders and good men in these jobs. But the general structure of the thing is directly conducive to anti-masculinity, not masculine virtue.
01:32:05 Yeah, great points.
01:32:06 Gentlemen, it's been a wonderful time having a conversation about fatherlessness in America.
01:32:11 Looking forward to part two next week.
01:32:15 We're going to be talking some of the root causes.
01:32:17 So we've talked about diagnosis symptoms, but then we'll get into next week some of the root causes.
01:32:22 And, you know, I think that'll be another enlightening conversation.
01:32:26 Yes.
01:32:27 So, Brian, would you close us down?
01:32:28 I'm going to have you close us down.
01:32:30 But before you do, just tell us a little bit about New Christendom Press.
01:32:33 Yeah.
01:32:33 what people can be looking forward to. Yeah, New Christendom Press is an endeavor that we are all
01:32:39 working together to attempt to build a publishing house, a modern multimedia publishing house
01:32:44 that can create resources that are in the vein of theology with calluses, as Dan says,
01:32:51 theology with practical anchor points that you can hook onto that will actually move the needle
01:32:58 in your life to show you the good and the true and the beautiful in every part of what it means
01:33:04 to be human. And so we're hard at work here in Ogden, aiming to build that, writing books,
01:33:11 getting authors that we think are going to be helpful to you, like C.R. Wiley, writing a book
01:33:15 on some of what we talked about today, even. Expect to continue to see high-quality podcasts,
01:33:21 some new projects launching here in 2023 on that front, and also a conference. And so if you'd like
01:33:28 to support us or learn more about that, sign up for our interest list for the conference in 2023,
01:33:34 you can go to newchristendompress.com and help us make this thing get off the ground with a bang,
01:33:42 and we hope it serves you. That's really our aim is that it would serve you and that this would be
01:33:47 an unbought Christian publishing house that could just start the right fires and build the right
01:33:54 things. Yeah, and you can also support the King's Hall at Patreon. And if you're curious, we have
01:34:00 talked, we have had quite a few After Hours shows that are not publicly released or just for our
01:34:06 patrons. So over the break, we were still busy producing content on the After Hours. And if
01:34:14 you're curious we have quite a few episodes on the generational divide between the boomers 0.98
01:34:18 millennials and our hopes for gen z for the zoomers that based generation that's coming up yeah we
01:34:25 have a chat group full of some wonderful gentlemen uh in the through the patreon as well so check that
01:34:31 out there's a lot of great rewards and also you help make us make this show possible i know i know
01:34:37 a lot of podcasts say that but it's true um we actually eric works full time for new christen
01:34:44 Impress. I work part-time. We all work part-time for New Kristen Impress. This is actually
01:34:48 something that we're aiming to put our blood and sweat and tears and strength into. And we can't
01:34:55 do that without you guys. We literally can't. So we appreciate your support everywhere that you guys
01:34:59 have been giving it. And in the meantime, remember, Winkit Kwesa Winkit. He conquers who conquers
01:35:05 himself. Start there. And we'll see you next time on the King's Hall.
01:35:14 well in case you didn't know we have another king's hall show called the after hours and
01:35:22 it's available only to our patrons we have a great time in the after hours i play hype songs
01:35:27 which brian loves sometimes we even talk about brian's cut we talk about recent news on x and
01:35:32 answer listener questions overall it's a great time so i'd encourage you to head over to patreon.com
01:35:38 slash the king's hall if you'd like to support the show and get some extra content
01:35:42 Thank you.