TRIGGERnometry - October 03, 2026


"Andy Burnham Is Away With The Fairies" – Andrew Neil

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Labour Conference, Diesel Shortage and Far Right Labradors - Off the Fence Andy Burnham Will Save Britain — He Just Has to Destroy It First - Konstantin Kisin

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 18 minutes

Words per minute

159.09

Word count

12,541

Sentence count

878

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

15

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I want to talk about something that men collectively pretend isn't an issue and collectively know
00:00:06 absolutely it is. Uncomfortable underwear. Sheath sorted it. Sheath.com. The dual pouch
00:00:12 system separates and supports everything properly. So you're not making constant adjustments or
00:00:17 dealing with chafing that by 3pm has become genuinely distracted. Trusted by fighters,
00:00:23 athletes, and veterans who don't have patience for gear that doesn't hold up. Speaking of
00:00:28 veterans. Sheath was founded by Robert Patton, who developed it during his second tour. That's
00:00:33 not a marketing angle. That's just the actual story. And 10,000 five-star reviews from men
00:00:39 who tried them and didn't go back suggest the product delivers on the idea. 100% money-back
00:00:45 guarantee on the first pair. There is no downside scenario here. Sheath.com, code trigonometry for
00:00:52 20% off. Try them once and the underwear you own right now will feel like a punishment by
00:00:57 comparison that's 20 discount code again it's trigonometry at sheath.com
00:01:03 it's the people who blame uh it's british attitudes to blame because the british people
00:01:12 think they can have scandinavian levels of cradle to the grave welfare on kind of mid-atlantic
00:01:22 taxes. And here's the thing, you can't. Although if people vote in a way that results in a right
00:01:28 of center government that might not deliver on all these things, if the country does vote
00:01:34 for the Andy Burnham prospectus, that's it. We are a socialist tax and spend future. There's
00:01:43 no going back from that. He believes that a bigger state means more growth. I hope he's
00:01:49 he's away with the fairies. 1.00
00:01:51 But that's his belief. 0.99
00:01:53 Why don't you think it's going to work?
00:01:54 Because I don't see anywhere in the world where it ever has.
00:01:59 So a crisis in the bond markets
00:02:01 could force this government into doing things it doesn't want to do.
00:02:05 I think we are heading for some really tough times.
00:02:10 Are you too popular? Is life too easy?
00:02:14 Then head over to our merch store and change your life forever
00:02:17 by telling the world you watch Trigonometry.
00:02:20 You'll be able to buy hoodies, T-shirts, caps, stickers, posters,
00:02:23 and, of course, the world-famous Trigonometry mug.
00:02:26 Go to shop.triggerpod.co.uk.
00:02:29 That's shop.triggerpod.co.uk,
00:02:31 and become part of the show.
00:02:34 Andrew Neal, welcome to Trigonometry.
00:02:36 Lovely to be here in the heart of Westminster.
00:02:38 Exactly. Thanks for giving away our location.
00:02:41 Thank you. Now we're going to get doxxed and protested and attacked.
00:02:44 Westminster's a big place.
00:02:45 Yeah.
00:02:46 And we're right next to Pimlico, as you know.
00:02:48 Exactly.
00:02:49 Thank you.
00:02:50 Strong star.
00:02:51 Andrew, what a pleasure.
00:02:53 We've been meaning to have you on for a long time.
00:02:56 We want to talk to you about the BBC later on.
00:02:58 But actually, I think with your experience
00:03:01 and with the sort of serious commentary you provide,
00:03:05 we'd love to just hear a very broad sweep of your thoughts
00:03:08 on actually what is happening in our country.
00:03:11 Okay.
00:03:12 Well, there's a lot happening, but not much of it very good.
00:03:16 I mean, I think politics has gone through a major change.
00:03:20 The story of 2025 was the rise of the insurgents on the left and the right.
00:03:26 Reform doing well, taking a lead in the polls.
00:03:29 The Greens coming up fast, causing Labour palpitations, overtaking the Lib Dems.
00:03:35 And so by this time last year, the Greens are well ahead of the Lib Dems.
00:03:40 Labour's really worried about them.
00:03:41 and reform is ahead in the polls, over 30%.
00:03:45 And when they get over 30%,
00:03:47 a lot of seats start to fall their way.
00:03:50 And that was then.
00:03:51 Now, here we are a year later,
00:03:54 and it's gone into reverse.
00:03:57 The Greens have had a bad year,
00:03:59 though not as well covered
00:04:00 as the bad year that reformers had.
00:04:03 And Mr. Farage, in particular,
00:04:05 and the problem with a one-man band
00:04:07 is if the one man has a bad year.
00:04:09 Well, if the one man is out of tune,
00:04:10 The whole band's out of tune, and that's been a problem for reform.
00:04:14 So you've seen, to my surprise, in a way, the re-emergence of the two legacy parties.
00:04:22 Labour has had a new lease of life under Andy Burnham.
00:04:26 They're now ahead in the polls, though not by much.
00:04:29 They're still in the 20s.
00:04:30 Kemi Badenoch, I think, has come through as a formidable Conservative leader.
00:04:33 Her problem is to get her growing popularity to rub off on her party, which is a very tarnished 0.99
00:04:42 brand. And that hasn't happened yet. But it is now down to Reform, Labour, Tory, the three. They're 0.91
00:04:50 all almost, with Labour that bit ahead, but they're almost all within statistical shouting distance of
00:04:56 each other. And that's a big change. And that's a return to a more familiar politics. In the
00:05:02 meantime, as that political change has been going on, the British economy has turned out to be much
00:05:09 more resilient in the face of Trump's war than I thought it would be. Nothing to write home about,
00:05:14 but then there's no economy was writing home about with the possible exception of America before the
00:05:20 war. And we've done not badly, just that the growth rate is redone again. I think that's about as good
00:05:26 as it's going to get. I think we are heading for some really tough times. I think this is going to
00:05:31 be a difficult winter, a winter of discontent, not in the old-fashioned way of strikes, but in terms
00:05:38 of we head into winter with rising inflation, rising interest rates, rising mortgages, no end
00:05:45 in sight with Trump's war, a new cost-of-living crisis coming down the pike with energy bills,
00:05:51 and with a political system that really doesn't know how to handle this. We're speaking in the
00:05:58 week of the Labour Party conference, in which neither the new Chancellor, John Healy, nor the
00:06:03 Prime Minister, Mr. Burnham, had anything to say about the winter in Storford. Nothing. It was all
00:06:10 about the next manifesto. And oh, looking back, I've got a miner's lamp on my shelf. And, you know,
00:06:17 this curious mixture of nostalgia and folklore that still dominates the Labour Party. And
00:06:25 how to deal with the cost of living crisis,
00:06:28 how to deal with other things that are going to be difficult,
00:06:31 what's rising interest rates,
00:06:33 how are you going to ever hit your housing target
00:06:34 if mortgages are rising?
00:06:36 None of that was done.
00:06:38 So we still, to me, clearly have major economic problems
00:06:41 in the political system
00:06:42 that is not up to providing the solutions.
00:06:44 Well, like you said,
00:06:45 there was a lot of very pleasant-sounding optimistic promises
00:06:49 about things that will be done primarily after the next election.
00:06:52 So it didn't seem like there was much of substance.
00:06:55 But the one thing that was completely missing, and appears to me to be completely missing more broadly from the conversation outside of a few people, is the debt and the deficit, which is continuing to increase it, and the fact that the yields are now higher than they were under List Trust, if I remember correctly.
00:07:13 They are, indeed.
00:07:14 So we are now in a position where we're spending huge amounts of money paying off the interest on the debt we already have, continuing to borrow more.
00:07:22 And now you have a prime minister who says we must undo everything that was done in the last 40 years, which means to go back to bigger government and more government intervention.
00:07:32 What does that mean for us economically?
00:07:34 It means that we're in trouble, and that it means he wants a bigger state and higher taxation
00:07:40 at a time when we have the highest tax burden in peacetime already, and the state already
00:07:47 accounts for about 45% of our GDP, which is also high by modern times.
00:07:52 So he wants to go, instead of saying, well, taxes are too high, the state's too big, it's
00:07:58 not very good at what a lot of it does, let's pare it back, let's have lower taxes, let's
00:08:02 have a state which concentrates on doing what the state can do and do it well rather than trying to
00:08:08 do everything he wants to move in the opposite direction and no politician is very keen in
00:08:14 talking much about the national debt or about the budget deficit which every year adds to that debt
00:08:21 because they don't know what to do about it i mean in america fiscal conservatism is dead
00:08:26 no one talks about it on the republican or the democrat side and their national debt is now 40
00:08:31 trillion, $40 trillion. Nobody even knows what that means. I just think it's a lot.
00:08:38 Ronald Reagan once said to me, he said, you know, Andrew, a billion here, a billion there,
00:08:44 it soon adds up to real money. Well, it's now a trillion here, a trillion there. And we've got
00:08:50 a developing fiscal crisis on the other side of the channel, Francis. Got some real problems at
00:08:55 the moment which haven't been much covered. So Britain's not alone in this, but Britain is
00:09:00 peculiarly vulnerable to it. We still pay a moron premium thanks to the brilliant work of Liz Truss 0.98
00:09:09 during that short period that I call the cluster truss. I could call it something ruder, but I know 0.97
00:09:15 this is a family show. So I think the cluster truss will do. And rather than take steps that
00:09:21 would recognize that, Rachel Reeves, a Starmer, and now Mr. Healy and Mr. Burnham are going to
00:09:29 add to that. They're going to add to the amount of spending. They're going to add to the amount
00:09:34 of debt. And that's a pretty dangerous thing to do, because at the moment, the bond markets,
00:09:41 which is where governments go to borrow, are pretty skittish about everybody, which is why
00:09:47 there has been a global rise in the price you have to pay if you're a government to get your
00:09:53 debt away. The 30-year bonds in America this year just reached a new record, the highest since 2002.
00:10:00 This year, our 10-year bonds, the government yesterday in Britain borrowed another 4 billion
00:10:06 and it had to pay, it's a 10-year bond, it's a guilt as they're called in Britain, it's a 10-year
00:10:13 guilt, and we had to pay the highest interest rate since 1999. So you can get the debt away,
00:10:20 But you're having to pay more.
00:10:22 And of course, down the road,
00:10:23 you have to pay more on debt interest all the time.
00:10:26 And it's already $110 billion.
00:10:28 If debt interest was a government department,
00:10:31 it would be the third biggest government department in Britain.
00:10:33 And you have to pay it.
00:10:35 And you have to find the money for it.
00:10:37 And we're particularly vulnerable
00:10:39 because the bond markets are already making us pay more for our debt
00:10:44 than any other G7 country.
00:10:46 and we still have more inflation built into our system
00:10:51 than Europe or the United States.
00:10:55 And it's that inflation that nudges up interest rates
00:10:58 because, you know, if inflation's 3%
00:11:03 and you're being asked to lend the government money,
00:11:06 you're going to want a lot more than 3% to get...
00:11:08 I mean, 3% just keeps it...
00:11:11 You don't make any money out of that at all.
00:11:13 And so that combination of our past record, the size of our debt, the size of our deficit, and the fact that inflation is kind of built into the system in Britain now means that the bond markets have us in the crosshairs more than anybody else.
00:11:34 So come the budget, this government better be very careful what it does.
00:11:38 If it tries to fiddle or be smart with the fiscal rules, they will pay a big penalty.
00:11:44 And as will we all.
00:11:46 But I think it's inevitable that they will do that, given what we've already talked about,
00:11:50 the tack towards more government, more spending, etc.
00:11:54 And I've been a bit of an accelerationist in all of this for a while,
00:11:59 which I think it seems to me the British public are not willing to make the adjustments
00:12:03 that we're going to have to reckon with the massive debt and the deficit.
00:12:08 And a Burnham-led fiscal crisis is, as far as I can see,
00:12:13 the only way that we're ever going to get back to some sanity.
00:12:16 Is this a bad theory, a good theory?
00:12:19 Well, I think you're right that no one's going to do very much without a crisis.
00:12:26 And people are only going to tinker.
00:12:28 Yeah.
00:12:29 And although the government claims that the deficit is on a downward trajectory, not quite
00:12:37 clear that it is.
00:12:38 I mean, we've already overborrowed in the first five, six months of this fiscal year.
00:12:43 And we could end up borrowing as much this year as we did last year, which would be about
00:12:47 $130 billion on top of the $3 trillion.
00:12:50 So that doesn't send a great signal.
00:12:53 And no one's got much appetite to do it because they're all between a rock and a hard place.
00:12:58 cutting public spending seems to be beyond the pale for this government,
00:13:03 even though that would be a natural way to start.
00:13:06 Their own backbenchers won't let them.
00:13:07 They won't let them, because you kill Starmer.
00:13:09 Tried in a minor way, one of the reasons why he's no longer prime minister.
00:13:13 British government now spends about £1.4 trillion a year,
00:13:18 but we're not going to touch spending.
00:13:20 And there was no mention at the Labour conference of any kind of spending cuts at all.
00:13:26 So what do you then do?
00:13:27 borrow more, the scope for borrowing more is going to be very, very limited, if anything,
00:13:34 because it's not a case that you can't borrow. But the more you borrow, the more the markets
00:13:40 will demand a risk premium. So you'll end up paying more and more and more interest in your
00:13:46 debt service costs will rise and rise. So where does that leave? Well, it leaves tax.
00:13:51 And at the moment in the Treasury, they're scampering around trying to find various ways
00:13:58 of increasing taxes because the government has ruled out an increase in income tax, VAT,
00:14:05 and national insurance contributions of employees. These are by far the three biggest tax revenue
00:14:11 sources. So if you haven't got access to them, you start to look at all sorts of other things
00:14:16 and it's the worst possible way to handle taxation
00:14:20 because small tax rises by definition don't raise much
00:14:26 and they're nearly all bad.
00:14:28 They nearly all screw things up in ways you didn't foresee.
00:14:31 They complicate what's already the biggest tax code in the world.
00:14:36 Our tax code is longer than anybody else's.
00:14:39 An accountant who wanted to print it out and bring it to you
00:14:41 would need a wheelbarrow.
00:14:43 That's how big it is.
00:14:44 So the more tax cuts you have, small tinkering here, there, mansion tax.
00:14:50 Remember George Osborne's pasty tax and all the rest of it.
00:14:53 It's the worst possible way to raise money, but they have no money.
00:14:57 They won't cut.
00:14:57 They can't borrow.
00:14:59 And so that's what we're going to have.
00:15:00 And that will set the economy back even more.
00:15:03 So there may come a point.
00:15:05 I don't think it'll be triggered in Britain, but it could be triggered by a loss of faith
00:15:10 in America or by a bond crisis in France.
00:15:14 and that will wave up against us.
00:15:17 And just as the IMF forced the government into drastic cuts in 1976
00:15:23 when we last had a tax and spend Labour government,
00:15:26 so a crisis in the bond markets could force this government
00:15:30 into doing things it doesn't want to do.
00:15:32 And Andrew, we went around at the time of the last one.
00:15:35 What does that look like for ordinary people?
00:15:37 People watching this and listening to this,
00:15:39 what does that mean will happen for them?
00:15:42 What happened last time was that the British government ran out of dollars.
00:15:49 In these days, it borrowed in dollars.
00:15:51 We don't have that problem today.
00:15:52 We borrow in pounds, so there's no exchange rate exposure.
00:15:56 But it borrowed in dollars, the pound collapsed, and it couldn't raise the dollars to pay back
00:16:01 in dollars.
00:16:02 So it had to go to the IMF, the International Monetary Fund, essentially American, run
00:16:07 for a dollar loan, which was about three billion pounds worth of dollars to pay back the dollar
00:16:15 loans. But the price the IMF said for that was that we want major cuts in public spending
00:16:22 right across the board. And so it was two things. It was humility, humiliating that here was one of
00:16:30 the great countries, great economies of the world having to go to the IMF to borrow. IMF was meant
00:16:37 for third world countries and places that needed help in difficult times.
00:16:42 And that at foreign demand, we had to take huge chunks out of the budget.
00:16:49 It was a very, very humiliating time for the country, for the Labour government,
00:16:55 and it never really recovered from it.
00:16:57 It never really recovered.
00:16:59 I mean, look, we can blame politicians all we want,
00:17:04 But there's the adage, which we all know,
00:17:06 is that you get the politicians you deserve.
00:17:09 How much do we all have to take responsibility for this?
00:17:12 Because we all know that Burnham,
00:17:16 it doesn't matter who it is in charge,
00:17:17 once they start implementing these kind of cuts
00:17:21 and the state starts shrinking,
00:17:22 there's a very real risk they'll get voted out.
00:17:25 Exactly.
00:17:26 It's the people who blame.
00:17:28 It's British attitudes to blame
00:17:30 because the British people think
00:17:33 they can have Scandinavian levels of cradle-to-the-grave welfare
00:17:39 on kind of mid-Atlantic taxis.
00:17:44 You know, higher than America, but a lot lower than Europe.
00:17:51 And here's the thing, you can't,
00:17:53 particularly once you've run out of space for borrowing.
00:17:56 And in a way, the European left has always been more honest
00:18:00 than the British left.
00:18:01 The European left has always said,
00:18:03 look, if you want all this welfare, that's fine.
00:18:05 We're in favor of that.
00:18:07 But everybody's going to have to pay higher taxes,
00:18:09 not just the rich.
00:18:11 Everybody's going to pay higher taxes
00:18:13 from low to middle earners onwards,
00:18:16 because that's where the real money is.
00:18:18 The British left says, no, you can have all of that
00:18:21 and we'll only tax the top 5%.
00:18:23 Even Jeremy Corbyn, he said,
00:18:26 we'll just tax the top 5%. 1.00
00:18:27 We'll just get the non-toms.
00:18:30 Well, just get these rich millionaires that don't pay any tax.
00:18:34 And two things, or three things, the problem with that is,
00:18:38 one, the affluent in this country actually pay a lot of tax.
00:18:42 The top 1% account for almost 30% of income tax receipts.
00:18:49 So they're already paying quite a lot.
00:18:51 And the top 10%, I think 60%.
00:18:53 That's right.
00:18:53 so if you tax them too much and they walk out the door
00:18:59 and there is nobody more mobile
00:19:01 than a well-educated English-speaking professional
00:19:04 they walk out the door, your tax base walks out the door with it
00:19:08 we have a tax base more skewed to the rich paying tax
00:19:11 than any economy in Europe
00:19:13 so that's your tax base that you risk walking out the door
00:19:18 And yet we think that it can all be financed by not us paying more tax. Somebody else would pay
00:19:28 more tax. And it's become a kind of free ride. Plus, there's been a psychological change.
00:19:35 We've fallen back in love with big government. You know, it took Mrs. Thatcher quite a while to
00:19:43 shake the government's addiction, of the people's addiction to big government. But she did it in
00:19:51 the end. And Blair and Brown built on her legacy. And they did not increase the size of the state
00:19:57 by very much at all. And they didn't increase taxes by very much. They didn't increase income
00:20:02 tax rates at all until Brown decided to leave a little bomb for the incoming government in the
00:20:08 last minute, but that's not what we've done now. I think two things happened in recent history.
00:20:14 One was that the previous Conservative government, under Mr. Cameron and then the shambles of
00:20:20 Prime Ministers that followed, actually lost faith with the Thatcher legacy and began to move
00:20:28 away from it, began to leave less in markets, to leave less in competition. I mean, they stitched
00:20:35 up the energy market, so it's effectively run by government. That was done under them now.
00:20:40 And then COVID came. And COVID is like a war. War equals big government. It's the only way you can
00:20:47 win. COVID was the same. It's a pandemic. We need big government. We need a scheme to pay people
00:20:54 when they're not working. And then Ukraine came. And that was a war. And that had a huge energy 0.99
00:21:00 crisis, more big government, now subsidies for household energy bills. Boris Johnson was a big
00:21:06 government conservative. Donald Trump is a big government conservative as well. And so suddenly
00:21:11 big government is fashionable again. But the thing the British don't seem to realize, they rather
00:21:16 like big government. They don't say, you're doing too much. They say, well, you're doing that. Why
00:21:20 can't you do that? Why can't you do that? That's become the culture. And the problem with that is
00:21:26 that in the end, government tries to do too much, and it ends up doing almost everything badly.
00:21:34 And the idea that government should do only what government has to do and do it well,
00:21:41 which is a kind of Thatcherite, Jeffersonian view of government, that's gone by the board.
00:21:48 And yet, although as night follows day, high taxes follow big government, in the end, you
00:21:56 can't have one without the other. But we don't seem to accept that. We think, no, we can have
00:22:02 big government, but only that rich guy around the corner. He needs to pay more tax. I don't need to
00:22:07 pay more tax. Why should I pay? I'd pay a lot of tax already. And so I think the whole cultural
00:22:13 attitude of the country is out of kilter for taking whoever's in power, of taking the right
00:22:20 decisions that would get us back onto an even keel. I assumed selling the merch would be the
00:22:25 hard part of running the trigonometry store. Checkout is, and Shopify had already solved that
00:22:31 before we even launched. I'm not what you call a natural businessman. And yet, the trigonometry
00:22:36 store somehow works, mostly because Shopify built the hard part before we ever opened it. Because
00:22:41 the moment someone's actually ready to pay, Shopify makes sure they can. And if they've bought before,
00:22:46 their details are already saved, so it's one tap and done. That's time back to grow the business
00:22:51 instead of running it. If you want to start the same way, that's shopify.co.uk slash trigger.
00:22:56 With Shopify, nothing stands between your idea and a real business. So go make it one. Start
00:23:02 your free trial at shopify.co.uk slash trigger. Start your free trial at shopify.co.uk slash
00:23:09 trigger. And it also strikes me that there's a real politics of envy going on. You see it
00:23:16 online, there's a real hatred of the top 1%, as if the rest of the people feel that they've
00:23:22 been cheated by people earning more money than them. It strikes me, actually, as quite un-British.
00:23:30 Well, it's un-British, and it's kind of stupid as well, because there's a kind of 1.00
00:23:34 implication that this person has only become a billionaire by screwing you. Well, where's 0.99
00:23:41 the evidence for that? You know, in a way, you would want more billionaires if they're creating
00:23:45 more jobs and investing and creating more people.
00:23:49 I mean, we're boasting at the moment because our high-tech sector is a lot better than
00:23:54 we think it is because we're always so down on ourselves.
00:23:57 I mean, we have more unicorns, which is a high-tech startup worth a billion.
00:24:04 We have more unicorns than the three biggest unicorn markets combined in Europe, more than
00:24:11 the three biggest combined.
00:24:13 That's a success story.
00:24:14 But the culture doesn't treat it as a success.
00:24:17 The culture is, well, why are you so rich?
00:24:19 Why am I not?
00:24:20 But then we have politicians who pander to that.
00:24:23 And previous Tory governments have pander to that as well.
00:24:26 You want more wealth.
00:24:28 I mean, it's very interesting that in Andy Burnham's speech,
00:24:32 there wasn't a single word about wealth creation
00:24:35 or what generates wealth.
00:24:38 Not a single word about promoting enterprise.
00:24:40 Not a single word about encouraging businesses
00:24:43 and getting more competition.
00:24:45 Everything that gives you the revenue, the resource
00:24:49 to then spend on schools and hospitals and better roads
00:24:53 and a better health service and so on.
00:24:56 And we've got a political culture now
00:24:59 which is obsessed with cutting up the cake.
00:25:02 You can have just that bit.
00:25:04 I'm going to have this bit.
00:25:05 You can have anything.
00:25:06 You've got enough.
00:25:07 Rather than a set of policies that will say,
00:25:12 hey, how do we make this cake bigger?
00:25:15 And then there'll be more to go around for everybody.
00:25:18 I mean, there's one thing that we're ignoring here.
00:25:20 And there's plenty of people who are watching this
00:25:22 who are on the left.
00:25:23 And to be fair, they've got a point.
00:25:25 And they're going to go, Andrew, come on, be fair.
00:25:27 What about the economic crash 2008?
00:25:30 That was a really devastating effect on our economy.
00:25:34 Wages haven't really grown since then.
00:25:37 That isn't people's fault.
00:25:38 They're still going out.
00:25:39 They're still working hard.
00:25:40 I think that's true.
00:25:42 And I think the long tail, the long shadow of the great financial crash of 2008 has been
00:25:52 seriously underappreciated.
00:25:54 You see, the great fear in 2008 when this crash took place was that that crash, as in
00:26:04 1929, would morph into a Great Depression, as it did in the 1930s.
00:26:11 America lost a quarter of its GDP, 25% of the labor force.
00:26:15 America unemployed.
00:26:17 Times of huge hardship in this country, in South Wales, Clydeside, and north of England.
00:26:25 And so all of the policy work went into trying to stop that from happening.
00:26:32 And the solution, and it was the right solution, was QE, quantities of easing,
00:26:37 the printing, electronic printing of money.
00:26:40 Not helicopter money that you just drop
00:26:43 and you never get back,
00:26:44 but money in a way that you put into the system
00:26:46 and then when it's done,
00:26:48 you begin to take it out again.
00:26:50 It was a very sophisticated way.
00:26:52 Ben Bernanke, who'd written the definitive book
00:26:55 on the crash of 1929,
00:26:57 we were lucky he was chairman
00:26:59 of the Federal Reserve at the time.
00:27:01 That was the right thing to do,
00:27:03 but it had a consequence.
00:27:05 Because all that money,
00:27:06 let's just take Britain.
00:27:07 The Bank of England bought £875 billion worth of bonds from the banks and other institutional
00:27:20 investors.
00:27:21 It put these bonds onto its balance sheet and it put the money onto the bank's balance
00:27:27 sheet.
00:27:27 So the theory that they'll lend more, they'll get the money into the system.
00:27:32 Now, it stopped the Great Depression, and that should not be underestimated.
00:27:36 but that money had to find a place to go. And of course, where does it go? It goes into assets.
00:27:43 It goes into stocks and shares and property and companies. And who has these assets? People who
00:27:50 are already pretty well off, who've already got a big house in London, have already got a stock
00:27:55 and share portfolio. And you had a situation where, to put it bluntly, a little bit unsophisticated,
00:28:02 but it's good enough. The people who had caused the crash, the big financial institutions,
00:28:09 were suddenly doing incredibly well again, with all this money was now on their balance sheet.
00:28:14 They had to spend, you had a 10 million pound house in London, it was now 14 million, 15 million.
00:28:20 And the people who'd done nothing to cause the crash, the workers, people on a wage,
00:28:26 were seeing their wages not rising at all, and they were living week to week or month to month.
00:28:32 So, of course, resentment was about to burn.
00:28:34 They were right.
00:28:35 And we didn't see this happening quickly enough.
00:28:38 We dined out on the fact,
00:28:40 we've stopped a great recession.
00:28:42 Thank God.
00:28:43 Isn't that a great achievement?
00:28:44 We've done better than the 30s.
00:28:46 We didn't see the consequences for quite some time
00:28:50 of the resentment that was building up
00:28:54 among those who hadn't caused the crash,
00:28:57 but were suffering,
00:28:59 looking at those who had caused the crash,
00:29:02 and doing better than ever before.
00:29:06 And then you add in mass migration on top of that,
00:29:11 which made life more difficult for blue-collar workers as well,
00:29:15 and helped to depress wages,
00:29:17 which were already depressed badly enough.
00:29:20 And you had a situation where the politics of it turned sour.
00:29:26 And ordinary people begin to think,
00:29:28 hey, nobody's listening to me anymore.
00:29:30 Why am I being penalized?
00:29:31 And I believe that if it wasn't for that long tail, that dark shadow of the great crash, there would not have been Brexit. We would not have voted to leave in 2016. And Donald Trump would not have won in 2016.
00:29:49 Both these votes were the revenge of what my old mentor, Alistair Burnett, who was editor of The Economist, used to call, with reverence, plain folk in the nicest sense of the word, the plain, decent people of this country.
00:30:04 They were the rebellion of the plain folk of this country against the elites who had caused so many of our problems, but were still doing so well.
00:30:16 And it has continued since, and it explains the rise of the National Rally of Le Pen in France and also of the AFD in Germany, of the Sweden Democrats in Sweden, not the Social Democrats, the Sweden Democrats, of Madame Maloney's party in Italy.
00:30:33 It's had an enormous political impact,
00:30:36 which is not over yet, which is still there.
00:30:39 Well, as you say, I mean, it's clear we're living
00:30:41 in the age of populism, both left and right,
00:30:44 across the European continent.
00:30:46 What's interesting to me about what you were just talking about
00:30:48 is the cyclical nature of things,
00:30:49 because people say that great financial institutions
00:30:51 caused the crash, but I think it's clear
00:30:54 that it was the repealing of Glass-Steagall in the US
00:30:56 and also some of the laws around financial regulations
00:30:59 in this country that meant that they were able
00:31:02 to do the things that had been previously been illegal. And those things were brought in after
00:31:07 the 1929 crash. So we seem to go around in circles. And to me, this leap into, I mean,
00:31:14 the left used to deny they won socialism, but I think now they're openly championing it. And that's
00:31:20 what you saw at the Labour conference. Oh, I don't think there's any doubt about that. I mean,
00:31:24 Andy Burnham laid out the most explicit tax and spend socialism of any Labour leader.
00:31:32 other than the brief Corbyn interregnum,
00:31:34 and he never really spelled out very well.
00:31:37 I think you have to go back to the 1970s,
00:31:39 and even the 1970s, they weren't so explicit about it.
00:31:44 And I think you can like it or dislike it,
00:31:46 but the one thing you can't say is that we don't know what he stands for.
00:31:50 We now know what he stands for, it's quite clear.
00:31:52 We now know what he meant by rolling back 40 years of neoliberalism.
00:31:57 It was kind of unclear if that was just a buzz phrase.
00:31:59 What the hell is neoliberalism?
00:32:00 Andrew, have you worked out what that means yet? Because I hear a lot of people saying
00:32:04 neoliberalism. What does it mean? It means the end of the Thatcher settlement.
00:32:08 Right. So Thatcherism was neoliberalism in that conception.
00:32:12 Well, that's what he's called. No one called it that at the time. I mean, nobody other than
00:32:16 policy wonks call it that at any time. But neoliberalism is meant to be an updated version
00:32:23 of 19th century liberal economics,
00:32:26 of free markets, limited government, and sound money.
00:32:32 And it gets neo because in a modern sense,
00:32:35 it's always going to be that bit different
00:32:37 in a sophisticated modern economy.
00:32:40 And he was quite explicit.
00:32:42 Today, he wants the state to control housing.
00:32:46 I don't quite know how you do that,
00:32:48 but he wants the state to control housing.
00:32:50 Do you mean rent controls by that?
00:32:51 No, well, he may. 1.00
00:32:53 But I think he means more council house building, but more control of private landlords. 1.00
00:33:02 If you're a private landlord they don't like, then they want the right to come and take your property away.
00:33:08 He said that explicitly in his speech.
00:33:12 He wants to control energy, for the state to control energy.
00:33:16 He wants the state to control water and other utilities.
00:33:22 And at the same time, he wants the state to grow in size.
00:33:26 And he knows that taxes will have to rise to pay for that.
00:33:29 So it's a quite, it's a big change.
00:33:33 Now, the fact is that Thatcherism and the way it was consolidated
00:33:37 under Blair and Brown, very cleverly, I think,
00:33:40 was already beginning to erode, ironically,
00:33:43 under the previous Tory government.
00:33:45 They had lost faith in it.
00:33:46 And Boris Johnson, in particular, when he came along completely,
00:33:49 You know, he was just obsessed with big government.
00:33:52 I mean, was he wanting to build a tunnel under the Irish Sea at one stage?
00:33:57 You know, I mean, it was all because someone had to tell him
00:33:59 there's a really deep ditch in the Irish Sea.
00:34:02 It's not quite easy to build a tunnel.
00:34:04 So that was already underway, the flight from a largely market-led economy
00:34:12 with huge social underpinning.
00:34:15 Nobody denies that.
00:34:16 Social market economy is the best way to describe it.
00:34:19 And Andy Burnham wants to finish the job.
00:34:23 He wants a bigger state in everything.
00:34:24 He wants the state to be the guiding light.
00:34:27 He believes that a bigger state means more growth.
00:34:30 That's his theory of growth.
00:34:33 He doesn't have a plan for growth, but he has a theory of growth.
00:34:36 He believes that a combination of more state intervention,
00:34:42 ideally of state ownership, where he can't afford that,
00:34:45 like the water companies, then more state control.
00:34:48 uh more state control more state ownership coupled with a dash of burnham type devolution
00:34:57 where you empower not just the central state but the local mayors or whatever the government is
00:35:03 that's his theory of growth he believes that will bring growth back my own view is he's away with 0.99
00:35:11 the fairies but that's his belief why don't you think it's going to work because i don't see 0.97
00:35:18 anywhere in the world, where it ever has. Indeed, the whole lesson of social democracy 0.93
00:35:24 in continental Europe of the late 20th and early 21st century is that social democracy
00:35:35 works really well in encouraging business and enterprise and of spreading the wealth
00:35:44 through the country, provided you don't let the state get too big. You don't let the state become
00:35:51 ubiquitous. You don't try to control everything. I mean, if you look at the history of the Swedish
00:35:57 Social Democrats, they did gangbusters as long as they didn't let the state get too big, and then
00:36:03 they lost it. And the state got bigger and bigger and bigger. They started talking about taking over
00:36:09 companies and giving unions a stake in companies and controlling them. And the whole thing fell
00:36:15 apart in the 80s and 90s. So I don't know anywhere. And look, I look at a country like France,
00:36:23 where the state is much bigger than it is. The state accounts for 56% of France's GDP.
00:36:28 It's still only 45 in hours. And I look at Germany, where the state is big as well.
00:36:33 And if state ownership and state control equaled economic growth,
00:36:41 Germany and France would be booming.
00:36:44 And they're not even growing.
00:36:46 They're growing even more slowly than we are.
00:36:49 So I see no correlation, unlike Mr. Burnham's theory of growth,
00:36:55 between more state control, more state ownership,
00:36:59 a bigger state in economic growth.
00:37:02 Indeed, I see the opposite, that there comes a time when the state is so big, it's a dampener on growth.
00:37:08 It becomes a hindrance to growth, and that's where we are now.
00:37:15 And what that leads to, as we've touched on before, is the rise of populism.
00:37:19 Now, you know, before you could sort of dismiss it, maybe it was just one person here or one person over there.
00:37:26 But you're looking at Europe, and there's a very real chance.
00:37:32 I mean, the AFD are going to do very, very well.
00:37:35 Well, they've already won two state elections.
00:37:37 So there may be a chance of them getting actually into power,
00:37:41 significant, real power.
00:37:43 Harder to see, because you can't form a government in Germany
00:37:46 without doing a coalition, and nobody will deal with them.
00:37:49 But it doesn't mean to say they will not.
00:37:50 If an election was held tomorrow in Germany,
00:37:53 they would have almost the same number of seats
00:37:58 as the social democrats and the christian democrats combined
00:38:01 and although there would be nobody to deal with them to form a government
00:38:05 they would have huge influence on whoever the government was
00:38:08 so they are a rising power
00:38:10 and not just in the east which is their traditional heartland
00:38:13 so that's what's happening in europe
00:38:15 sorry andrew we'll just go back to with the afd
00:38:18 can you just because i don't know and i want everybody says they're far right
00:38:22 what actually are they
00:38:23 Although, you know, people throw around the words hard right in all sorts of things.
00:38:28 Reform in this country is called hard right.
00:38:31 Le Pen's national rally in France is still called hard right.
00:38:35 Maloney sometimes in Italy is still called hard right.
00:38:39 The AFD is hard right.
00:38:41 That is a hard right party.
00:38:43 Can you define the term for us, Andrew?
00:38:45 Because here, like you say, I hear conservative politicians being described as hard right.
00:38:49 It's ethno-nationalist.
00:38:51 It basically wants to round up people
00:38:53 who weren't born in Germany and get rid of them.
00:38:56 It's an ethno-nationalist party 0.71
00:38:58 with the added tweak of being very pro-Kremlin.
00:39:02 Quite remarkable that the right,
00:39:04 the populist right, has this soft spot
00:39:06 for Mr. Putin's Russia.
00:39:08 You know, you saw a bit of that in reform.
00:39:11 Le Pen's party was pretty close.
00:39:14 I mean, she's managed to get away from that.
00:39:17 Mrs. Maloney in Italy
00:39:19 has not done that.
00:39:22 She's been very solid for Ukraine.
00:39:24 But her party, the Brotherhood of Italy party,
00:39:28 is very pro-Kremlin on that.
00:39:30 But the bigger issue,
00:39:32 coming back to this era of big government,
00:39:35 is that the populist left and the populist right,
00:39:40 they both believe in big government.
00:39:42 They don't go out left, right, in a horizontal line.
00:39:47 They come in a circle.
00:39:48 though, if you look at the economic policies of Le Pen in France and of Mélenchon, who's the
00:39:54 populist left equivalent, who seems to have been around forever, they're not that different. They
00:40:00 want big government. They don't like big business. They want protectionism. So that means that even
00:40:07 the populists, you know, in the old days, the radical right meant Reaganite or Thatcherite,
00:40:13 and that would take on big government. That would cut taxes, reduce government,
00:40:16 get the enterprise animal spirits going again. It's not the populace, right?
00:40:22 If you own gold, you probably bought it for the same reason I did, because you looked at what
00:40:27 central banks are doing to currencies and decided you wanted something they can't print. Good
00:40:32 reasoning. But here's the thing nobody talks about after you make that decision. Your gold is just
00:40:37 sitting there. It's not doing anything. You're paying to store it. You're paying to insure it.
00:40:41 and in the meantime it earns precisely nothing until now what you're about to hear is not a
00:40:47 normal gold advert today's sponsor is monetary metals they've figured out something that once
00:40:52 you hear it seems obvious but almost nobody in the gold world is doing it monetary metals connects
00:40:59 gold owners with productive businesses refiners jewelers companies that actually need physical
00:41:05 gold to operate those businesses lease your gold and pay you a yield not in dollars not in pounds
00:41:12 in gold so instead of your gold sitting in a vault costing you money it's out in the real economy
00:41:18 doing something useful and you're earning more ounces of gold for it up to four percent annual
00:41:23 yield paid in gold if you already own gold this is the logical next step visit monetary-metals.com
00:41:30 slash trigonometry, or click the link in the description. See how your gold can stop costing
00:41:36 you money and start earning you more gold. That's monetary-metals.com slash trigonometry.
00:41:42 Well, it's interesting because I don't know what your opinion on this. It'd be interesting to
00:41:46 discuss this in terms of this country being perhaps the exception, because certainly the
00:41:50 people at the top of reform, the populist right-wing party in this country, we've had them
00:41:55 all on Nigel Farage, Soella Bravham, and Robert Jenner. And I've always asked them this question
00:41:59 because to me this is fascinating about the difference between all of them
00:42:04 who are clearly Thatcherites and believe in small government and low taxes
00:42:07 and a lot of their newly acquired voter base
00:42:10 who are far to the left of them on economics.
00:42:13 On economics, that's right.
00:42:15 Right.
00:42:15 So the question is, are we perhaps the outlier
00:42:19 in that we do actually in this country have a populist right-wing alternative
00:42:23 which believes in small government still?
00:42:25 I'm not sure it does because although you're quite right,
00:42:28 Nigel Farage is basically a Thatcherite.
00:42:31 I think Richard Tice, I think he's the deputy leader,
00:42:34 he's basically a Thatcherite.
00:42:36 But they come up against the people whose votes they need.
00:42:39 And so you end up, these Thatcherites saying,
00:42:42 well, actually, I think we should abolish
00:42:45 the two-child limit of welfare.
00:42:48 And Farage came out in favour of abolishing it,
00:42:51 which is what Labour did.
00:42:52 You've seen here the triple lock,
00:42:54 which Andy Burnham has had the guts to do something about.
00:42:57 Oh, no reform is attacking that.
00:42:59 You know, they say they're Thatcherite,
00:43:01 but they're actually the party of big welfare
00:43:02 because the Red Wall,
00:43:04 they're worried that the Red Wall's in favor of welfare,
00:43:06 so they don't want to do anything to piss off the Red Wall.
00:43:09 So although our populist right,
00:43:12 first of all, is nowhere near as right as anything like the AFD.
00:43:16 I mean, I think for that,
00:43:17 you have to go more to restore parties like that.
00:43:21 And it isn't as right on economic.
00:43:22 I think you are right.
00:43:23 It's not as obsessed with the big government
00:43:26 as the populist right in continental Europe.
00:43:30 But it's, and it's instincts of what you say they are,
00:43:33 they are more small government.
00:43:35 But at the end of the day,
00:43:36 it looks as if it's potential constituency,
00:43:37 and so you don't get the benefit of that.
00:43:39 Well, this is where we come back
00:43:40 to both my and France's point,
00:43:42 which is it's ultimately up to the people of this country
00:43:45 who want big government.
00:43:46 And it looks to me like they're going to get it good and hard.
00:43:49 And until we all learn the lesson
00:43:51 of what happens when you do that,
00:43:53 we're going to be trapped in the situation.
00:43:55 Well, we're in an interesting time. We've just come out of the Labour Party conference in Liverpool. And the Tory party conference in Birmingham is going to open in the upcoming weekend and go into the earlier part of next week.
00:44:11 And I think now the interesting thing we see, how do the Conservatives position themselves?
00:44:17 They are now up against a clearly tax and spend socialist government.
00:44:24 So do they now say this is our chance to rediscover our Thatcherite roots?
00:44:31 And of course, bring them into a modern setting and modern issues, which I would guess is
00:44:37 probably came a bit in North's instincts, but can she bring the party with her? Is she prepared to
00:44:44 take unpopular decisions, even unpopular policies that might not in the short run have a lateral
00:44:51 advantage? But I think sometimes you have to have the courage and the faith in your own convictions
00:44:59 and in your own analysis. And if you think that given the size of government in Britain already,
00:45:07 and the size of the tax burden and the scale of the borrowing,
00:45:12 then attempting to do more of the same on a grand scale,
00:45:17 which is now the Burnham strategy, 0.86
00:45:20 if you think that's the route to going to hell in a handbasket,
00:45:23 then you need the intellectual courage to lay down the markers,
00:45:31 to explain why this is going to happen,
00:45:33 to explain what the alternative is,
00:45:37 to have the policies ready with the alternative,
00:45:40 and to be ready to move when you are proved right.
00:45:43 Because after all, that's what happened in the 70s.
00:45:46 I mean, I was with The Economist in the 70s.
00:45:49 It was my first main job out of university.
00:45:53 And a lot of the work that was done in the 1970s
00:45:56 developed, rediscovered the market,
00:45:59 invented the concept of privatizing a lot of state-owned services and state-owned industries,
00:46:08 of providing a tax system that would incentivize individuals and companies and entrepreneurs.
00:46:17 Now, for a while, and also predicting that what labor was up to would end in tears, in disaster,
00:46:24 and, in particular, what had to be done about the unions.
00:46:30 That was the single biggest problem in the 70s.
00:46:35 Without tackling the unions, you could do almost nothing
00:46:39 to build an alternative agenda.
00:46:41 Now, for a long time, we kind of felt we were tramping away
00:46:47 in the vineyards and many people taking notice of us
00:46:52 or of it ever coming our way, but it did.
00:46:56 We were vindicated by the IMF coming in 76.
00:47:00 We were vindicated by a winter of discontent.
00:47:03 You go back to the 70s, we were told,
00:47:05 the only reason the unions are on strike
00:47:06 is because it's an evil Tory government
00:47:09 and if only we had a Labour government,
00:47:11 we wouldn't go on strike.
00:47:12 Well, last time I looked,
00:47:14 there was a Labour government in 78, 79
00:47:16 when we had the winter of discontent.
00:47:18 And so all that was blown apart.
00:47:19 And here, bit by bit, it wasn't just the economists, but it played a major part.
00:47:24 There were other think tanks, not a thousand miles from where we are.
00:47:28 They had the courage of their convictions.
00:47:30 They did their homework.
00:47:32 They were proved right.
00:47:33 And they had an alternative agenda to take advantage of that.
00:47:38 And I think that's what the Tories have to do now and be ready to move when they're proved right.
00:47:44 look the problem with the Tories is they're so tarnished correct they're so tarnished there are
00:47:52 lots of people particularly working class conservatives more than anyone who will look
00:47:58 at the Tories and look at what they have done particularly when it comes to immigration
00:48:03 and go I'm not I'm just not doing it and you can't blame them I don't blame them because
00:48:09 they're right. And I think that is the problem. I mean, it's almost unheard of for, given the
00:48:17 thumping they got in July 2024, it's unheard of for any party like that to recover for the next
00:48:26 election. I mean, if you look when Labour lost in 79, it was 97 before they got back in. You know,
00:48:34 when the Tories lost in 97, it was 2010. And even then, they only got back in with a coalition with
00:48:41 the Liberal Democrats. There, you look, again, when Labour lost in 2010, it was 24 before they
00:48:50 got back. Normally, when you get thumped, you don't recover. And the Tories were royally and
00:48:55 deservedly thumped in July of 2024. And they did let their own supporters down. They let them down.
00:49:03 You take the immigration thing above all else.
00:49:07 They knew that immigration was a really big issue
00:49:10 for their blue-collar supporters.
00:49:13 They knew it was causing real anguish and pain,
00:49:16 not just economically, but for many socially as well.
00:49:19 It was changing the nature of the societies
00:49:22 that they were brought up in.
00:49:24 They said, vote Brexit and we'll put it right.
00:49:26 We'll get it right.
00:49:28 People said, right, we'll vote Brexit.
00:49:29 it. And then in 2022, 21, under the great Boris Johnson, we had a net migration of half a million.
00:49:39 That wasn't bad enough. We had a net migration of almost a million the next year. And if that
00:49:44 wasn't enough, we had a net migration of another million the following year. Mr. Johnson, the only
00:49:52 politician ever to have an immigration wave named after him. The Boris wave. You don't recover from
00:49:59 that quickly. You just, and ironically, the Tories eventually did put things in place
00:50:08 which have had a major impact on net migration. I mean, this year it'll be about 170,000.
00:50:15 Takeout students is already closer to 100,000 now. And of course, Labour, who opposed all these
00:50:20 changes, is getting the benefit of it. So I think you're right. I don't, I think Kemi
00:50:26 Badenoch, who, as I say, I think has emerged as a leader of some distinction, but I don't think
00:50:32 she, she doesn't rescue the Tories by the time of the next election. And Andrew, you mentioned
00:50:38 Brexit. The current Labour government are now talking about reversing it and they haven't
00:50:42 as going as far as reversing it. Yeah, it's one of the options, Mr. Burnham says.
00:50:47 Francis and I both voted Remain, but we were outraged by some of the way that unfolded from there,
00:50:57 where people wanted to unilaterally overturn a democratic vote that they didn't agree with.
00:51:02 What would happen to this country if Labour tried to take this country back into the European Union?
00:51:08 I think if they tried, at the moment, they think it's going to be a piece of cake,
00:51:13 because the polls say that most people want to rejoin.
00:51:17 and that they've got buyer's remorse and that they wish they'd never voted for Brexit in the
00:51:23 first place. And there is an element of that which is true. But that changes the moment you start to
00:51:31 have the debate. That changes the moment you start to talk about the issues. That changes
00:51:37 the moment you're presented with the price of rejoining the club, which will be enormous. I
00:51:43 I mean, even Germany this week is rebelling against the size of the next European budget,
00:51:51 which is, I think, now over a trillion, of which Britain would have to pay a big share.
00:51:57 This time with no rebate.
00:52:00 If that's a rebate, that's never coming back, baby.
00:52:03 That's gone.
00:52:04 That's history.
00:52:06 So that's the price of entry.
00:52:07 That would be 20, 30, 40 billion a year.
00:52:11 We don't know.
00:52:12 A lot of money.
00:52:14 And then we'll be raising the issue, well, what about the euro?
00:52:19 Are you going to join that?
00:52:20 Because we think you should.
00:52:21 New members should join the euro.
00:52:23 And although we could probably get around that,
00:52:28 we'd be under pressure to give some kind of indication
00:52:31 that we're prepared to join the euro at some stage and revisit that.
00:52:35 And then you've got Schengen.
00:52:39 Well, new members have meant to join Schengen.
00:52:42 This is free movement.
00:52:43 It's free movement with bells on.
00:52:46 And you start to add all that up and you begin to say,
00:52:51 maybe this isn't such a good idea after all.
00:52:54 And then the debate will come out because, you see,
00:52:57 the argument at the moment, my view is that there were
00:53:01 actually very good economic arguments for not voting too easy.
00:53:08 And it's just a pity that Remain didn't make them.
00:53:11 I mean, the Remain fought an appalling, negative, complacent campaign, and did for many Remainers
00:53:20 like the egregious Alastair Campbell and so on.
00:53:23 They only started fighting after they'd lost.
00:53:25 And we had that in a lifetime of covering British politics.
00:53:31 That period between 2016 and 2019, the Theresa May period, was the most miserable time I
00:53:39 can remember in British politics.
00:53:41 It was just, we were rudderless.
00:53:43 We were being buffeted by the Supreme Court on one side,
00:53:47 Keir Starmer's second referendum on the other,
00:53:50 Theresa May clueless about what to do regarding Brexit 1.00
00:53:53 as a problem to be managed rather than the only proper way forward 1.00
00:53:58 whether you were for or against it, an opportunity to be seized.
00:54:01 It was a terrible time.
00:54:04 And the one thing I'll give Mr. Johnson credit for
00:54:06 was winning that December election in 2019,
00:54:10 which kind of ended that bit. You put Europe back on the agenda. That comes back. That miserable
00:54:17 time all comes back. And it sucked the bandwidth out of British politics. It meant the final,
00:54:25 the end of that decade of the Tory government towards 2020. It had run out of any purpose,
00:54:32 of any agenda of other than to get Brexit over the line in some way. It was humiliating. The
00:54:41 Europeans gave us a punishment beating for having the audacity to even think of leaving and to also
00:54:49 to make sure that no one else thought of following us. And they won. No one else has
00:54:54 followed us. Even the AFD in Germany, which used to be an exit party, doesn't want to do that.
00:55:01 Like Le Pen used to be no more.
00:55:03 She doesn't even want to leave the euro.
00:55:05 So you bring all that back.
00:55:08 And then other people will say,
00:55:10 well, the argument is,
00:55:12 this is how we get growth back into the system.
00:55:15 If we can join the single market,
00:55:17 join the customs union,
00:55:19 we'll get that economic growth.
00:55:21 And in theory, that may be the case.
00:55:24 But if it is the case,
00:55:26 why are Germany, Italy, and France
00:55:29 growing more small and slowly than we are.
00:55:32 Of course, last time I looked,
00:55:33 they didn't leave the customs union.
00:55:35 They didn't leave the single market.
00:55:36 So I think it starts off with something we're good.
00:55:39 And I think it's something that they think,
00:55:41 hey, we can do this.
00:55:42 The rank and file of Labour, the Lib Dems, 1.00
00:55:45 the Greens, the media, the chattering classes, 0.88
00:55:48 the metropolitan white collar public sector workers 0.65
00:55:52 who are now Labour's natural base.
00:55:55 They're going to love it.
00:55:56 Let's do it. 0.99
00:55:57 and it is, to use a technical term, has all the makings of a shitshow. 0.88
00:56:03 And there will come a point, if they get that far down the road, 0.87
00:56:07 that Burnham will be saying, why did I ever do this?
00:56:10 Why did I go down this road?
00:56:11 Because I've now got no time to do anything else.
00:56:14 I'm knackered trying to get this over the line.
00:56:17 And there's all these other things I wanted to do,
00:56:18 and I've got no time for them.
00:56:21 Do you think, and a lot of people have said
00:56:24 that the next general election in this country is existential.
00:56:27 Would you share that opinion, or do you think that's hyperbolic?
00:56:30 We always say that because we want people to take notice of what we're saying.
00:56:34 It depends on what it's fought on.
00:56:37 It depends on what the dividing line is.
00:56:40 Now, if it's fought on a dividing line,
00:56:44 and this could involve conservative and reform on one side,
00:56:49 maybe a little closer than they'd like to make out,
00:56:52 because it's dawned on them that divided they fall
00:56:56 and some kind of accommodation will have to be reached,
00:57:00 but it is another matter.
00:57:02 But if it's a choice between returning to a more market economy,
00:57:10 more enterprise-driven, more business-friendly,
00:57:14 more lower tax, smaller government,
00:57:17 versus the Andy Burnham prospectus, which is the opposite,
00:57:22 then yeah, that's a big choice.
00:57:24 Because although if people vote in a way that results in a right-of-centre government
00:57:29 that might not deliver on all these things,
00:57:33 if the country does vote for the Andy Burnham prospectus, that's it.
00:57:37 We are a socialist tax-and-spend future.
00:57:43 There's no going back from that if it votes for it.
00:57:46 And with a coalition, he may not get an overall majority,
00:57:50 even with a coalition of Lib Dems, Greens, SNP,
00:57:55 giving them moral support when he needs it.
00:57:57 You have locked the country in
00:58:00 to a tax-and-spend socialist future in the 2030s.
00:58:06 The people who watch this show have generally done more thinking
00:58:09 about how governments operate the most,
00:58:11 but there's a difference between understanding the problem
00:58:14 and having actually built insulation against it.
00:58:18 That's the world Mikel Thorup operates in. He's been living as an expat for over 25 years,
00:58:23 visiting more than 110 countries and calling nine of them home. He founded Expat Money nearly a
00:58:28 decade ago to help others do the same. When he helped someone build an international plan B,
00:58:33 the knowledge he brings is entirely firsthand. Every recommendation comes from something he
00:58:38 has already done himself. Expat Money works specifically with freedom-minded families
00:58:43 and investors who want to reduce their exposure on any one government or any one system.
00:58:49 Second residencies, second citizenships, offshore banking, international real estate,
00:58:53 legal structures that spread your life across borders.
00:58:56 Mikkel has put together a free report called Plan B Residencies and Instant Citizenships.
00:59:02 It covers five routes to a second passport, including one that almost never gets discussed.
00:59:07 How a foreign residency functions as genuine political insurance,
00:59:10 which countries actually make sense
00:59:13 depending on what you're trying to protect
00:59:14 and what it realistically costs.
00:59:17 Go to expatmoney.com slash trigger
00:59:19 or click the link in the description of this episode
00:59:22 to download the report.
00:59:23 There's no charge, no catch.
00:59:25 That's expatmoney.com slash trigger.
00:59:29 Andrew, one other thing I wanted to touch on
00:59:31 before we head to questions from our supporters
00:59:33 is the BBC.
00:59:34 You were a stalwart for many, many years.
00:59:36 Many years.
00:59:37 Many years.
00:59:38 At a time when I would say it was a great institution that I really admired, but for many of us, it doesn't feel like it has remained one since. Do you share that analysis?
00:59:49 Yes, I do. The BBC still does many great things, but I think the BBC's biggest weakness is the idea it can just carry on as it is.
00:59:59 You know, the BBC business model, if I can put it that way, was invented when Lennon was in the Kremlin and Warren Harding was in the White House.
01:00:13 And I forget, and I think it was maybe Baldwin was forming his first government.
01:00:19 I can't remember in the early 20s because the government was probably born of law or something like that.
01:00:24 And I've ventured to suggest that this is a different world
01:00:27 and that that business model just can't play.
01:00:31 Look, I don't think young people today,
01:00:36 given the huge choice of streamers and YouTube
01:00:40 and the endless channels on Sky,
01:00:44 which I'm proud to have started and launched,
01:00:47 are going to pay for something they don't watch.
01:00:50 I mean, it's just beyond their cultural recognition.
01:00:55 Well, I have to pay for it, but I never watch it.
01:00:56 Yeah, but you still have to pay.
01:00:58 And until the BBC gets off that model,
01:01:01 I think it's cruising for a bruising.
01:01:03 Now, it'll be given a new lease of life by this government
01:01:07 because this government, its nostalgia is not just
01:01:13 for heavy industry and trade unions and miners' lamps
01:01:17 and gravy and chips or whatever it is Andy Burnham
01:01:22 eats instead of biscuits.
01:01:25 It still thinks there's a Fleet Street Tory press
01:01:28 that matters, which, of course, there isn't
01:01:33 in the way it did.
01:01:34 In the days when The Sun sold four million copies,
01:01:38 had 12 million readers,
01:01:40 there isn't a Tory press like that anymore.
01:01:42 It's a shadow of its former self.
01:01:45 But it doesn't see that.
01:01:47 And it sees the BBC as a bulwark against that Tory press.
01:01:53 So this government will be kind to it in whichever way it renews it.
01:01:59 But I don't think, and I think the BBC is a bit of a death wish too,
01:02:05 because as it cuts its cloth to meet its budget,
01:02:10 it seems to me almost everything it cuts is actually the public service bit
01:02:15 that you could say, well, actually, I'm glad the BBC does that
01:02:18 and not the stuff that the market would do.
01:02:22 I don't need to be, I've never watched Strictly come dancing
01:02:24 or whatever it's called, but I don't need the BBC
01:02:26 to provide me with Strictly.
01:02:28 I think the market's pretty capable of doing that.
01:02:30 I don't, that recent commercial of what's the BBC ever done
01:02:34 for me kind of thing, a piece of propaganda,
01:02:37 which I think it ran in the middle of the World Cup
01:02:39 in this country, right.
01:02:42 It never mentioned, it was all the things
01:02:45 that, you know, East End does.
01:02:46 Well, it's a soap opera.
01:02:47 Markets can do soap operas.
01:02:49 You know, there are plenty of, you know,
01:02:50 Coronation Street, I think that's ITV.
01:02:53 And it never mentioned,
01:02:55 even in the middle of the proms,
01:02:56 which we had just started,
01:02:57 it never mentioned the proms.
01:02:59 One of the great celebrations of music in the world,
01:03:04 of which the BBC is an integral part.
01:03:06 News got a passing glance.
01:03:09 News has got like three seconds,
01:03:11 whereas, you know, proper public service news,
01:03:13 It's not necessarily the one we have at the moment.
01:03:16 So it seems to me it's lost the plot.
01:03:18 So there is a Neil plan for the BBC.
01:03:21 Do you want to hear it?
01:03:22 Sure.
01:03:22 Neil plan is simple.
01:03:24 You divide it into two.
01:03:28 The bit that's free to air,
01:03:31 available on all platforms,
01:03:33 is BBC Core.
01:03:36 That's the public service broadcasting element.
01:03:40 It is, you turn the Arts Council,
01:03:42 into the Council for Arts and Broadcasting.
01:03:46 And you channel about a billion pounds
01:03:49 through that council to the BBC
01:03:52 to pay for the things that are genuine public service broadcasting
01:03:58 and that national events are carried there.
01:04:02 Everybody can watch them.
01:04:04 The nation comes together.
01:04:06 Even, you know, quite challenging drama,
01:04:08 giving new directors a chance to fail and so on.
01:04:12 things the market would be a little bit wary about. It does that and everybody gets it and
01:04:18 nobody has to pay for it. And I reckon you could do all of that for about a billion. Everything else
01:04:24 is the British HBO. If the programs are that good and people want to watch them and they're that
01:04:30 popular, fine, subscribe to the BBC subscription and pay for it. And then I think, you know, if
01:04:40 the BBC is right in how great its programs are, people would pay for it. And I wouldn't make it
01:04:49 a private company. I'd make it kind of like a John Lewis sort of company, a mutual fund.
01:04:56 But because it was now a separate entity from the state, still be regulated by Ofcom, obviously,
01:05:02 and so on, couldn't take advertising. It would be a subscription-led channel,
01:05:06 regulated, but it could go to the market and it could borrow money to make more programs
01:05:14 and do deals with other foreign commercial broadcasters. At the moment, two things are
01:05:21 killing the BBC in terms of drama. One is it just can't afford the per-episode cost now.
01:05:29 I mean, the streaming has made per-episode cost around $10 million an episode now, BBC.
01:05:36 The Night Manager, which is the most expensive BBC drama
01:05:39 for a long while, was about three million pounds.
01:05:42 That's a ton of money.
01:05:43 They can't afford to make that many of them.
01:05:47 So that's it.
01:05:48 And the other thing is that to get its drama off the ground,
01:05:51 and The Night Manager is another good example of that,
01:05:54 they need to do co-production deals,
01:05:56 usually with Americans or other big broadcasters,
01:05:59 to which they sell all the international rights.
01:06:02 So they don't get that stream of income
01:06:04 coming in from international rights.
01:06:06 This would free them up to do it.
01:06:09 And hey, look, if the BBC is wrong
01:06:11 and they can't get many people to subscribe,
01:06:15 well, you should never have been forcing me
01:06:16 to pay in the first place.
01:06:17 The market has spoken.
01:06:19 But if they're right,
01:06:22 then I think a future more suited
01:06:26 to the environment we're in.
01:06:28 And let's not forget that although the BBC
01:06:30 is obviously in some trouble
01:06:32 and it's cuts, cuts, cuts.
01:06:35 And I can't remember when it last made a decent drama
01:06:37 I wanted to watch.
01:06:39 Let's not forget that the streamers
01:06:41 have been a godsend for Britain.
01:06:43 I mean, we're so used to talking ourselves, Diane.
01:06:46 This country is an audiovisual superpower.
01:06:52 Last year, we made more Hollywood blockbusters
01:06:56 than Hollywood.
01:06:58 We have more in that final segment
01:07:01 of the M25, as you look at the map,
01:07:05 the final segment from the M4
01:07:07 through to glorious downtown Watford.
01:07:11 There is now more studio soundstage space there
01:07:17 than in the whole of greater Los Angeles.
01:07:21 12 billion pounds spent on production,
01:07:24 movie and TV in this country last year.
01:07:27 World beat us.
01:07:29 Look at the streamers.
01:07:29 Everything from adolescence to slow horses to black doves to the agency, which, interestingly, the American version of the French Triumph Liburo, they're actually based in London.
01:07:44 And we have the skills, the skill base, the technology.
01:07:48 Our CGI is world-beating.
01:07:50 We're not as highly unionized.
01:07:52 I'll tell you the difference if you go.
01:07:55 I mean, they're even shooting Batman again in Glasgow.
01:07:59 In Glasgow, Batman.
01:08:01 Well, it is similar to Gotham.
01:08:02 Exactly.
01:08:04 Let me assure you, it's much more dangerous.
01:08:09 I mean, Batman turned up and said, screw this.
01:08:13 A violent crime-infested city.
01:08:15 Batman turned up and said, screw this.
01:08:16 I'm getting out of here.
01:08:17 There's nothing I can do about this place.
01:08:21 And so we make all these things.
01:08:24 I mean, Game of Thrones and Titanic is now a major tourist asset.
01:08:29 for Northern Ireland.
01:08:31 So we're a huge success in these things.
01:08:35 And the BBC's played a part in that.
01:08:37 And if it was freed from the current constraints
01:08:40 and stopped having to do a lot of nonsense
01:08:42 that it doesn't have to do,
01:08:44 then I think it could flourish.
01:08:47 If it doesn't flourish,
01:08:48 people have spoken with their words.
01:08:50 Well, and you make sense because there's no reason
01:08:52 these two things should really be tied together.
01:08:54 Current affairs in particular is where I think
01:08:56 the BBC lost a lot of people,
01:08:58 particularly in the last 10 years.
01:09:00 And look, there used to be this critique of the BBC
01:09:03 that it's not actually impartial in the way that it claims to be.
01:09:10 And look at you.
01:09:11 I mean, you're clearly sort of centre-right,
01:09:13 but there were Conservative election candidates
01:09:16 who were terrified of you when you were interviewing them.
01:09:19 Including Boris Johnson.
01:09:20 That's right.
01:09:22 He came on this podcast later and we grilled him too,
01:09:25 but not nearly as hard as you would have done.
01:09:27 He ended up hiding in a freezer.
01:09:30 I was shouting, lock the door.
01:09:32 You were as impartial as a person can be, I think, from the outside.
01:09:37 But what you've seen since the BBC has started losing a lot of its key presenters is they've
01:09:42 all gone on to have their own podcast.
01:09:44 And the claims that people made about these people not being impartial have all been borne
01:09:48 out by the fact that these people are now radical leftists, basically.
01:09:51 I'm afraid this is true.
01:09:53 And, you know, the BBC is not alone in that.
01:09:55 there is something about public service broadcasting.
01:09:59 There's something about broadcasting in general,
01:10:01 probably because it's all metropolitan-based.
01:10:04 And big metropolises these days are left-wing.
01:10:07 That's a change from times gone by.
01:10:10 You know, there was a time when Liverpool or Glasgow
01:10:13 had as many Tory MPs as they had Labour.
01:10:15 You're not going to fight that now.
01:10:17 So they're all big.
01:10:18 And it's why I thought it was always a joke
01:10:19 that, oh, we move the BBC to Manchester,
01:10:22 then that'll change itself.
01:10:23 Excuse me, it's even more left-wing than London. 0.74
01:10:26 It's all nonsense.
01:10:27 So I think there's something kind of systemic
01:10:29 that's so difficult.
01:10:31 And you hire young university graduates
01:10:33 who live in metropolitan areas,
01:10:36 who come from middle-class backgrounds.
01:10:39 Remember, the one thing of which diversity
01:10:41 is not allowed in the BBC is class.
01:10:44 Everything else can be diverse, 0.97
01:10:46 but we're not going to help poor kids 0.99
01:10:48 from poor backgrounds get on that.
01:10:51 So there is something,
01:10:53 And it's true of ABC in Australia, it's true of ZDF in Germany, it's true of Entendu in France, or of PBS in America.
01:11:04 There's just something that public service broadcasting on the news leans to the left.
01:11:10 Which means in the Neil scheme of the BBC, on the billion pound public service broadcasting core, of which news would be the crown jewel, you would have to have special, special emphasis on restoring impartiality.
01:11:31 and a really tough internal regulation
01:11:34 to investigate every breach
01:11:37 and to penalize those who breached it
01:11:39 and to keep it real and keep it impartial
01:11:42 and keep it honest.
01:11:44 Because if you're using my tax money,
01:11:48 nevermind at the moment my tax money,
01:11:50 to provide a news service,
01:11:52 you have no right to make it biased.
01:11:55 If you aren't biased, you know, watch Sky
01:11:56 or Channel 4 News.
01:11:58 That's not my tax money.
01:11:59 Or in America, Fox News, tax money.
01:12:02 MS Now, tax money.
01:12:04 So if you're using my money,
01:12:06 and I don't object in principle
01:12:07 to the use of this for a country Britain's size
01:12:10 in which BBC News is a world brand,
01:12:14 I can see that there's a role
01:12:15 for government to help prevent that.
01:12:17 But you have an obligation
01:12:18 to make sure it is the most impartial service in the world.
01:12:23 And here's a thought.
01:12:24 Every piece of media at the moment
01:12:27 is looking for a unique selling point.
01:12:29 USP
01:12:30 in an overcrowded market
01:12:32 what makes us different
01:12:35 oh here's something to be different
01:12:36 you can trust us
01:12:38 in fact we are
01:12:40 going to fact check
01:12:43 all the fake news
01:12:44 if it goes mainstream
01:12:46 we are the people
01:12:47 not BBC verify
01:12:49 it just reinforces the existing
01:12:52 ethos and culture
01:12:53 we are going to be
01:12:55 it's our very
01:12:58 reason for existing and i think that would be a great selling point and the british and you could
01:13:06 sell that around the world by the way people would love more and more people are thinking well
01:13:10 what is true what can i who can i trust these days so that's the new plan and it will never happen
01:13:17 on that happy note yeah andrew final question always the same what's the one thing we're not
01:13:24 talking about that we really should be right at this stage right now being a newsman let's deal
01:13:29 with the news the the really scary thing coming down the pike right now is the prospect of donald
01:13:37 trump into introducing a diesel a ban on diesel exports because if he does that
01:13:44 it'll be very bad for Europe, but a potential catastrophe for Britain.
01:13:54 Why do I say that? I'll just give you the facts. America is now the biggest exporter of diesel in
01:14:02 the world. 1.5 million barrels a day of diesel. They refine the oil and it comes out as the
01:14:09 refined product. We used to be self-sufficient in diesel, but our politicians, brilliant,
01:14:17 brilliant move, closed all of our refineries bar four. These are politicians that talk about
01:14:23 the re-industrialization of Britain while they're closing the refineries. So we only have four
01:14:28 refineries left that can produce diesel. And that means that 55% of what we, of our diesel needs
01:14:37 are now imported. And a third of that comes from America. We are the biggest importer
01:14:45 of American diesel in the world. Europe imports two, but we import more. And here's the other
01:14:53 difference. In closing the refineries, our re-industrialization-obsessed politicians
01:15:00 closed our storage.
01:15:03 We have 42 days of diesel storage.
01:15:06 We have diesel stored that would compensate
01:15:10 for 42 days of imports.
01:15:13 France, 250.
01:15:15 Germany, 280.
01:15:17 Italy, 320.
01:15:19 We have 42.
01:15:20 So basically a month.
01:15:21 Basically a month.
01:15:23 So we are wide open.
01:15:25 And there is no question in my mind.
01:15:27 If Trump was to do it,
01:15:28 and the midterms are going so badly for him
01:15:30 and he doesn't care about anything else,
01:15:33 I wouldn't rule out that he does it.
01:15:35 In my view, even for America,
01:15:38 it would be economically wrong
01:15:39 because I don't think it would.
01:15:40 The idea is you stop exporting,
01:15:42 you can flood the American market with diesel
01:15:45 and the price will come down.
01:15:47 And it's particularly hurting in those Midwest states
01:15:50 that he's in danger of losing.
01:15:51 So I see the political logic of it,
01:15:54 but he hasn't quite worked out
01:15:56 with the oil in downtown
01:15:57 is that there is no national network of pipes in America.
01:16:01 It's regional markets.
01:16:03 And California is short of diesel.
01:16:05 And when you flood the market,
01:16:06 you couldn't get the diesel to California
01:16:08 from the coast, to the Gulf Coast,
01:16:11 where the refineries are.
01:16:12 So I don't think it would work,
01:16:12 but that won't stop him from trying to do it.
01:16:14 And if he was to proceed in doing that,
01:16:17 this country will be in recession by Christmas.
01:16:21 And we're not talking enough about this.
01:16:25 I was speaking to the business secretary.
01:16:27 John Healy never mentioned in his speech, Andy Burnham was too busy with his hopey-changey thing to realize we should be building up.
01:16:35 Because here's the problem. There's no time to.
01:16:38 The reason why there's such shortage of refining capacity at the moment is that Ukrainian drones have taken out a third of Russian diesel.
01:16:47 We used to import our biggest chunk of diesel from Russia.
01:16:52 Well, Russia's now importing diesel from India
01:16:54 because it can't produce enough itself.
01:16:58 And there's not anything like enough diesel getting out of the Gulf.
01:17:03 That was the other thing.
01:17:04 I mean, the Gulf used to add value to its crude oil, these Gulf states.
01:17:07 They would refine the crude oil.
01:17:10 It's worth a lot more as diesel.
01:17:11 Comes as jet fuel.
01:17:13 Jet fuel now selling for $180 a barrel in Asia at the moment.
01:17:18 So they said, right, but it's not getting out.
01:17:20 So we went to America as the big source.
01:17:24 And if Trump stops that, we have nowhere else to go.
01:17:28 Our farming, our construction industry,
01:17:32 our road haulage is entirely dependent on diesel.
01:17:37 And these three things, in many ways,
01:17:40 are the backbone of our economy.
01:17:42 Andrew Neil, thank you so much for coming on.
01:17:44 We should mention, of course, you are now a fellow YouTuber
01:17:46 and we encourage everybody to...
01:17:47 I joined the elite.
01:17:49 How far the mighty have fallen, I would say.
01:17:52 The digital elite.
01:17:53 Andrew, great to have you on.
01:17:55 Thank you.
01:17:55 And thank you for your time and for your questions.
01:17:57 And head on over to triggerpod.co.uk
01:18:00 where Andrew is going to answer your questions.
01:18:05 Which has been the worst government
01:18:06 you've had the pleasure of holding to account
01:18:09 and where does the current one rank?
01:18:19 We'll be right back.