00:10:04.320What's a plan for the future for land use and transportation needs?
00:10:13.500All of a sudden, talking about climate change, it turns out climate change is the entire
00:10:18.320framework upon which this document was prepared.
00:10:20.840so the capital planning region operates and and this is what it says in their document page six
00:10:27.460operates is the winnipeg metropolitan region the regional planning bylaw applies to the wmr again
00:10:35.000that's the winnipeg metropolitan region member municipalities including the city of winnipeg
00:10:40.220selkirk neverville stonewall village of donatar i'm not sure if i'm saying that properly
00:10:46.220Rural Municipalities of Carchet, East St. Paul, Headingley, MacDonald, Richo, Rockwood, Rosser, Springfield, St. Andrew, St. Clement, St. Francis, Tachet, and West St. Paul.
00:10:58.940So in all, there are 18 different municipalities in on this, and each one of those municipalities has got a representative on the board of directors, plus four provincial appointees.
00:11:12.040Do you know anything about how these people were appointed to this board?
00:11:17.820And who created this board in the first place?
00:13:35.400I'm not sure exactly what particular sections they don't abide to, but you don't have to abide to any based on the fact that they're exempt from it, which is really strange.
00:13:45.160like why would they be exempt why would the government say you don't even have to follow
00:13:50.000you're going to be incorporated but you don't have to follow the rules of corporations in the
00:13:54.340province so we've got a representative from each one of the 18 municipalities involved in the
00:14:02.740winnipeg metropolitan region including there are four appointees let me bring them up on the screen
00:14:08.540here for everybody to see you've got the wmr chair who is michael moore and he's a provincial
00:14:15.820employee what do we know about this fellow michael moore has been around for a long time
00:14:22.060in these types of roles uh not like not government exact government but offshoots like ngos non
00:14:28.700governmental organizations i first i think i first ran into michael in 99 maybe with the pan am games
00:14:36.540he was a worked on the staff i was on the board as a volunteer he was he had a fairly significant
00:14:44.300role i think in the pan american games in 99 then he resurfaced uh i might miss some of his positions
00:14:52.380but as the uh the guy the ceo for restaurants in manitoba mantel restaurant association
00:14:59.980and then later he was with the home builders association in a similar ceo role
00:15:04.780and then he's i think then he becomes part of the uh w uh mr so he he might have had some other
00:15:15.540positions in between those are the three that i remember the pan and games restaurant association
00:15:20.840home builders so he's a board jumper that's that's his role he goes around sharing boards
00:15:25.900that he has nothing real to do with no stake in the game yeah like he would be a classic
00:18:35.620There's a set of bylaws that the WMR has
00:18:38.800when they became active in April of 2023.
00:18:42.860They have a set of bylaws that they put in place that should actually just reflect the rules that were given to them through the legislation when they amended the Planning Act.
00:18:58.860But they added a couple extra things to there that I was sorting out today.
00:19:04.060And so these individuals were appointed by their own councils.
00:19:10.220So their councils would have picked one person from their council to sit on this as a board, as a director.
00:19:19.220And they would be, normally it looks like it's almost all mayors.
00:32:07.200somebody in an infraction on this bylaw or that bylaw,
00:32:10.800or some guy wants to get a variance to put a garage on his property that's what they deal with
00:32:16.080and all of a sudden the rules are not no longer made by them they're made by this the regional
00:32:22.240group and something that applies in the city of winnipeg would not necessarily apply in selker or
00:32:30.000in springfield or mcdonald so the whole like if i was a counselor and i'm reading this i'm going so
00:32:37.200why are we joining this group we're giving up all our authority we're we're like useless here
00:32:44.080to support greenhouse gas mitigation and advanced low carbon transportation options
00:32:49.520the winnipeg metropolitan region will pursue strategies and options that identify potential
00:32:55.920zero emission vehicle charging refueling corridors and identify opportunities to install and align
00:33:01.440supporting infrastructure so what have we got in this act ken that talks about um gas vehicles
00:33:10.040being restricted for travel on the highways and byways in this area yeah it's spread out a little
00:33:17.140bit it's not all in one spot i picked it up in different areas of the uh of the document but
00:33:22.360basically uh single occupancy vehicles like your regular car and that's as compared to a shared
00:33:30.980transportation what they call it mobility or some crazy terminology for but a bus versus a car
00:33:40.480bus good car bad if it's if it's if it's electric good anywhere but if it's gas fueled we have too
00:33:47.960many we have too many vehicles uh gas fueled vehicles and that's what's causing the climate
00:33:52.740change in the in the transportation plan by the city which was put up the same day a different
00:33:57.940document it's confusing they have a big pie chart and the pie chart shows 37 percent of carbon
00:34:04.860emission carbon dioxide emission that comes from cars and then it's got trucks 24 and then other
00:34:11.640things so the the city of winnipeg they said 37 that's the worst it's the biggest angle the biggest
00:34:19.340chunk of the pie is vehicles so obviously they're bad gotta get rid of them and i'm not sure where
00:34:25.140i read this but it said that they their goal was to get rid of 60 percent yeah of gas field vehicles
00:34:32.540i've read i don't have read that somewhere or in this document or somewhere else but
00:34:36.560that would be one of the un sort of sort of goals that would be attempting to achieve
00:34:42.780so this is not going to happen all at once just so everybody is clear on on this they're not going
00:34:49.740to suddenly want you know the next day after this thing gets approved they're not going to say your
00:34:54.120car is going to be impounded because it uses uh gas or diesel it's going to be a slow rollout
00:35:01.640it's still going to happen that's part of the plan but the language is flowery and when you
00:35:07.000read the document you really have to go through it and almost read between the lines and of course
00:35:11.320it's designed that way what about land use ken when we talk about land use you were talking
00:35:16.760about your own personal property and me the other day i thought that was a great example
00:35:20.280Yeah. So the land use thing is based on population density. So they have targets. And in this document, if you spend a lot of time on the pictures, on all the maps and things, you get a lot more information, a lot more detail.
00:35:37.220pretty much you know i'm an accountant and i know numbers are numbers and you can't really
00:35:41.760you know change a number so if it's a number you can sort of read it and say their target
00:35:47.520ultimate maximum density 370 people per acre and 250 people per acre in other zones is acceptable
00:36:01.140but one person per acre is not acceptable so I worked out some numbers on that like what's the
00:36:08.940current situation in Manitoba there's 160 million acres in our province and of that total we have
00:36:16.3001.3 to 1.4 million people so right now each person has about 114 acres each but we obviously
00:36:27.620we don't need 114 acres each so where's all the excess land going well it's parks beaches uh
00:36:34.500fishing places personal property i mean let's let's be honest you have golf courses that kind
00:36:43.440of thing right yeah all that kind of stuff so one of the reasons that manitoba is such a great place
00:36:49.020to live is just that we have so much space we have space so why would we want to cram people into
00:36:53.860little uh ghettos you know they call you know community complete communities now and not 150.96
00:37:02.100minute cities what would you do people don't want to live people like their yard they like to go sit
00:37:07.540and have a barbecue or cut their they cut in their grass and enjoying a little garden and things like
00:37:12.560that outside well this does not fit into the plan this is a waste of space people should be
00:37:18.300occupying it i mean they go as far as to suggest that if you're if you live in your house by
00:37:22.820yourself like i do you would have to bring people to live with you i'm not sure who who who gets
00:37:29.620designated to come and live with me but i don't want anybody here that's why i'm i'm kind of happy
00:37:33.740living here by myself yeah that that's it's in there that's part of this plan is to increase
00:37:39.740the density so that is the craziest part of this thing and this also is going to affect the people
00:37:46.880in the rural areas in the the rural municipalities they're going to have to have different density
00:37:51.900And I think a lot of the individual councils are fighting with this.
00:37:58.020You know, should a lot be one acre or two acres?
00:38:01.360Well, they're talking about, yeah, one acre.
00:38:03.480You can have like 250 people on it if it's properly populated.
00:38:10.040So let me ask you, this document, the wording of it, does it talk about existing structures and lands?
00:38:18.640or is this exclusive to new developments?
00:39:38.240Is there any talk about expropriation here?
00:39:41.000Yeah, so in the Planning Act, it talks about the powers that are given to them from the province.
00:39:51.020So the first part of the discussion on power and authority, it says that they have the right to buy, sell, lease, mortgage, real property, which is land and building.
00:40:06.320And then in the next sentence, it says personal property.
00:40:09.580Well, when you go look at the definition of personal property, it's all other property that's not real property.
01:09:12.660You guys had a conversation yesterday.
01:09:17.360Maggie, how up to date are you on this situation?
01:09:20.260Because I know that you've got all kinds of things going on in all kinds of areas of the country.
01:09:25.400Well, I'm trying to just review all the documents in between the other work that I'm doing.
01:09:34.140So I was able to read the official plan today, at least skim through it.
01:09:39.680What jumped out to me was the environmental section, of course.
01:09:44.560I always recommend going and looking at the environmental section because that is obviously where a lot of these sustainable development goals are coming in.
01:09:59.420It's kind of the portal, the gateway for it all.
01:10:02.120um ken you mentioned earlier what i had said on the levine show that oh you know don't worry too
01:10:09.320much we can always we can always pull it out at the root when when we get organized enough but
01:10:14.440you know when you see that environmental section and it's essentially an outline of the partners
01:10:20.480for climate protection program and their data collection and just really solidifying all of
01:10:27.200their goals into an official plan like that, then it really does get hard to, to back them out of
01:10:35.160it. You know, we could withdraw them from the program, but it's in their official plan at that
01:10:39.300point. So it makes it a bit harder. So I would definitely kick up a fuss about that and point
01:10:47.720to the origin of those, those mandates that they're trying to put into the official plan
01:10:55.820around the environment. And yeah, great suggestions tonight. I like the idea of the website
01:11:02.260and I'm going to the 18 different municipalities and having town halls. I would definitely
01:11:08.620recommend having a petition, having a really good clear idea of what, what it is that, you know,
01:11:14.660we can't just go in there and say, we don't like the whole thing, throw it all up. You know,
01:11:19.160it doesn't quite work like that, but if we can focus in, like we did Enduro Dumber on their
01:11:24.520official plan and say there's there's three problems with this plan well maybe we listed a
01:11:29.860few more and I could almost think of what the problems would be for that official plan that I
01:11:34.980would go for you know a lack of public consultation the fact that it was done by the staff essentially
01:11:40.920or this corporation and not the elected officials who are the ones who are supposed to be coming up
01:17:37.320thing we're thinking about getting some ads
01:17:39.180uh in on the back page or front page of some of those local newspapers and get the message out
01:17:44.580that way or announced billboards billboards do billboards like the guy tried to do billboards
01:17:49.100in toronto and they shut him down so he's taking him to the court uh court now
01:17:52.660that was about something different altogether maggie how important is it for because there's
01:18:00.100a lot of disparate groups in this area just like everywhere else you've got you know freedom people
01:18:04.460here freedom people there and they've been fighting and they don't get along and they
01:18:07.460call each other names and this person did this and this person did that how important is it now
01:18:13.520with something like this coming right down the pipe to for all of those groups to put that stuff
01:18:19.240aside and come together you know it's going to be the natural outcome is is the groups will come
01:18:25.600together and and they and that is what what i recommend we do is we start with a small group
01:18:32.280So we have Ken. Ken's going to find a couple of people to get together and and have meetings with and people like myself and you that kind of come along and support and guide and and and create that that campaign of awareness and, you know, those foundational concerns.
01:18:51.060And what will eventually happen is, is the groups will come together and they will, they will battle this similar enemy because it's on their doorstep. Right. And it's similar in British Columbia. I've been working with that group and I think it's going to be the same in every province.
01:19:08.700We have 20 to 50 different groups and organizations working in a province and something like this comes in and they all see it as as an important, you know, really important to get involved with because they know how important it is to address this at the local level now, I think, which is a great thing for our country to finally realize that we do have a voice and it's really at that local level.
01:19:36.740we can make a difference and um yeah it's it's definitely already bringing the groups together
01:19:42.380so i just hope and pray that in winnipeg that will be the result there and i think you're probably
01:19:50.300already seeing it people from the different groups are showing up and they're getting together they
01:19:55.340have a new enemy now right my enemy's enemy is my friend ken have you seen this merging of of the
01:20:03.880minds because i know that you've been involved in this almost since the beginning yeah i i never
01:20:09.760understood why people with similar backgrounds or similar feelings are fighting each other
01:20:17.740and i think it boils down to ego at some point in time and i think i've already seen it in this
01:20:24.820movement here some egos that are again in the way of things uh getting way of of getting together
01:20:31.000because you have to get together you have to collaborate you can't be duplicating the other's
01:20:35.700work if somebody's prepared to do something let them do it they don't have to oversee it or you
01:20:40.900know try to change it um but the other thing that shadow mentions is about people going and getting
01:20:47.760a little bit over the top at the meetings because all that's going to happen is that uh they're
01:20:53.700going to tag everybody with the same brush right they're going to say you're all the same you're0.95
01:20:57.280all a bunch of you know wackos and uh whatever right wing extremists knuckle draggers white0.92
01:21:04.000nationalists all of that yeah right yeah yeah so when i spoke first time i wore a jacket and a0.84
01:21:10.600nice shirt and kind of looked like an accountant for a change and uh did my thing about the guys
01:21:17.400looking what are you dressed like that for it's a funeral what else what else will i dress like
01:21:21.360this but you just want to you want to look like uh you're not a right-wing wild whatever although
01:21:29.340i am but i don't want to look like is there anything we've forgotten to mention so far
01:21:35.360tonight at all anything um i don't think so there's so much in here you could you could talk
01:21:42.920about these oh there's one thing uh when i was talking about all the power that this private
01:21:48.380corporation had about acquiring land and expropriating the land and then maybe selling
01:21:53.180it off and making a profit or or whatever the other power they have is they have the power to
01:21:59.740charge fees for services rendered so like a municipality can charge you you know 50 for a
01:22:08.580permit to build a garage well this group this private corporation is legislated to be able to
01:22:15.140charge fees so i thought that was kind of interesting so these these counselors that
01:22:21.180are in these various municipalities are going to cede their their invoicing rights to this
01:22:27.900private company in their municipality so again i found that to be rather here's here's something
01:22:35.040else that i just ran across in this winnipeg metro region spreadsheet here data collection