The Michael Knowles Show - November 21, 2025


Ep. 1862 - Somali Migrants CAUGHT Using Your Tax Dollars To Fund Terrorists


Episode Stats

Length

49 minutes

Words per Minute

178.42027

Word Count

8,839

Sentence Count

714

Misogynist Sentences

37

Hate Speech Sentences

55


Summary

The average IQ in Somalia is supposedly 67 or 68, which is supposed to be the average. And yet, according to a new report, Somalis seem a lot smarter than Americans. The Minnesota taxpayers have been tricking Minnesota taxpayers into paying them hundreds of millions of dollars in fraudulent welfare claims, much of which goes back to Somalia to fund Al-Shabaab, a foreign terrorist organization that the United States has directly fought against.


Transcript

00:00:00.000 Rinse takes your laundry and hand delivers it to your door, expertly cleaned and folded.
00:00:04.720 So you could take the time once spent folding and sorting and waiting to finally pursue a whole new version of you.
00:00:10.780 Like tea time you.
00:00:12.760 Mmm.
00:00:13.580 Or this tea time you.
00:00:16.120 Or even this tea time you.
00:00:18.680 So did you hear about Dave?
00:00:19.900 Or even tea time, tea time, tea time you.
00:00:22.800 Mmm.
00:00:23.760 So update on Dave.
00:00:25.780 It's up to you. We'll take the laundry.
00:00:28.060 Rinse. It's time to be great.
00:00:31.000 At Desjardins, we speak business.
00:00:34.040 We speak equipment modernization.
00:00:36.120 We're fluent in data digitization and expansion into foreign markets.
00:00:40.040 And we can talk all day about streamlining manufacturing processes.
00:00:44.320 Because at Desjardins Business, we speak the same language you do.
00:00:48.020 Business.
00:00:48.820 So join the more than 400,000 Canadian entrepreneurs who already count on us.
00:00:53.460 And contact Desjardins today.
00:00:55.600 We'd love to talk business.
00:00:57.380 Daily Wire Plus annual memberships are 50% off during our Black Friday sale.
00:01:04.760 That includes inside annual and all-access memberships.
00:01:07.500 There's more to enjoy than ever before.
00:01:09.440 That means more new daily shows from the most trusted voices in conservative media.
00:01:14.060 Uncensored, ad-free, and available an hour before you can see or hear them anywhere else.
00:01:19.660 More new series that capture conviction, courage, and the human story.
00:01:23.100 More documentaries that challenge the culture and expose what's really happening.
00:01:26.320 And when we say premium, we're proving it.
00:01:27.940 With the long-awaited seven-part epic series, The Pendragon Cycle, Rise of the Merlin.
00:01:32.320 The Legend begins streaming January 22, 2026, exclusively on Daily Wire Plus.
00:01:38.100 All Access members get early access to episodes one and two at Christmas Day.
00:01:41.760 50% off Black Friday is our biggest sale of the year.
00:01:44.940 It only happens once a year.
00:01:46.140 When it's gone, it's gone.
00:01:47.500 Go to dailywire.com slash subscribe and join now.
00:01:52.080 Right now, head on over to dailywire.com slash subscribe.
00:01:55.680 It is very important that you take advantage of the best Daily Wire sale of the year.
00:02:01.060 50% off membership.
00:02:03.360 You get so much.
00:02:04.480 All the docs, all the shows, all the...
00:02:06.300 Forget about the other hosts.
00:02:07.420 You get all of the all-access creme de la creme benefits with me, your beloved podcaster.
00:02:14.140 So head on over, dailywire.com slash subscribe.
00:02:18.500 Everyone says Somalis are stupid.
00:02:21.540 The average IQ in Somalia is supposedly 67 or 68.
00:02:26.660 Well, well below 100, which is supposed to be the average.
00:02:30.960 And yet, in many ways, Somalis seem a lot smarter than Americans.
00:02:36.400 Because according to a new report, Somalis have been tricking Minnesota taxpayers
00:02:40.580 into paying them hundreds of millions of dollars in fraudulent welfare claims.
00:02:45.900 Much of which has gone back to Somalia to fund Al-Shabaab, a foreign terrorist organization
00:02:51.640 that the United States has directly fought against.
00:02:54.600 As a federal counterterrorism source concluded, quote,
00:02:57.560 the largest funder of Al-Shabaab is the Minnesota taxpayer.
00:03:02.400 The Minnesota Somalis managed to pull off this incredible operation for a few reasons.
00:03:08.820 One, they have a cohesive group identity.
00:03:12.780 Two, they have a clear sense of political friends and enemies.
00:03:16.560 Three, they have stable traditions.
00:03:19.380 Four, they have the ability to coordinate among themselves to achieve political ends.
00:03:24.180 They might be schemers, and they might be criminals, and they might even be terrorists.
00:03:30.780 But I hesitate to call them stupid.
00:03:34.560 Because as a matter of purely political intelligence,
00:03:38.220 if the average Somali IQ really is 68,
00:03:42.320 ours is in the single digits.
00:03:43.920 I'm Michael Knowles.
00:03:44.640 This is The Michael Knowles Show.
00:03:45.460 Really big show, really big show.
00:04:06.460 We have my friend Lila Rose joining us.
00:04:08.420 She will join us specifically to talk about the ex-congressional aide
00:04:12.520 who has just hired a fetish artist to carve her body up
00:04:17.620 to make it seem as though she was attacked by leftists for being a Trump supporter.
00:04:22.580 This is a weird one.
00:04:23.780 Well, it's weird for a lot of reasons,
00:04:24.960 but it's especially weird because it's a hate hoax coming from the right,
00:04:28.080 and you almost never hear about those.
00:04:29.180 First, though, I want to tell you about Lean.
00:04:30.920 Go to BrickHouseSale.com.
00:04:32.200 Here's something you do not see every day.
00:04:33.720 Doctors running a Black Friday sale.
00:04:35.760 That is exactly what is happening at BrickHouse Nutrition.
00:04:38.140 They're doing 30% off everything, their biggest sale all year.
00:04:41.420 We're talking about legitimately impressive stuff here.
00:04:43.880 There's Lean, which is their doctor-formulated weight loss supplement
00:04:46.640 designed for people who want real results
00:04:48.260 without having to deal with mandatory injections.
00:04:51.220 Multiple producers and employees at The Daily Wire have tried Lean.
00:04:54.740 They've been so impressed with how effective Lean has been
00:04:56.960 in such a short period of time.
00:04:58.500 There is also creatone.
00:05:00.060 That's creatine.
00:05:01.160 It is actually made for women.
00:05:03.300 Helps you look leaner, more toned,
00:05:04.940 without having to add a bunch of extra workouts
00:05:07.160 or restrictive dieting to your routine.
00:05:08.720 And Field of Greens, the only super fruit and vegetable drink
00:05:11.800 that has been shown in an actual university study
00:05:14.040 to help slow aging.
00:05:15.400 They even guarantee that you will see health improvements
00:05:17.640 that your doctor will notice for Ebold,
00:05:19.800 plus everything else they make,
00:05:21.560 Better Sleep Products, Superior Collagen.
00:05:23.780 All of it is 30% off right now.
00:05:25.460 Deal will not last long.
00:05:26.680 Black Friday prices move fast.
00:05:28.880 Go to BrickHouseSale.com.
00:05:30.100 Grab 30% off while it's still available.
00:05:32.280 BrickHouseSale.com for 30% off.
00:05:35.080 The Somali story.
00:05:36.240 It's just unbelievable.
00:05:37.940 My hat's off to the Somalis.
00:05:41.160 You got to hand it to them.
00:05:42.720 The hubris, the chauvinism from Westerners
00:05:47.180 who say those Somalis, their IQ is below 70.
00:05:51.060 These guys, they can barely walk around
00:05:53.180 and breathe at the same time.
00:05:54.480 Well, they tricked you, didn't they?
00:05:56.740 You can call Somalis stupid all you want.
00:05:59.240 They just tricked you, supposedly genius American taxpayers,
00:06:05.400 into funding their terror group in Somalia.
00:06:08.860 This is from the report.
00:06:10.720 It's out of City Journal, Chris Rufo.
00:06:12.320 Just phenomenal work as always.
00:06:15.000 Minnesota's Medicaid Housing Stabilization Services Program
00:06:18.380 is the first of its kind in its country.
00:06:20.840 It's not the first subsidized housing program,
00:06:23.180 but it's the first of this kind in as much as
00:06:25.560 the goal was so broad.
00:06:27.540 It was to help seniors.
00:06:28.720 It was to help drug addicts.
00:06:29.840 It was to help the disabled.
00:06:31.100 It was to help the mentally ill.
00:06:33.380 And it was specifically designed
00:06:35.120 with very low barriers to entry.
00:06:36.900 Because the Libs say, okay,
00:06:37.680 we got these welfare programs,
00:06:39.100 but they're not reaching as many people
00:06:41.740 as we want them to reach
00:06:42.840 because it excludes all sorts of people
00:06:45.320 who might commit fraud,
00:06:46.700 who might not want to give up their drug addictions,
00:06:48.780 who have all sorts of antisocial behaviors.
00:06:51.220 And so they say,
00:06:51.880 what if we just get rid of the barriers to entry?
00:06:53.500 Then we'll give money to more people,
00:06:56.380 including Al-Shabaab.
00:06:58.060 So they say,
00:06:58.960 there are minimum requirements for reimbursement.
00:07:00.940 The annual estimate for how much this is going to cost
00:07:03.840 was a little over $2.5 million.
00:07:05.860 First year,
00:07:07.300 program pays out more than $21 million in claims.
00:07:11.100 So many, many multiples.
00:07:14.160 In the ensuing years,
00:07:15.360 costs shot up to $42 million,
00:07:17.840 so it doubled.
00:07:18.340 Then $74 million.
00:07:20.300 Then $104 million.
00:07:21.820 So now we're at 50 times
00:07:23.400 almost what it was supposed to cost.
00:07:26.660 Then during the first six months of 2025,
00:07:28.680 payouts totaled $61 million.
00:07:30.560 So annualized could be $122 million.
00:07:34.340 On top of that,
00:07:36.120 that was one welfare program
00:07:37.660 the Somalis exploited.
00:07:38.940 There's another one called Feeding Our Future.
00:07:41.660 When this article was published,
00:07:44.240 which was within the last few days,
00:07:46.080 the U.S. Attorney's Office reported
00:07:48.420 that Abdullah al-Nur Jassau
00:07:51.680 had become the 56th defendant to plead guilty
00:07:54.940 in the $250 million
00:07:56.900 Feeding Our Future fraud scheme.
00:07:59.660 I think that number now
00:08:00.660 is jumping up to 77 people
00:08:02.280 being prosecuted for it.
00:08:03.560 The number's going to go way, way higher
00:08:04.780 because it was a massive
00:08:06.240 community-wide fraud scheme
00:08:08.200 to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars.
00:08:11.200 Then,
00:08:12.640 forget about the housing,
00:08:13.940 forget about the food.
00:08:14.540 There was an autism fraud scheme.
00:08:16.540 Yes, autism fraud.
00:08:18.560 Was there?
00:08:19.940 I didn't know that was a type of fraud,
00:08:21.420 but there's autism fraud.
00:08:22.760 Minnesota's Early Intensive Developmental
00:08:24.620 and Behavioral Intervention Program,
00:08:26.300 the Somalis perpetrated
00:08:27.500 a $14 million fraud scheme against that.
00:08:31.040 They pretended to have autism
00:08:32.280 and they got a lot of money.
00:08:34.380 On and on and on.
00:08:36.120 A ton of this money has gone to Al-Shabaab.
00:08:38.660 So what are we to take from this?
00:08:41.220 One,
00:08:42.240 we got to get these Somalis out, okay?
00:08:44.160 It's no knock on them.
00:08:45.800 Actually,
00:08:46.400 they have my respect.
00:08:48.660 They don't have my respect
00:08:50.000 because they're lying
00:08:50.780 and committing sins
00:08:52.040 and doing all sorts of bad stuff.
00:08:53.440 But they do,
00:08:53.980 at a base political level,
00:08:55.540 they have my respect
00:08:56.640 for getting it done
00:08:58.100 for their community
00:08:58.780 at the expense
00:09:00.520 of the American taxpayer,
00:09:01.860 specifically the Minnesota taxpayer.
00:09:03.040 But they got to go.
00:09:05.560 Guys,
00:09:06.380 there are a lot of problems.
00:09:07.600 They're bringing in foreign religion,
00:09:09.320 foreign religious practices.
00:09:10.220 They're marrying their relatives.
00:09:11.960 They're committing immigration fraud.
00:09:13.360 They're committing welfare fraud.
00:09:14.460 They got to go.
00:09:15.320 They got to go.
00:09:15.940 I'm not saying all of them.
00:09:17.160 Some, I assume,
00:09:18.040 are good people,
00:09:18.980 but most of them have to go,
00:09:20.600 starting with Ilhan Omar.
00:09:22.000 However,
00:09:22.760 the real takeaway I have,
00:09:24.040 the thing that I find most interesting
00:09:25.080 and no one's talking about here
00:09:26.560 is for all my life,
00:09:29.360 Americans on the right
00:09:31.380 had this kind of instinct,
00:09:33.480 instinctive,
00:09:34.620 polemical,
00:09:36.360 I don't know,
00:09:37.340 habit
00:09:38.680 against welfare.
00:09:41.400 They said,
00:09:41.700 how welfare is being abused.
00:09:43.020 There are these welfare queens.
00:09:44.180 We need to minimize
00:09:45.060 the welfare programs.
00:09:46.840 These social safety nets
00:09:47.900 can turn into spider webs
00:09:49.040 that entrap people
00:09:49.920 in actual cycles of poverty.
00:09:51.460 And so we need to cut welfare.
00:09:53.580 That was what the right believed.
00:09:54.880 And there's been a turn
00:09:56.040 in recent years
00:09:57.460 from the new right,
00:09:58.440 and I'm very sympathetic to this,
00:10:00.820 which is to say,
00:10:01.960 well, welfare is not bad in itself.
00:10:04.000 And we do need to care about the poor
00:10:06.500 because politics really should be oriented
00:10:08.320 toward the common good.
00:10:09.240 And one of the great errors
00:10:10.660 of the American right
00:10:11.800 in the last 60, 70 years
00:10:13.320 is it became much too libertarian,
00:10:15.420 much too focused
00:10:16.120 on a hyper-individualism
00:10:17.500 that really is borrowed from the left.
00:10:19.280 It doesn't traditionally
00:10:20.080 come from the right.
00:10:20.940 And so we need to care more
00:10:21.760 about the common good,
00:10:22.540 and so maybe we should loosen up
00:10:23.560 on welfare.
00:10:24.280 And what's very funny,
00:10:25.200 everything old is new again.
00:10:27.200 As Animal Farm says,
00:10:28.500 donkeys live a very long time.
00:10:29.740 You've never seen a dead donkey.
00:10:31.180 Now we're kind of coming back
00:10:32.300 and we're saying,
00:10:32.640 actually, no,
00:10:33.160 this welfare program,
00:10:34.320 we got to cut it.
00:10:35.680 There's so much fraud.
00:10:36.860 Even just nationally,
00:10:37.700 the government shutdown showed us
00:10:38.620 there's so much fraud
00:10:39.500 with food stamps.
00:10:40.460 Now we call it SNAP.
00:10:41.760 It's like 10% of Tennessee
00:10:43.040 or something is on food stamps.
00:10:44.320 They don't need it.
00:10:45.240 There's no social stigma
00:10:46.160 associated with it anymore.
00:10:47.080 It's like,
00:10:47.560 maybe we need to cut this back, guys.
00:10:49.060 We're funding al-Shabaab,
00:10:50.220 like enough with the welfare, right?
00:10:51.920 So what does this mean for us?
00:10:53.700 What do we conclude?
00:10:55.060 Were we right 20 years ago
00:10:57.260 in the super libertarian
00:10:58.880 neocon-infused days?
00:11:00.280 Or is the new right right?
00:11:01.680 Is the new new right?
00:11:02.800 What is,
00:11:03.180 where are we supposed
00:11:03.600 to think about this?
00:11:05.080 The point to take away is,
00:11:07.000 you cannot divorce economic policy
00:11:09.760 from social policy.
00:11:11.720 Ben and I were having this debate
00:11:12.980 the other day on Friendly Fire.
00:11:14.420 Ben said,
00:11:16.160 you know,
00:11:16.340 really you gotta separate
00:11:17.700 social policy from economic policy.
00:11:19.700 Economic health doesn't necessarily
00:11:20.860 mean social health.
00:11:21.700 And my argument is,
00:11:22.540 no,
00:11:22.720 we're integral creatures
00:11:23.940 and you can't really separate
00:11:25.580 these two things.
00:11:27.300 And so in this case,
00:11:29.060 what we're saying is,
00:11:30.080 yes,
00:11:30.320 you could have
00:11:31.660 a more robust welfare program
00:11:34.360 and, you know,
00:11:36.100 a greater care for the common good
00:11:37.400 if you have
00:11:38.180 a higher trust society.
00:11:39.400 If you don't have
00:11:40.020 a bunch of freaking Somalis
00:11:41.480 who are trying to scheme
00:11:42.700 the system so that they can
00:11:43.980 go fund terrorists overseas.
00:11:46.040 Yeah,
00:11:46.600 you need social solidarity
00:11:48.820 in order to have
00:11:50.320 a more robust social safety net.
00:11:51.860 This is why it works
00:11:52.660 in homogenous countries
00:11:53.640 like in Scandinavia.
00:11:56.260 That's the issue.
00:11:57.120 The takeaway is,
00:11:58.660 the traditional,
00:12:01.160 like,
00:12:01.420 not traditional,
00:12:02.240 neo-traditional,
00:12:03.280 I don't know,
00:12:03.600 Reagan right
00:12:04.440 comes out and says,
00:12:06.360 look,
00:12:06.520 we need to cut welfare.
00:12:08.020 There's a lot of fraud.
00:12:08.660 Yeah,
00:12:08.760 they were right about that.
00:12:09.900 And the new right
00:12:10.900 comes out and says,
00:12:11.840 we need to care more
00:12:14.300 about the common good.
00:12:15.340 And they're right about that too.
00:12:17.340 And the conclusion of it is,
00:12:19.120 you need to recognize
00:12:20.400 it's not just culture
00:12:22.400 and politics
00:12:23.180 and social policy
00:12:24.020 and economic policy
00:12:24.880 and foreign policy.
00:12:25.760 It's all kind of the same.
00:12:27.500 It's all one political community.
00:12:29.520 And we need to get rid
00:12:31.200 of these scheming Somalis
00:12:32.640 because they are smarter than us
00:12:35.260 in many ways
00:12:36.720 when it comes to
00:12:37.600 political philosophy.
00:12:38.220 Okay,
00:12:38.620 I want to bring on my friend Lila
00:12:39.600 to talk about
00:12:40.580 another really bizarre story
00:12:43.240 coming out of Congress.
00:12:44.880 First of all,
00:12:45.480 I want to tell you
00:12:45.780 about Legacy Box.
00:12:46.880 Go to LegacyBox.com
00:12:48.200 slash Knowles.
00:12:49.560 Do you have shoeboxes
00:12:50.440 full of old videotapes
00:12:51.420 and photos with memories
00:12:52.240 that you would love to share
00:12:53.460 with the family this Christmas?
00:12:54.880 Right now,
00:12:55.960 you can get exclusive early access
00:12:57.340 to Legacy Box's
00:12:58.460 Black Friday sale
00:12:59.540 and digitize your old memories
00:13:01.120 for just $9 per tape.
00:13:02.800 Whether it's VHS,
00:13:03.820 VHSC,
00:13:04.620 Hi8,
00:13:05.180 Film Reels,
00:13:05.680 or any of the 12 other types
00:13:07.100 of analog media they handle,
00:13:08.540 you are saving over $15 per item.
00:13:10.540 Here's the best part.
00:13:11.420 If you digitize your memories now,
00:13:13.500 Legacy Box will have
00:13:14.280 everything digitized
00:13:15.160 and sent back to you
00:13:15.960 in the cloud by Christmas
00:13:17.020 so you can relive
00:13:18.100 all those precious moments
00:13:19.040 with your family
00:13:19.600 during the holidays.
00:13:20.880 Legacy Box has been doing this
00:13:21.940 for over 10 years now.
00:13:23.120 They're the world's largest digitizer
00:13:24.520 for a reason.
00:13:25.180 They've already helped
00:13:25.700 over a million families
00:13:26.540 preserve everything
00:13:27.420 from wedding days
00:13:28.460 to chaotic childhood Christmases
00:13:29.820 to family road trips
00:13:30.960 out to Yellowstone.
00:13:31.860 For just $9 per tape,
00:13:33.720 you can make sure
00:13:34.300 those moments are not just
00:13:35.440 sitting in a box somewhere
00:13:36.340 gathering dust.
00:13:37.240 These are basically
00:13:38.660 the most valuable things you own.
00:13:40.080 I don't mean that
00:13:40.560 in a schmaltzy way,
00:13:41.700 but even if you've got a house,
00:13:42.840 you've got a car,
00:13:43.360 whatever,
00:13:44.120 all that stuff can be replaced
00:13:45.620 and you can make more money
00:13:46.500 and you can make less money
00:13:47.300 and those family memories
00:13:49.060 can never be replaced.
00:13:50.560 So make sure
00:13:51.080 you preserve them forever.
00:13:52.000 You've heard about Legacy Box
00:13:53.500 all year.
00:13:53.880 Now's the best time
00:13:54.480 to digitize your memories.
00:13:56.040 This $9 deal
00:13:56.860 will not last long.
00:13:57.820 Legacybox.com
00:13:58.620 slash Knowles
00:13:59.200 for early access
00:14:00.040 to the best deal of the year.
00:14:01.900 Secure your digitized memories
00:14:03.140 by Christmas.
00:14:04.200 Legacybox.com
00:14:04.920 slash Knowles.
00:14:05.760 Legacybox.com
00:14:06.680 slash Knowles.
00:14:08.920 Lila Rose,
00:14:09.840 I'm home again, Rose.
00:14:10.900 Lila,
00:14:11.280 wonderful to have you on the show.
00:14:12.600 Thank you for being here.
00:14:14.040 Good morning
00:14:14.760 and I've got my pumpkin spice latte
00:14:16.300 so I am ready to go.
00:14:17.620 I am roiling with envy.
00:14:21.100 It's simmering over actually
00:14:23.040 just like that tasty fall.
00:14:23.960 Got to ask that producer
00:14:25.120 to help you out.
00:14:26.360 Wow,
00:14:26.880 what do I have?
00:14:27.800 I just have some,
00:14:28.560 I don't know,
00:14:29.000 millennial bubbly slap.
00:14:31.880 So Lila,
00:14:32.800 really weird story.
00:14:33.800 I wanted a female perspective
00:14:34.940 on this.
00:14:38.280 I'll just state the facts first
00:14:39.960 before I get to my commentary.
00:14:43.100 An ex-GOP congressional aide
00:14:46.000 has mutilated herself.
00:14:48.900 So she was found by police
00:14:50.620 and she had all of these scars
00:14:52.900 all over her body,
00:14:53.960 slices,
00:14:54.700 lacerations,
00:14:55.580 and the words
00:14:56.720 Trump whore
00:14:58.400 carved across her body.
00:15:00.880 Trump whore.
00:15:01.660 And she was zip tied
00:15:02.900 and she was,
00:15:04.040 I think,
00:15:04.340 mostly clothed,
00:15:05.240 but still,
00:15:05.720 it was really horrifying.
00:15:06.680 And she said
00:15:07.640 that she was assaulted
00:15:09.740 by three men
00:15:10.760 who did this
00:15:11.520 because she's a Trump supporter.
00:15:13.240 She's worked
00:15:13.760 for a Republican member
00:15:15.200 of Congress.
00:15:15.580 I think she's a law student now.
00:15:17.560 And it turns out
00:15:18.900 she did it herself.
00:15:21.180 They found zip ties
00:15:22.720 in her car.
00:15:23.360 I think she was driving
00:15:23.840 a Maserati.
00:15:24.620 I think that was
00:15:24.980 in some of the reporting.
00:15:26.160 And she paid
00:15:28.100 500 bucks
00:15:28.940 to a fetish artist
00:15:30.480 to carve her up.
00:15:32.280 She's a very pretty girl,
00:15:33.700 beautiful girl.
00:15:34.700 And she's now like
00:15:35.760 probably permanently
00:15:37.380 mutilated herself
00:15:38.760 for this hate.
00:15:40.620 So all of the hate hoaxes
00:15:42.800 in our lifetimes,
00:15:43.960 virtually all of them,
00:15:44.720 have come from the left.
00:15:46.440 You know,
00:15:46.620 it's Jussie Smollett.
00:15:48.220 You know,
00:15:48.500 he's walking around
00:15:49.360 just trying to eat
00:15:49.780 a Subway sandwich
00:15:50.360 and then a bunch
00:15:51.860 of Nigerian white supremacists
00:15:53.300 come up and say
00:15:54.420 it's MAGA country.
00:15:55.940 They're calling this woman
00:15:57.320 Hussie Smollett,
00:15:58.280 which is not very nice,
00:15:59.260 but I'm a sucker
00:15:59.700 for a good pun.
00:16:00.720 And it's really bizarre.
00:16:02.620 It's coming from the right.
00:16:04.400 And I don't,
00:16:05.820 part of my instinct,
00:16:06.820 you know how much
00:16:07.320 I love women?
00:16:07.920 Part of my instinct is,
00:16:08.860 man,
00:16:09.180 women are crazier
00:16:10.080 than I thought they were.
00:16:11.160 I don't know.
00:16:12.340 What am I to make
00:16:13.660 of this, Lila?
00:16:15.460 I think you're right.
00:16:16.780 They are crazy today.
00:16:18.220 I mean,
00:16:18.900 we always have
00:16:20.280 the tendency to be crazy,
00:16:21.580 but the girls today
00:16:22.560 are not okay.
00:16:23.660 That is an objective reality.
00:16:25.700 And this is an example of it,
00:16:27.720 and it is happening
00:16:28.400 on both the right
00:16:29.160 and the left.
00:16:29.820 In this case,
00:16:30.480 I think it's the
00:16:31.320 extreme attention seeking
00:16:33.300 that many young women
00:16:34.500 are being,
00:16:35.700 just from a very young age,
00:16:37.880 they are being formed
00:16:38.940 that this is the way
00:16:39.760 they should be.
00:16:40.540 I mean,
00:16:40.680 think about social media,
00:16:41.740 what it does
00:16:42.200 to the female psyche.
00:16:44.000 It's like constant comparison,
00:16:45.540 constant attention,
00:16:46.600 constant making yourself,
00:16:48.300 putting yourself out there
00:16:49.340 via sexualization.
00:16:50.640 I mean,
00:16:51.160 the issue of OnlyFans today
00:16:52.760 is obviously horrific,
00:16:54.140 young girls
00:16:54.580 prostituting themselves.
00:16:56.280 But in this case,
00:16:57.280 what you're seeing too,
00:16:58.380 Michael,
00:16:58.660 which is really interesting here,
00:16:59.960 is really people
00:17:01.180 trying to cash in
00:17:02.320 on being right-leaning
00:17:03.780 or conservative
00:17:04.760 or Trump-supporting
00:17:06.120 and making that their brand
00:17:07.760 and then obviously
00:17:08.580 doing their own
00:17:09.340 narcissistic spin on it,
00:17:10.480 in this case with this girl,
00:17:11.440 this horrific self-harm
00:17:12.720 narcissistic spin
00:17:13.720 where she's,
00:17:14.880 you know,
00:17:15.300 literally injuring herself
00:17:16.560 to get attention.
00:17:17.960 And that's what this is.
00:17:18.520 She's injuring herself
00:17:19.300 to get attention.
00:17:20.260 But it shows a culture shift
00:17:21.660 because now
00:17:22.340 it's actually popular
00:17:23.620 to be on the right
00:17:24.380 and she's almost
00:17:24.980 leaning into it
00:17:25.840 to say,
00:17:26.200 well,
00:17:26.340 I'm being hurt for it,
00:17:27.620 but it's actually part
00:17:28.340 of some sort of
00:17:28.860 a status symbol for her.
00:17:30.380 So you could say
00:17:31.180 in one sense,
00:17:32.160 the one silver lining
00:17:33.280 of this story,
00:17:33.980 Michael,
00:17:34.260 if there is a silver lining,
00:17:36.020 is that now
00:17:36.660 it's mainstream
00:17:37.260 to be on the right.
00:17:39.280 It's much more mainstream
00:17:40.020 than it's ever been,
00:17:41.380 but this is how
00:17:42.120 we're going to use
00:17:42.620 and abuse that opportunity
00:17:44.180 and how this young woman is.
00:17:46.300 So the girls need help.
00:17:47.620 I'm working on it,
00:17:48.380 Michael.
00:17:48.720 We're trying to help
00:17:49.600 these girls,
00:17:50.260 but it's rough out there
00:17:51.780 because between social media,
00:17:53.360 mental health issues,
00:17:54.260 the spiritual crisis,
00:17:55.760 the self-obsession
00:17:57.020 is at an all-time high
00:17:58.420 and dealing with that
00:18:00.300 is a very complicated problem.
00:18:02.360 It's very tough,
00:18:03.340 but it's doable.
00:18:04.360 It's possible.
00:18:05.200 We're going to win this,
00:18:05.760 but it's going to take some time.
00:18:06.980 I'm so glad
00:18:08.020 you mentioned
00:18:08.580 the silver lining
00:18:09.300 because I didn't want
00:18:10.020 to be the one to say it,
00:18:11.180 but I did have
00:18:12.120 the same reaction.
00:18:14.000 And you put it
00:18:15.220 in really clear terms.
00:18:16.800 The girl committed self-harm
00:18:19.560 to get attention,
00:18:21.260 which is a tale
00:18:22.240 as old as time.
00:18:23.060 That actually is something
00:18:24.340 that teenage girls
00:18:26.000 and young 20s girls
00:18:27.740 have done for a long time.
00:18:29.380 What makes this weird,
00:18:31.000 well,
00:18:31.520 one is the extreme lengths
00:18:33.120 she went to,
00:18:33.760 but actually what is weirder is
00:18:36.220 this always comes
00:18:37.700 from the left.
00:18:38.360 It's always a black girl
00:18:40.600 saying white supremacists
00:18:41.980 attacked her
00:18:42.660 and it never happened
00:18:43.580 or it's a girl
00:18:45.120 saying some man attacked her
00:18:46.140 and it didn't happen
00:18:46.720 or because of toxic masculinity
00:18:49.340 or whatever
00:18:49.700 or it's a Democrat,
00:18:52.500 it's Jussie Smollett
00:18:53.360 saying white supremacists
00:18:56.100 came in the south side
00:18:57.020 of Chicago
00:18:57.420 and took my subway sandwich
00:18:58.460 because it's MAGA country.
00:18:59.840 We never,
00:19:00.680 we never see this
00:19:01.860 from the right.
00:19:02.840 And to me,
00:19:04.020 it's the same silver lining
00:19:06.300 of the most recent season
00:19:07.380 of South Park.
00:19:08.680 Some conservatives
00:19:09.860 took it in good fun.
00:19:11.000 I think Charlie Kirk
00:19:11.560 who was parodied on it,
00:19:12.640 he took it in good fun.
00:19:13.960 But some conservatives
00:19:15.660 said why is South Park
00:19:16.940 going after the right now?
00:19:18.600 And I thought,
00:19:19.340 well,
00:19:20.000 it's actually a nice thing
00:19:20.820 because South Park
00:19:21.920 always goes after the regime.
00:19:23.800 And so when the regime
00:19:24.700 was woke,
00:19:25.440 they went after woke
00:19:26.260 and they had PC principle.
00:19:27.240 When the regime was run
00:19:30.000 by just kind of libs,
00:19:31.460 they went after the libs
00:19:32.540 and Al Gore
00:19:33.200 and ManBearPig.
00:19:35.700 And now the right
00:19:38.560 kind of has political power
00:19:40.320 basically for the first time
00:19:42.500 in my life.
00:19:43.240 It has real institutional,
00:19:45.060 cultural,
00:19:45.880 popular political power.
00:19:47.900 I guess that's a good thing.
00:19:49.900 I want to actually,
00:19:50.340 I want to get your take
00:19:50.920 on the sort of self-obsession here.
00:19:53.480 Did you see this woman
00:19:54.480 who just went viral on TikTok
00:19:56.620 for promoting her childless,
00:19:59.920 for those who haven't seen it,
00:20:01.140 here she is.
00:20:05.140 If you're only listening,
00:20:06.260 it says,
00:20:06.460 things that just make sense
00:20:07.780 in my child-free life.
00:20:10.060 Sleeping in as long as I want.
00:20:12.080 Coffee breaks in peace.
00:20:15.200 Disposable income.
00:20:18.080 She has like weird sculptures,
00:20:20.740 hand sculpture.
00:20:22.480 Always quiet.
00:20:24.080 Candles as plants.
00:20:25.100 Watching cartoons
00:20:28.940 because I want to.
00:20:29.960 Oh my goodness.
00:20:32.140 Never missing a brunch.
00:20:34.020 Never missing a brunch
00:20:34.960 because my time is all mine.
00:20:37.620 My time is all mine.
00:20:39.420 She's having some like
00:20:40.500 corpse reviver
00:20:41.120 or some kind of brunchy drink.
00:20:44.860 Lila, your take?
00:20:47.200 I mean,
00:20:47.820 if you want to eat
00:20:48.260 at McDonald's every day
00:20:49.340 and never have the experience
00:20:50.900 of going to a steakhouse,
00:20:52.020 I mean,
00:20:52.300 it's even,
00:20:52.800 that's not even the best comparison
00:20:54.040 because you can't compare anything
00:20:55.620 to family and love
00:20:56.640 and relationships and children.
00:20:57.900 There's just,
00:20:58.340 there's no comparison.
00:20:59.460 It's a new horizon of joy,
00:21:01.140 a new horizon of meeting,
00:21:02.580 a new horizon of responsibility,
00:21:04.660 100%.
00:21:05.560 But the level of superficiality
00:21:08.380 that this woman
00:21:09.540 is celebrating
00:21:10.700 as some sort of
00:21:11.900 advantage to her,
00:21:13.380 as some sort of,
00:21:14.180 you know,
00:21:14.440 amazing opportunity
00:21:15.600 that she has,
00:21:16.560 it's quite frankly
00:21:17.740 depressing and sad to see.
00:21:19.800 And it's back to
00:21:20.340 what we were talking about earlier,
00:21:21.180 Michael,
00:21:21.680 the girls are not okay.
00:21:23.120 And this girl
00:21:23.820 is her whole identity
00:21:24.800 is making videos now
00:21:26.020 for TikTok
00:21:26.500 and going to brunches.
00:21:28.520 Newsflash,
00:21:29.080 when you're a mother,
00:21:29.920 when you're a wife,
00:21:30.520 you can still go to brunch.
00:21:31.760 You can still watch cartoons
00:21:33.040 with your kids.
00:21:34.180 You can still do
00:21:35.000 virtually everything
00:21:35.800 in her video,
00:21:36.720 except now you're surrounded
00:21:37.780 by human love.
00:21:39.180 You have someone
00:21:40.220 that you're loving
00:21:41.040 and being loved by
00:21:41.900 as opposed to
00:21:42.640 being alone
00:21:44.120 and ultimately,
00:21:45.220 I think miserable.
00:21:46.000 When people are alone,
00:21:47.360 the social data shows
00:21:48.400 people get miserable.
00:21:49.660 So I feel bad for her.
00:21:51.180 But this is a trend.
00:21:52.240 And again,
00:21:52.700 it's TikTok likes.
00:21:53.560 That's what this is about.
00:21:54.520 Literally,
00:21:54.880 it's a TikTok video.
00:21:56.060 And she's not going to be happy.
00:21:57.420 She's going to probably
00:21:57.820 look back on this in 10 years
00:21:58.940 or 15 years
00:22:00.440 and say,
00:22:00.780 oh my gosh,
00:22:01.340 I can't have children anymore.
00:22:02.740 And this is happening
00:22:03.360 to so many women today.
00:22:04.680 I can't have children anymore.
00:22:05.700 What did I do with my life?
00:22:07.080 This is what struck me.
00:22:08.260 It was how TikTok-y it is
00:22:09.980 and how on the nose it is.
00:22:12.980 Like when I,
00:22:13.700 when people write in,
00:22:14.560 they say,
00:22:14.800 should I have kids?
00:22:15.280 Should I get married?
00:22:15.760 Whatever.
00:22:15.960 I say,
00:22:16.480 yeah,
00:22:16.920 you should.
00:22:17.420 Because at a certain point,
00:22:18.440 brunch just doesn't hit
00:22:19.700 the same way it did
00:22:21.240 10 years ago.
00:22:22.080 And she uses that example.
00:22:24.240 She goes,
00:22:24.500 but I love brunch.
00:22:25.900 And I said,
00:22:26.380 no,
00:22:26.540 brunch is great,
00:22:27.500 man.
00:22:27.640 Go to brunch with your kids.
00:22:29.120 Yeah,
00:22:29.500 you can go to brunch
00:22:30.060 with your kids.
00:22:30.820 Listen,
00:22:31.060 I've brunched
00:22:31.520 with the best of them.
00:22:32.360 I used to do those
00:22:33.240 boozy brunches,
00:22:34.460 bottle of champagne
00:22:35.500 to a man.
00:22:36.640 Look,
00:22:37.020 they're fun,
00:22:37.780 but they're less
00:22:39.240 and less fun over time.
00:22:40.240 She says,
00:22:40.500 I have disposable income.
00:22:41.380 And then she points
00:22:42.440 at really kitschy
00:22:44.760 kind of ugly art.
00:22:46.120 I don't mean to
00:22:46.760 knock her taste,
00:22:47.560 but it's like,
00:22:48.260 it's not even,
00:22:49.620 you're not even using
00:22:50.520 your disposable income
00:22:51.300 in a good way.
00:22:51.920 You're not even using
00:22:52.540 your leisure time
00:22:53.260 in a good way.
00:22:53.960 And I guess what hits me
00:22:55.100 about it,
00:22:55.540 because plenty of women
00:22:56.740 can't have kids,
00:22:57.540 plenty of couples
00:22:58.020 struggle with infertility.
00:22:59.440 There are women
00:23:00.040 who want to get married
00:23:00.860 who don't get married
00:23:01.820 and it just doesn't
00:23:02.760 work out for them.
00:23:03.560 And that's a fact
00:23:04.220 of the fallen world.
00:23:05.080 It doesn't happen a ton.
00:23:06.800 It's not super widespread,
00:23:07.620 though it's increasingly
00:23:08.660 a problem,
00:23:09.200 but that's a fact.
00:23:11.060 And I was trying to think,
00:23:11.920 okay,
00:23:12.040 well,
00:23:12.320 what is the difference
00:23:14.120 between those,
00:23:14.640 let's say,
00:23:15.560 a couple that can't have kids
00:23:16.540 or a woman who
00:23:18.080 she really wants
00:23:18.720 to get married
00:23:19.260 and she's tried everything
00:23:20.480 she can possibly try
00:23:21.320 and it just,
00:23:22.120 for whatever reason,
00:23:22.720 it just hasn't worked out.
00:23:23.760 What's the difference
00:23:24.380 between that woman
00:23:25.300 who will be alone
00:23:27.360 for a lot of time
00:23:28.000 in her apartment
00:23:28.480 and the woman on TikTok?
00:23:31.100 And it seems to me
00:23:31.960 the difference is
00:23:32.880 the self-obsession.
00:23:35.660 Everything that woman
00:23:36.860 talked about
00:23:37.680 was about her.
00:23:39.420 Yes.
00:23:41.460 There's no soup kitchens
00:23:42.580 in this video.
00:23:43.800 There's no,
00:23:44.360 I'm helping my little nieces
00:23:46.200 and nephews on the weekend
00:23:47.040 because you can be
00:23:47.840 a single woman
00:23:48.480 or a single man
00:23:49.480 and live a beautiful,
00:23:50.980 meaningful life.
00:23:51.580 And you can actually
00:23:52.200 have a vocation
00:23:53.040 to celibacy even
00:23:54.300 where you don't have
00:23:55.720 biological children
00:23:56.680 or maybe you struggle
00:23:57.800 with infertility
00:23:58.540 and you're not able
00:23:59.240 to have biological children.
00:24:00.560 You can still live
00:24:01.000 an incredibly meaningful life,
00:24:02.200 but the common denominator
00:24:03.440 always is
00:24:04.640 human relationships.
00:24:06.520 It's always responsibility
00:24:07.740 for other people,
00:24:09.180 being loved by other people
00:24:10.600 and loving them back.
00:24:11.920 And if you don't have
00:24:12.560 that in your life,
00:24:13.140 you're a hedonist materialist
00:24:14.620 that is going to be miserable
00:24:16.140 on an eternal level.
00:24:18.340 And that's what,
00:24:19.100 this is eternal consequences
00:24:20.520 for this.
00:24:21.080 And so that's why it's serious.
00:24:21.980 We can laugh about a TikTok video,
00:24:23.540 but it's a serious
00:24:24.340 spiritual sickness and crisis
00:24:26.000 which needs people
00:24:27.340 to be waking up from
00:24:28.760 by saying,
00:24:29.340 you're not going to be happy
00:24:30.240 like this
00:24:30.880 and look at what
00:24:31.720 you're missing out on.
00:24:33.060 Yes.
00:24:33.480 It will rob you
00:24:34.800 of all the joys.
00:24:35.820 It will put you
00:24:36.400 in a temporal,
00:24:37.040 if not an eternal hell,
00:24:38.660 but you will get
00:24:40.620 as many mimosas
00:24:41.760 as you want.
00:24:42.480 So, you know,
00:24:42.920 you're kind of like on one.
00:24:44.300 I still go to brunch
00:24:45.040 with my kids, okay?
00:24:46.240 So I don't buy the whole
00:24:47.460 brunch is impossible
00:24:48.420 with kids.
00:24:49.600 That's true.
00:24:50.400 You could do it.
00:24:52.340 You should,
00:24:52.820 I would say,
00:24:53.460 I would recommend drinking
00:24:54.180 less than a bottle
00:24:54.900 of champagne per minute,
00:24:55.780 but you can still get
00:24:56.460 half a bottle in.
00:24:57.240 It's fine.
00:24:57.720 Especially if the diner
00:24:58.500 is close by.
00:24:59.560 Lila, marvelous to see you
00:25:00.480 as always.
00:25:01.440 Just a reminder,
00:25:02.060 you do a billion,
00:25:03.000 a billion different things,
00:25:04.260 obviously with live action,
00:25:05.200 with the podcast,
00:25:05.700 but where can everyone
00:25:06.900 find you?
00:25:08.400 Thank you.
00:25:08.940 Well, liveaction.org
00:25:09.980 is our website
00:25:10.760 and the Lila Rose show
00:25:11.700 wherever you get
00:25:12.240 your podcasts.
00:25:13.180 Go do it.
00:25:14.020 Go do it right now, Lila.
00:25:15.260 Lovely to see you.
00:25:16.160 Thank you.
00:25:16.580 Now I want to tell
00:25:17.040 all of you about Shopify.
00:25:19.420 Go to shopify.com
00:25:21.080 slash Knowles.
00:25:22.740 Starting your own business,
00:25:23.780 starting your own podcast,
00:25:24.940 which is a business,
00:25:25.720 can be very,
00:25:26.640 very intimidating.
00:25:28.020 Let Shopify help you.
00:25:30.880 Shopify is the commerce
00:25:32.100 platform beyond millions
00:25:33.020 of businesses around the world
00:25:34.040 and 10% of all e-commerce
00:25:35.120 in the U.S.
00:25:35.900 We even use it
00:25:36.900 for our own Daily Wire shop
00:25:37.980 to make sure things
00:25:38.620 are running smoothly
00:25:39.280 and efficiently
00:25:39.780 so you all can get the goods.
00:25:42.020 You might be asking,
00:25:42.880 what if I can't design a website?
00:25:44.160 What if I'm worried
00:25:44.700 people haven't heard
00:25:45.300 about my brand?
00:25:46.300 No problem.
00:25:47.120 Shopify has got you covered
00:25:48.440 from the start
00:25:48.960 with beautiful,
00:25:49.600 ready-to-go templates
00:25:50.220 that match your brand's style,
00:25:52.100 help you find customers
00:25:52.880 through easy-to-run email
00:25:53.840 and social media campaigns.
00:25:55.380 If you need a hand
00:25:56.320 with Everyday Tasks,
00:25:57.320 their AI tools
00:25:57.960 created specifically for commerce
00:25:59.420 can help enhance
00:26:00.520 product images,
00:26:01.300 write descriptions,
00:26:01.820 and more.
00:26:02.520 Plus,
00:26:03.240 their award-winning
00:26:03.800 customer support
00:26:04.440 is available 24-7
00:26:05.520 to share advice
00:26:06.520 if you ever get stuck.
00:26:07.840 Turn your big business idea
00:26:09.200 into
00:26:09.720 with Shopify on your side.
00:26:12.340 Sign up for your $1
00:26:13.480 per month trial.
00:26:14.620 Start selling today
00:26:15.780 at shopify.com
00:26:17.080 slash Knowles.
00:26:17.580 Can't-a-w-l-a-s.
00:26:18.560 Shopify.com
00:26:19.300 slash Knowles.
00:26:20.440 That is
00:26:20.960 shopify.com
00:26:22.880 slash Knowles.
00:26:27.160 Speaking of young people
00:26:28.380 and speaking of children,
00:26:29.700 actually,
00:26:30.240 famous children,
00:26:31.900 Naylin Haley,
00:26:33.300 Nikki Haley's son,
00:26:34.420 just went on Tucker's show
00:26:35.720 and lit the internet on fire
00:26:37.780 because of this claim
00:26:40.140 that he made
00:26:41.220 about public office
00:26:43.020 and naturalized citizens.
00:26:46.080 And there's so many
00:26:47.180 different aspects
00:26:47.840 to immigration
00:26:48.800 that it's not just
00:26:49.880 the migration part of it,
00:26:51.580 but a lot of other things
00:26:52.960 that are just
00:26:53.500 out of control.
00:26:54.380 Like what?
00:26:55.120 So,
00:26:56.300 naturalized citizens
00:26:58.060 should not be able
00:26:58.820 to hold public office.
00:27:00.280 Growing up here
00:27:01.400 is a big part
00:27:01.960 of understanding
00:27:02.480 the country.
00:27:03.800 We need to stop
00:27:04.860 and limit
00:27:05.740 the amount of foreign students
00:27:06.840 that are coming
00:27:07.280 into our universities.
00:27:08.520 Some of them are spies,
00:27:09.440 by the way,
00:27:10.180 for foreign governments,
00:27:11.160 but it's also just
00:27:12.440 we should put our kids first.
00:27:13.900 And we should also
00:27:17.740 not allow dual citizenship
00:27:19.260 because that's the stupidest idea.
00:27:21.620 You're either American
00:27:22.700 or you're not.
00:27:24.020 And everyone wants
00:27:24.980 to make it so complicated.
00:27:26.140 That's the thing
00:27:26.640 that I don't like
00:27:27.260 about the past generation
00:27:28.100 is they're always about
00:27:28.720 the rules,
00:27:29.340 the process,
00:27:30.240 and regulation.
00:27:31.360 No,
00:27:31.500 it's really simple.
00:27:32.500 You're just America first.
00:27:34.240 People should have their loyalty
00:27:35.220 to America first.
00:27:36.680 And if they can't do that,
00:27:37.940 then this ain't the country
00:27:38.500 for you.
00:27:39.860 This is a really important,
00:27:41.580 broad political point.
00:27:42.960 And I know there are
00:27:43.440 going to be a bunch of people
00:27:44.360 who are going to find exceptions
00:27:46.040 and they're going to say,
00:27:47.000 oh, well,
00:27:47.560 you know,
00:27:47.960 I've got Italian citizenship
00:27:49.880 because of my grandparents.
00:27:51.820 And it doesn't mean
00:27:52.620 I'm loyal to Italy
00:27:54.000 or whatever.
00:27:54.780 I came from another country
00:27:56.120 and they won't let me
00:27:56.560 renounce my citizenship.
00:27:57.300 Okay, yeah, sure.
00:27:58.000 There are all sorts of exceptions.
00:27:59.260 No one denies it.
00:28:00.220 But what about
00:28:02.040 the broader political point
00:28:03.440 he's making?
00:28:05.000 What he is saying,
00:28:06.480 even go back,
00:28:06.980 I felt the first point
00:28:07.900 was even stronger.
00:28:08.980 When he says
00:28:09.600 naturalized citizens
00:28:11.180 shouldn't hold public office.
00:28:12.480 Now, it might be difficult
00:28:13.700 to make that,
00:28:15.040 to make a case for that legally
00:28:16.800 or what, you know,
00:28:17.400 you could change laws, I guess.
00:28:18.760 The broader point
00:28:20.000 that he's saying is
00:28:21.040 citizenship,
00:28:22.740 true citizenship,
00:28:24.180 takes time.
00:28:25.940 It doesn't just happen overnight.
00:28:27.800 You don't come here
00:28:29.160 from some far-flung country
00:28:30.940 with a radically different culture,
00:28:32.580 with a radically different religion,
00:28:33.840 with radically different practices.
00:28:35.240 You don't just come here
00:28:36.560 and memorize a few facts
00:28:38.420 about American civics
00:28:39.440 and take the test,
00:28:40.620 raise your right hand,
00:28:41.360 and magically become
00:28:42.580 as American as apple pie.
00:28:44.780 That doesn't happen.
00:28:45.800 That's a very rationalist view.
00:28:47.400 That's a very liberal view.
00:28:48.880 That's a very abstract,
00:28:51.080 ideological view.
00:28:52.580 But it's not real.
00:28:54.340 It's not real.
00:28:55.540 Citizenship actually takes time.
00:28:57.880 It's not to say
00:28:58.760 that there is just something
00:28:59.640 magical in the blood
00:29:00.620 that makes a citizen,
00:29:01.540 that forecloses citizenship
00:29:03.760 to other people,
00:29:04.700 other peoples.
00:29:06.120 But it is to say
00:29:07.120 that citizenship takes time.
00:29:09.480 When you're here
00:29:10.340 for a long time,
00:29:12.020 two, three,
00:29:14.040 10, 12,
00:29:15.720 13 generations,
00:29:17.100 you're going to see
00:29:18.700 a difference
00:29:19.380 in culture,
00:29:22.840 in tradition,
00:29:24.020 in habit,
00:29:24.960 in attitude.
00:29:25.700 And you don't just
00:29:26.840 get that overnight.
00:29:28.240 It takes time.
00:29:29.560 What Nail and Haley
00:29:31.080 is pointing to here
00:29:32.240 is the fact that
00:29:33.440 politics is deeper
00:29:34.620 than just saying
00:29:35.840 a few words
00:29:36.620 or memorizing
00:29:37.420 a few facts.
00:29:38.560 Politics is deeper
00:29:39.560 than just assenting
00:29:41.080 to a few creedal abstractions.
00:29:44.080 And that's,
00:29:44.540 in recent decades,
00:29:45.720 we have reduced
00:29:46.840 citizenship to that.
00:29:49.140 America's just an idea.
00:29:51.900 And diversity is our strength.
00:29:54.080 And anyone can beat America.
00:29:55.160 That isn't true.
00:29:57.440 There's a creedal aspect
00:29:58.380 to the country
00:29:59.540 as there is
00:30:01.040 to most countries.
00:30:02.140 But it's more than that.
00:30:03.880 It's also geography.
00:30:05.020 It's also borders.
00:30:06.940 It's also habits.
00:30:08.580 It's also traditions.
00:30:09.460 It's also hot dogs
00:30:10.080 on the 4th of July.
00:30:10.940 And it's also people.
00:30:12.800 Okay?
00:30:14.060 The fact that we have
00:30:14.920 a great,
00:30:15.280 you know,
00:30:16.640 a great founding story
00:30:17.540 of America,
00:30:18.220 beginning with the Mayflower,
00:30:19.220 which is a terrific cigar brand.
00:30:20.760 And I think about,
00:30:21.640 okay,
00:30:21.820 so some of my ancestors
00:30:22.500 came on the Mayflower.
00:30:23.320 Some came on a sardine boat
00:30:24.220 from Sicily.
00:30:24.840 But some came on the Mayflower.
00:30:26.480 And some other English settlers
00:30:28.200 came a little bit later
00:30:29.560 in 1660.
00:30:31.440 You have John Knowles arrives.
00:30:33.360 The Knowles family home
00:30:34.660 stood in New Hampshire
00:30:36.200 from about 1660
00:30:38.360 until 1994
00:30:39.560 when it burned down.
00:30:41.700 Okay?
00:30:42.860 Centuries.
00:30:45.040 334 years,
00:30:46.040 by my count,
00:30:47.020 this home stood.
00:30:48.280 And when you're,
00:30:49.280 when you get that
00:30:49.920 into your bones,
00:30:50.740 when you get that
00:30:51.200 into your habit,
00:30:51.740 you just,
00:30:53.360 that will change you.
00:30:54.840 That will shape you
00:30:55.880 in a way
00:30:56.320 that arriving
00:30:57.180 off an airplane
00:30:58.060 from Uganda
00:30:59.280 and learning
00:31:00.660 who George Washington is
00:31:01.880 and answering
00:31:02.960 a few simple questions
00:31:03.900 on a test
00:31:04.360 is not going to make
00:31:05.240 you an American.
00:31:06.060 And what he's saying
00:31:06.880 is that the people
00:31:08.180 who just got here
00:31:09.000 probably shouldn't be
00:31:09.800 the ones in office.
00:31:10.620 And that's obviously true.
00:31:13.020 That's obviously true.
00:31:15.040 Maybe there,
00:31:15.800 maybe there are some exceptions.
00:31:16.980 Maybe a blue blood
00:31:18.120 is really bad for office
00:31:19.420 and maybe some guy
00:31:20.560 who got here
00:31:21.120 is the exception
00:31:21.680 that proves the rule.
00:31:22.280 But the rule stands
00:31:23.080 nevertheless.
00:31:24.080 And on the point
00:31:24.700 of dual loyalty,
00:31:25.700 this is just a problem
00:31:26.680 of nationalism,
00:31:28.640 of the Westphalian system.
00:31:30.360 Yes,
00:31:30.620 you cannot simultaneously
00:31:32.040 be equally loyal
00:31:34.020 to two things
00:31:34.960 of the same kind.
00:31:36.280 It's just not possible.
00:31:38.380 You can be loyal
00:31:39.720 to two things
00:31:40.600 of different kinds.
00:31:41.700 I can have a loyalty
00:31:42.540 to my Mayflower cigars
00:31:44.820 and a loyalty
00:31:45.440 to my comfy sweaters.
00:31:46.540 By the way,
00:31:46.860 we're going to have
00:31:47.140 a new sweater
00:31:47.580 I'm debuting
00:31:48.120 in the Membrum Segmentum,
00:31:49.100 so stay tuned for that.
00:31:49.980 Because those are things
00:31:50.800 of different kinds.
00:31:52.280 But I can't be equally loyal
00:31:53.400 to the United States
00:31:54.300 and the United Kingdom.
00:31:55.860 I can have great affection
00:31:56.880 for the United Kingdom.
00:31:57.760 I can have great affection
00:31:58.480 for Italy
00:31:58.940 as an ancestral home.
00:32:00.360 But no,
00:32:01.640 the two things
00:32:02.020 are the same kind.
00:32:02.500 You have to have
00:32:03.780 your loyalty
00:32:04.220 chiefly to one
00:32:05.560 of those things.
00:32:06.540 That's just how it works.
00:32:08.680 And it's great
00:32:10.440 in the case of
00:32:11.120 Nalen Haley
00:32:11.960 because he is the,
00:32:14.660 what,
00:32:15.060 grandchild of immigrants.
00:32:16.860 So he's saying,
00:32:17.360 look,
00:32:17.520 I'm speaking
00:32:17.880 from experience here.
00:32:18.820 You know,
00:32:19.220 I think that
00:32:20.560 it takes some time.
00:32:21.400 And,
00:32:22.420 you know,
00:32:23.180 you develop more
00:32:24.200 American habits over time.
00:32:25.420 So really great point.
00:32:26.620 Even if
00:32:27.640 one can't quite implement
00:32:30.040 the particulars
00:32:30.820 of the things
00:32:31.240 he's talking about,
00:32:32.080 at the broader point
00:32:33.060 of political philosophy
00:32:33.780 and citizenship,
00:32:34.560 he's making a very,
00:32:36.180 very important argument
00:32:37.220 that previously
00:32:38.200 would have been considered
00:32:38.960 totally common sense.
00:32:40.300 Okay,
00:32:40.540 speaking of identity politics,
00:32:41.820 this is another insane story
00:32:43.620 that everyone just knows.
00:32:46.080 They all,
00:32:46.820 everyone knew
00:32:47.560 that the Somalis
00:32:48.380 in Minnesota
00:32:48.900 were scheming
00:32:49.640 and defrauding people.
00:32:50.920 We all knew it.
00:32:51.640 Now we have proof.
00:32:53.020 And everyone knew
00:32:54.940 that Capitol Hill staffers
00:32:56.740 are completely insane.
00:32:57.680 We all knew that.
00:32:58.220 In fact,
00:32:58.320 I think that woman
00:32:58.960 who chopped herself up,
00:33:00.440 I think that she might be
00:33:01.480 the least psychotic
00:33:02.920 Capitol Hill staffer,
00:33:04.680 Washington,
00:33:05.060 D.C. staffer.
00:33:05.720 We all knew it.
00:33:06.320 Now we have some proof.
00:33:07.100 Here,
00:33:08.380 we now have
00:33:09.620 a really important thread.
00:33:10.580 This was posted
00:33:11.020 by uncorrelated underscore
00:33:13.220 who went through
00:33:15.060 a meme that you see.
00:33:15.980 And the meme is
00:33:16.700 you look into
00:33:17.340 crime databases
00:33:18.920 and you see,
00:33:20.260 you know,
00:33:20.620 name,
00:33:21.760 Jose,
00:33:22.760 age,
00:33:23.440 29,
00:33:24.920 race,
00:33:26.080 white.
00:33:27.000 And you see the picture
00:33:27.840 and it's like
00:33:28.560 the most Latino looking guy
00:33:29.760 you ever saw
00:33:30.180 in your entire life.
00:33:31.640 You know,
00:33:31.940 face tatted up,
00:33:33.120 Venezuelan.
00:33:34.100 But it's ethnicity,
00:33:35.540 white,
00:33:36.100 race,
00:33:36.700 white,
00:33:36.940 or whatever.
00:33:38.540 And you see this a lot
00:33:39.600 anecdotally.
00:33:40.600 So,
00:33:41.340 this account posts,
00:33:42.600 white by default,
00:33:43.180 the viral posts were right.
00:33:44.360 We scraped five and a half
00:33:45.420 million criminal records
00:33:46.360 and one and a half million
00:33:47.240 mugshots from 39 states.
00:33:49.640 29% of Hispanics
00:33:51.440 are being misclassified
00:33:52.940 as white
00:33:53.620 in official
00:33:54.720 Department of Corrections
00:33:55.660 databases.
00:33:57.420 The thread goes on.
00:33:58.580 Everyone's seen
00:33:59.120 the collages.
00:33:59.880 The problem is
00:34:00.420 it's anecdotal,
00:34:01.140 cherry picked,
00:34:01.660 no way to verify.
00:34:02.540 So,
00:34:02.740 we had one and a half
00:34:03.580 million mugshots,
00:34:04.340 names,
00:34:04.560 and official racial
00:34:05.560 classifications.
00:34:06.340 Time to test it
00:34:07.000 systematically.
00:34:08.100 And once this
00:34:09.320 individual ran
00:34:11.180 these numbers,
00:34:12.060 according to this guy's
00:34:12.920 analysis,
00:34:13.380 correcting for
00:34:14.940 misclassification,
00:34:16.320 Hispanic criminal
00:34:17.700 record rates
00:34:18.480 increase
00:34:19.200 by 20 to 31%.
00:34:21.600 White criminal
00:34:23.880 record rates
00:34:24.540 decrease
00:34:25.240 by 4 to 6%.
00:34:26.780 Black crime rates
00:34:28.900 decrease
00:34:29.580 by 1%.
00:34:30.420 So,
00:34:31.380 the black rates
00:34:31.920 remain basically
00:34:32.600 the same.
00:34:33.520 The white rates
00:34:34.300 significantly decrease
00:34:35.860 and the Hispanic rates
00:34:36.980 very,
00:34:37.940 very significantly
00:34:38.600 increase.
00:34:40.380 Why is this
00:34:41.080 happening?
00:34:42.020 There's going to be
00:34:42.640 some pedantic person
00:34:43.380 that says,
00:34:43.980 well,
00:34:44.240 you know,
00:34:44.520 actually,
00:34:45.820 it's because race
00:34:46.800 and ethnicity
00:34:47.220 are different things.
00:34:48.160 And actually,
00:34:48.600 there are many
00:34:48.920 Hispanic people
00:34:49.580 who identify
00:34:50.220 as white.
00:34:50.940 And obviously,
00:34:51.740 there are some
00:34:52.480 Hispanic people
00:34:53.020 who are much
00:34:53.380 whiter and others
00:34:54.080 who are a little
00:34:54.580 darker and others
00:34:55.280 who have more
00:34:55.700 of an admixture
00:34:56.180 of the indigenous
00:34:56.720 people.
00:34:57.120 And so,
00:34:57.360 there's actually,
00:34:57.880 I mean,
00:34:58.000 yeah,
00:34:58.160 yeah,
00:34:58.320 yeah,
00:34:58.500 yeah.
00:35:00.600 But that's not
00:35:02.180 meaningful in the
00:35:03.340 American context.
00:35:04.560 In the American
00:35:05.460 context,
00:35:06.080 when we're trying
00:35:06.760 to get down to
00:35:07.660 different ethnic
00:35:08.760 or racial enclaves,
00:35:09.860 different cultural
00:35:11.060 groupings,
00:35:12.340 when we're trying
00:35:12.960 to get to the
00:35:13.680 heart of the
00:35:14.020 matter,
00:35:15.820 no one thinks
00:35:16.840 that white
00:35:18.040 and Hispanic
00:35:18.680 mean the same
00:35:19.240 thing.
00:35:20.460 No one thinks
00:35:21.500 that white
00:35:22.300 and black
00:35:22.680 mean the same
00:35:23.140 thing or Hispanic
00:35:23.740 and black
00:35:24.020 mean the same
00:35:24.400 thing.
00:35:24.680 We know what
00:35:27.280 you're doing
00:35:27.880 when you are
00:35:29.120 misclassified.
00:35:29.700 Because the
00:35:30.260 misclassifications
00:35:31.200 only seem to go
00:35:32.180 in one direction.
00:35:33.240 And the point,
00:35:33.920 obviously,
00:35:34.420 is to avoid
00:35:36.440 the politically
00:35:36.940 incorrect fact
00:35:37.760 that white
00:35:38.340 people commit
00:35:38.900 relatively little
00:35:39.740 crime,
00:35:40.300 especially relatively
00:35:40.900 little violent
00:35:41.380 crime.
00:35:42.720 And other
00:35:44.020 racial groups
00:35:44.760 commit a
00:35:45.880 significantly
00:35:46.320 higher proportion
00:35:47.720 of violent
00:35:48.080 crime.
00:35:48.580 And that's
00:35:49.220 politically
00:35:49.500 incorrect because
00:35:50.580 we're not
00:35:52.360 supposed to say
00:35:53.060 that white
00:35:53.940 people have
00:35:56.260 an advantage
00:35:56.760 at any kind
00:35:57.500 of social
00:35:57.840 outcome.
00:35:58.880 Or if they
00:35:59.640 do,
00:35:59.920 it's the
00:36:00.320 result of
00:36:00.780 some terrible
00:36:01.280 system of
00:36:01.780 oppression or
00:36:02.300 whatever.
00:36:02.540 And it's
00:36:03.740 just icky and
00:36:04.500 it's called
00:36:04.900 racist.
00:36:05.440 It's like a
00:36:06.040 racist fact or
00:36:06.780 something.
00:36:07.360 But I guess
00:36:08.020 the rejoinder to
00:36:09.060 this is,
00:36:10.060 if you actually
00:36:11.600 love people and
00:36:13.580 you want to
00:36:14.440 help them and
00:36:14.880 you want them
00:36:15.260 to improve,
00:36:16.520 the first thing
00:36:17.740 you have to do
00:36:18.200 is acknowledge
00:36:18.760 reality.
00:36:19.880 So, if there's
00:36:21.400 a particular
00:36:22.400 problem with
00:36:22.840 black crime,
00:36:23.660 which obviously
00:36:24.200 there is,
00:36:25.280 or in this
00:36:26.000 case, what
00:36:26.360 we're talking
00:36:26.660 about, if
00:36:27.040 there is a
00:36:27.640 serious problem
00:36:28.740 with Hispanic
00:36:29.440 crime,
00:36:31.120 problems that
00:36:31.920 you don't
00:36:32.400 see when it
00:36:33.200 comes to
00:36:33.460 white people,
00:36:34.280 then the
00:36:35.260 first step to
00:36:36.040 helping them
00:36:37.060 to fixing the
00:36:37.900 problem, and
00:36:38.960 don't forget,
00:36:39.560 we punish
00:36:40.440 evildoers not
00:36:42.080 only to protect
00:36:42.820 the innocent,
00:36:43.500 but also to
00:36:44.500 help the
00:36:45.440 evildoers.
00:36:46.880 Because it
00:36:48.000 harms you when
00:36:48.980 you do evil
00:36:49.680 things.
00:36:50.600 This is an
00:36:50.980 observation that
00:36:51.620 goes back to
00:36:52.300 Plato and the
00:36:53.480 Gorgias.
00:36:54.120 This is an
00:36:54.620 observation that
00:36:55.480 goes back to
00:36:56.640 the Bible.
00:37:00.200 It helps the
00:37:01.600 guilty to be
00:37:02.380 punished.
00:37:03.600 If you want
00:37:04.000 to help them,
00:37:04.960 you have to
00:37:05.500 acknowledge reality.
00:37:07.360 And so much
00:37:08.180 of, I think,
00:37:08.780 what undergirds
00:37:09.460 modern leftism,
00:37:10.700 all the way up
00:37:11.480 to the
00:37:11.700 transgender
00:37:12.080 ideology,
00:37:12.740 maybe that's a
00:37:13.180 special example,
00:37:14.380 is that they
00:37:16.020 believe that
00:37:16.640 lies are
00:37:17.540 helpful and
00:37:18.340 good and
00:37:18.720 nice, and
00:37:19.640 that the
00:37:19.940 truth is
00:37:20.420 cruel, and
00:37:21.120 that you
00:37:21.540 have to
00:37:21.760 avoid it.
00:37:22.300 Okay.
00:37:23.340 Oh, there's
00:37:23.880 so much good
00:37:25.120 stuff to get
00:37:25.660 to, but
00:37:26.780 we don't have
00:37:28.020 time.
00:37:28.320 Because I
00:37:29.880 want to get
00:37:30.340 to the
00:37:30.580 mailbag.
00:37:30.920 Before we
00:37:31.140 get to the
00:37:31.380 mailbag, I
00:37:31.740 want to tell
00:37:31.980 you about
00:37:32.160 St. Paul
00:37:32.420 Center.
00:37:32.880 Go to
00:37:33.140 stpaulcenter.com
00:37:34.220 slash
00:37:34.520 America.
00:37:35.100 America has
00:37:35.520 reached a
00:37:35.960 cultural and
00:37:36.640 spiritual crossroads.
00:37:37.940 People are
00:37:38.260 looking for the
00:37:38.760 truth.
00:37:39.400 In their
00:37:39.640 search, more
00:37:40.100 and more
00:37:40.300 people are
00:37:40.660 turning to
00:37:40.980 the Bible
00:37:41.320 for answers.
00:37:42.020 Bible Across
00:37:42.400 America is a
00:37:43.060 nationwide Bible
00:37:43.740 study, biggest
00:37:44.700 Bible study in
00:37:45.260 the country,
00:37:46.060 hosted by the
00:37:46.620 St. Paul Center
00:37:47.220 for Biblical
00:37:47.720 Theology.
00:37:48.380 Seven-week
00:37:48.700 Bible study
00:37:49.180 exploring the
00:37:50.260 personal challenge
00:37:51.400 of affirming
00:37:52.020 Christ as
00:37:52.700 teacher and
00:37:53.140 Lord.
00:37:54.020 Join the
00:37:54.440 movement and
00:37:58.320 September 5th.
00:37:58.940 Certainly not
00:37:59.480 too late to
00:37:59.980 sign up.
00:38:00.400 Do it right
00:38:00.740 now.
00:38:00.980 You go to
00:38:01.220 stpaulcenter.com
00:38:02.760 slash
00:38:03.080 America.
00:38:03.580 I love the
00:38:04.080 St. Paul
00:38:04.400 Center.
00:38:05.520 I was just
00:38:05.860 at the
00:38:06.040 St. Paul
00:38:06.300 Center
00:38:06.560 Gala.
00:38:07.500 I have
00:38:08.160 the study
00:38:09.340 Bible that
00:38:10.260 was the
00:38:10.700 Ignatius
00:38:11.020 study Bible
00:38:11.620 that was
00:38:12.360 edited by
00:38:12.840 Scott Hahn
00:38:13.500 who founded
00:38:13.920 the St. Paul
00:38:14.380 Center.
00:38:14.960 It's one of
00:38:15.300 two books
00:38:15.780 on my desk
00:38:16.500 at home.
00:38:17.680 Unbelievable
00:38:18.040 insights that
00:38:19.840 can come from
00:38:20.660 the St. Paul
00:38:21.020 Center, especially
00:38:21.500 at this moment
00:38:21.960 where there's a
00:38:22.620 big spike in
00:38:23.180 Bible sales, a
00:38:24.240 big spike in
00:38:25.000 church attendance, a
00:38:26.300 big interest in
00:38:28.040 the eternal
00:38:28.680 questions and
00:38:29.340 returning to
00:38:29.820 faith.
00:38:30.480 Avail yourself
00:38:31.080 of the best
00:38:31.620 resources available.
00:38:33.060 Go to
00:38:33.420 stpaulcenter.com
00:38:35.300 slash
00:38:36.080 America.
00:38:37.760 Our best deal
00:38:38.560 of the year is
00:38:38.860 happening right
00:38:39.340 now.
00:38:39.580 Daily Wire Plus
00:38:40.000 membership is
00:38:40.440 50% off.
00:38:42.500 There's nothing
00:38:42.880 negative to say
00:38:43.540 about it.
00:38:44.860 Even on the
00:38:45.420 internet, even on
00:38:45.980 social media, you
00:38:46.500 want to say
00:38:46.760 something negative
00:38:47.260 about everything,
00:38:47.880 but you get
00:38:49.040 ad-free, uncensored
00:38:50.500 Daily Wire shows
00:38:51.260 an hour early
00:38:52.320 before everyone
00:38:53.000 else.
00:38:53.440 You get live
00:38:53.900 chats with the
00:38:54.460 show.
00:38:55.140 You get
00:38:55.560 investigative
00:38:56.020 journalism.
00:38:56.660 You get our
00:38:56.900 whole library of
00:38:57.560 premium
00:38:57.820 entertainment.
00:38:58.580 That includes
00:38:59.100 the Pendragon
00:38:59.620 cycle, Rise of
00:39:00.340 the Merlin,
00:39:00.820 premieres January
00:39:01.380 22nd.
00:39:02.320 All access
00:39:02.820 members get
00:39:03.300 exclusive early
00:39:03.900 access on
00:39:04.420 Christmas Day
00:39:04.920 to episodes
00:39:05.340 1 and 2.
00:39:06.480 Go to
00:39:06.740 dailywire.com
00:39:07.320 slash subscribe
00:39:07.940 and save
00:39:08.140 50% on your
00:39:09.200 Daily Wire Plus
00:39:09.880 annual membership
00:39:10.780 now.
00:39:12.520 My favorite
00:39:13.240 comment yesterday
00:39:13.760 is from
00:39:14.040 Kauskualdoas.
00:39:16.460 What a name.
00:39:17.160 It says, let me
00:39:17.620 guess, Chicago
00:39:18.200 man is code for
00:39:19.060 like youth or
00:39:19.860 Florida man at
00:39:20.500 this point.
00:39:20.900 Yeah, a little
00:39:21.640 euphemistic, I
00:39:22.720 suppose.
00:39:24.120 Finally, finally,
00:39:24.820 we've arrived at my
00:39:25.400 favorite time of the
00:39:25.900 week when I get to
00:39:26.400 hear from you in
00:39:26.740 the mailbag.
00:39:27.200 Mailbag is
00:39:27.540 sponsored by
00:39:27.940 Pure Talk.
00:39:28.380 Go to
00:39:28.460 puretalk.com
00:39:29.140 slash
00:39:29.360 Knowles, K-N-O-W-L-E-S
00:39:31.140 today.
00:39:31.700 Take it away.
00:39:32.780 Hey, Michael.
00:39:33.380 I haven't really
00:39:34.100 planned this
00:39:34.780 question, just
00:39:35.620 shooting from the
00:39:36.080 hip here.
00:39:36.580 So you talked
00:39:37.140 today about how
00:39:39.340 marriages have
00:39:40.140 really fallen in
00:39:42.140 the sense of being
00:39:43.180 able to break
00:39:44.420 apart from them
00:39:45.500 and divorce at
00:39:46.740 will without any
00:39:47.940 cause.
00:39:48.440 Do you think that
00:39:50.180 would change or do
00:39:50.840 you think there
00:39:51.160 would be a thing
00:39:51.660 where like normal
00:39:53.500 couples like us
00:39:54.560 have go into like a
00:39:57.600 prenup agreement but
00:39:58.500 in the opposite way
00:39:59.340 where they make it
00:40:00.440 really impossible to
00:40:02.600 get divorced because
00:40:05.300 of how it's been
00:40:07.480 made now.
00:40:09.460 Curious on what you
00:40:10.660 think the trend will
00:40:11.300 be as a father of
00:40:13.040 two beautiful little
00:40:14.740 girls and soon to be
00:40:16.160 three.
00:40:16.760 Thank you.
00:40:17.700 The trend will
00:40:18.400 follow.
00:40:18.900 It's a very good
00:40:19.300 question.
00:40:19.680 The trend will
00:40:20.100 follow whatever the
00:40:20.820 limits of the
00:40:21.300 political order are.
00:40:22.820 So what you're
00:40:23.680 describing is a kind
00:40:25.180 of private fix for a
00:40:27.980 public failure.
00:40:28.940 The public failure
00:40:29.780 being the
00:40:30.300 liberalization of
00:40:31.100 marriage, the
00:40:31.860 encouragement of
00:40:32.600 divorce, and the
00:40:36.480 subsequent collapse
00:40:37.220 in marriage rates.
00:40:38.120 And so the private
00:40:38.780 fix is, okay, well
00:40:40.080 we're going to
00:40:41.000 constrain people far
00:40:43.000 beyond the bounds of
00:40:44.160 the law and that's
00:40:45.120 not going to work.
00:40:46.420 It's not going to
00:40:47.220 work because ultimately
00:40:49.100 these matters will be
00:40:50.380 adjudicated by courts
00:40:51.460 and the courts will
00:40:52.100 defer to the public
00:40:52.980 law.
00:40:53.380 They won't honor the
00:40:55.400 private compacts or
00:40:57.140 contracts that you've
00:40:58.160 signed.
00:40:58.780 So there's no way out.
00:41:00.660 This is the conservative
00:41:03.920 and especially libertarian
00:41:05.120 instinct is to say,
00:41:05.980 well look, I don't want
00:41:06.620 to deal with all the
00:41:07.420 stupid politics.
00:41:08.220 I don't want to have to
00:41:08.840 run for office.
00:41:09.420 It's such a hassle.
00:41:10.100 I don't want to have to
00:41:11.340 deal with the extreme
00:41:13.260 TDM of trying to
00:41:14.160 pass laws and then
00:41:15.480 fight the bureaucrats
00:41:16.480 who don't want to
00:41:16.920 properly implement the
00:41:17.800 laws and I just don't
00:41:18.380 want to deal with it.
00:41:19.220 So I'm just going to
00:41:20.020 retreat to my own
00:41:20.920 little community and
00:41:22.440 my own smallest
00:41:23.280 community, my family,
00:41:24.260 and I'm just going to
00:41:24.760 try to have private
00:41:25.500 solutions.
00:41:26.060 I get the temptations
00:41:26.880 for all of that.
00:41:28.140 I work in the private
00:41:28.860 sector.
00:41:29.240 I get it.
00:41:30.680 Ultimately, that's not
00:41:31.480 going to work.
00:41:32.840 Ultimately, you have to
00:41:34.600 wield the political
00:41:35.320 order.
00:41:35.620 And so if the
00:41:36.400 political order
00:41:36.940 encourages divorce and
00:41:38.120 discourages marriage
00:41:38.920 as it currently does,
00:41:40.340 and the political
00:41:40.900 order now, in fact,
00:41:42.160 has abolished marriage
00:41:43.080 practically by
00:41:43.700 redefining it through
00:41:44.440 Obergefell, then you're
00:41:46.200 going to get less
00:41:46.880 marriage and you're
00:41:47.600 going to get more
00:41:47.820 divorce.
00:41:48.720 Or you're going to
00:41:49.040 get a lot of divorce
00:41:49.860 at least.
00:41:50.240 The trends will go up
00:41:50.960 and down.
00:41:51.720 But if you have a
00:41:52.800 political order that
00:41:53.360 encourages marriage and
00:41:54.340 discourages divorce,
00:41:56.140 then you're going to
00:41:56.620 get more marriage and
00:41:57.220 less divorce.
00:41:57.680 That's how it works.
00:41:58.460 I've talked about the
00:41:59.280 Knowles prenup.
00:42:00.300 The Knowles prenup, it
00:42:01.140 says, before you get
00:42:02.280 married, you sign it.
00:42:03.020 It says, whichever party
00:42:04.360 institutes or initiates
00:42:05.700 the divorce forfeits
00:42:06.680 everything.
00:42:08.920 I like this in
00:42:09.880 principle, but probably
00:42:11.340 in most cases it would
00:42:12.280 not work because you're
00:42:14.560 going to, the judge is
00:42:15.960 always going to defer to
00:42:16.660 the liberal political
00:42:17.880 order.
00:42:18.500 And, you know, in the
00:42:21.040 case of liberalism, it's
00:42:22.300 going to favor divorce.
00:42:23.560 That's just how it goes.
00:42:24.540 We have to fix that.
00:42:25.700 It's a political
00:42:26.140 problem.
00:42:26.620 Next question.
00:42:27.620 Hi, Michael.
00:42:28.300 Longtime listener, huge
00:42:29.620 fan, and I had a
00:42:30.500 question about health
00:42:31.220 care.
00:42:31.800 I have a lot of
00:42:32.520 experience with doctors
00:42:33.660 and hospitals since I'm
00:42:34.860 chronically ill.
00:42:36.000 I have health insurance,
00:42:37.020 but that's not the
00:42:37.820 problem.
00:42:38.280 The problem that I and
00:42:39.440 many people face is the
00:42:40.500 quality of the medical
00:42:41.320 system itself.
00:42:42.760 Medical malpractice and
00:42:43.820 physician error are
00:42:44.680 literally the third
00:42:45.660 leading cause of death
00:42:46.680 in America, and no one
00:42:47.860 ever talks about it.
00:42:49.200 Women's health care
00:42:49.740 specifically is horrible.
00:42:51.660 Every woman I know has
00:42:52.520 been dismissed and
00:42:53.300 mistreated by more
00:42:54.120 doctors than those that
00:42:55.040 actually cared.
00:42:56.240 Doctors don't run tests,
00:42:57.240 they don't do research,
00:42:58.080 they don't put care into
00:42:58.900 you, it's a revolving
00:42:59.820 door system, and it's
00:43:01.420 just hopeless.
00:43:02.900 My question for you is,
00:43:04.540 why is everyone on both
00:43:05.780 sides of the aisle
00:43:06.460 focused on the buzzword
00:43:07.700 health care, and yet no
00:43:09.080 one ever mentions the
00:43:09.940 horrible state of the
00:43:10.760 actual medical systems?
00:43:12.240 Why don't we see any
00:43:13.100 conservatives focusing on
00:43:14.240 this, giving it any
00:43:15.040 attention?
00:43:15.980 Is change even possible?
00:43:17.420 I'd love to know your
00:43:18.200 thoughts.
00:43:19.340 Yeah, really good
00:43:19.960 question.
00:43:20.560 It's because it's very,
00:43:22.080 very difficult.
00:43:24.180 And so for the left,
00:43:25.580 they focus really just on
00:43:27.360 medical insurance, or
00:43:28.760 government-backed
00:43:29.620 medical insurance, or
00:43:30.720 ways to strong-arm
00:43:32.380 private medical
00:43:32.980 insurance, and they
00:43:33.640 focus on this because
00:43:35.320 they're trying to expand
00:43:36.100 another welfare program
00:43:37.060 to give themselves more
00:43:38.260 control.
00:43:40.740 Ultimately, I think
00:43:41.560 that's what it is.
00:43:42.140 Some idealists might
00:43:44.060 have more utopian
00:43:44.820 views, but ultimately
00:43:45.640 that's what the brass
00:43:46.440 tax comes down to.
00:43:47.600 And then on the right,
00:43:49.080 they don't really have
00:43:49.860 very good ideas because
00:43:51.200 unfortunately, of all
00:43:52.680 the options on the
00:43:53.420 table, the system that
00:43:54.540 we currently have is
00:43:55.920 better than the
00:43:56.500 alternatives.
00:43:58.000 And obviously, the
00:43:58.520 system we currently have
00:43:59.620 was seriously damaged
00:44:01.020 by Obamacare, and
00:44:02.640 Trump tried to repeal
00:44:03.540 that in the first
00:44:04.500 term, and John
00:44:05.320 McCain stabbed his
00:44:07.140 constituents in the
00:44:07.800 back, basically, and
00:44:08.860 refused to do that.
00:44:11.180 So we're stuck with
00:44:12.460 Obamacare.
00:44:14.000 You know, the medical
00:44:14.660 problems really began
00:44:16.560 under FDR.
00:44:18.600 It was first FDR's fault
00:44:19.940 because he instituted
00:44:20.740 wage caps, but not caps
00:44:22.880 on fringe benefits,
00:44:23.880 which is when you went
00:44:25.040 from very, very few
00:44:26.040 Americans having
00:44:26.740 health care associated
00:44:27.560 with employment to,
00:44:28.940 by 1958, virtually all
00:44:31.040 of them, three-quarters
00:44:31.660 of them.
00:44:34.180 That system then, you
00:44:36.080 know, continued, and
00:44:36.960 then with Obamacare, it
00:44:38.620 was, you know, the
00:44:39.680 perverse incentives to
00:44:41.200 it were further
00:44:41.820 entrenched.
00:44:42.600 And the insurance does
00:44:43.700 affect the quality of
00:44:44.620 care.
00:44:45.800 And the crazy system we
00:44:47.260 have where if you pay
00:44:47.840 with insurance, a
00:44:48.600 procedure costs 30
00:44:49.360 grand.
00:44:49.980 If you pay with cash,
00:44:50.800 it costs two grand.
00:44:51.860 It creates all sorts of
00:44:53.160 bad incentives and
00:44:54.440 compromises the quality
00:44:55.560 of the care.
00:44:55.940 But the conclusion
00:44:56.960 that you should draw
00:44:57.520 from it is that
00:44:58.680 medical care is not
00:45:01.200 this magically
00:45:03.320 different field of
00:45:04.840 human activity from
00:45:05.680 every other one.
00:45:06.540 If you bring
00:45:07.100 contractors into your
00:45:08.060 house to fix a door
00:45:09.200 or to, I don't know,
00:45:10.920 to improve something,
00:45:12.480 you're going to have
00:45:13.420 to manage them.
00:45:14.360 You're going to have
00:45:14.880 to get different bids,
00:45:16.500 different offers, try
00:45:17.380 to figure out who
00:45:18.100 really has expertise,
00:45:19.140 and you're going to
00:45:19.420 have to pick one.
00:45:20.580 When it comes to
00:45:22.340 almost anything, a
00:45:24.100 car mechanic, I
00:45:25.260 don't know, a
00:45:26.320 tailor, anything
00:45:27.600 like that, you are
00:45:29.240 ultimately managing.
00:45:30.200 You're bringing your
00:45:30.760 judgment to bear to
00:45:31.680 figure out who's going
00:45:32.200 to do the best job.
00:45:33.880 That's true in medical
00:45:35.220 care, too.
00:45:36.320 You don't just leave
00:45:37.820 that up to someone
00:45:39.320 else, and you don't
00:45:39.840 leave it up to some
00:45:40.420 faceless insurance
00:45:41.480 company or the
00:45:42.340 government because
00:45:43.860 they're going to do
00:45:45.780 a worse job than
00:45:47.140 just about anybody.
00:45:48.400 Okay.
00:45:49.540 Do we have time for
00:45:50.280 one more mailbag?
00:45:50.800 I want one more
00:45:51.400 mailbag question.
00:45:52.000 Okay.
00:45:54.240 Hi, Michael.
00:45:55.060 I'm going to try to
00:45:55.760 keep this short.
00:45:56.820 I've written mailbag,
00:45:58.340 but never voiced, so
00:45:59.200 I feel awkward, but
00:46:00.080 okay.
00:46:01.240 My question for you
00:46:02.040 is, do you have any
00:46:03.260 recommendations for a
00:46:04.340 confirmation name?
00:46:05.780 I was baptized and
00:46:06.980 received my first
00:46:07.620 communion as a child,
00:46:08.680 but I was never
00:46:09.520 confirmed.
00:46:10.520 For most of my life,
00:46:11.300 I would describe
00:46:11.780 myself as like a
00:46:12.800 sleepy Christian.
00:46:14.400 In 2020, during
00:46:15.540 college, I lost my
00:46:16.920 mother to cancer, and
00:46:17.940 in the years that
00:46:18.520 followed, I drifted
00:46:19.300 even further into the
00:46:20.520 traps and distractions
00:46:21.400 of this world.
00:46:23.700 A few years ago, I
00:46:24.940 found my way back to
00:46:25.740 church through a
00:46:26.500 non-denominational
00:46:27.320 community, thanks in
00:46:28.540 large part to voices
00:46:29.420 and podcasters like
00:46:30.460 yours who helped
00:46:31.800 reignite that spirit
00:46:33.080 of faith in me.
00:46:34.920 Not long after, I
00:46:35.920 reconnected with my
00:46:36.720 now long-term
00:46:37.320 boyfriend, who is
00:46:38.260 Catholic, and he
00:46:38.980 gently led me back to
00:46:39.860 the Catholic church.
00:46:41.360 I am now going
00:46:42.320 through OCIA, and I
00:46:44.300 couldn't be more
00:46:44.720 grateful or excited
00:46:45.600 for this journey.
00:46:46.540 His mother is
00:46:47.500 actually my sponsor,
00:46:48.860 and again, I want
00:46:50.300 to thank voices like
00:46:51.120 yours who kind of
00:46:52.540 reignited this interest
00:46:54.820 in Catholicism.
00:46:56.480 As I approach
00:46:57.360 confirmation, I want
00:46:58.580 to choose a name that
00:46:59.340 reflects my story and
00:47:00.760 symbolizes my path that
00:47:01.960 God has brought me on,
00:47:03.140 and I deeply value your
00:47:04.680 biblical insight.
00:47:05.900 I'm going to love to
00:47:06.540 hear any name
00:47:07.280 recommendations you
00:47:08.080 might have.
00:47:08.920 Thank you for your
00:47:09.680 show.
00:47:09.980 Thank you for what you
00:47:10.580 do.
00:47:11.580 I think you impact so
00:47:13.400 many people around the
00:47:14.640 world, me being one of
00:47:16.300 them.
00:47:16.680 So, thank you.
00:47:17.580 Well, that's a very
00:47:18.340 kind, very, very sweet
00:47:19.440 question, and you and
00:47:21.340 I have fairly similar
00:47:22.360 stories, oddly enough,
00:47:24.320 other than the
00:47:24.800 boyfriend thing.
00:47:25.780 I didn't have one of
00:47:26.640 those, though I did
00:47:27.000 reconnect with my
00:47:27.800 long-term girlfriend,
00:47:29.120 I guess, around that
00:47:30.440 time.
00:47:30.660 So, it's interesting.
00:47:31.540 We have very, very
00:47:32.040 similar stories.
00:47:33.240 The name that comes to
00:47:34.220 mind is Augustine.
00:47:36.320 You know, you were kind
00:47:37.320 of raised, especially the
00:47:38.820 role of the mother.
00:47:39.700 You know, St.
00:47:40.140 Monica played this
00:47:40.900 very, very important
00:47:41.840 role in her son's life,
00:47:42.980 and she was praying for
00:47:43.640 his conversion, and
00:47:44.520 there's a great meme of,
00:47:45.720 you know, it's like, you
00:47:46.800 know, the entire world
00:47:47.780 is basically being held
00:47:49.320 up by the prayers of
00:47:50.360 old women.
00:47:51.860 You know, and we never
00:47:52.960 acknowledge that, but it's
00:47:54.480 substantially true.
00:47:56.460 And Augustine, obviously,
00:47:57.960 you know, went through a
00:47:58.660 period of a bit of
00:47:59.500 rebellious youth, and
00:48:01.180 then came fully into
00:48:03.280 faith and said, you
00:48:04.060 know, oh, how late I
00:48:05.380 found you, how, you
00:48:06.580 know, oh, love ever
00:48:07.560 ancient, ever new.
00:48:08.440 And so, yeah, and you
00:48:12.260 can pick names, you
00:48:12.920 know, women religious
00:48:15.020 and lay women who have
00:48:17.060 confirmation names, they
00:48:17.980 can pick male names all
00:48:18.920 the time.
00:48:19.240 There are plenty of men,
00:48:19.860 especially like royals of
00:48:20.860 Europe, plenty of men with
00:48:22.020 the name Maria is one of
00:48:23.100 their, like, 15 names.
00:48:24.120 So, anyway, Augustine
00:48:25.740 comes to mind.
00:48:26.400 I don't know.
00:48:26.960 It's kind of, you could
00:48:28.080 pronounce it Augustine.
00:48:30.260 It's a more Latinate way,
00:48:31.420 and then it seems more
00:48:32.160 feminine, but that's the
00:48:33.380 one that comes to mind,
00:48:34.040 but, you know, you can't
00:48:34.700 go wrong.
00:48:35.120 Glad to hear it.
00:48:35.540 Okay, today's Fake
00:48:36.220 Headline Friday.
00:48:36.720 The rest of the show
00:48:37.180 continues now.
00:48:37.680 You do not want to miss
00:48:38.360 it.
00:48:38.940 You don't want to miss
00:48:39.540 it, too, because I'm
00:48:40.360 debuting one of my
00:48:41.420 favorite sweaters, and I
00:48:43.500 can't, I need to, I need
00:48:44.920 you to settle a debate
00:48:46.100 between me and the
00:48:46.800 wardrobe room.
00:48:48.260 Become a member now.
00:48:49.040 Use code NOLS,
00:48:49.560 K-N-W-L-E-S at
00:48:50.280 checkout for two months
00:48:50.840 free on all annual
00:48:51.580 plans.
00:49:07.680 And if you're comfortable turn
00:49:19.480 who's fancy.
00:49:21.040 And I'll be like
00:49:22.520 tags from now.
00:49:24.420 Ooh, Judith.
00:49:25.060 I'm going to be like,
00:49:25.560 buckraham,
00:49:26.440 you're leaving us.
00:49:27.700 A-