Western Standard - November 20, 2026


From filet to food banks | Why food inflation isn’t coming down

Why your next car could cost $12,000 more Could this bill let you legally kill a home invader? MP Sandra Cobena responds

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

141.0

Word count

3,594

Sentence count

216


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show
00:00:20 of the Western Standard. It is Thursday, November the 19th. Food prices are going way up,
00:00:26 rising faster than inflation generally, and with some, such as beef, rising even faster than overall food inflation.
00:00:34 In fact, I'd say that it's not just the prices are going up, but that they're going up faster.
00:00:38 However, what I say is not necessarily definitive.
00:00:43 With me today is Canada's food professor, Dr. Sylvain Charlebois.
00:00:50 Welcome to Hannaford, Dr. Charlebois.
00:00:53 Well, your show last time did very well, and I notice I hear you on the radio all the time,
00:01:03 and my wife is constantly reminding me that she's heard you again,
00:01:08 and you need to have him on the show.
00:01:11 So here you are.
00:01:12 Let's get right to it.
00:01:13 You were most recently in the news because you were saying that Food Banks Canada
00:01:18 And food banks generally across the country are going gangbusters.
00:01:23 They're recording massive visits, I think 2.35 million visits in a single month, which is a record.
00:01:33 That seems quite appalling, frankly.
00:01:36 Canada is a wealthy country, and how can it be that so many people are in need of free food from the food bank?
00:01:46 It's a great question.
00:01:48 I get that question a lot. How can it be? I mean, Canada, we really produce a lot of food and
00:01:54 yet there's still a lot of people being left behind. Let's start with the low 20%,
00:02:01 so low income earners in our country. So we've actually seen many policies taking care of that
00:02:09 group. For example, the GST rebate enhancement program, it is called the grocery rebate program
00:02:16 now. Of course, that program has helped the lower 20% in terms of income earners in our country.
00:02:28 And so their disposable income has actually increased. But still, when you take into
00:02:33 consideration transportation, shelter, taxes, of course, and food, there's most of these
00:02:43 households, when they show up at the grocery store, they show up and they have a budgetary
00:02:50 deficit, which is really a challenge for them. But the biggest challenge I think in Canada is
00:02:55 the middle class, the lower middle class. We actually looked at some numbers recently.
00:03:02 And when you look at wages versus costs, the cost of living, again, including shelter,
00:03:10 taxes, transportation, and food. Right now, the average household will probably have about
00:03:18 $6,000 to $7,000 left in their bank account. And that's basically less. It's 11% less in
00:03:28 constant dollars compared to 2016, so 10 years ago. So if people feel under pressure as a result of
00:03:36 the cost of living, that's why your dollar is not doing as much work as it used to 10 years ago.
00:03:44 So, okay, so inflation is certainly the issue there. But I noticed that when they put the
00:03:52 inflation numbers out, they often have quite a big basket. And there are things in there that
00:03:56 most people don't buy every week, like television sets. And sure, those have not been going up as
00:04:01 fast as food. So how much confidence do you have in the inflation numbers as they apply to food
00:04:09 that come out of Statistics Canada? Yeah, so I've been openly skeptical
00:04:16 about Statistics Canada's measurement practices when it comes to inflation. We do have our own
00:04:24 data and it's not overly consistent with what we're seeing right now. So we go through cycles
00:04:31 We actually collect our own data. And sometimes I actually feel that the Statistic Canada is always about six months behind. But they do often underestimate inflation for a few reasons. One, I do think that they are partnering with just a couple of grocers. We don't know who they are. I believe they are two.
00:04:54 They're probably selective in terms of the data they give to the agency.
00:04:58 And two, there are things like shrinkflation, skimflation, which is reducing the amount of food you get for the same amount of money.
00:05:08 And we see no evidence that Sisyphe Canada actually is taking those factors into consideration.
00:05:14 So to us, Sisyphe Canada is just an indicator like anything else.
00:05:18 So we actually do track it.
00:05:20 We look at it.
00:05:21 But it's an indicator.
00:05:23 it may not reflect exactly how people feel and what people see at the grocery store.
00:05:29 You know, so then I almost hesitate these days to even talk about shrinkflation
00:05:33 because it's like a trigger.
00:05:35 The moment you mention it, whoever you're talking to comes back with their examples
00:05:40 of three things that have been made smaller or there are less of them in the packet,
00:05:47 whatever it is.
00:05:48 But here's a question that I'm instructed by my wife to ask you.
00:05:54 Yes, prices are rising, but are they now rising faster?
00:05:59 I mean, every time we talk about this, yeah, prices are up.
00:06:02 Sure, they are a couple of percent here, a couple of percent there, year by year by year.
00:06:06 But it seems like they're going up much faster now.
00:06:08 Is that just the way we're feeling when we go to the hotel, or is it actual real-life experience?
00:06:16 uh there's a couple of observations uh that i can share with you one uh yes uh food prices are
00:06:25 rising faster than uh than everything else in the economy and it's been like that for well over two
00:06:32 years with the exception of august uh at september of this year most months we've seen food inflation
00:06:40 being above general headline inflation.
00:06:45 And when that happens, basically,
00:06:46 people absolutely see higher prices at the grocery store.
00:06:50 So that feeling you get is simply because
00:06:53 at the grocery store,
00:06:54 things are much more difficult and challenging.
00:06:58 The other reality is that,
00:07:00 and I do think that this is probably the biggest problem
00:07:04 we're all facing as Canadians,
00:07:06 and this is a comment I've actually made
00:07:08 several times in Parliament,
00:07:10 before committees in Ottawa is that food inflation is certainly a problem, a challenge for a lot of
00:07:18 families. But the biggest problem is price volatility. You see, because we have so many
00:07:25 vulnerabilities embedded within our food system, we tend to see prices go up and down, go up and
00:07:31 down. And people will always remember when prices are higher. So, for example, if you see your
00:07:39 favorite cut of beef, double in price, you'll remember that price. And you may decide to just
00:07:46 walk away from that category altogether for a while and perhaps even forever. And so that's
00:07:53 what's playing against Canadians right now. It's the volatility, especially affecting fresh
00:07:59 produce, meat, fish and seafood, bakery, all of these categories. We have seen a lot of volatility
00:08:07 And prices are much more volatile in Canada than anywhere else amongst G20 countries.
00:08:17 We don't process as much.
00:08:20 You see, we've always looked at Farmgate.
00:08:24 We looked at consumers.
00:08:26 But it's the missing middle.
00:08:29 The missing middle is desperate for attention.
00:08:32 And that's processing.
00:08:33 Processing, if you have a strong processing sector, you can do a lot of things.
00:08:40 You can innovate, but you basically create an anchor for the entire system.
00:08:44 It's easier to support farmers.
00:08:47 It's easier to actually innovate for consumers.
00:08:50 But most importantly, you gain the ability to absorb these major shocks that we've seen,
00:08:56 these systemic shocks like ukraine like covid and of course more certainly with the straight
00:09:02 of our moose with higher energy costs if you do not food for yourself and for external markets
00:09:10 you become way more vulnerable and and this is in the last five years i think we've actually had
00:09:17 many reasons to appreciate many opportunities to appreciate how important that is and that's
00:09:22 why we're seeing more attention given to the missing middle why doesn't canada have a more
00:09:28 robust processing center because it's cheaper elsewhere to make look at the u.s for example
00:09:35 the u.s are canadian counter tariffs playing into this then i mean you may grow the food
00:09:42 it's processed in the united states when it comes back across the border there's a counter tariff
00:09:46 upgo our prices. Is that what's happening? Well, tariffs and counter tariffs haven't really
00:09:52 impacted food all that much. There were periods under Prime Minister Trudeau, then Prime Minister
00:09:58 Trudeau, we saw some tariffs and counter tariffs impacting food, but that's long gone now. I believe
00:10:05 that both President Trump and Prime Minister Carney have been extremely careful not to affect
00:10:11 the food industry all that much. In fact, in the first six months of this year, we've actually
00:10:16 sold more food to the U.S. than ever, it's up 6% compared to the first six months of 2025.
00:10:24 So trade-wise, things are pretty healthy in the agri-food sector between the two countries.
00:10:30 Despite the noise, despite everything, we actually do have a healthy trading situation
00:10:37 with the U.S. from a food perspective.
00:10:40 And so when you think about money, when you think about innovation and processing, the money will always go, there's least resistance. It's easier. And frankly, the processing sector in the U.S. is much more robust.
00:10:58 Since President Trump has been back in power since January of 2025, we have seen, if you look at GDP per hour work in food manufacturing, basically the sector in the U.S. is about a percent or two percent more productive.
00:11:19 And they've actually lost jobs. So that's because of AI, because of robotics, because of automation. In the U.S., they've actually invested in food manufacturing, which actually has made the sector much more productive.
00:11:33 In Canada, in the last 18 months, we've seen the opposite.
00:11:38 In fact, if you look at GDP per hour worked in Canada, that's gone down almost 7% in the last 18 months.
00:11:48 So when we talk about a productivity crisis, that's what we're talking about.
00:11:53 Well, who has to fix that?
00:11:55 I mean, is there something that the government has been doing that they need to stop doing
00:12:00 or something that they need to start doing?
00:12:02 or is it the lack of confidence in the food processes themselves?
00:12:07 How do you fix this?
00:12:08 That's a good question.
00:12:09 So how do you fix this?
00:12:12 I mean, there's been some promises around interprovincial trade barriers
00:12:16 to actually allow for companies to expand and sell outside their own province,
00:12:23 and that's been a struggle.
00:12:25 We've seen many announcements, but not much more than that.
00:12:32 Also, we have seen recent announcements that we're encouraging from Ottawa.
00:12:39 For example, Ottawa has actually created a billion-dollar fund to reinvest in manufacturing to basically increase our food manufacturing's capacity, which is interesting.
00:12:51 But also, and this is probably the best thing that has come out of Ottawa in recent months, is that in September, Prime Minister Carney actually announced the creation of a productivity mega deduction fund.
00:13:07 And this is a multi-billion dollar program that will allow SMEs, small and medium-sized businesses, to actually reinvest in their facility in robotics automation, R&D.
00:13:22 And because right now, most companies are, a lot of them are family-owned and they're very risk-averse and they don't have access to capital.
00:13:32 This particular program, my guess, will actually help.
00:13:36 So that was a good move on behalf of Ottawa, but it is going to take years before we see any changes.
00:13:44 So better late than never, but the announcement that we have seen this year should have happened at least a few years ago.
00:13:52 But now we're dealing with major systemic shocks that are impacting food affordability in Canada.
00:13:58 Well, Dr. Charlebaugh, I want to talk to you a little bit about AI in a minute.
00:14:01 But there was one other thing that you were in the news for recently.
00:14:05 your recent commentary noted that people who have lived in Canada for 10 years or less
00:14:10 now make up nearly 31% of food bank clients.
00:14:15 That's up sharply from 2019, and this in a year when we're taking half a million immigrants.
00:14:21 So, I mean, our question is this.
00:14:22 Should the government of Canada be weighing immigration levels and settlement capacity
00:14:27 against food affordability and the ability of newcomers to become self-sufficient
00:14:32 without relying on donated food?
00:14:34 I mean, these people, they come in, they have to find a place to live, rents go up, all their money goes to rent, they've got nothing left to buy food, and now they're at the food bank.
00:14:44 Is that what's happening here?
00:14:49 Likely.
00:14:50 Now, as soon as we talk about immigration, we tend to be called racist in Canada, and that's why it is the big elephant in the room.
00:14:58 But I think we need to have an honest conversation about our immigration policies.
00:15:03 I don't know of one Canadian who's against immigration.
00:15:06 We're not making babies anymore, so we need immigration to sustain our economy.
00:15:13 But it's how it's being managed, I think.
00:15:15 It's being managed recklessly.
00:15:18 And we're allowing a record number of people to come in.
00:15:22 And we're not assuring ourselves that these people will actually have, not only have a decent living,
00:15:28 But also it won't compromise the quality of life of other Canadians as well along the way.
00:15:35 So I am concerned about the amount of people coming in.
00:15:38 Of course, from an agri-food perspective, a lot of immigrants do play a very important role in our ag economy as workers.
00:15:45 But also, at the same time, we have seen many people come in disrupting our macroeconomic picture, making the lives of everyone, including you and I, more expensive along the way.
00:16:01 Okay, so, but just to repeat that figure, nearly 31% of food bank clients, where it's nearly a third of food bank clients.
00:16:11 They're newcomers.
00:16:12 They're newcomers less than 10 years.
00:16:15 Yeah.
00:16:15 So, I mean, that's an indicator.
00:16:18 That's an indication that something is wrong.
00:16:21 So if we're allowing these people into our country, why do they need help?
00:16:25 It should be the opposite.
00:16:29 Well, it should.
00:16:31 Look, let's put that one on the side for a minute because we don't have unlimited time, unfortunately.
00:16:36 And I do want to talk to you a little bit about artificial intelligence in the food industry from two angles.
00:16:42 First, what does AI in the food industry do for the food industry?
00:16:46 And secondly, I'm working on a theory that quite a lot of the system outages that we have experienced over the past 10 days
00:16:55 are actually related to AI systems that think they see a problem and then run after it,
00:17:03 and then their attempts to fix it just make it 150 times worse.
00:17:09 Now, I could be wrong.
00:17:11 Nobody really in an official position is saying this.
00:17:16 This is just based on me talking to people I know who are in the business of fixing things when they go wrong in that sector.
00:17:25 But let's just talk about AI, first of all, then.
00:17:30 What good can AI do in the food processing industry?
00:17:36 uh ai has actually done wonders i mean we've been using ai for uh 17 to 20 years already as a lab
00:17:46 and so this is not new what is new of course is is how we've democratized ai and and how
00:17:54 our companies and institutions are embracing ai to optimize operations uh to do research to do
00:18:04 things much more quickly, more efficiently. And there's nothing wrong with that. But as you adopt
00:18:11 AI-related practices, you will make, depending of the infrastructure you have, and sometimes
00:18:19 it may actually be obsolete, you're exposing your organization to some threats. And they are
00:18:27 cyber attackers out there. And I'm just thinking about one case that is very food-related
00:18:33 out of Europe. As you may be aware, in Europe, over 700 supermarkets have actually been cyber
00:18:43 attacked. They actually decided to take control of freezers and coolers and jacked up temperatures
00:18:51 up to 50 degrees overnight, spoiling millions and millions of dollars in inventory in over 700
00:19:00 stores in Europe. And the reason why it happened is because all of these schoolers and freezers
00:19:06 are connected to a broader, complicated system that is actually run by AI and helping humans
00:19:18 making decision monitoring risk and things like that. So those incidences in Europe are really
00:19:25 forcing Canadian operators to think differently about how you support your AI ambitions and how
00:19:34 you get to the proper infrastructure to support those AI ambitions over time. So is plugging all
00:19:42 systems into one thing the right idea, basically? Well, the European example, I believe, is
00:19:49 complicated further by the fact that they have very simple passwords, the kind of things that
00:19:53 would guess and so there seems to have been a lack of diligence in the people who are operating
00:20:00 that system but nevertheless it's distinguishable from other AI problems in as much as that was a
00:20:06 deliberate attack whereas what you're talking about AI in the food industry seems to be
00:20:13 that AI can actually be quite helpful if we as long as we don't let it get away on us and
00:20:19 in terms of controlling inventories
00:20:21 and being able to predict
00:20:24 when foods should be shipped
00:20:25 to known locations
00:20:27 because the demand will be there.
00:20:29 We can analyze those things.
00:20:32 So would you make that same distinction?
00:20:35 Yes, absolutely.
00:20:37 So from an industry perspective,
00:20:39 of course, I think,
00:20:41 and in fact, in Toronto,
00:20:43 over the next few days,
00:20:43 I'll be meeting with many companies
00:20:46 and we'll have that exact discussion
00:20:48 What's the future of AI in the industry?
00:20:50 And I think a lot of companies do see potential for growth.
00:20:54 And, of course, it's all about forecasting as well.
00:20:58 People don't realize that our behavior as consumers actually will have an impact or does have an impact on a day-to-day basis on how industry supplies food to all of us.
00:21:09 How do they make sure that they have the right broccoli, the right tomato, the right apple or the right products in the store when you show up?
00:21:19 You need to forecast and a lot of factors will impact our behavior and decisions of the grocery store.
00:21:25 So the more you're able to predict our decisions, the better off you are as a company.
00:21:30 So there's some wonders. There's some wonders in genetics as well.
00:21:34 But for the time being, of course, people are forced to think about risks.
00:21:40 So as we adopt AI as a company or as a sector, what are the vulnerabilities that will emerge and the blind spots that we need to be aware of, generally speaking?
00:21:53 fast running out of time here so then uh so two questions um first if we're going to enter an
00:22:01 era where systems are unstable for a while for whatever reason what is your advice to people
00:22:09 who want to make sure they don't run out of the things they want to eat
00:22:13 what how long should you prepare for yeah absolutely uh in fact actually i was looking
00:22:19 Yeah, I was looking at Costco shares this morning, and they're way up compared to last month, 11%.
00:22:26 And that's probably why a lot of markets are expecting people to think differently about risks, of course, individuals.
00:22:34 And people will be stocking up, and people are stocking up.
00:22:39 And the ideal timeline for food and water is typically three days.
00:22:44 I think with three days worth of food, you're okay.
00:22:47 But I would say that most households already have that. It's just people are just revisiting their inventory at home, making sure that they have everything they need.
00:22:58 In fact, 20 years ago, when we were anticipating a major world pandemic, it was kind of the same rhetoric, the same message that was actually being broadcast and shared across networks.
00:23:13 So I would say the same thing now. And frankly, I wouldn't be concerned about running out of food in terms of the industry itself.
00:23:23 COVID was really peculiar because we basically decided to shut down an entire sector, which is food service, restaurants.
00:23:31 And that's $100 billion in sales. So obviously there was more pressure that transferred over to retail.
00:23:37 But within days, we saw retail replenish shelves again, so there was some instability for a while, but we went back to normal, well, some sort of normal soon after.
00:23:52 Okay, last question.
00:23:54 Why isn't beef so damn expensive?
00:23:59 Well, we're not out of the woods, unfortunately.
00:24:03 It's because there's just no inventory.
00:24:05 There's just no product.
00:24:06 In fact, Tyson just closed a plant in the U.S.
00:24:10 They're losing money, basically.
00:24:13 They're losing money in terms of harvesting beef overall.
00:24:19 So it's been a challenge for the sector.
00:24:22 But we're not expecting things to get back to normal until probably July or August of 2027.
00:24:27 In the meantime, we know that Ottawa has negotiated with South American countries like Brazil, Uruguay, and Argentina, the Mercosur Group, to actually allow more beef into Canada to bring down prices very quickly.
00:24:45 So there's no deal yet, but we're expecting something, some sort of announcement within the next month or so.
00:24:51 You know, if they do that, I will give them a clean pass on just about everything else.
00:24:57 so that's great news
00:24:59 join the club
00:25:03 Dr. Sylvain Charlebois
00:25:06 Canada's food professor
00:25:08 what a pleasure to have you on the program again
00:25:10 thank you so much for your time
00:25:12 and I just think your advice
00:25:15 about just three days of the things
00:25:17 you really need is probably something
00:25:18 everybody needs to
00:25:19 needs to take notice of
00:25:23 thanks for being here
00:25:24 take care, bye bye
00:25:26 For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.