The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - October 01, 2026


The Secret to Great Storytelling | Interview with Chris Dangerfield

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters #1517 The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters #1519

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 26 minutes

Words per minute

172.18

Word count

14,852

Sentence count

—

Harmful content

Toxicity

37

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to this very special interview where I should we should be talking all about
00:00:04 storytelling about the art of storytelling the past the present and even the future of
00:00:09 storytelling and I'm joined by a very special guest a great storyteller in and of his own right
00:00:14 one Mr Chris Dangerfield Sir Christopher of House Dangerfield how are you sir
00:00:18 Christopher of the House Dangerfield I've I had some really good news last night which is going to
00:00:25 my literary career is likely to explode off of the back of it i had to go for an hour walk
00:00:32 in the middle of the night yeah to just a shake of the adrenaline out brilliant so i'm very happy
00:00:39 but i'm also very tired i've always written at night you know everything quiets down i'm not
00:00:47 being assled on social media this this phone this phone that computer whatsapp facebook you know it
00:00:53 works it's all just nice and quiet the missus finishes doing the house and cooking and she's
00:00:58 gone to bed and I just write I've always done that but I've now reached I'm starting to reach
00:01:05 it's the law of diminishing returns I'll be up all night but I'm tired and I'm not getting a lot
00:01:11 written and then I'm sleeping most of the day whereas I used to get up in about midday
00:01:17 and uh and you know have a day and then right and i've decided to change that and so last night i
00:01:26 was meant to go to bed at midnight you see that was the plan start a new life at my ripe old age
00:01:32 and uh i couldn't because i was full of adrenaline and excited and like a child which is a nice way
00:01:39 to be when you're not a child yeah yeah no great i am stoked for you i'm jealous in the best
00:01:45 possible way that you are now published because i've i hope to be published one day i've had
00:01:51 pretensions of that pretty much my whole life so first of all let's talk about your book before
00:01:56 we start talking about storytelling on sort of a conceptual level and all sorts of other things
00:02:00 about social media and that stuff first of all tell us about tell us about your book oh there's
00:02:06 more than one you know i'd like if i can rub the jealousy in a bit i i was first published when i
00:02:12 was 23 done a load of guerrilla marketing some really interesting stuff i'm writing an article
00:02:19 on my sub stack about that soon for self-published authors because it was stocked in waterstones
00:02:26 brick and mortar stores across the country first novel i ever wrote i wrote it in three weeks i've
00:02:31 got the original handwritten draft in a suitcase in the bedroom there but um there's about in those
00:02:39 days there probably still is but there's about five or six waterstones just in the Charing Cross
00:02:44 area there's one in Trafalgar Square there's a few on the actual Charing Cross I think one on
00:02:49 Tottenham Court Road which is the same as Charing Cross Road one down on Oxford Street and if I had
00:02:54 a date with a young lady and I did have dates with young ladies in those when I was that young
00:03:01 I'd go around all the shops and take the book out of the shelf so instead of it being spying on it
00:03:09 would be faced on and then as the day started oh should we go and get a cup of tea i'd say yeah
00:03:14 i've just got to buy a book and i would go to all the waterstones and i just need to go to the
00:03:20 literary fiction section and uh she'd be like oh and it's not you oh that's back in print
00:03:28 if you can't show off chris the whole point of achieving anything in life ever is to show off
00:03:37 for a woman isn't it that's the that's the point of achieving things isn't it
00:03:41 if it you know i love writing i've always written if there were no women i wouldn't
00:03:48 you know not not just on a superficial should we say sensual level but there's no there's no
00:04:01 reason in life if you take women away there's no reason so yeah for sure so I really showed off and
00:04:08 it worked well you know five or six shots and it's there faced on and I had a real treat once I mean
00:04:14 I've done this many times someone actually bought it while me and my date were there and inside I'm
00:04:23 just hallelujah but I had to sort of go I was like well you know that's why they stop it because
00:04:31 people buy it and sort of turn around so that was at 23 um i've never stopped writing but i set up
00:04:39 a business you you know you've got to earn money it's very hard to earn a living selling books it
00:04:45 really is even if you're what people call successful you know you've got to really be
00:04:50 successful to make a half decent living selling books um and it and that sort of took over i never
00:04:58 stop writing but the effort required to self-publish and we'll get on to why I don't go
00:05:06 through publishing houses that'll be part of when I talk about storytelling and its cultural values
00:05:12 and its historical functions and things like that but last year I mean I've been working on a novel
00:05:20 for 10 years and that's not out of laziness it's out of running the business living a life
00:05:27 and having to write but it's also nearly at the moment i'm on the last draft it's connected to
00:05:34 the good news i had by the way that that's why it's important to me 10 years of work and
00:05:40 but it's structurally very complex not necessarily for the reader but in writing it it's it's been a
00:05:49 very very tricky right but last year i there's there's about 50 short stories on my sub stack
00:05:57 and one of them was about a couple of uh 14 year old no 12 year olds just a boy and a girl sitting
00:06:04 in a shed and you know most of my sub stack isn't about nice innocent sort of things like that and
00:06:11 it really went down well and then I wrote one about a 10 year old boy that wasn't innocent it's
00:06:17 quite a brutal unpleasant story and that went down really well and so I've written a few other
00:06:24 stories and i thought i was thinking right i need to get you know i try and get two shorts out a
00:06:28 month on substack i thought i never do by the way um even though there's a paid tier where they're
00:06:34 you know they're promised that and two audio versions of it but i think people understand
00:06:39 that they're not going to ever get what i promise um it's part of my brand
00:06:45 quite a fortunate part my brain um and I started writing from a 14 year old's point of view I
00:06:56 thought imagine you're 14 you know right just just sit you know I don't I never plan my books
00:07:02 in writing they call them planners and pantsers you either plan your novel all your characters
00:07:09 your story arc your hero's journey you know it's like giving a newborn baby a biopsy it's not for
00:07:15 me i sit and write and i always i only write autobiographically which makes it easier because
00:07:22 well i say it makes it easier makes it it can make it more complicated because in the first
00:07:27 memory yeah i write about myself that's that's what i do but memory language and recall and
00:07:36 writing put those four philosophical thunderbolts in the same bowl and that's why the last novel's
00:07:44 taken 10 years and it's still not finished but that story of a 14 year old i just didn't stop
00:07:51 and i thought hang on these are these these little visionettes they're like uh diary entries i could
00:07:57 like well not a diary because the diary is more daily isn't it like journal entries slightly
00:08:02 americanized but more like a journal entry and that's that's what that became so i can
00:08:08 there you go let's get that bad boy in focus there we go available in all good bookstores
00:08:13 well on the internet it absolutely is and libraries of course and of course amazon amazon's
00:08:19 good because you get all the author endorsements and you get all the reviews and it's done really
00:08:25 well it totally exceeded my expectations and has also luck in a beautiful way sort of set the
00:08:32 ground uh we're going back to branding for this next big novel which is about at the moment final
00:08:39 draft stage about 800 pages oof that's a tone yeah it yeah it's it's uh it's interesting actually
00:08:50 you know codex the codex it comes from the latin codex i think it comes from the latin code
00:09:00 or something that's that it actually means a block of wood or part of a tree and and and and
00:09:11 the word came about from originally the written word which is which had already gone through you
00:09:19 You know, Socrates considered writing a dangerous supplement to speech.
00:09:26 You know, interestingly, I think we talked about this before briefly,
00:09:31 his star pupil Plato had to write down Socrates' teachings.
00:09:37 Otherwise, unless they were passed on through oral tradition.
00:09:40 Yeah, the Socratic dialogues weren't written by Socrates.
00:09:45 Yeah, he didn't believe in it.
00:09:46 800 pages, though.
00:09:47 God, that is long.
00:09:48 Are you happy with it?
00:09:49 I think it's the best piece of literature ever written.
00:09:54 And is it in the first person?
00:09:56 Can we just stick on what I just said?
00:09:59 Because I'm not lying or joking.
00:10:02 And there's a reason for that.
00:10:03 Because why would I write it if I didn't think it was amazing?
00:10:09 Well, fair enough.
00:10:10 Yeah, that's how I feel about when I write.
00:10:12 Yeah, I wouldn't let people see it unless I was happy with it.
00:10:15 Yeah, I absolutely feel that way.
00:10:16 It's interesting, though.
00:10:17 A number of things you've said there I'd like to bounce off.
00:10:19 loads of different interesting things you've said there because I write as well I've written
00:10:23 quite a lot of articles published in a number of different places I've tried writing novels
00:10:28 my whole life I've finished three arguably four and loads and loads of short stories
00:10:33 never got anything published properly because I never thought it was really worth trying to
00:10:38 get a literary agent and trying to get it published because it's not good enough it's
00:10:42 not quality enough yet however I've been working on one novel for well over 10 years and I'm
00:10:47 hopefully going to finish it in the next realistically the next year or maybe two don't
00:10:52 know but I'm working on it for a long long long time polishing it like a like an oil painting
00:10:57 it's just more and more and more detail I put so when you talk about you're not a planner
00:11:01 I really am I have to plan I have to have a beginning a middle and an end if my end isn't
00:11:07 perfectly realized I can't be writing characters and dialogue and stuff I can't be doing I'm a
00:11:12 i'm a planner's planner i might everything must be planned out and then a bit like uh an oil
00:11:17 painting as well there's endless fine detail you could it's never ended and i and that's
00:11:22 unfortunately how i write so it's like uh it's like a heavy weight on me it's why i'm not that
00:11:27 prolific because i go back to it and i i i obsess over every word choice every every word decision
00:11:36 every sentence no that doesn't work right and i've used that adjective too many times already
00:11:39 and that doesn't and I just so I think maybe we're very very different in style I'm really
00:11:45 not a stream of consciousness when it comes to writing fiction prose it's not stream of
00:11:50 consciousness everything is wrung out of me it's like it's like um it is a chore it's work because
00:11:56 it for me it needs to be it needs to be perfect if it's not if it's not very very very good I
00:12:02 don't want anyone to see it that's I guess we're very different like that right not that yours
00:12:08 isn't perfect sorry just to be clear i'm not saying yours isn't perfect i'm not saying that
00:12:11 sorry i'm just saying it doesn't flow out of me you're starting to say that you sit down for a
00:12:16 day and it starts to flow out of you mine has to be wrung out like it's uh i don't know i wish i
00:12:23 was more like i could just more just let it go just just write and just write but i just can't
00:12:28 i guess i'm not i don't know you talk to me about your process that it's interesting because all
00:12:34 writing is stream of consciousness you know if you actually define that you sit down and you
00:12:41 put words and sentences and paragraphs together there's there's no do you understand what i'm
00:12:47 saying there's no there's no this idea of there was in or in the mid-60s people started writing
00:12:53 stream of consciousness jack kararak no they they they just thought it that it might read in a the
00:13:00 narrative structure is slightly different but they thought about every word and every sentence
00:13:06 for sure there's no there's no other way of getting words from here onto the page like do
00:13:12 you go back as being a do you go back oh yeah yeah do you go back and rewrite your stuff over
00:13:19 and over and over and over again right okay yes okay right now this is this is this this is what
00:13:25 I wanted to pick up on what you were just talking about.
00:13:28 You said you haven't published anything properly.
00:13:33 And what I think you mean by that is you haven't had anything traditionally published.
00:13:38 And you're refining and refining and trying to make it perfect.
00:13:44 Now, I think traditional publishing has devastated literature.
00:13:51 It absolutely devastated.
00:13:53 I mean, give me the classics of the last 30 years.
00:13:57 Oh, I don't know. 0.97
00:13:58 Some shit by Dan Brown, something by J.K. Rowling. 0.99
00:14:01 God only knows. 1.00
00:14:02 The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas.
00:14:03 I mean...
00:14:03 I don't know.
00:14:04 You tell me.
00:14:07 There aren't any.
00:14:08 Infinite Jess, perhaps.
00:14:09 David Closter Wallace, that's one.
00:14:11 Now, if you go back to 1970 and I asked you for the classics of the previous 50 years,
00:14:17 you can just trot them out.
00:14:19 now when when you say properly look at the amount of gatekeeping that book is then going to have to
00:14:25 go through you can't you can't go to a publisher now well you can go to very small publishers
00:14:30 but they're not going to help you they're going to want you to have already done the work and
00:14:34 have a big social media presence a footprint and all of that sort of thing which you have
00:14:39 but they're going to earn off of your the work you've done building up that uh that cultural
00:14:46 footprint but so you're gonna have to go for an agent and then and i if an agent gets you a
00:14:52 publisher that publisher's then going to get you a line editor a copy editor a developmental editor
00:14:59 in my i see that then as a collaboration and the idea of all those crazy editors i mean a
00:15:08 proofreader is different a proofreader is correcting mistakes you've made they're making
00:15:13 write things you intended to write so if the puncture right you you put a single quote instead
00:15:19 of a double quote for some dialogue or whatever that's what a proofreader does but all those other
00:15:25 editors they are make they are they are kicking your manuscript into shape to make it more likely
00:15:34 to sell they've got very little interest if any in literature in your story in the way you want 0.68
00:15:42 to tell it that and i understand that i'm not an idiot it's a business but the big five
00:15:48 your random houses uh penguin etc who own most of the other ones people think that like hatchet
00:15:55 and all that uh well hatchet's one big five i guess but it's a multi-user a multi-writer
00:16:05 a collaboration and that worries me yeah that worries me yeah i don't want this is where
00:16:10 well if you tried publish you're gonna get that yeah now jk rowling she doesn't have to
00:16:17 they tell her she tells them what's happening because she's gonna sell millions of books
00:16:23 that's gonna happen do you know what it makes me think of chris sorry sorry to interrupt you know
00:16:27 what it makes me think of where i have tried to get a literary agent in the past they're like wait
00:16:32 you're a younger white back then I was younger you're a younger white dude you're talking about
00:16:35 base things you're talking about historical fiction where the white man wins and stuff like
00:16:39 that yeah no thanks pass not in a million years not even close barely even let one line letters
00:16:44 saying no thank you do you know what it reminds me of where you're talking about all those different
00:16:47 editors well there's a film called Reds and a really early 80s film called Reds with Warren
00:16:54 Beattie and it's about the American playwright and journalist John Reed who was one of those
00:17:01 guys that was actually an american that was the 1917 russian revolution and wrote about it he was
00:17:07 friends with um a number of other famous famous writers at the time anyway there's a just there's
00:17:13 one bit in that film where he's a journalist and he sends in his copy and the editors or the editor
00:17:20 and other people have twiddled around and fiddled around with what he's written and he just says
00:17:26 now you don't write you don't rewrite what i write now you don't do it otherwise it's all
00:17:31 over forget it i'm not doing anything now you don't rewrite what i write that's it end of story
00:17:35 not one word that's how i feel about my writing that's how i feel about my writing no no i put
00:17:42 blood sweat and tears into that and now if i've let you see it and let you read it it is perfect
00:17:47 no you're not changing it and so and so probably i probably won't get all that far with one of the
00:17:53 big publishing houses because no you're not going to rewrite it you can take it or leave it you're
00:17:57 probably going to leave it but take it or leave it that's what I wrote that's it I mean am I mad
00:18:02 you you tell that to an agent not even the publisher tell that to an agent and they'll
00:18:09 just say yeah shut the door on the way out and don't come back yeah probably but that's why I
00:18:17 self-publish but I don't self-publish I'm published by Ugly Mink Ugly Mink is a publishing
00:18:22 it's an imprint of ugly mink i just so happen to own ugly mink well okay yeah it's a nice way of
00:18:31 doing it but i mean look at this you're looking at about uh after uh production costs about 70
00:18:38 60 something like that royalty if you self-publish on amazon you you go traditional publishing with
00:18:48 With the cultural footprint you've spent years building from your History Bro channel, from the lower seat, from other things you've done, it's about 7.5% of the after-production cost royalty.
00:19:01 so let's say the book is let's say it's a tenner um production costs probably about five because
00:19:09 i've got to pay that line editor copy editor proofreader developmental editor uh a publicist
00:19:14 marketing team uh dinners with all their friends who work at the guardian the telegraph for all
00:19:20 the reviews and all the all the nepotism that exists in that hideous industry and so the
00:19:25 production cost of your book you're now looking at seven percent of about three quid so 21 pence
00:19:32 per book sale you want to make a living i'm a full-time professional writer i can't
00:19:39 i can't make 21p a book
00:19:41 yeah no it's one of those things only the very but it's actually the same in most walks of life
00:19:49 only the very very very top of the of the pile make big bucks and become extremely wealthy like
00:19:57 stephen king or jk rowling of course it's obvious to say it's only a tiny tiny 0.991 percent of
00:20:03 writers end up super wealthy isn't it of course of course yes but you can earn a living you just
00:20:10 don't see it as a one book project i mean i've got a five-year plan a five-year seven book plan
00:20:17 that would be five novels and two books of shorts at least as a full-time writer someone who wakes
00:20:24 up and writes non-negotiable six seven hours a day it's strange to say non-negotiable and then
00:20:30 say six or seven it sort of is negotiable but after six hours um i need to be getting a novel
00:20:37 out a year so so loving the time and newly mags was released last year the one i've been working
00:20:44 on for 10 years will be out hopefully late November I mean I want to get it before Christmas
00:20:51 for obvious reasons but it's not going to sell well because like it's 800 pages it will cost
00:20:58 about 25 pound because you pay you've got to pay for those 800 pages and the ink and the printing
00:21:04 and the paper um but I've got another novel ready for after that about my business how I set up my
00:21:12 business on no money and it became the biggest in its niche in England and America and I was a
00:21:19 using heroin addict when I set that business up but I've left that business I've left it now
00:21:25 that's why I am a full-time right that's why this has to work because I have no income otherwise
00:21:30 I put that pressure on me because I know that I you know me and the missus are not going to eat
00:21:36 if it doesn't work I'm happy with that because I think I'm a very good writer and you have to
00:21:42 be you know you wouldn't do when I say that to people they get a bit shitty about it excuse the
00:21:48 language but are you good are you good at doing what you do yeah of course you are that's why you
00:21:54 do it and people like it watch it but when you say it about something like sort of writing or
00:21:59 painting people get funny about it and who do you think you are well I'm just a writer I'm just a
00:22:06 storyteller and we're a storytelling culture we can branch into that if you want well you know
00:22:12 when when we bump into someone this is why all the gatekeeping upsets me the gatekeeping of the
00:22:19 agent before the publisher and then the publisher and the developmental editor the line editor the
00:22:24 copy editor all that and the political stuff i mean i used to have agents years ago and i wrote
00:22:30 i used to write treatments and and screenplays for miramax and the like um never never got any
00:22:37 made but i did see the film three years later written by someone else i did see things i'd
00:22:44 written get made you know that there's all that to deal with as well when you're giving people
00:22:50 ideas now we don't want that well sometimes what they mean is that's a great idea i know the perfect
00:22:57 friend of mine to yeah manifest that into the world so so all that gatekeeping when i was on
00:23:06 my undergraduate degree I had a tutor arrive in my second year who was an actual mentor
00:23:13 I worshipped him I he taught me the importance of art he taught me how important it was
00:23:23 to know about it you know if you want to be an artist because then I wanted to be an artist
00:23:28 even though my final piece of work on that degree was a written work um
00:23:32 but he he took me from someone who thought you sort of just done something because you liked it
00:23:39 into the the social function and historical realities of art and he said to me once he said
00:23:48 why why do you make art and I didn't have an answer and we we talked about it and in the end
00:23:54 He said to me, look, if people aren't making art, independent individuals with no ideological pressure on them,
00:24:07 in the future, our history will be dominated by big money, big power and marketing.
00:24:17 And that our visual history, because it was an art school, you know, we'll look back at things.
00:24:23 i mean andy warhol is an amazing example of that and that's why i always argue about
00:24:30 warhol is a fantastic artist because he he's he got he got students to screen print
00:24:39 cans of campbell's soup and people are like that's not art well we can do we can talk about what art
00:24:47 is all day but the beauty of the lack of definition is what makes it art to me and
00:24:53 warhol was sort of predicting how things are going and and and he was showing us the material
00:25:01 modes of production of the era what was happening in the late 60s what was happening 70 80 years
00:25:09 after the industrial revolution now that's where art was uh Andy Warhol done a um a picture of a
00:25:18 screen print of a lot of stilettos and you can go back a hundred years and Van Gogh done a picture
00:25:24 of some peasant shoes in oil paints and that that that hundred year change in what was considered
00:25:32 modern art you know Van Gogh wasn't considered you know a renaissance painter he was like
00:25:38 who is this madman and and literally let's lock him up um but going back to us being a story people
00:25:47 and why it's so important when we bump into someone in the street we might not have seen
00:25:52 them for a couple of days couple of weeks couple of months couple of years hello mate what's what's
00:25:57 been happening hello mate how are you it's an invitation for a story you know when someone
00:26:03 says how are you you rarely say in in a in a social situation you rarely say i'm all right
00:26:10 my bank account is fine um there's food in the cupboard um i've got a bad toe you never answer
00:26:17 the question you you take the invitation for a story you say i'll tell you what and and then you
00:26:24 you'll say the other night you know you know you know johnny peters um jack's dad well he's come
00:26:31 around the house and you start telling a story and then they engage with that story and your
00:26:37 culture and your traditions are being repeated and that's the important part of stories repetition
00:26:43 look at the european fairy tale tradition you know you've got um obviously hans christian
00:26:50 anson the brothers grim um uh the french geezer what was it i think it's perrault maybe jean
00:26:56 Perrault. I'm guessing
00:26:58 Jean because it probably is
00:27:00 old Pierre, but it's not Pierre Perrault. That doesn't
00:27:02 sound right. You know, look at those
00:27:04 old European fairy stories. Were you
00:27:06 read them as a child? Yeah, Hans Christian
00:27:08 Anderson, stuff like that. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah.
00:27:10 Look at the themes of the European
00:27:12 fairy stories, like
00:27:14 revenge,
00:27:15 vindication, murder, 0.83
00:27:19 death.
00:27:20 A lot of them ended
00:27:22 with marriage
00:27:24 and a family as a
00:27:26 success oh we got married and we had a family and everyone lived happily ever after but before that
00:27:34 and and we used to read these to our children our four and our five and our six-year-olds
00:27:39 stories where people do chop off people's heads people people get killed people get drowned
00:27:45 that all these all these you know western culture has lost adequate rituals especially for men
00:27:55 but it does include women for growth and change especially around like puberty look at other
00:28:03 cultures look at look at the jewish culture look what they do around puberty when a boy turns to
00:28:08 a man there's a celebration there's a ritual that's been repeated for a long time and that 0.94
00:28:14 repetition has value where are the the children get read fairy tales these days where have all
00:28:22 those great writers and those great books gone no they don't know them literally and I know it's
00:28:27 a very overused word but literally the Teletubbies about 20 years ago I guess that was replaced
00:28:37 the very rich European fairy tale tradition that had been going on orally for centuries
00:28:45 and then got written down and was repeated there's now some woman I'm really glad I can't remember
00:28:51 her name but she does a show on youtube and everyone i know who's got young kids love it
00:28:57 and she's there and it's like i'm not the sun but i love the sun everyone loves the sun for like an
00:29:08 hour and that's what children are being brought up on now we were being brought up on revenge
00:29:15 murder death treachery vindication vengeance we were we literally were that's all gone
00:29:22 what a what a dramatic change and when and when we go we go back to the gatekeeping of traditional
00:29:31 publishing all that gatekeeping you have to go through where they kick your your work into shape
00:29:37 change it turn it into a different story that goes here that goes here no we can't say that
00:29:42 oh no oh no that's too real no oh that's vulgar all that gets changed then big money big power
00:29:49 gets control of our cultural narrative and once you get control of the cultural narrative
00:29:56 you get control of the historical narrative and that's why independent writers and independent
00:30:03 publishers and storytelling is so important like it's not just it's not it's not just books it's
00:30:13 not just tales it's it's a fundamental organizing an operative principle of western civilization
00:30:24 that has been taken from it in a matter of decades no i'd agree with uh loads of things
00:30:30 you said there i mean i think one of the things that separates us from the beasts one of the
00:30:35 things that separates man from animals is speech obviously cognitive ability and storytelling
00:30:42 culture if you like storytelling that's what all culture is i suppose in the end boils down to
00:30:49 storytelling i can't remember where i read it was a great quote from somewhere or somewhere other
00:30:53 can't remember what it was maybe a dan simmons book or an ian banks because said god would have
00:30:59 destroyed men long ago but he just loved the stories so much that men that men dreamed up
00:31:05 yeah i love it yeah it does set us apart um i mean what i do for epochs my history theme show
00:31:10 pie in the paywall and i see this.com what that really is is an exercise in storytelling each
00:31:16 one's a long-form bit of content about history and it's not writing prose like a novel but each
00:31:21 one i try and have i do try and tell a story a beginning middle and an end with some sort of
00:31:27 narrative stream and sometimes they're a little bit more complicated than others with various
00:31:31 streams and cutting back but usually it's pretty linear pretty straightforward chronological
00:31:35 storytelling nonetheless an exercise in in storytelling and like anything else you get
00:31:40 better the more you do it with like almost anything the more you do it the better you're
00:31:43 going to get at it and um i just find it i find it fun like i really do find it fun and this this
00:31:52 novel i'm working i've been working on for a long time it's like it's even though it's i find
00:31:57 difficult and I described it as sort of a weight on my shoulders and it's like it's like it's real
00:32:01 work like it's real work but it's a labor of love also though absolutely a labor of love it's
00:32:06 something to be proud of afterwards when you said you sit down or sometimes you sit down do seven
00:32:10 hours a day or whatever I just it sounds like it sounds really weak if you get someone actually
00:32:16 works in the fields you get someone that carries a hod of bricks around on their back all day
00:32:20 you get someone that properly grafts with their hands all day long you get someone like me a
00:32:25 soft-handed college boy sitting there saying oh it's really difficult to sit there and write for
00:32:31 hours on end I tell you though psychologically mentally it is draining it's really honestly for
00:32:37 me anyway it's really really draining to sit there for more than a couple of hours at a pop
00:32:42 without a break and just and just sort of beat the way I do it beat myself up a little bit about
00:32:49 no that's not good enough that's not right that's not what I meant that's not what I want to say
00:32:51 i want to and just just you know really work it's real work at least psychologically at least
00:32:57 mentally real real work but um to get back to what you're saying about storytelling i think
00:33:01 is on a very very interesting thread there about children about fairy tales that yeah i was brought
00:33:07 up a lot with um things like hang christian anderson loads of things in the western tradition
00:33:11 things like the just so stories kipling things like a roll dial lots of roll dial stories are
00:33:17 really violent and horrible little kiddies get disappear and get murdered people get their heads
00:33:22 locked off i remember when i was a kid loads of little kids they love that if you talk about
00:33:26 history they're like well how did he die then you know they love little kids usually quite they 0.98
00:33:32 they like they've got toilet humor they love things about piss and shit and people getting killed and 0.98
00:33:36 blood and heads flying kids love that you know usually yeah because that's their world their 0.99
00:33:42 world is that they're worried about their parents dying they they realize they're a child they go
00:33:49 for a phase it's psychoanalytically known as well in certain fields of psychoanalytics um the mirror
00:33:56 phase where the where it's the creation of the pronoun distinction where they recognize that
00:34:02 they're an other they see someone and they think oh actually i'm a me that's actually a
00:34:11 developmental phase of the child and as soon as that happens that that's traumatic i know trauma
00:34:17 gets thrown thrown all over the place but that is quite traumatic so reading those fairy tales to
00:34:23 children it what i was talking about having adequate rituals when a parent is reading a story
00:34:31 about fear about you know about going to the grandmother hang on that grandmother looks a bit
00:34:37 dangerous looks a bit frightening you know because it's a wolf it's a wolf dressed up as
00:34:42 your grandma and you know and and and and children fear death children know about death their world
00:34:50 is very small all that stuff's really important i just want to build real quick on what you said
00:34:55 there chris about about death like a small child's think i mean this again another thing that sets
00:35:00 apart from the animals is we know we're going to die and you're introduced to that inevitably as a
00:35:06 child whether you really grasp it or not but at some point as a small child you you're told that
00:35:11 the people you love are going to die and that you are going to die now again that is a traumatic
00:35:17 thing it really is a traumatic thing most of us go through our lives just not really thinking
00:35:21 about it but you know it's there um and so i know when i was a kid when i was a kid i was
00:35:27 i was fascinated in history obviously and i'd be told all the stories from alexander to caesar to
00:35:32 henry the fifth whatever and i'll inevitably be like well how did he die and like the bloodier
00:35:38 and gorier and more horrific it is the more i was like oh really when i'm like eight or whatever
00:35:42 but there you go because it appeals to the things that you've been thinking about because you don't
00:35:47 have a job you haven't got to earn money you haven't got to go shopping so you're left with
00:35:51 the realities i mean i would have it that culture exists to fill that space between birth and death
00:35:58 it's like a distraction that's why we do it because otherwise you're just faced with the
00:36:03 truth the ultimate truth is that this is temporary you're a visitor and so we we we do these things
00:36:11 we create these things to take our mind off it but going back to cultural narratives and this
00:36:17 is really important again especially with repetition and stories culture is there it's a
00:36:24 It's a shared, it's a shared group of stories or group is a weird word.
00:36:31 I don't know what the communal noun is for stories, but it's a load of stories that a particular people share and have repeated through generations.
00:36:41 And it's crazy that in Western Europe now, we're being told that our culture, the exclusive agent in our civilization has to be inclusive.
00:36:56 Because that negates the very reason for existing culture exists to say to others, you're not us.
00:37:05 And that's all right.
00:37:06 you grew up somewhere else you've got different traditions different language
00:37:10 probably a different god but you're not us and we know that because this is our culture these
00:37:18 are our stories and yet um legally uh the the judiciary the media the education system
00:37:30 everything is saying no no western people your culture needs to be more inclusive essentially
00:37:39 diluted your the thing that keeps you together as a group has to be destroyed and it's worked
00:37:49 it's worked but let's let's be honest look at the state of the place look at western europe
00:37:54 let's just take germany england and france there are people there are people without a culture
00:37:59 holding them together there's no exclusivity they've lost their stories and and and you know
00:38:05 i was talking about uh meeting someone in the street and you know oh how are you and then you
00:38:10 get into a back and forth of stories don't see that on social media now i'm not knocking social
00:38:16 media but rarely do you have a back and forth of stories on social media it's usually people
00:38:24 making a claim not substantiating it and then slagging people off who disagree with it
00:38:30 that's fine there's a there's a there's a place for that yeah but increasingly there isn't the
00:38:37 in real life uh engagements that you know the gen z have grown up online rarely um i mean you're a
00:38:48 lot younger than me i think but um in our in the summer holidays you get up at eight o'clock you
00:38:54 know this is a little bit jumpers the goalposts and i am an old man but you'd get up at eight
00:38:59 o'clock you'd put your hot wheat a bit you'd throw your hot wheat a bit down your throat
00:39:03 you'd go out and you'd come back when the sun was going down have your dinner have a bath
00:39:08 and go to bed well have a bath if it was a sunday it was only one a week when i was when i was yeah
00:39:14 Yeah, I mean, I'm not that much younger than you.
00:39:17 I certainly grew up in a world where there was no PCs, no mobile phones.
00:39:21 We were so poor, we didn't have a landline in our house when I was a kid.
00:39:24 We didn't get a landline until I was at secondary school.
00:39:26 The TV in the corner, you had like four channels, and they finished not that late.
00:39:34 And so, yeah, you lived a real life.
00:39:35 You touched grass every single day because there was nothing else to do.
00:39:39 Yeah, we read.
00:39:39 I mean, my household, we were poor, working class, three up, two down terraced house, but we had a massive bookcase, well, more than one massive bookcase.
00:39:48 And we read. I was read two when I was a child, and I read a fair bit as soon as I could read.
00:39:55 But nowadays, that is a dying thing. I was talking about it.
00:39:59 In fact, on The Breakfast Show this morning, there was a story saying, reading is good for your mind and your soul and your health, regardless of what genre it is.
00:40:08 And I was like, yeah, obviously, but reading, tell me what you think about this, Chris, that reading seems to be, let alone writing, reading seems to be a dying thing.
00:40:17 Yeah, sure, people will read a web page.
00:40:20 Yeah, people will read a bit of what they want to read on the internet.
00:40:24 A summary.
00:40:25 Yeah, they'll read a Wikipedia synopsis of something, maybe.
00:40:29 They'll read the comments under a video.
00:40:31 but sitting down there with a real life hard copy book with a broken spine and it smells of
00:40:37 moldy paper sit there for three four five hours reading it going off into a fancy land of the
00:40:42 author's creation people don't do that very much I don't know very many people that do that
00:40:48 regularly and it seems to me a terrible shame a crying shame it seems to me a detriment to
00:40:55 the human condition to human civilization that millions of people don't do that on a regular
00:41:01 basis i mean what's your i guess i'm preaching to the choir here but what's your thoughts and
00:41:05 feelings on that you already touched on it earlier when you talked about writing being work
00:41:10 now you know one of the things i detest about the literary community or people who think they're the
00:41:16 literary community like on threads i don't know if you know but there's this failed social media
00:41:22 thing that met her uncle threads um and people are on there like tomorrow morning i'm going to
00:41:29 wake up a published author it's like that is okay you know and this whole i'm a writer you know
00:41:38 okay my dad was a bricklayer and i'm not taking anything away from writers like you know obviously
00:41:45 being one but the work for me the work part of it yes it's mentally taxing and you never stop
00:41:52 thinking about what you're working on even when i walk away from the keyboard i'm still processing
00:41:57 and all that but it's the it's the notion of the expert and and and that requires a lifetime of
00:42:06 experience if you're writing about yourself you need to have to some extent some kind of
00:42:11 extraordinary life not necessarily an exceptional one but but one that um focuses on well for me
00:42:20 that the themes from fairy stories essentially we get back there but you've also you know to be a
00:42:26 good writer you need to know what's gone before you need especially in your genre you know if you
00:42:32 haven't put that work in you're going to sit down and be you know i get i get so many people come to
00:42:40 me i've started writing a novel you read it and i'm like well how much have you written about
00:42:45 about five pages and i say right keep hold of it keep working on it well done in six weeks if you
00:42:53 want me to have a look at it i will no one ever has because in six weeks that little buzz they
00:43:01 got of actually writing something they've looked at it and have cringed their bottom jaw loose
00:43:06 because it's rubbish because they're not experts they haven't spent 20 30 years doing this now
00:43:13 understandably you've got the anomalies like proust or whoever who wrote the most amazing 0.77
00:43:19 things when they were 23 years old right okay it happens john keats they are anomalies but
00:43:26 with the damage that has been done to our culture that the lack of the expert has been part of that
00:43:34 and and we've writing especially so i mean i i don't know if we talked about this last time
00:43:40 but penguin random house in canada they said you can send us your full manuscript which is weird
00:43:47 usually it's the first three chapters you know they don't even want to give the whole thing a
00:43:52 proper go they want to know that if someone picks it up in a bookshop and starts reading it that
00:43:56 they'll buy it no just send us first read i don't even use chapters chapters are just an overhang
00:44:02 from when i talk to writers and they say oh i'm on chapter seven if i want to piss about if i want 0.99
00:44:09 to be a bit of an arsehole i say why do you use chapters and they're like you idiot and i'm like 0.68
00:44:14 no but why do you use chapters no one's given me an answer yet no one another another good one 0.91
00:44:21 when people talk about their edits yeah is it is it is it alexander dumas chapters or is it
00:44:26 dan brown chapters ones dozens and dozens and dozens of pages a dan brown chapter can be
00:44:33 two paragraphs sometimes can't it so yeah it's nonsense yeah it's completely arbitrary
00:44:36 bukowski can be a bit like that and i adore bukowski but um it's knowing why and it's like
00:44:43 the editing thing you know i i have to be a bit careful being a a bit of a cantankerous old
00:44:51 bastard on social media because i also use it to guerrilla market my work but when people say oh i
00:44:56 had my first session with an editor today and i told you already that i'd say that's a collaboration 0.88
00:45:01 oh you oh you're doing a collab you're writing a collaboration then and i just get piled on you
00:45:07 know it's just me at the bottom and i and i you know i call it on myself but the other one i say
00:45:12 is what's the difference between writing and editing?
00:45:17 And they're like, oh, you call yourself a writer.
00:45:21 Can't believe your book's got 4.8 stars.
00:45:25 And I say, yeah, okay,
00:45:26 but what is the difference between writing and editing?
00:45:30 And no one can give me an answer because there isn't.
00:45:34 Writing is the process of adding, removing,
00:45:38 rearranging words and punctuation.
00:45:41 how would you define editing to me yeah a very very similar thing if not the same thing yeah
00:45:48 yeah yeah because i mean the way i do i write something and then i'm editing it over and over
00:45:52 and over and over again that's what writing is now now i'm not saying that to be i know more i i i've
00:46:01 read derrida but the reason i say it is because that that links back to the the the lack of
00:46:07 expertise in literature where it with love in the time of nudie mags it's pointless me keep
00:46:14 hanging it up because it doesn't work but do buy it i mean you know i know my stuff
00:46:19 but with that it's a journal of a of a of a 14 year old but i had to do something that
00:46:27 someone who's quiet has an expertise in writing has to do i had to make that i had to make the
00:46:36 storytelling more intelligent than a 14 year old's voice because it's a book for adults it's not a
00:46:45 young it's not it's not for a 14 year old 14 if i sold that to a 14 year old their mother would
00:46:51 you know come and smack me around the chops it's i had to i had to pull it off otherwise you'd get
00:46:56 bored you know what it's like when your baby's sitting someone's kids after two hours you've
00:47:01 had enough you know they they're not very clever they're not very intelligent and so the conversation
00:47:06 isn't great there is a certain amount of novelty and it's interesting and you know sometimes i'll
00:47:12 start psychoanalyzing them don't tell your mum but to sustain 250 pages i knew that
00:47:21 the actual storytelling had to be more intelligent than a 14 year old and that that takes that takes
00:47:29 35 years of writing and reading to be able to pull that off and thankfully i have but you say
00:47:37 things like that to people who call themselves writers on social media they don't even know
00:47:43 what you're talking about and it's along with the editing thing it's along with the uh well you know
00:47:49 i you know sometimes i'll just break and i'll go have you seen have you seen the quality of
00:47:56 discourse on what this is meant to be the the author threads we're all meant to be authors 0.99
00:48:02 have you seen the quality of discourse here you know it's it's pathetic you know you're you're 0.99
00:48:10 sometimes i'll just say i'll say you're all low iq idiots and i don't say that because i want to be 0.99
00:48:16 a git i'm trying to tone my language down but but because they seem to come across like that 0.99
00:48:24 I'm willing to be
00:48:26 I have my mind changed
00:48:27 But it hasn't happened yet
00:48:29 You've said so many things I want to
00:48:31 Bounce off of
00:48:33 First of all your character, your main story
00:48:35 It's a trope isn't it, the classic
00:48:37 Overly intelligent
00:48:40 Child in film and literature
00:48:42 Like Lisa Simpson 1.00
00:48:43 Real life kids are dumb 1.00
00:48:45 And it's not their fault, I'm not even a pop at real life kids 1.00
00:48:48 It's just you haven't lived a life
00:48:49 That's one of the reasons why I never
00:48:51 I never seriously tried to get the novels I wrote in my 20s or early 30s published because I knew
00:48:58 I could tell that they're not that great I feel what makes a good novel is when you read it
00:49:08 you feel as though you're in the hands of an expert writer an expert storyteller that the
00:49:16 person that's writing it the author has got a very very highly developed highly honed
00:49:22 sort of a literary sensibility that only comes with age every now and again you might see don't 0.98
00:49:31 you an 11 year old has published a novel have they it will be shit and they've only done it 1.00
00:49:36 because their dad owns the publishing company yeah no it will be shit it will be shit you need 1.00
00:49:41 to have lived a life and you need to have honed a literary sensibility over many many many many 0.98
00:49:46 years otherwise it's not going to be very good that's my that's my feeling that's my opinion
00:49:52 and as for the art of storytelling god chris we're already probably two-thirds of the way
00:49:57 through our time i'd love to just talk about just this with you for a couple of hours
00:50:00 is the whole world the whole sphere around crafting a story so you talked about how you do it mostly
00:50:08 in the first person I do it nearly always or always really in the sort of third person
00:50:13 omniscient narrator and so then I've got so many decisions to make and I'm second guessing myself
00:50:19 nearly all the time it's like am I going to do a piece of third person narration am I going to set
00:50:24 the scene how flowery how florid am I going to do it is it going to be a soft touch or am I going
00:50:28 to do a whole Dickens paragraph of description of the room etc etc and then when I've got some
00:50:33 dialogue now is it the right point for dialogue okay is the dialogue going to be a few pages of
00:50:38 dialogue or is it just going to be a couple of points of dialogue and then and then endlessly
00:50:42 second guessing myself about the dialogue itself oh i'm not a good dialogue writer i can't write
00:50:46 dialogue i'm not worthy and then and then and on and on and on and on am i going to end the scene
00:50:52 there at what you know and then actually actually truly like the meta crafting of the story not
00:50:58 just the craft of the individual paragraph the individual chapter the individual bits of
00:51:02 description and dialogue you're doing but the crafting of the overall meta narrative at what
00:51:06 point do I break scene here do I just um do I just uh montage ahead two years into the future now
00:51:13 or not and on and on and on and on second guessing myself for years on end um but at some point I
00:51:21 think it would I think it might have been Rolf Harris of all people talked about again the
00:51:28 analogy the parallel of an oil painting he said at a certain point you just have to abandon it
00:51:34 because it will never be finished you can keep polishing it you can keep touching it further and
00:51:39 further and further detail and it will never be finished it will not be perfect ever so at some
00:51:44 point you as the creator as the author in this instance you have to say right and there's a line
00:51:50 under it it's done I'm finished with it and but when is that point when is that point I mean the
00:51:56 the decisions it's a difficult thing writing I mean tell me a little bit more about your process
00:52:00 how you deal with those types of questions well first of all perfection is a killer just forget
00:52:06 about it yeah secondly you're writing a book you know grow up you're right that's all you're doing
00:52:12 you're writing a book i mean it's significant it's important but it's not you're not carving
00:52:18 it in stone it's just you're just writing it on paper so just go for it my the novel i've been
00:52:24 writing for 10 years the spine of it is written in the first person present which is very clunky
00:52:31 it's very clunky to read you know it you open it and it's like i'm walking down the road
00:52:37 most people are used to first person pass don't they i was walking down the road you know 10
00:52:44 years ago but my you know and you're like hang on a minute this is happening now okay but in the
00:52:51 same paragraph i'll change tenses because i just write like that and because because although i'm
00:52:57 writing in the first person i'm having memories the character who's in the in the present is
00:53:04 remembering something this is why it's taken 10 years because it's got like a mandelbrock structure
00:53:10 to it i can give you i can give you an exact example from the novel i'm sitting in the french
00:53:16 house on dean street lovely boozer if ever you're in soho go to the french house on dean street
00:53:21 and uh i was very young and it's in the story it's in it's in the the new manuscript
00:53:29 or the old manuscript and and it's the story of the the leslie the woman behind the jump the
00:53:37 landlady she says i don't know why they don't just go around to the park on wardour street
00:53:43 and lock them all up everyone knows they sell heroin and i think i'm gonna go and buy some
00:53:51 you know i was like 23 all right and it's it's relevant to the novel because the novel follows
00:53:58 the true story of me going to thailand to cold turkey in a guest house so so so i tell i tell
00:54:08 so i'm walking down the road and i'm sort of you know the withdrawal starting to kick in in the
00:54:13 present and i'll say the first time i tried it i was it and then it goes into first person past
00:54:18 because i was in the french house pub 30 years ago so then it's in the past as i'm walking out
00:54:26 of the french house i walk past the admiral duncan which was a boozer that got blown up
00:54:32 when i was in the french house once so then i start telling that story so already i'm in thailand
00:54:40 walking down the road in the present then i've started talking about the french house and leslie
00:54:45 telling me where i can score skag i decided to go and score that but then i'd walk past the admiral
00:54:51 duncan and i talk about that being blown up but there was three other bombs that year when i was
00:54:57 in the same town or city when they went off so i start talking about those stories about all these
00:55:03 bombs going off when i was there one on brick lane when i was living in bethnal green as a kid when i
00:55:08 went up to carnaby street to buy my mod parker in the 1982 mod revival i mean the fishtail used
00:55:14 to drag along the floor behind me and and now and now i'm talking about that from that goes this
00:55:20 between leaving the french house to go and score on wardour street there's about 50 pages
00:55:28 of other stories and each of those stories another story comes out of it and another
00:55:35 comes out of that that's why i liken it to a mandelbrock or fractals perhaps is easy
00:55:40 but what i've got to do i've got to trace my footsteps back because i can't not finish the
00:55:49 i'm a bit i'm a bit unwilling to say original story but i've got to get back to
00:55:58 walking out of the french house to go and score because that's part of the the spine of the story
00:56:06 the first time i used error in so but but i don't just walk around there all those memories that i
00:56:14 that come to me on the walk around there come into the come into the manuscript but like
00:56:21 but the decision making process chris so like what makes you decide well that branch and for
00:56:27 this long and if there's any dialogue in it or not and at what point do you return to the original
00:56:32 thing oh these are decisions decision after decision after decision does it just sort of
00:56:37 flow out kind of naturally or is it like is it are you endlessly well over years like no that's
00:56:44 not quite right that has to go there and you know as much as is required but I've learned that from
00:56:51 writing for 30 years it's just a judgment you know i've sort of i've found a voice that works
00:56:58 for me that doesn't necessarily mean it works for other people i mean people familiar with my
00:57:04 substack will have read stories where i just endlessly digress um but surely with a short
00:57:10 story it's it's uh slightly different well it is it's a very different form actually because you
00:57:17 can you know three thousand words or whatever although some of them are they're long shorts
00:57:22 um but you know is it relevant is it adding to the story is it you know i don't just i this isn't
00:57:31 just a free for all of things i can remember but is that is this showing is this giving the
00:57:38 character depth is this foreshadowing things that happen later in a way where things that happen
00:57:46 later are going to land heavier because hang on a minute that weird little bit he spoke about
00:57:54 100 pages ago it's obvious that he's going to do this now because that's the sort of person he
00:58:03 grew up as so when when you ask me what do you keep in what do you take out it you know it's
00:58:11 it's kind of it's very subjective but what's required and and whether it adds to the story
00:58:19 in a in in a way that makes it a better reading experience but but just before i let you give you
00:58:26 let you get a word in edgeways um i don't believe reading is a passive act there's where my work
00:58:38 you know just as in music the silences are as just as important as the notes saying the silence
00:58:45 is out of a bit of mozart and it's just a racket they're just as important so what you leave out
00:58:51 of a novel of a story is equally important as what you put in so when a reader reads my stuff
00:58:59 and i leave stuff out i don't want i don't want them to read any of my stuff my shorts love in
00:59:07 The Time of Nudie Mags, the new novel, the old novel, anything passively.
00:59:12 I want them to be actively engaged in the creation of meaning.
00:59:18 And that's going to be different for every reader because they are a context of themselves.
00:59:26 If I if I if I write about a working class, if I mention a working class kid that had a lot of books in his house and was read to and had a black and white telly.
00:59:36 they didn't have a telephone you're going to identify with that because you because that's
00:59:41 that was your experience of upbringing you told me earlier in this in this chat but there might be a
00:59:47 an upper middle class an upper class person reading it and that's totally foreign to them
00:59:53 so the same words but a different meaning i always say this the words are mine but the meaning
01:00:00 belongs to the reader and they will translate that according to their personal context
01:00:07 well that is what question sorry go on yep to answer your question i don't know is the answer
01:00:16 i'm trying to contrive something the truth is and i think it's the best thing to say in any
01:00:21 conversation if it's true i don't know i don't know why i why that stays and that goes it just
01:00:29 feels right when i read it back i'm like that works and as you were saying about um uh rolf
01:00:37 varis good lord um you know it's the same with writing you don't finish a novel a novel finishes
01:00:44 you you just like i'm done i'm done no yeah i'm on the last draft of the i mean the the the one
01:00:53 i've been writing for 10 years it's it's insane it's it's it's like there's there's whole sections
01:00:59 written like a film noir sort of scene and it's just and it comes out the blue there's no there's
01:01:05 been nothing about film noir in the first 100 pages and then suddenly you know it's just something
01:01:12 out of chinatown the book is also made up inside the text there's nursery rhymes there's advert
01:01:20 advertising slogans. There's dialogue from movies that I've used as non-dialogue, as prose
01:01:32 in the text. It's as if I've got all the cultural sort of baggage that has been imposed on me in
01:01:40 the 54 years I've been alive, run it out into that text. So people will be reading it and
01:01:47 there's a there's a description of me going into a brothel or something and in the conversation
01:01:53 i'm having someone thinking what's that hang on that's an alca seltzer that's an alca seltzer
01:01:59 advertising line or they might read another bit like i've used loads of apocalypse now in it
01:02:05 loads because i will have i need a film on when i'm writing i can't do music i can't do silence
01:02:11 i'll always have a film on and apocalypse now is visually wonderful i need silence
01:02:17 as i'm writing and captain willard says something amazing i think i'll have that
01:02:26 i might not put it in that bit so the book is like a cultural sponge the text is like a cultural
01:02:32 sponge as well as the story but not for not for no reason because because that's the culture that
01:02:40 readers have grown up in as well that's part of their memory system i do it i do it very
01:02:46 differently we've got all different styles of voices there where you do it sounds like you've
01:02:51 got all different voices i uh i um sort of uh get uh spend a lot of time and energy making the voice
01:03:01 at least the voice of the narrator the omniscient narrator as perfectly uniform as possible
01:03:08 if anything in the voice of it so it's not jumping around between tenses it's not jumping
01:03:14 around between different styles that at least the narrator itself is uniform throughout the whole
01:03:21 book uh but that's just me that's just the artistic decision i've decided to to go with
01:03:26 but bo when you talk you jump around tenses you've just done it then yeah why would you
01:03:33 change that when you're writing because it's imperfect it's normal it's just normal what
01:03:40 people do but i want that text to be as good as it can be basically as good as it can be i want it
01:03:46 to be able to stand the test of time i want someone to be able to pick it up a hundred years
01:03:51 from now 500 years from now and read a quality piece of literature that's why so so do i don't
01:03:58 get me wrong i'm not saying i'm not saying that at all no i'm not saying that at all i'm not saying
01:04:02 that at all don't get me wrong i've just perhaps i obsess over it far too well i know i obsess over
01:04:07 it far too much that thing about perfection you're never going to get it stop trying just let it go
01:04:13 it's easier said than done though it's easier said done so one of the things one of the things
01:04:16 actually talked about right at the beginning or you talked about and I wanted to jump in and add
01:04:21 to it um but you'd moved on to like a dozen other things that were interesting but that thing you
01:04:26 said where people are really quite brutal when it comes to writing for some reason if you say
01:04:31 oh I've tried my hand a bit of making pottery people are usually quite kind oh have you yeah
01:04:36 That's a good start.
01:04:37 Well done.
01:04:38 Keep it going.
01:04:39 You've done any number of things.
01:04:40 People are like, oh, yeah, well, good luck to you.
01:04:43 Keep going.
01:04:43 Good stuff.
01:04:44 But for writing, quite often, you must have found this,
01:04:47 quite often people are immediately very, very, very critical.
01:04:52 For some reason, when it comes to writing, fiction, prose, 0.99
01:04:56 they'll read it and they feel at liberty to go, no, that's shit. 1.00
01:05:00 You're shit. 1.00
01:05:01 Stop trying. 1.00
01:05:03 You must have come across that in your life.
01:05:04 Yes, but I think that's actually defendable, because it's like we've all got a voice, and I mean a physical voice, we've all got a voice, and everyone will sing at some point, if they're at home on their own, and something comes on the radio or whatever, on the wireless, and they might go, I've always loved you, it's not very good.
01:05:29 now most people can write they can write with a pen or a computer whatever but they're not experts
01:05:38 they haven't put the work in learning how to do it they haven't refined their voice they haven't
01:05:44 read enough they don't they haven't looked at the world around them in a way where they can 0.99
01:05:50 translate it and that's why i will to an extent defend people saying that's shit because it 0.88
01:05:59 usually is well yeah well yeah yeah because people because people can write because we're 0.92
01:06:05 all taught it at school they then go from i can write to well if i write loads i've written a
01:06:12 novel but they're not an expert do you understand like i think a writer needs to be as much of an
01:06:19 expert as an architect an architect studies architecture at school or let's say a brain
01:06:26 surgeon, studies medicine for like eight, nine years, and then has to stand by the master
01:06:33 watching for another four or five years before they're even allowed anywhere near a real
01:06:39 operation. A writer has to have that same level of expertise, if they're to have any relevant
01:06:47 social role or function, which leads on to what you said, and then later a historical function,
01:06:55 where someone can pick up that book
01:06:58 and it will tell them something honest and true
01:07:02 about the time it was written.
01:07:06 And so that's why I will defend people on the whole 0.99
01:07:09 saying your novel's shit, because most of them are. 0.99
01:07:14 Or they don't seem to give you much credit. 0.99
01:07:16 For example, quite often what you get is
01:07:18 you let someone read something you've written
01:07:20 and basically they might not say it exactly like this, 0.98
01:07:22 but it boils down to that's not as good as kerouac or dickens therefore you're shit right 0.94
01:07:29 i've read books that are good and this isn't that good it's like oh i'm only bloody hell 0.86
01:07:34 give me a cut me some slack but i know you mean usually it isn't very good you're right uh one
01:07:38 other thing quickly because i'm running out of time unfortunately we'll have to do this again
01:07:41 chris there's so many things we haven't touched on i want to talk to you much much more about
01:07:46 diving into dialogue diving into sort of the meta structure of a story but we won't have time i've
01:07:51 only got about 10 minutes left I want to talk to you quickly a bit about one other thing you said
01:07:55 a few minutes ago that uh bridge between the words you choose as the author and what the reader reads
01:08:02 and when I write fiction I'm sort of I'm constantly thinking about the reader whoever
01:08:10 that is everyone else in the whole world I suppose what are they going to think when they
01:08:15 read that line is it what I want them to think and I can only manipulate them as it were so
01:08:21 far at some point you've got to give up and different words mean different things to different
01:08:25 people of course but again that it's like that's what I meant by it is that what most people are
01:08:30 going to take though from it is that the the picture the image I want them to conjure in their
01:08:35 mind it is it or not and well that's the whole ball game isn't it that's the art of storytelling
01:08:41 that's the art of writing is to be able to do that well if everyone could do that well we'd all be a
01:08:46 JK Rowling wouldn't we and whatever that magic is you know I think of a great writer who's a great
01:08:51 writer to me somebody like um uh maybe i don't know hemingway a master of that with with a very
01:08:59 very few words paint a picture and you've got it and it's you you're quite confident it's what he
01:09:05 wanted you to picture as well that the the magic of that i could not disagree more love hemingway
01:09:11 i'm not disagreeing with that okay but he doesn't have language doesn't work like that bow
01:09:18 Basic semiotics doesn't work like that.
01:09:21 Explain yourself, Sarah.
01:09:22 What do you mean?
01:09:23 Meaning is continually deferred.
01:09:25 It never settles.
01:09:27 Oh, yeah, I know.
01:09:27 It's always moving.
01:09:29 If you're sitting there, this is why it's a heavy weight on you.
01:09:32 This is why it's like a burden on you.
01:09:34 And this is why you haven't finished it.
01:09:35 Because if you're trying to write it in a way where every reader,
01:09:42 every possible reader reads it as you intended it.
01:09:46 Oh, I know that's impossible. I know that's impossible though as well.
01:09:50 You misunderstood your tools. You don't understand your tools because language doesn't work like that.
01:09:56 Forget it. Tell your story. There's too much space between the writer and the text and the text and the reader for you to have any control over how they're going to interpret it.
01:10:12 you can give them signposts but they're going to choose what direction that signpost is going to
01:10:20 take okay put it like this chris have you ever written a piece perhaps just a descriptive piece
01:10:24 and then you ask someone who's read it like what did you get from it what's the sort of image you
01:10:31 you built in your mind or you know describe to me read tell me back what you got from that piece
01:10:37 of descriptive writing and they they describe something that was nowhere near nowhere near what
01:10:44 you intended like not like not even close in fact sometimes the opposite when I've had that feedback
01:10:49 I feel like I've I've failed as the writer I've failed to even begin to to paint the picture for
01:10:57 them it's like I'm not I'm not happy with that and I get that it's impossible as you said impossible
01:11:03 to actually do it properly for all people of course of course that's an exercise in impossibility
01:11:07 but to get it as best as possible to get it as close as possible you you wouldn't mind if someone
01:11:14 read some of your prose and just got the opposite of what you intended you wouldn't mind that
01:11:20 wouldn't bother you i would have to uh it would that that would be pulling the rug out from under
01:11:25 my total understanding of language memory and writing i mean the beauty of substack is i put
01:11:33 a short story up and i'll get 60 comments and they're all different if everyone was like oh
01:11:42 this made me think of this or this maybe and they were all the same i'll be like hang on i've got
01:11:47 this language like wrong how the hell has this happened you know if they were all robots maybe
01:11:54 but hopefully uh they're not no you can't do it you can't do it what you can do is aim for truth
01:12:03 that's what I do I had I had an eight-week experience in Thailand I want to tell that
01:12:10 story I know that language never settles it's constantly deferred you talk about you talked
01:12:18 about writing a book and in a hundred years someone reading it it may it may work they may
01:12:24 well still enjoy it but it's going to mean so much it's going to be so different because a hundred
01:12:30 years has passed you know about you know imagine reading the naked lunch borris's cut and paste
01:12:37 when he when it come out i think uh what's that late 50s early 60s when it came out if this was
01:12:44 revolutionary what what's this narrative structure this reads like he's just chopped up a lot of
01:12:50 notebooks and stuck them together because that's what he done read someone releases that now it'd
01:12:57 be like oh it's like the naked lunch oh it's a cut and paste because we've done that we've been
01:13:02 there i mean language is a fool's errand anyway you because because it doesn't it it never set
01:13:09 up language is context dependent and context is always moving and so what you what what i try to
01:13:18 do is try and document the truth of my memory using language and then let it go let it go and
01:13:31 it's a living thing after that if someone if someone comes back to me say i read your novel
01:13:38 and you know what you experienced what you went through blah blah blah whatever they said i'd
01:13:46 have to accept i wouldn't say to them no you got it wrong how can i that too yeah you laugh you see
01:13:52 i would yeah you've heard oh sorry sorry no i misunderstood what question you asked would i
01:13:59 laugh sorry i think i misunderstood what you was asking there say it again right so if i wrote
01:14:05 something and it yeah i put it out there i described the novel as a living thing yeah you
01:14:11 know it's out of my hands once i've finished writing it and then if someone come back to me
01:14:16 and they said, oh, I read your novel, the one where I was looking for truth.
01:14:20 Let's take the 10,000 words, multi-layered, Mandelbrot, many tenses,
01:14:26 cultural sponge novel that I've been writing.
01:14:31 And they say to me, it made me think about this and it made me think about that.
01:14:37 And, you know, it seems to me that you think addiction is blah, blah, blah.
01:14:42 i i would never say to them no you got it wrong you've got it wrong you've missed misread my book
01:14:51 you've interpreted it you've interpreted it incorrectly and the reason i laughed is because
01:14:57 i said i wouldn't say that and you went i would that seems yeah i would and i mean this i mean
01:15:05 that this comes from a good place that seems ludicrous to me really a writer would say to a
01:15:11 reader no you got it wrong how do they get it wrong there's no right or wrong there yeah no i
01:15:19 would absolutely if if i've got an intention an aim and if i failed to express that properly
01:15:25 then i failed as the writer and they have misinterpreted it but i guess we're just
01:15:31 we're looking at in a complete entirely philosophically different way i think we're
01:15:37 looking at it in like a profoundly different way like why i think i think of my prose my fiction
01:15:43 as like a a an exercise in telling a specific story and that story yeah and that story what
01:15:50 does that story have meaning hopefully yeah hopefully so you can tell the story perfectly
01:15:58 you know the cat sat on the mat right i've got that sorted out that um the owner fed the cat
01:16:06 yeah that happened it was dark and gloomy i've explained that right but so you give that no you
01:16:14 give that novel to two different people one of them is someone who grew up in afghanistan has
01:16:21 fought in well just been a war person all their life uh it was an orphan born an orphan grew up
01:16:29 in like you know like for red cross hospitals has got no legs the other person is elon musk do you
01:16:38 think they're going to get the same meaning out of the same text no no of course not so why why do
01:16:45 you seek to control that when when you when you just said you can't you've just come it's like
01:16:54 it was like a confession bow of course no it's not possible but you aim for as close to that as
01:17:00 you can in my mind so take this as an example chris say you write a passage and you meant that
01:17:07 you as the author meant the passage to be read sarcastically right that was your intention as
01:17:12 the author two different people read it one of them reads it correctly as sarcastic and the other
01:17:18 one doesn't the other one takes it at face value surely you can say they've misinterpreted what
01:17:22 you wrote you can't say yes that's perfectly valid it's not perfectly valid it was supposed
01:17:26 to be sarcastic and they've failed to get that i can say to them that i intended that to be sarcasm
01:17:32 but i'm not talking i'm talking about the meaning of it and that is always theirs the words are
01:17:40 mine but the meaning's theirs every time without that i mean that's true that's fair i mean i
01:17:47 understand what you i absolutely of course i understand what you're saying you know i think
01:17:50 you'd write a brilliant book though well it is is quite tight the way i do it is sort of
01:17:57 i'll finish it i'll finish it within the next year realistically hopefully less listen let me
01:18:03 tell you i'm going to tell you something this might be the best bit of advice give up on it
01:18:09 because when people talk about writer's block i've never had writer's block i have the opposite
01:18:14 problem i can't stop writing i'll be up till 7 a.m writing that's why i'm half dead all the time
01:18:20 And it's not hard
01:18:23 It's hard work
01:18:24 It's demanding physically and mentally
01:18:26 But I love it
01:18:28 I love it, I've never stopped
01:18:30 If it's hard work
01:18:32 If you've not finished a novel
01:18:34 If you've not finished a short story
01:18:36 Ever
01:18:36 You might not be a writer
01:18:39 Or you might not be in the right place to write
01:18:42 I mean I have, I've finished three or four novels
01:18:44 And written dozens of short stories
01:18:46 Hang on, hang on, whoa, whoa
01:18:47 You've finished four novels
01:18:50 Why don't you publish them?
01:18:52 I don't think they're good enough
01:18:54 I wrote them mainly in my late 20s, early 30s
01:18:56 And my jaw would fall off from cringe
01:18:59 They're not that good
01:19:03 They're really not
01:19:03 But the way I do it
01:19:05 Is that I can't force myself
01:19:07 This sounds so
01:19:10 Lame maybe to you Chris
01:19:11 I don't know, to a lot of people
01:19:12 This sounds like such an airy fairy
01:19:15 Lovey dovey
01:19:16 Theatre kid thing to say
01:19:18 But it's true in my case
01:19:19 the muse needs to be upon me every now and again it'll be like right oh yes oh i've got two thousand
01:19:26 words in me boom and it flows out and it's very good but that's kind of rare and i never i never
01:19:32 really force myself i never say right tonight you're going to sit down and do three hours
01:19:37 and you must do it because that i it just it doesn't really come so every now and again
01:19:42 more so as i get older more so um in fact when i was younger it was better and then in my mid
01:19:48 in my 20s and 30s not so much but it's coming back to me it seems in the last few years
01:19:51 but again the muse will be with me and it's something I've been thinking about on and off
01:19:56 for days weeks and suddenly I'm like ah the scene has crystallized the dialogue has crystallized
01:20:01 yes yes it's good boom and I'll write stuff and then maybe it might be a long session
01:20:05 might be a fair few hours right it comes out and it's good that's how it works for me that's just
01:20:10 me um so it's not like I've got writer's block it's just the everything has to be right the
01:20:16 feeling this real like you you say you used to i do a lot late at night when everything's quiet
01:20:20 tv's off computers or phones off no one's around it's quite silent and then if the muse comes then
01:20:27 is some quality writing i i don't does that speak to you at all does that make any sense to your
01:20:33 mind it does but it's gonna hurt because it's gonna hurt you because me and the writers i talk
01:20:41 to who are very very successful writers some of them sold millions of books the muse is always
01:20:49 upon us yeah i wish it was mate i wish that were the case i'm not going to talk for them i'll talk
01:20:56 for me but i do know it's true for them we have the opposite problem i can't switch that way of
01:21:02 looking at the world off me and the missus go out to a restaurant i'm thinking about i'm i'm thinking
01:21:10 about the semiotics of the situation, the translation of the situation.
01:21:16 I think that probably goes back to that element of expertise.
01:21:20 You know, you've put the time in and it's a calling, isn't it?
01:21:25 It's a calling.
01:21:26 And that doesn't mean that you won't ever get there.
01:21:30 I'm sure I will.
01:21:30 I know I will.
01:21:31 The muse comes upon me enough that I can eventually get novel length things out of it.
01:21:37 But yeah, it's not constantly on.
01:21:38 What do you want to achieve from a novel?
01:21:42 I give you £50,000 and a lovely room down on the Welsh seafront,
01:21:51 somewhere beautiful, like the ideal sort of traditional romantic writer's cottage.
01:21:57 You've got to do nothing except for write.
01:22:01 What are the aims and objectives of that novel?
01:22:06 to tell an entertaining story i suppose is the bottom line of it entertain so you'd be happy
01:22:13 writing harry potter well hopefully more than merely entertain hopefully something of of value
01:22:19 beyond entertainment yeah hopefully i'm making a statement about very all sorts of various things
01:22:24 whether it's cultural or political even yeah hopefully it's more than mere entertainment
01:22:30 yeah hopefully i'll be saying something of value as well and i would suggest that those
01:22:35 written works that do have cultural, political, ideological, and historical value,
01:22:46 the entertainment you get from them is on a far more profound level than the entertainment you're
01:22:53 going to get from Harry Potter, the Da Vinci Code. Yeah, I'm thinking like a Dostoevsky or an Orwell
01:23:00 novel, where it's a novel and it's entertaining and it's a story, but there's more to it than
01:23:04 that yeah i do try and weave that into my stuff absolutely i'm saying something about the human
01:23:08 condition about about history about politics yeah yeah it's more than just telling a story for its
01:23:15 own sake for the frivolous for its own sake but you're also always already and there's no getting
01:23:22 out of this making a statement about reading right in language and storytelling that's that's that's
01:23:30 just a necessary part of the work but it's like when a bricklayer builds a wall you know you can
01:23:35 see the the the history of the building in the wall oh there's the cement there's the bricks
01:23:41 we've got to start rounding up so maybe a nice place to finish this conversation would be let
01:23:46 me flip the script on you there sir christopher of house dangefield if you were if i gave you
01:23:51 50 grand and you've got six months to sit in a in a lovely welsh cottage with nothing to do but
01:23:56 right what do you what what do you want to get out of the finished product assuming you finished
01:24:02 the product at the end of that time what would you what were your aims and goals there i would
01:24:06 i would hope to write something that had political cultural and historical value okay very similar
01:24:14 goals then ultimately very very similar goals some something else you said about truth yeah
01:24:20 something that's true something that speaks to the human condition that anyone even 100 years
01:24:24 time could see something that's true and real about themselves reflected back in that yeah and
01:24:29 also the modes of production and consumption that were happening when it was written well yeah
01:24:36 inevitably that's a true historical document in that you know you read something like the road
01:24:41 to wigan pier you're going to get a very different story than a lot of historians like to sort of
01:24:48 change the way things are you know where the west is currently having its history rewritten
01:24:53 as you know and and it's only literature that is sort of holding that back
01:25:00 not well not only literature art and literature the creative arts the there are actually a
01:25:06 counter narrative oh to actually these people built england these people built america what
01:25:13 hang on no and so so that that element of truth is important in writing as well and
01:25:19 just just the mode of production being part of the mode of production okay chris i've got around
01:25:26 it up there uh we've got around it off there with just no more time i would love to again i would
01:25:31 need double the time come back again i want to talk more about would you be interested in talking
01:25:36 about really really delving into the minutiae of storytelling because we talked around it a fair
01:25:41 bit today didn't we we talked about various things but really the art of writing something
01:25:46 of course that's all i do of course brilliant okay chris dangerfield thank you very much for
01:25:55 your time massively appreciate it we'll get you back on whenever you want talk about anything
01:25:58 else you want it doesn't have to be writing don't a pigeonhole you you're so much more than that
01:26:02 um we get you on if you ever want to come on the breakfast show whatever you want buddy
01:26:07 we'll be here for you it's been a real pleasure thank you thank you sir hope you enjoyed that
01:26:13 interview and until next time, take care.