The Megyn Kelly Show - October 01, 2026


"Cornell 7" Lawyer Speaks Out, Plus Bombshell New Texts From "Jane Doe," and Kevin Reddington's Bizarre Tactic | Ep. 1410

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Jack Smith Grilled, Trump Hosts AI Summit, NYT Executive Allegedly Killed by In-Laws: AM Update 9⧸30 Letitia James Starts "Cornell 7" Witch Hunt, and JD Vance's Important Comment on Men, with Sean Davis and Sohrab Ahmari | Ep. 1411

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 47 minutes

Words per minute

163.37

Word count

17,535

Sentence count

1,190

Harmful content

Misogyny

35

sentences flagged

Toxicity

95

sentences flagged

Hate speech

24

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey, guys, Megyn Kelly here. Like millions of you, I love true crime content. So this summer,
00:00:07 we created the show I always wanted to listen to. We're calling it MK Confidential. One case
00:00:13 per week, five episodes, Monday through Friday. New episodes every weeknight. JonBenet Ramsey,
00:00:20 Shaundra Levy, the DC Snipers, Scott Peterson, and some you've likely never heard of before.
00:00:26 Search for The Megyn Kelly Show wherever you listen to podcasts.
00:00:29 You'll find it there. 0.97
00:00:30 Hey, can you help carry these groceries?
00:00:33 Uh, no.
00:00:34 Come on, just grab one bag, please.
00:00:37 You should be more careful.
00:00:39 Why don't you ever help?
00:00:41 I'm your debt.
00:00:42 It's your job to carry the load.
00:00:44 I'm done carrying you.
00:00:46 It's time to break up with your debt.
00:00:48 We can help you reduce your debt by up to 80% and feel great again.
00:00:53 Farber Debt Solutions, licensed insolvency trustees.
00:00:56 Get the truth about debt.
00:00:58 You paid for those.
00:01:01 Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, live on Sirius XM Channel 111 every weekday at New East.
00:01:12 Hey everyone, I'm Megyn Kelly.
00:01:14 Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show.
00:01:15 Today, we pick up where we left off yesterday as we have a lot of updates to the Cornell
00:01:20 story on the accuser, what happened in the weeks between the alleged gang rape and her reporting
00:01:28 it to authorities, and more. We noted yesterday how many are falling into the same traps we've
00:01:33 seen over the years in stories like the Duke fake lacrosse rape case or the UVA fake rape case
00:01:40 involving a fraternity there, where there is a rush to judgment and a total disregard for due
00:01:47 process, the presumption of innocence or even common courtesy for those being accused of one
00:01:54 of the most serious crimes a person can commit. This morning, video emerged online of one of the
00:02:01 men listed as a defendant in Jane Doe's lawsuit. Cornell student Jillio Lopes being confronted on
00:02:08 campus watch are you not like embarrassed to be here after all of this time after the case comes
00:02:17 out your name is here your face is on paper are you not ashamed that you still here you're with 0.90
00:02:22 an education while jane joe had to fucking realize there's a reason for that right what's the reason 0.99
00:02:27 for that i'm not gonna talk about all this right now yeah and i you never will because you're a 1.00
00:02:33 disgusting person. You're a disgusting 1.00
00:02:35 person. Everyone in Cornell is ashamed 1.00
00:02:37 of you. Like, that group chat
00:02:39 is fucking disgusting. 0.99
00:02:42 Were you in the group chat? 1.00
00:02:44 Yeah, and none of you 0.99
00:02:47 did shit. 0.99
00:02:50 You're in the lawsuit, man. 1.00
00:02:51 I don't know what the fuck to tell you. 1.00
00:02:53 I'm just disgusted by you. I just wanted 1.00
00:02:55 to let you know personally.
00:02:57 I'm ashamed to be on the same campus 1.00
00:02:59 as you, and you're a gross person. 0.98
00:03:03 Here to react to this, and with more on the case, is the attorney representing Lopes, Tara Davis. 0.95
00:03:10 When it comes to supplements, we all know there are two things that matter, that it works and that you can trust it.
00:03:16 Rather than just tell you about Relief Factor, we often bring you what their real customers have to say.
00:03:21 One, Jim, said he ran out of Relief Factor twice and that both times his aches, stiffness, and pain came back.
00:03:28 Once he restarted it, he says he felt better again.
00:03:30 As Jim puts it, quote, you know something's working when you run out of it.
00:03:34 I know many people who have used Relief Factor and had it work for them, including me.
00:03:38 I took it from my shoulder and then ordered it again and found real relief.
00:03:43 They make it easy to find out if you're going to join me as a satisfied Relief Factor customer
00:03:47 and talking about how much it helps you tackle your daily aches and pains.
00:03:51 Three weeks for just 17 bucks and 76 cents.
00:03:55 Simply go to relieffactor.com or call 1-800-4-RELIEF.
00:03:58 You will connect with their friendly local team, and they will do everything they can to help you.
00:04:03 And maybe you will be sharing your story with them and with me soon, too.
00:04:09 Tara, welcome to the show. Thanks so much for being here.
00:04:11 Thank you for having me.
00:04:12 I'm sorry for what your client is going through, because even if he is adjudicated guilty,
00:04:20 if he winds up indicted by some grand jury, the rush to judgment here is stomach-turning,
00:04:25 and it is literally un-American.
00:04:28 Can you give us some background on how first you got involved in this?
00:04:33 Because when I look at your resume, it looks like you're the lawyer I would call if, God forbid, a son of mine got pulled into a Title IX hearing like these boys did at Cornell University.
00:04:43 Thank you. I appreciate that.
00:04:45 So I've been involved since the university conduct proceeding.
00:04:50 I became involved shortly after the notice of allegations were sent out.
00:04:54 So from the very beginning through the university's conduct process, through the investigation, the hearings and the appeals, I was working with the with my client.
00:05:05 And so I have been involved since the very beginning.
00:05:09 OK, so you were there alongside of him for the Title IX proceeding that happened on Cornell's campus.
00:05:16 Correct. OK, amazing, because it wasn't so long ago that you weren't entitled to have a lawyer there with you.
00:05:22 under the Barack Obama years, the lawyer, you had no right as a defendant to even have your
00:05:27 counsel present. Isn't that true? Correct. Yeah. I mean, there has been a lot of changes that have
00:05:31 happened since 2011 when the dear colleague letter was issued. So we did have a period of
00:05:36 time where attorneys were able to attend and cross-examine witnesses. There was a change in
00:05:42 the administration and correspondingly the regulations, as you mentioned. And at that
00:05:48 point, those rights were taken away for a period of time. Fortunately, not too long before they
00:05:53 were reinstated. So now we are back to the position of being able to attend, being able to
00:06:00 cross-examine witnesses. And in fact, the parties involved are not able to cross-examine parties
00:06:07 themselves. They are required to have advisors. They don't have to be legal advisors, but they
00:06:12 have to have advisors conduct the cross-examination. It's an incredible, I mean, and very valuable
00:06:18 restoration. I have to say, God bless President Trump for doing it because it was Arne Duncan
00:06:21 under Barack Obama who wrote that dear colleague letter that changed due process rights, eliminated
00:06:27 them for anyone accused on college campuses nationwide. You're talking about a boy's entire
00:06:32 future, his college education, being labeled a sex offender for the rest of his life. And they
00:06:38 were told by Barack Obama's administration, you can't have a lawyer in there. You can't
00:06:42 cross-examine. You have very limited rights to discovery. It was very, very wrong. Trump
00:06:47 reversed it. And here we are now with your client and others being accused by Jane Doe.
00:06:54 Can I ask you, first of all, I have a real problem personally with the fact that she's
00:07:00 maintaining her anonymity and she's named all seven of these young men explicitly. Their names
00:07:06 are in every newspaper in the country right now.
00:07:09 Can you comment on that?
00:07:10 Yeah, absolutely.
00:07:11 And, you know, New York State,
00:07:12 and perhaps part of the reason she chose to file 0.95
00:07:14 in the New York State court
00:07:16 is because they are quite deferential
00:07:18 to parties that bring cases
00:07:21 that involve allegations of this nature.
00:07:24 So there is an opportunity to challenge that status,
00:07:27 and we do have a return date
00:07:29 for the parties to oppose her request
00:07:31 to appear by pseudonym.
00:07:34 But I think that the courts are likely to allow her to remain that status because of, again, the nature of the allegations and that courts typically do allow parties to proceed as a doe.
00:07:45 On the other side, you know, oftentimes we talk about is it appropriate to name the defendants, right?
00:07:52 I mean, if we're bringing a lawsuit on the plaintiff's side, which we often do, do we name the other parties?
00:07:56 And at this point, there have been some discussions about do we move to keep that pseudonym status or try to remove it?
00:08:05 And from our perspective, it doesn't matter at this point.
00:08:08 I mean, the cat's out of the bag. Like you said, their names are everywhere.
00:08:11 So even if we were able to get them changed to John Doe's one through seven, everyone already knows their names and faces.
00:08:19 Yep. Yep. We we tried not to say them yesterday, but I mean, having you on, we're going to say them.
00:08:25 And I'm giving serious thought to saying her name, too, once I've confirmed it, because the members of the media can do what they think is ethical.
00:08:32 And we have had many examples in the past, including of The New York Times, naming an accuser if they think the circumstances warrant it.
00:08:41 And I think we're there on this case personally, but continue to review.
00:08:46 So can you walk us through a little bit of the timeline?
00:08:48 When did Giglio first find out that what he thought, because he was one of the, he's one of the young men accused of actually having a sexual encounter with her.
00:08:58 There were four out of the seven who allegedly did.
00:09:01 He is one of them.
00:09:02 And my understanding is all of these boys thought it was consensual.
00:09:05 I mean, it was raunchy and it was a night of debauchery, if you will, involving ketamine, et cetera.
00:09:10 But the text messages after the fact and her initial statements appear to confirm that all involved believed this was consensual, racy, but consensual in on the night it happened and the days thereafter.
00:09:25 So how did he first get wind that she was changing her tune?
00:09:29 Yeah. So, I mean, I can't speak to the other defendants, certainly.
00:09:32 I don't think and I don't know exactly the timeline for him.
00:09:37 I can say that he did not have any indication that this was going to become something more serious than than just a kind of a crazy night until he heard that there was a report that had been made.
00:09:49 And there was a report that was filed, as you know, with the Cornell police.
00:09:53 But there was also a campus wide report that was made to all of Cornell.
00:09:57 So at that point, people started to recognize that this was going to become a more serious matter and it likely was going to be investigated.
00:10:06 The Title IX notice did not come out till January.
00:10:10 But by that point, because of the campus crime alert, they had an understanding that that there was likely going to be an investigation.
00:10:18 And the event, we should remind people, happened in October is October 19th, overnight into the 20th.
00:10:23 Correct.
00:10:24 So it made news campus wide in January, but it had been it had occurred a couple of months prior.
00:10:31 So today, The New York Times has reports that it has gotten its hands on the Title IX documents on the the filings around that issue, including it looks like hearing transcripts.
00:10:46 First of all, are you surprised that that they have that?
00:10:49 I am. I don't know where that came from.
00:10:51 I mean, certainly there are a lot of people involved.
00:10:54 There's a lot of parties involved in the lawsuit, but also a lot of people that are aware of what's happening.
00:10:59 So, you know, I suppose it's not surprising that someone leaked them.
00:11:03 I don't know who and I haven't seen them, so I'm not sure exactly which documents they are.
00:11:08 Yeah. And same. I mean, I'm only going off of what they what they printed.
00:11:13 But they they have a lot in here that confirms, frankly, what I was theorizing about yesterday.
00:11:21 which is that Jane Doe very clearly initially did not think she had been raped at all and that it
00:11:29 looks like from the documents they're reporting on, it was her roommate who tried to convince her
00:11:35 that she had been raped as opposed to Jane Doe coming up with this on her own, a notion she'd
00:11:41 been toying with. And then there was a crucial denial by the Chi-Fi chapter president
00:11:50 to allowing Jane Doe to go to a Halloween party.
00:11:54 And that's when she got really mad 0.99
00:11:55 from what I read in the New York Times.
00:11:57 Can you elaborate?
00:11:59 I don't recall specifically conversations
00:12:01 with the roommate.
00:12:02 I know she did speak to some of her friends
00:12:05 in the sorority house
00:12:06 in the days following the interactions.
00:12:11 But I can say that I do know
00:12:13 that the week following the events that issue,
00:12:16 there was some kind of a Halloween event
00:12:19 or themed party that she had planned to attend some member of the fraternity.
00:12:24 I'm not certain if it was the president, but some member of the fraternity told her that
00:12:29 that she shouldn't come or disinvited her in some way, something to that effect.
00:12:34 And I think she was upset by that.
00:12:38 Yes, what what the Times is reporting was that is that in the days thereafter, first
00:12:44 of all, that the roommate the roommate says one roommate told investigators Jane Doe did
00:12:48 not use the word rape or assault when they were first talking about it the day after.
00:12:53 It seemed like she was in shock, her other roommate leader told investigators, quote,
00:12:56 not really understanding the gravity of what she was saying.
00:13:00 She went to her big sister, Jane Doe, did at the Tridel house and told the sister, there 0.99
00:13:06 are roommates circulating, this is the next day, October 21st, that she was a slut. 0.94
00:13:13 The big sister, who's a junior at Cornell at the time, told investigators, Jane Doe 0.97
00:13:16 added with a laugh. Unfortunately, they're true, these rumors. The big sister brought up her own
00:13:24 passing. I could tell that she had not yet processed what happened. And then she had her
00:13:30 text, Jane Doe had a text exchange with another one of the defendants known as defendant number
00:13:34 two. Again, we're saying the names now. This one's named Jonathan Newell. And she reassured him in
00:13:40 this text where he said, I want to apologize for how things went down. That quote, in her words,
00:13:45 at the end of the day, none of the sexual stuff was illegal. And honestly, I really liked being
00:13:51 with you and Matt, she wrote explicitly. Then she would get angrier because by October 23rd,
00:13:59 which was, looks like two days later, she texted bro, everyone knows. And I think this is to
00:14:07 Matt, the guy she was meeting initially when she showed up at the house.
00:14:11 She said the episode was ruining my life temporarily, that her reputation had been destroyed, said all she could do was sleep and cry all day.
00:14:20 Matthew Ingalls assured her it would all blow over soon, noting how fast nonsense spreads at this school and that she did not have anything to be ashamed of.
00:14:27 You're right, said Jane Doe. It'll get better.
00:14:30 And then what the New York Times reports is that even though she had more texts, and I'll get into them later when you're not here, I don't want to bore you. You've seen it all. But that ultimately we got to the Halloween party. She was eager to attend. That Mr. Ingalls texted her again saying, we want you here. Chi-Fi is your house. You're welcome here. She wrote, thank you. I really appreciate that. I'll bring my SIGs tomorrow.
00:14:57 And then she received a phone call from the fraternity president disinviting her.
00:15:01 It was for her own good, she said.
00:15:04 And she wrote back, I knew this was going to happen. 0.97
00:15:06 The woman will always get the short end of the stick.
00:15:08 Y'all aren't my friends. 1.00
00:15:09 Y'all are covering your asses. 0.99
00:15:12 And then she sent a nasty text to Mr. Newell, man number two. 0.99
00:15:17 Let's be clear, 90% of what happened then was not consensual.
00:15:20 I was given more than I can remember, more key, short for ketamine.
00:15:24 and I know that I told you I felt uncomfortable
00:15:27 and I didn't know anyone in that room.
00:15:30 It went on from there.
00:15:32 And then within days, literally within days,
00:15:36 she was at the campus police.
00:15:38 So, I mean, to me, this is evidence of a woman
00:15:41 who was involved in a consensual exchange
00:15:45 that then her friends, campus rumor mill,
00:15:49 and ultimately anger over feeling rejected
00:15:51 by the fraternity, some of whose members she was with, led this woman to change her story.
00:16:00 Yeah, and I think those all sound accurate. And I do recall those text messages. And I agree with
00:16:06 the general sentiment. I mean, again, I know what my client has told me about what happened
00:16:11 from his perspective. He had very limited involvement in the events of that night. It
00:16:16 was at the very beginning of the night for a short period of time. And the testimony and evidence
00:16:22 that came out during the university's conduct proceeding confirmed all of that. So from his
00:16:28 perspective, I mean, yes, everything was consensual and there was no question about it.
00:16:35 So if I ask something you can't tell me, please obviously feel free to say so. But
00:16:40 what happened to your client at the proceedings? We know two were expelled
00:16:44 and five weren't.
00:16:47 Some were given temporary suspensions.
00:16:51 Yeah, he received a suspension period
00:16:52 in addition to some educational sanctions,
00:16:55 one of which included a component involving an essay,
00:16:58 which I think is where people got that information
00:17:00 and kind of ran with the assumption
00:17:02 that that was the full sanction.
00:17:04 It was not.
00:17:05 He did receive a suspension period.
00:17:07 What was the story with the essays?
00:17:09 Because some are out there tweeting nonstop,
00:17:13 omg all they had to do was write essays you know how how outrageous and it just seems like
00:17:18 absolutely insane to think a university like cornell would ever leave it at that because
00:17:22 we all know from the history if anything they bend over backward to believe any woman accuser
00:17:28 and to throw the book at the male defendants so tell us the story of the essay yeah and i agree
00:17:32 with you i heard you talk about that yesterday as well it's something along the lines of what
00:17:36 you just said in terms of cornell being the institution that it is would never just assign
00:17:40 essays to someone found responsible for a Title IX violation. And honestly, in all the cases I've
00:17:46 done over many years, I can't recall a single case where someone found responsible was assigned
00:17:51 only an essay. I think that that's just absurd and it wouldn't happen. They had essays, some of
00:17:59 them to write. Again, I don't know every sanction because I wasn't privy to all the materials,
00:18:02 but that came in combination with a number of other sanctions. It was just one piece of the
00:18:08 sanctions received. I think it was, yeah, it's Casey Johnson, with whom I've been working for
00:18:14 years as a guest on my new shows, who really is one of the best in terms of covering what's been
00:18:20 happening on college campuses to young men and the erosion of due process and these, you know,
00:18:24 you're guilty, you're presumed guilty by all the irrelevant authorities. And he writes in a piece
00:18:31 for National Review yesterday, that Cornell is in the top five of universities nationwide
00:18:39 that have faced lawsuits by male respondents who claim their cases were handled unfairly.
00:18:45 It's one of the top five most unfair to men being accused. And that's the unfortunate news for your
00:18:52 client is he happens to go to this Ivy League university that does not appear to believe
00:18:57 in due process for men accused by young women. It's really outrageous. Okay, so the essay,
00:19:04 the temporary suspension, and now we saw in that video at the top of the show,
00:19:08 he's still trying to complete his education there. We believe he's a senior. How's that going?
00:19:14 Yeah, it's not easy, certainly. I mean, he's trying to get to his classes and complete his
00:19:20 degree eventually but as you can imagine it's incredibly difficult um his name his reputation
00:19:28 everything has been affected by this his family's name um they're getting doxed online i mean he's
00:19:34 having safety concerns so it's really scary um and unfortunately or fortunately he's able to be on
00:19:41 campus right i mean he served his sanction and that's concluded and he is permitted to be back
00:19:47 But unfortunately, people, you know, don't see it that way and want him to not be there any longer.
00:19:54 So it's it's really, really difficult.
00:19:57 You know, I mean, he's just, I think, trying to get by the day to day right now.
00:20:02 Did things change in the past week?
00:20:04 Because I understand, you know, the students on Cornell University campus generally knew who the accuser was and who the accused were.
00:20:13 but this week it's gone viral because she filed her civil lawsuit naming them and now the whole
00:20:20 country knows so did things change this week oh absolutely in the past week or two absolutely
00:20:25 i just said not i mean this was something that occurred two years ago you know so people knew
00:20:30 about it at the time people talked about it there was the rumor mill but after that things had really
00:20:34 quieted down um and there were some of the students that were not permitted back that were
00:20:39 expelled. But the past two weeks, things have just really, you know, spread like wildfire. And
00:20:45 he's had to deal with things that have not been an issue until this case was filed.
00:20:51 It's very hard to get into Cornell or any Ivy League university. It's harder than ever.
00:20:59 He's now done four years there, which is also an accomplishment in and of itself.
00:21:03 Does he worry now about getting a job? I mean, that's the goal when you leave a university,
00:21:09 Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. And I'm sure they all do. I mean, you know, putting aside what's happening on campus, like I said, his name's out there, his picture's out there. And regardless of what happens in the civil suit or with the DA, you know, whether they decide to go forward if there are criminal charges, regardless of what happens with any of that, this information has spread so dramatically across the news, across social media, that it's going to be out there and it's going to live on the Internet.
00:21:39 you know, forever. So that's certainly, I think, and he hasn't said that to me directly,
00:21:44 but I have to imagine that all of these dependents are feeling that way.
00:21:48 We have a lot of moms who watch this show. Can you speak at all to how his parents are handling this?
00:21:54 Yeah, I think as any of us would, I'm a mom too. I have boys. So, you know, this is certainly
00:22:00 something that I think about a lot. And I think they're devastated, right? I mean, to go through
00:22:06 not only the the university process in itself was incredibly emotionally taxing um it was a long
00:22:14 process there was uh you know a lot involved in that and then getting to the point where you get
00:22:19 a sanction and then serving that sanction and feeling as though it's over only to be faced with
00:22:25 this now and to have this kind of attention and focus on on your son on your family it's it's
00:22:31 it's awful it's awful what they're dealing with and i they're concerned for him understandable
00:22:36 Yeah. Oh my gosh. I'm sure. I'm sure they're all, all the families must be devastated right now. I'll ask you about what she alleges. You can tell me whatever you can. She alleges in her civil case that Matt Ingalls was the one we referred to as man number one. That's the one she showed up at the Chi-Fi house to see. They danced together. He said, can we have a threesome with somebody? And she alleged to police that she said yes.
00:23:04 Then she alleges in paragraph 158,
00:23:06 at one point defendant Ingalls
00:23:08 could no longer maintain an erection,
00:23:10 so he stopped participating and told the other two 0.72
00:23:12 he was going to take a nap and proceed to get up,
00:23:15 move to a bed and sleep.
00:23:16 Defendant Newell, that's defendant number two, 1.00
00:23:19 then began reaching for her vagina 1.00
00:23:22 with his hand multiple times, 1.00
00:23:23 and each time plaintiff pushed his hand away.
00:23:25 Paragraph 160, soon after defendant Lopes,
00:23:28 and it is Lopes, it's not Lopez, you tell us,
00:23:30 entered the room,
00:23:31 grabbed plaintiff away from defendant Newell and began kissing her while defendant Newell 1.00
00:23:36 groped her from behind, specifically reaching for her vagina. Paragraph 161 defendant Lopes 0.99
00:23:42 and Newell then placed plaintiff on a bed and the two men began having sex with plaintiff 0.83
00:23:46 initiating another assault. This is her lawyer's language and her civil complaint
00:23:50 all without plaintiff's consent. So that's, I mean, there's a few more allegations,
00:23:55 but that's the crux of it. Does he deny those allegations?
00:23:59 Yes, that's just not factual. It's not what was presented in the hearing through any of the testimony through the evidence. It's just not factual and it's just mischaracterized. And I mean, one thing I'll say is that the amount of information included in the complaint, which is, I think, 101 pages, is very limited.
00:24:19 And this was a proceeding that took place for months that resulted in an investigative record about 1,500 pages long that included 50 witness interviews and 12 and a half days of a hearing.
00:24:34 So there's just much, much more background and context and detail than what's being presented in this complaint.
00:24:44 And your client is male number three in the allegations, just to be clear, yes?
00:24:49 Uh, I believe so.
00:24:52 Yeah. Okay. Mel number three. Okay. Then, um, does he deny that he had sex with her that night?
00:25:00 No. 0.84
00:25:01 Okay. And his defense is that it was consensual.
00:25:04 Correct.
00:25:06 And what about the drugs? Like how big a factor was the ketamine at the title nine hearing?
00:25:12 it was extensively discussed um there were a lot of questions about it uh not surprisingly
00:25:20 um the testimony provided was was pretty inconsistent as far as the timeline uh i don't
00:25:28 think there's a dispute that it was present at some point but it it it's still not exactly
00:25:33 clear to me what the timeline was as far as when when if at all the complaint had consumed any
00:25:42 when that happened and who was involved.
00:25:46 Did the university expel people, can you tell us, based on the drugs
00:25:51 or based on the allegations of sexual assault?
00:25:56 It's hard to separate out.
00:25:57 I mean, I would say if there was solely an allegation of drug use,
00:26:00 probably not.
00:26:02 You're probably not looking at an expulsion.
00:26:04 But here the relevance is to the question of capacity.
00:26:07 So, you know, in looking at the allegations of sexual assault,
00:26:11 the question is whether she was incapacitated such that she could not consent because of her
00:26:17 consumption of different substances that night.
00:26:21 And that was something that we've now heard from the DA for Ithaca and the county there,
00:26:28 that he felt he could not prove in a court of law that she was incapacitated based on her own
00:26:34 six-page, single-spaced typed statement that have, according to him, 20 of her handwritten notes.
00:26:42 So she edited it, she added to it, and then she signed it under penalties of perjury.
00:26:47 And he believed that that statement, which we haven't seen, what made clear that throughout
00:26:52 that night, there was not an issue of her capacity, that while she was increasingly intoxicated,
00:26:59 It was always her own choice at her own hand and that she never reached the point of full physical incapacitation, meaning unconsciousness or inability to speak or interact.
00:27:11 Is that your understanding?
00:27:13 I mean, again, it's a bit hard for me to speak to.
00:27:15 I know that when my client was involved earlier in the evening at the earlier end of these events, she was not incapacitated as far as we saw through all the testimony, her own testimony included, as well as the evidence.
00:27:29 So how long did the whole thing go on?
00:27:33 How many hours did this happen over?
00:27:36 The alleged event we're talking about, I believe.
00:27:40 Yeah.
00:27:40 So she says that she arrived to the house, I think, around 11 o'clock and left sometime after about 5.45 or 6 a.m.
00:27:50 Okay.
00:27:51 Because her roommate, according to this New York Times report on the Title IX proceeding, says she didn't get back home until 11 a.m. that morning.
00:27:57 But she, do you know, is that when she left the Ki-Fi house?
00:28:02 Because she said she fell asleep for a time.
00:28:03 Yeah, she may have fallen asleep for some time after the last sexual encounter that 0.93
00:28:08 she had and left later that morning.
00:28:09 I don't recall if it was 11 o'clock.
00:28:12 That could be right.
00:28:13 I just don't recall exactly.
00:28:15 Okay.
00:28:16 So there were, as I read the complaint and the six-page statement, the excerpts that
00:28:22 we've been given, et cetera, it looks to me like there were three sexual interludes that
00:28:27 she had in the course of that time. There was, um, the first one, which I think was with Matt
00:28:34 and, uh, this other guy, number two. And then there was a second one, which involved Matt and
00:28:40 your client. And then there was a third one later in the evening. Is that correct? That sounds
00:28:46 correct. Okay. So what you're saying is you feel very satisfied that she had capacity when she was
00:28:56 with your client, you're not going to speak to what her status was or how she was on the third
00:29:01 interlude. Correct. Okay. Um, and they have separate counsel, those young ones. You only, 0.97
00:29:08 only represent Lopes. Yes. Okay. Um, and so does Lopes admit to drug use that night?
00:29:16 No, he didn't use any drugs that night. Okay. So she's accusing him, I think,
00:29:22 I think she's accusing all seven of them, excuse me, of snorting ketamine off of her, quote, perfect body.
00:29:29 He says that's not true?
00:29:31 That is not true.
00:29:33 Okay.
00:29:33 And did he do one of the hair follicle tests like Scott Kretschmar did to prove that he did not take ketamine?
00:29:42 I don't believe so.
00:29:43 I think Scott K. was the only one who did that.
00:29:47 Okay.
00:29:47 But it was not, he wasn't found guilty of it, I guess.
00:29:50 Is that the way to phrase it at the Title IX hearing?
00:29:54 He, sorry, he being Scott or my client?
00:29:59 Your client. 1.00
00:29:59 Yeah, Lopes.
00:30:00 Yeah, sorry.
00:30:01 No, I believe the hearing panel had found that he wasn't involved in the use of the
00:30:05 academy that night.
00:30:07 Okay.
00:30:07 So what was he, is found guilty the right word?
00:30:11 I mean, what was he?
00:30:12 Found responsible.
00:30:14 What did they say he did, the Title IX panel?
00:30:17 He was found responsible for some violations of their policy.
00:30:20 I don't know that I want to go into too much detail on that.
00:30:24 Okay.
00:30:25 There is a remarkable report in UnHerd today, the reporting by our friend, Sarabha Mari,
00:30:31 who spoke with the lawyer representing this other defendant, Scott Ketchmark.
00:30:38 And that lawyer tells UnHerd that during the proceeding, at least during Scott's portion,
00:30:45 I don't know what your experience was, the chief investigator for the Title IX team
00:30:49 was in her car. She was driving for 45 minutes of it. And that at another point, he could see
00:30:57 from her glasses that she was surfing online, like barely paying attention to evidence that
00:31:03 his lawyer said was actually exculpatory for Scott. What was your experience and Jillio's?
00:31:11 I do recall that. I think everyone made note of that. I mean, this was a long proceeding. Like I
00:31:16 said it was 12 and a half days of testimony but there was one point probably about halfway through
00:31:22 where it wasn't the hearing chair it was one of the other panelists where everyone noticed that
00:31:27 she was in a car she had the seat belt on and you could kind of see movement from driving in in her
00:31:32 glasses so i mean do you think they were taking this seriously at you know these so-called
00:31:39 investigators and those who are going to be determining these boys fate i think they were
00:31:43 taking it seriously i don't know that they were perhaps or at least this particular individual
00:31:49 was paying attention as much as she should have been throughout the entire thing um but i do think
00:31:54 they were taking it seriously and in terms of recognizing how how serious the allegations were
00:31:59 um but that was one of the the concerns that we had with with the process i mean you know from
00:32:06 our perspective there were a number of things cornell did in terms of their uh handling of
00:32:10 the case, which I don't think were perfect, but that was one thing I know that a lot of the
00:32:14 advisors picked up on. Yeah, you would definitely want them to be paying attention when you're
00:32:20 presenting your exculpatory evidence. So now we're seeing text messages between Jane Doe and
00:32:29 a number, actually, of the boys after the fact. Definitely with Matt, also with defendant number
00:32:37 two, and maybe some others. Some of it, the reporting is confusing because they don't
00:32:42 reveal the names in each instance or they block them out. But is that your understanding that in
00:32:48 the days after this happened, all of the text messaging from Jane Doe reflected a woman who
00:32:55 believed that the experience had been consensual? There were some that indicated that, yes. I think
00:33:02 the ones more close in time to when the events happened, I think that did shift as more time
00:33:08 passed. But the initial ones, there was certainly some indication of that.
00:33:13 And as somebody yesterday had emerged, and we spent some time on this on the show,
00:33:17 that the six page statement to which she swore under penalties of perjury did not use the word
00:33:22 rape, except in a hypothetical context, like, geez, if I had fallen asleep and they had sex 0.97
00:33:27 with me, that would have been rape. But she did not actually accuse them of rape in that statement. 0.89
00:33:32 Is that true? I have to check that. That sounds correct. I think, you know, it's important to
00:33:38 keep in mind, though, from the university's perspective that that's not how they define
00:33:42 a violation of policy. Right. So from their perspective, it's a question of whether it
00:33:48 was consensual or not. So it could have been that she had that in mind when she was drafting
00:33:54 the statement. But I don't I'd have to double check if she used that word.
00:33:58 did the university find the young men responsible for rape so they wouldn't find them responsible
00:34:07 for rape because that's not necessarily the the the terminology used it would have been
00:34:11 sexual assault that they would classify it as was anyone found lie or responsible for sexual assault
00:34:18 expelled uh i i don't know for certain because i don't know every sanction that was imposed
00:34:23 for all seven of them. Okay. But some were found responsible for sexual assault in the eyes of the
00:34:30 university. Why do you think the DA is reopening this case and now going to submit it to a grand
00:34:38 jury? I mean, to me, it seems like pressure to do so. I mean, people are outraged, understandably.
00:34:45 I mean, if they're hearing the way that she's presenting the case, of course, people are going
00:34:49 to be horrified and outraged at what's being said. So I think it is just that pressure to
00:34:55 take another look at it. And if they didn't do any real investigation at the time, you know,
00:35:01 perhaps they feel that that now is the time to do it to make sure that they reach the right
00:35:05 decision initially. What do you think people out there need to know about this case that they don't
00:35:12 know? I think they need to understand that there's a lot more to what happened. And again, I'm not
00:35:19 speaking for every defendant. I'm not saying there was no wrongdoing, you know, or things that
00:35:25 happened that maybe shouldn't have, but there's a lot more that needs to be considered. And this
00:35:31 is all going to come out through the case, right? I mean, we're in the early phases of the complaint
00:35:35 just having been filed. There's going to be discovery and depositions and a lot more information
00:35:41 is going to come out. So I would just, you know, encourage people to be perhaps a bit more open
00:35:46 minded and not immediately jump to conclusions about about who did what and who's guilty or not.
00:35:53 Are there are you thinking of documents that you've seen that are going to come out or do you
00:35:59 think it's testimony that you're going to elicit? Both, but probably primarily the testimony,
00:36:03 because that makes up the majority of the investigative record.
00:36:09 There is an allegation that The New York Times is repeating today from the Title IX proceeding
00:36:15 that this Jane Doe told at least a roommate that she had been sexually assaulted before.
00:36:23 This is not her first accusation of sexual assault. Is that news to you?
00:36:29 I don't want to comment on that one. You know, I want to respect the privacy on her past history.
00:36:34 Okay, sure. And can you confirm, you know, I'm not going to ask you to name the Jane Doe, but is it your understanding that she is from the South, from Alabama?
00:36:49 I recall she's from somewhere far from New York. I honestly don't recall exactly where it was.
00:36:56 But I'm pretty sure she said something about living a few thousand miles away. So I know it wasn't in the tribe.
00:37:02 Yeah, a thousand. A thousand. Yep. And your understanding is, even though she's not from New York State, that she filed, you think, she filed the New York State Supreme because you think that's the place that would be most friendly to allowing her to proceed anonymously? Or do you think it could go beyond that as somebody who practices this kind of law?
00:37:22 I mean, there's a couple of factors.
00:37:23 I think it jurisdictionally probably made the most sense because of where all the defendants
00:37:27 are located or the far majority are located.
00:37:29 I'm sure that was consideration number one.
00:37:32 But I do think New York State as a general matter, you know, is pretty accommodating
00:37:39 in terms of allowing for parties to proceed by pseudonym.
00:37:43 Mm hmm.
00:37:44 The I think the biggest thing that led to this getting revived by the D.A., who seems
00:37:51 to not think that there is a case here is the Snapchat exchange, which he says he didn't have
00:37:57 at the time. But he also says he thinks it's irrelevant legally. But it just reflects so
00:38:02 poorly on the young men involved, the free P word upstairs. And then we learned overnight that
00:38:08 there's another piece of the exchange where someone texts shop still open and someone else
00:38:15 responds, yeah. Just let me ask you explicitly whether Lopes is involved in the excerpts that
00:38:22 we've seen. He is not. And that was something that was confirmed through the hearing process
00:38:26 as well. He was not on there. He was not active in that group. And actually, the first time he
00:38:32 ever saw it was in his second interview with the investigators in February of 2025.
00:38:39 So can I get you to comment on that? Because, you know, if you heard me yesterday, you heard me
00:38:43 say there's a serious moral problem with the exchanges here. And, you know, I have my own
00:38:50 judgments about even what happened in that room, even if it were consensual. But I don't think a
00:38:55 crime was committed, as I also said. But can you speak to the moral outrage piece of it and
00:38:59 what the young men are thinking about that now? Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's awful. I was sitting
00:39:06 with him in that interview when we saw that for the first time. And I think we were equally
00:39:09 horrified, you know, to see people even talking in that way. And yeah, I mean, putting aside the
00:39:15 fact that it may not on its own be a violation of any policy or a crime necessarily to talk in that
00:39:21 way, it's disturbing. And I'm sure that, you know, the men that are on there are embarrassed as they
00:39:28 should be. And so, you know, I certainly agree. I mean, to see people talk in that way is very
00:39:34 upsetting. This is a weird question, maybe, but I, you know, part of me is shocked to, to see even
00:39:43 what we do know happened in there with, you know, three different threesomes and the, the drugs that
00:39:48 part of me is shocked that kids who work this hard to get into this elite institution would
00:39:53 behave like that. I'm maybe I'm just naive Tara, but can you shed any light on it? Uh, I think I,
00:40:00 you know i no longer share um any of that naivete just because i've been doing this for long enough
00:40:06 to to see this over and over again not to this level but um you know just seeing kids who are
00:40:11 away from home for the first time and experimenting with different things regardless of whether it's
00:40:16 a huge ivy league school on the east coast or small liberal arts on the west coast um
00:40:23 kids do dumb things right and hopefully it's not to this extent where it leads to
00:40:29 conduct findings and sanctions and potential criminal activity, right? I mean, we hope that
00:40:35 it's things that are just a matter of a learning experience, but it doesn't surprise me because
00:40:41 we've seen this over and over. Again, not to this level, but we, you know, every day we're
00:40:48 getting calls of different things that people have concerns about with their universities and
00:40:53 colleges. One of the concerns, and I thank you, I'm grateful to you for being here today,
00:41:02 is the doxing not only of the young men, but their lawyers. This Jeremy Salon, who represents
00:41:11 the other guy I mentioned, he came out and said he personally is being doxed. I'm going to play
00:41:18 that soundbite, it's number seven. We're interpreting that snap now as something horrible
00:41:24 and horrific. And it may have been, but he did not know this. And that's why he went there and
00:41:27 he was looking for his roommate or his friend who had left the room at the time. So I don't know
00:41:32 what else we could do. And I just, please, I've been, I have gotten docs that you can't fathom
00:41:37 to the point about me being Jewish, Zionist rapist. I should be raped. My family should be 1.00
00:41:45 brutalized my 0.78
00:41:47 address, everything. I'm getting calls
00:41:50 every 30 seconds. I'm getting calls
00:41:51 as I'm sitting here with you. Threats and threats
00:41:53 and threats. People need to pause
00:41:56 understand the facts
00:41:57 and if there needs to be accountability
00:41:59 there should be accountability. But if there doesn't
00:42:02 give someone the benefit of the doubt 0.71
00:42:04 she could be a victim
00:42:05 and even if she really is in full extent
00:42:08 it doesn't mean that Scott
00:42:09 who is not someone who did anything
00:42:12 wrong should be victimized 0.61
00:42:13 and abused and thrown over the coals, 0.94
00:42:15 raked over the coals.
00:42:18 Are you worried about that, Tara,
00:42:19 for you and your other lawyers?
00:42:22 Yeah, I mean, I, you know,
00:42:23 certainly in coming on to speak with you,
00:42:25 it's something I thought about
00:42:26 in terms of, you know,
00:42:28 people having a perspective
00:42:29 about this case.
00:42:31 And, but like I said,
00:42:33 there's a lot more here that,
00:42:35 and like Jeremy said,
00:42:37 I mean, there's a lot of facts
00:42:38 that have to come out
00:42:39 and I think people need to pause
00:42:40 and just wait to see,
00:42:42 you know, what happens with the case and where this goes, because it's easy to rush to judgment
00:42:48 based on the information that's been shared in the media. But there's a lot more that needs to
00:42:52 be considered. Really? So do you think the people who have rushed to condemn these boys as gang
00:42:57 rapists might wind up embarrassed? I hope they I don't know that they'll wind up embarrassed or
00:43:04 that I hope they do, but I hope they they can be open minded and revise their opinions when
00:43:10 warranted. Wow. Some of the craziness we've heard has come from random people online. Some
00:43:17 has come from some of the most powerful lawmakers in America. Your client is just a kid at Cornell
00:43:24 University. It's a lot to have, you know, people like Chuck Schumer attacking him explicitly,
00:43:33 the Senate minority leader, but he did. Schumer posted on X the following. The allegations of
00:43:39 sexual assault and rape at Cornell University are horrifying and deserve a thorough investigation
00:43:43 that leaves no stone unturned. It took extraordinary courage for this young woman to come forward
00:43:47 to university administrators and police. I mean, already she's the courageous one. This is already
00:43:54 assuming something illegal happened and that she's got the courage and she's the one we should
00:44:00 be celebrating. It's very wrong for a politician to be doing this. He goes on, what she reported
00:44:05 demanded urgency, seriousness, and an unflinching pursuit of the truth from the very beginning.
00:44:09 Sexual assault remains far too common on college campuses across America and the culture of silence
00:44:14 and complicity that allows it to persist must be confronted. It's incumbent upon all of us,
00:44:19 elected officials, university leaders, faculty, and students to build campus communities
00:44:23 where sexual violence is never tolerated, maximized, or minimized or ignored. There
00:44:28 must now be a truly independent and exhaustive investigation, not only into what happened,
00:44:33 but into how this case was handled from the moment she came forward.
00:44:37 Every fact must be uncovered.
00:44:38 Every failure must be examined.
00:44:40 Wherever wrongdoing occurred, there must be accountability.
00:44:43 She had the courage to come forward.
00:44:44 No survivor should have to summon that courage
00:44:46 and then fight the system to make it respond.
00:44:50 Your reaction to that?
00:44:51 I mean, I agree with the majority of what he's saying.
00:44:53 And there's no question that sexual assault is a problem on college campuses.
00:44:57 And we know that.
00:44:58 And the data shows that.
00:45:00 But that doesn't mean that that's what happened here.
00:45:02 And do you think that the likes of Chuck Schumer and some Democrats may use this to try to restore the Title IX provisions for due process on college campus that were in place under Barack Obama?
00:45:17 I don't know. I mean, I think the process that is in place, it does work, not 100% of the time,
00:45:24 but like I said, I've been to a lot of these hearings, and when the processes are implemented
00:45:29 and followed, they do reach correct outcomes. I assume you do not want to see a restoration of
00:45:36 the Barack Obama era of Title IX enforcement? Preferably not.
00:45:41 Yeah, I mean, I can I can speak to it myself.
00:45:45 Absolutely not.
00:45:46 I've seen too many boys lives get ruined with no really no appeal.
00:45:50 Even if you find the devastating text message after the fact, the universities, they don't care and they don't listen.
00:45:55 Here's Elise Slotkin, who is a Democrat from the state of Michigan, U.S.
00:45:58 Senator. 1.00
00:45:59 We know what it's like when institutions fail women.
00:46:03 Now it's time for Cornell to step up and treat this with the seriousness they should have treated it two years ago.
00:46:09 that institutions have plenty of tools and accountability measures, they can remove students.
00:46:19 They can suspend them indefinitely until the court proceedings. They can do a million things.
00:46:27 Writing an essay, in my mind, is not part of that list. When we make the decision that because
00:46:33 young men have a promising career ahead of them that they shouldn't face accountability
00:46:40 for violently assaulting a woman like then we've lost our way what's your response to that
00:46:48 i mean again with the essays that that wasn't the outcome so i agree that there should be
00:46:54 accountability and there are plenty of cases where that's appropriate and it may have even
00:46:57 been appropriate here with respect to some of the defendants but this unfortunately is another
00:47:02 you know, snapshot of people who don't have all the facts and are reading what's, you know,
00:47:09 the soundbite that's been circulated and gone viral as far as what the allegations are.
00:47:15 Last but not least, the folks on TikTok are having themselves a week.
00:47:20 Your client has to live with this and get confronted by random
00:47:24 co-eds on campus as a result of this kind of rhetoric. I'll play some for you.
00:47:28 ruin their futures ruin them fucking ruin their futures because maybe just maybe if we hold young 0.99
00:47:40 people accountable then we won't have rapist presidents and that is a future that i would 0.98
00:47:48 love love love to see if you're gonna do the crime ruin ruin ruin their futures i really do believe
00:48:00 that every single person who is in that group chat who's chose not to speak up is complicit in
00:48:05 this violent crime the gutless bystanders are just as culpable in my opinion if a dog were to
00:48:11 bought you what would happen the dog would be put down okay justice will be served because if it's
00:48:18 my daughter you guys would be hanging upside down in my basement slowly bleeding but violence is not
00:48:23 the answer guys unless it comes to my kids i haven't been able to stop thinking about the 0.96
00:48:27 cornell rapists i don't call them the cornell seven because they're rapists so we call them
00:48:32 the cornell rapists what do they need to know about julio that they don't know i think they
00:48:41 need to wait and see what the evidence shows i mean like i said um she was not incapacitated at
00:48:47 the time that he was involved with her um the evidence shows that the the decision shows that
00:48:54 he was not aware of the snapchat messaging so i'm not you know again saying that there was no
00:48:59 wrongdoing here to some degree but there there was no evidence sufficient to show that there
00:49:07 was a crime committed. And, you know, I'm all for accountability as well. And certainly if there
00:49:13 were some of these defendants and students that were accountable, right, they should be held
00:49:18 responsible for that. And they were. They were imposed sanctions. So, you know, it's not like
00:49:23 they're found responsible and automatically permitted to return to campus and go about
00:49:29 their lives. I mean, they did receive sanctions from the university. To those who say he walked
00:49:35 in there this is a woman who is clearly high or drunk out of her mind and he should have turned 0.85
00:49:40 around and walked right back out and or stopped the whole thing what say you that's not how she
00:49:47 was presenting and the evidence will show that she was not presenting in a way that would have
00:49:52 suggested that she was not aware of what was happening so he thought she was she had total
00:49:59 capacity and was there enjoying herself i don't know that i would phrase it exactly like that i
00:50:04 I think I'll leave it at that, though.
00:50:07 Okay.
00:50:07 Fair enough.
00:50:08 Listen, thank you.
00:50:09 I know it's risky, sadly, for you personally to come out and speak to this, which is very,
00:50:14 very wrong.
00:50:15 Everyone accused deserves a good lawyer.
00:50:18 That's how our system works.
00:50:20 And your client deserves to have people stay open-minded to what his defense is before
00:50:26 he's had the chance to present it publicly.
00:50:27 He should not be dragged in this way.
00:50:29 We really appreciate it, Tara.
00:50:30 Thank you.
00:50:31 Thank you.
00:50:32 All the best to you.
00:50:33 You too.
00:50:33 Wow, this is turning into, I mean, full Salem witch trial. These guys are being lynched in the media before we've heard anything. Tara, that guy Jeremy, who I just played, those are the only two who have gone on camera to speak out. So we haven't even heard the defense of most of these guys. And yet, still, you get these women all over social media. You get Slotkin. You get Schumer. There's more to reveal. We'll do it when we come back, along with some other news.
00:51:02 It's no wonder so many people are scared of AI because it is changing everything,
00:51:06 including how criminals steal. They're targeting something most Americans do not even realize is
00:51:11 vulnerable, the thousands of bucks in equity in your home. A scammer can use AI to craft the
00:51:17 perfect document that they file with the county, transferring your home into their name, and then
00:51:22 use your ownership to take out loans or sell it for quick cash. This is evil. It's called title
00:51:28 fraud and it is happening all over America. That is why there's home title lock and their million
00:51:34 dollar triple lock protection. These guys will monitor your property records 24 seven, alert you
00:51:40 of any changes to your title and give the triple lock difference. If you become a victim, home title
00:51:45 locks expert restoration is backed up by up to 1 million bucks to fix the fraud and restore your
00:51:52 title. For cybersecurity awareness month, home title lock is offering a free title history report
00:51:57 plus an extended 30-day trial so you can see what it's all about risk-free.
00:52:03 Just use the promo code MEGAN30 at HomeTitleLock.com to find out today if you're already a victim.
00:52:10 The AI threat is real. Do not let scammers have the upper hand.
00:52:14 That's HomeTitleLock.com, promo code MEGAN30 to get peace of mind today.
00:52:19 I'm Megan Kelly. Every day on The Megan Kelly Show, we bring you the news,
00:52:23 and this summer, we're bringing you something extra.
00:52:26 Before I was a journalist, I was a lawyer.
00:52:28 I've spent 20 plus years now covering crime and the law.
00:52:32 So I built a true crime series that I always wanted to listen to.
00:52:36 We're calling it MK Confidential.
00:52:38 And there we cover cases that you've heard about, like JonBenet Ramsey,
00:52:42 Chandra Levy, the DC Snipers, Scott Peterson, and some that you haven't.
00:52:47 One case per week, five episodes, Monday through Friday.
00:52:51 New episodes every weeknight.
00:52:52 Search for The Megyn Kelly Show wherever you listen to podcasts,
00:52:55 and you will find MK Confidential.
00:52:58 At Capital One, we don't just use technology,
00:53:01 we architect it.
00:53:03 Our teams have true end-to-end product ownership,
00:53:06 shipping distributed systems
00:53:07 that handle high concurrency at scale.
00:53:10 No single server bottlenecks,
00:53:12 engineered beyond legacy downtime,
00:53:15 and operating right here in downtown Toronto.
00:53:18 That's technology at Capital One.
00:53:20 Search technology at Capital One Canada.
00:53:25 I'm swimming in information here, swimming in it, like drowning in it at the moment and
00:53:35 trying to keep it all straight for you. But here, here's the chronology. I didn't want to waste
00:53:40 Tara's time with going through the text to the text to the text. She was very forthcoming. That
00:53:46 is the most forthcoming we've heard any defense lawyer representing any one of these seven be.
00:53:51 so credit to her. A lot came out overnight, so I want to go through it with you. First of all,
00:54:02 you've got, okay, the reveal of texts from October 23rd. This is four days after the incident,
00:54:12 all right? And they don't make clear who she was talking to in this text exchange, but she writes,
00:54:19 bro everyone knows and then the peace sign i'm incredibly stressed out some random blocked out
00:54:27 told some of my friends i don't even know who that is how blank she know me how blank she know me so
00:54:35 i don't know exactly who she's texting with i'm going to guess it's defendant number one who's
00:54:41 matthew um because that seems to be her main friend at ki-fi and the one identified as male
00:54:48 number one, who opened the door, with whom she danced, who she thought was attractive, etc.
00:54:53 And then she texts him, still on October 23rd, four days after the incident, I will also say,
00:54:58 this is ruining my life temporarily. My reputation is destroyed, and I'm utterly ashamed. That's
00:55:07 extremely important right there, because that's the motivation. I mean, her defenders will say
00:55:15 that's the consequence of being gang raped. And I think there's a very strong argument by the young 0.88
00:55:21 men that it's the reason she changed her story. It's the reason she went from very clearly
00:55:28 saying, I consented to this and nothing illegal happened, which was another text she sent right
00:55:34 around this timeframe to one of the young men, to I was gang raped and it was not consensual and I
00:55:40 was incapacitated the whole time. And she's kind of telling us right here in her own words,
00:55:44 my reputation is destroyed and I'm utterly ashamed that all these people know. She says it.
00:55:52 All these people know my reputation is destroyed. I'm utterly ashamed. Then his piece of this
00:55:58 exchange, whoever she's texting with is blocked out by ABC. She goes on to say, you're right.
00:56:03 It'll get better. And thank you. Everyone's just jealous of us. But also like everyone needs to
00:56:09 grow up. Listen to this. Cause sexuality and sex and blank is changing and stuff like this is going
00:56:15 to become more common. I'm also really open-minded though. I love you King. Also tell anyone who
00:56:22 gives you blank that I'll actually beat them up that don't want the smoke. I promise. So she seems
00:56:30 to be saying to this guy, October 23rd, again, I'm just guessing it's male number one, Matthew,
00:56:36 that, um, she's mad. Her reputation is destroyed. She feels ashamed because everyone's talking about
00:56:45 it. And she says, I'm stressed because some of my friends know. And how do these people know
00:56:51 about it? And then he apparently says, everyone's just jealous of us. And she responds, you're right.
00:56:57 It will get better. And you think everyone's just jealous of us, but also everyone needs to grow up
00:57:04 Because sexuality and sex, it's changing.
00:57:08 And stuff like this is going to become more common.
00:57:11 I'm also really open-minded, though.
00:57:13 And then I love you, King.
00:57:15 This is one of her alleged rapists, we think, that she's talking to.
00:57:23 I love you, King.
00:57:24 I mean, if this really is defendant number one, Matthew, this is just a deeply problematic text for her side.
00:57:33 I love you, King.
00:57:34 I'm just really open-minded. Sex and sexuality is going to become more common like this,
00:57:42 meaning threesomes, obviously. This is devastating. Okay, now that was 1023.
00:57:49 Now, as I pointed out to you in the New York Times piece today that has the Title IX
00:57:57 hearing information in it, there is a reveal about what happened around this Halloween party
00:58:05 that was just devastating for Ki-Fi. Okay. Yeah. By the way, the New York Times confirms that that
00:58:11 October 23rd text is with man number one. His name is Matthew Ingalls. I guess we're going to
00:58:19 out them all. The New York Times has named him. And they also confirm, she wrote, bro, everyone
00:58:26 knows. This episode is ruining my life temporarily. My reputation has been destroyed. And then they
00:58:31 add that she wrote all she could do was sleep and cry all day. He assured her it would blow over
00:58:35 soon, noting how fast nonsense spreads at this school, saying she did not have anything to be
00:58:40 ashamed of. You're right, she responded. It'll get better. Okay, then she had a text with her
00:58:47 big sister that week. She wrote to the big sister, have you heard the rumor about your little? In
00:58:55 the meantime, Jane Doe had delivered strict instructions to one of her roommates. If anyone
00:58:58 asks about this, say it didn't happen. The roommate was plainly concerned. Initially,
00:59:03 the roommate said, Jane Doe was quote, kind of recounting it as this crazy, this sort of crazy
00:59:08 thing that she had done. So the roommate's confirming that Jane Doe came back from the house
00:59:12 and just thought it was a crazy thing she'd done, a crazy night she'd had. And then I told you in
00:59:16 that one text, she was saying people to her big sister, people are saying, I'm a slut and they're 1.00
00:59:22 right. Ha ha. I've got to tell you something. Okay. I told you yesterday that I was in Tridel 1.00
00:59:28 and you know, there's a, there's, I loved Tridel for the year that I was in it. And I deactivated
00:59:35 the next year because as I told you yesterday, I had a boyfriend who was in an athlete there and
00:59:39 they couldn't, he wasn't allowed at any of the parties. So I'm like, I don't want to go to these
00:59:42 parties. What am I doing here? Anyway, um, the, the, you've, you've probably heard the saying
00:59:48 of tridellt is tridellt everyone else has. And I'm not going to lie, there was a reputation
00:59:52 amongst some that they were kind of easy. Not yours truly, something I've always prided myself
00:59:59 on. Not easy. Really, not easy in any way. But anyway, there was a reputation in that the saying
01:00:06 was tridellt everyone else has. This girl seems to be leaning in saying, I just, you know, very
01:00:14 open-minded and sex and sexuality, it's all changing. And you know, like she's kind of cool
01:00:18 with all this. And then says to the, to the big sis, allegedly that there are rumors circulating
01:00:26 that I'm a slut. And then says with a laugh quote, unfortunately they're true. Now that was two days 0.99
01:00:32 after the alleged rape, the alleged gang rape. Now she, she's saying to her, people are calling
01:00:37 me a slut and they're right. Okay. So this is like, this is the, these are the initial texts 1.00
01:00:45 that same day, October 21st, she received a text message from defendant number two. His name is
01:00:51 Jonathan Newell. This is the one who tweeted out or Snapchat, Snapchat it out. So it's spelled
01:01:04 differently, Jonathan Newell, in the Snapchat free P word in the alumni PU. I don't know what
01:01:09 that stands for. It was an alumni room. So defendant number two, you know, we had some
01:01:14 harsh words for him yesterday. He's going to have to spend some time reconciling his behavior
01:01:20 with what I assume his parents taught him is ethical conduct. And she does have a text with
01:01:28 him. He was engaged in at least two of these threesomes, Jonathan Newell, allegedly. And
01:01:34 she has a text message with him on October 21st. That reads, this is according to the New York
01:01:45 Times' report of the Title IX proceedings. She got a text message from him, one of the men she
01:01:52 would go on to accuse of sexual assault. Quote, I just wanted to apologize for how things went
01:01:56 down the other night. He then said that both he and Matthew Ingalls, defendant number one,
01:02:01 another of the men she would lead or accuse of assault, both felt terrible for being too under
01:02:04 the influence of drugs and alcohol to, quote, shut it down and kick people out before it got
01:02:08 way out of hand. Jane Doe replied and assured him, quote, at the end of the day, none of the
01:02:14 sexual stuff was illegal. And honestly, I really liked being with you and Matt, end quote.
01:02:20 I mean I'm pretty sure that the parents of Matthew Ingalls and Jonathan Newell are probably very
01:02:30 outraged even though their son wrote that ridiculous snapchat and probably is the one
01:02:36 who got this whole thing reopened he's got it in writing from this woman that she enjoyed 0.98
01:02:41 her sex with him and that initial threesome that she enjoyed it and that none of it was
01:02:48 illegal in her viewpoint. Again, that's not determinative, but it's not helpful to a
01:02:53 prosecution. Then things started to change a bit. Well, actually, before we get to that, okay.
01:03:02 Then she had the, then she had an exchange on October 25th. Defendant number one, Matthew
01:03:07 Ingalls, texted her, you good? She replied that defendant number two, Mr. Newell, had, quote,
01:03:13 definitely told people. Days later, she sent Matthew Ingalls an image of the forum post
01:03:20 that she had found. She said while she was randomly surfing, suggesting there'd been a
01:03:25 gang rape at Ki-Fi, and she sent it to Matthew with three question marks. And he responded,
01:03:32 ridiculous. I'm going to report that. Ridiculous. I'm going to report that. 0.99
01:03:37 So there we are in late October with these exchanges, and there's nothing about a rape. 0.95
01:03:43 There's only her calling herself a slut and saying attitudes about sex are changing and calling, I believe, defendant number one, Matthew, I believe, that's not on this statement, I'm assuming, a king, saying, love you, king. 0.89
01:04:00 Then comes, according to the New York Times, the Halloween party. 0.95
01:04:06 As Halloween approached, Jane Doe's roommates told investigators her understanding of what
01:04:11 happened appeared to have shifted.
01:04:14 Around October 28th, Mr. Ingalls was on the phone with Jane Doe, and according to one
01:04:18 of her roommates, who said she overheard the conversation, he apologized to her.
01:04:23 But rather than assure him everything was okay, Jane Doe took a different tone.
01:04:27 Quote, how could you let this happen?
01:04:29 End quote.
01:04:30 The roommate recalled her saying, quote, I think she wanted it to be consensual.
01:04:35 End quote. The roommate told investigators looking back on how Jane Doe was processing the alleged assault. The roommate told investigators that Jane Doe had been sexually assaulted before, which made it particularly hard for her to talk openly about what had happened.
01:04:49 Quote, I'd have conversations and she would describe a part of what happened and I would tell her that that is what could be classified as rape.
01:04:58 So here is the roommate admitting that she is the one who introduced the concept of rape 0.84
01:05:04 to Jane Doe. She'd also read online that someone got gang raped at Ki-Fi, but it is the roommate
01:05:11 telling her, you're not a slut. You were gang raped. And the roommate testified to this, 1.00
01:05:19 that I would tell her this is what could be classified as rape. Okay, but Jane Doe was not
01:05:26 yet deterred from her desire, I think, to be with defendant one Matthew Ingalls, who
01:05:33 she thought she was attracted to, who she said she enjoyed her interlude with, who she
01:05:37 danced with and went to the Chi-Fi house to be with on the night in question.
01:05:41 The Times reports at Chi-Fi, the fraternity was preparing for a Halloween party and Jane
01:05:46 Doe was eager to attend. 0.74
01:05:48 Now, I've got to ask you if you have just been gang raped by four to seven fraternity 0.94
01:05:55 members at Chi-Fi, why would you be eager to attend a party at the fraternity house?
01:06:03 This is what came out at the Title IX hearing. She was eager to attend. She said, I am a slut.
01:06:11 She said, attitudes about sex and sexuality are changing. This is going to be happening a lot 1.00
01:06:15 more frequently. Okay. She's eager to attend the party at her alleged gang rapist's house.
01:06:24 Text messages included in the investigation show Matt Ingalls assuring Jane Doe that he
01:06:29 and other frat members wanted her to be there.
01:06:32 Quote, Ki-Fi is your house and you are welcome here, end quote, he wrote, relaying the views
01:06:37 of the fraternity's president who was not among those accused of sexual assault.
01:06:41 She responded, quote, thank you.
01:06:43 I really appreciate that, end quote.
01:06:45 And then added, quote, with a heart, I'll bring my cigs tomorrow, end quote.
01:06:50 But then, this is critical in my view, Jane Doe received a phone call from the fraternity's president, according to the text messages.
01:06:58 She was disinvited from the party.
01:07:01 It was for her own good, he said. 1.00
01:07:05 Now, I'm just going to say that was colossally fucking stupid. 1.00
01:07:12 Absolutely idiotic by that guy. 1.00
01:07:16 Now you're going to step in? 1.00
01:07:18 Now you're going to enforce some sort of moral code around her wellness and safety.
01:07:24 Dude, what did you think was going to happen?
01:07:29 Did you think that was going to make her feel all warm and fuzzy about Chi-Fi and the guys in it? 0.81
01:07:36 Or do you think that might light a fire under this woman who's already being told by her roommate she was raped
01:07:43 and starting to rethink the narrative around that night, according to that roommate.
01:07:52 So, and by the way, if you think she's in danger and it's for her own safety
01:07:56 in terms of coming back to Chi-Fi, you get your young men in order.
01:08:00 You have a little team meeting where you say no one lays a hand on her.
01:08:05 Everybody better behave like a perfect gentleman.
01:08:08 Or you know what? You cancel your party that year.
01:08:12 Just absolutely idiotic. 1.00
01:08:16 So it set her off. 1.00
01:08:19 She sent a biting text, not to the fraternity president, but to her friend, Matthew Ingalls.
01:08:25 I knew this was going to happen, she wrote.
01:08:27 The woman will always get the short end of the stick.
01:08:30 I read this earlier with Tara.
01:08:32 Y'all aren't my friends. 1.00
01:08:34 Y'all are covering your asses. 0.99
01:08:37 That is all right in advance of Halloween. 0.99
01:08:41 It's not dated in the New York Times.
01:08:45 Then, okay, by November 3rd,
01:08:49 she appears to have concluded that she was assaulted.
01:08:52 She sent a text to Mr. Newell.
01:08:56 Mr. Newell, by November 3rd.
01:09:01 Okay, and in that November 3rd text,
01:09:04 She wrote, let's be clear that 90% of what happened that night was not consensual.
01:09:10 I was given more key, meaning ketamine, than I can remember.
01:09:15 And I know that I told you I felt uncomfortable and I didn't know anyone in the room.
01:09:20 The text continued with her telling Newell, defendant number two, that one of her only 0.99
01:09:27 memories was doing ketamine off of his penis. 1.00
01:09:31 quote, in front of everyone like a sex doll slash worker, end quote. 1.00
01:09:39 This is not good for the young man, of course. And now she is saying it was, most of it was 0.95
01:09:45 non-consensual. I told you I felt uncomfortable. I didn't want anyone in the room and that she felt
01:09:51 like she was a sex doll or sex worker. Now, feeling like a sex doll or sex worker was going 1.00
01:09:57 to happen to virtually anybody other than one of these paid prostitutes. You know, if you go into 0.99
01:10:04 a room and voluntarily have sex with four to seven men, it's really only four, she's saying, 0.60
01:10:09 you're probably going to feel like that. That's why you shouldn't do it, among the many, many
01:10:12 reasons. And by the way, she showed up at the Chi-Fi house at 11 o'clock on, you know, some
01:10:19 evening, the October 19th. Let me, pro tip, nothing good is going to happen to you if you show up at
01:10:26 a fraternity house on a college campus at 11 p.m. any night of the week. Ever. Ever. And then
01:10:34 as soon as you go upstairs with somebody, guess what? They're going to think it's consent to
01:10:40 sleeping with them. Virtually every single man on earth is going to think you would like to have
01:10:47 sex with him. If you show up at the fraternity house at 11 o'clock at night, then willingly go
01:10:52 upstairs with them. And according to Jane Doe, this Matthew Ingalls then turned around to her
01:10:58 and said, would you consider having a threesome with another guy and me? And she said, yeah,
01:11:03 actually, yes, I would like to. So now you're really telegraphing consent, which she's completely
01:11:10 rejecting now. But those facts we know from her, from her six-page statement. So here we go. That
01:11:19 was November 3rd when she said it wasn't consensual, a lot of it. I told you I felt
01:11:25 uncomfortable. I didn't know anyone in the room. And the one memory was doing ketamine off of
01:11:31 your penis in front of everyone like a sex doll slash worker. Now on November 7th, she went to 1.00
01:11:38 an emergency room in Ithaca and requested a rape kit. I haven't heard much about what happened
01:11:43 with the rape kit, but I don't think from sexual interludes that happened on October 19th,
01:11:50 there would be anything relevant or probative by 11-7 other than possibly that bruise she said
01:11:57 she got on her rear end from one of the threesomes where she alleges defendant number two, that's
01:12:03 Newell, slapped her rear end hard. So it's possible that was noted, but I don't think any evidence of
01:12:11 actual intercourse would still be there. November 7th, that same day, male number one, this Matthew
01:12:17 Ingalls texted her, quote, my ex told me I'm being labeled an assaulter in the public eye.
01:12:25 I was going to ask if you may have said something along those lines to someone,
01:12:28 but I know you wouldn't. Then she responds, quote, I had a friend who was going to Chi-Fi
01:12:37 and I said, don't, but I've never mentioned your name.
01:12:43 She also then writes to him, I haven't said anything, but I do know people are changing
01:12:49 the narrative because like in any sexual scenario with one woman and many men, the woman was
01:12:55 probably the victim. You can see it's changing, right? It's changing, but she doesn't say you
01:13:03 raped me. What she doesn't say to Matthew Ingalls is, you and your friends raped me. I was out of 1.00
01:13:09 my mind, drunk and high. The next day, November 8th, he asked for a phone call. And by this point,
01:13:18 she's been to the, you know, in for a rape exam. She said she was done talking to him and that she
01:13:25 knew he, quote, lied. ABC says it's unclear what she was referring to when she says he, quote,
01:13:31 lied. He asked what she meant and asked her to call. And she answered, quote, no, never again.
01:13:39 I mean, he must have known he was effed by this point. About a week later, she gave a sworn
01:13:44 statement to Cornell police saying she felt incapacitated, declined some of the sexual
01:13:49 activity, and that the encounters, quote, felt like coercion. She, of course, then filled out
01:13:56 a six-page statement in which we believe she did not accuse them of rape explicitly
01:14:01 and did recount multiple instances of turning down certain sex acts that night and so on.
01:14:10 You know, her whole story seemed to indicate consciousness and ability to control her
01:14:16 conduct, which is deeply problematic for any prosecutor trying to prosecute this as a rape
01:14:23 case. So those are the reveals that we got overnight about the text messaging. And you can see
01:14:31 exactly what I predicted yesterday. She did this. We used to call it Sunday morning regrets back in
01:14:39 my day. She felt like a slut. She tried to laugh it off. She felt ashamed. She was still talking 1.00
01:14:47 to Matthew, the one she liked. She felt like maybe something could happen there. And then that
01:14:54 idiotic university president barred her from the Chi-Fi party, honestly. I realize this isn't the 1.00
01:15:02 main issue. I'm just saying, how fucking stupid can you be? And I think that really set her off. 1.00
01:15:09 She had the roommate in her ear saying, this sounds like rape to me. And slowly but surely, 0.60
01:15:16 she was getting pissed off because word was getting around campus and clearly the guys had
01:15:21 talked. And she didn't really want that. You know, at first with them, she's like, well,
01:15:26 sex and sexuality are changing. But what she really wanted was for people not to know what
01:15:31 she did. Because even in 2024, then America, there was a judgment attached to repeated group sex,
01:15:39 three threesomes in a night, which is kind of a relief to find out that there's still judgment
01:15:46 around that. And now here we are. Now here we are. Yeah. She filed the civil lawsuit. Again,
01:15:53 we're going to find out who she is. I do believe she's the gal from Alabama that is being named 1.00
01:15:59 online. I'm not naming anybody, not being absolutely sure who it is, but there's one
01:16:06 woman from Alabama. I mean, people, the online sleuths basically figured out who was in Tridel
01:16:10 at the time. And there were only about 50 young women. And then they figured out who didn't stay
01:16:15 at Cornell because this gal did not stay at Cornell. And then they got it down to about 10
01:16:19 or 12. Then they figured out who was from a town about a thousand miles away from Cornell because
01:16:25 she alleges in the complaint that she was from a small town around a thousand miles away. And that
01:16:30 made the list even shorter. Then they started to do further detective work, like who stopped
01:16:37 posting on Instagram around this time, et cetera. And they did get to a name. Again, we don't know
01:16:43 that it's this person who's being named, but she is this person who they, the internet believes it
01:16:47 is, is from Alabama. And Jane Doe hired a lawyer who's admitted in Alabama, who may be from
01:16:53 Alabama, the main guy who's representing her on the case. So he's got a New York address and he's
01:16:59 got an Alabama address. So that's interesting too. I guess she lives in New York now, but
01:17:04 query that connection. Why would she be hiring? Why would a New York plaintiff be hiring an 0.98
01:17:11 Alabama lawyer. And look, I stand by what I said yesterday. I just don't think there is any reason
01:17:20 when you are talking about a civil lawsuit asking for money to protect the identity of a woman
01:17:29 alleging rape when she names all of the defendants. This has to stop. We are treating women like it's
01:17:37 the handmaid's tale and that, you know, there's a paternalistic society that controls everything 0.62
01:17:42 around them and that somehow they're to blame for even for the real victims. You know, let's say she
01:17:48 actually is a real victim and all of this is true. They gang raped her. There's no shame on the 0.98
01:17:55 victim. We have been saying that we won't say the names of rape victims for a long, long time now
01:18:03 because they get shamed. Why do they get shamed? It's not a fucking rape victim's fault when she
01:18:07 gets raped. The shame is on the defendant. So this whole policy comes out of an anachronistic 1.00
01:18:15 understanding of this paternalistic society and how a woman's chaste reputation must be maintained.
01:18:23 And I'm sorry, but we are equal participants with equal power in society now. And this rule
01:18:29 is outdated. It's actually a sexist rule, sexist against women, treating them as like the fairer 0.84
01:18:36 sex that doesn't have equal power in America. And the way it's being applied here, and in many other
01:18:42 cases, is it's unfair to the male defendants. It's another serious problem of doing this.
01:18:49 Now, I'm not sure if I would feel this way if there had just been criminal charges brought
01:18:53 against these guys, because that's, I mean, I don't know. It's probably the same feeling. But
01:19:00 for sure, when it's a civil lawsuit and the person's trying to get money, she's like, pay me?
01:19:06 Like, I want to get paid. And by the way, let's not forget this woman never went back to the DA. 0.77
01:19:11 She never went back and said, now I have a Snapchat message. Please look at this and
01:19:14 consider charging. She never used her lawyer to say, please reopen the case. Why don't you
01:19:19 interview me? You never did. She went right to the tort claim with her palm out asking for money.
01:19:26 I just don't see, there's no ethical impediment stopping any media person from naming her.
01:19:32 so we'll find out who she is at some point soon i'm sure and it's unclear whether the new york
01:19:41 courts will even allow her to maintain that cloak of anonymity though it being new york i would
01:19:46 imagine they will um okay we're gonna move on to other news can we talk about picky eaters for a
01:19:53 second if you've got a kid who survives on basically three foods i want to share an easy
01:19:57 way to help fill their nutritional gaps. It's a tasteless, colorless vitamin powder called
01:20:04 Ella Ola. Mealtime with kids can be stressful, like an endless negotiation, but Ella Ola can
01:20:10 change the game. It's not a gummy or a chewable. You just mix one packet a day right into whatever
01:20:15 they're already eating or drinking. Milk, juice, yogurt, oatmeal, even ketchup. They genuinely
01:20:20 cannot detect it at all. Ella Ola was developed with pediatricians and delivers 19 essential
01:20:26 vitamins and minerals plus nutrients from 15 organic fruits and vegetables. It has zero sugar,
01:20:32 zero artificial dyes, and is free from the top nine food allergens. Over 1 million parents have
01:20:38 already made the switch for that extra peace of mind. Ella Ola is offering you 20% off your first
01:20:43 purchase. Just go to ellaola.com and the discount is applied automatically. No code needed. Try it
01:20:50 risk-free with Ella Ola's 45-day money-back guarantee. Go to ellaola.com slash mk for 20%
01:20:57 off your first purchase. Everyone's talking about weight loss injections because the results can be
01:21:02 so dramatic. They work by lowering blood sugar and reducing appetite. But what if you're looking
01:21:07 to lose weight but are not interested in painful weekly injections, especially when you hear about
01:21:12 some of those intense side effects? That's why doctors created a weight loss supplement called
01:21:17 Lean, and the results could be remarkable. Lean says the studied ingredients in their product
01:21:23 have been shown to lower your blood sugar, burn fat by converting it into energy, and curb your
01:21:28 appetite and cravings so you are not as hungry. But listen, Lean is not for the casual dieter with
01:21:33 only a few pounds to lose. The doctors at Brickhouse Nutrition created Lean for frustrated
01:21:39 dieters with 10 or more pounds to lose. You could get started with 20% off and free rush shipping,
01:21:45 adding lean to your healthy diet and exercise plan. Visit TakeLean.com and enter MK for your
01:21:51 discount. That's promo code MK at TakeLean.com. I'm Megan Kelly. Every day on The Megan Kelly
01:21:58 Show, we bring you the news, and this summer, we're bringing you something extra. Before I was
01:22:03 a journalist, I was a lawyer. I've spent 20-plus years now covering crime and the law, so I built
01:22:09 a true crime series that I always wanted to listen to. We're calling it MK Confidential,
01:22:14 And there we cover cases that you've heard about, like JonBenet Ramsey, Chandra Levy,
01:22:19 the DC Snipers, Scott Peterson, and some that you haven't.
01:22:23 One case per week, five episodes, Monday through Friday.
01:22:27 New episodes every weeknight.
01:22:29 Search for The Megyn Kelly Show wherever you listen to podcasts and you will find MK Confidential.
01:22:34 At Capital One, we don't just use technology, we architect it.
01:22:39 Our teams have true end-to-end product ownership.
01:22:42 shipping distributed systems that handle high concurrency at scale.
01:22:47 No single-server bottlenecks,
01:22:49 engineered beyond legacy downtime,
01:22:51 and operating right here in downtown Toronto.
01:22:55 That's technology at Capital One.
01:22:57 Search technology at Capital One Canada.
01:23:05 Hey everyone, it's me, Megan Kelly.
01:23:07 I've got some exciting news.
01:23:09 I now have my very own channel on Sirius XM.
01:23:13 It's called the Megyn Kelly Channel, and it is where you will hear the truth, unfiltered, with no agenda, and no apologies.
01:23:19 Along with the Megyn Kelly Show, you're going to hear from people like Mark Halperin, Link Lauren, Maureen Callahan, Emily Jashinsky, Jesse Kelly, Real Clear Politics, and many more.
01:23:28 It's bold, no BS news, only on the Megyn Kelly Channel, Sirius XM 111, and on the Sirius XM app.
01:23:39 There was a Lindsey Clancy hearing on Tuesday and nothing much happened because it was a status hearing and they did not really take on the issue of the holdout juror and what should happen to him.
01:23:51 Kevin Reddington is out for that guy's scalp.
01:23:53 But there was some talk around it.
01:23:56 And the nation's jaw collectively dropped when Kevin Reddington suddenly, after a whole trial of admitting, was never in doubt, that his client, Lindsay Clancy, had murdered her three children, suddenly injected new doubt into that question or tried to inject new doubt into that question with the following sound.
01:24:22 side 11 where is the evidence that she did this the evidence is that she cut her wrists cut her
01:24:31 throat standing in front of the mirror blood drops then went over to the window and propelled
01:24:36 herself out of the window your honor heard evidence that she indicated that the screen
01:24:40 was cut your honor also heard evidence that in fact the screen was not cut
01:24:45 your honor could infer obviously as a rational jury could infer that in fact this is a false
01:24:50 memory that she had, because she believes that the screen was cut. And it wasn't.
01:24:55 But in any event, she propels herself out the window
01:24:58 and sustains the injuries that Your Honor is well aware that she sustained.
01:25:03 Your Honor recalls looking at the blood spatter
01:25:06 evidence and the drops on the floor. Where are the smears
01:25:10 from a person who has just cut their wrists, cut their throat, is in a
01:25:14 state of psychosis that throws themselves out a window.
01:25:18 Where are the smears from that person walking across the blood up to the window?
01:25:25 What?
01:25:27 What are you saying?
01:25:28 You already admitted this at the trial.
01:25:31 Now he's trying to do a defense on the merits like she might not have done it, like actual innocence.
01:25:37 He's getting like crazed with his power.
01:25:41 He's drunk on his own wine.
01:25:43 Now, after the 11 person jury, minus the holdout, that 11 people on the jury decided that they were ready to vote, not guilty by reason of mental defect or insanity.
01:25:55 Look at him. He's like, I'm going for the straight all out innocence now.
01:26:00 OK, a little preview of what trial number two is going to look like.
01:26:04 He doubled down just in case you think that was a one off here in SOT 12.
01:26:07 this entire case is based on speculation where is the admission where does she say that she did
01:26:18 this and what's most chilling is the fact that when she comes out of this obvious coma that she
01:26:28 is in that when she comes out of it your honor heard the testimony from the psychiatrist and
01:26:34 from the doctors at Brigham and Women's Hospital.
01:26:37 She was told what happened.
01:26:40 She had no memory of what happened.
01:26:44 Why does she recall cutting the screen?
01:26:47 Why does she recall killing the children
01:26:50 where she's told what happened and had no memory?
01:26:55 There's no evidence that she admitted that she did this.
01:26:59 So you have no evidence from the defendant.
01:27:02 In Massachusetts, an uncorroborated statement of a defendant obviously is not evidence.
01:27:06 You have to have corroboration.
01:27:07 I submit to the court there is no evidence.
01:27:09 She made any statements as far as the actual killing of the children, which forms the basis of the indictments.
01:27:17 This is so crazy.
01:27:18 He's trying to relitigate the whole case now.
01:27:21 OK, your trial is over.
01:27:23 It ended in a mistrial.
01:27:25 Your client is likely to be retried.
01:27:27 You are trying to stop that, but there is a 99% chance it gets retried unless you and the prosecutor can come to some agreement.
01:27:36 But he is going to reindict her short of that.
01:27:38 And at that trial, you can go for this argument, Kevin Reddington, and argue actual innocence.
01:27:44 For some reason, you failed to in trial number one.
01:27:47 And maybe you're now going to get attacked as having provided ineffective assistance.
01:27:52 maybe lindsey clancy's going to actually appeal the mistrial or the the grant of one saying i was 0.96
01:27:58 ineffectively assisted by this idiot who gave up the farm by not arguing that i was actually 0.85
01:28:03 innocent um which is what he did don't trust me here's a soundbite for you with kevin reddington 1.00
01:28:12 then versus now. Watch. This is a woman that did not get the medication,
01:28:22 did not get the medical treatment that she so deserved. This is a woman that was suffering from
01:28:31 psychosis at the time that she went down to that basement.
01:28:37 Where's the evidence that she did this? Where is the evidence that she did this?
01:28:42 Okay. What happened in the basement is the murders. I mean, there's just been no question
01:28:48 that she did it all along. The husband, like his testimonial, like everyone knows she did it.
01:29:00 And Kevin Reddington did not dispute, did not dispute and admitted that she was in the basement,
01:29:08 that she was she was under psychosis when she went down to the basement.
01:29:14 That's that was the defense. It's very strange.
01:29:17 And he was asked about this reversal when he went on the show of our pal Billy Bush,
01:29:24 hot mics on Tuesday. Watch here. Stop 14.
01:29:27 Today, it felt to me, you know, honestly, that you opened the door a little bit to what actually happened.
01:29:32 And and and his involvement again, did you go one way back and then the other way?
01:29:38 No, not at all. Again, as I already said, what I did was argued exactly what I argued in my
01:29:44 closing to the jury, exactly what I argued in motions for required finding. The government
01:29:50 has to prove probable cause. I don't care, full stop, whatever the case may be. If they can't
01:29:57 prove the guilt of the citizen based on their investigation, that person's entitled to a not
01:30:03 guilty, regardless of what a defense may be. And this investigation was so horrific,
01:30:10 so atrocious, that it just defies, it boggles the mind why this investigation ended up the way it
01:30:18 did. So I had to raise that issue on the motion for a required finding. Okay, but you blew it
01:30:24 because you didn't raise it in the trial in chief. And in fact, what we heard in the trial in chief
01:30:29 was testimony from Patrick Clancy,
01:30:32 the victim's father,
01:30:35 about Lindsay's call to him
01:30:38 a week after the murders.
01:30:40 Quote, she said she heard a man's voice
01:30:44 telling her that if she didn't do it now,
01:30:47 she would lose her chance
01:30:48 or something like that. 0.98
01:30:50 I mean, this is what they fucking gave up the farm on this. 0.99
01:30:52 Get it together, sir. 0.99
01:30:53 Okay, get it together. 0.99
01:30:55 It's ridiculous. 0.99
01:30:56 She did it. 0.98
01:30:57 Good luck trying to persuade a jury otherwise.
01:31:03 There's news about the holdout juror.
01:31:06 He, as you may know, issued a statement on tape saying, I didn't have any doubt, actually.
01:31:12 I had no doubt.
01:31:14 And then his attorneys went on panity on Tuesday, and they are none too happy with Kevin Reddington
01:31:22 for besmirching their client as a lying felon, accusing him of lying under oath, which is a
01:31:29 felony, repeatedly just for doing his civic duty. Listen here, Asat 15.
01:31:37 Oh, Sean, I can tell you, we're going to file a bargain plan. Look, he filed, in his words that
01:31:42 we just heard a second ago, he said that all he's done is file a motion. Well, even if you take that
01:31:49 is true, which it obviously isn't. The motion that he filed was unprecedented. You don't attack
01:31:55 jurors this way. You don't single them out. And we're going to file a bar complaint. I want your
01:32:00 audience to know. I want you to know that that's happening. Absolutely. And here's the holdout
01:32:06 juror himself. Hi, my name is Michael Peggy Desronville, also known as the lone juror.
01:32:13 I know the whole focus has been on me, but we want to reel everything back and put the focus on the three angels that's at hand.
01:32:23 The ones that can't speak for themselves, the ones that can't defend themselves, and the ones that can't fight the battles.
01:32:31 And those are Cora, Dawson, and Callan.
01:32:35 A little bit about me.
01:32:37 I want to thank God for my Catholic faith.
01:32:39 I want to thank God for blessing me with the ability to love my daughter.
01:32:46 And foremost, I would like to thank everyone, every individual that has supported me throughout this difficult situation.
01:32:56 Your prayers, your emotional support, your psychological support is tremendous to my heart.
01:33:06 that I feel, that I sense, that I know.
01:33:11 I do want to thank you from the bottom of my heart.
01:33:14 Thank you.
01:33:16 There you go.
01:33:17 They're filing bar complaint against Kevin Reddington
01:33:19 as well they should.
01:33:22 How dare he accuse a juror of committing a felony
01:33:27 in the middle of the trial
01:33:29 because he won't come to a verdict
01:33:32 along the lines that defense counsel wants.
01:33:34 That is so outrageous. And now he has spent weeks attacking and defaming this private citizen.
01:33:43 It's just beyond the pale. And honestly, all of the defense lawyers and prosecutors in Massachusetts
01:33:52 should join in this motion. They should make an example out of this guy. The judge should throw
01:34:00 the book at Kevin Reddington. He should be outraged, this judge in this case, and the
01:34:05 bar should throw the book at him in the ethical proceeding. There is zealous advocacy, which
01:34:12 is expected of every lawyer, and then there is harassment of a juror proceeding in good
01:34:19 faith. This is deeply wrong. The attorney went on to speak a bit about what has happened
01:34:27 to Michael Desronville, the holdout juror, since Kevin Reddington began his nonsense. Here's Thought
01:34:32 16. His life has changed dramatically. He has been docked. He has been threatened. He has been
01:34:40 harassed. But as I've said, Michael is absolutely indestructible. He will not be broken by this.
01:34:48 And he has remained calm, cool, and collected. And the man that you saw on that video is
01:34:56 Michael. Michael is a man of devout Catholic faith who loves his daughter, cares very deeply
01:35:03 about the three innocent children who were murdered, and is somebody who cares also
01:35:10 very deeply about the United States Constitution and following the law and following the evidence.
01:35:17 This is just so insane. So the drama there goes on and on and doesn't look like it's coming to
01:35:23 a close anytime soon. There will be a hearing about the holdout juror. It was rescheduled
01:35:29 because they hadn't copied his lawyers and given them enough time to respond to all the
01:35:33 allegations swirling around him. So they asked for that to be postponed, which was accommodated
01:35:39 by the lawyers, the prosecution and defense. But we will be getting to that. And when we
01:35:44 do, we will have it covered for you. Okay, there is other legal news that we need to
01:35:49 get to on a case we spent a fair amount of time on last week, which was the murder accusations
01:35:57 against so-called pastor, music pastor, worship pastor, Caleb Flynn. This guy in Ohio who was
01:36:05 married to Ashley for 15 years. They have two daughters. And this is the guy who had tried out
01:36:13 for American Idol. I failed. And he said his wife was just so very pretty, Ashley, and he loved her
01:36:20 so much and she encouraged him to try out for American Idol, but he failed. And then 15 years
01:36:25 later, I guess her good looks had waned in his eye because he started banging some 20-year-old
01:36:32 who frequented his church, Alea. And he had an affair with Alea for some two years or so,
01:36:40 18 months to two years. And this is Caleb and his wife, Ashley. And this Alea and he had over
01:36:49 100,000 text messages with one another referring to poor Ashley as, quote, douche and bitch 1.00
01:36:57 and other choice terms. Both of them called her that. By the way, all the testimony was that 1.00
01:37:03 Ashley was such a lovely person. And the text messages from her to Caleb, her husband,
01:37:07 showed somebody who was actually quite sweet and loving.
01:37:12 She clearly at one point found out about the affair
01:37:14 because at one point she said, like, where are you?
01:37:17 And he said he was working and she said, be honest, are you with her?
01:37:22 I mean, like, can you imagine?
01:37:24 Most of us would have been, like, driving there in our bathrobes
01:37:28 with our, you know, moisturizer all over our face,
01:37:32 banging on whatever door he said he was behind.
01:37:34 Like, it would not be, are you with her? 1.00
01:37:36 it would be, I'm going to fucking kill this person. Not really, but just like yell at. 1.00
01:37:42 Anyway, he shot his wife twice in the head as she lay sleeping and then tried to claim that
01:37:50 an intruder had come in through the garage door while he was out of the room in with the daughters
01:37:54 and he was shock, shock. They had a fan on and they didn't hear it. And, you know, he just
01:37:58 couldn't believe it. And he called 911 and, you know, got the worst actor award for his ridiculous 0.98
01:38:03 histrionics and within days was arrested. And in the closing argument, his lawyer 0.73
01:38:09 went for it, um, really went for it and went after Alaya and basically tried to tell the jury,
01:38:18 how do you know she didn't do it? Which was a good card. He should have played
01:38:23 even harder during the course of the trial. But here's a bit of that in SOT 17.
01:38:27 The judge is going to provide you instructions. And basically the bottom line is you can believe
01:38:32 or disbelief all or any part in any way
01:38:36 that's his testimony.
01:38:39 So let's do a little test.
01:38:42 Should we believe Aliyah?
01:38:45 If you believe that she was a virgin
01:38:47 and she did Caleb, 0.99
01:38:48 I have some swamp plant that I would like to sell you. 0.88
01:38:52 And then you have the unmitigated gall
01:38:56 to lie to the FBI.
01:39:02 Okay, she wanted to save her reputation.
01:39:07 How would you do that?
01:39:10 The issue here isn't whether he was a good husband, 1.00
01:39:15 was he an asshole, 1.00
01:39:18 or any other label you want to put on him. 1.00
01:39:23 Bad husband.
01:39:25 That's not the issue.
01:39:32 So there you go.
01:39:40 If you could, if you could not hear it, he asked, should we believe Alaya?
01:39:44 If you believe that she was a virgin when she did Caleb, I have some swampland I would like to sell you.
01:39:49 OK, well, was the jury persuaded that they should find him not guilty because Alaya may have done it?
01:39:57 Here's the verdict.
01:39:58 Sat 18.
01:39:59 we the jury in this case being duly impaneled and sworn find the defendant caleb c flynn guilty of
01:40:07 aggravated murder as charged in count one of the indictment we the jury in this case being duly
01:40:13 impaneled and sworn find the defendant caleb c flynn guilty of murder as charged in count four
01:40:19 of the indictment at this time juror number one mr applegate were these verdicts your own yes okay
01:40:26 Thank you. Ms. Atkins, were these verdicts your own? Members of the jury, you are now discharged
01:40:34 from your duties. Thank you. Ms. Osendorf, if you would walk them out.
01:40:47 The defendant, who has been crying more than John Boehner at a tearful event,
01:40:54 has been in tears the entire time.
01:40:58 And of course, when his own fate was determined,
01:41:00 he blubbered like a small toddler.
01:41:03 He will now be going to prison 0.99
01:41:04 and no one gives a shit that he is upset about it. 0.98
01:41:07 So goodbye, Caleb Flynn. 0.98
01:41:09 I wish you no good luck.
01:41:10 I actually hope you do not enjoy prison,
01:41:13 but that some of your prison,
01:41:16 fellow prisoners do enjoy your stint there.
01:41:18 And I'll just leave it at that.
01:41:20 I want to give you the latest on Presley Gerber
01:41:23 because there's news via TMZ on that today.
01:41:27 And it's unbelievable, guys.
01:41:29 It's unbelievable.
01:41:31 So, you know, all along we've been having,
01:41:33 I had questions about why was he in this,
01:41:37 what kind of a rehab can you OD in?
01:41:41 You know, and I told you that I had a loved one
01:41:42 who went to Karen Rehab here in the Northeast
01:41:45 and you could not get anywhere near there
01:41:47 with anything even approaching intoxicating in your bag
01:41:52 or for your loved ones, stuff that, you know, you would never think would be used as a drug,
01:41:57 would be confiscated from you as a visitor. So I didn't understand this. And then it turned out
01:42:02 he wasn't at a rehab facility. He was at a, like a sober house, which is much, much short of a
01:42:10 rehab. Okay. I don't, I still didn't understand why they would take somebody who's an active
01:42:15 addiction, quite clearly, and put him in a sober house. And now TMZ is reporting on that. And it's
01:42:23 pretty clear now. TMZ reports that Presley Gerber did have a sober coach. Remember I had said,
01:42:34 why not have a sober coach? There is somebody you can pay to follow you around when you're
01:42:38 really vulnerable to make sure you don't drink. He did have a sober coach. They say he had a sober
01:42:42 coach, the sober coach had planned to take Presley to an rehab facility, an actual rehab
01:42:48 facility, the following Monday, but needed to put him somewhere over the weekend. So he took him to
01:42:55 this place called Resolutions and just left him there. Here is Harvey Levin expanding on Presley's
01:43:03 last hours, SOT 22. I want to tell you what I know about Presley Gerber's death, and I know a lot.
01:43:12 I want to start with the Saturday morning before he died, 24 hours before he was found dead.
01:43:21 Presley Gerber was in a therapy group with other men and was very open about his struggles,
01:43:30 about his personal life, about his battle with substances.
01:43:37 That morning, I am told he was fine.
01:43:42 He was not high. It changed midday.
01:43:46 There were people who had contact with him in the middle of the day on Saturday.
01:43:52 And it became apparent that Presley Gerber started to circle the drain.
01:43:59 He was clearly high and scared.
01:44:02 Um, what people around him told me is that he was actually scared that something bad
01:44:11 was going to happen to him and felt a need, uh, to get some help.
01:44:17 Now he was with a sober coach at least part of the day and at around six o'clock in the
01:44:23 evening on Saturday, that sober coach, we're told, contacted Resolutions Living. The sober
01:44:33 coach, we're told, contacted Resolutions and said, I want to bring Presley in, but I need
01:44:43 you to know that he's high. And the facility said, bring him in. Just bring him in. Presley
01:44:53 Gerber is in this house and nobody is looking. Where is the sober coach? If the sober coach
01:45:03 knows that he was high going in, where is the sober coach in all of this? Because based on what
01:45:12 we know, it appears that sober coach was nowhere in sight. So he got dumped there by his sober
01:45:20 coach. And TMZ also obtained this video of Presley, which they say he took of himself
01:45:28 Saturday evening around 10 p.m. He would only have, what, 12 hours to live? He looks very thin.
01:45:38 It's being shot on the side and then back up. It looks jumpy, TMZ says, because they had to
01:45:43 slow it down. But he's showing his room. It's supposed to be luxury accommodations.
01:45:49 and I don't know whether this was posted
01:45:52 or just found on his phone.
01:45:53 I mean, honestly, if this was just on his phone,
01:45:55 then they got this from his family,
01:45:58 which is very strange.
01:46:00 Why would the family be leaking videos
01:46:03 of Presley Gerber to TMZ?
01:46:06 Perhaps he posted it on his social media
01:46:08 and then took it down.
01:46:10 We didn't see it
01:46:11 and we checked the social media right away.
01:46:13 I don't know how we got our hands on this,
01:46:18 but it is disturbing to see Presley Gerber within hours of his death when he had no family around
01:46:25 him, clearly no friends, and no sober coach to protect him. It's very sad. They also, TMZ,
01:46:35 did caught up with this Dr. Reza Nambavi, who owns Resolutions, and they asked him,
01:46:40 why would you admit somebody while high? I'm just going to show you just a little bit of this,
01:46:45 top 24. Doctor, why would you admit Presley Gerber into your sober house if you knew he was, he was
01:46:54 high? Is there anything you could say to the public? That's it. She keeps firing questions
01:47:03 at him and he keeps walking away because he knows all of this is deeply problematic.
01:47:10 More on that as we get it. And we will see you again tomorrow. Thank you for tuning in.
01:47:15 Thanks for listening to The Megyn Kelly Show. No BS, no agenda, and no fear.