00:00:00.000so prime minister mark carney ended up blowing up his own bad trade deal last night and now he
00:00:06.720and all of the liberals are pretending that this was a master stroke of policy on his part
00:00:12.800no it was not it was a bad deal three days ago we all knew it was a bad deal do you know who
00:00:19.360didn't realize it was a bad deal apparently until two seconds before the deadline
00:00:24.240prime minister mark carney he was calling it a good deal up until the very last second because
00:00:30.960he's incompetent he's a terrible negotiator he's waited a year and a half giving up a lot of
00:00:36.560concessions for nothing building no new leverage and also not being willing to give up really0.99
00:00:42.800stupid things that would actually potentially get us benefits on the other side and here we are
00:00:47.680still no deal 50 u.s tariffs on five percent more of our exports good job liberals but of course0.99
00:00:55.800there's going to be tons of liberals online and people in the media pretending like mark carney's0.85
00:01:01.000keeping us safe he is the warm embrace that canadians crave he sucks at his job i'm sorry
00:01:09.240wasn't he elected in 2025 because he was going to get us a good deal so far the best he's he can do
00:01:16.600is almost continue to sign really bad deals,
00:01:20.200have us badger him for multiple days straight,
00:01:22.740and then he pulls out at the last minute
00:01:24.340and then gives himself a pat on the back
00:01:26.080because I said I was never going to sign a bad deal.
00:01:28.880It's like, okay, you also had a second half to that promise
00:01:32.640that you were going to get a good deal,
00:01:34.120and we haven't budged an inch since Election Day.
00:01:37.360Actually, no, we've actually gone backwards since Election Day
00:01:40.900in terms of our actual hand that we have to play in negotiations.
00:01:45.760Mark Carney has been burning cards this entire time for nothing and acts like he's somehow being very savvy by being non-committal in terms of a final deal.
00:01:56.200Check out this statement he released about 50 minutes ago or so.
00:01:59.960I thought this was a little bit of a better statement to show than his really long one yesterday because the long one said absolutely nothing in it.
00:02:07.740And at least this is a more condensed version.
00:02:53.020Late last evening, I instructed our negotiators to return to Ottawa.
00:02:56.920We cannot accept what the U.S. has offered, and we will not give what they have asked.
00:03:02.200And we'll match the U.S. new tariffs dollar for dollar in order to protect Canadian workers, farmers, families, and businesses.
00:03:08.340we take the step confident that is the best interest of canadians in the coming days we
00:03:13.060will release details of these new tariffs measures which will come into force tuesday after labor day
00:03:17.960um like honestly i don't even know why he doesn't just implement them now that's always the
00:03:23.140confusing thing do you want to be aggressive or do you not want to be aggressive because as much
00:03:27.620as i make fun of the elbows up trade strategy it could work if you stick to it but carney doesn't
00:03:35.620he's all over the place. He's about to sign crappy deals, being overly permissive about
00:03:41.740certain things, and then he pulls back at the last second, and then he makes a threat,
00:03:46.360and then he concedes on something in favor of nothing. It's like, can we stick to one strategy
00:03:51.600here? Because we're being really, really confusing. And I know there's going to be so many people out
00:03:56.460there saying, well, why aren't you blaming the Americans? I do partly blame the Americans in1.00
00:04:01.060the sense that they started this. I don't like it. Yes, we've had dairy and poultry and other0.95
00:04:05.880sort of supply management tariffs on them for decades. I don't like that. We also have other
00:04:10.300regulatory restrictions that block certain U.S. and other non-Canadian goods from entering our
00:04:15.640market. That's not good. I also don't think exactly justified what the U.S. did. Yes,
00:04:21.800they pay for our security and we've been lagging when it comes to our NATO commitments.
00:04:25.720I get it. Still a stupid thing to tariff us.0.99
00:04:28.960But I blame our government because I'm a Canadian.0.99
00:04:33.020And at the end of the day, although I am patriotic, the thing is I blame the person that is supposed to be serving us.
00:04:39.720Trump's not supposed to be serving us.
00:04:41.820So when I see Mark Carney constantly blaming the Americans for everything going on,
00:04:46.600While not one person in the liberal media or in liberal political circles is investigating the fact that Mark Carney promised he was going to get a good deal and has not been looking into what's been actually going on here, it is maddening.0.98
00:05:00.300He sucks, and that is why we are losing.0.96
00:05:02.860It's like the other team in a sport pulled a dirty move on your team.1.00
00:05:08.880It's like a hockey game, and they've been just making some really dirty plays the entire time, and you lost.
00:05:14.900And it's like, OK, I didn't like that. We also lost 4-0, and those dirty plays didn't exactly result in why we lost. We lost because we suck. Yeah, I don't like the way they play the sport, but goodness, can we also not suck at the sport? Like, that's what I'm asking here.
00:05:32.180I want to move on to some clips of Carney speaking at the press conference just a little bit ago.
00:05:37.920I want to actually start off, which one should we start off with?
00:05:41.440Let's talk about him doing the dollar for dollar tariff trading thing.
00:05:45.320And I want to move into his explanation for why he pulled out at the last second of this deal.
00:05:51.060Now, Canada will match Washington's new tariffs dollar for dollar in order to protect Canadian workers, farmers, families and businesses.
00:06:02.180Our response will be concentrated in sectors such as steel, dairy, appliances, agricultural
00:06:09.180equipment, pulp and paper, and electronics.
00:06:12.920Also include products that are currently subject to unjustified Section 232 and 338 tariffs.
00:06:21.920This is a focused response, a focused response to protect and defend our industries and allow
00:06:27.760them to compete with us products in the canadian market this is why i say if you're gonna go
00:06:34.140aggressive go aggressive in the sense that if the thing is that america can handle the counter
00:06:40.840tariffs better than we can handle their tariffs so why aren't we saying no what we're going to
00:06:46.380get even more leverage and go super aggressive we're going to put in place tariffs that are 100
00:06:50.480tariffs in response now that wouldn't be my strategy i'd probably have taken a different
00:06:55.100strategy a year and a half ago. But now, why are we just basically slowly ramping up the temperature
00:07:02.260to where they ramp it up to? Why not do something more? And that's kind of my problem with Mark
00:07:06.800Carney. He's never taking like some audacious play. Nothing he's doing is smart. And now I'm
00:07:12.960just thinking about it. Why was he in Italy during the negotiations for this deal? I thought we
00:07:20.480elected him because he's a great negotiator who has dealt with donald trump before why were you
00:07:26.140messing around in italy rather than being in the room having the commander in the room leading his
00:07:34.000troops figuring out what we're willing to give up to get to a better deal and when you actually0.96
00:07:39.160listen to what ended up breaking the deal what caused us to walk away it's kind of pathetic it's
00:07:45.240a bit of a longer video here thank you for sit comedia for uh clipping it sit comedia here if
00:07:50.600you guys want to go find them on x they uh posted his uh him answering the question from a reporter
00:07:57.280because obviously he never brought up the entire time of what actually caused the deal to fall
00:08:01.400apart listened closely to what he brings up because he brings up some stuff about autos
00:08:06.360that doesn't sound good but the problem is the even with this change not made the auto part of
00:08:12.960the deal still sucked. We were going to keep in place 15% auto tariffs on most of our auto
00:08:19.940manufacturing. That's stupid. But listen to the other excuses he bakes into this response.1.00
00:08:26.180I'm hoping you can tell us what the specific last minute changes that the Americans proposed
00:08:29.920that made a deal in Tenable. Thank you. Thank you for the question. Look, I would say two things.
00:08:35.860One is there are some specifics and I'll give you some examples, but it was also a cumulative
00:08:40.060aspect as i mentioned in my remarks uh about the by the way that's nonsense when he says it's a
00:08:45.300cumulative no it's not it's not cumulative over time because up until the last second he and his
00:08:51.780people were marketing this as a good deal we're going to get to a vashi capellos clip a little
00:08:55.560bit later where she right after this all happened said well it was surprising because the canadian
00:09:00.640negotiators and our spokespeople that were running around saying this was a really good deal and that
00:09:05.180we were happy to sign it and then he suddenly killed it i'm sorry was the thing that was last
00:09:09.920minute that killed the deal literally in the last minute i don't think so i think he just realized0.54
00:09:14.820the canadian public wasn't going to buy this garbage and then he pulled back from it now i'm
00:09:19.340a conservative in the sense that i want to deal but i don't want to deal at all costs but the0.93
00:09:24.820thing is i'm also not going to applaud him for not signing the deal because it's his fault in part
00:09:30.380that the deals keep being bad and we have to keep pulling back from them.
00:09:36.360Willingness, Donald Trump in total, to enter into a true economic partnership.
00:09:44.660But in terms of specifics, I'll give you three, and I know there's other questions.
00:09:48.380First, with respect to the auto industry, both in terms of the level of the tariffs,
00:09:55.140the treatment of Canadian content, so Canadian parts, Canadian steel, Canadian content in vehicles,
00:10:03.660the scope of the tariffs, Americans wanted to limit it to autos only,
00:10:09.760not include medium and heavy autos and light trucks, to be more specific,
00:10:13.180not include medium and heavy-duty trucks, which is a big change, obviously,
00:10:17.260and with respect to Ford's new plan, for example, in Oakville, which is F-350s, 450s, 550s.
00:10:24.400would have been excluded uh gm silverado uh uh same thing would have been uh excluded from that
00:10:31.440so what this tells me is like one i don't believe him this happened absolutely last minute because
00:10:36.800from him answering later on it sounds like there was just a clarification and they're saying no
00:10:41.360when we said it was going to be 15 tariffs on all autos it's going to be 15 tariffs on all autos
00:10:47.040he's saying well before it sounded like what it was going to be was that we were going to have
00:10:52.720you know heavy medium and heavy duty trucks were not going to be included which i guess he's
00:10:59.120thinking well that's okay because then we could just pivot our market towards only building those
00:11:02.960things it would still not be a good deal because think of all the people who don't build those
00:11:07.280things that would be going out of business or would be basically having to sell a lot of these
00:11:12.080cars at like a very thin profit margin or a loss so they can clear out the models that they are
00:11:17.520currently contracted to build and then they would have to move only to medium and heavy autos
00:11:22.640like maybe that would make it a little bit better but the 25 steel and aluminum tariffs were still
00:11:27.860terrible apparently we were going to have softwood lumber tariffs included on this and there was a
00:11:32.500bunch of other stuff that was going to be included including the u.s being able to trade into canada
00:11:37.260tariff free while they made tariffs on us so i don't believe him when he says that this is somehow
00:11:43.420the straw that broke the camel's back the next thing he's going to list as being a problem are0.97
00:11:49.020like really dumb so that first auto thing was half dumb okay maybe you could if let's say this0.98
00:11:55.600deal was only about the auto thing and we were giving up a couple things in favor of the autos0.99
00:12:00.760maybe you could say that was justified okay 15 on the smaller cars and whatnot but maybe our
00:12:07.960market will just shift towards the medium and heavies and then later on down the road maybe
00:12:11.740we can figure out how to get the 15 removed on the smaller cars okay i could maybe see the logic
00:12:17.340there but that doesn't make the deal good the deal still overall sucks and you shouldn't sign it
00:12:22.620no rationale just for exclusion um so effectively moving into a series of terms that would have
00:12:30.860would made uh the production more uneconomic over time okay so that's that's that's a change
00:12:38.780that restriction that clarification that precision um was was a change uh the u.s introduced and by
00:12:45.740the way again he just said there that that precision that clarification uh that was a big
00:12:50.620change so it wasn't actually a change he was probably just pretend he might have even absolutely
00:12:56.620knew what the terms were but he's just pretending to be dumb here after the fact and be like oh i0.87
00:13:01.180thought it wasn't going to include uh medium and heavy trucks uh but it does oh that sucks i guess
00:13:06.940we can't sign it it sounds like he knew it because all he's not saying that this was last minute
00:13:10.460change he says oh it was a last minute precision so you probably knew it and you're just pretending
00:13:15.660to not know it and then at the last minute you're like oh does this also include heavy trucks and
00:13:19.980they're like yeah and then you said like oh i can't sign this it sucks i'm like yeah it's
00:13:24.540obvious it sucks it sucked three days ago and if i was part of the negotiating team even before that0.90
00:13:30.060i would have known that whatever their preliminary plans were also sucked it's not because i'm a0.91
00:13:34.140genius just because i'm not an idiot but now here are the other two things he mentions as being the
00:13:39.340deal breakers at the last uh hours in the last hours um efforts to restrict our ability to have
00:13:45.900other trade deals you heard me say a moment ago what we've accomplished in the last year 20 new
00:13:51.820deals economic and security partnership the prospect of doubling our market access because
00:13:57.420we believe in free trade uh we're the partner of choice in many respects for countries around the
00:14:02.540world and the americans wanted to restrict that they had language that they wanted to restrict
00:14:06.140unacceptable that's very vague again there was language that would restrict that the idea that
00:14:12.220we couldn't maybe go around signing free trade deals and i've even seen some conservative people
00:14:16.940thinking oh that's insane if america's just restricting our ability to sign free trade deals
00:14:22.140depends on what he means by that because frankly based on all of the commentary i've heard from
00:14:27.820the americans over time and again i'm not trying to say it's actually a good stipulation i like it
00:14:32.540I'm just saying that there could be reasonable things that they asked for inside this terrible deal that I would have never signed.
00:14:38.380I think that what he's indicating is the Americans were asking for us to basically stop our plans of integrating more with China, because that has been the thing they've always brought up more than anything else.
00:14:50.800They don't really like our integration with China. It's a national security threat to the U.S.
00:14:55.180mark carney said they were our biggest national security threat in 2025 and that has always been
00:15:00.280something that the americans have frequently brought up as an irritant to them and somehow0.90
00:15:05.220that's like a thing we're going to fight tooth and nail for that's what makes it so silly carney
00:15:10.240was about to sign a deal for things i'm like oh my goodness don't give that up or don't accept
00:15:14.920those tariff rates they're way too high still but so but he was going to sign it apparently that was
00:15:20.260fine for him but the things that he'll fight tooth and nail for are the china deal and as
00:15:25.780we're going to get to in a second here bill c11 and bill c18 uh and i'll give you a third
00:15:36.820continual efforts always resisted as i said in my remarks and always will be resisted
00:15:41.540efforts to restrict our protections of our language our culture and in effect our sovereignty
00:15:50.780so elements coming in ramping up any of them individually but collectively uh put us in a
00:15:59.000position where uh what had been on a trajectory absent those elements for a fair deal a good deal
00:16:07.800for Canadians, not perfect, but a good deal. That's where I think people need to focus on
00:16:14.080that last part. One, going back to what he said is the third point, and then the collective
00:16:18.140point he made at the end. The third point was, oh, our language and our sovereignty and our
00:16:24.520culture. He's talking about Bill C-11 and Bill C-18. The government basically forcing bad quality
00:16:31.260government-funded Canadian content onto streaming services. Bill C-18, the online news act that
00:16:36.940makes it. So I still can access my own Facebook page that I put thousands and thousands of dollars
00:16:42.500into over time back when I used to write articles for the National Telegraph and I didn't make
00:16:48.280videos. Because back in the day, it was actually very easy to write articles and distribute them
00:16:52.880on Facebook. But the Trudeau government, and this is a policy that Carnia stood by, tried to basically
00:16:58.620extort Facebook saying, pay the CBC and CTV News and the other legacy outlets $50 million a year
00:17:05.380or whatever the amount of money was going to be.
00:17:07.380I think I've always heard that that was going to be about the figure.
00:17:10.320You had to pay them that extortion money
00:17:12.080or you're not allowed to host news content on your platform in Canada
00:17:25.960one, he apparently didn't understand the auto part of the very...
00:17:29.700He didn't understand the very clear deal on autos within the bad deal.
00:17:35.380The second one was China, it sounds like, and the third one was we were going to be forced to get rid of Bill C-11, Bill C-18, which I believe most Canadians would dance on the grave of if we got rid of it.
00:17:48.180That would have been actually one of the really good things out of the deal, but that's the funny thing.0.54
00:17:52.620Two out of the three things that were deemed bad, that killed the deal, two of them are things that I would love to get rid of regardless.0.99
00:18:01.340I don't want to integrate more with China. Why are we letting them dump EVs into our economy that they stole the designs to make and they didn't have to incur any of the R&D costs? That's actual unfair trade. They steal your R&D, they build copycat products with a little bit of some changes here and there, and then they sell the cheap products sans the R&D costs into your country, and obviously you can't compete because your businesses actually had to go through the research and development for their new products and whatnot.1.00
00:18:30.760and the Chinese firms don't but anyways now I want to go into some of the takes the takes if I0.98
00:18:38.140can say have been ridiculous the the takes are just I don't even know how to describe this stuff
00:18:46.120I'm trying to find this one oh did it disappear I hope it didn't but there's there's all these
00:18:51.580people like trying to slap Carney on the back and act like he just made a master stroke of a
00:18:58.120decision by pulling out of this when he was the one who thought it was a good deal in the first
00:19:02.660place while we were all screaming at him that it was a bad deal. I've been doing that the past few
00:19:06.800days. This is a stupid deal he was going to sign. He was basically getting pushed into it because1.00
00:19:11.660he thought he needed a deal, I guess, until he realized, maybe the premiers told him, maybe he
00:19:17.040saw the people's reaction online that it was bad, and then he finally pulled out. But look at this
00:19:21.420person. Stella Starfish says, at this point, I'd like to remind everyone that if you blame Carney
00:19:27.960and his team for getting no deal, you are traitors to Canada. You want the U.S. to destroy our great
00:19:33.860country and rule over Canada. Remember that one of the stipulations was that they wanted to set
00:19:39.020Canada's trade policy. That wasn't a stipulation. That was a vague insinuation that Mark Carney
00:19:45.580made based on the language of the deal, which I believe probably indicates that they had a
00:19:50.200problem with our China deal, and they wanted us to rip it up, and that apparently is something that
00:19:54.580we're going to pull out of this bad deal over. Again, there was already good reasons to pull
00:19:59.080out of the deal. That's a stupid reason to pull out of the deal. I want to then jump over to what1.00
00:20:05.080Pierre Polyev said in response to all this. I thought his response was pretty good. Now,
00:20:09.680a lot of people are saying, like, oh, well, why is he not attacking Carney? It's a hard land to
00:20:15.920attack Carney. I can do it here because I'm a random YouTuber who can just kind of start
00:20:20.100sounding off right away. In any party, Daniel Smith made a very diplomatic post. Pure Poly have
00:20:25.640made a very diplomatic post. I think they're perfectly fine. I think that they're going to
00:20:30.540have to develop their way of pushing back on Carney and how he's, you know, completely ruined
00:20:35.420our negotiating stance over time. But for now, this is probably fine. Polyef says conservatives
00:20:41.380are disappointed that the United States has chosen to impose further and justify tariffs on Canada.
00:20:45.920They threaten the jobs and livelihoods of families right across our country.
00:20:49.840Canada must stand united to defend our country against these unfair attacks on our jobs and businesses.
00:20:54.760Canada cannot accept one-sided tariffs that will de-industrialize our country,
00:20:59.060which that is an insinuation that the deal that Carney at one point was calling good was bad.
00:21:03.920It would have de-industrialized us absolutely.
00:21:06.500Then he goes on to say, nor couldn't we accept a bad deal.
00:21:09.400Instead, we must continue to fight for tariff-free trade.
00:21:12.340Later today, I will seek a call of the Prime Minister to discuss what we can do to fight for our workers, businesses, and economy.
00:21:19.180Conservatives will always put our country first.
00:21:21.460Conservatives support actions to protect Canadians and our industries targeted by these unfair U.S. tariffs.
00:21:25.840We also need urgent economic reforms to restore growth, protect jobs, and save our industry.
00:21:31.120That must include ending the industrialized carbon tax, repealing anti-development laws,
00:21:35.760greenlighting the 500 economic projects waiting federal approval,
00:21:38.740and major tax reforms to return investment to our country, reward work, and recharge our economy.