00:00:51.560On select 2026 Bronco Sport Models, get over $9,000 in total price adjustments.
00:00:56.900For details, visit your Ontario Ford store or Ford.ca.
00:01:00.760Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, live on Sirius XM Channel 111 every weekday at New East.
00:01:12.460Hey everyone, I'm Megyn Kelly. Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show. Happy Tuesday.
00:01:17.060Well, today we've got updates for you on Hayden Penetier and what's going on with Brad Pitt's
00:01:21.760daughter. But first, the trial that's been riveting the nation, the murder case against
00:01:26.620Lindsay Clancy, now winding down. Clancy admitted that she killed her three children,
00:01:32.300five-year-old Cora, three-year-old Dawson, and eight-month-old Callan in January of 2023,
00:01:38.000but she has pleaded not guilty thanks to mental disease or defect. Her lawyers arguing that she
00:01:45.000had postpartum psychosis, which left her unable to understand what she was doing was wrong.
00:01:51.700There is dispute about whether, in fact, she was suffering from psychosis or not.
00:01:57.520Prosecutors acknowledge that she was having mental health issues, but psychosis is something
00:02:03.460that's particular, and their experts over on the prosecution team have said that is
00:02:08.920not something that typically affects women eight months after birth, and now we're getting
00:02:14.580into the testimony about whether she did or did not hear alleged voices.
00:02:19.740Prosecutors yesterday calling forensic psychologist Dr. Kirk Heilbrin to the stand, who who cast doubts on Lindsey Clancy's claims on this front about did she hear voices or did she just hear her own internal thoughts as she decided to kill her own children?
00:02:50.300And she's never experienced it since, but she only experienced it for the 18 minutes
00:02:57.680or so that it took to kill the children.
00:03:02.920and to put it mildly that would be a very very unusual
00:03:10.300pattern or or manifestation of how this kind of thing comes about uh very unusual i've been doing
00:03:19.480this kind of evaluation for many many years and i'm always very careful when someone tells me
00:03:27.400that they experienced the symptom only during the course of committing an offense.
00:03:33.840Of course, because it smells. It seems convenient. It seems made up in order to help get you off.
00:03:40.700This is the prosecution's witness. It was called as a rebuttal witness as they finished their case.
00:03:46.060They rested their case. The defense then rested its case. These are rebuttal witnesses meant to
00:03:50.800rehabilitate the prosecution's main argument. The defense objected to Dr. Heilbrunn's testimony
00:03:59.740when we covered this in AM update this morning. He brought up, the prosecution did not bring it up,
00:04:05.820but he brought up a reference to Lindsay Clancy's Catholic faith here.
00:04:12.200Could describe for us the evidence that you saw for suicide combined with altruistic filicide.
00:04:18.060Yeah. Altruistic filicide is a term that's used that means killing your kids out of love so that you could basically they wouldn't have to suffer so you could prevent their suffering.
00:04:38.340And further evidence that you saw for the suicide combined with altruistic filicide?
00:04:43.320There was. One of the things that she said when asked about what happened is that in the course of strangling each child, she said, go to God, baby, go to God.
00:05:01.060And that was part of her expectation that she and the children would be together in heaven with God.
00:05:09.020She was raised as a Catholic, and this, as I understand, Catholic considerations, that's not necessarily what happens.
00:05:21.940But when I asked her about that, when I said, isn't suicide a moral sin?
00:05:38.240You're not allowed to get into the defendant's religion.
00:05:42.620This is a passing reference on a discussion that they had, and they tried to blow it up into some huge deal with Clancy's attorney, Kevin Reddington, who he just—this came up a week ago.
00:05:55.020There was a reference to her religion, and the question by some of her supporters was, oh, there should be a mistrial, and Kevin Reddington then said, why would I want a mistrial?
00:06:05.280I don't want to start this thing all over again. But now he saw an opportunity to at least put a little chit in there for an appeal just in case this thing doesn't go his way.
00:06:16.100And so like any good defense attorney, he decided to sort of do a masquerade, in my opinion, of being deeply offended by this passing reference to whether Catholicism allows you to kill your kids and then yourself.
00:06:29.400a newsflash. It doesn't. Anyway, he called for a mistrial. Here it is.
00:06:36.620I have to move for a mistrial reluctantly. The reason is that this is intentional misconduct
00:06:42.820on the part of the prosecution. You know that this whole idea of injecting Roman Catholic faith,
00:06:50.900the concept of mortal sin um into this trial occurred i don't even remember now about a week
00:06:59.700ago and i objected but before i could get the objection out your honor had us at the sidebar
00:07:05.940at the same time and very forcefully um in my opinion indicated to the jurors that they should
00:07:13.880not consider that to any degree uh the fact that this is not the first time that it occurred during
00:07:20.700the trial and the prosecution has previously brought up the concept of mortal sin. Based on
00:07:26.180your ruling in the past, in conjunction with the fact that they brought it up again,
00:07:31.520I believe it was intentional misconduct. And I feel that the court should grant a motion for
00:07:36.700mistrial. Is anyone confused about Christianity and Catholicism finding suicide a mortal sin?
00:07:47.820And is that a big news flash to your average juror in Massachusetts, which is heavily Catholic?
00:07:54.240I think we're good. This is ridiculous.
00:07:56.860The prosecutor noted that she didn't actually ask a question about religion and that really all the witness was doing was recounting a conversation he had with her about it.
00:08:05.560She was trying to justify it, saying, oh, you know, I wanted them to go with God.
00:08:36.960But even if this is altruistic filicide, you know, killing your children because you think it's what's best for them.
00:08:44.620It's not a defense. That's not a defense. It's not a defense.
00:08:50.200Judge William Sullivan rejected the motion for a mistrial, but he wasn't exactly pleased with the prosecution.
00:08:56.600He testified she was raised as a Catholic.
00:09:00.360And as I understand Catholic considerations, that's not necessarily what happens.
00:09:05.560how is any of that proper at this point but oh it was not theatrics
00:09:15.320i i'm not going to uh declare mistrial at this time what i am going to do is i'm going to bring
00:09:26.800the jury in i'm going to tell them to disregard it i'm going to tell them that it's an inappropriate
00:09:32.180area of inquiry, and that this witness's understanding of Catholic dogma or Catholic
00:09:39.220teaching is irrelevant. Okay. Dr. Kirk Heilbrunn is back on the witness stand this morning as the
00:09:48.100case moves toward its conclusion. We could have closing arguments as soon as this afternoon.
00:09:54.100Joining me now to react to this case and more is board-certified internist and addiction
00:09:58.760specialist, Dr. Drew. He is the host of Ask Dr. Drew. We are still a couple months out,
00:10:05.540but the midterms are fast approaching and make no mistake, if the house flips,
00:10:09.440it's a big deal for our economy. That uncertainty is one of the reasons to consider diversifying now
00:10:15.300with gold from Birch Gold Group. In the three months leading up to the 2024 presidential
00:10:20.380election, the price of gold jumped over 12%. Why? It's a hedge against uncertainty. If you do not
00:10:27.700own gold, consider talking with Birch Gold. They will discuss your goals and explain how precious
00:10:33.500metals can fit into your savings. They could even help you convert an existing IRA or 401k
00:10:39.220into an IRA in gold for no additional money out of pocket. Text the letters MK to the number
00:10:45.000989898 and get a free info kit and some solid information. The midterms will be here before
00:10:50.980you know it, don't wait. Text MK to 989898 now. Dr. Drew, great to see you again. I mean,
00:10:59.720what did you make of that? Well, first of all, it makes me sad you're not practicing law anymore
00:11:03.420because we need you out there with a common sense approach to the reality. But there's so much to
00:11:09.480unpack here. And you did a great job of sort of bringing up the relevance and the legal issues.
00:11:15.140But let me talk a little bit about the medical stuff. And then I want to get at the philosophical
00:11:18.940crux of what's going on in this case, which is that the altruistic filicide is somewhat
00:11:25.100relevant from the standpoint that it's a common preoccupation in psychosis of various types,
00:11:34.000not strictly speaking postpartum psychosis. And the doctor on the stand was absolutely correct.
00:11:39.260To have a postpartum psychosis eight months after pregnancy is odd, and to have only transient
00:11:44.740hallucinations is unusual, though we don't know the extent to which she was connected to reality
00:11:52.440leading up to that, which is really all that counts. And the second issue that keeps getting
00:11:57.380brought up that really should have been, seems to me, sort of discussed here on the stand,
00:12:02.460which was, yes, it's unusual, but her medical management was also unusual. And it is certainly
00:12:09.020a possibility that the medication she was receiving could have made the psychotic symptoms worse
00:12:15.780because they clearly thought they were treating depression. And sometimes when people aggressively
00:12:20.700treat depression in somebody with bipolar, and we know she has bipolar because she was on Lamictal,
00:12:25.580which is a mood-stabilizing medicine that puts her... What's that? Someone concluded that she
00:12:31.240was bipolar. The husband disputes that. Okay. They put her on meds for it. So someone
00:12:35.120to diagnose that. And that increases the probability of postpartum psychosis dramatically.
00:12:41.660The vast majority of postpartum psychosis is in bipolar patients. But could the medical team,
00:12:48.420which was very fragmented, a lot of it was done by ER doctors, were completely
00:12:53.540unequipped to do this. And is that a possible reason that this was so odd?
00:12:59.440Yeah. I mean, I definitely see the medical community as having had a hand in where this wound up, for sure. I mean, it's just, who hasn't had the experience of, you know, one doctor tells you this, another doctor tells you that, they don't coordinate.
00:13:17.940I mean, honestly, like, and I am somebody, I have means, I can pay out of pocket for these doctors, and it happens to me.
00:13:24.760If you don't have good insurance and, you know, you're just dealing with the system as it's set up, you are definitely going to get conflicting medical advice.
00:13:34.900I mean, I've never had it on, like, I don't take any, you know, mental health drugs, but, you know, just regular drugs on, like, whatever, your flu or whatever you're battling.
00:13:44.820And this poor woman, as you see, like the number of people weighing in, the cacophony of meds that were thrown at her, you can see the cocktail was dangerous and not well managed.
00:13:55.980But that doesn't mean she didn't plan, knowing what it would do and what it would mean, the murder of her children.
00:14:04.960And, you know, you said that the extent to which she was connected to reality leading up to the murders is relevant.
00:14:41.340It happens more than we want to admit, both to schizophrenics and to postpartum psychosis.
00:14:46.120It's an awful thing when it is missed.
00:14:48.840And I want to make one quick pitch on what you said about the health care system.
00:14:52.740Underlying the deficiencies is the evisceration of primary care.
00:14:56.960There needs to be a well-trained primary care doctor supervising all of it, taking in the information, being the ombudsman for the patient and guiding him or her through it.
00:15:08.940But most of my time these days is spent guiding my family and friends through the health care system.
00:15:15.100And I think to myself, what would have happened if I hadn't been here?
00:15:18.800It's just unbelievable how deficient the system is in terms of the care that people get.
00:15:25.300Well, and I actually think we're seeing some of that play out in another way than the Lindsay Clancy trial.
00:15:33.280In my experience, so I've been on the air, you know, with this show for about six years.
00:15:37.580And in my experience, there is a vast delta between traditional medicine and functional medicine.
00:15:46.000And you can wind up with diametrically opposing points of view from doctors in those respective camps to where you as a civilian have no idea what to do.
00:16:00.860And a lot of the people who are just disgusted with what's happening to Lindsay Clancy, many of them are more functional medicine people who don't really believe in these psychotropic drugs to begin with and can't believe that this medical system just completely drugged her up so severely.
00:16:17.440And then some are still in the old traditional medicine mindset and just don't understand why there wasn't, as you're pointing out, a primary care physician who was at the helm, who was running herd on these very serious drugs being poured into this woman's body.
00:16:33.940And, yeah, I am very in favor of medical freedom.
00:16:37.500COVID taught us that the government, much to my amazement, can get involved, that most doctors are employees now, and the employer can get involved.
00:16:46.360you need to maintain the freedom for yourself and your family. But primary care needs to be a part
00:16:52.140of that because no matter whether you choose somebody more functionally or allopathic oriented,
00:16:57.380educate yourself and act accordingly. But there's something deeper in this case that I wanted to
00:17:02.660get. It's a perfect day for me to talk to you about this because I've been thinking a lot about
00:17:05.920this, which is a philosophical question, which is that when somebody engages in violent acts of any
00:17:13.200type there's always reasons for it that are of a psychological psychiatric nature whether it's where
00:17:20.880you were brought up or the violence you experience or the trauma you experienced in childhood
00:17:25.360or something happened you know the but whatever it might be there are many different causational
00:17:31.840influences on somebody being violent why do we draw the line right here is the question you know
00:17:40.080why do we say, well, at psychosis, there's a reason she became psychotic. There was a mess
00:17:45.580here. There was a lot of reasons, but you look at anybody being violent. I'm just proposing this as
00:17:50.860a, as a sort of a polemic, which is everybody has horrible backgrounds when they are violent.
00:17:57.000It's always the case. There's a lot of stuff there, psychiatrically, psychologically. Now,
00:18:01.960why do we differentiate that from say this? That's a very good question. Yes, exactly. If
00:18:08.740you picked your average gangbanger off of the streets in South Chicago and looked at his
00:18:15.660childhood experience, you'd be horrified. Yes. Horrified. Exactly. And you would accurately
00:18:20.860predict that he'd join a gang and participate in gang violence himself. But her, yeah, it's a
00:18:26.640different story. Now we're like, we're looking for a more specific reason. Did the drugs do it?
00:18:32.280What did it? That's an interesting question. It is. I mean, I don't. What do you think?
00:18:36.340Because we expect more, I think, of mothers.
00:18:41.320And a person like Lindsay, who doesn't seem to have had a lifetime of trauma leading up to this horrific act.
00:18:46.800That's right. So there's one caveat, I would say, which is, you know, we in this country talk a lot about evil and we seem very confused about what that means.
00:18:55.200But there are people who enjoy hurting other people that exist. That's evil. There's no doubt about it.
00:19:00.740and there are people who end up hurting other people
00:19:03.780and feel like they're either doing good
00:19:50.960Like, I mean, you have guys who are basically frothing at the mouth, unable to put two sentences together, who are still psychotic when the cops show up.
00:20:18.920finding. So like, I look at her, she's a lot closer to sane than they are. And I just legally,
00:20:25.160the standard's so high, I don't see it. And I don't really care because she's ruined her life.
00:20:31.080Her earthly time here is effectively over, whether she's alive or dead. You kill your three children,
00:20:37.560I don't think you're ever going to be happy, ever. And if you are, most of us are going to
00:20:42.560begrudge it to you. So I don't have a lot of care in my heart for what happens to Lindsay Clancy.
00:20:48.660I don't care if she goes to the mental institution for the rest of her life, if she goes to a prison for some limited amount of time.
00:20:55.480My lawyer friends are telling me she might be out on the streets earlier if she stays within the prison system than if she goes into a mental facility where they tend to hold you longer.
00:21:07.660So that's, I mean, for people who really want to see her punished, query what they should be rooting for.
00:21:12.020For me, I'm like, this woman's life is effectively over either way.
00:21:15.600I completely agree with you. But let me I want to go back to the legal standard. It's really important to understand the medical standard, legal standard are completely different. And the legal standard is any evidence of consciousness of doing something wrong, essentially, and very state by state a little bit. But generally, it's almost impossible. That's why lawyers don't even try not guilty by reason of insanity, because you can't you can't prove it. It's impossible to say, because everybody has to plan whatever it is they're doing, even if it's just to get a machete.
00:21:47.760All you have to do is the slightest evidence of doing you aware that you're doing something wrong or that other people would even understand it as something wrong.
00:34:17.440And the next thing you know, your patient's in a downward spiral.
00:34:20.120And she was getting like, this one woman who was treating her seemed like an idiot who hadn't been out of medical school more than two minutes, who wasn't on the case.
00:34:29.620Then she wound up in the care of physician's assistants who weren't even doctors.
00:34:36.140No offense to physician's assistants, but there should be a psychiatrist managing psychiatric medicine.
00:34:42.840And so, and she did see, I mean, I will say this for Lindsay Clancy.
00:34:46.560she and the husband did seem to try to reach out for medical help like with these meds over and
00:34:54.340over and over again and she wasn't keeping it a secret that she was having these issues she seemed
00:34:59.140to have been jumping up and down saying for the love of god somebody please help yes and back to
00:35:03.840my what i was saying about primary care you're not going to see doctors anymore in primary care
00:35:07.560some look some physicians assistants and nurse practitioners are outstanding some are not but
00:35:12.760you're not going to see doctors anymore that's what you're that the insurance company has made
00:35:16.280sure to set it up that way they have eviscerated primary care i'm telling you the other thing is
00:35:22.380primary care extenders and otherwise are the predominant prescribers of these medicines
00:35:29.160and they are not trained to do it i was interested in the brain in psychiatry i arrived at the
00:35:36.640psychiatric hospital was very enthusiastic about learning psychiatry i thought i knew something
00:35:40.920about it. After a year, I thought, oh my God, I don't know anything. I need psychiatric consults
00:35:46.360because it gets complicated. After five years there, I went, I'm never prescribing without a
00:35:50.620psychiatric consult. And they almost are never asked for. And patients resist them. They resist
00:35:56.120psychiatric consults. I don't want to see that. I'm not crazy. I don't want to see a psychiatrist.
00:36:00.140Well, I love my therapist. I have said before, he's more like a life coach than he is a shrink,
00:36:05.300But I can I can sum up his advice for all the listening audience. People are complicated. People are complicated. He's right. We are. We are. But but there but you you mentioned the the growing sort of what's going the mob that's growing around Lindsay Clancy. I am gravely concerned about mobs right now.
00:36:27.620I predicted it. I wanted to write a chapter about it in a book because I saw the narcissistic turn.
00:36:33.920I saw all the trauma in childhood, and I couldn't find a period of history where there was as much of that as pre-revolutionary France.
00:36:40.700So I just deduced that there's going to be guillotines, there's going to be mobs, and we are in it.
00:36:46.160And it's dangerous now. It's really—I woke up this morning feeling scared.
00:36:50.820Thank you for saying that, because I've worried about this, Doc, because much in the same way when we see a suicide, you know, a very prominent public suicide, they tend to come in threes.
00:37:00.460You know, it's almost always the case, just from a news person's perspective, that when you see one, then you see follow-up ones.
00:37:07.760Remember, there was Anthony Bourdain and there was Kate Spade, and then we just had two others publicly.
00:37:13.120But in any event, I worry about that dynamic affecting moms.
00:37:19.260like the idea has been floated and and in a way blessed by these loons who are doing these videos
00:37:27.960and like making lindsey clancy into some sort of a heroine there should be a fair amount of
00:37:32.820condemnation and scorn even if you have some empathy for her and the mental health struggle
00:37:37.640she went through i think we we must have a fair amount of condemnation and scorn well
00:37:42.360I must tell you what I'm seeing, uh, in response to, and it's not that, uh, which is
00:37:50.440men fleeing. I'm just seeing a male flight. I would call it, uh, from, from relationships.
00:37:59.960Uh, you, you go on Instagram and X and you'll see all men. Like I don't, these women should not,
00:38:06.200they don't, I don't want them to have my kids. I don't want these. I don't know, no, no, no,
00:38:08.760they're right well and it's it's you know that 90 day fiancee show was prescient they're going
00:38:17.180elsewhere to find women to be in relationships with and it has accelerated uh a lot of they
00:38:25.060should what's it they should well they're doing it and it's they should why would you marry one
00:38:29.600of these lunatics you you there any any man any man out there should marry somebody who is mentally
00:38:36.300well i mean that has to be the first criterion you know like before you do anything what's her
00:38:43.540family like what what's her background like how does she handle adversity stress sadness like
00:38:50.600all of those things need to be like you can't you can compromise on like oh he's not as clever as
00:38:57.460i'd like you know i'd like somebody with a sharper sense of humor you cannot compromise on basic
00:39:01.820mental health. I agree with you. And there's a layer above that, which is there is a movement
00:39:10.540to vilify men. And a lot of women have bought fully into it and then have strange expectations
00:39:16.880about marriage and childbearing, as we were talking about earlier. And there's, I was, again,
00:39:22.460maybe the algorithm is feeding me stuff, but I saw a ridiculous number of videos, women saying,
00:39:28.400oh i'm just not feeling it anymore i just i love the guy you know yeah they're in a beautiful home
00:39:32.960you know they're obviously he's very supportive of them financially and otherwise and uh i need
00:39:37.200to end this i'm not kind of kind of not feeling it and then fast forward to a video of somebody's
00:39:41.440the same woman sobbing like he doesn't want to be my friend anymore and i just and men think to
00:39:45.840themselves honey you just ruined his life you destroyed this guy and of course he doesn't want
00:39:50.160to be your friend and there's all this confusion going on in in women and men and their relationships
00:39:57.920in this country it's not so much elsewhere so men are fleeing it's it's sad to see
00:40:02.500i i completely agree this is one of the many reasons why dr jordan peterson's work has been
00:40:08.440so important and his he'll fire right back at you if you play that card what about you how great
00:40:15.440are you you think you're so great sister like you have no flaws what do you think led him to be so
00:40:20.060apathetic or to wind up cheating he's not you know it's not about i'm not ready to do that i'm not
00:40:24.480but it's also not about always blaming the man it's it's it is it's more that zone where
00:40:32.460you know it's so it's so um disposable humans are disposable relationships are disposable
00:40:39.960that that's a horrible quality we need to invest in relations this whole notion of building a
00:40:46.000family people don't even talk about that when they get married they talk about weddings
00:40:50.660You're going to be the head of a family that gets built, and you're going to build it, God willing, through generations.
00:40:57.360And that is the function of those two people getting married.
00:41:09.260Right. And if you get to it, if you do do it, you've got to think about leading this unit that is the foundation of society.
00:41:18.600And it's under attack. It's been under attack for quite a while.
00:41:21.720Yeah. Some of that messaging, it has been apparent in these crazy videos that here's a little flavor of what we're hearing around the Clancy trial on this front.
00:42:18.420Russia, Eastern Europe, Europe, you know, like where you have more hardline women who
00:42:23.300respect and love their men and understand like a family hierarchy and are fine with it.
00:42:27.380But like, yeah, I would never want somebody I know and love to wind up with that crazy
00:42:33.100But I, at the same time, I was such a moderate, Megan, I'm brutal this way in my own brain, which I get what she's saying. I get the point. I get, yes, yes, horrible things have happened to women, for sure, for sure. That doesn't mean that we should use, what, the court system as a means of getting justice for the Salem witch trial for women that were mistreated.
00:43:00.440Salem witch trial, that was made up shit. There were no witches. They were pointing at normal female behavior and calling it witch-like behavior because of religious zealotry. And in this case, there's no dispute. She killed those three children. Absolutely no dispute.
00:43:15.520i would say there's something even more sinister that they're not acknowledging is that the salem
00:43:19.360wichita was a mass formation psychosis it was hysteria and i would argue that's what's happening
00:43:26.800all over the place in this country for every little medical issue it's happened for cyclospora
00:43:31.440it's happening for monkeypox is that everything is everything is a mass formation now that is
00:43:36.800exceedingly dangerous it's it's the mob stuff i was mob behavior i was talking about i mean mob
00:43:41.840job, crime syndicate. I mean, people are gathering and scapegoating. It's out of control right now.
00:43:49.000It's very strange. It's a leftist phenomenon. It's not happening on the right. This is not
00:43:53.680right-wing women, conservative women are not posting these videos. They are not falling for
00:43:58.780this nonsense. They don't talk about men that way. This is a leftist thing. And I was saying the other
00:44:03.360day that these women who are posting these videos that we're looking at together, you know, why are
00:44:09.360they doing it? And I think it's because on the left, it's very popular to have every disorder
00:44:14.760ever known to man, whatever it is, you've got it. And the more of them you have, the more special
00:44:21.380you are, the more you get to talk about yourself, which is a very favorite pastime for this sort of
00:44:26.980brand of women. And nothing, nothing, I've mentioned this to the audience, embodies this more
00:44:31.540to me than this woman who was stopped on suspicion of DWI a couple of years ago. You got to watch
00:44:37.740this drew but this cop is so respectful of her she's a nut but she she's one of them and you watch
00:44:47.340i have like really bad social anxiety and stuff i get you
00:44:50.920right back here please miss perry am i i'm non-binary so okay what do you go by
00:45:04.200Kai. How can I refer to you tonight? Kai? Kai. Okay. Hey, I'm smelling alcohol. I know. How much have you consumed tonight? Like, probably three drinks. I need to run you through some tests right now. Stand facing me, please. But I just want you to know that I also have very bad social anxiety. You and me both. Okay. Okay. Any recent head trauma, traumatic brain injuries, anything I need to know about? Uh, mental, yes.
00:45:27.900focus on my finger please i am you're just like trying to intimidate me i don't know how i'm
00:45:36.200trying to do that this is the test as you know as an indigenous person and there's a bunch of
00:45:41.100going around i'm sorry but it's just for me to be on my toes i get you can you remember that i told
00:45:50.080you that i'm non-binary yeah i'll try my hardest i'll refer to you as kai right yes perfect i
00:45:57.880I need to know if you have any injuries
00:53:07.920You can find all of his content at drdrew.tv.
00:53:12.840So, Dr. Drew, there's another case that's different from Lindsay Clancy, but it's got some shades that are similar that I wanted to ask you about.
00:53:22.140It's a horrific murder of an 18-year-old young woman.
00:53:28.180Her name was Caroline Heinz, and she was allegedly murdered by her boyfriend, Royce Moser.
00:53:36.020They'd been dating for quite some time.
00:53:38.540They had been to at least two proms together.
00:53:40.480This just happened. She was 18. She was a rising freshman going off to Pennsylvania Western
00:53:47.660University. She was a standout soccer player, was set to make her collegiate debut for the
00:53:53.620university. Next week, she had one sister. She was dating Royce Moser, who graduated from Cannon
00:54:01.140McMillan High School. She went to a different high school, about seven miles away. He, as far
00:54:06.620as I know, was not off to college, but whatever.
00:54:09.880They were together for quite some time.
00:54:12.220Two proms together, including one 12 weeks ago.
00:54:24.400best two nights ever with you, with hearts.
00:54:28.620It went back and forth with her hearts and his hearts.
00:54:32.400And then on Wednesday of last week at 9.30 p.m., according to a police affidavit, here's what happened.
00:54:42.740Heinz, again, Caroline is her first name, left her father's home in Peters Township around 9.30 p.m.
00:54:49.040She told her dad she might stop at a Target before returning to campus.
00:54:53.340She met up with Royce Moser, the boyfriend, outside of his father's home after spending the day with her family, just north of Pittsburgh, this is.
00:55:03.720During the discussion, Royce Moser reportedly became angry.
00:55:08.240He told her, and we don't know why, what caused the fight, but they were clearly having a fight or a breakup or something.
00:55:13.320Quote, he told her, wait, I have something for you, and went inside of the residence to get a knife.
00:56:01.340They then left the Jeep Cherokee near the California's library and Heinz, with Heinz still inside.
00:56:08.780The mother, Rachel, then drove the son, Royce, back to her residence where he cleaned his clothes and showered.
00:56:16.820Meanwhile, Caroline's father had been checking her iPhone location.
00:56:21.440He later checked her location on his phone, noticed that she had stopped at her boyfriend's house where her devices put her for about 30 minutes.
00:56:29.480After he was unable to get a hold of her, the California Police Department, California, Pennsylvania Police Department was contacted because an air tag in her vehicle showed she was in a parking lot in the borough.
00:56:41.040According to court documents, the police department was notified to check the area for a Jeep Cherokee at 1224 a.m.
00:56:51.840The mother of the son, Royce, Rachel, told investigators her son called her in early morning hours and said he needed her to follow him to the university to drop off a vehicle, later admitting he had stabbed Heinz and needed a ride home.
00:57:06.760She appears to have been brought in much earlier in the evening.
00:57:10.340She said he told her that he had demons and did not know whether Caroline was alive or dead when he moved her.
00:57:20.940He gave an interview himself, Royce did, told investigators that he had a, quote, demon take over during the confrontation before he retrieved the knife and stabbed her.
00:57:31.040He told police how his mother had helped him to clean the car, told him to take a bath, then shower after.
00:57:37.220She allegedly put his clothes in the washing machine for him.
00:57:41.040Royce told the police his mother took the knife that was used to stab the victim and put it in a garbage bag to be put in the trash outside of her house where, indeed, they found it.
00:57:52.280He's now been charged with homicide, among other charges.
00:57:54.620The mother is charged with hindering apprehension of a fugitive and tampering with evidence, among other charges.
00:58:01.760um this is as far as we know out of the blue as far as we know they're not referencing any
00:58:08.280criminal history or juvenile history for the defendant here the prom the hearts it's horrible
00:58:14.280in an instant two lives at least completely ruined forever i mean i don't i guess we'll
00:58:20.760learn more about it as time goes along but it's incomprehensible and when things seem
00:58:27.420incomprehensible to me i always worry about dark triad and psychopathy and psychopathy is a
00:58:34.040heritable disorder and mom seems to have manifested some of the same stuff which is not acknowledging
00:58:40.340that something wrong was going on it think about how different right yeah i mean people will go oh
00:58:44.780do anything to protect my kids no you shouldn't no you shouldn't when they when they do horrible
00:58:48.540things you got to let things come to bear look at the the murderer of charlie kirk what did his dad
00:58:54.860do. Turned him in. We think, I think that's what happened. Right. Yeah. And that's the right thing
00:59:00.660to do. That's the correct thing to do. You go, Oh, you've done something horrible. Here we go.
00:59:06.500This is, I would not protect you for this. And let me ask you a question on this because to me,
00:59:11.500it seems as a parent, you know, the first horrible thing is not usually murder. There's, there's
00:59:17.720probably a long line in this kid's history of the mother and possibly the father downplaying
00:59:24.780it making excuses getting him out of it you know sort of teaching him yes the absence of
00:59:30.380accountability that's my guess that is exactly what tends to happen and the parental denial
00:59:35.340even when the children can be the child is severely impaired with all kinds of things you
00:59:39.940know psychiatric problems the the getting the parents to come to terms with or get the individual
00:59:44.560to care is is what causes the catastrophes they don't get them there soon enough and they're in
00:59:49.860so much denial about it, or they minimize it, they marginalize it, that kind of stuff.
00:59:55.400People need to understand the difference between a parenting problem and a brain problem. They are
01:00:00.180very, very different phenomenon. And you need to get brain issues to a professional quickly,
01:00:06.000or horrible things can happen. In this case, I agree with you, though, it's probably more of a
01:00:10.920antisocial quality to what he has been doing. The mom also antisocial, perhaps, and is sort of,
01:00:17.800you know, manipulating and minimizing and dissembling. And it's tragic. It's just unbelievable.
01:00:23.020I mean, look at those pictures. Imagine your daughter was dating a kid like that. You wouldn't
01:00:26.900even be, let's say they were away at college and you had met the kid, but you just see the pictures
01:00:30.600online. You wouldn't even have a reason to be suspicious, right? That's kind of the way
01:00:34.840psychopathy and dark triad stuff goes. What's dark triad? Machiavellianism,
01:00:40.960narcissism, and psychopathy, the three together. And people are thinking in terms of having varying
01:00:47.160degrees of one or the other, but some people have all three in full blossom. And all this stuff is
01:00:52.720way more common these days, certainly than the cluster B side, we call that the narcissism side
01:00:58.440than we've had maybe ever. And once again, acting out is the norm for those people,
01:01:05.240for those disorders. But how do you like, how do you predict? I mean, if you could, if you could
01:01:11.820do this, you'd, you'd be a billionaire. Well, not a billionaire, I'd be able to save a bunch of
01:01:15.260you know because you can't predict well i'm just saying like this would be an extremely marketable
01:01:20.100skill thing to be able to do um predict violence you know it's like teenage love maybe gone awry
01:01:30.780she's going off to college he's not but like he took then he took a knife and stabbed her in the
01:01:36.000heart i mean this is on the heels of 2025 carmelo anthony took a knife and stabbed austin metcalf
01:01:42.880in the heart a complete stranger i mean at least in the latter situation when it's young love i
01:01:48.640don't know i mean let's face it you know men in love with women have been killing them for a long
01:01:55.280long time this is actually not that unusual sadly but like the austin metcalf was such a shocker
01:02:01.720because it was like out of nowhere like just one teen taking a knife and stabbing another to death
01:02:07.020in the heart and yet with new information that has come out in court apparently it wasn't just
01:02:11.960Oh, just two, two random, random high functioning teens who happened to run in the wrong, you
01:12:35.900Wildly, I'm holding my phone up, yeah.
01:12:37.000um the uh the the listing of what she was going through right grief because her younger brother
01:12:46.920had died a couple years ago he also what had a substance abuse problem though is said to have
01:12:52.220died of congenital heart defects at age 28 which i'm sure were not helped by his substance abuse
01:12:58.580problem um addiction we covered with her physical pain we covered and agoraphobia can you speak to
01:13:05.500this because in my experience, it is not unusual to find somebody with an addiction problem who's
01:13:12.020got agoraphobia or is a hoarder or has some other issue on the mental health scale. I don't know if
01:13:22.540it's caused by addiction, if the mental health stuff causes the addiction and the other stuff,
01:13:26.660but can you speak to that? The agoraphobia jumped out at me.
01:13:28.880it it it much like the pain oftentimes the drugs that they're doing make all their psychiatric
01:13:36.220symptoms pain oh pain gets worse on opiates that's just the way it is it causes it causes
01:13:41.080an intensification of pain then you get headaches because you're in withdrawal then you get low back
01:13:45.160pain because you're in withdrawal and you just escalate the pain and then you end up on
01:13:49.200benzodiazepines at night for sleep because you're taking all these opiates and trying to get off
01:13:53.500those, that's where the agoraphobia and anxiety and panic kicked in. And maybe she hadn't had
01:13:59.720enough time off those drugs to really let that subside. Then what we more commonly see or most
01:14:06.100commonly see, I would say, is the concomitant childhood trauma, right? Childhood trauma is
01:14:11.560the rocket fuel for addiction. And none of this stuff is causational. The cause is that it's
01:14:16.560genetic. And you either have the gene or you don't, but there are these influences that activate the
01:14:21.960gene, and childhood trauma would have to be number one. And in her case, you know, it brings up the
01:14:27.240whole topic of childhood stars. And there's the interesting things people talk about with that.
01:14:32.680You know, Danny Bonaduce was the first to sort of educate me that more often than not,
01:14:37.160something's up with the parents. And if your parents were good, you end up with Ron Howard.
01:14:41.240If they weren't good, you end up with Danny Bonaduce, however he would say it.
01:14:45.260But there's another issue I have found on top of that, which is that they get into the children.
01:14:54.200First of all, they're in an adult world with adults all the time, taking on adult responsibility.
01:14:58.840That's traumatic for a child, number one.
01:15:00.680Not massively traumatic, but traumatic.
01:15:03.160Number two, they may have fractured families that they have come from, and they get into these productions where it's a family unit.
01:15:10.240It forms a family, sometimes for multiple seasons.
01:15:13.100And what no one prepares the child for is that, let's say, after six seasons where this is your dad and you feel really good about him and he's not, I understand he's not my dad, but I feel very close to him and this family feels very safe for me.
01:15:26.040End of the production, everybody scatters to the wind and they never see each other again.
01:15:30.760That is profoundly abandoning for these children.
01:15:34.020And a lot of them bring that up specifically.
01:24:28.340And unfortunately, when these mandatory reporters began reporting to the Division of Child and Family Services, you've got to look into this girl's case.
01:24:38.040The parents kept denying it and then ultimately pulled her from the school system and were allowed to just say, oh, we're homeschooling her.
01:35:19.940And he reportedly, Brian, the boyfriend, tried to administer it to her unsuccessfully.
01:35:26.840Here, listen to him talking about domestic violence and how he just needed some education, Drew.
01:35:35.580My biggest thing about domestic violence is I don't think it is taught early enough in life.
01:35:45.560Never in my life did I ever get taught what domestic violence was, right?
01:35:51.980maybe if i did at an early age maybe i wouldn't have done what i did we don't know
01:35:59.540but it's one of those things you think about
01:36:03.800so all right yeah you got the training to me it's you don't get it's not about getting taught about
01:36:10.640dv it's about anger management you know emotional regulation communication what say you years
01:36:19.360years of work and not just oh that's what that is okay we're done here it's like it's like saying
01:36:25.540it's literally like saying uh you know somebody has a schizophrenia or bipolar disorder and it's
01:36:31.600like do you come to we're teaching you what this thing is you have oh okay we'll see you later no
01:36:37.080then you treat it the education is to get people to the point where they can acknowledge that they
01:36:42.180need treatment that this is not okay that it's pathological it's dangerous and he something is
01:36:49.660up there i don't know what's going on with him but it would require a lot and i bet i just wonder
01:36:55.540if alcohol is involved because in and by the way he also had that flavor of oh i was exposed to
01:37:01.280domestic violence my whole life i just thought it was okay i i which does happen to people i mean
01:37:06.140they but that is not but i mean thinking that he didn't know his domestic violence when he was
01:37:10.120punching her in the face? I'm pretty sure he knew. I would agree with you. But if you saw it in
01:37:14.680childhood, again, giving it a name doesn't mean you're not going to repeat that exactly what you
01:37:19.240were exposed to in childhood. The reports of him attacking her continue to come out. We continue
01:37:29.500to learn more. This is a neighbor. This is not 26. And it was on Inside Edition last week. Listen
01:37:38.660to this. This is a neighbor of Hayden's. Hayden Panettiere's neighbor is making shocking
01:37:43.840allegations about the troubled star's relationship with her boyfriend. She was always such a bright
01:37:48.740light when she was by herself. When she was with Brian, she was so subdued and seemed almost like
01:37:54.980a different person. Mia Terrazas says she called 911 a half a dozen times to report disturbances
01:38:01.800in Hayden's apartment in West Hollywood. Was there ever any instances where you thought there
01:38:06.320could be domestic violence going on oh absolutely i saw her leaving on a gurney um brian was right
01:38:13.900next to her and i asked her if she was okay and it looked to me that she you know had suffered
01:38:20.920some type of trauma that uh you know looked to be battering and it was clear she was terrified
01:38:29.340brian hickerson was jailed for 45 days in 2021 for punching hayden with his closed fist in the
01:38:35.940face and was banned from the apartment complex where Hayden lived. This image of Hickerson was
01:38:41.360posted on the property. Warning to all residents, if he is seen anywhere on this property,
01:38:46.820please call 911 immediately. Consistent with what she was doing at the book signings. I'm needing
01:38:53.760a bath. I feel so bad for all these topics we're getting into. This is like really tough material.
01:38:59.800But, you know, in addition to the stickiness of the cycle of abuse and the cult of two that people get into, the women particularly, their personal resources and their sense of themselves get severely eroded in relationships like this.
01:39:19.680They really don't have the capacity to pull themselves out of it.
01:39:25.100They just keep going, sinking deeper and deeper.
01:39:27.940And then, again, if you're using substances on top of that, that's how they try to manage it.
01:39:31.660And, of course, that only makes things worse.
01:39:34.180So it sounds like, Drew, you would have said, like, if Hayden had come to you and said, how about I write a memoir and then I go on a book tour?
01:41:18.520I mean, we'll wait for the toxicology, but it seems clear.
01:41:21.460And now Rob Shooter is reporting that sources are telling him law enforcement has seized the cameras around the Greenville, South Carolina apartment where she was found dead and where that boyfriend was living.
01:41:33.660So we always say that she may have been sober there.
01:41:37.520And I think that's after her long, long period of treatment, which was excellent.