Western Standard - September 05, 2026


THE PIPELINE: Are Canada’s Conservatives collapsing?


Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

169.14

Word count

8,141

Sentence count

406

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

36

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 Good day and welcome to The Pipeline.
00:00:26.380 Today is September 2nd, 2026.
00:00:29.120 I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:00:32.780 I'm joined by our usual crew today, Western Standard Senior Alberta Columnist Corey Morgan.
00:00:38.720 Hey, Dave.
00:00:40.500 Senior Columnist Nigel Henniford.
00:00:43.140 Welcome home.
00:00:44.100 Senior News Editor Dave Naylor.
00:00:47.240 Did you just break your glasses? No, I didn't.
00:00:49.580 A little too vigorous senior gesture on it.
00:00:52.460 And coming to us from a beautiful, formerly beautiful Vancouver, our BC reporter, Alex Zoltan.
00:01:01.860 So Alex is going to, he's here because we're going to talk about BC's Kamikaze Conservatives.
00:01:08.120 The absolute, total implosion of the BC Conservative Party was nice while it lasted.
00:01:14.600 Looked like it might be getting patched back together when Carolyn Finley won the leadership.
00:01:18.420 seems that it's not really panned out as uh as was hoped by some um and the party is facing
00:01:26.560 daily defections out of caucus uh it seems doubtful but the new leader carolyn finley is
00:01:32.540 gonna be able to survive this maybe alex will correct me if i'm wrong we're gonna talk about
00:01:37.260 what the hell is going on with the total meltdown of bc's conservatives uh before that though we 0.98
00:01:41.880 We will talk about why do our federal conservatives suck so much. 0.98
00:01:48.020 Nigel, I think, has already said he's going to disagree with me on that one. 0.98
00:01:51.020 That's okay.
00:01:51.820 That's what he's here for.
00:01:53.920 But the conservatives just got routed in all three by-elections.
00:01:58.380 You know, in incumbent liberal seats, that's to be expected.
00:02:02.840 The conservative vote share was down in all seats.
00:02:04.740 And they lost one incumbent seat, moving from holding it for eight to ten years to losing it into third place.
00:02:12.820 So, you know, can Pierre Paliab survive?
00:02:17.180 Questions creeping back up about his leadership.
00:02:20.520 And what does the Conservative Party even stand for anymore?
00:02:25.220 First, we're going to start with a segment I have decided to call Lake Epstein.
00:02:30.320 You all know already that Donald Trump signed some order officially,
00:02:39.740 at least for the American government
00:02:42.040 renaming Lake Ontario
00:02:44.100 to Like America 0.99
00:02:46.360 following what he did with 0.52
00:02:48.440 the Gulf of Mexico
00:02:50.360 renamed to the
00:02:52.040 Gulf of America.
00:02:57.500 He's obviously trolling.
00:03:01.240 Nigel,
00:03:02.520 he is, Trump is
00:03:04.360 a master
00:03:05.940 at getting under the skin of his
00:03:07.860 opponents or his enemies
00:03:09.340 uh you know the world was really introduced to this during the first round of republican primary
00:03:15.620 debates in 2015 uh 2016 uh you know he'd come up with nickbeams for everyone little marco
00:03:22.580 uh lion ted my favorite was low energy jeb uh it just you know cutting to the quick and getting
00:03:31.340 as a getting gets under the skin of his opponents gets them to overreact uh he's clearly doing the
00:03:38.580 same thing again here it's childish it's beneath the dignity of a president but these are not new 0.99
00:03:46.360 things for him it's what he does he's a professional asshole and he employs that as a weapon um i don't 0.99
00:03:53.540 even necessarily mean that as an insult it's just what he does you know he played it on tv in the 0.99
00:03:58.040 apprentice he plays it as a character maybe he is an asshole in real life i don't know the guy 0.92
00:04:02.360 but he certainly uses as a character as a persona he gets under the skin of his opponents gets them 0.99
00:04:07.580 to overreact or react
00:04:09.480 emotionally.
00:04:12.240 I think
00:04:13.260 Prime Minister Mark Carney did
00:04:15.520 not, he hasn't overreacted.
00:04:17.520 His brand is, he's like an accountant
00:04:19.540 practically. He's a banker. He's very dull.
00:04:22.040 Definitely got Doug Ford to
00:04:23.600 react though. Stands in front of a big sign.
00:04:25.560 It's going to be Lake Ontario forever.
00:04:28.100 Getting us to react emotionally.
00:04:30.500 Essentially just moving the
00:04:31.640 goalposts. So we're now talking about
00:04:33.560 almost as if it'd be a negotiating point.
00:04:35.640 Rather than us care about this point of economic trade policy, we're probably going to somehow demand that he respect the pronouns of Lake Ontario.
00:04:44.640 Who knows where this will end, but certainly Donald Trump has always used humiliation as a bargaining tool.
00:04:55.040 It's in his book. It manifests.
00:04:59.240 I actually, in expectation of this discussion, I just went through to see.
00:05:04.320 I don't think this is a full list of what he's done.
00:05:07.700 But, you know, after Mark Carney took the job, he said, Governor Carney and his flunky Ford.
00:05:16.280 Well, do you think Doug Ford is going to sit back and take that?
00:05:19.800 Of course he didn't.
00:05:20.580 He went out and made his own outrageous comments. 1.00
00:05:23.380 But the question is, who actually looks like a real idiot then? 0.99
00:05:26.920 It's maybe Mr. Ford, who should have showed a little more class. 0.99
00:05:30.560 We know to expect it from the president.
00:05:33.900 Anyway, way back when Justin Trudeau was prime minister,
00:05:40.100 that's when he began the 51st state.
00:05:42.540 It is very obvious from the footage that dates from those days
00:05:46.180 that he thought of Justin Trudeau very much the way we thought of him
00:05:51.620 here in Western Canada.
00:05:53.180 And to be polite, not a serious player.
00:05:57.980 And so it goes on.
00:05:59.960 What we actually have ended up with now is a country that is so focused on the insults
00:06:08.560 that they're not very good at responding to them, just blind rage.
00:06:16.100 You know, what really hurts is when the insults come close to the truth.
00:06:20.940 Like the 51st state, maybe not so much.
00:06:24.000 Well, when you see the kind of pictures that were posted by Pete Hegseth
00:06:30.540 of people in the military who are clearly not in the warrior caste, 1.00
00:06:38.420 then you kind of know that actually that's true.
00:06:42.380 The truth hurts.
00:06:45.260 Our military did a fantastic job in Afghanistan.
00:06:48.380 best troops in the world, and they've inherited a defense bureaucracy that makes advancement of 0.55
00:06:58.880 women and sexual minorities more important than fighting skill. The Yanks didn't miss that. And 0.99
00:07:06.680 so when Hegseth puts out his barbs, it hurts because, you know, it reflects a certain truth
00:07:12.760 that nobody wants to acknowledge.
00:07:14.960 But all of this is designed to weaken us in negotiations.
00:07:19.820 Right now, the country is in an uproar,
00:07:22.540 and Mr. Carney can say what he likes and do what he likes,
00:07:27.300 and nobody's going to object because he's representing Canada.
00:07:31.100 This is what really gets under my skin.
00:07:34.240 Dave, I want to hear from you about how you think
00:07:37.380 Canadian officials should react.
00:07:39.320 um you know my my sense is we should probably not get down in the muck with them uh kind of the way
00:07:47.500 sort of as forward tends to do i mean if we were going to it shouldn't be we're like ontario
00:07:54.440 forever if we're gonna get in the muck get really in the muck there's two ways to do a trump be
00:07:59.820 above him don't get down to his level or trump trump if you're gonna do that you know canada
00:08:06.260 should have said well fine we're changing the leg name of lake ontario too or we're naming it lake
00:08:11.700 epstein and you know that that would get under his skin my fears actually get under his skin too much
00:08:16.820 and he'd actually invade he'll actually send the tanks but you know should we should we play like
00:08:23.140 trump uh you know yeah hit him back just as hard or do you think we should say above it or just kind
00:08:29.620 of this goofy defensiveness like ford no you have to be classy right canadians are known for their
00:08:35.780 class and their their politeness uh and as you said if you try and out trump trump i don't know
00:08:41.160 if that's possible you know you blame me to lake epstein and then yeah you never know the marines
00:08:45.660 will be coming across lake ontario but no you don't want to get down in the muck it's not a
00:08:51.640 very nice place to be and you know i think most of the premiers have responded with class except 0.93
00:08:58.100 on ford uh you know who just can't control himself and he's he's got to be the loud buffoon 0.96
00:09:03.620 in the room. And that's caught the attention of Trump, no doubt, because he calls him 0.96
00:09:08.980 Carney's lackey. So be classy, Canada.
00:09:13.880 Corey, I think if one of you two are more likely to say we should, well, just hit Trump back,
00:09:20.960 would he respect that more if we hit back and say, ah, two could play that game. Fine. You say
00:09:26.640 Lake America, I say Lake Epstein. I don't, I mean, Trump's not going to change. The only thing we can
00:09:33.060 changes how we react to them.
00:09:34.920 And, uh, yeah, as a person who plays, uh, well, and then lives 0.98
00:09:38.940 an asshole on the internet myself, I understand that approach 0.92
00:09:42.940 and dealing with political discourse and getting people. 1.00
00:09:46.060 But the thing is, if a person can't play back correctly, they will lose.
00:09:51.300 It's kind of like Dave and Nigel are saying when I'm prodding at somebody
00:09:54.360 politically and they're not good at that kind of game and I get under their skin,
00:09:57.920 typically they're going to say something online that they probably shouldn't have.
00:10:01.440 If they'd have maintained composure and not tried to come back on my terms, they could have come out of that exchange a little better. 0.96
00:10:08.420 With Trump, as Steve said, you're diving into the pen with the master pig and you're not going to fare well.
00:10:14.000 And it's not the nature of the person. 0.99
00:10:16.380 You know, Carney isn't that sort of dirty, but the pig enjoys it. 0.98
00:10:19.500 Kind of, exactly, yes. 0.97
00:10:20.820 And Carney's just not of that cut anyways.
00:10:23.240 If we had a prime minister who was of a character like that, then perhaps it could be done.
00:10:26.860 So we've got to look at where our ability to at least control our own messaging can sit, because we'll never control his.
00:10:34.540 And as tempting as it is to try and fight her back in the Lake Epstein would be fun. 0.65
00:10:38.560 It'd be funny.
00:10:39.300 I don't see our government having the nature to be able to do that effectively, I'm afraid.
00:10:44.500 No.
00:10:45.260 I mean, and while we should stand up for ourselves, we're not America.
00:10:50.700 I mean, this is not rough. These are not peer equivalents of like England, you know, Britain and France or Russia and China.
00:10:59.260 You know, we're not we're not in the same peer class as the United States.
00:11:03.900 It's it's it's tough. They do have more power than we've got.
00:11:07.560 They have more leverage than we've got.
00:11:11.620 And yeah, and I'm not sure trying to get down like that works like, you know, think back again to that first Republican primary.
00:11:17.580 think of the debates trump just went out there and bullied them like he just bullied them one by one
00:11:24.560 just diminished them and pushed them down and one by one they fell he sucked up all the oxygen uh
00:11:31.100 and they but i'm not sure this is an argument for trying to stay classy as well a lot of the other
00:11:36.580 republican candidates they try to stay classy like oh everyone will see this is beneath the dignity
00:11:41.460 of the office no one's going to take you seriously but his ability to kind of bully and i'm not even
00:11:46.460 saying bully pejoratively it's it's a valuable political skill i guess uh but his ability to
00:11:51.720 suck up the oxygen every one of those classy conventional republican candidates they all
00:11:58.120 went down you know you put up generic democrats against them he knocks all of them down so i'm 0.97
00:12:04.860 not sure that works either well yeah i mean the bottom line is it's worked for him gotten him
00:12:10.340 results but he's appealing to a different culture than then again the canadian political class has
00:12:15.320 to look at. I mean, is it more appreciated by the people on the ground who do support Trump when he
00:12:19.520 does that versus how would it be received and appreciated by Canadians? I mean, we're a little
00:12:23.180 more restrained. We're a little more uptight with those things. A Canadian persona playing that game
00:12:28.620 might not get the same success that Trump did. I mean, it's undeniable, as you said, when he
00:12:32.480 shoves, he sucked the air out of the room and just owns those debates. But would that tactic work
00:12:37.940 here? That's something that's being exposed. There is a cultural difference between Canada and the
00:12:41.040 United States. I mean, we're very close, but we're different too. And there is a backlash amongst
00:12:45.020 uh uh some american leaders when governors and border states and whatnot they've all come out 0.94
00:12:50.380 unanimously and said come on don't be so silly let's you know we rely on canada let's get let's
00:12:55.420 get a deal done so it's not 100 that he's got support no but yeah and i mean it's it's hurting 0.91
00:13:01.420 some states down there but you know if we can wear out this game i guess i mean nevada's hurting
00:13:06.300 las vegas you know if the snowbird trade is really decimated the numbers in canada is going down i
00:13:11.180 I mean, the bad dollar helps, but some people, a lot of people are just choosing not to go down there.
00:13:15.260 I'm not sure what he's trying to achieve here.
00:13:16.960 I don't think he's particularly serious about 51st state stuff.
00:13:22.040 I mean, if you gave him the option, would he go for it?
00:13:24.280 Oh, yeah, he absolutely would.
00:13:26.320 As long as it was named after him or something.
00:13:27.940 Yeah, yeah, yeah, something like that.
00:13:30.560 But if he could, would he?
00:13:32.620 I have little doubt that, yes, he would.
00:13:34.920 But is this an active, serious foreign policy goal of the Trump administration?
00:13:40.840 No.
00:13:41.280 So I'm not sure what he's trying to get.
00:13:43.240 Well, I think maybe he's trying to keep Mr. Carney right where he is.
00:13:49.160 Carney works for Trump.
00:13:52.180 And when he insults Canada and Canadians, the reaction so far has been to forgive Mr. Carney all kinds of things that we might otherwise hold against him,
00:14:05.000 like a complete lack of action on any of the plans that he said that he had for the country
00:14:10.920 and have in place somebody who mr trump thinks he can handle and so far frankly he's entitled
00:14:21.520 to his opinion on that because mr carney has not been an effective uh uh he's not got the deal
00:14:28.120 done he can only go on with this for so long and things are going to people are going to say well
00:14:34.240 fine. We like the fact that you're an earnest Canadian. We like the fact that you've stood up
00:14:39.960 to Trump, but now you have to make a deal. Now you have to get the job done. You said you're the
00:14:45.820 guy to handle Trump. Well, handle him and let's get on with making motor cars. I noticed or I
00:14:51.820 note he was musing today about renaming the Strait of Hormuz into the Strait of Trump.
00:14:57.000 Yeah. You know, it wouldn't be the most unplausible conspiracy theory that Trump and Kanye are actually kind of in on it together.
00:15:10.520 Polyev was slated to win possibly the biggest majority government in the history of Canada, and then they got the shit kicked out of them. 0.86
00:15:19.620 The liberals massively increased their share of the vote, came within a hair of a majority, now have an effective majority.
00:15:27.000 um and you know trump would have been aware that every time he opened his mouth about uh 51st state
00:15:36.240 stuff the liberal numbers jumped two points every time he said it two points two points two points
00:15:40.380 two points carney was in many ways installed by trump and i think it's a mistake for people to
00:15:48.320 think that trump cares about maybe the closer ideological affinity of of the conservatives
00:15:54.040 with the Republicans. Trump is the least ideological president, at least since Bill
00:16:00.620 Clinton, possibly much, much earlier. Hard to say where. But he is, you know, if you just take
00:16:08.760 conventional Republican conservative ideas and conventional liberal and Democratic ideas,
00:16:14.220 he is remarkably unideological. He would have not fit in a Bush or a Reagan Republican party.
00:16:23.560 In fact, he wasn't a member of the Bush or Republican parties.
00:16:27.520 So I don't think Trump actually cares.
00:16:29.400 You should remind the Democrats that he was actually once a registered Democrat.
00:16:33.240 Yeah, but also I don't think he was a conventional Democrat either.
00:16:35.500 He was a dealmaker.
00:16:36.740 He doesn't really care about ideology, which is why he'll work with a kind of monarctical communist like Kim Jong-un.
00:16:45.480 You know, he doesn't care.
00:16:46.720 He's a dealmaker.
00:16:48.620 And so he probably doesn't care if it's a liberal or a conservative in Canada.
00:16:53.560 He probably just wants someone who he could do a deal with.
00:16:59.600 And when he continues to talk like this, all he does is help Carney.
00:17:03.700 Carney's numbers are up again.
00:17:05.640 They've now swept all three by-elections.
00:17:07.760 Even the Parti Quebecois has said if they win the current Quebec election that's going on,
00:17:12.980 they've postponed their plans for a referendum on independence until after Trump is gone. 0.98
00:17:18.780 So, I think that's a segue into why do our Conservatives suck? 0.86
00:17:24.220 I know you're going to disagree with me, Nigel Wood will disagree with me, 0.96
00:17:27.520 but the Conservatives' query just got routed in all three by-elections.
00:17:32.580 I mean, losing a by-election where you never had a chance and the Liberals already held it,
00:17:38.540 you know, Beaches, East York, I mean, I don't put that in the negative category for the Conservatives.
00:17:43.120 Their vote share was down. They came in a crazy distant third, like 13% of the vote behind the NDP.
00:17:50.420 So I wouldn't count that. But there was one writing in Quebec. I can never name their writings.
00:17:54.880 But the Conservatives had held it for 8 to 10 years.
00:17:59.220 Carney very shrewdly appointed that Conservative MP to the Senate, opening it up.
00:18:05.140 And the Liberals won it fairly handedly.
00:18:08.320 Second place, though, wasn't even the Conservatives. It was the Bloc. 0.51
00:18:10.600 The Conservatives dropped to a distant third place.
00:18:13.120 And then, and then, uh, and then one more, uh, Vancouver and Vancouver liberals,
00:18:17.740 obviously that was a hold for the liberals.
00:18:19.700 The conservative numbers continue to drop and drop and drop.
00:18:23.460 They would lose a lot of seats.
00:18:24.560 They would be a smaller official opposition if there's an election today.
00:18:28.500 Polyev's personal numbers continue to drop lower and lower.
00:18:32.660 Uh, he's in a tough spot here.
00:18:34.740 Um, but he's had a fair number of defections to the liberals.
00:18:39.020 Uh, I think his leadership is a question.
00:18:42.680 He survived with the membership at the convention here in Calgary very handedly.
00:18:47.340 He got a very strong mandate.
00:18:49.220 But, you know, ask Alison Redford.
00:18:50.960 Ask Ed Stelmack.
00:18:54.660 There's been many leaders who survive a vote of the members, but then circumstances continue to undermine them.
00:19:02.520 Their support erodes in caucus, and then they're eventually pushed out.
00:19:06.420 Yeah, no, he's in dire straits because, I mean, the sharks were already circling before these by-elections.
00:19:11.200 They used BC as a proxy battleground to fight with each other with political operatives.
00:19:17.100 I mean, that party's divided and it's reflecting into the provincial parties now
00:19:20.000 because, come on, let's face it, Corey and Ford are smelling and gunning for that spot 1.00
00:19:24.980 and they need Polyev out of the way.
00:19:27.380 There was no chance he was going to win a couple of those seats,
00:19:30.460 probably no chance he would ever win the Quebec one.
00:19:32.960 But to take such a devastating hit, I mean, he lost ground on all of them.
00:19:37.800 By-elections are an opportunity typically for the opposition.
00:19:40.380 It's a risk way people for voters to signal if they want change on the federal front or provincial, whatever it may be.
00:19:47.520 It could have been an opportunity for him to even show point gains in a couple of ridings.
00:19:53.320 Instead, he was devastated in all of them.
00:19:54.980 Well, they didn't even hold the one they had.
00:19:56.160 No, and they lost it terribly.
00:19:58.020 It wasn't a narrow one.
00:19:58.960 They got slaughtered.
00:20:00.520 The Vancouver one actually was traditionally a swing riding.
00:20:03.640 It was a liberal hold, but that was a reform seat if we go far enough back.
00:20:07.200 Again, maybe not winnable today with the change of demographics, but they could have been represented better within it.
00:20:15.140 He needs some kind of victory, some kind of spark of life to show that he can turn these things around.
00:20:21.480 It ties into a bit of what you're speaking of before.
00:20:23.840 Carney's turned into a juggernaut.
00:20:25.740 This trade more might not, well, it's not.
00:20:27.680 It's not good for Canada.
00:20:29.000 It's been political gold for Carney.
00:20:30.960 It has.
00:20:31.500 He's had that external enemy he can always point towards.
00:20:34.220 every time Trump does belittle Carney, Carney support in Canada goes up. You know, and I don't
00:20:40.300 know if it's by design sort of as you might've implied before, but it's definitely put up
00:20:44.140 a really politically difficult circumstance for Polly. I have to try and figure out how to carve 0.96
00:20:48.900 a niche to gain support in here. And if he could have found a way in those by-elections,
00:20:54.900 he would have. They, just to have held their ground would have been a victory at this point,
00:20:59.820 But to have been beaten down like that, particularly in the one they lost,
00:21:04.680 he's in serious trouble now and, and, uh, we'll just see who comes up after him.
00:21:10.420 Well, you know, I got to tell you that this country at the moment has gone mad.
00:21:18.480 People are not listening.
00:21:19.740 They're not listening to policy.
00:21:21.460 All they can think of is how much they hate Trump and because they hate Trump,
00:21:27.260 They therefore approve of their Canadian prime minister, whatever he does.
00:21:31.740 I fully agree.
00:21:32.580 And so the question is, if you suddenly removed Polyarv out of the mix,
00:21:38.800 what would the next guy do that was different in that situation?
00:21:43.900 There is actually, until people settle down and start to look at this,
00:21:51.380 realizing that there's another side to the story,
00:21:54.040 there's nothing that anybody can do on the opposition side.
00:21:56.840 There isn't a position, in my view, you may differ, but in my view, there is no statement
00:22:04.220 that Polyev could have made or a position that he could have adopted that people would
00:22:09.360 say, ah, you know, I never thought I would have made it.
00:22:11.280 I'm in agreement with you.
00:22:13.280 I think that Polyev's in a situation not of his own making, but the bottom line, he still 0.97
00:22:19.040 just is screwed. 0.99
00:22:20.040 Well, he is screwed, but then if he is screwed, the whole party is screwed. 1.00
00:22:23.340 Yeah. 0.99
00:22:24.340 Well, that's kind of what we're getting to.
00:22:25.340 where you know you cannot have carny carny and what this what you don't want to do if you're
00:22:34.140 the leader of the opposition is always be swapping out your leader now if you don't like this one we
00:22:39.980 got another oh you didn't you you didn't like sheer well hey let's let's take a chance on an
00:22:44.060 air force colonel no oh yeah sorry about that oh polyev here's your man like sometimes you've
00:22:50.940 just got to be persuaded you've got to be prepared to do the long march like crit town you know
00:22:57.100 chretien lost in what was it 94 uh no no 84 84 i beg your pardon thank you that was a leadership
00:23:03.740 race yeah and leadership yeah but he lost it and then he had to sit through brian malroney for
00:23:08.300 number of years and then finally he came back and he stayed for nine years there you can't
00:23:15.580 Man, sometimes politics is a long haul, and I do believe that our Conservative Party makes
00:23:23.660 a mistake when we give one person one chance once, and then we're on to the next thing.
00:23:31.160 I think you're mostly right.
00:23:35.080 There was a rally around the flag movement, obviously, when Trump started going after
00:23:42.520 you know 51st state and governor trudeau and these things and the liberals were able to capitalize on
00:23:47.660 that in the way that the conservatives were not able to and i'm not sure there was a particularly
00:23:51.860 effective way for the conservatives to pivot into that it just didn't fit with the brand as well
00:23:57.080 uh just because of ideological affinity between republicans and conservatives a lot of canadian
00:24:02.000 public saw them as suspect there's just not a lot i think they could have particularly done
00:24:06.540 But now that that is done, what is in Paliyev's control is what he's talking about, what he's focusing on.
00:24:15.240 And he is still sounding in many ways like it's the same set of issues with Trudeau in 2024.
00:24:24.980 The government's less incompetent than it was, and it's still incompetent, but it's less of a front issue for most voters.
00:24:33.760 You know, I've said this before, mass migration is a gigantic meta-issue and it feeds into everything. It feeds into cost of living, it feeds into crime, it feeds into public order, feeds into the economy, housing, all of these things. 0.78
00:24:50.840 but he's still
00:24:52.900 afraid. He won't
00:24:55.040 touch it. Carney came along
00:24:56.940 and he took the real easy
00:24:58.880 issues away off the table
00:25:00.660 from Polyev. He took away the consumer carbon tax
00:25:02.800 not the industrial one but the one most people
00:25:04.800 think about at least. He takes that off the table.
00:25:09.040 You know
00:25:09.220 he took
00:25:10.040 some of the other
00:25:12.660 less popular things just quickly took them off
00:25:15.000 the table. It was very similar I remember
00:25:16.920 to when Prentice came in to fix
00:25:18.920 the disaster of Alison Redford
00:25:20.820 Just some of these real peas under the mattress takes them away.
00:25:26.040 There's still something left on the table for Polyev to fight with that Carney has not taken off the table.
00:25:32.060 But he's too afraid to do it because of the names he'll get called for it.
00:25:37.420 Yeah, well, you know, there's a lot of truth in what you're saying, Derek.
00:25:41.800 But I think with Mr. Polyev, he is just in that situation there.
00:25:48.360 You know, you're a student of history, so you'll recognize this.
00:25:52.020 At the start of the First World War, common sense was nowhere to be found. 0.57
00:25:57.700 Jingoism in England, the German equivalent in Berlin.
00:26:03.320 People were not listening to reason.
00:26:05.640 They were not listening to arguments.
00:26:07.720 They just had a passion for their cause, which was to fight, fight, fight.
00:26:13.140 Well, the trains had to run.
00:26:14.100 so right now there's not a time to be coming up with carefully thought out policy alternatives
00:26:21.980 for the opposition parties nobody cares nobody is listening all they want to hear is somebody
00:26:29.040 condemn the american president and that they will applaud now there will come a time and it may not
00:26:37.600 be as far off as we fear that canadian is going to say all right well we've had our fun you know
00:26:42.800 we have rebuked the president. We have not yielded to his demands, but we don't actually have a trade
00:26:51.040 deal. And there are a lot of people who are going to feel the consequences of this soon if we don't
00:26:57.900 do something. So, Mr. Carney, you marketed yourself to us in 2025 as the guy who could
00:27:05.240 handle Trump. You were the guy to negotiate with the American president, and you would
00:27:12.400 see us through. I agree it's not been easy, sir, but now you're going to have to do something
00:27:18.880 with that.
00:27:19.880 Paul Yev claimed a victory today when the government announced they were not bringing
00:27:24.000 back the gasoline tax. That's something the conservatives have been pounding that for
00:27:31.680 a couple of weeks now.
00:27:32.720 do voters ever give credit for the guy who proposed the idea no the conservatives didn't get credit
00:27:37.120 for the one when carney got rid of the consumer carbon tax carney got all the credit that's just
00:27:42.720 the way it works that's why we're here to bring the truth to the people derrick exactly that's
00:27:46.960 right i think cory duff protests a little bit too much yeah look at the uh the last election
00:27:52.160 record number of conservative votes eight million uh 8.4 yes yes because you were wrong you were
00:27:59.360 wrong the last time. Well, as it's nothing like being wrong on public television. Check your
00:28:04.400 numbers. So 8.4 million votes. And, you know, just weeks before the election, he was going to win.
00:28:10.560 And then elbows up came and and he was screwed. I personally think it's a mainstream media 0.81
00:28:20.880 fueled thing where they've got the Laurentian talking heads all crapping all over all the time
00:28:26.880 on CBC, all the time on CTV, all the time on global, you have liberal heads smashing
00:28:32.320 polyam. So people are thinking, well, yeah, he must be in big trouble. He's not. He's
00:28:38.500 still going across the country. He's still drawing huge crowds wherever he goes. And
00:28:44.160 you know, he's still fighting the good fight. We haven't heard anything yet from anybody
00:28:49.780 in the caucus, you know, complaining about it.
00:28:52.680 Except for the, what, how many who have defected to the Liberals?
00:28:56.380 That was a significant number.
00:28:57.580 They were morally bankrupt, those people, right?
00:29:00.440 They sold out.
00:29:02.320 They sold out their constituents who voted for them.
00:29:06.980 But that's always said of whenever someone on the team you sympathize with goes to the other side.
00:29:12.000 When it's the other side, it's like, ah, they saw the light.
00:29:14.600 Now they're moral.
00:29:15.540 They've joined the moral team.
00:29:17.100 I mean, it's the same.
00:29:18.460 you could always those news stories you can it's insert sentiment insert party and it's always just
00:29:25.020 in the inverse depending on if it's coming or going to or from your team well derek you don't
00:29:29.020 really believe that anybody can look moral by going over to the liberal party no no i don't
00:29:33.580 but i seem to think you can be very well going to the liberals to the conservatives i i don't
00:29:37.740 know why i think that but i i seem to um i look i it's baked in the media is not going to like
00:29:45.820 conservatives and that's just not in canada uh it's not just america that's just everywhere it is
00:29:50.300 the the media is not gonna like conservatives particularly the more conservative you get
00:29:54.620 conservatives gotta stop complaining about it that's just the way it is what you gotta do is
00:29:59.680 have some balls about fighting going around them and polyev to his credit showed some but he totally
00:30:06.700 chickened out in the last election his signature promise that he had been campaigning on for years
00:30:11.440 to defund the CBC he threw that overboard once uh the polls turned against him and he wanted to try
00:30:17.260 and get a you know some more sympathetic coverage from the CBC guess what it didn't materialize
00:30:22.640 his promise to get rid of all the mainstream media uh media bailout subsidies he campaigned
00:30:28.800 on that for years boom throw it overboard in the last election to try and gain sympathetic coverage
00:30:33.640 from the media. None of that materialized. He chickened out. He doesn't seem to have
00:30:45.580 the courage that he appeared to have earlier on when he was running for the Conservative leader
00:30:51.540 and early on as Conservative leader. He is a career politician. He's been a politician his
00:30:59.240 entire adult life. And in some ways, that's a good thing. You can be experienced, you know your way
00:31:04.520 around. In some ways, it's a bad thing. And where it's a bad thing is it tends to make you extremely
00:31:08.800 risk adverse. You've been trained from cradle to grave to repeat the talking points, to stay
00:31:14.720 on the message. You're going to get in less trouble doing that. But it means you're not going to take
00:31:19.280 the big risks when you need to take a big risk. If there was opportunities in the last election to
00:31:23.380 take a big risk, he didn't take it. He doubled down on his message. And he's still staying the
00:31:27.460 same way now there are things he can do to move the needle right now and he just seems to be
00:31:33.640 you know like you're pulling a string on the back of him and he just repeats the talking points
00:31:38.340 programmed and it's boring and yeah i agree yeah the conservatives shouldn't necessarily jettison
00:31:44.240 their leader every single election but between those elections they've got to show their ability
00:31:49.040 to grow to improve and to rise to the challenge we're not seeing that right now so it'd be very
00:31:54.040 easy to agree with you, Derek, on the way that conservatives stay on script and on message.
00:32:02.920 And there is a reason why they do that. As you will remember from the early years of Harper
00:32:09.880 administration, there is the so-called bozo eruption, which somebody actually says what they
00:32:15.160 really think and that takes the media spotlight away from the from the leader
00:32:21.520 and away more importantly from the from the policy message I actually look back
00:32:28.180 with some some rose-colored glasses on British Columbia in the 1970s when you
00:32:34.240 had a government composed of car dealers and ranchers but especially the
00:32:39.340 car dealers because they were very hard to corral and uh they said what they thought people loved
00:32:46.380 it and you got big you got big uh uh majorities for the social credit government back in those
00:32:53.180 days but we're not dealing with the same population and we're not frankly we don't
00:32:57.900 have enough car dealers to do the job so i have to say that uh much as you long for a charismatic
00:33:04.940 conservative who can stay on message but at the same time field the questions in such a way that
00:33:12.400 they don't become a talking point for the other side probably what he is doing is safer this is
00:33:18.740 a good uh excellent segue from bc car dealers to the bc conservatives we're going to bring in alex
00:33:24.060 now um alex uh geez are you coming to us from a tave in the hindu kush mountains of afghanistan
00:33:32.120 I'm coming to you from BC 1.00
00:33:35.320 so it's probably just as dangerous
00:33:37.020 okay
00:33:37.600 it's pretty similar now
00:33:40.400 BC has
00:33:43.580 for a long time Alberta
00:33:45.300 had the undisputed crown as the most
00:33:47.200 interesting polity in Canada
00:33:49.540 particularly on the conservative side
00:33:51.160 we have most definitively lost
00:33:53.400 that title for the last
00:33:55.360 few years to you guys
00:33:56.720 we're having a referendum on independence
00:33:59.040 and you are still somehow more
00:34:00.900 interesting right now just in the pure chaos of things uh carolyn finley becomes the leader of
00:34:06.200 the bc conservative opposition um you know coming off after a ton of chaos surrounding john rustat
00:34:12.960 uh ousted as leader uh i guess the hope was that she'd be able to corral it all back together
00:34:17.780 instead it's been quite the opposite rather than bringing it back together it's flown even further
00:34:22.500 apart the party looks like a fragment grenade at this point i know some of the messaging early on
00:34:28.980 was, oh, it's just the B.C. liberal, kind of the left wing of the party leaving.
00:34:33.100 I know you've got an analysis piece out just the other day saying, well, maybe some of
00:34:37.620 that is kind of true, but that's not really the full picture.
00:34:40.760 What in the hell is happening with the B.C. conservatives right now?
00:34:44.260 So I'll share a story with you that I shared with Dave yesterday over an email.
00:34:47.780 So when I attended the leadership convention in Vancouver, where Carrie Lynn Finley won,
00:34:54.420 it was held at a railway station somewhere downtown, and it was wide open.
00:34:58.880 windows and doors. And when she won, everybody, not everybody, a third of the audience all came
00:35:04.300 out at once on their way to the parking lot, which is, I assume, not terribly unusual for
00:35:08.720 leadership campaigns. There's never going to be 100% consensus. And so some people leave early.
00:35:14.420 But what I found particularly interesting was one person came up to me, and I don't know who
00:35:18.440 this person is. If they're watching this, I encourage them to reach out to me because I'd
00:35:22.340 like to talk to them again. They came up to me and they said, the real winner tonight is you.
00:35:26.860 and i said well what do you mean and he said the media the woman who just won is very corrupt
00:35:32.540 and you are going to be very very busy now i can't confirm the corruption part but i have been very
00:35:39.500 very busy uh well there has been at least uh let's call it corrupt adjacent activity there was
00:35:49.440 oh it's beyond corrupt adjacent eric yeah i was being polite and uh trying not to get sued
00:35:54.900 Why don't you just give us kind of a quick abbreviated version of what's gone on there with these characters, some of which are connected, obviously, with Alberta and how that's played into the leadership?
00:36:07.500 Yeah. So the Alberta part, actually, I think, is being radically overplayed by the left wing media and the legacy media here in B.C.
00:36:13.380 I've spoken to many people within the B.C. Conservative Caucus, as well as a few of the defectors.
00:36:17.920 And the issue of Alberta independence has never come up. And why?
00:36:22.140 No, I mean, some of the characters are from Alberta.
00:36:25.540 True. So there's one character in particular named Apollo Chung, who at one point had a high-level position with the Alberta Republican Party.
00:36:32.780 He also had a staffer position with the BC NDP, and then he played a major role in Carrie Lynn Finley's leadership campaign.
00:36:40.340 So he's kind of been referred to as an ideologically flexible, roving fixer.
00:36:47.980 so somebody who is highly competent in the world of politics but really doesn't have any principles
00:36:52.940 he was caught in a surreptitious recording where he said that he didn't give an f about the province
00:37:00.460 of british columbia and that he thought that the conservative underlings were weird and that 0.97
00:37:06.040 effing white people were crazy um which i i find to be just an astounding thing to say it's kind of 0.93
00:37:12.760 funny and it's true yeah it is it is true some of the time he also said that he wasn't going to 0.98
00:37:20.440 leave until he was given five hundred thousand dollars so it sounded like there was some type
00:37:24.040 of embezzlement going on there as well now the reason that this is so outrageous for the bc
00:37:28.880 conservative party is that running parallel to that story is another story where they've hired
00:37:33.460 a gentleman named chris delaney as the chief of staff and the largest complaint against chris
00:37:38.280 Delaney is that he's instituted an almost impossible to pass purity test for new hires.
00:37:44.980 And so that's what makes this so absurd. Apollo Chung passed the purity test,
00:37:49.600 but almost nobody else can. And I think that that would probably be the simplest explanation for
00:37:56.140 why people are giving up on the party. It's not that they're secret liberals. It's not that
00:37:59.660 there's a coup d'etat. It's not that they're conspiring together. It's that they've made
00:38:04.520 some really, really abysmal choices in terms of staffing. Okay, but Carolyn Finley, the
00:38:10.640 conservative leader, she sacked Apollo. I mean, that's an interesting name to go with
00:38:18.600 China. Yes, it certainly is. And he calls white people crazy. But she sacked him. She
00:38:27.820 obviously had no choice. There's actually been a continued series of like, the heads
00:38:32.480 rolling down and it's like that series in the movie Apocalypto with the heads rolling down
00:38:36.140 the Mayan temple uh pyramid the Mayan pyramid uh there's lots of heads rolling down uh sacrifices
00:38:43.080 to try and save her leadership here um she's cleaned house there uh but the defections continue
00:38:50.440 to mount and mount what is the real problem facing her leadership was it just you know
00:39:00.200 that she's seen as lacking judgment by putting this kind of weird uh grifting mercenary in
00:39:07.640 uh and that was it or or is it a bigger issue the really fascinating thing is that every individual
00:39:14.600 who is defected has given their own personal reason and none of them are alike so for instance
00:39:19.640 peter millibar he said that it was a combination of different things that clashed with his values
00:39:25.560 He famously was running against her in the leadership race, and she infamously criticized him for having a wife who is indigenous and worked for the Kamloops Indian Band as a potential conflict of interest.
00:39:36.060 He did not cite that as the only reason, however.
00:39:39.120 He said that, you know, there was a number of different things.
00:39:41.620 You can read into that what you will.
00:39:43.600 She went out for a publicized dinner with Dallas Brody of 1BC, who has a lot of problems with other people in the caucus.
00:39:50.120 Ian Payton, the next gentleman who stepped away, said that he stepped away because she offered him an inducement to step down.
00:39:56.780 I believe it was a high-level agriculture consultant job.
00:40:00.640 That may or may not be illegal.
00:40:02.180 Oh, an inducement to step down so she could take the seat in the by-election.
00:40:05.220 Correct.
00:40:05.920 Yeah, yeah. 1.00
00:40:06.560 Rosalind Bird, who is a first-term conservative, true blue conservative, she was also asked to step down in exchange for some sort of party favor.
00:40:13.960 She hasn't quite confirmed that, but it's well suggested.
00:40:16.680 it. And she said that she was screamed at by her chief of staff, Chris Delaney. And so that's why
00:40:23.520 she stepped away. The next person to step away, it's hard to keep track of them all, as I hope
00:40:28.600 you can understand. Teresa Watt stepped away because a leaked text message during the campaign 0.92
00:40:34.040 showed that Carrie Lynn Finley accused her of being CCP, which would be in reference to the
00:40:38.500 Chinese Communist Party. And on and on and on it goes. Again, I find it very hard to believe that
00:40:44.920 this is some concerted conspiracy against Carrie Lynn Finley when all of these different reasons
00:40:49.760 are so individualistic and subjective. It seems like it's just a mess. There's no other way to
00:40:56.440 describe it, frankly. And we had number eight today, didn't we, Alex? Correct. Yeah. I'm not
00:41:02.040 surprised, but who was this one? So Donegal Wilson, actually, she's, I'm in Penticton right
00:41:06.960 now. So she's the MLA for the adjacent riding in Princeton. And her reason for leaving was that
00:41:12.740 she said she would give the leadership three months for a chance. And she asked for a private
00:41:17.840 meeting with, again, the chief of staff and Carrie Lynn Finley two weeks ago, and the private meeting
00:41:22.960 never happened. And so she said, there's no communication. That's another consistent theme,
00:41:26.760 actually. It's one of the only consistent themes is the lack of communication. And Alia Warbus,
00:41:33.680 who resigned on Monday, her reason was because there was supposed to be a unifying caucus
00:41:38.360 meeting on monday morning and they canceled it at the last minute so if you look through the list i
00:41:43.400 mean it there's eight people that have left and for eight entirely different reasons none of which
00:41:49.080 are on policy by the way nobody has recited any policy difference with the leader whatsoever which
00:41:53.960 is also interesting yeah the inducements thing is a little interesting i mean you're not allowed to
00:41:59.720 offer like a job or an inducement to resign uh for by-elections but it literally happens every
00:42:07.320 single time like we know the way it works the leader you know someone's elected leader i should
00:42:13.760 say every single time but most of the time uh you step down you know new leaders elected and
00:42:20.880 they don't have a seat someone's gotta step aside they take care of that person that person doesn't
00:42:27.760 go stand in the soup kitchen line they get taken care of the rcmp has now launched an investigation
00:42:35.360 and is interviewing MLA's today, as a matter of fact.
00:42:39.240 Because you're supposed to be indirect about it.
00:42:42.540 Hey, you know, I need a seat.
00:42:46.160 You know, I know a guy who's looking,
00:42:49.460 there's this company that needs,
00:42:51.820 there's a good gig for the board of this company.
00:42:55.180 Have you thought about the private sector?
00:42:57.100 You're supposed to do it that way.
00:42:59.220 It happens all the time in every party.
00:43:02.200 It's not limited to any one party
00:43:03.420 or end of the political spectrum.
00:43:04.960 happens all the time but you're supposed to go about it that way you're not supposed to be like
00:43:09.820 hey please resign and if you do that we got this over here waiting for you you know you're not
00:43:16.200 supposed to be that brazen about it so yeah now the police are investigating they are
00:43:19.180 oh alex what is the over under on uh finley's survival chance here
00:43:27.900 oh that is such an interesting question just given the character that she is
00:43:33.820 so during the leadership race there was at least five or six times when i thought she was dead in
00:43:38.720 the water and one thing that one of her most amazing qualities is that she is an incredibly
00:43:42.900 resilient woman um she things just kind of seem to bounce off of her she seems to have like you 0.97
00:43:49.180 know the the old saying like what is a cat has nine lives and her political career seems to have 0.92
00:43:53.900 those nine lives however she's used eight yeah exactly we're we're already up to eight so
00:44:00.980 So the MLAs have left. Yeah, I mean, I don't know. I mean, there's still another 29 MLAs to go until it's just her and her husband, theoretically speaking. So, yeah, I mean, the by-election coming up here is make or break for her.
00:44:18.920 If she loses that, it would mean that a very well-respected, in fact, conservative MLA stepped down to give her an opportunity.
00:44:25.880 And if she isn't able to pass that test, then I would say that her days are less than numbered.
00:44:32.740 We did have an exclusive poll that Alex got yesterday showing her polling ahead in the writing at the moment.
00:44:40.240 But interestingly enough about that poll.
00:44:42.000 It's supposed to be a safe conservative seat, yeah.
00:44:44.380 Yeah, interestingly enough about that poll.
00:44:46.460 And the seat itself actually is a swing riding.
00:44:48.920 So it went NDP in 2020 and conservative in 2024.
00:44:53.120 But the interesting thing about that poll was that Finley was ahead by double digits against EB, but EB was the preferred premier, which gives you an idea of maybe how well informed the 212 people were that they polled.
00:45:09.780 Oh, look, we're actually ahead of time.
00:45:12.680 But OK, so we're going to put up in it there.
00:45:15.880 Alex, thanks a lot.
00:45:16.880 I appreciate you BC-splaining what's going on.
00:45:21.820 I have a feeling you're going to hand you back.
00:45:24.020 I'm sorry, I'll just add this.
00:45:25.420 I feel, I suspect sometimes that people out of province
00:45:28.740 watch our politics more closely than we do.
00:45:31.200 I don't know if that's just because we look away
00:45:32.940 out of embarrassment or shame,
00:45:34.340 but I find that interesting as well.
00:45:37.020 We see ourselves reflected back.
00:45:41.040 You know, my time in politics was born out of the chaos
00:45:44.280 of literally the official opposition
00:45:45.700 deciding to shut down shop and cross the floor and then a couple of years later they're in charge of
00:45:51.940 the government it's uh yeah we we we see ourselves reflected back uh back when we look in the mirror
00:45:57.860 of bc so uh thank you very much alex thanks for having me dave nigel cory thank you and uh thank
00:46:05.060 you john on production and all of you who have joined us uh for 45 minutes today on the pipeline
00:46:11.460 i'm glad to be back uh i was away in ukraine uh i don't even know what you got i didn't watch the
00:46:16.260 episodes while i'm gone i don't know what you guys said about me you know behind my back
00:46:20.020 nothing we wouldn't say right here that bad okay record ratings though the record according to john
00:46:26.500 okay well good um all right uh so yeah i'm glad to be back uh back home in alberta uh
00:46:34.980 tomorrow night we've got our second ever uh video conference call for the editor circle the editor
00:46:40.020 Circle is our premium membership subscription tier. It's $20 a month or $200 a year. You're
00:46:47.300 going to get exclusive briefings from me and the other senior editors of the Western Standard. You
00:46:52.080 get to join us on our monthly Editor's Circle video conference call. We get the inside scoop
00:46:57.680 about what's going on in the newsroom. And we have conversations and get feedback from Editor's
00:47:03.300 Circle members on what it is you guys want to see reflected in the Western Standard. And we've had
00:47:08.000 great feedback so far.
00:47:10.440 Very interesting
00:47:11.040 input from our Editor Circle members.
00:47:14.340 You can sign up there.
00:47:15.600 Go to the subscribe section of Western Standard.
00:47:18.040 Or just log in on the profile
00:47:20.060 section of your account to upgrade your existing
00:47:21.920 Western Standard subscription.
00:47:23.620 Thank you very much for joining us today, and God bless.
00:47:38.000 We'll be right back.