The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad - August 20, 2026


Eric Metaxas - Revolution - The Birth of the Greatest Nation Ever (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_1036)

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
On the Dangers of Lacking Critical Thinking Skills (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_1035) Dr. Nathan Cofnas - Was It Right to Alert the World About Jason Arday? (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_1037)

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

180.4

Word count

8,973

Sentence count

568

Harmful content

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

15

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I'm delighted to report that I have joined as a visiting professor the Declaration of Independence
00:00:06 Center for the Study of American Freedom at the University of Mississippi. The center offers
00:00:12 educational opportunities, speakers, internship, and reading groups for the University of Mississippi
00:00:18 community. It is named in honor of the United States founding document which constitutes the
00:00:25 nation as a political community and expresses fundamental principles of American freedom,
00:00:31 including in the recognition of the importance of Judeo-Christian values in shaping American
00:00:37 exceptionalism. Dedicated to the academic and open-minded exploration of these principles,
00:00:44 the Center exists to encourage exploration into the many facets of freedom. It will sponsor a
00:00:50 speaker series, and an interdisciplinary faculty research team. If you'd like to learn more about
00:00:56 the center, please visit Ole Miss, that's O-L-E-M-I-S-S dot E-D-U slash independence slash.
00:01:05 Hi everybody, this is Gatsad. I've got a fantastic guest today. I was all proud
00:01:09 looking at myself in the mirror because I've got a New York Times bestseller,
00:01:13 but the current guy has many New York Times bestseller. Let me first say hello to you,
00:01:18 Eric Metaxas, how are you doing, sir? How sick that we have to mention the New York Times. It's
00:01:24 like mentioning the Soviet Union or North Korea. That's the world we live in. I guess it's a 0.87
00:01:30 metric. I'm glad my books have done well. It's always funny to me every time somebody mentions
00:01:38 that, but thank you. All right. Let me mention a few of those books. Then I'm going to mention
00:01:42 the book that dropped i think june 2nd doing very well uh all right so here are the the the big
00:01:50 bestsellers although you've published i think maybe 30 children's book as well and so on so i
00:01:54 think your top one is bonhoeffer pastor martyr prophet and spy then martin luther the man who
00:02:02 rediscovered god and changed the world you're ready look what i've got on my personal library
00:02:07 wow 1950 edition yes sir now that is why i wrote my luther book because i said there hasn't been
00:02:16 a kind of a definitive story of luther since that book which is a great book but it was 70 years and
00:02:22 i said you know what i'm gonna i'm gonna but that's yeah that's okay does this guy compete
00:02:27 with you because this is more recent do you know this one um i don't know that's my book came out
00:02:33 in 2017 for the 500th anniversary and it was the only book i've ever written that got a review in
00:02:40 the new york times generally favorable which is shocking they must have not looked very deeply
00:02:44 into my background all right let me just mention the other books if you can keep it the forgotten
00:02:50 promise of american liberty miracles what they are what why they happen and how they can change
00:02:56 your life and then your sort of seven series seven women and the secret of their greatness
00:03:00 Seven Men and the Secret of Their Greatness. I presume that I'm number one on that list,
00:03:05 or you'll be coming out with a new list where I'll be number one. And then, you ready? Your
00:03:10 latest book. I love it because I'm at the Declaration of Independence Center for the
00:03:15 Study of American Freedom. June 2nd, this year, Revolution, The Birth of the Greatest Nation
00:03:21 in the History of the World. Talk to us about the book. Well, first of all, I have to explain
00:03:29 that, you know, my book Revolution has been 10 weeks as of yesterday, yesterday marked the 10th
00:03:40 week on the New York Times list, which is a very big deal. I say this because it's a big book
00:03:46 and because we're living at a time when, you know, well, let me put it another way.
00:03:55 And I said about two years ago, a friend of mine, in fact, a friend of mine who introduced me to you, said to me, you should think about writing a book on the American Revolution.
00:04:06 He read the first chapter of my book called Seven Men and the Secret of Their Greatness.
00:04:11 The first chapter is George Washington.
00:04:13 And he said he was so moved by that chapter.
00:04:15 He says, Eric, you got to write the rest of the story.
00:04:18 And usually friends suggest to write a book and you think, thank you very much.
00:04:21 I don't need a book suggestion.
00:04:22 And, you know, I don't have two years of my life to devote to your idea.
00:04:26 But when he said you should write a book about the revolution, I thought, you know what?
00:04:31 I'm shocked to think this is a good idea because there hasn't been a book in a while
00:04:35 that really tells the whole story of how America came into being 250 years ago.
00:04:42 Of course, this year is the 250th.
00:04:44 I say it's the supercentennial of the nation.
00:04:47 I remember the bicentennial was a big thing.
00:04:49 I said, I think we need a book that tells the straight story. And I think that simply in telling
00:04:56 the story of the revolution in, you know, in a fun way, when I say, I mean, it's not like the
00:05:00 book is full of jokes, but the point is, it should be fun to read history. It should be a romp,
00:05:07 a gallop, if it's the story of the birth of America, which is, you know, one of the happiest
00:05:11 stories in history, the good guys win. It's an amazing story. So I said, okay, I'm going to do
00:05:18 that. And then when I told my friends that I'm writing a book on the revolution, they all said,
00:05:24 so many of them said to me, what's your angle? What angle are you going to take? And I said,
00:05:29 I don't have an angle. I just think that the flat out telling of the story is a huge public service.
00:05:35 We need to know our history. In a way, the story of America is a story for the whole world. It's
00:05:41 not just a new nation. It's a new kind of nation where the people will govern themselves. It's a
00:05:46 radical idea. I said, I just want to tell the story. And I want to revisit all those figures
00:05:51 and all those stories within the story that most Americans maybe learned in fifth grade or eighth
00:05:56 grade. And then we forgot about it. The story of Nathan Hale and Henry Knox and, you know,
00:06:00 these names, Ticonderoga. And I mean, there are so many extraordinary figures. So I said,
00:06:07 I just want to tell the story. I think this is important because we're living in a time where
00:06:10 people have been denigrating the United States, denigrating the founding and the founders. And
00:06:15 And I said, I just want to tell the true story, the straight story.
00:06:19 But eventually, I found an angle in a sense.
00:06:23 And it's not like my book is about that angle.
00:06:25 But I was really astonished to see the role of faith in the 13 colonies.
00:06:34 I mean, I'm a person of faith.
00:06:35 I'm a Christian.
00:06:36 But I was not expecting to see it so dramatically present.
00:06:40 So my book is not about that, but it's there. 0.67
00:06:43 I mean, I really have to say I was just so astonished that everywhere I looked, I mean, in fact, the actual impetus for the revolution, the guys who really started the trouble in Boston, the Massachusetts Bay, they were all descendants of Puritans, very strong Reformation theology that really, this was the focus in a sense that pushed them to Lexington and Concord to that moment. 0.68
00:07:10 So all of that comes into the story. But I'll finally say in answering this question that I really felt we need to celebrate what's good. And a lot of times we hear the negative news and we need a template for it. Here's some good news. Here's where we started the idea of governing ourselves and liberty and equality and all this. Where did that come from? I think we need to know that story. That's why I wrote the book.
00:07:38 Do you think that if you were to place all of those figures at the start of the revolution in today's world, would they sort of pat themselves on the back and say, my goodness, look what we started? Or would they say, what the hell is going on with the United States? Why are we teaching our children to be self-loathing about the country that they live in? Or is it maybe a bit of both?
00:08:03 I think it's unquestionably both. I think they would be astonished that this experiment succeeded
00:08:10 because this is one of the things that I hope I get across in the book, the wildness of the idea,
00:08:16 the implausibility of an idea that people would govern themselves. We kind of take it for granted.
00:08:22 This had never been done. Everybody had kings. You have a king or a tyrant, a bad king or an
00:08:29 okay king, but the idea that we will have no king, we will govern ourselves. What a crazy idea. Why
00:08:35 would that work? And the fact of the matter is, it won't work unless you do what they did. The
00:08:41 reason my book is titled The Revolution or Revolution and not The American Revolution is I
00:08:46 say it's the only revolution in the history of the world that genuinely succeeded in doing what it
00:08:51 set out to do. The French Revolution is a bitter tragedy and a joke. I mean, it turns into a blood
00:08:56 bath of terror. It's like a proto-Marxist revolution. And they end in trading their
00:09:02 king for an emperor dictator. It didn't go the way they thought. And the same thing with
00:09:09 these demonic parodies of revolution, the Bolshevik revolution or the Chinese communist 0.74
00:09:15 revolution that ended in enslaving millions who they promised were going to give the power to
00:09:19 the people. So the American revolution really stands in a unique position in the history of
00:09:26 the world. And I think in the 250th year, we need to understand how it happened, what led to it,
00:09:33 not just, you know, the revolution starting with the war in 1775 and Lexington and Concord, but
00:09:38 what led up to that, to that moment, and then what it was that kept them going. And we do need
00:09:43 to understand that, you know, to talk about what they would think today with the lunacy around us,
00:09:49 they knew back then they were in an existential crisis. What they were doing should never have
00:09:54 succeeded. Apart from the hand of God, apart from providence, it doesn't make natural sense that
00:09:59 this group of people would defeat the greatest nation and power in the world. And I think we're
00:10:06 in a similar existential crisis now. And one of the reasons I wrote the book and hope people will
00:10:10 read the book genuinely is because we need to be reminded in the midst of an existential crisis,
00:10:16 how do you get through an existential crisis? The fact of the matter is you could lose,
00:10:22 But I think, you know, as a man of faith, I would say I think it's God's will that we don't lose, that we succeed.
00:10:30 This is a beautiful idea.
00:10:31 It was a beautiful idea in 1776.
00:10:34 I think in the Civil War, it was another existential crisis.
00:10:37 We're in a third one now.
00:10:39 And all the forces of hell are arrayed against us. 0.87
00:10:41 I mean, Islamofascism, Marxist lunacy, anarchy. 1.00
00:10:46 I mean, whatever you name it, you know, mix in a little transgenderism. 1.00
00:10:50 is madness. How do we deal with that? Well, the question is, how did they deal with it? Because 1.00
00:10:56 they were dealing with something rather similar, even though we don't think so. It's always the
00:11:01 same thing. The forces of good versus the forces of evil, depending on what manifestations those
00:11:07 forces are taking. But it's very similar, and there are dramatic similarities.
00:11:12 In psychology, when you are trying to ascribe causality to something, there's something called the fundamental attribution error whereby you can either ascribe something to the situation, right, or to the disposition of the individual who was in the situation.
00:11:32 So using that framework, I want to link that to the revolution. Did the revolution happen because these ideas that were simmering were there in that moment? And it could have been different actors who instantiated those ideas? Or did it require the unique disposition of those great men that I guess you cover in one of your other books for them to pull it off?
00:12:00 Or we could have replaced them with other courageous, enlightened people, and the movie would have ended up the same way.
00:12:08 I think it's hard to say because I think we really, I mean, it ends up being both because the ideas could not have existed without these people.
00:12:16 These people were the existence of these ideas.
00:12:19 I mean, you know, because not everybody agreed with these ideas.
00:12:22 So you have to have enough people that sort of get this or that can convince others of
00:12:27 the importance of fighting for these ideas.
00:12:31 And so what are the ideas?
00:12:32 I mean, the most fundamental idea, and I, you know, I always get annoyed when people
00:12:37 say, oh, it was the Enlightenment.
00:12:39 It was the Bible.
00:12:40 OK, the idea that, you know, the French Enlightenment would lead to the American Revolution.
00:12:46 No, I mean, there are aspects of the Enlightenment.
00:12:48 It gets complicated.
00:12:48 But the point is that the radical idea that our rights come from God, you really have to go back to the Sinai Covenant.
00:12:57 And most of the figures, especially in Puritan, Massachusetts, in New England, they were looking to the Old Testament.
00:13:05 They're looking to the Sinai Covenant.
00:13:06 They're looking to the Jews, to the Israelites, to the Hebrews of 3,000 years earlier, who come out from under Pharaoh, who come out from Egypt, delivered by God.
00:13:18 They don't do this on their own exactly.
00:13:20 It's, you know, they did it with God.
00:13:23 They come out from under that and they're alone in the Sinai wilderness.
00:13:27 And what do they do?
00:13:27 They look to God directly.
00:13:29 That's the model for the men of the 1760s and 1770s.
00:13:35 I mean, especially the lead figures, you know, Samuel Adams and John Adams.
00:13:41 They really were very conscious of this.
00:13:43 This was explicit.
00:13:44 This is a reprisal of the Sinai covenant.
00:13:47 And in fact, it's an amazing thing, you know, because the centrality of God in this kind of narrative, most people say, well, wait a minute, they were deists or they were, you know, and the more research I did, the more I thought, this is nonsense.
00:14:03 Almost none of them were deists.
00:14:05 It's just preposterous even to bring it up.
00:14:07 And then if you think about it, the two least religious figures in the Continental Congress,
00:14:13 so let's say Jefferson and Franklin, when they were asked to come up with a seal for
00:14:19 the new nation, so in the middle of 1776, you know, okay, we need a declaration and
00:14:23 now we need a seal.
00:14:24 Give us a picture, an image of the new nation.
00:14:26 What are the least religious figures come up with?
00:14:28 Benjamin Franklin comes up with the image of Moses overseeing the parting of the Red
00:14:33 Sea and Pharaoh's army drowning. And Frank Jefferson comes up with the image of the Israelites
00:14:41 following the pillar of fire in the cloud, following God in the wilderness. It does not
00:14:47 get more Old Testament, more biblical than this image. And this comes from the two least 0.98
00:14:52 religious figures. So they all understood this. Samuel Adams gives a speech on August 1st,
00:14:59 1776 to Congress. So he's a member of Congress speaking to Congress. This is not a
00:15:03 Bible study, and he's speaking to Congress, and he says, we have restored the sovereign, capital S,
00:15:08 to whom alone all men must be obedient. He's talking about God is our sovereign. We are going
00:15:14 back to the Sinai covenant. God is our sovereign. Just as Samuel rebukes the people of Israel when
00:15:20 they want Saul for a king, and he says, you had a king. It was the Lord your God. This is the image
00:15:25 that we have among the members of Congress. They're saying, we're doing this daring thing.
00:15:30 We're looking directly at God.
00:15:31 We hope it works, but that's the idea.
00:15:34 This is explicit.
00:15:35 This is conscious.
00:15:36 They repeat it over and over and over.
00:15:38 It's everywhere.
00:15:39 And that's what really amazed me, Gad, is the ubiquity of this idea.
00:15:44 It's not just, oh, I found an example.
00:15:46 I mean, it's everywhere.
00:15:48 They are all quoting the Bible, I mean, involuntarily.
00:15:54 I mean, it just comes out of them as they're talking and so on and so forth.
00:15:57 And I thought, even if you're not a person of faith, you need to be historically honest, to be intellectually honest.
00:16:05 You have to acknowledge that these men did these things because they thought this was God's idea of how to govern ourselves.
00:16:12 That this idea that our rights come from God and that government exists simply to protect those rights.
00:16:18 This is a sacred idea. And that to, in a sense, you know, to bow before man when God is requiring something else of us, we cannot do that. We're men of honor. We will rather die than be enslaved or bow to a statue of Nebuchadnezzar or, you know, pinch some incense to an image of Caesar. We refuse to do that.
00:16:45 That's really what they were thinking. And I think that, you know, today, living in such a secular world, we sort of forget about that. And it's like, well, you can't really forget about it. You don't have to agree with it. I mean, I do agree with it, but you don't have to. But you have to acknowledge that's why they did what they did. That's why they risked their lives, their fortunes, their sacred honor. This wasn't just for power. This was, in fact, not for power. It was for principle. And that's a very beautiful and noble idea. And I think we need to acknowledge the nobility of it.
00:17:14 But earlier you mentioned that, you know, the angle that you ended up taking was one that was coming from faith.
00:17:21 And you've often, in our current conversation, mentioned faith and God, which is actually a really good segue to link your book to mine.
00:17:29 Because as you know, and you were kind enough to invite me on your show last week, we talked about suicidal empathy.
00:17:35 And so you're going to see in a second how I'm going to tie these two together.
00:17:38 The First Amendment, of course, has the freedom of religion, you know, edict. And of course, many of the suicidally empathetic Americans, whenever I intervene and say, you know, not all religions are the same, not all religions are equally likely to operate within an ethos of plurality.
00:18:00 And of course, I usually point to Islam. Then they say, but no, we can't. It's right there in the First Amendment, freedom of religion. And then, of course, the argument is, for those who understand my point, is that, well, the Constitution and the amendments are not a suicide pact.
00:18:17 So I recognize as a Jewish person that the United States, yes, it's built on Judeo-Christian ethics, but it's a Christian nation, to your point, right? And the fact that I can come to the United States and flourish whatever faith I have, or if I had no faith, is wonderful, but I don't espouse any positions that are contrary to the foundational principles of the United States.
00:18:44 So how can we get, Eric, the suicidally empathetic people who just through rote parroting keep repeating, but we have freedom of religion, but we, but if, well, listen, again, they're absolutely ignorant. And this is people, it's one thing to be ignorant. It's one thing to be ignorant. Many people are ignorant. I'm ignorant of many things. But it's another thing to be ignorant of your ignorance. 0.98
00:19:09 It's even the worst thing to be proud of your ignorance. 1.00
00:19:12 And these people are proud of their ignorance. 0.99
00:19:14 They have no idea what they're talking about. 0.98
00:19:16 They should absolutely feel free to shut up, to learn a little bit about what they're talking
00:19:21 about, because this idea of freedom of religion, I mean, if I say my religion has killed the 0.96
00:19:25 Jews, are we going to say, okay, you're entitled to your religion? 0.53
00:19:30 We don't have that kind of freedom of religion.
00:19:33 We have something.
00:19:34 We have to take this idea seriously.
00:19:35 What does this mean, freedom of religion?
00:19:37 How did the founders see it? And I mean, I have to say, you know, the idea of equality, the idea of liberty, these ideas do not come from the Koran, ladies and gentlemen. The Koran is antithetical to those ideas. Be honest about it.
00:19:56 Now, in America, if you say, I'm a Muslim, can I live in America? Our answer is usually yes. You don't have to agree with everything, but on the basics, if you want to take over and institute Sharia law, we're not going to allow that. We have a set of values, and even the value that welcomes people with whom we differ is a biblical value, okay?
00:20:19 It doesn't come from the Koran.
00:20:21 It doesn't come from the French atheist philosophers.
00:20:24 It's a biblical idea.
00:20:26 It doesn't come from anywhere else.
00:20:28 It comes from the Bible.
00:20:29 And so we welcome strangers.
00:20:32 We welcome people with different ideas because we are Christians, because we're people of the book.
00:20:38 So, again, there's an irony here, you know, that when people sloppily say we have freedom of religion, you have to say, well, first of all, where did that idea come from?
00:20:47 Yes, it came from the Bible by way of the Reformation. That's where that idea came from. Theocracy is an idea that we have realized. I mean, what I keep saying is that the value of the Enlightenment critiques of Christian faith is that it forced the Christian faith to kind of squeeze the Bible harder to say what's really here and out pops liberty, out pops this idea of religious liberty, that this is fundamental to the Bible.
00:21:16 We now see this clearly. Martin Luther didn't see it. He just wanted freedom from the Vatican.
00:21:23 Okay, well, what about freedom from the Lutherans? What about freedom? In other words, religious
00:21:27 liberty is a sacred idea. It takes centuries for us to kind of figure it out. But I mean,
00:21:32 I've written about, I wrote a biography of William Wilberforce called Amazing Grace. 0.97
00:21:36 You know, it took centuries for Christians to figure out that, ah, slavery is an abomination 0.97
00:21:41 before God. The Bible teaches us to treat others as we would want others to treat us. 0.95
00:21:47 It takes centuries for these ideas, these biblical ideas, to work their way into history.
00:21:53 And the United States of America, this idea of people governing themselves and the sanctity of
00:21:58 the individual, that we're going to set up a government to protect the minorities so that
00:22:04 it can't be mob rule, which is pure democracy. All of this stuff comes from the Bible. And even
00:22:10 if you don't agree with the Bible, you have to acknowledge that's where these ideas come from.
00:22:14 And so it's, again, there's a lot here. Now, my book, to be clear, it's not about those things.
00:22:18 My book is not a religious book. It's just a kind of a gallop through the history. And it's a
00:22:24 beautiful history, how it all happened and the figures and their funny stories, crazy stories,
00:22:29 incredible heroes, and some real despicable villains. But behind it all, you know, whenever
00:22:35 I just have a few minutes to talk about it, I realized this is the piece that I was missing
00:22:39 and that most Americans are missing.
00:22:41 We need to understand where these ideas come from
00:22:44 and where the men of the revolution,
00:22:46 what animated them.
00:22:48 When I often play the game,
00:22:50 and I've even written an article about it,
00:22:52 if you had 10 historical figures
00:22:55 throughout all of recorded history
00:22:57 that you could invite to a party,
00:22:58 who would they be?
00:22:59 Maybe 10 would be too many for us to go through.
00:23:01 But if we focus on the revolution figures,
00:23:05 you go out, four of you to dinner.
00:23:07 so you can invite three other guys, who are you bringing to that dinner, Eric?
00:23:12 Well, definitely not Thomas Jefferson.
00:23:13 I keep saying, I hate to denigrate him, but I feel like he's very overrated compared to
00:23:17 John Adams.
00:23:18 John Adams should be 10 times more famous than Thomas Jefferson.
00:23:23 I mean, he is a towering figure, and my book is not about him, you know, it's about everybody,
00:23:29 but he stands very tall.
00:23:31 He is an amazing figure.
00:23:32 He writes an essay, one of the first chapters of my book is about an essay that he wrote
00:23:36 in 1765. I'd never known it before. Most people have never mentioned it. It is an astonishing
00:23:42 essay that lays everything out brilliantly. So he's a huge figure. And I think he had a great
00:23:48 sense of humor, very acerbic and funny. When he comes to the Continental Congress in 1774,
00:23:55 when they first gathered, the first gathering where they're meeting each other, because they
00:23:59 have no idea what lies ahead. They gather in Philadelphia, no clue that there's going to be
00:24:04 a second continental Congress and a war or whatever. And he, in his diary is noting these
00:24:10 people that he's meeting that, you know, he's going to make history with them, but he's never
00:24:13 met them before the Rutledges and, uh, you know, Caesar Rodney, uh, and these different figures
00:24:19 and his descriptions of them are hilarious. And anytime I find anything like hilarious,
00:24:25 I have to put it in my book because I said, I want this to be entertaining and people need to
00:24:29 know that, that people back then had a, had a sense of humor. And I don't know that he was
00:24:34 trying to be hilarious, but just these sly comments that John Adams makes. He's an amazing
00:24:40 figure and a profound Christian who really right in the beginning was making sure that things don't
00:24:49 go off. I mean, the Boston Massacre, I tell that story, of course, in 1770, he defended the British
00:24:55 soldiers in the Boston Massacre because he said this is the right thing to do. If we're going to 0.81
00:25:01 move forward, we have to be the ones with 100% integrity, which brings us back to this Old
00:25:07 Testament idea of covenant, that if we honor God in how we behave, God will honor us. So we're not
00:25:14 going to do whatever it takes to win. We're going to honor God in how we fight, in how we move
00:25:21 forward, because we trust that God will be with us. And that's a radical position. Deists don't
00:25:29 do that. George Washington was not a deist, because he's another one I'd want at the dinner
00:25:34 table. My goodness, my goodness, what a towering figure in history is this man. George, you think,
00:25:41 did we make him up? He's like a cartoon character. No, he was a real human being
00:25:44 with an absolutely towering character, amazing man of virtue, public virtue, private virtue.
00:25:51 And you realize these are real people. And I think part of why I wrote the book is I think
00:25:56 we need to understand that we we need to know their stories to help model ourselves on them
00:26:04 these are these are amazing people real people who did something that even they were were not
00:26:10 uh they were they were never cavalier about oh you know we should win they thought this is we
00:26:16 humble ourselves that this is a sacred idea in history and if we're the ones to allow it to come
00:26:22 into history we'll do our best but they were very humble uh but yeah george washington i mean what
00:26:28 a figure he is and then there's some real villains in the book john adams george washington yeah
00:26:33 third guy oh yeah okay so you're you're gonna push me and press me to actually come up with a
00:26:38 israel putnam okay israel putnam a lot of people gonna mention israel putnam is a character you
00:26:46 know when you say this guy's a character he was because i'm from connecticut today i'm in
00:26:51 Connecticut. He was, um, a Connecticut native who, who by the time of the revolution is like an old
00:26:57 guy. He's in his fifties. He's a veteran, a grizzled veteran. He's at Bunker Hill. What a
00:27:01 character he is. I just, just for the joy of being around him, you, you just know you want to be
00:27:06 around that guy. He's going to be fun, uh, to be around Henry Knox. Wow. Henry Knox. I mean,
00:27:14 that's another one. I think, I mean, I remember when I was in fifth grade and I, I write this
00:27:19 in the acknowledgments to the book. So at the end of the book, I acknowledge three, well, the third
00:27:25 group of people is one man. It's my fifth grade history teacher who changed my life by being
00:27:32 faithful to speak to fifth graders. And I, his name was Robert McDevitt in Danbury, Connecticut,
00:27:39 Beaverbrook School, Danbury, Connecticut. And I will never forget, even though I was nine years
00:27:43 old that year that it affected me hearing the stories. And one of the stories was the story
00:27:51 of Henry Knox, 25-year-old, going on a crazy journey on an errand to Ticonderoga, 300 miles
00:28:00 from Boston, to get the guns, the cannon, 120,000 pounds of cannon, to bring them from the heights
00:28:10 of Ticonderoga down across four frozen rivers and over the icy, snowy Berkshire mountains with
00:28:17 oxen and sleds, 250 oxen, many horses, 125 sleds. It's an insane story. It's like Hannibal crossing
00:28:28 the Alps on elephants. And that is just one of these stories. You say, what would I do to sit
00:28:35 down with that guy. And then, of course, Benjamin Franklin, because Benjamin Franklin, and he's a
00:28:42 very central figure in the story, too. It's kind of amazing. I didn't realize quite how central he
00:28:47 was all through the revolution. I mean, a very, very central figure. He was, of course, world
00:28:54 famous before it all began. I mean, he was a world famous scientist and on and on and on.
00:28:58 and uh there's a chapter in the book about when he is betrayed in england in 1773 uh he he is
00:29:08 working very hard to bring reconciliation between the british and the americans before the war
00:29:13 starts and he is humiliated publicly in england by the king's privy council it's really uh
00:29:19 it it shows you the darkness one of the themes of the book um one of the angles of the book as i say
00:29:27 is the corruption and cynicism of the british elites and they humiliate franklin it's it's
00:29:35 one of my favorite chapters in the book because it really shows you something that most people
00:29:39 don't know that story and um he is an extraordinary figure i mean absolutely extraordinary so the fact
00:29:46 that these guys get together and there are there are others i mean i tell the story of nathan hale
00:29:51 basically martyred for the cause at age 21, one of the great heroes of American history.
00:29:57 The Ken Burns PBS documentary, which I say to people, miss it if you can. Try to miss it because
00:30:03 it's not really worth 12 hours for sure, but I had to watch it. They devote 10 seconds to an
00:30:10 anodyne mention of this hero, Nathan Hale. And that to me summarizes the left. They can't celebrate
00:30:16 greatness and goodness and beauty and truth because they don't really believe in those
00:30:20 things. And they always have to kind of wring their hands and talk about the bad stuff or the
00:30:24 guilt or it's there's two sides to the story. They can't celebrate something beautiful. And if
00:30:29 there's anything beautiful in this beautiful story, it's the story of Nathan Hale. So a lot
00:30:34 of heroes. All right. So when I answered the question of who are the 10 people that I would
00:30:41 invite, the person that I put on top of that list, and I'll explain in a second why, would be
00:30:46 Leonardo da Vinci, because as someone myself who is very much of a staunch
00:30:52 interdisciplinarian, and in my academic work, I publish in medicine and in psychology and in
00:30:58 marketing and in politics. I don't care. I just go wherever my mind is interested in going. I don't
00:31:04 care about these sort of tight lane silos. So I admire people who are very much polymaths in
00:31:11 their orientations. My reading of these people, and I don't nearly have as much expertise on any
00:31:18 of these folks as you do. So you'll tell me, you'll correct me if I'm wrong. I get the feeling
00:31:23 that if we can say that there is one thing that was common across many of these original founding
00:31:29 fathers is that they were polymaths. They were very well read. They did know Latin and Greek and
00:31:37 read philosophy and so on. Whereas, unfortunately, today, we see that the average person who goes to
00:31:45 UC Berkeley to study mathematics is eight years behind. They're not breaking open a book. So,
00:31:51 would it be correct that in addition to their courage and vision, they were all very much
00:31:57 interdisciplinary in their orientation? Most of them, absolutely. And it's funny because you
00:32:02 You described me, and I normally put it less positively, I say I'm scattered, I'm all over
00:32:07 the place, because many of my books, it's the same kind of thing. I mean, I don't, I rarely
00:32:11 write about the same thing twice. And I think there's real value in that and having a popular
00:32:16 level of, you know, ability to communicate on a popular level, and to get excited about things.
00:32:21 And I've never used the term interdisciplinarian, but I'm going to use that for myself now,
00:32:26 because I think that that's that describes me, but I hadn't thought of it. Polymath is even
00:32:31 better. But I think you're right. They were. They were men who understood. I mean, first of all,
00:32:39 they understood the principles at stake. So this was not power politics. This was,
00:32:46 what are these principles? And are we right? A very humble look at, you know, we don't want to
00:32:51 just go forward to go forward. Are we right? Is God with us in this? Because this is a,
00:32:56 We're risking our lives. This is a big deal. But if we're right, then we will risk everything.
00:33:03 And I think that that requires breadth of knowledge, as you put it, as you're referring to what you're that's what you're referring to here, that they really were thinking deeply about this.
00:33:14 Now, not Israel Putnam. He wasn't thinking so deeply about it. But there are, I mean, when I think of John Adams and Samuel Adams, and there are so many figures that we can't even mention. Joseph Warren, who was the leader of the whole movement before the beginning. He's killed at Bunker Hill. And they thought it's over. It was like the death of Charlie Kirk. It was like a horror. How can we possibly go on?
00:33:39 And I mean, it's an amazing, people should know his name.
00:33:44 John Hancock is another amazingly vital, central figure.
00:33:48 Paul Revere, incredibly central.
00:33:51 And we think of him as, oh, he's famous because he rode a horse.
00:33:53 My goodness, he did so much.
00:33:57 And it's in the beginning of my book, I cover a lot of this stuff because I think it's sort
00:34:00 of the fun stuff and how it all happened.
00:34:03 And there's riots and street theater and crazy stuff.
00:34:06 But these were great men. And I think God calls us all to be great men and women. And so we need to know the stories of these great men, because, you know, we're made for that. We're supposed to, you know, look at our times as they look at their times. Is there something that I can do that matters? They really were willing to do that. And you can't help but be inspired.
00:34:29 And I think, you know, I'm thrilled, honestly, that a lot of people, I mean, if people read the Amazon reviews or whatever, that a lot of people are saying the book is extremely readable.
00:34:39 It's a page turner.
00:34:41 As an author, you know, I'm thrilled because it's not enough just to say, okay, I wrote about it.
00:34:47 I want people to kind of know this is your story.
00:34:51 You're responsible for this information.
00:34:52 So this is a, you know, a fun textbook of everything.
00:34:57 it's going to be on the test because we're in the test now. We're experiencing this now. We're
00:35:02 having our liberties threatened now. We need to, we need to know this. We need to, you know, and I
00:35:07 said, so I want, it should be fun to read and I'm glad people think it is, but it's also very
00:35:13 important because we are going through this now. We have to examine ourselves and ask ourselves,
00:35:18 what are my principles today? Do we, am I living by principles or I just hate the other guy or
00:35:22 what you know what's what's really going on i you mentioned amazon reviews so prior to us coming on
00:35:29 this uh this show i checked quickly some of the blurbs and i saw that there was one from andrew
00:35:35 clavin and uh coincidentally i'll be on his show about 45 minutes after you and i end and
00:35:42 i get to an earlier comment you made about you know people being funny and so on one of the
00:35:47 things that I first, that made me aware of Andrew Clavin, he used to do this series, I don't know if
00:35:53 you remember, I don't think he does anymore, where it was really quite acerbic and satirical, where
00:35:58 he's making fun of all the lunacy. And that really spoke to my heart, because as you probably know,
00:36:03 I'm someone who's quite sarcastic and quite satirical. And I always tell people, the reason
00:36:09 why dictators usually get rid of the men with sharp tongues and stingy pens is because they
00:36:17 are the ones who pose a mortal threat to you. It's not the guys that are tall with the big
00:36:24 muscles. We can get rid of those guys quickly. But the guy who's got the sharp tongue, I got to
00:36:29 get rid of him. That's exactly right. And so I think it's one of the reasons I love Andrew,
00:36:35 because we both enjoy, you know, joking constantly, even when we shouldn't joke,
00:36:39 we can't help it. But I found, and I have to say, there's a lot of funny stuff in the book,
00:36:44 which you wouldn't expect, but I found stuff that I just thought, I have to put this in.
00:36:50 This is just entertaining and weird and hilarious and stuff. And, and I think that's part of the joy
00:36:56 of history is encountering this stuff and these figures that they, they are, these are human
00:37:00 beings, just as we are. And, you know, and some of the, I mean, there's a, there's something I
00:37:04 found. I mean, there's stuff in this book, which is probably in no other book on the revolution.
00:37:08 I, I put in a section telling the story of John Adams spent a night in the same bed with Benjamin
00:37:16 Franklin in a small bed, in a small room, in an inn on their way to Staten Island for a peace
00:37:25 conversation, peace talks with Admiral Howe. It's the most bizarre thing. They argue about whether
00:37:30 to keep the window open or closed. It's September and John Adams thinks we're going to catch cold.
00:37:35 And Ben Franklin explains, haven't you read my essay on whatever? I mean, this is all true.
00:37:41 This is not made up. This is not, you know, something, some kitschy idea for a book. This
00:37:45 is true. And there are many crazy stories like that, that you just, I mean, it makes history
00:37:52 come alive. There's another story where Benedict Arnold and his men, they have a church service in
00:37:59 Newburyport, Massachusetts, before they go on this insane journey into the interior of Maine
00:38:05 to go to Canada, hoping to draw Canada in as a 14th colony. And they go to this church service,
00:38:12 and after the church service, they ask to see the crypt, to see the grave of the great evangelist,
00:38:17 George Whitefield. He is a central figure in the 18th century. It was his preaching that led to
00:38:22 the Great Awakening, which really led to the idea that we can govern ourselves. I mean, he's
00:38:27 absolutely central. And it's why faith is central. They want to see his grave. And then they ask the
00:38:33 section, can you remove the coffin lid? He'd been buried five years. And I just thought, is this,
00:38:41 are we making this up? And there's several accounts of this. So they've removed the coffin
00:38:44 lid. He's molded to dust, but the cuffs and the collar of his clerical gown are still extant.
00:38:50 and they cut those into strips to take as holy relics on their mission, which tells you
00:38:57 that the officers in the Continental Army saw this evangelist as the patron saint of their cause.
00:39:05 In other words, the ideas from the Bible are central to self-government, to liberty,
00:39:11 to the, I mean, all of this stuff, you know, that's a true story. I mean, but there are many
00:39:15 stories like that. I don't want to spoil everything, but I think that it tells you
00:39:19 something. You know, all these stories kind of give you a piece of the picture. Yeah, well, I
00:39:24 want to ask you one or two more questions, but I want to be mindful of your time. I was chatting
00:39:28 earlier today, we were at a coffee shop, my wife and I and I was telling her about I'm a huge fan
00:39:33 of Lionel Messi, as are, I guess, most people in the world. And I was watching him on a clip.
00:39:39 Usually he doesn't say many personal things, doesn't share much personal stuff. But he was
00:39:43 being interviewed by two podcasters. And they asked him, you know, are you romantic? And then
00:39:48 he was saying well you know my wife complains that i don't tell her enough how much i love her
00:39:52 and i'm not demonstrative and then you realize that all of these characters that we lionize and
00:39:58 in some cases idolize are operating using the exact same software as the rest of us right i
00:40:05 mean aristotle was once a baby that was having a hard time walking and and so it there's something
00:40:12 quite uh lovely about the fact that we humanize these characters yeah no yeah that's that's
00:40:20 exactly right and i and i tell you another one of the at the end of the book uh you know i i devote
00:40:27 a lot of time to talking about benedict darnold what a story i mean it is a story for the ages
00:40:33 how he goes over to the dark side it's like the you know lucifer falling it's like the story of
00:40:39 Judas. It's like, it's really Lucifer in Paradise Lost. I mean, it's so compelling. How does this
00:40:46 happen? And it is horrifying, but at the same time, very compelling story. You just can't take
00:40:52 your eyes off it or you can't, you just want to hear more because it's so fascinating because he
00:40:57 was such a hero. And then he goes to the dark side. And then there are two figures, both of whom,
00:41:03 generals, General Charles Lee and General Horatio Gates, both of whom really outclassed
00:41:11 Washington militarily, but were not chosen to lead the Continental Congress. And they both reveal
00:41:19 that they're not of the caliber of Washington in terms of character, which is what mattered.
00:41:28 That was the dispositive thing in the leader of the Continental Armies, was a man of tremendous character, which was George Washington.
00:41:36 And these two figures are basically gunning for his head, undermining him, really wanting their own glory.
00:41:43 This is what's so fascinating.
00:41:44 So they become villains in the story, even though history hasn't quite painted them that way.
00:41:49 You realize that they would have loved to see Washington fail.
00:41:53 They cared more about their careers, militarily speaking, than they did about the cause, whereas most of the principal figures cared about the cause more than their own lives.
00:42:05 And that is just a picture.
00:42:07 And both of them are humiliatingly, well, both of these figures, Charles Lee and Rachel Gates, get humiliating comeuppances, which again, as I'm doing the research, I don't know where this is going to go.
00:42:21 And then you discover, wow, both of them completely lose their reputations by the end of everything.
00:42:26 All they cared about was their reputation.
00:42:28 They worship their own reputation and they lose everything.
00:42:31 That's the irony.
00:42:32 Washington, he cared, you know, about the cause and devotes himself to the cause, just as John Adams did and so many others.
00:42:40 Samuel Adams and John, they really genuinely cared about the cause.
00:42:45 And because of that, you know, they have great reputations.
00:42:48 So there's the irony.
00:42:50 Two quick final rapid fire questions, and then I'll let you go.
00:42:53 Question one, I have many aspiring authors who watch the show and they will often write
00:43:01 to me, how do I write my first book?
00:43:03 What do I do?
00:43:04 And so on.
00:43:05 Well, we have in front of us here a very, very successful author.
00:43:09 If I were to ask you, if you were leading a seminar now on how to write your first book,
00:43:14 what would be two, three prescriptions that you could offer our listeners and viewers?
00:43:18 Well, before I answer the question, I would say, maybe don't write it, because I think a lot of people are convinced I have to write a book. And it's like, I don't know, I don't think the world needs more books. So you better be sure that you have something to say or that you have, you know, because, you know, you don't get extra credit for like producing a quote unquote book. The question is, what do you want to say? And does it need to be said in book form, you know?
00:43:39 But the main thing I always say is read great writing, read great writing, read writers who love writing and who love words.
00:43:49 And I pride myself on that, that that that my writing is not just correct or whatever, but that it's compellingly written in a way that I think that's very important.
00:44:00 And so it's important to read people. Right now I'm finishing a book by Stefan Zweig. He was a famous novelist in the early part of the 20th century. And I'm writing a book by him. And just his style, his prose style is so beautiful and so compelling.
00:44:20 And yesterday I was rereading Moby Dick and I'm in awe.
00:44:26 I can't, I want to scream.
00:44:28 I was on a plane ride from California.
00:44:29 I want to scream how great he is.
00:44:32 Moby Dick, I mean, I almost can't compare anything to the genius of, I mean, you have
00:44:37 to compare him to Shakespeare, but reading great writing, reading the classics is number
00:44:43 one to me.
00:44:44 If you are interested in writing, that's the key because there's just a lot of bad
00:44:49 I host a popular podcast. I get millions of books sent to me. Most of them are not readable. Even I might agree with every syllable, but they're not particularly readable. And so that's actually very, very important to me that you have to have something to say that you're convinced it has to be said in a book form. And then you have to write it in a way that really people don't want to put it down.
00:45:11 I think that that's if people want to put it down, I would say maybe you can say it somehow more entertainingly or whatever.
00:45:19 We all have people who tell boring stories and you're kind of, you know, you're looking over their shoulders.
00:45:23 But those people should have a self-consciousness to say, I don't need to tell this story because I don't know how to tell it in a way that, you know, it's supposed to be for the listener and a book supposed to be for the reader.
00:45:33 And so I feel we have to set us a high bar in terms of what is the what is the what are the ideas?
00:45:40 Do you really have to say this?
00:45:41 And then who is the reader?
00:45:45 And will the reader really get something out of this? 0.57
00:45:47 So I feel, you know, I have, I'm a little bit like the soup Nazi when it comes to books.
00:45:56 You know, it's a high bar, very high bar.
00:45:58 You mentioned Stephen Svite.
00:46:00 I received as a gift a first edition biography by him of Mary, Queen of the Scots.
00:46:09 Wow. So, I mean, I should show it to you. It's absolutely breathtaking. Last question, very quick to answer, but maybe the most important question in our conversation today. Did you ever reach out to that grade five teacher that so influenced you? If yes, tell us about it. If no, why not, Eric?
00:46:29 Well, I would have loved to. He passed away some years ago, I think five or so years ago. And I've thought of him many times over the years. I never dreamt that I would write a book on the American Revolution. I mean, if you talk to me five or four years ago or three years ago, Eric, do you think you'll ever write a book on the American Revolution? I can say, I guarantee you, I won't.
00:46:50 So when I found myself writing about the revolution and then being haunted by what I heard over 50 years ago, so two of his children reached out to me.
00:47:01 They heard me speaking on some podcast because I've spoken on many podcasts.
00:47:06 And I wrote back to his kids, but I want to meet them.
00:47:09 I want to talk to them.
00:47:10 I really get tears in my eyes when I think of this teacher.
00:47:13 Wow. I cannot tell I cannot express sufficiently my love for the man who for 180 afternoons taught these ungrateful nine and 10 year olds about American history and filled our minds with Ticonderoga and Henry Knox and Baron von Steuben and just being faithful, just being faithful where he was planted.
00:47:38 And I quote at the end of my book, I quote the last passage of Middlemarch, where they
00:47:43 talk about, you know, this woman, Dorothea Brooke, who, you know, that these people,
00:47:49 these are the people who change the world, who lie in unvisited tombs.
00:47:54 These are the great people of the world, and we should all aspire to be one of them.
00:47:58 And so when I think of Mr. McDevitt, Robert McDevitt, I could, I really could cry.
00:48:04 I look forward to meeting him in heaven because he was he was a great man.
00:48:10 And it really it's one of the regrets of my life that I was unable to stay in touch with him.
00:48:16 You know, I'll end very quickly with this and then we'll say goodbye offline.
00:48:20 I received an email during COVID.
00:48:23 It was sort of the reverse, not you reaching out to your teacher.
00:48:27 But my grade seven teacher reached out to me to say, hey, I recently watched you at all of these lectures.
00:48:35 I don't know if you remember me, but I was your grade seven teacher at Iona Elementary School.
00:48:41 In Montreal, you could go to elementary school all the way up to grade seven.
00:48:44 And I actually remembered her very well.
00:48:46 And we ended up meeting for coffee.
00:48:48 So it works both ways.
00:48:50 It's lovely when you reach out to your former teachers and it's lovely when they reach out.
00:48:54 What a pleasure to have you on the show.
00:48:56 thank you so much people go out get the book revolution fantastic book eric i look forward
00:49:02 to hopefully meeting you at socrates in the city soon yes yes and i look forward to it and i say
00:49:08 to people listen i don't care if you read my book but it wouldn't kill you to buy two or three copies
00:49:12 that's if i could leave you with a final thought and i actually i say this in all seriousness
00:49:16 buy it on amazon uh barnes and noble is barely carrying it maybe because they they know i'm
00:49:22 conservative but it's a new york times bestseller they're always in the front of the store
00:49:25 everywhere. And you cannot find it in the front of the store. And that tells me something dark
00:49:32 is going on. So I ask people buy it on Amazon. And my website, of course, is just my name,
00:49:36 ericmetaxas.com. You can find me there. But it's just a joy to be on your podcast. I feel
00:49:41 honored. Thank you very much. Thank you, Eric. Stay on the line so we can say goodbye.